BREAK UP THE USA
Case in point: everyone takes for granted that it’s normal for a country of 320 million to be dictated to by a single central authority. The only debate we’re permitted to have is who should be selected to carry out this grotesque and inhumane function.
Here’s the debate we should be having instead: what if we simply abandoned this quixotic mission, and went our separate ways? It’s an idea that’s gaining traction — much too late, to be sure, but better late than never.
For a long time it seemed as if the idea of secession was unlikely to take hold in modern America. Schoolchildren, after all, are told to associate secession with slavery and treason. American journalists treat the idea as if it were self-evidently ridiculous and contemptible (an attitude they curiously do not adopt when faced with US war propaganda, I might add).
And yet all it took was the election of Donald Trump for the alleged toxicity of secession to vanish entirely. The left’s principled opposition to secession and devotion to the holy Union went promptly out the window on November 8, 2016. Today, about one in three Californians polled favors the Golden State’s secession from the Union.
In other words, some people seem to be coming to the conclusion that the whole system is rotten and should be abandoned.
It’s true that most leftists have not come around to this way of thinking. Many have adopted the creepy slogan “not my president” – in other words, I may not want this particular person having the power to intervene in all aspects of life and holding in his hands the ability to destroy the entire earth, but I most certainly do want someone else to have those powers.
Not exactly a head-on challenge to the system, in other words. (That’s what we libertarians are for.) The problem in their view is only that the wrong people are in charge.
Indeed, leftists who once said “small is beautiful” and “question authority” had little trouble embracing large federal bureaucracies in charge of education, health, housing, and pretty much every important thing. And these authorities , of course, you are not to question (unless they are headed by a Trump nominee, in which case they may be temporarily ignored).
Meanwhile, the right wing has been calling for the abolition of the Department of Education practically since its creation in 1979. That hasn’t happened, as you may have noticed. Having the agency in Republican hands became the more urgent task.
Each side pours tremendous resources into trying to take control of the federal apparatus and lord it over the whole country.
How about we call it quits?
No more federal fiefdoms, no more forcing 320 million people into a single mold, no more dictating to everyone from the central state.
Radical, yes, and surely not a perspective we were exposed to as schoolchildren. But is it so unreasonable? Is it not in fact the very height of reason and good sense? And some people, we may reasonably hope, may be prepared to consider these simple and humane questions for the very first time.
Now can we imagine the left actually growing so unhappy as to favor secession as a genuine solution?
Here’s what I know. On the one hand, the left made its long march through the institutions: universities, the media, popular culture. Their intention was to remake American society. The task involved an enormous amount of time and wealth. Secession would amount to abandoning this string of successes, and it’s hard to imagine them giving up in this way after sinking all those resources into the long march.
At the same time, it’s possible that the cultural elite have come to despise the American bourgeoisie so much that they’re willing to treat all of that as a sunk cost, and simply get out.
Whatever the case may be, what we can and should do is encourage all decentralization and secession talk, such that these heretofore forbidden options become live once again.
I can already hear the objections from Beltway libertarians, who are not known for supporting political decentralization. To the contrary, they long for the day when libertarian judges and lawmakers will impose liberty on the entire country. And on a more basic level, they find talk of states’ rights, nullification, and secession – about which they hold the most exquisitely conventional and p.c. views – to be sources of embarrassment.
How are they going to rub elbows with the Fed chairman if they’re associated with ideas like these?
Of course we would like to see liberty flourish everywhere. But it’s foolish not to accept more limited victories and finite goals when these are the only realistic options.
The great libertarians – from Felix Morley and Frank Chodorov to Murray Rothbard and Hans Hoppe — have always favored political decentralization; F.A. Hayek once said that in the future liberty was more likely to flourish in small states. This is surely the way forward for us today, if we want to see tangible changes in our lifetimes.
Thomas Sowell referred to two competing visions that lay at the heart of so much political debate: the constrained and the unconstrained. In the constrained vision, man’s nature is not really malleable, his existence contains an element of tragedy, and there is little that politics can do by way of grandiose schemes to perfect society. In the unconstrained vision, the only limitation to how much society can be remade in the image of its political rulers is how much the rubes are willing to stomach at a given moment.
