Separating fact from sickening media fiction on Trump’s immigration executive order
“Any alien coming to this country must or ought to know, that this being an independent nation, it has all the rights concerning the removal of aliens which belong by the law of nations to any other; that while he remains in the country in the character of an alien, he can claim no other privilege than such as an alien is entitled to, and consequently, whatever risque he may incur in that capacity is incurred voluntarily, with the hope that in due time by his unexceptionable conduct, he may become a citizen of the United States.” ~ Justice James Iredell, 1799
It’s important not to conflate political arguments with legal arguments, as many liberals and far too many “conservatives” on social media are doing. While the timing and coordination of implementing this order might have been poorly planned, we shouldn’t allow that to undermine the broader need to defend our sovereignty. For courts to violate years’ worth of precedent and steal our sovereignty should concern everyone.
What the order actually does
Among other things, the key provisions at the center of the existing controversy are as follows:
It shuts off the issuance of all new immigrant and non-immigrant visas for 30 days from the following seven volatile countries: Syria, Iraq, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen. Any non-citizen from those seven countries (not “all” Muslim countries) is excluded from entering the country during this time-period (which usually means they won’t be able to board a direct flight to America). After 90 days, the secretary of state and secretary of homeland security must submit a report to completely revamp the vetting process going forward.
Within 60 days, countries will have to submit any information that the administration determines necessary, pursuant to the findings of this report, in order to adjudicate a visa application and ensure they are properly vetted. Any country that fails to submit this information will not be able to send foreign nationals to our country. All the while, the ban can be extended and expanded at any time.
In addition, the entire refugee resettlement program is suspended for four months pending a complete investigation of the program and a plan to restructure it and prioritize those who are truly in danger of religious persecution. After 120 days, the program may resume, but only for those countries Secretaries Kelly and Tillerson determine do not pose a threat. The program from Syria is completely suspended until the president personally gives the green light.
[T]his was actually a judicious and cautious approach from Trump.
With regards to refugees and those who seek to enter from the seven countries temporarily excluded, the order gave discretion to the State Department and DHS to admit individuals on a case-by-case basis for important reasons, even during the temporary moratorium.
Statement of principles on the right of a country to exclude non-citizens
Those who want to immigrate : There is no affirmative right, constitutional or otherwise, to visit or settle in the United States. Period.
Based on the social contract, social compact, sovereignty, long-standing law of nation-states, governance by the consent of the governed, the plenary power of Congress over immigration, and 200 years of case law, our political branches of government have the power to exclude or invite any individual or classes people for any reason on a temporary or even permanent basis – without any involvement from the courts. [1] Congress has already delegated its authority to the president to shut off any form of immigration at will at any time.
Immigrants already here : Those already admitted to this country with the consent of the citizenry have unalienable rights. They cannot be indefinitely detained. However, they can be deported for any reason if they are not citizens. In Fong Yue Ting v. United States ( 1893), which is still settled law, the court ruled that Congress has the same plenary power to deport aliens for any reason as it does to exclude them and that the statutory procedures and conditions for doing so are due process. [2] Congress has established the process for deportation of those already here. However, as long as a legal permanent resident leaves the country he has no affirmative right to re-enter. [3] Either way, they have absolutely no right to judicial review other than to ensure that statutes are properly followed.
But can Trump prevent those with green cards from re-entering the country?
The statute is clear as day. The Immigration and Nationality Act (§ 212(f)) gives the president plenary power to “by proclamation, and for such period as he shall deem necessary, suspend the entry of all aliens or any class of aliens as immigrants or nonimmigrants .” Clearly, the president has the authority to block any non-citizen – including refugees, green card holders, and foreign students – from entering the country. Also, for purposes of deportation, there is no difference between a green card holder or a holder of a non-immigrant visa. No foreign national who has not yet obtained citizenship has an affirmative right to re-enter the country.
Is this a ban on Muslim immigration?
No, it’s a moratorium on immigration or re-entries from seven individual countries and a temporary moratorium on refugees from all countries, subject to case-by-case exceptions.
Why didn’t Trump place restrictions on immigration/visas from Saudi Arabia and other Muslim countries?
That’s probably a good idea. But this was actually a judicious and cautious approach from Trump to start with low-hanging fruit. These seven countries are failed states or enemies of the U.S. (in the case of Iran). As such, there is absolutely no way to share data with the host countries and properly vet them. Somalia has been one of the biggest trouble spots. The other countries are marred in Islamic civil wars. Moreover, these are the countries that existing law targets for travel restrictions, and that Obama’s own DHS listed last year .
