Bill To Put Ten Commandments Displays in Public Places Ignored By GOP-Led Oklahoma Senate
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/friendlyatheist/2017/04/28/bill-to-put-ten-commandments-displays-in-public-places-blocked-by-gop-led-oklahoma-senate/?utm_medium=email&utm_source=BRSS&utm_campaign=Nonreligious&utm_content=361
The Oklahoma Senate has pulled a bill that would have allowed the Ten Commandments to be posted on public property, including schools and courthouses, effectively killing legislation that had already been approved by the State House.
After a years-long battle over a Ten Commandments monument outside the Capitol building — which conservatives lost — State Rep. John Bennett proposed House Bill 2177 which would let “historically significant documents” be plastered in public spaces. But let’s be honest: no one cares about the Magna Carta. This was always about promoting Christianity through the government.
In presenting the bill… Bennett made it clear his primary interest is the Ten Commandments, saying they have “impacted American law and culture with a force similar only to that of the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.”
Bennett never explained how rules about worshiping only one specific God, rejecting false idols, keeping the Sabbath Day holy, and taking the Lord’s name in vain have anything to do with our law… but I’m not the one spinning an obvious lie.
He also ignored the fact that it’s legal (though not ethical) to commit adultery, lie, and covet. The point is: our law is not based on the Decalogue.
Bennett was so aware that what he was doing was wrong that the bill included a passage authorizing the Attorney General to defend it using taxpayer money. You know, just in case they got sued.
Bills that don’t break the law don’t need that provision.
Would Islamic or Satanic displays be included in the mix? Not at all, said another Republican legislator:
Rep. Kevin Calvey, R-Edmond, said it is unlikely the law could be used to erect a monument to “Satanism” because “I don’t think our country was founded on Satanism.”
Similarly, Calvey said, the Koran need not be included because, he said, Islam did not play a significant role in the founding of America.
That’s convenient, isn’t it?
(For what it’s worth, The Satanic Temple’s Seven Fundamental Tenets have more overlap with the Constitution than just about everything in the Ten Commandments.)
All of that took place in March, and I was certain the bill would skate through the Senate. It’s not like the GOP cares about respecting the Constitution when cheap promotion of Christianity is on the line.
But check out what happened yesterday:
A bill that could have allowed the Ten Commandments on government property was quietly pulled from consideration Thursday, severely hurting its chances to become law.
House Bill 2177 was on the Senate agenda, but Floor Leader Greg Treat, R-Oklahoma City, announced that it wouldn’t be heard before moving on to other business. House bills must be heard in the Senate by the end of business Thursday.
That’s it. It’s gone. No explanation offered. Maybe Treat was hoping no one would notice so that House Republicans could still get credit for trying to push their religious views on everyone else while avoiding the backlash when the state inevitably got sued.
In any case, this latest attempt to push the Ten Commandments onto the public has failed. It won’t be the last time conservatives try something like this, but take solace in the fact that they either recognized the folly of passing this bill or couldn’t do it despite overwhelming GOP majorities in the Capitol.
The Oklahoma Senate has pulled a bill that would have allowed the Ten Commandments to be posted on public property, including schools and courthouses, effectively killing legislation that had already been approved by the State House.
After a years-long battle over a Ten Commandments monument outside the Capitol building — which conservatives lost — State Rep. John Bennett proposed House Bill 2177 which would let “historically significant documents” be plastered in public spaces. But let’s be honest: no one cares about the Magna Carta. This was always about promoting Christianity through the government.
In presenting the bill… Bennett made it clear his primary interest is the Ten Commandments, saying they have “impacted American law and culture with a force similar only to that of the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.”
Bennett never explained how rules about worshiping only one specific God, rejecting false idols, keeping the Sabbath Day holy, and taking the Lord’s name in vain have anything to do with our law… but I’m not the one spinning an obvious lie.
He also ignored the fact that it’s legal (though not ethical) to commit adultery, lie, and covet. The point is: our law is not based on the Decalogue.
Bennett was so aware that what he was doing was wrong that the bill included a passage authorizing the Attorney General to defend it using taxpayer money. You know, just in case they got sued.
Bills that don’t break the law don’t need that provision.
Would Islamic or Satanic displays be included in the mix? Not at all, said another Republican legislator:
Rep. Kevin Calvey, R-Edmond, said it is unlikely the law could be used to erect a monument to “Satanism” because “I don’t think our country was founded on Satanism.”
