Exclusive: China warns U.S. surveillance plane near "Man made military islands"
Above the South China Sea (CNN)The Chinese navy issued warnings eight times as a U.S. surveillance plane on Wednesday swooped over islands that Beijing is using to extend its zone of influence. The series of man-made islands and the massive Chinese military build-up on them have alarmed the Pentagon, which is carrying out the surveillance flights in order to make clear the U.S. does not recognize China's territorial claims. The militarized islands have also alarmed America's regional allies. READ: China cautions U.S. Navy on patrols A CNN team was given exclusive access to join in the surveillance flights over the contested waters, which the Pentagon allowed for the first time in order to raise awareness about the challenge posed by the islands and the growing U.S. response. CNN was aboard the P8-A Poseidon, America's most advanced surveillance and submarine-hunting aircraft, and quickly learned that the Chinese are themselves displeased by the U.S. pushback. "This is the Chinese navy ... This is the Chinese navy ... Please go away ... to avoid misunderstanding," a voice in English crackled through the radio of the aircraft in which CNN was present. This is the first time the Pentagon has declassified video of China's building activity and audio of Chinese challenges of a U.S. aircraft.

An old adage - those who play with fire are going to get burned.
Another old adage - this could be the start of something big.
I've been watching this for almost 18-months now. At every step, things become a bit more dicey. Be prepared for ship and aircraft collisions here in the near future.
I hope we continue to use surveillance planes on the islands and keep our Navy very active in the area. These are not China's territorial waters and if we cede them to them now, then there will be no end to the additional claims they will make. Their "territorial waters" claims will continue to grow as long as we let them and no nations in that entire section of the Pacific will be able to ship any cargo or operate a Navy without paying a tariff to them.
Dicey yes, but stop them now. Let's not give them Czechoslovakia.
Who is going to stop them? Did anyone stop Russia from annexing Crimea?
We are going to be in a war by the end of a year...
We must and will stop them, just by the constant presence of our navy, preferable aircraft carrier groups in the disputed waters. I think that if we stare them down, they will blink first. They will not dare to attack an America Naval Vessel or aircraft in the disputed waters. I don't see a war with China. We need each other far too much for that to happen. Which is why they'll blink.
The Crimea was essentially in Russia's backyard. There was no way to support any operation to oppose Russian there in the Black Sea. The same would be true of Georgia.
In looking at a map, once can instantly see the difference between the two due to geography in the East and South China Seas with that of the Black Sea.
Our trade with China will keep us out of a shooting war with them. They need our economy to support theirs. If that trade drops off significantly, then the possibility of war become real.
The other thing to keep your eyes on would be for Russia to begin offering large chunks of areas of Siberia (Formerly known as "The Northern Resource Area") over to China for development. Russia has oil and many raw materials that China wants and needs. If these resources are secured by agreement, China greatly reduces it's vulnerability through Naval blockaid.
One thing that would mark the imminent initiation of hostile activities would be China's refusal to sell rare earth magnets to the US. These critical items are found in everything from your DVD player to high powered tracking and targeting radars. Our economy cannot operate without them, and China controls 95% of the worlds supply of these magnets.
Actually China is breaking international law by trying to expand their territory by producing the islands.
If China really wants put the hurt on the US they should just cash in all their US treasuries.
We have and will continue to do so.
But China claiming that these man made islands have the right to exclusion zones, and territorial waters is in direct conflict with international "Convention of the Law of the Seas". UNCLOS which China is a signatory to. They can build all the islands they want, but only natural islands have rights.
Are artificial islands mentioned in UNCLOS?
Funny thing, this has brought back a memory from my first year in university. There was a lecture on conception in P.E. class where a video was played. It showed an egg and a sperm wiggling its way towards it. Someone high up in the lecture hall shouted in a squeeky falsetto voice "Keep away!!!" It brought the house down.
That is a good summary of the situation fly.
Why would they burn down their own money tree?
I don't think so. We're more valuable to their economy as a trading partner right now.
You're right. For now they need us far too much for a shooting war. Besides losing us as a trading partner it would be bad for their economy over all. We would lose products made in China, but we could also refuse to honor the value of their Treasury Notes in any way that they hold, since they would be our enemy.