These competing visions are reaching an endgame vis-a-vis one another. As Angelo Codevilla observes, the left has overplayed its hand. The regular folks have reached the limits of their toleration of leftist intimidation and thought control, and are hitting back.
We can fight it out, or we can go our separate ways.
When I say go our separate ways, I don’t mean “the left” goes one way and “the right” goes another. I mean the left goes one way and everyone else — rather a diverse group indeed — goes another. People who live for moral posturing, to broadcast their superiority over everyone else, and to steamroll differences in the name of “diversity,” should go one way, and everyone who rolls his eyes at all this should go another.
“No people and no part of a people,” said Ludwig von Mises nearly one hundred years ago, “shall be held against its will in a political association that it does not want.” So much wisdom in that simple sentiment. And so much conflict and anguish could be avoided if only we’d heed it.
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

I have long believed this to be the only solution for our differences.
For who? You? Sorry but I am not on board and here is why.
First of all, define leftist. Is it just a democrat, a socialist or just someone who disagrees with how you would like to see government run?
The map above is the electoral college map. It is not a representation of this country. It is a representation of voting districts, most of which are gerrymandered. That map only represents this last election. Here is the one fro 2008:
Literally half the map is one color or the other. And even that doesn't represent population.. but that s a whole different story. See, the issue here is are the independents, or swing voters, or those who hate both failed parties. Right now they make up more than either party does.
When I say go our separate ways, I don’t mean “the left” goes one way and “the right” goes another. I mean the left goes one way and everyone else — rather a diverse group indeed — goes another.
I am always amused when I read something like this. It's like we have forgotten American History. This country was built on the left. Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, were the leftist of their time. Radical ideas like telling the king to take a walk. The diverse group that you identify here are have people in it that voted for Obama in the last election. They were looking for change.
What the real issue is, is that there is real concern that President Trump will be able to govern. If he has the skills. Personally, I don't, but hey, he won, so he is my president for at least 4 years. But do I think that this election defines the country? Not at all. I think we may be at turning point with what we expect our government to do for us or not.. but I don't believe that we are NOT a UNITED States. We are redefining ourselves as we have many other times in our history. Where we will end up, is yet to be determined.
The map above is the electoral college map. It is not a representation of this country. It is a representation of voting districts, most of which are gerrymandered.
It's not a map of Districts, it's a map of counties. Which means it is irrelevant when it comes to the electoral college.
I did a map by district and posted it back in November in a discussion with Mac on voting and why the popular vote doesn't work.
WE were discussing how to make the electoral college work without disenfranchising a single voter.
The search here doesn't work very well and I can no longer find it. It was in the columnist section of the FP but it has dropped off now...
It looks a LOT different than the electoral college map..... A LOT more red than blue. (than even the county map above)
Hey I found one, it uses different colors to juxtapose both the presidential by district and the house by district on one map which is even more revealing of the nationwide breadth of Trumps win....
No landslide mind you, but a complete win nonetheless.
Here it is...
And yet no where in that representation are independents.
That is true, it represent how the votes totaled by district, and the only ones that counted were the ones that finalized it one way or the other....
I think is is interesting in that it also shows how Trump won..... (By turning Democrat districts to Republican and how few it actually took)
I am always amused when I read something like this. It's like we have forgotten American History. This country was built on the left. Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, were the leftist of their time. Radical ideas like telling the king to take a walk. The diverse group that you identify here are have people in it that voted for Obama in the last election. They were looking for change.
To start with I'm a registered Democrat, but most on here would call me a DINO. I would say I am more of a Libertarian than anything else. The Founding Fathers can be compared to the Left of today no more than saying exhaling is the same as inhaling. They were more Libertarian than anything else. It boils down to collectivism. The Founding Fathers were more for the individual than for the collective. The Left today are for the collective with equal outcomes.
Sure, they want change, more change than we already have from the Founding Father's original intentions. The Left today are for bigger government to take care of everyone from cradle to grave.
The Founding Fathers were very Liberal if you think of those who are in favor of change if you look at the traditional definition, but in their time they were completely controlled by the King, which would be basically the same as big government today. They wanted that to end.
