╌>

A student who worked in a Chinese iPhone factory explains why manufacturing jobs aren't coming back

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  kavika  •  9 years ago  •  12 comments

A student who worked in a Chinese iPhone factory explains why manufacturing jobs aren't coming back

It's going to take a lot more than concrete and machines to manufacture iPhones in the U.S.

 


Loading...   

 


CNBC recently spoke with Dejian Zeng, a graduate student at NYU's Wagner School of Public Service, who spent last summer working undercover building iPhones at Pegatron, one of Apple's manufacturing partners.

After returning from the trip, which was organized by NYU and China's Labor Watch, Zeng said he's convinced that U.S. workers aren't going to be shuffling into factories to build iPhones any time soon.

How exactly does a student at a prestigious U.S. university end up in China, sitting quietly on a stool, inserting parts into iPhones, one by one?

© Provided by CNBC

Zeng walked CNBC through his decision to spend six weeks in a factory working 12 hours shifts Monday through Saturday, mostly during the night, and what he discovered along the way.

© Provided by CNBC

"I just showed up"


It turns out getting into an iPhone factory isn't that hard.

"They just gave me the address of the factory and I just went. I just showed up. When I was there I saw people holding luggage waiting in a long line, so I just stood in the line," Zeng told CNBC in an interview.

"When it was my turn they asked for my ID, asked to see my hand and asked me to recite the English alphabet. I got in after that. It took less than 30 seconds. You don't have to apply or have any skills."

© Provided by CNBC

Zeng told CNBC he went to the factory because China Labor Watch was expecting a strike, and it wanted boots on the ground in case a strike occurred to understand how it happened.

Zeng said China Labor Watch had done research and had noticed that, while wages weren't terrible, Pegatron's factory was cutting down the subsidies it offered workers on things like food, which ultimately meant workers were getting paid less. As he phrased it, Pegatron was using a bit of a loophole to save money while also meeting wage labor requirements. Zeng also claims he saw several violations, such as mandatory overtime, which he addressed in an open letter to Apple in March .

© Provided by CNBC

Why it can't happen here


Now that he's seen how a Chinese iPhone factory operates, Zeng doesn't believe that Apple (AAPL) or other companies will be able to build competitive factories in the U.S., no matter what politicians want them to do.

"The first thing I can think of from a labor perspective is that the wages are unacceptable for American workers. So, in the factories, I was getting paid about 3100 yuan, or $450, per month. I don't think American workers can accept those kind of wages based on living conditions and prices here," Zeng said.

"Even if they relocate factories to the U.S. they'd replace workers with robots," Zeng said. He said Pegatron already uses robots to apply cameras to iPhones, and to drop batteries into the devices. Robots, Zeng said, are more precise than human workers, and precision is particularly important for those two components.

© Provided by CNBC

The only reason human labor is still used, he believes, is because it's cheaper in some cases.

"We are using labor in China instead of a machine because labor is cheaper than maintaining machines. If you relocate factories to the States you need to think of how to manage the workers," Zeng explained.

Zeng never saw the strike he was there to monitor, but he believes that sort of strike could easily happen in the U.S. "We don't have labor unions in China. Unions are strong organizations in the States, and that could cause a lot of trouble with management."

He added that high turnover and lack of labor leadership makes strikes unlikely in China.

"The turnover rate is extremely high, people leave after 2 weeks or a month. For ordinary workers, it's very hard to have a thought that, 'hey I don't like this, we need to organize.' It needs to be middle management, a line manager, someone who holds meetings with you every day and who gives demands, and if they said during a meeting 'we need to strike tomorrow and we need to fight for wages,' I could see that. But that's not happening."

© Provided by CNBC

Even China is getting too expensive


Meanwhile, Zeng also said that factories are starting to appear in other countries where human labor costs are even cheaper than in China.

"China is developing. Prices for food and housing are increasing, so you have to increase wages accordingly. The government set minimum wages, and wages are going up, so [the] cost for labor is going up. Other places like Bangladesh, the wages are really low. They're shutting down factories in China and moving to where labor costs are lower. Factories used to be in America, then they moved to China, and now they're moving over to Vietnam and Bangladesh."

If President Trump wants iPhones manufactured in the U.S., Apple will need to front the cost to pay the much higher wages required in the U.S., which means that consumers will have to be willing to pay more. Either that, or it will have to rely a lot more on machines, which won't create jobs, and might end up taking them.

Link to article with video...http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/a-student-who-worked-in-a-chinese-iphone-factory-explains-why-manufacturing-jobs-arent-coming-back/ar-BBAyp2Q?li=BBnb7Kz&ocid=U219DHP


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     9 years ago

Cheap labor has always been the key to movement of manufacturing.

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

This is why we need government intervention and government activism in the form of a social safety net and other economic programs to benefit the disadvantaged. Capitalism REQUIRES that there be many people who will be poor , or as poor as conditions will permit, because capitalism requires that the capitalist (owner) seek the lowest possible labor cost in order to maximize profit. Capitalism is a race to the bottom for many workers. Government is needed to alleviate this otherwise unsolvable problem. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

No the safety nets also drives up the cost of doing business in this country.  Driving up the cost drives business offshore. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   9 years ago

We know you are scrooge. How did he end up?  Having nightmares about his wasted life. 

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

John,

What we have is corporatism, not capitalism, certainly not as Smith invisioned it. What we have is a system that our Founding Fathers would have loved, a system that keeps the old white guys at the top, that goes for government too, so government is not the answer. What we need is something no one wants to try.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

True the unions distorting free market wages drives manufacturing offshore. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika   replied to  Dean Moriarty   9 years ago

Dean it was quite clear in the article that the cost of labor, not unions, since China does not have unions is the motivator to moving manufacturing to cheaper labor markets.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika   replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

Cheap labor started decades ago with Japan, Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong. As the wages grew, the manufacturing moved. First to SE Asia, China and now it moving to areas like Bangladesh and Vietnam.

It is the way of the world and capitalism.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    9 years ago

"So, in the factories, I was getting paid about 3100 yuan, or $450, per month."

"China is developing. Prices for food and housing are increasing, so you have to increase wages accordingly. The government set minimum wages, and wages are going up, so [the] cost for labor is going up."

Believe it or not, that starting wage for an unskilled worker is not so bad here in China, it is a lot better than subsistence, because a person can pay all necessary living expenses with that provided they do not look for luxuries. What happens here most times is that both H and W work, and if they have children that are very young, the retired grandparents look after them. On our daily walks here we see innumerable examples of that - it is a traditional cultural custom.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika   replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

Thanks for the information. I saw much the same on  my trips to China.

 
 

Who is online