╌>

Outside California , Clinton Is A Big Time Popular Vote Loser

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  27 comments

Outside California , Clinton Is A  Big Time Popular Vote Loser
Outside California, Clinton Is A Big-Time Popular Vote Loser
Hillary Clinton's lead in the popular vote depends entirely on her outsized
JOHN MERLINE5:00 AM ET
Donald Trump's opponents are having something of a field day with news that Hillary Clinton's lead in the popular vote currently tops 1 million.

As US News put it, "Trump's legitimacy has been called into question by his adversaries because he didn't win the popular vote, adding to the desire among his critics to defy him from the start of his administration."


The Nation alerted its readers that "Republican nominee will become president with less popular support than a number of major-party candidates who lost races for the presidency." (The Nation conveniently ignores the fact that Bill Clinton won his first race with just 43% of the popular vote.)

California Sen. Barbara Boxer introduced a bill to eliminate the Electoral College, calling it an "undemocratic system that does not reflect our modern society that."


comment_left_111616The feelings among those who supported Hillary Clinton is understandable. After all, as it stands, Trump currently has 46.78% of the vote, compared with Clinton's 47.69%. And as votes continue to be counted, her margin has increased, according to data from US Election Atlas.

But a closer look at the election returns show that Hillary's lead in the popular vote is entirely due to her oversized margin of victory in uber-liberal California.

First, let's look at the country as a whole.

So far, Trump has won the popular vote in 29 states, to Clinton's 20 states. (As of this writing, Michigan is still up in the air, although Trump currently leads in the vote count.) In other words, Trump carried 45% more states than Clinton.

Since winning state elections is what counts in the United States when running for president, Trump clearly outperformed Clinton. (Trump has 25% more electoral votes than Clinton.)

What's more, Trump's margin of victory in the states he won was, on average, higher than Clinton's.

Of the state's Trump won, he got 56.2% of the vote, on average. Of the states Clinton won, she got only 53.5% of the vote.

The only reason that Clinton is beating Trump in the overall popular vote is that California gave Clinton a huge margin of victory — which currently stands at 61% to 33%.

The thing is, California is a very populous and very liberal state — so far, it has counted more than 10.7 million ballots. As a result, California alone is dumping vast numbers of votes into the Clinton column — where she currently has 3 million more than Trump.

But what if California's vote was in line with all the other Democratic states, where Clinton beat Trump 53.5% to 40.2%?

If that were the case, Clinton would have received 860,000 fewer votes in California. And if Trump had captured the same share he received in those same Democratic states, he'd have gotten 773,000 more California votes.

In other words, if California was more like the average Democratic state, Trump would currently have a 400,000 vote lead in the nationwide popular vote.

It's no wonder Boxer wants to do away with the Electoral College, since it would let her state decide presidential elections, even if — as in this election — the Republican candidate did much better in far more states across the country.

As IBD pointed out in a recent editorial, the Electoral College was specifically designed to prevent candidates from winning the presidency simply by appealing to a few heavily-populated, highly partisan regions of the country. The Electoral College forces candidates to compete nationwide if they want to be president. That's a good thing.

Trump was right to say that, if the election were based on the popular vote, he'd have campaigned differently, particularly in states like California and New York where he had no hope of winning the popular vote but could have cut into Hillary's outsized margins and won more votes than her nationwide.

Yes, the Electoral College occasionally produces the odd outcome where the popular vote winner is the election night loser. But without the Electoral College, abnormally partisan states like California could permanently dominate the nation's politics.

It's unlikely people in "flyover" country would consider that fair, or even democratic. http://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/outside-california-clinton-is-a-big-time-popular-vote-loser/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    10 years ago

Of the state's Trump won, he got 56.2% of the vote, on average. Of the states Clinton won, she got only 53.5% of the vote.

The only reason that Clinton is beating Trump in the overall popular vote is that California gave Clinton a huge margin of victory — which currently stands at 61% to 33%.

 

Not buying into the premise of the article.

 

I mean, Trump won plenty of States with a similar 60 to 30 (give or take) breakdown.

As for the " he got 56.2 of the vote" , on average while she got 53.5 if true, so what?

The best tracking spreadsheet of the popular vote I've found is here .

It's updated several time through out the day and presently shows Hillary up by 1,400,000+, with a margin of victory at 1.1% and getting closer to the per-election national polls that showed 2 to 3 percent leads for her.