Why would Trump include green card holders in the ban on re-entry?
Both liberals and conservatives expressed concern over hundreds of individuals going over to fight for ISIS. We are already limited in how we can combat this growing threat among U.S. citizens. Given that it is completely legal to exclude non-citizens upon re-entry, Trump extended the ban to legal permanent residents as well.
If a Somali refugee is travelling back to Somalia (so much for credible fear of persecution!), government officials should have the ability to prevent that person from coming back when necessary. Obviously, there are some individuals from these seven countries who already have green cards and we might not want to exclude. That is why the order grants discretion to the State Department to issue case-by-case exemptions for “religious persecution, “or when the person is already in transit and denying admission would cause undue hardship.” A CBP agent is always stationed at any international airport from which these individuals would board a direct flight to the United States (Paris and Dubai, for example). That individual would not allow anyone covered by this ban onto a U.S.-bound flight unless he grants them a hardship exemption.
Indeed, it appears that green card holders returning yesterday from those seven countries were all granted entry .
What’s with the chaos at the airports and the courts?
Henceforth, CBP agents will not allow individual aliens from those seven countries to board a flight to the U.S. So the chaos will end.
The problem arose from the 100 or so individuals that were already in transit when the order took effect. When they arrived at American airports, they were detained at customs. Standing at this point is not tantamount to being on American soil. [4] However, a federal judge in New York issued a stay and prevented the feds from sending two individuals back on a flight. Other judges have prevented officials from even detaining such persons. It’s unclear if federal agents might have made a mistake and released some of these individuals before ordering them to leave the country. Once they are released onto American soil, any effort to remove them is treated as a deportation, not an exclusion, and is subject to the due process afforded them by congressional statutes (not the Constitution).
Thus, it’s unclear if the stay even applied to any element of the order or whether it applied to anomalous circumstances or particular actions taken by federal officials that overstepped the order.
It’s also confusing because many contemporary judges have no respect for our sovereignty and have been gradually chipping away at the plenary power of Congress (or the president, pursuant to statute) to exclude aliens re-entering the country, despite years of settled law. If courts are indeed violating our sovereignty, this is the very grave danger I warned about in Stolen Sovereignty . Either way, it should not affect the ability of the administration to enforce the order against those who want to prospectively board flights to return.
- Flashback 1: The Obama-Clinton 'Muslim Ban'
- Flashback 2:The executive action on immigration Obama refuses to use
[1] Nishimura Ekiu v. United States, 142 US 651 (1892). [“ It is an accepted maxim of international law that every sovereign nation has the power, as inherent in sovereignty, and essential to self-preservation, to forbid the entrance of foreigners within its dominions , or to admit them only in such cases and upon such conditions as it may see fit to prescribe.”]
[2] Fong Yue Ting v. United States, 149 US 707 (1893). [“the right of a nation to expel or deport foreigners who have not been naturalized, or taken any steps towards becoming citizens of the country, rests upon the same grounds, and is as absolute and unqualified as the right to prohibit and prevent their entrance into the country.”]
[3] As Justice Felix Frankfurter observed, the notion that immigration policy is “entrusted exclusively to Congress has become about as firmly embedded in the legislative and judicial tissues of our body politic as any aspect of our government…" “[T]here is not merely 'a page of history'… but a whole volume,” wrote Frankfurter, that any alien not legally domiciled in this country is as if he is standing outside our soil as it relates to due process rights or judicial review to overturn a deportation. Galvan v. Press 347 US 531–32 (1954). What better authority on this subject than Justice Robert Jackson, the famous Nuremberg prosecutor who was a champion of due process rights (he wrote the dissent in Korematsu v. United States, the Japanese internment case) and regarded as one of the greatest writers of his time? Here is what he had to say: “Due process does not invest any alien with a right to enter the United States, nor confer on those admitted the right to remain against the national will.” Shaughnessy v. Mezei, 345 US 222-223 (1953) (Jackson, J., dissenting).
[4] United States v. Ju Toy, 198 US 253 (1905); Shaughnessy v. Mezei, 345 US 215 (1953).
Chris Pandolfo contributed to this report.
https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2017/01/trump-immigration-executive-order-fact-fiction
Tags
seeder
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoThe law is clear. He is within his rights as President to do exactly what he has done. INCLUDING those with green-cards. Get over it.
