╌>

Infant Sentenced To Death By European Human Rights Court

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  9 years ago  •  28 comments

Infant Sentenced To Death By European Human Rights Court
Ten-month-old Charlie Gard was sentenced to die by the European Court of Human Rights (EHCR), Tuesday, who ruled against potentially life-saving treatment for him.

The ECHR ordered that Gard’s life support be shut off and blocked him from travel to the U.S. for experimental treatment for which Gard’s parents raised over $1.7 million. Doctors diagnosed the infant boy with a rare mitochondrial disease, according to a report from Daily Mail. The court labeled the Gard’s appeal case “inadmissible” and upheld the previous decision of the U.K. High Court, saying their decision in Gard’s case was “final.”

“Subjecting him to nucleoside therapy is unknown territory — it has never even been tested on mouse models — but it may, or may not, subject the patient to pain, possibly even to mutations,” wrote Justice Francis in the High Court’s judgement. “But if Charlie’s damaged brain function cannot be improved, as all seem to agree, then how can he be any better off than he is now, which is in a condition that his parents believe should not be sustained?”

Francis then concluded that the hospital “may lawfully withdraw all treatment, save for palliative care, to permit Charlie to die with dignity.” Gard was born with encephalomyopathic mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome (MDDS), which causes gradual muscle weakening and brain damage. Doctors at Ormond counseled Gard’s parents, Chris Gard and Connie Yates, to remove Gard’s ventilator in March and said it would be best for Gard to “die with dignity.” Gard’s parents refused on the grounds that they wanted to take Gard to the U.S. for a treatment known as nucleoside, which a doctor from the U.S. said he would be willing to perform.

Pursuant to U.K. law, the hospital appealed to the U.K. High Court, who ruled in favor of the the hospital and blocked travel to the U.S. for Gard and his parents. An appeals court and the London Supreme Court struck down appeals from Gard’s parents, who then turned to the ECHR, but the court did not intervene on their behalf.

Dr. Brian Callister of Nevada, who has spoken out against assisted suicide and euthanasia, said the court’s decision was contemptible.

“To withdraw life support against somebody’s will when they have hope of a treatment that either could extend their life or, who knows how long it could extend it, who knows what kind of quality of life may or may not be available — to take away that hope and say ‘you’re life is worth nothing’ I think is wrong on every level,” Callister told The Daily Caller News Foundation. “It’s wrong on a human level. It’s wrong on any basic level of medical ethics, and there are medical ethicists out there in Europe and the United States who think that’s just fine. I think they’ve got a screw loose.” The courts cited reports from expert counsel, which said that Gard was likely in pain and was suffering. However, Callister said that while it was possible that Gard was in pain, pain and suffering are subjective terms and typically are not the reasons that people legally end their lives, according to data from the state of Oregon.

“Pain is not even in the top five — doesn’t even make the top five of reasons listed in Oregon of people that commit assisted suicide,” Callister said. “It doesn’t make the top five. Burden to family, loss of autonomy —those are the top reasons people kill themselves legally.”

Callister was careful to differentiate between euthanasia and ending life support, which he said were two different matters. While euthanasia constitutes actively killing a person, ending the artificial prolonging of life via machines when a patient no longer wants to live via machine is simply “letting nature take its course” and is not morally reprehensible in Callister’s eyes. In Gard’s case, however, Callister said it was wrong of the court to deny his family the opportunity to seek treatment, whether or not it would have prolonged or saved Gard’s life, and the ruling could have “indirectly contributed to his death.”

Given the ECHR’s geographical range of jurisdiction, Callister also said he was suspicious of their stance on human rights, citing euthanasia practices in Belgium and the Netherlands.

“Keep in mind those are places where it’s legal to euthanize people now,” Callister said. “So, I’m going to be real suspect of any group that talks about human rights in places where euthanasia is legal, and I’m not talking about assisted suicide. I’m talking about actively killing people — often involuntarily or without their knowledge.”

The ECHR has made questionable calls concerning human rights in the past, such as when the court pressured Ireland to legalize abortion, saying that Ireland’s ban on abortion violated human rights and put mothers at risk of harm and death. Ireland, however, had one of the lowest maternal mortality rates in Europe at the time and still does.

