╌>

How Not To Make America Great Again

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  9 years ago  •  32 comments

How Not To Make America Great Again


ap16307545912052_0.jpg?itok=dyidCppf




AP Photo/Claire Galofaro






Terry Wright, a 59-year-old retired union painter, adjusts the U.S. flag on his porch in Portland, a white, working class neighborhood in Louisville. 




--------------------

http://prospect.org/article/how-not-make-america-great-again

It’s the 1950s, Donald Trump  told  New York Times  reporter David Sanger , that is the “again” he has in mind when he speaks of making American great again. We may cavil that in the Fifties, African Americans still suffered under Jim Crow laws and women endured their own distinctive discrimination, but for the white male working class—whose heirs, today, are the core of Trump’s support—things had never been better. They were still the guys who’d won World War II, and their newfound material prosperity was the social miracle of the age, and testament to the rightness of the American way.           

But if Trump’s appeal to his base is his promise to restore these onetime protagonists of the American epic to their rightful place, he’ll need a radically different set of economic policies than those he now champions. Bringing back the factories won’t in itself recreate the lost economic Eden of the Eisenhower era. A factory can sustain a community by generating middle-income jobs—or it can submerge that community by paying no more than Walmart wages. Increasingly, American factories do the latter.

Trump may hail the promise of a manufacturing renaissance, but as a  report last year  from the UC Berkeley Center for Labor Research and Education, citing a previous study from the National Employment Law Project, made clear, “the typical manufacturing production worker made 7.7 percent below the median wage for all occupations.” In 2014, the median hourly wage for assembly line workers employed directly by the manufacturer was $15.04, but for the growing number employed by staffing agencies (which the Berkeley Center put at a rapidly rising 9 percent of factory workers, and who constitute the majority of the workers at Nissan’s auto factories in Mississippi and Tennessee), the median wage was $10.88. Indeed, fully 59 percent of the families of factory workers in Mississippi, the Berkeley study documented, were on some form of public assistance (Medicaid, food stamps, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and the like), while the national average for such factory worker families was 34 percent.

Today, the only factory workers who can claim some kind of economic kinship with those of the era which Trump vows to resurrect are the ones in unionized factories, where hourly wages can reach as high as $30. But there are fewer and fewer such workers. In 2000, according to a  Pew Research Center report , 19 percent of manufacturing workers belonged to a union. By 2014, that figure had fallen to 13 percent, even as the number of all manufacturing workers also declined from 11 million to eight million.

That’s a far cry from the 1950s, when close to 60 percent of manufacturing workers enjoyed the pay and benefits of a union contract, which is the main reason why median household income in those years rose at the same rate as productivity. The steeply progressive taxation of the years during and following World War II (which saw the highest marginal rate top 90 percent) also yielded working-class gains the likes of which we’ve not seen since. As John Kenneth Galbraith documented in his 1958 classic  The Affluent Society , the lowest-income quintile of American families saw their after-tax incomes rise by 42 percent during the 1940s, the second lowest by 37 percent, the third lowest (that is, the middle) by 24 percent, the fourth lowest by 16 percent, and the fifth lowest (that is, the richest) by 8 percent. The wealthiest 5 percent actually saw their incomes drop by 2 percent.

In short, absent unions and New Deal progressive taxation, the economy of the 1950s that Trump sees as the era of American greatness would never have existed.

And how will Trump’s policies recreate that broadly-shared prosperity? They won’t. The tax plans his campaign put out were every bit as regressive as those of the ‘40s and ‘50s were progressive, slashing taxes chiefly on Trump’s economic peers. The anti-union designs of congressional Republicans and such Trump appointees as Labor Secretary-designate Andy Puzder will likely push the rate of private-sector unionization below 5 percent, all but extinguishing the last vestiges of collective bargaining. A factory may open here or there, but odds are it will pay its workers—or rather, the temps who labor there full time—what they could make at Walmart or one of Puzder’s fast-food franchises.

Bringing back the widely-shared prosperity of the time when America was Trumpianally Great requires a great deal more than bringing back a factory or two or 200 or 2000—even if those factories aren’t as automated as nearly every factory is these days. It requires giving workers the right to demand their fair share of the revenues they produce. It requires a tax code that rewards work rather than speculation. American won’t be “great again” until ordinary Americans regain the power that Trump and the Republicans are determined to keep far from their grasp.

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

In short, absent unions and New Deal progressive taxation, the economy of the 1950s that Trump sees as the era of American greatness would never have existed.

And how will Trump’s policies recreate that broadly-shared prosperity? They won’t. The tax plans his campaign put out were every bit as regressive as those of the ‘40s and ‘50s were progressive, slashing taxes chiefly on Trump’s economic peers. The anti-union designs of congressional Republicans and such Trump appointees as Labor Secretary-designate Andy Puzder will likely push the rate of private-sector unionization below 5 percent, all but extinguishing the last vestiges of collective bargaining. A factory may open here or there, but odds are it will pay its workers—or rather, the temps who labor there full time—what they could make at Walmart or one of Puzder’s fast-food franchises.