JohnRussell
replied to
Dowser
9 years agoIt made 'sense' to put people in concentration camps and internment camps too. It makes 'sense' to enslave people (if you are the slaveowner.) Making 'sense' is not necessarily the standard we are looking for.
Dowser
replied to
JohnRussell
9 years agoWhere did I say that I agreed with the premise? All I said was that it was a well-researched, sensible article. It did not contain bad words, and it was well-reasoned. That's NOT to say that I agree with it.
Sheesh, John. Stop criticizing anything that offends your personal agenda. I'm trying to figure out HOW I feel about all this-- Part of that is listening to both sides.
JohnRussell
replied to
Dowser
9 years agoSorry Dowser. You gave the article tacit approval. Be responsible for your own comments for petes sake.
Dowser
replied to
JohnRussell
9 years agoI approve the reasonable tone of the article. There, that I will own.
JohnRussell
9 years agoThe seeded article just puts a logical framework onto a cruel policy. Frankly, any repressive or restrictive or punitive policy can be put in official sounding , logical, language. All totalitarian governments are quite good at that.
In addition, the entire refugee resettlement program is suspended for four months pending a complete investigation of the program and a plan to restructure it and prioritize those who are truly in danger of religious persecution.
There has been virtually no violence perpetrated by people from the seven affected countries. I read this morning that there have been zero deaths in the US from terrorist attacks by individuals who had immigrated to the US from those countries. Not zero last months or last year. Zero.
What then is the necessity of this action? The chances of any individual American being killed by a terrorist is negligible. So why is Trump so anxious to do this that the immigration officials tasked with carrying out the process of the order were literally unprepared to do so yesterday?
It is fear mongering. This is how a demagogue like Trump keeps his hold on people. Play to their fears and prejudices.
seeder
Uncle Bruce
replied to
JohnRussell
9 years agoJohn.
Let's discuss this. Civilly.
It's not a question of If it's happened, but when it will happen.
The evidence is there that the terrorist organizations of the world have used open borders and refugee status to carry out terrorist attacks. One only has to look at what has happened in Europe in the past few years.
Luckily, it hasn't happened here. Yet.
But that doesn't mean it wont. And at some point we are going to have to take a hard line look at our open hearts and borders. When do you suppose we should do that? Now, before a refugee or immigrant commits an act of terror that kills innocent people? Or do we wait until it does happen, and then blame the President for not doing enough to protect us?
Trump campaigned on a statement of "banning Muslims". And he was widely criticized for it. Even by his running mate Pence. This is the "Art of the Deal" Trump. He opens high, and negotiates down to something that can be accepted.
And what has he negotiated down to? NOTHING that isn't already a policy, but that has been set up for reform. All of the countries have already been designated as "countries of concern". The only addition to that is Syria.
What he has done is taken a time out. 120 days. With direction to the agencies to have a plan before him in 60 days for a better vetting process. This isn't a permanent ban. Not yet. It requires the agencies to work with the 7 nations to provide us with acceptable measures for vetting individuals from those countries. I say it isn't a permanent ban yet because he leaves open the option to permanently ban if those nations refuse to assist in the vetting process. All of this can be read in the Order.
Trump is not banning Muslims. He is denying visas to EVERYONE in those countries. Muslim, Christian, Jew, Spaghetti Monster followers. His order does say that when the ban is lifted, refugee status will be afforded to Christians as a priority. Because right now those are the most persecuted from those countries.
As for the number of refugees, just as my other article stated, the cap at 50,000 is not a drastic reduction in the norm, it is a return to the norm.
I can remember a time when Obama signed an Executive Order that allowed for the government to take control of industry and infrastructure in time of National Crisis. The front page of the old NT site went absolutely bonkers over this. Conservatives almost lost their minds over the perceived power grab. But I did some research. And I found that it was nothing more than a re-issue of an Executive order dating back to the Truman Administration. Every President reissues it. I urge you to actually look at what has been included in THIS order, and set aside the Alternative facts that the MSM is reporting on it.
A. Macarthur
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoTrump is not banning Muslims. He is denying visas to EVERYONE in those countries. Muslim, Christian, Jew, Spaghetti Monster followers. His order does say that when the ban is lifted, refugee status will be afforded to Christians as a priority. Because right now those are the most persecuted from those countries.
I haven't seen that, but if you can show it's the case, I'll consider its rationale.
Otherwise, I for one appreciates your effort to disagree and discuss a hot topic with civility.
seeder
Uncle Bruce
replied to
A. Macarthur
9 years agoWhich part Mac?