Gard’s parents were heartbroken over the ECHR’s decision, and though they cannot use the money they raised to save their son, they said they will donate the money for treatment of other children suffering from the same mitochondrial disease. Gard will be taken off life support Friday.

“I look at this postmodern world, when it comes to medical ethics, as a world in decay,” Callister said. http://dailycaller.com/2017/06/29/infant-sentenced-to-death-by-european-human-rights-court/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    9 years ago

Sad to see governments controlling who lives or dies.    Why not allow these folks to take their child and seek possibly, very possibly life saving treatment, if it doesn't work, he's really no worse off than he was before.

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave    9 years ago

What is, also, tearing the parents to pieces is that they can't even take their own baby home.  Horrible!

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    9 years ago

I find this a little bizarre

Dr. Brian Callister of Nevada, who has spoken out against assisted suicide and euthanasia, said the court’s decision was contemptible.

“To withdraw life support against somebody’s will when they have hope of a treatment that either could extend their life or, who knows how long it could extend it, who knows what kind of quality of life may or may not be available — to take away that hope and say ‘you’re life is worth nothing’ I think is wrong on every level,” Callister told The Daily Caller News Foundation. “It’s wrong on a human level. It’s wrong on any basic level of medical ethics, and there are medical ethicists out there in Europe and the United States who think that’s just fine. I think they’ve got a screw loose.” The courts cited reports from expert counsel, which said that Gard was likely in pain and was suffering. However, Callister said that while it was possible that Gard was in pain, pain and suffering are subjective terms and typically are not the reasons that people legally end their lives, according to data from the state of Oregon.

“Pain is not even in the top five — doesn’t even make the top five of reasons listed in Oregon of people that commit assisted suicide,” Callister said. “It doesn’t make the top five. Burden to family, loss of autonomy —those are the top reasons people kill themselves legally.”

 

People who commit suicide are generally at an age where they can speak for themselves and describe their pain to someone else. A ten month old can hardly do that. 

It's a hard decision for anyone to make to take an action that will put the child in mortal danger. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    9 years ago

Barrister Victoria Butler-Cole , who was instructed by a guardian appointed by the judge to independently represent Charlie’s interests, also said doctors should stop providing life-support treatment.

She said the treatment proposed in America is not ‘pioneering or life-sustaining’ but a ‘purely experimental’ process which has ‘no real prospect of improving Charlie’s condition or quality of life’.

She said continuing life-support treatment will not benefit Charlie but only ‘prolong the process of dying’.

She suggested that the treatment would be ‘futile’ and said the idea that it will help is ‘not so much a chance as a wish’.

Barrister Sophia Roper , representing Charlie’s parents, said the baby should be given a chance to improve.

She said he will not suffer significant harm if he undergoes treatment in America.

She said his parents think there is a chance that their child will improve.

She said his parents’ wishes should carry ‘great weight’.

 

 

What is mitochondrial depletion syndrome?

 

Charlie Gard was born with mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome.

 

The baby is said to be one of only 16 people to be diagnosed with it in the world.

 

Mitochondria are responsible for creating more than 90% of the energy needed by the body to sustain life and support organ function

 

The heart, brain, muscles and lungs rely on this the most.

 

But the disease affects each individual differently.

 

Symptoms include seizures, strokes, severe developmental delays, inability to walk, talk, see, and digest food.

 

In Charlie’s case, he is unable to get energy to his muscles, kidney and brain.

 

It is typically fatal in infancy and early childhood, and there is no known cure.

 

But parents, Connie and Chris, were hoping to try a treatment called nucleoside bypass therapy to help reduce the affects.



Read more: 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

It sounds like the proposed US treatment would not be a cure, but an 'experiment'. 

 

The case followed British law. If the people in Britain don't approve of this sort of thing, they can change the law. 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Without experiments, there may never be a cure. The child was going to die. It could have been the only beneficial thing that the child and his parents could have provided to mankind, was to submit him to be used for the possibility of developing or discovering a cure for this horrid condition.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

Had the parents not raised a million dollars over the internet I doubt we would have heard too much about this case outside of England. 

It is a hard thing , but there doesn't seem to be any medical experts who said the child had a viable future. 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

How many years, how many centuries, how many experiments did it take for a Sabine and a Salk to find a method to prevent polio? America is even negative about stem cell research, despite the pleas by Superman.

 
 

Who is online




107 visitors