Similarly, Calvey said, the Koran need not be included because, he said, Islam did not play a significant role in the founding of America.
That’s convenient, isn’t it?
(For what it’s worth, The Satanic Temple’s Seven Fundamental Tenets have more overlap with the Constitution than just about everything in the Ten Commandments.)
All of that took place in March, and I was certain the bill would skate through the Senate. It’s not like the GOP cares about respecting the Constitution when cheap promotion of Christianity is on the line.
But check out what happened yesterday:
A bill that could have allowed the Ten Commandments on government property was quietly pulled from consideration Thursday, severely hurting its chances to become law.
House Bill 2177 was on the Senate agenda, but Floor Leader Greg Treat, R-Oklahoma City, announced that it wouldn’t be heard before moving on to other business. House bills must be heard in the Senate by the end of business Thursday.
That’s it. It’s gone. No explanation offered. Maybe Treat was hoping no one would notice so that House Republicans could still get credit for trying to push their religious views on everyone else while avoiding the backlash when the state inevitably got sued.
In any case, this latest attempt to push the Ten Commandments onto the public has failed. It won’t be the last time conservatives try something like this, but take solace in the fact that they either recognized the folly of passing this bill or couldn’t do it despite overwhelming GOP majorities in the Capitol.
Tags
Who is online
116 visitors

"Maybe Treat was hoping no one would notice so that House Republicans could still get credit for trying to push their religious views on everyone else while avoiding the backlash when the state inevitably got sued."
Sounds like what the US House and Senate are doing with healthcare. Bad cop good cop.
American law is NOT based on the Ten Commandments! They have NO place on Public Property as they are religious statements belonging to only ONE religion and by displaying them they indicate that the American government favors the Christian religion over all other religions and thereby establishes the Christian religion as the Official religion of the United States of America which is Unconstitutional!
It's funny how these monuments attract Satanists.
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/friendlyatheist/2017/04/30/a-mn-town-wanted-a-christian-war-memorial-now-theyll-also-have-a-satanic-one/?utm_medium=email&utm_source=BRSS&utm_campaign=Nonreligious&utm_content=361
"American law is NOT based on the Ten Commandments! They have NO place on Public Property as they are religious statements belonging to only ONE religion and by displaying them they indicate that the American government favors the Christian religion over all other religions and thereby establishes the Christian religion as the Official religion of the United States of America which is Unconstitutional!."
"they are religious statements belonging to only ONE religion"
Hey Randy, are you sure Moses was a Christian?
That statement makes no sense.
Then I will try to explain it to you. YOUR statement was that the 10 Commandments belong to only ONE religion, and then you go on to indicate that they represent Christianity (making it pretty clear that you feel that the 10 Commandments represent only the Christian religion. However, surely you are also aware that the 10 Commandments were given toi Moses by God (as so well displayed in the movie The Ten Commandments, if not in the Old Testament). It was my understanding, and correct me if I am wrong, but I thought Moses was a Jew, not a Christian, and since the 10 Commandments were presented to him to give to the Jews who were escaping enslavement in Egypt, I think it was quite a while before Jesus was born. Therefore, by deductive reasoning I came to the conclusion that Christianity is not the ONLY religion that has anything to do with the 10 Commandments.
Farshtaist?
I understand. However you must understand that here in America the Ten Commandments have been COMPLETELY stolen by the Christian far right and the Born Again types. When someone in the United States talks about someone insisting on the Ten Commandments being placed in a public building or in a courthouse or Public Square or Park, it is NEVER a Jewish action. It is ALWAYS a right wing Christian action. It is ALWAYS a right wing CHRISTIAN church of some type behind it. I certainly meant no offense. I was simply reacting to local actions.
I accept what you are saying. (Where have I heard that before.)
There's a lot of that going around.
LOL
Correct me if I'm wrong but the the legal jurisprudence that is US law, is entirely based on "English Common Law" which in itself is derived from principles based on the ten commandments?
If secular law were derived from the Ten Commandments, it would be legal to diddle children but illegal to be jealous of your neighbor's donkey.
Am I wrong? I don't think so. If you follow "English Common Law" to its roots, you will find the ten commandments in its rudimentary form. However, images and statuary depicting the 10 commandments are also considered religious icons and as such, should not be displayed in public buildings.