The part about denying entry of all? That's covered because his order states "Individuals from". He never mentions Islam or Muslims, although his rational in the order does mention honor killings and such.
As for preference to Christians:
(b) Upon the resumption of USRAP admissions, the Secretary of State, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, is further directed to make changes, to the extent permitted by law, to prioritize refugee claims made by individuals on the basis of religious-based persecution, provided that the religion of the individual is a minority religion in the individual's country of nationality. Where necessary and appropriate, the Secretaries of State and Homeland Security shall recommend legislation to the President that would assist with such prioritization.
A. Macarthur
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoto the extent permitted by law, to prioritize refugee claims made by individuals on the basis of religious-based persecution, provided that the religion of the individual is a minority religion in the individual's country of nationality.
The term "to the extent possible" constitutes a proviso that renders everything else subject to whim, bias, partisanship … you name it. When I was involved in contract negotiations, I would never have agreed to any management-written clause with that phrase, the word "may" instead of "will/shall/must" …
… regarding the words …
" … provided that the religion of the individual is a minority religion in the individual's country of nationality … "
How many of the countries Trump has named have Islam as a minority religion?
That would be … NONE.
Consequently, it's a Muslim ban.
But I will listen to any specific rebuttal to what I posted above.
seeder
Uncle Bruce
replied to
A. Macarthur
9 years agoI disagree. It starts with this:
Upon the resumption of USRAP admissions
meaning when the ban is lifted. 90 days I believe.
As for this being a Muslim ban, since the admissions has been suspended for all individuals, it's not a Muslim ban. Upon resumption, it doesn't state that only Christians will be allowed refugee status. It states Religious based persecution. This could include Sunni Muslims of Iraq, Kurdish Muslims, Yazidis, Mandaeans, etc. To be sure, this is a result of Christian persecution, but Christians are not the only ones being persecuted in that part of the world.
A. Macarthur
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoIt states Religious based persecution. This could include Sunni Muslims of Iraq, Kurdish Muslims, Yazidis, Mandaeans,
It could, but I'll wager you $10 for a charity of your or my choice, that it won't.
And it also equivocates in the language I cited.
We disagree.
seeder
Uncle Bruce
replied to
A. Macarthur
9 years agoWe disagree.
The irony of this AMac is the parallels with our arguments on gun control. At this point I would make a statement that while there may be flaws in this plan, we need to do something. Which I believe is the crux of your argument on gun control.
A. Macarthur
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoLaws, including the Constitution itself, can be amended or changed or abolished to reflect the time in which they are in effect.
I have never advocated a ban on firearms nor laws that can not be enforced; I deem any/all laws be written, passed and/or amended in order to do whatever positive effects they can plausibly, reasonably generate.
The equivocating language in the law you cited, Trump's rush to implement it in such a way that his own administration can't get on the same page, and, that every related fuck up is called a "media" misrepresentation … all of this makes for bad government.
Good back-and-forth on this, Bruce.
seeder
Uncle Bruce
replied to
A. Macarthur
9 years agoI have a new article up that goes into more detail about this, including Trump's talking points on the matter:
JohnRussell
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoThe largest Muslim population country in the world was not included in the order.
Hmmm. You might say Indonesia doesn't export terrorists.
But they might one day, maybe even one day soon, who knows. You said that we have to ban these Muslims from the seven countries because it is inevitable that one day someone from these countries will commit a terrorist act on US soil. That may be so. But is also inevitable that one day a terrorist will come from Indonesia or someplace outside the seven.
I think what will happen is that after the 4 month period Trump will say "that worked really well and kept America safe" so let's continue it and expand it. The thing is, doing nothing probably would have worked just as well. After all , there have been no terror attacks from immigrants from these countries. But we will get the argument that Trump prevented massive terrorist attacks.
The previous administration said that refugees are already vetted for two years. That has worked. Why are we changing? How do we know these new rules won't act to spur terrorist recruitment? Some experts have said they think it will.
I don't trust the lying piece of shit mf Trump as far as I could throw him. Or Bannon, elevated now to the National Security Council. What in jack shit does he know about national security?
They are stoking nationalism and ethnocentrism, and this is a way to go about it. That is what is going on here.
JohnRussell
9 years agoI have no idea why people, other than right wing ideologues and other Trump butt kissers , would applaud this article. All it does is reaffirm the cruel and unnecessary 'right' of Trump to impose these bans. It gives no justification for them.