Today Right Wing and Left Wing do not mean Conservative and Liberal according to the traditional definition. The Right Wing is for small government, individualism, equality, individual rights, separation of powers and a weak executive, while the Left Wing is for big government, collectivism, equality of outcome and collective entitlements.
The difference in then and now is being Liberal then and wanting change was to rid them of the big government and being Liberal today is wanting more big government.
You can say they were the Left in their day, but they wanted the exact opposite of what the Left wants today. The Founding Fathers were for individualism and the Left today are for collectivism.
If this is not true, then why do the left identify with big government and vote for people who promise it to them?
With all due respect I think that saying that liberals are in favor of big government oversimplifies the issue very much. Liberals do want a government that is a servant of the people and that has a very strong safety net because that is good for the overall health of the nation. It does not have to be big government as much as it needs to be efficient government. Again, big government is an oversimplification IMHO.
This is an Infowars story that mentions two racists , Murray Rothbard and Lew Rockwell , who were also anachro-capitalists.
This article is the equivalent of mental masturbation.
Half the country would prefer to live with marxist principles and the other have not.
How can one have a serious conversation when the term "marxist" is thrown out?
Again from the Pew, the large variation of political views in this country:
This is the true view of American political views, without the hyperbole.
We aren't ever going to agree with one another. We can Either restore States rights or fracture the divide into two countries.
Given the above picture we were never going to agree with each other and probably, we never have. Yet we remained a country. The balance of states rights vs federal rights has been an ongoing discussion since the writing of the Constitution. It is something that is very shifting and not fixed. You, as a libertarian, resist any form of government. I as an independent, view it issue by issue. There is probably even points where we agree, but for that matter, I am sure there are points where I agree with John. But here is the rub; right now, there are far more indies than any other political group, so it is we who have to suffer you guys, and not the other way around. And yet we do with grace and with consideration to the other POV's.
I highly suspect there are far less "independents" who truly vote that way, than you think.
How many "independents" almost always vote Democratic? How many almost always vote Republican? I would suggest that this is the case for most independents.
I am an indie and I have voted for all parties. I know a whole lot of indies and I know that they just like me.
I bet there on those on this site that HATE to think of Jefferson as a liberal... LOL!
I agree Dowser. In fact, he was an anarchist.
For his time, yes! LOL!!!
I agree Dowser.
So do I, a virulent liberal in fact.
In fact, he was an anarchist.
Nope, not hardly, Anarchists want to blow it all up and have no rules. Not Jefferson at all.
"I do not know whether it is to yourself or Mr. Adams I am to give my thanks for the copy of the new constitution. I beg leave through you to place them where due. It will be yet three weeks before I shall receive them from America. There are very good articles in it: and very bad. I do not know which preponderate. What we have lately read in the history of Holland, in the chapter on the Stadtholder, would have sufficed to set me against a Chief magistrate eligible for a long duration, if I had ever been disposed towards one: and what we have always read of the elections of Polish kings should have forever excluded the idea of one continuable for life. Wonderful is the effect of impudent and persevering lying. The British ministry have so long hired their gazetteers to repeat and model into every form lies about our being in anarchy, that the world has at length believed them, the English nation has believed them, the ministers themselves have come to believe them, and what is more wonderful, we have believed them ourselves. Yet where does this anarchy exist? Where did it ever exist, except in the single instance of Massachusets? And can history produce an instance of a rebellion so honourably conducted? I say nothing of it's motives. They were founded in ignorance, not wickedness. God forbid we should ever be 20. years without such a rebellion. [1] The people can not be all, and always, well informed. The part which is wrong will be discontented in proportion to the importance of the facts they misconceive. If they remain quiet under such misconceptions it is a lethargy, the forerunner of death to the public liberty. We have had 13. states independant 11. years. There has been one rebellion. That comes to one rebellion in a century and a half for each state. What country ever existed a century and a half without a rebellion? And what country can preserve it's liberties if their rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance? Let them take arms. The remedy is to set them right as to facts, pardon and pacify them. What signify a few lives lost in a century or two? The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants. It is it's natural manure. Our Convention has been too much impressed by the insurrection of Massachusets: and in the spur of the moment they are setting up a kite to keep the hen yard in order. I hope in god this article will be rectified before the new constitution is accepted." - Thomas Jefferson to William Stephens Smith, Paris , 13 Nov. 1787 [2]
He wasn't talking about anarchy, he was talking about stirring up the pot, adjusting the social order to maintain the freedom we had gained.
