February 10, 2017
What will you do when terrorists attack, or U.S. friction with some foreign power turns into a military confrontation? I don’t mean in your personal life, where you should keep calm and carry on. I mean politically. Think about it carefully: The fate of the republic may depend on your answer.
Of course, nobody knows whether there will be a shocking, 9/11-type event, or what form it might take. But surely there’s a pretty good chance that sometime over the next few years something nasty will happen — a terrorist attack on a public place, an exchange of fire in the South China Sea, something. Then what?
After 9/11, the overwhelming public response was to rally around the commander in chief. Doubts about the legitimacy of a president who lost the popular vote and was installed by a bare majority on the Supreme Court were swept aside. Unquestioning support for the man in the White House was, many Americans believed, what patriotism demanded.
The truth was that even then the urge toward national unity was one-sided, with Republican exploitation of the atrocity for political gain beginning almost immediately. But people didn’t want to hear about it; I got angry mail, not just from Republicans but from Democrats, whenever I pointed out what was going on.
Unfortunately, the suspension of critical thinking ended as such suspensions usually do — badly. The Bush administration exploited the post-9/11 rush of patriotism to take America into an unrelated war, then used the initial illusion of success in that war to ram through huge tax cuts for the wealthy.
Bad as that was, however, the consequences if Donald Trump finds himself similarly empowered will be incomparably worse.
We’re only three weeks into the Trump administration, but it’s already clear that any hopes that Mr. Trump and those around him would be even slightly ennobled by the responsibilities of office were foolish. Every day brings further evidence that this is a man who completely conflates the national interest with his personal self-interest, and who has surrounded himself with people who see it the same way. And each day also brings further evidence of his lack of respect for democratic values.
You might be tempted to say that the latest flare-up, over Nordstrom’s decision to drop Ivanka Trump’s clothing line, is trivial. But it isn’t. For one thing, until now it would have been inconceivable that a sitting president would attack a private company for decisions that hurt his family’s business interests.
But what’s even worse is the way Sean Spicer, Mr. Trump’s spokesman, framed the issue: Nordstrom’s business decision was a “direct attack” on the president’s policies. L’état, c’est moi.
Mr. Trump’s attack on Judge James Robart, who put a stay on his immigration ban, was equally unprecedented. Previous presidents, including Barack Obama, have disagreed with and complained about judicial rulings. But that’s very different from attacking the very right of a judge — or, as the man who controls 4,000 nuclear weapons put it, a “so-called judge” — to rule against the president.
The really striking thing about Mr. Trump’s Twitter tirade, however, was his palpable eagerness to see an attack on America, which would show everyone the folly of constraining his power:
Never mind the utter falsity of the claim that bad people are “pouring in,” or for that matter of the whole premise behind the ban. What we see here is the most powerful man in the world blatantly telegraphing his intention to use national misfortune to grab even more power. And the question becomes, who will stop him?
Don’t talk about institutions, and the checks and balances they create. Institutions are only as good as the people who serve them. Authoritarianism, American-style, can be averted only if people have the courage to stand against it. So who are these people?
It certainly won’t be Mr. Trump’s inner circle. It won’t be Jeff Sessions, his new attorney general, with his long history of contempt for voting rights. It might be the courts — but Mr. Trump is doing all he can to delegitimize judicial oversight in advance.
What about Congress? Well, its members like to give patriotic speeches. And maybe, just maybe, there are enough Republican senators who really do care about America’s fundamental values to cross party lines in their defense. But given what we’ve seen so far, that’s just hopeful speculation.
In the end, I fear, it’s going to rest on the people — on whether enough Americans are willing to take a public stand. We can’t handle another post-9/11-style suspension of doubt about the man in charge; if that happens, America as we know it will soon be gone

If Trump were an honest, relatively moral, person we would have less cause to fear what he might do. Alas, that is not the case.
Krugman can get his white flag ready as we pound his liberal socialist ideology into the ground.
Liberals premising an argument with
"people" are saying."
Just perfect irony. Almost as good , refusing to accept the results of the election a few weeks after telling everyone that not accepting the results of an election was in Americans and treasonous.
Well we are listening... and guess what we are not hearing, seeing reading..
FACTS!
PROOF!
TRUTH!
No Sources to back anything up...
WHICH MEANS IT'S PROPAGANDA.
Everything they are posting is propaganda....
Their fears are triggered because they do not have control...
Poor babies...