 

 

As you can see Trump is currently winning the 13 Swing States by 48.5% to Hillary's 46.6%.

The other States, the Non-Swing States, like California or Texas, Clinton is leading 48.6% to Trumps 45.9%.

 

Not sure why folk are tying to dis American voters just because of where they live. 

The fact that will go down in the history books is that Hillary won the race, and Americas heart, by the millions but Trump won the contest.

 

Oh well, we lived through the Disco years, lets hope President Trump does better by America than that.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  ArkansasHermit   10 years ago

Looking over that spreadsheet [thanks for the link] it appears that this seed is fairly close to accurate . Of the locations for which Clinton got > 60% of the popular vote only 2 of them had any substantial quantity of vote totals : California & Mass. with Cali having a much larger total ...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

This article could not be more stupid if it tried. 

California has 1 out of 8 Americans living in it. You can't take away that number of people and then say "if" , and have it mean anything. 

 

How about something really meaningful about this election?

Clinton is expected to have won the popular vote by 2 million when all the votes are counted. All of those two million votes are the same thing as votes that were not counted. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"Clinton is expected to have won the popular vote by 2 million when all the votes are counted. All of those two million votes are the same thing as votes that were not counted. "

Who would an illegal alien vote for?  Considering 3 million votes (and counting) were fraudulent she didn't win shit.  

This is one reason "popular vote" is unacceptable. Another is that this entire election would have been decided by one state full of moonbats.   Exactly what the electoral system was designed to stop.  It works.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

 this entire election would have been decided by one state full of moonbats. 

This statement is nonsensical. One state can no more decide the election by itself than Southern Baptists can.  Furthermore it would make just as much sense to say the bigots in Texas could have decided the election. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

CA and NY could easily decide elections.  You yourself said 1 in 8 Americans live in CA didn't you?   The electoral system is designed to stop highly populated areas with like views from deciding the election for everyone and sorry but Texas has no where near the population of California.

I noticed you intentionally ignored the important part of the post which is that she didn't even really win popular vote if you throw out the fraudulent votes.    Sucks to back a loser, huh?   BTW that is another HUGE reason for the electoral system.  They would be fighting over fraudulent votes until the next election.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

seems some people are having a hard time understanding , more likely accepting  that the race for the presidency is not one huge national race or campaign, it is 50 +( talking about DC , protectorates and territories that still vote) individual state races where the results contribute through the awarding of EC votes.

 Those supposed 2 million votes still counted , the problem is they only counted in securing that the states( that they were cast in) EC votes would go to a specific candidate , those 2 million votes do not affect any other states vote , nor the outcome as the system is set up.

 there have been calls to ditch the electoral college, all that would take is a constitutional amendment  , Unfortunately, it would take ratification by the very states that would be adversely affected , right now there are 9 states with the bare min of 3 EC votes  think they are going to vote to ratify to nullify the importance or the weight of their vote?

 Also keep in mind to defeat such an amendment would simply take 13 states to fail to ratify, If all 9 of the min EC vote states fail to ratify , that leaves 4 states that would have to decide not to ratify . can anyone name 4 states other than the 9 that would wish to keep their EC votes due to the chance the popular vote is centered in high population density areas? outside their respective states?

people have a better chance of changing how the ec votes are awarded on the state level since that's where its decided how  an individual states ec votes are dispersed, and I say that because a constitutional amendment to drop the EC has about as much chance as ...... well I will let you fill in the blank with whatever impossability  you desire.

I like to remember this , didn't come up with it , but it remains very true, Once political power is granted ,it is very difficult to impossible to take back with out the consent of those that hold it . and it holds true at all levels of politics. 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

Mark,

While I totally agree with what you said, my issue is with the premise of this article. In fact, it runs contrary to what you just posted. No matter how you slice it, California's electoral votes are no different than Wyoming's. That is the purpose of the electoral system. And since California is part of the US, their votes both electoral and popular count. 

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Perrie, maybe that will show folks I'm not what they think on both sides , lol.

 I took the title , read the body , read the comments , and posted to the comments , tried to keep it like a civics class discussion. Lord knows ( whatever lord or being one choices to believe in ) my civics class teacher is more than likely rolling over in her grave laughing, because when my class did its mock constitutional convention , I was an adamant and vocal opponent of the electoral college., I took me almost 20 years later , and another 20 to figure out a way to make the EC actually work for all the voters , but I DID finally get it .

