╌>

Research Problems Unravel Liberal Narrative Alleging ‘Everyone Is Racist’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  barney-frank  •  9 years ago  •  32 comments

Research Problems Unravel Liberal Narrative Alleging ‘Everyone Is Racist’

                                                                      

                                                                       18e1486845928596.jpg

 

 

 

Years of sensational coverage has made the ‘implicit bias’ test out to be a foolproof predictor of racist belief. The evidence strongly suggests otherwise.

 

 

 

One of the more pervasive assumptions of modern American society, particularly in my generation, is the notion that “ everyone is racist ,” “society” has made everyone racist, and—most importantly—much of this racism is “implicit” or “subconscious,” something that isn’t directly observable but nonetheless real.

“They’ve done tests,” people insist. “These tests show that you are more likely to have positive responses towards white faces and negative responses towards black faces. It’s been proven by science. You’re probably racist, too, even if you deny it.”

These “tests” have constituted a critical cornerstone of the modern progressive view of racism: where no actual racial animus can be found, liberals have often resorted to accusations of “unconscious” racism, pointing to alleged research that shows an alleged subliminal streak of racism deep within the hearts of us all.

What is most convenient about these accusations is that they cannot readily be denied. If someone accuses you, without any specific evidence, of harboring deep-seated racist tendencies, how can you possibly deny it and prove yourself bigotry-free? You can’t, which is the point.

Well. There are indications that these “tests,” far from being reliable or determinative of any kind of racial animus, are actually—what’s the word?— bunk.

The Weakness of the Implicit Bias Test


The first indication came earlier this year at  New York Magazine , in the form of a massive,  13,000-word essay  that examines the ubiquitous racism-detecting examination: the “implicit association test” (IAT). According to author Jesse Singal, research shows the test “is a noisy, unreliable measure that correlates far too weakly with any real-world outcomes to be used to predict individuals’ behavior.” Years of sensational coverage has made this test out to be a foolproof predictor of racist belief. The evidence strongly suggests otherwise.

Over at Vox recently , German Lopez further examined the IAT’s shortcomings. His own experience with this device would be fantastically humorous if it were not so sad. He took the test three different times, each with a different result. One showed him “free of racism, even at the subconscious level,” one showed him with “a slight automatic preference for white people,” and one more showed him with  another  “slight automatic preference—only now it was in favor of black people.”

“At this point,” he writes, “I was at a loss as to what this test was telling me. Should I consider the average of my three results, essentially showing I had no bias at all? Or should I have used the latest result? Was this test even worth taking seriously, or was it bullsh-t?”

Meditate on the cosmic absurdity of this situation: a grown man struggling to determine whether he is a bigot based on the results of an Internet test. It is hard to tell if this is modern liberalism at its peak, or at its nadir. Maybe both.

The Test Doesn’t Work Individually Or Collectively


Lopez’s investigation turns up solid evidence to suggest this test is, indeed, bullsh-t. Lopez quotes Calvin Lai, the director of the Project Implicit, who claims: “[The test] can predict things in the aggregate, but it cannot predict behavior at the level of an individual” when that individual has only taken the test once.

But as University of Connecticut researcher Hart Blanton once pointed out, this is a self-defeating distinction: “If you’re not willing to say what the positive [IAT score] means at the individual level,” he told  New York Magazine , “you have no idea what it means at the aggregate level. … If I’m willing to give 100 kids an IQ test, and not willing to say what an individual kid’s score means, how can I then say 75 percent of them are geniuses, or are learning disabled?”

This is eminently true. But perhaps the most shocking aspect of the IAT is not that it is ineffective both individually and collectively, it’s that, according to its creators,  it doesn’t even measure racism . Lopez quotes Tony Greenwald, another co-creator of the test, who says: “I and my colleagues and collaborators do not call the IAT results a measure of implicit prejudice [or] implicit racism…Racism and prejudice are explicit attitudes with components of hostility or negative animus toward a group. The IAT doesn’t even begin to measure something like that.”

Got that? The test that for years has been used to justify countless accusations of racism  isn’t even designed to qualify racism . This, mind you, coming from  the creators of the test!

This Test Has Already Taught Americans a Lie


These revelations are bad enough. More disturbing still that the implicit-association test has been around for some time, and has become a pop culture touchstone—profiled, as Lopez points out, in books like Malcolm Gladwell’s “Blink” and newspapers like the  New York   Times,  among countless other places. The test’s supposed ability to identity unconscious racism in individual test-takers has become one of those things that “everyone knows.” It has been this way for years.

Yet for all this time the test creators have apparently not mounted any significant effort to dissuade the public of these wrong assumptions. It would have taken nothing more than a jointly authored op-ed in the opinion pages of the  Times  or the Washington  Post  to set the record straight .  Nothing of the sort seems to have been done.