Trump had one chance to have a successful presidency, and he is blowing it. He had to CHANGE, and appear to be honest and psychologically stable, and he has not done it. He is the same blowharding, constantly lying and petty fool that he was for the year and a half campaign. He is going down the drain.
Does he have some power right now? Yes, but it is fleeting. A majority is already uniting against him and his flunkies.
John, you continue to outdo yourself.
Don't you have some communists to find under your bed?
John,
This country does still have checks and balances, something that Germany didn't have. I am not saying that it is impossible to happen, but highly unlikely and this is a bit of a panic attack.
It is more about the attempt than the results. Donald Trump is not an honest person. If there was a "Reichstag Fire", he would come under immediate suspicion. He has done this to himself.
John,
Do you actually believe that Trump would do that? I mean for real?
I don't like the dude, but that has never crossed my mind.
Well, I don't think he would burn down Congress, if that is what you mean.
Would he look the other way while a terrorist incident was staged? I wouldn't put it past him.
Do you actually believe that Trump would do that? I mean for real?
Well, his poll numbers are continuing to fall. Worse, now when Americans are asked the general question of, " should Trump be impeached" , 46% say no while 46% say yes and we're only weeks into his cluster fork.
Americans Now Evenly Divided on Impeaching Trump
Raleigh, N.C. – PPP's new national poll finds that Donald Trump's popularity as President has declined precipitously just over the last two weeks.
On our first poll of his Presidency voters were evenly divided on Trump, with 44% approving of him and 44% also disapproving. Now his approval rating is 43%, while his
disapproval has gone all the way up to 53%.
If voters could choose they'd rather have both Barack Obama (52/44) or Hillary Clinton (49/45) instead of Trump.
Just three weeks into his administration, voters are already evenly divided on the issue of impeaching Trump with 46% in favor and 46% opposed.
Support for impeaching Trump has crept up from 35% 2 weeks ago, to 40% last week, to its 46% standing this week. While Clinton voters initially only supported Trump's
impeachment 65/14, after seeing him in office over the last few weeks that's gone up already to 83/6.
Lots more for Pres Trump to worry about in this PPP report.
Voters think he's over reaching to make a country safe...that they already consider to be safe.
66% of Americans consider the United States to be a safe country, to only 23% who consider it unsafe. Perhaps as an outgrowth of that sentiment only 45% of voters support Trump's Executive Order on immigration, to 49% who are opposed to it.
Among those who do support it you have to wonder how well thought out their position is - by a 51/23 margin Trump voters say that the Bowling Green Massacre shows why Trump's immigration policy is needed.
By a 48/43 spread, voters do think that the intent of the Executive Order is to be a Muslim ban. And just 22% support a Muslim ban, to 65% who are opposed.
The order has also increasingly raised issues about Trump's competence in voters' eyes - only 27% think the Executive Order was well executed, to 66% who think it was poorly executed. The spread on that question was 39/55, when we asked last week.
Trump has shown a knack for starting two dumpster fires today in order to draw peoples attention away from the one he lit yesterday so the thought of him doing something drastic, should his numbers continue to fall, isn't that far fetched.
Pres. Trump's thoughts about what actions to take in order to distract might not immediately go toward staging his own "Reichstag Fire" but you've got to just know that that's one of Bannon's wet dreams.
I bet some of his clingy supporters even had family members that were killed in the Bowling Green massacre.
Well there are some similarities,
Kristolnacht? we definitely have seen people smashing up the glass haven't we? Just like the Nazis...
And the reams and reams of endless propaganda? stuff that comes from unprovable/verifiable "Sources"
And miles and miles of accusations accusing everyone that disagrees with you everything but a human being....
WELL?
They said that Trump would bring out the Nazis,
I guess it did....
That is what most people are seeing.
Most people judge others by their actions, not their anglish {snicker}
It is funny to watch someone like you, who has this constant air of self-righteousness about you, defend a Donald Trump. You don't want it to be about Trump, who is indefensible, you want it to be about you and your 'understanding' of the American people, who according to you demanded the ascension of a Trump because it rebuked the liberals and socialists.
Trump's administration cannot go a day without become tangled in it's own mistakes, lies and disinformation. He is getting rapidly to the point of not deserving any benefit of the doubt.
NWM,
You are talking about random acts of civil terrorism. This is not a new phenom.
See, here is my problem with this discussion. You are both talking in the extreme and blowing things out of proportion. That I can't get my head wrapped around.
Well, some people call them organized acts of civil terrorism. No randomness at all. Officials are preparing for acts of violence long before any liberal protest event cause past experience tells than that it is anything but random.