Jefferson was a Republican, one side of the Democrat-Republican party, he described then as what would soon become known as Whigs, a term of art that he coined himself. (in his discussion on Whigs and Tories and how they have been present from the first government man created)
Anarchy in the terms as being described in England at the time, (complete disarray) his passage rejects such terms...
WE cannot take that passage out of context....
The full passage...
The British ministry have so long hired their gazetteers to repeat and model into every form lies about our being in anarchy, that the world has at length believed them, the English nation has believed them, the ministers themselves have come to believe them, and what is more wonderful, we have believed them ourselves. Yet where does this anarchy exist? Where did it ever exist, except in the single instance of Massachusets? And can history produce an instance of a rebellion so honourably conducted? I say nothing of it's motives. They were founded in ignorance, not wickedness. God forbid we should ever be 20. years without such a rebellion. [1] The people can not be all, and always, well informed. The part which is wrong will be discontented in proportion to the importance of the facts they misconceive. If they remain quiet under such misconceptions it is a lethargy, the forerunner of death to the public liberty. We have had 13. states independant 11. years. There has been one rebellion. That comes to one rebellion in a century and a half for each state. What country ever existed a century and a half without a rebellion? And what country can preserve it's liberties if their rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance? Let them take arms. The remedy is to set them right as to facts, pardon and pacify them.
I turned yours to black, look at the first part I put in red, it is an absolute rejection of anarchy. As the British government and many around the world was falsely claiming that our nation was a nation in anarchy. He rejects that ideal in toto.
The second part I put in brown concerns how you deal with anarchy, which he states that if necessary, you take up arms and put them down and pacify them. Revolution he recognizes as a natural governmental state, one we hope doesn't come around very often, but should be visited in part every 20 or so years to keep the nation fresh and moving forward. But if that revolution goes to far and slips into anarchy, then put it down and set the anarchists right, forgive them, and pacify them.
Those are not the ideals of an anarchist.
Sorry.
I will meet you halfway. He did say that some rebellion is good for a country and should be tolerated, he also was for the union staying together. But the first part, does not negate that he was much more shall we say, left leaning.. then people portray him.
Now we can agree, but a liberal in his times is not a liberal today......
I really need to dig out his dissertation on whigs and tories and give it a go here.
It's eye opening....
TJ was definitely a whig in capital letters.
So was Abraham Lincoln.
I wonder if King George III thought he was... It all has to be taken in the context of his times.
I've always thought of him as a liberal... Not fond of anarchy, which is about what we have right now. I feel that this last election has really destabilized our country, and that's NOT a good thing.
and your correct he was a liberal, not an anarchist.
I feel that this last election has really destabilized our country, and that's NOT a good thing.
This country has been destabilized long before Trump got elected. The pendulum swings to the left and then to the right. The farther it swings in one direction the farther it swings in the other direction. It was on the verge of swinging so far in one direction, it would have been impossible to swing back.
The Tree of Liberty is:
Jefferson goes on to outline three basic forms of civil management: 1) no government at all, 2) a government in which the voice of the people is well represented, and 3) a government of force, “… as is the case in all other monarchies, and in most of the other republics.”
It should come as no surprise that, while he was sympathetic to the first, he was a champion of the second and a foe of the third. But at what point does government action carried out for the good of the whole but perceived by the part (assuming imperfect information being available) justify the charge of tyranny? And at what point would he concede to either rebellion to overthrow, or government force to preserve, the cohesion of a legitimate government acting in its belief that it was acting in good faith for the greatest good (all actions will have its supporters and detractors)? Especially, when the remedy of electing representatives is readily available? What would be his “test” for necessity - for justifiable rebellion against civil authority knowing that it is the government's obligation to preserve itself and the safety, happiness/property and prosperity of the greater part of its citizens?
I bet there on those on this site that HATE to think of Jefferson as a liberal... LOL!