Bringing back the widely-shared prosperity of the time when America was Trumpianally Great requires a great deal more than bringing back a factory or two or 200 or 2000—even if those factories aren’t as automated as nearly every factory is these days. It requires giving workers the right to demand their fair share of the revenues they produce. It requires a tax code that rewards work rather than speculation. American won’t be “great again” until ordinary Americans regain the power that Trump and the Republicans are determined to keep far from their grasp.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Unions have been bleeding members since the '60's and the young today specifically avoid them if they can.

They do not like the control a Union brings to the workplace. (and money grabbing to the paycheck)

Fully 75% of unions today are government employee unions, when you add the unions that are ensconced within large government contractors. It jumps to 95%

The American workforce has rejected labor unions and has been rejecting them for over 50 years.

Before you claim how great they are and so desperately needed, you might want to find out why they are being massively rejected by the workers they are supposed to represent.

The only thing unions bring to the table, is huge campaign coffers for the liberals. That's it.

And that is why liberals love them.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

The union worker was the backbone of America. Having been a union member for some years I enjoyed excellent wages and benefits. When I retired I have a nice defined pension plan and medical coverage.

Sadly, Union is a horrible word to many and there have been, and will continue to be the movement to destroy union labor in the U.S. IMO the end result will be less and less money and benefits for the worker and more and more money for the corporations.

 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

We will never have "income equality" without a revival of organized labor. 

The incoming administration will be relentlessly anti-union, and the income gap will grow not shrink. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Income equality? Unless you are a Communist, no one wants that. Not all workers earn equal rewards.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Cerenkov   9 years ago

The concept of "income equality" does not refer to everyone making the same salary or income. 

Educate yourself about a topic if you want to discuss it. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

I'm educated. You support income redistribution. You want to take money from those that earned it and give it to those who didn't. Same scheme, different name.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    9 years ago

Lots of thoughts here.

I don't believe in income equality. Even with the same position, you will always have some who work harder than others. 

That being said, I do see some benefits to unions... but also downsides. 

When my dad worked for Republic and Fairchild, they were union shops. When they had a walk out, all the guys lost their jobs, since the both companies couldn't make the pay increases. 

On the other hand, when he went to work for Grumman, they were union free. They kept it that way by telling their employees that they were part of the "Grumman Family"

Well a bit after his retirement, the family must have had a spat. He saw his pension end, and his benefits cut. Had their been a union contract, this wouldn't have happened. 

Personally, I grew leary of both. When I became a teacher, I didn't join the UFT for 3 years. The only reason I did, was that there was an impending strike, and I would be made to come in and no one likes a scab. Personally, I didn't see any great benefit from the UFT. I never had a single pay raise without a major giveback, so why was I paying those dues?

I am still ambivalent about unions. I think they do good in some industries and not so much in others. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   9 years ago

If you have a union, there is the potential of reforming and improving the union. 

If you have no union, you have no organized labor. You have a one sided negotiation. You accept what the company wants to pay you or you don't work there.

Why shouldn't labor be organized to benefit workers? Why should the company have all the power?

If some unions are not effective enough or fair enough within their own ranks, then they should be reformed. Don't throw the whole thing out.  

Screen Shot 2015 06 03 at 11.54.20 AM

The economic problem of this generation in the United States is  income inequality. The rich continue to get richer, and the rest of America wonders when, if ever, a raise is coming. The CEO-to-average-worker pay ratio in 2013 was 331:1.  For every dollar the average employee  made, a CEO made $331. Back in 1983,  the ratio was less than 50:1 . (At Wal-Mart in 2013, the  ratio was over 1000:1 .)

One of the best solutions to this problem is for workers to organize and form unions. As you can see from  the chart above , the share of income going to the top 10% of earners took off as union membership fell.

Don't get me wrong, there are a lot of legitimate drawbacks to unions. It adds another layer of political bureaucracy to the workforce. The workplace becomes less flexible, and more split into an us (workers) and them (managers) mentality. That can hurt team cohesion. And overall, it can be a detriment to business.

On the other hand, it can also remind workers that  their company isn't their friend  — everybody deserves to be paid fairly for their work. Unions can be frustrating for workers, until a crisis happens and they suddenly become indispensable. 

Organizing may not be the only solution to income inequality. But it's a big one, and it could move the economy in the right direction.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

If you have a union what are the odds you will put your business out of business. There are very few unions shops left in Detroit not because they kicked the union out. The reason is the unions drove them under. The market sets the wages not the unions. It's not 1950 anymore the rest of the world knows how to build things too these days. They are no longer carrying baskets of rice on their heads in China. Wake up Rip Van Winkle you're not living in today's marketplace. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   9 years ago

If every workplace in America was unionized, either corporations would accept a lower rate of profit in order to pay their workers better, or they would outsource all their operations in order to maintain profit at the expense of wages. Then we would have revolution in America. 

Unions are weakened and companies can do what they wish now, which is gin up profit at the expense of labor. 

Labor should get a minimum share of the pie, ---- in a set period of time when labor's share falls below a predetermined percentage, a punitive tax should be applied to business. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Let us know how the Revolution works out for you the rest of us are living and working in reality and the global marketplace. 

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    9 years ago

How Not To Make America Great Again

Piss on your allies in international forums to the benefit of Islamic colonialism and terrorism.

 
 

Who is online




Hallux


84 visitors