I'm more a believer in the evidence that is right in front of me.
And I don't need to wrap my had around anything when the media is inundated with stark images of the proof.
And I'm not going to minimize or excuse it.... Violence begets violence, it is just a matter of time.
The historical pattern is there, if people would only open their eyes to see it.
The largest protest in the history of the country, the women's protests of Jan. 21, went off with millions of participants and no violence. The violent protests are are tiny part of the opposition to trump.
The centrist/libertarian Andrew Sullivan has an interesting column today which I may seed as a stand alone article. Here is part of it -
"I think this is a fundamental reason why so many of us have been so unsettled, anxious, and near panic these past few months. It is not so much this president’s agenda. That always changes from administration to administration. It is that when the linchpin of an entire country is literally delusional, clinically deceptive, and responds to any attempt to correct the record with rage and vengeance, everyone is always on edge.
There is no anchor any more. At the core of the administration of the most powerful country on earth, there is, instead, madness.
With someone like this barging into your consciousness every hour of every day, you begin to get a glimpse of what it must be like to live in an autocracy of some kind. Every day in countries unfortunate enough to be ruled by a lone dictator, people are constantly subjected to the Supreme Leader’s presence, in their homes, in their workplaces, as they walk down the street. Big Brother never leaves you alone. His face bears down on you on every flickering screen. He begins to permeate your psyche and soul; he dominates every news cycle and issues pronouncements — each one shocking and destabilizing — round the clock. He delights in constantly provoking and surprising you, so that his monstrous ego can be perennially fed. And because he is also mentally unstable, forever lashing out in manic spasms of pain and anger, you live each day with some measure of trepidation. What will he come out with next? Somehow, he is never in control of himself and yet he is always in control of you."
John, he's merely commenting on what is actually happening, as opposed to what might happen. You might want to climb down off your perch and learn something, though watch where you step in the bottom of your cage.
"...The enormity of the defiling of the White House in just three weeks is staggering. For decades the world’s security was undergirded by America’s word. The words that issued from the Oval Office were solemn. It was on America’s word, as expressed by the president, that the European continent and allies like Japan built their postwar security.
Now the words that fall from Trump’s pursed lips or, often misspelled, onto his Twitter feed are trite or false or meaningless. He’s angry with Nordstrom, for heaven’s sake, because the department store chain dropped his daughter Ivanka’s clothing line! This is the concern of the leader of the free world.
Unpresidented!
I was struck by how Paul Horner, who runs a big Facebook fake-news operation, described our times in The Washington Post : “Honestly people are definitely dumber. They just keep passing stuff around. Nobody fact-checks anything anymore — I mean, that’s how Trump got elected. He just said whatever he wanted, and people believed everything, and when the things he said turned out not to be true, people didn’t care because they’d already accepted it. It’s real scary. I’ve never seen anything like it.”
We’ve never seen anything like it because when hundreds of millions of Americans are connected, anyone, clueless or not, can disseminate what they like with a click.
Horner came up, during the campaign, with the fake news story that a protester at a Trump rally had been paid $3,500. It went viral. We’ve had fake news accounts of how Hillary Clinton paid $62 million to Beyoncé and Jay Z to perform in Cleveland, and how Khizr Khan, the father of the Muslim American officer killed in Iraq, was an agent of the Muslim Brotherhood. Fake news — BREAKING! SHOCKING! — swayed the election.
Now we have President Trump suggesting that the real fake news is his negative polls — along with CNN, The New York Times, The Washington Post and any other news organizations that are doing their jobs: holding his authority to account and bearing witness to his acts. Stephen Bannon, Trump’s man of the shadows, thinks the media should “ keep its mouth shut. ” We won’t.
Sometimes I try to imagine what Trump’s Reichstag fire moment might be. In February 1933, a few weeks after Hitler became chancellor, fire engulfed the parliament in Berlin — an act of arson whose origin is still unclear. A recent New Yorker article by George Prochnik quoted the Austrian writer Stefan Zweig on Hitler’s savage reaction: “At one blow all of justice in Germany was smashed.”
From a president who loathes the press, who insults the judiciary, who has no time for American ideals of liberty or democracy, and whose predilection for violence is evident, what would be the reaction to a Reichstag fire in American guise — say a major act of terrorism?
We can only shudder at the thought.
Facts matter. The federal judiciary is pushing back. The administration is leaking. Journalism (no qualifier needed) has never been more important. Truth has not yet perished, but to deny that it is under siege would be to invite disaster."