At the very least freeze them. I see no reason for us to repay a country anything, as long as they are shooting at us.
That's not what Rand Paul would do.
And we cannot leave our Navy way out there on a limb like you just described. The Navy can project power, but only when there is sufficient land and air force to back them up as needed. The Navy can throw a lot of weight, but once that weight is thrown, they are way out there on the end of a stick.
On their own. They are the rapid retaliation force, but it is a finite force also. Once in action, we have about 8 hours to get the 504th and its associated brothers in the air and on the way... and about 6 hours to get the airforce on the scene.
You understand what that means? It takes about three months to move a sufficient fighting force anywhere in the world battle ready. if you reduce the Army to nothing but ready reaction forces then it would take six months to even get a unit manned and another three to get them trained in the basics.
Under your scenario, we had better win in the first two days, or we will be fighting on our own soil... (or using nuclear weapons)
Rand would do exactly what his father would have done, culled the overseas forces to the minimum needed to fulfill commitments, using the savings to build the heck out of everything else. Ditch the projects that are soaking up so much money and move that to equipment we have that is the best now.
He would increase the manpower particularly of the army and station them here at home. He would build more ships for the navy, and replace our aging F-15 fleet with F-22's a proven design and the best fighter plane in the air right now.
The Military doesn't project economic power, that is done by a strong dollar and strong market. Strong dollar and the profit starts coming back to us as a nation.
It's not isolation Rand would do, Libertarians do not want isolation, we want non-interference non-involvement.
Libertarians always have both hands out in friendship, but slap us in the face, and take the next ten years figuring out how you fucked yourself.
That, is the way it should be and never will be with the establishment in power.
The five cornerstones of military doctrine:
We'll give you a pass on this one since like many, you've never studied war as a profession. While it is important to control the waters and airspace, true political change of those you are opposing only comes from ground forces.
The US Army and much of the Marine war making hardware is worn out after the long engagements in Afghanistan and Iraq. As such, cutting funding for upgrading and replacement of hardware for these ground forces will only degrade their capabilities further.
The "600 ship" Reagan era Navy would be a huge mistake (again), furthermore, where are you going to get the money from for the ships and personnel? Reagan and Lehman put ships to sea that didn't have ammunition in the 1980s. They brought the Iowa's back without refurbishing their main batteries which lead to the death of 47 sailors in the Iowa's #2 turret in April of 89. (FYI most of the new ships put to sea were authorized by the Carter administration.)
The Navy currently has 434 active and reserve ships on roster. We have 10 carrier battlegroups, and could use one more that would push us to around 450 ships to do what we need while maintaining the rest properly.
But again, unless you cut the beloved F-35, just where the hell are you going to get the money from without raising taxes?
We have 10 carrier battlegroups, and could use one more that would push us to around 450 ships to do what we need while maintaining the rest properly.
Just so it's not named the USS George W. Bush! How about the USS Dick Cheney!
I remember, it took nine months to reactivate the Missouri, and they were forced to redo the 16 inchers cause corrosion had set in. they had to completely dismantle every 5" gun and replace all the gaskets and rubber, two of the turbines were frozen and had to be rebuilt. That is on top of upgrading all the electrics and install modern control, communications and weapons systems.
The Iowas guns were never done although the corrosion was even worse, they ran out of money. Also, if it wasn't for a politician wanting to see an actual 16 gun fired they wouldn't have died. they claimed it was a training accident, it was actually a demonstration that didn't have to happen. (training was already over and the skipper didn't want to do it)
NEVER NEVER allow politicians the power to demand anything when it concerns firing large guns, leave it to the men who know.
Actually prime would be two more carrier groups, they could use another in the Pacific. And if as suspected the PI allows us to re-open Subic Bay, we will have the base for it. But we do need one more. And it should be named the USS America.
467 ships, (we would need another Command ship) we should be able to support that with the dumping of that flying hotdog bun...
The Iowas guns were never done although the corrosion was even worse, they ran out of money.
It was my understanding of the investigation that they also only had WWII powder packs to use on the 16 inch guns and that the powder was very unstable.
I read up on the Iowa explosion through:
"A Glimpse of Hell" and "Explosion Aboard the Iowa"
Both books are very much worth the time for those interested in the topic.
