The US Supreme Court said Monday that the government cannot base a prosecution for sending an Internet threat solely on how the message was perceived.
Although the ruling was based on interpreting criminal law, and not on the First Amendment, it amounted to another strongly pro-free expression decision from the court under Chief Justice John Roberts.
The justices threw out the conviction of a Pennsylvania amusement park worker, Anthony Elonis, who began posting threatening message on Facebook in 2010 after his wife left him and took their two children.
One of his posts said, "There's one way to love you but a thousand ways to kill you. I'm not going to rest until your body is a mess, soaked in blood, and dying from all the little cuts."
After his estranged wife got a restraining order, he wrote, "Put it in your pocket. Is it thick enough to stop a bullet?"
Elonis was found guilty after the jury was instructed that the legal test was how his messages were perceived. In an 8-1 ruling, the court today said that was wrong.
The test, the court said, is what the sender means, not whether the recipient considers it a threat.
"Federal criminal liability generally does not turn solely on the results of an act without considering the defendant's mental state," Chief Justice Robert wrote.
There's no doubt, Roberts said, that the requirement of a guilty state of mind is satisfied "if the defendant transmits a communication for the purpose of issuing a threat, or with knowledge that the communication will be viewed as a threat."
Advocates for victims of domestic violence condemned the ruling and said the court failed to recognize how terrifying social media threats can be.
"Threats cause devastating harm to victims, including fear, anxiety, loss of sleep, and disruption, regardless of whether the abuser intended to threaten or only intended to vent or to make a joke," said Kim Gandy, president of the National Network to End Domestic Violence.
But civil liberties groups, including the ACLU, had urged the court to toss out the conviction.
"Today's decision properly recognizes that the law has for centuries required the government to prove criminal intent before putting someone in jail," said Steve Shapiro, the ACLU's national legal director. The ruling, he said, "is not a license to threaten, which remains illegal when properly proved."
Elonis was arrested in December 2010 and charged with violating a federal law that makes it a crime to transmit threats to injure someone else. He said he was kidding, imitating explicit rapper Eminem.
His lawyer argued that the legal test for a true threat should be the intent of the person making the statement. But the Obama administration argued that a message is illegal if a reasonable person would consider it threatening, regardless of what the sender intended.
Elonis's legal troubles are not over. He was arrested last week on domestic violence charges, accused of throwing a cooking pot at the mother of his current girlfriend.
~~Link~~ ~~Second Try~~ The article this linked to seems to have been moved. See Fortune link in comments below, if this doesn't work.

Coming from Roberts? Really not that interesting - more like "typical"
Individual rights be gone - period.
After reading the article, and the links to include Fortune, to say that the ruling is bizarre is an understatement IMO.
For a ''real world'' perspective, if someone sent me this message, ''One of his posts said, "There's one way to love you but a thousand ways to kill you. I'm not going to rest until your body is a mess, soaked in blood, and dying from all the little cuts.", whether it was via FB, email, phone, written letter or smoke signals, I would interpret it as ''I'm going to kill you''. His mental state is of no matter to me, he said he was going to kill me. Couch it anyway you want, but that is the end result. Threats such as this one, have in many instances led to the killing of the person receiving it. This is especially true when it comes to a woman being threated.
The consequences of this have ''disaster'' written all over it.
Good article Feronia.
I have mixed feelings about this ruling. Between teens, often these things are just venting. On the other hand, adults in serious disputes, these could be considered menacing at least and a true danger at worst.
Link is broken?
Interesting for sure...
I didn't have a problem with any of the links. First time showed ''cannot display this page'', clicked on it again and it worked fine.
I wonder the reaction of Roberts if someone sent hima message via FB, like the one above. LOLOL, he'd call out the National Guard to cover his ass, and the sender would be in jail in a NY minute.
There are many reasonable people who feel threatened by the actions of the Obama administration . Why doesn't that apply ?
I'd be serving life...or the death penalty if it was a federal crime.
IDK . I just took that quote out of the article . I didn't write the article ...
Bad, bad, bad decision. Opens online stalking up to legal status including death threats. The SCOTUS will deeply regret the results of this ruling with future cases in lower courts and the inevitable deaths, murders and suicides, they will lead to.
This pretty much opened Pandora's box.
So ... when you free associate like a woman it's OK but when a guy does it he's stoned ?
Petey hasn't been on his game of late. The hard part is deciding if it is due to him being under or over medicated.
He's just not been the same Roo for some reason......
Of course thisguy meant to scare the wits out of his ex-wife. Sheleft him and took his children,and there wasn't anything he could do about it, so why not make her life as terrifying as possible? Girlfriend or no girlfriend, his main reason for getting up in the morning was to wreak as much havoc as possible upon his wife, and by proxy, his children.
What's worse, is thatMr. Elonis is loving every, single second ofhis little victory...not because his conviction was overturned, and not because he'sbasking in the glow ofhis 15 minutes,but because he was able to shit all over hiswife and children. Again.
Hewas convicted for makingcontinuous, specific, and plausible threats against his ex-wife.Yet to hear him tell it, he was unfairly convicted for making continuous, specific, and plausible jokes against hisex-wife. That the Supreme Courteven consideredthe argument, is disappointing.Their rulingis a huge step backwards in regard to finding a solution forwhat has become a very seriousproblem.
There is good news, though. He still doesn't have his wife and children, and there is still nothing he can do about it.
You got nuthin when all you've got is personal attacks . But that's nothin new for you . Go away "pussy"cat .
Agreed.
How is it that bomb threat, even if it turns out to be a fake one,can be treated as ajailable offence but a, "I'm going to kill you bitch" however worded, can not?
Robert G pretty much sums up my view of the case. I think the ruling was absolutely correct.
Don't give me ideas, LOL!
Roberts looks constipated, Ginsberg had two glasses of wine. The rest look as though they are contemplating the meaning of life on the Supreme Court.
Wait, on second glance, Sotomayor looks as though she ready to kick Roberts ass.
To what? A jury trial with proper instructions? The Horror!