A. Macarthur
9 years agoThe Conservative Review is an American media group whose goal is to provide conservative voters with a reliable source of information on the nature of federal officeholders and candidates for federal office.
Editor Mark Levin
In March 2016, Levin endorsed Ted Cruz for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination . [47] After Donald Trump was nominated, in September 2016, Levin stated on this radio program that he would vote for Donald Trump in the general election , following his declaration earlier that year that he was in the " Never Trump " camp. [48] He qualified his support by stating that, "I take no responsibility for the dumb things he says or the dumb things his surrogates say." [49]
Levin began his broadcasting career as a guest on conservative talk radio programs. For many years, he was a frequent contributor of legal opinions to The Rush Limbaugh Show , where Limbaugh referred to him on-air as "F. Lee Levin," a tongue-in-cheek reference to the defense attorney F. Lee Bailey . He was also a contributor to The Sean Hannity Show and eventually got a radio slot of his own on WABC , initially on Sundays beginning in 2002, then in the timeslot following Sean Hannity in 2003. Cumulus Media Networks began syndicating The Mark Levin Show nationally in 2006.
Levin is known for his frequent use of the pejorative "moron" and "puke" for people he opposes. [16] [17] [18] Hannity has nicknamed Mark Levin "The Great One". [19] Levin and Hannity remain frequent contributors to each other's programs. He is a leading conservative commentator, ranked 4–6 position nationally among talk radio programs, with a minimum of 7.75 million total weekly listenership according to Talkers Magazine . [20]
Kavika
9 years ago''The law is clear. He is within his rights as President to do exactly what he has done. INCLUDING those with green-cards. Get over it.''
Yes, it is legal. Many things have been legal, but not morally right. That is the history of our nation.
Slavery, legal at one time...Moral, NO
Chinese exclusion act, legal at one time...Moral, NO
Japanese internment camps..Legal at one time...Moral, NO
The St. Louis..Legal at one time...Moral, NO
Depriving people of their civil right...Legal at one time...Moral, NO
The list goes on Bruce. I guess that it depends on ones moral compass as to what is right and just. The law is written by those in power and in many cases it is legal, but not moral.
“Due process does not invest any alien with a right to enter the United States, nor confer on those admitted the right to remain against the national will.” Shaughnessy v. Mezei, 345 US 222-223 (1953) (Jackson, J., dissenting).''
So what this states is that anyone with a green card, if someone decides it's against the national will they have no right to be in the U.S. Who decides what is against the national will? Is a poll taken, does everyone get a vote for or against it?
IMO, this will be a great recruiting tool for terrorists around the world.
Kavika
replied to
Cerenkov
9 years agoI didn't say that they have a recruiting problem Cerenkov. I said it will be a great recruiting tool. They can add it what they are already doing.
I'm not interesting in not offending terrorists either, I am interested in hopping that this doesn't cause more American deaths by giving the terrorists additional tools to reach that end.
A. Macarthur
replied to
Cerenkov
9 years ago"IMO, this will be a great recruiting tool for terrorists around the world."
Where have you gotten the impression they have a recruiting problem? I'm not interested in not offending terrorists.
Go to your dictionary and look for the definitions of "more", "additional", "heightened" …
Are you interested in not offending allies?
I'm through with you in this thread.
Last word is yours.
Cerenkov
replied to
A. Macarthur
9 years agoI don't need a dictionary; I am well read.
If they have the tools they need vis a vis recruiting, as they clearly do, withholding redundant tools is not a good reason to avoid responding to a threat.
seeder
Uncle Bruce
replied to
Kavika
9 years agoDon't like it? Call your Congressman. Have him change the law.
A. Macarthur
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoDon't like it? Call your Congressman. Have him change the law.
Good idea … I speculate that many of those currently protesting in the streets of the U.S., will have already done so, or, will subsequently.
And check the major corporations who are objecting, the number of new or changed voter affiliations …
There's an anti-Trump shit storm goin' on.
Kavika
replied to
Uncle Bruce
9 years agoBruce, I thought that you wanted a discussion on this. I guess that I was wrong on that count.
magnoliaave
9 years agoIt appears some will protest anything ......it is in vogue now!
The ONLY problem that I have with this is the fact that those who were in transit should have been allowed to enter the U.S. with proper credentials.
President Trump will be handing down some very unpopular orders.....good for him and us! It is about time that our President stand strong against all the bleeding hearts in our Country.
BTW.....outstanding article!