More disturbingly, it seems as if many others aren’t willing to push against the test’s assumptions. They may be too afraid. When Lopez reached out to researcher Blanton for additional comment, Blanton refused: “I’m mostly trying to extricate myself from that debate,” he said. “It’s genuinely unpleasant.”

The lesson is clear: progressive racial politics, which reach almost a fever pitch in colleges and academic circles, may frighten dissenters into silence. Indeed, in the course of being interviewed for Singal’s  New York  piece, IAT co-creator Mahzarin Banaji claimed that at least a few critics of the test are simply “aggrieved individuals who think that Black people have it easy in American society.” Would you want to have that accusation lobbed against you, especially in the ultra-liberal, hyper-sensitive world of academia?

Re-Examine Social Stigmas Based on Predicted Animus


What does all of this suggest? Simply put, that much of the liberal narrative surrounding race may be total nonsense. Of course that doesn’t mean racism doesn’t exist, but it does mean we can’t trust this test or the narrative that everyone or even most people are automatically biased against, or likely to act out against, individuals with darker skin.

Common sense has always suggested the IAT is not something we should take very seriously. A silly button-pushing test can’t possibly plumb the depths of the human heart or even the human subconscious. But what if, as appears to be the case, the creators of the test  themselves  subtly indicate that the test isn’t all it’s cracked up to be? What if we have evidence that dissenting voices on this topic have been cowed into silence? What are we to make of this?

It is worth honestly examining our society’s presumptions regarding race and racism, “implicit” or otherwise, and determining whether these presumptions hold up. There is no real indication that the vast majority of our academies, much less American progressives, are up to the task; they have bungled the conversation thus far and show no intention of fixing it. So perhaps it’s up to the rest of us.

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    9 years ago

There is only one answer.  It's in our DNA.

If I want to go to the top of the mountain I look up while I'm walking.  If I spend my time looking down while walking I will surely fall off the mountain.  If I have a rash I want to heal I treat it with care and do the things that will help cure it.  I will not constantly scratch it everyday.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

If I want to go to the top of the mountain I look up while I'm walking.  If I spend my time looking down while walking I will surely fall off the mountain.

If you're going up a mountain it would be wise to be conscious of your entire surroundings, if you're not looking down while walking every 30 seconds or so you will surely fall off the mountain, lol.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

That Obama speech is almost enough to turn a non-racist into a racist !

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Petey Coober   9 years ago

That Obama speech is absolutely bullshit. Racism is nothing more than learned behaviour, nothing whatsoever to do with DNA or genetics. Example of a racist lesson - Cowboy movies. The white hat is worn by the hero, the black hat is worn by the villian.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]

 

When Obama says in that interview that racism is "in our DNA" he is using a figure of speech . 

Figure of speech

A figure of speech or rhetorical figure is figurative language in the form of a single word or phrase. It can be a special repetition, arrangement or omission of words with literal meaning, or a phrase with a specialized meaning not based on the literal meaning of the words. 
 

 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

"When Obama says in that interview that racism is "in our DNA" he is using a figure of speech."

Nice spin, John. You're very good at explaining what Obama meant, even though he never to told you. You would have qualified to be Obama's Press Secretary.

DNA is an undeniable genetic marker - nothing whatsoever to do with learned behaviour, even as a figure of speech.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    9 years ago

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  96WS6   9 years ago

I second that!!!

Thanks for a fine meal of truth!!!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

Glad you guys like it and feel free to use it anytime videomatergeneral. LOL

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

Prager U has a lot of other good ones too.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  96WS6   9 years ago

???

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

Sorry Buzz I don't have a written version

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  96WS6   9 years ago

I have no idea how this will come out Buzz.  I've lowered the quality quite a bit.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

Absolutley perfect video - no stopping, jumping, buffering - I's like being in a movie theatre.

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave    9 years ago

I am very particular who I keep company with,  You have to have substance.  My two best buddies are white....my least favorite Is brown....my third best buddy is black,  It all depends on the person.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson  replied to  magnoliaave   9 years ago

Mag, your post would make Archie Bunker cringe ! Lol !

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave  replied to  pat wilson   9 years ago

Not at all......I have friends from all walks of life.  I lived in Mexico and England.  My two best buddies go back 50 years.  My third best buddy I met 10 years ago.  The brown use to be buddy was always having some kind of issue.  She just couldn't accept anything good or bad....always a problem. 

Always bringing race into everything.  What?  I can't have two white friends, one black friend and not particularly like the brown friend?  That's racist?

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave  replied to  pat wilson   9 years ago

Not at all......I have friends from all walks of life.  I lived in Mexico and England.  My two best buddies go back 50 years.  My third best buddy I met 10 years ago.  The brown use to be buddy was always having some kind of issue.  She just couldn't accept anything good or bad....always a problem. 

Always bringing race into everything.  What?  I can't have two white friends, one black friend and not particularly like the brown friend?  That's racist?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    9 years ago

Very interesting article 

 
 

Who is online