GOP introduces plan to massively cut Social Security
On Thursday, Rep. Sam Johnson, a Republican from Texas and chair of the Ways and Means Committee, introduced legislation to significantly cut Social Security.
The bill introduced by Johnson, who is also the chair of the Social Security subcommittee, slashes benefits, adds means testing, and would raise the retirement age from 67 to 69.
For most workers, the bill would cut Social Security benefits substantially. As Michael Linden, associate director for tax and budget policy at Center for American Progress, pointed out on Twitter, a letter from Social Security’s Office of the Actuary calculated workers making around $50,000 would see checks shrink by between 11% and 35%.

Nearly every income bracket would see a reduction, save for the very bottom. People making around $12,280 in 2016 who have worked for 30 years would see an increase of around 20%. But young people making the same amount would be hit hard by the changes. If they had 14 years of work experience by 2016, they would see their benefits cut in half .
Don't believe everything you read unless you have the ability to read between the lines. First the GOP hasn't introduced anything. A Republican, that's one man has introduced legislation.
Center for American Progress
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Center for American Progress ( CAP ) is a progressive public policy research and advocacy organization . According to CAP, the center is "dedicated to improving the lives of all Americans, through bold, progressive ideas, as well as strong leadership and concerted action." [2] The Center presents a liberal [3] viewpoint on economic issues. It has its headquarters in Washington, D.C.
The president and chief executive officer of CAP is Neera Tanden , who worked for the Obama and Clinton administrations and for Hillary Clinton ’s campaigns. [4] The first president and CEO was John Podesta , who served as chief of staff to then U.S. President Bill Clinton , and is currently serving as Hillary Clinton's 2016 Campaign Director. [5] Podesta remained with the organization as chairman of the board until he joined the Obama White House staff in December 2013. Tom Daschle is the current chairman. [6]
Remember, don't believe everything you read. Everyone has an agenda. You just have to look for it. It helps if you can read between the lines as well. Fake News is alive and well.
For most workers, the bill would cut Social Security benefits substantially. As Michael Linden, associate director for tax and budget policy at Center for American Progress, pointed out on Twitter, a letter from Social Security’s Office of the Actuary calculated workers making around $50,000 would see checks shrink by between 11% and 35%.
Can you tell me which one of the 30 pages Michael Linden from Center for American Progress derived this information from? Office of the Actuary
How is this a fake news story?
Rep. Sam Johnson, R-Tex., chairman of the Ways and Means Social Security subcommittee. Is he not a republican congressman from Texas? Is he not chairman of the Ways and Means Social Security subcommittee?
Did he not introduce the bill?
It takes one person to introduce a bill in congress.
It is another failed liberal program many conservatives were against right from the get go. I can remember my father explaining to me how bad it is 35 years ago. Time to start phasing it out. It is on an unsustainable path right now.
It is another failed liberal program many conservatives were against right from the get go. I can remember my father explaining to me how bad it is 35 years ago. Time to start phasing it out.
I'm sure many of us here on NT would agree with those words of wisdom from your father-- and agree that Social security benefits should be reduced-- and better yet, eliminated altogether!
This is the Fake News Campaign put out by the Liberals. You see those lines in the graph above? Well the solid line is the way Social Security is today and the dotted line is the proposal from Sam Johnson. If it stays the way it is today it is going to die anyway. How many people do you know who paid all their lives and never received a dime of Social Security?
Social Security is on an unsustainable path as it is today. The author received all his information from the Center For American Progress, a left wing organization started by John Podesta. You can rest assured no matter what Sam Johnson proposed CFAP wouldn't have anything good to say about it even if it was the best thing since sliced bread.
Tell me again out of those 30 pages at this link where he derived the information to condemn the proposal.
For most workers, the bill would cut Social Security benefits substantially. As Michael Linden, associate director for tax and budget policy at Center for American Progress, pointed out on Twitter, a letter from Social Security’s Office of the Actuary calculated workers making around $50,000 would see checks shrink by between 11% and 35%.
Can you tell me which one of the 30 pages Michael Linden from Center for American Progress derived this information from? Office of the Actuary
I've paid into SS since 1973-- even paying double when I owned my own business and made both the employee payment and the employer match. Now, that I need it, it had better be there.
Dowser, armed and dangerous. And I won't be alone!
Dear Friend Dowser: Right there with you.
E.
It will be torches and pitchfork time!
Yes. I want my money back!
It seems everyone is ready to jump without knowing what they are jumping into judging from the comments thus far. Quite a few are just taking the article at its word without even having any idea if anything it says is true.