The latter gave more detailed information as to the investigation into the cause which will never be determined to a 100% certainty. The leading (real as opposed to the fabricated NIS) theory was an over-ram of the powder bags causing pre-ignition of the propellant which had been made volatile from it's age (1945 vintage) and improper storage in high heat and humidity. I was actually in the reserves at the time of the explosion. Our reserve unit was joined by a GMM2 that had gotten off the Iowa in the fall of 1988. He called in May of 1989 the cause of the explosion a full two years before Sandia National Laboratories made their report.
There were numerous other errors that had to line up for the explosion to occur which unfortunately they did.
In the Gulf War, the inconsistency of the older re-bagged propellants were cause of concern due to inaccuracy. Marine spotters were at risk of being killed by short rounds when spotting for the 16" guns.
The largest gun the Navy has right now is a 5"/127mm bore. The Marines could really use something around a 8"/203mm for shore bombardment during amphibious operations, but I don't know of anything being developed of that flavor. Monies are going to the damned F-35
Now you see there, hang around long enough and pieces start getting filled in.
I heard some idiot espousing that the breech had let go on ignition. Which kinda caused me to chuckle cause the threads on those interrupted screws is a full two inches deep and they rotate into full engagement, the breech (with the block closed) is actually stronger than the barrel at the trunnion. I KNOW this. Design test high limit pressure is 2.5 normal charge established in destructive testing in 1911 when the gun breech was originally designed.
My question became, How in the hell did they have a fire in the turret if the damned breech was closed? He couldn't answer so in front of a bunch of friends I told him he was full of HS... I knew about the old powder but my thought was that the ram limiter if set correctly wouldn't have caused an explosion, so I have always speculated that it was a misfire that wasn't handled correctly. Cause the breech HAD to be open for the turret fire to happen, once the overpressure blew out the doors and the video they released seemed to concur with that.
I didn't even begin to suspect a ramming accident. but that makes even more sense especially with a trainee gun crew...
Thank you for that bit of info.
Yeah the venerable 5"/51 originally designed in 1896. (of course in what mark 1,192 or something like that now nothing like the first one anymore) Great gun for everything except antiaircraft which of course it isn't needed for today..
Yeah I agree they made a mistake with doing away with the 8" howitzer. we still have a ton of them just rusting away in the midwest. It wouldn't take much to design a naval mount for it.
WE need some new blood at the top BAAAADDDD...
Here is a bit more then.
They know how far forward the ram was when the explosion took place, thus it would have been impossible for the breech to have been closed as the spanning tray (used in loading) was also in the loading position.
There had been issues (documented by the gun captain of the #2 turret) with the hydraulic system associated with the rammer which has four positions. Off . Forward hig h for high speed ramming of the projectile so it engages the riflings of the gun. Forward low for low speed/pressure ramming of the bag charges, and retract .
The rammer should only push the bag charges far enough into the breech to where the rear bag charge would contact the breech block. I don't recall how far they calculated that the ram was in the breech, but it was well in excess of where it should have been if they had been ramming the bag charges at the proper speed/force/distance. As the projectile was intact, the only other possibility was that the propellant had ignited.
Again they will never be able to prove what happened, but all evidence points to an over-ram of the bag charges.
The first book I pointed out dealt more with the conditions on the Iowa before, during and after the accident including the NIS fabricated story of a homosexual love affair that went bad. Important reading for sure. The second book is involved more with the forensic evidence which yields the information I just gave you an overview of.
Here is a copy of the Sandia Laboratories report
Apologies to 96 for the derail......
Again, apologies to 96 for the derail...
Here is a YouTube video of the loading sequence to further explain the loading sequence.
Sorry for getting back to this so late, but I was gone most of the day.
Thank you for that report, it clears up a lot of questions. Scientifically they can't and never will prove with specificity what happened, but they did blow apart that phony excuse the NIS gave.
For all practical purposes I think I now know. It probably was an overram combined with a provable defect in the powder bag design which occurred 45 years earlier when they were manufactured.
Thank you.
I have that video in my battleship folder, I also have the construction manuals and operation manuals for the 16"/50
Here is a better version of that video the one you links has poor sound at least on my system...
I love this kind of stuff..