Remember a pretty rainbow you saw after a rain. It's still a rainbow, but the definition has been hijacked just like the word gay when you were happy. The word Liberal has been hijacked the same way. Liberal today is not synonymous to Liberal during the days of our Founding Fathers. They were Liberals searching for independence and liberty. Today Liberal is synonymous to the exact opposite. They want more change. They want everyone to adhere to a central government which governs over them exactly opposite of Liberty and individualism.
He wanted change, but the exact opposite of the change the Left or Liberals want today or they wouldn't be supporting or voting for the people who promise them all the goodies at someone else expense.
But here is the rub; right now, there are far more indies than any other political group,
Are there more indies than there are people who generally support one of the two parties? No.
Correct?
Are there more indies than there are people who generally support one of the two parties? No.
Correct?
Not correct. Look at the first chart here:
There are more indies than in any party right now.
Independent = 36
------------------------------
Democrats = 33
Republicans = 28
_______
61
John,
Try again... I said that there are more independents than any one party... not both.
Perrie dear, independents are not the largest group then. Adherents of the parties are the largest group.
Put it like this, are there more independents or non-independents ?
John,
You are choosing to ignore what I am trying to say. In an election, most Republicans will vote Republican and most Dems will vote Dems, but the game changer in any election is the largest body of voters, who are independents. Hence why for 8 years you had Obama and now you have Trump.
I don't disagree with that. If there wasn't a number that changed from election to election (also allowing for new voters) then the same party would win every time.
What I am saying is the majority has not given up on the two party system.
It's the two party system that brought you Trump. How do you feel about that? Maybe if we had a third viable party, the outcome would have been different.
If more independents did the right thing Nov 8 we wouldn't be in this predicament.
If the dems did their job, maybe we wouldn't be here.
"When I say go our separate ways, I don’t mean “the left” goes one way and “the right” goes another. I mean the left goes one way and everyone else — rather a diverse group indeed — goes another."
And then down the road, "everyone else" fractures into a 'new left' and 'everyone else'. And down the road from that, the same thing happens repeatedly until you end up with what looks like a US map without a federal government (the Un-United States). Then it becomes apparent that what they all really need is to get together and formalize important agreements with one another to address the infrastructure that connects them all. In other words, taking Libertarianism to its logical conclusions amounts to recreating the wheel. Meanwhile, the rest of the world leaves us in the dust as we spend decades, centuries possibly, overthinking the concept of freedom when we could be focusing on being a competitive world power.
I have an idea - all the libertarians build an ark and go find a desert island where they can build their utopia, and the rest of us can stay here and remain Americans.
In other words, taking Libertarianism to its logical conclusions amounts to recreating the wheel. Meanwhile, the rest of the world leaves us in the dust as we spend decades, centuries possibly, overthinking the concept of freedom when we could be focusing on being a competitive world power.
I think that was pretty much the thesis of this article.
Yep, simply revealing what they do not know.
Or assuming what they think they do is truth.
Mostly it's funny....
Who is this "they" you are talking about? Anyone who does not absorb your wisdom? lol
Think of yourself and anyone who thinks like you.
which leaves only one conclusion...... Your absolutely right.
as long as I absorb none of yours.
The article is the same Anarchistic BS we have heard before. No solutions or constructive ideals, just "tear it all down".
Anarchism is a social philosophy which considers the state undesirable, unnecessary, and harmful, and instead promotes stateless societies , or anarchy . Anarchists seek to diminish or even eliminate reliance upon claims of authority in the conduct of human relations, but thus have widely disagreed on what additional criteria are essential or beneficial to anarchism and human society. It is usually identified as the most anti- authoritarian of social philosophies.
~Wiki~
No that's not what this article is about. It is about decentralization like Brexit. Brexit is not anarchy.
Secession from the United States is unconstitutional. States can leave the union, but only by act of Congress.
If the article were speaking about the US decentralizing from a union of other countries you would be correct Dean, but it most absolutely is NOT discussing that; rather, it is speaking of breaking apart the US.
That's right a union made up of individual states.
Yes, states, not countries. BIG difference.
Only individual in the respect that they govern themselves, A union as soon as they join.
AS far as the legal aspects of it, that was settled by the Civil War.... Once in you can never get out.