Too many are ready to jump down Sam Johnson's throat for wanting to take away their Social Security, when they don't even know that is true. I put a graph above to show how Social Security was going to be unsustainable after a number of years in the future and it was ignored as if it wasn't even there.
I think people just want to complain or have something to complain about and facts and other things like that just get in the way, so they just continue on their merry way without verifying anything that would hinder them from having something to complain about.
Just stop for a moment and think.... Do you really think Sam Johnson wants to gut everyone's Social Security? Does that make any real sense to you? Why would someone want to cut out the security blanket for the elderly? It doesn't make any sense. What Sam Johnson is acknowledging is Social Security is in trouble and the benefits will definitely be reduced if something is not done about it, according to Social Security itself.
But why bother yourselves with such trivial knowledge as that when you can have someone tell you a story of how he has introduced a plan that will massively cut Social Security and without anything more than that, you can believe it is true, especially when the information in the article comes directly from those most closely tied to the Clintons and Obama. It can be the bad old GOP, who want to take away your Social Security after you've paid in for so many years.
Just how much money is in the Social Security Fund anyway? Does anyone know? Well, starting in 2010 Social Security, which is paid out from the money received from people paying in today has had to supplement the amount needed to cover their expense with the interest they earn on their Treasury Bonds. I wouldn't be surprised that is all on paper, but I don't know. Well that cushion from those Treasury Bonds is being eaten away by the shortage of Social Security Taxes they receive and it won't be many years until the Bonds themselves will be eaten away to cover the shortfall if something isn't done to change the inevitable. Then it will truly be pay as you go as it was in the beginning.
Now don't you think it would be wise to plan a little ahead in order for our children and grandchildren to have a little piece of the pie or are we going to eat the whole thing ourselves and leave them with nothing but the empty pie pan?
Dear Friend Sixpick: There are intermediate to long term funding problems with Social Security. Agreed.
Where we may disagree, let me know if this is so, are the following considerations.
There will be shortfalls due to the fact that the population that collects Social Security upon retirement is living longer, and collecting more. The working middle class is shrinking, and not paying in enough to pick up that slack. Earners beyond a certain income point do not pay into the system the same proportion of their earnings as do people below them on the earnings scale. That helps a shortfall to occur.
Disability claims are up. This may have more to do with a lack of meaningful employment than recent increased medical challenges. That I do not know. It may be part of the problem.
It also may have to do with a health care system that is the world's most expensive, but far from most effective. That one is more than possible. Cutting SS and privatizing Medicare and Medicaid will harm rather than help resolve those issues, in my view. The best bang for the buck on health care is to get out ahead of disease. Increasing wellness, preventing illness, and the faster diagnosis and treatment plan implementation always bring best results at lowest costs.
The biggest problem I see is that there are fewer middle class jobs with good solid reliable salaries, wages and benefits. Not enough of the former middle class has the kind of meaningful substantial gainful activity that is needed to contribute to the system to refund it.
Large corporations lay off more than they hire. They use technology to eliminate employees up and down the economic pyramid. That all costs the system money in various ways. Small business is the job creation engine in America. It is getting crowded out in the credit markets by larger globalized concerns. Small firms today are the big ones tomorrow. Technologies mature. We need to reward innovation that creates jobs and generates government income, while reducing government expenses that deal with both un and under employment to make this all work. I know that is easier said than done. I think efforts should be here, not cutting necessary programs to insure their funding.
Cutting claims on SSA, which millions paid into for decades by calling it an entitlement, which it isn't will not resolve this issue. I wish I saw both or even either party addressing where the next wave of good paying jobs will come from to refund the system. It will need to come form innovation here which cannot export work, and which creates rather than eliminates high paying jobs. It will also need to make favorable our balance of trade rations.
More than anything else, reestablishing the middle class in the USA is what will refund and pay for SSA, Medicare, Medicaid, Unemployment Benefit Insurance, and technical higher education that produces turn key graduate employees trained in what commerce and industry need to compete globally; etc.
We also need to make the tax system more fair for all. Also it will be necessary to make sure all pay their fair share. That is where reform will do the most good, in my view.
I did see your chart.
I think you and I do not disagree about challenges to SSA and other very successful programs over the years that are necessary to keep America great.
I believe we differ in how to best address funding shortfalls.
Let me know your thoughts on this Six.
I greatly respect your well thought out viewpoints.
Peace and Abundant Blessings On Top of Holiday Greetings to You and Yours.
Enoch.