I think the title of the article is pretty spot on , the votes of the people of California ( or any highly populated state for that matter ) the signifigance of them do not cross the states boundries  and because of the Electoral system , an indirect method of voting used only for the presidential race , that popular vote cannot be won in one state and the excess results applied to another state to flip it into a win column  for any particular candidate. and that is what I believe the Popular vote adherants are looking at , they want a direct , true democratic vote , but that's not the system we have  or was given to us .

through the last week or so there have been many discussions about the pros and cons of the EC, and I do think it needs some fixing so that it more closely relates to how places vote. But there is one reason , no one , not even myself has breached as to why the EC came about . the founders , did not want dynasties , they made the absolute min qualifications for the office of president  that they could , so that the office was open to anyone that was a certain age , and a natural born citizen and had lived in the country for the last 7 years . Others can and do tack on their own qualifications as their want , but those are the only 3 the constitution dictate., so why the Ec only for the Presidency? to avoid , the appearance of the divine right of kings ( a monarchy) , so that the office could not be passed down within a family as a political right, and the control was left in the hands of the voters to decide if the individual candidate was qualified on their own merits , and not by merits or circumstance of birth. but that is only a tool keeping the vote in the hands of the populous , the EC helps make a candidate whom the mob may think because of connections  have to stand on their own merits , in other words they have to work for it , and if they lose an election , they didn't work for it . they didn't work hard enough to convince their detractors of their own merits , and I think this last election is proof that mud slinging is effective , but counter productive.

So again , why the EC vote only for the presidency ?  because the head executive officer , is not only the head of the executive branch , but they are the figurehead of the nation, they are the equal to all other leaders of other countries , be they elected or a monarchy or however they are chosen , The president of these United ( said with tougne in cheek) bows to no one and no other leader should be bowing to them in servitude or status.

 Washington  warned us against the formation of political parties , because the office of the presidency, represents not only within the nation , the whole of the nation to those outside our borders, and its been too long that the office was taken over by political parties .

Politicians always strive for more power individually , parties just gets more people behind that Idea, and the pendulum of power swings as the voters see fit  with the system afforded us.

 sorry for the long dissertation folks.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

In 2008 Obama won the election with 10 million more popular votes than McCain.  He won California with 3 million more popular votes than McCain.  He won New York with 2 million more popular votes than McCain.

Half of the popular votes he received for this election in 2008 came from those two states.  This means these two states provided at least half the popular votes he received compared to the other 48 states popular votes. 

Now tell me how could this represent the entire nation if we chose our president by popular votes?

I hear from those complaining the 1% have all the wealth and they don't like it.  How can they complain when the 4% (New York and California 2/50) control half the popular votes in this nation? 

I know Obama had at least 3 million more votes in California for 2008 and 2012.  I haven't gone to the trouble to see how many votes he won these two years in New York, but I can assume it was probably along the same lines.

One of the reasons for the Electoral College is to give all states a voice in the election of our president and not allow the most populous states to elect every president.  I would feel the same if everything was turned around.  I want all Americans to have a voice, but I want all states those Americans live in to also have a voice in electing our President.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact

seems 2 members that have signed on to the compact violated it  this past election and went with what the popular vote in the state said and not what the national popular vote dictated , Pa , and Mi.

pretty sure if it was used , a challenge would be issued in court and the USSC would end up deciding .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

stand corrected , Pa and Mi have bills pending , but no law to join the compact currently.

 so the question actually is , do the residents of those states want to keep the sanctity of their votes in state or give it up to popular national opinion, even if it is contrary to how they vote in state in the majority?

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

seems 2 members that have signed on to the compact violated it  this past election and went with what the popular vote in the state said and not what the national popular vote dictated , Pa , and Mi.

 

Mark the pact is set to go into effect once enough States have passed the law so that at least 270 EC votes are pledged.

If the goal of the Presidential election was to win the popular vote, then every vote in every State would count.  Meaning that XX's vote in Californian would count just as much as my vote in Arkansas would. 

It wouldn't matter where voters live, be it on a mountain top in the heart land or on the east/west coast, ALL votes would hold equal value, no more of this 3/5th compromise of the 1800's or the "got to keep the rabble from voting and ruining things" of the original framers.

The EC is an anachronism that has out lived any usefulness.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  ArkansasHermit   10 years ago

Exactly! One person, one vote. No matter where they live!

 
 

Who is online

CB


103 visitors