Two more Republican senators oppose health bill, killing measure for now
WASHINGTON (AP) — The latest GOP effort to repeal and replace "Obamacare" was fatally wounded in the Senate Monday night when two more Republican senators announced their opposition to legislation strongly backed by President Donald Trump.
The announcements from Sens. Mike Lee of Utah and Jerry Moran of Kansas left the Republican Party's long-promised effort to get rid of President Barack Obama's health care legislation reeling. Next steps, if any, were not immediately clear.
Lee and Moran both said they could not support Majority Leader Mitch McConnell's legislation in its current form. They joined GOP Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and Rand Paul of Kentucky, both of whom announced their opposition right after McConnell released the bill last Thursday.
McConnell is now at least two votes short in the closely divided Senate and may have to go back to the drawing board or even begin to negotiate with Democrats, a prospect he's threatened but resisted so far.
McConnell's bill "fails to repeal the Affordable Care Act or address healthcare's rising costs. For the same reasons I could not support the previous version of this bill, I cannot support this one," said Moran.
It was the second straight failure for McConnell, who had to cancel a vote on an earlier version of the bill last month when defeat became inevitable.
Trump had kept his distance from the Senate process, but Monday night's development was a major blow for him, too, as the president failed to rally support for what has been the GOP's trademark issue for seven years — ever since Obama and the Democrats passed the Affordable Care Act in the first place.
The Senate bill eliminated mandates and taxes under Obamacare, and unraveled a Medicaid expansion. But for conservatives like Lee and Paul it didn't go far enough in delivering on Republican Party promises to undo Obama's law, while moderates like Collins viewed the bill as too extreme in yanking insurance coverage from millions.
Tags
Who is online
96 visitors

I'll bet that more GOP Senators come out against it as well...Portman and Heller will be in that number.
I sure hope so after finding out it keeps many of the taxes in place. They need to stand with Rand and go for the full repeal.
Damn those lazy bum republicans that live off your taxes Dean.
You got that right.
Your going to have to keep paying those taxes Dean. Good on you for caring about your fellow man.
I'm proud of you.
You know I have no problem at all with paying taxes as they re necessary to run a human and humane civilized (read non-Right Wing Republican or Libertarian) society. I just want more control over not spending them on somethings, like wasted tax cuts for the already rich and much more expensive weapons platforms, like the new aircraft carriers, that we don't need.
That money would be better spent making sure that America is a healthy, well housed and well fed nation, which makes us much, much stronger.
I'll bet that more GOP Senators come out against it as well
They will. They just needed someone to break the dam open. Now Trump is saying just repeal Obamacare completely and do nothing else. Of course that will have even less of a chance then this, but they do have to sound tough for Trump's base.
Brian Sandoval, governor of NV (GOP) was really against it. They (Pence and others) went to the governors convention and Sandoval told Pence no and he didn't believe Pence's numbers.
Heller the GOP congressman from NV has been against it from the start
Sooner or later they are just going to have to come to the realization that they are not going to repeal the ACA. Now as far as I am concerned they can just rename it Trumpcare and lie that it was all of their idea in the first place and then fix the problems with it.
Now as far as I am concerned they can just rename it Trumpcare and lie that it was all of their idea in the first place and then fix the problems with it.
None of that is going to happen Randy. They will not rename it and take ownership of it, nor will they even try to fix anything about it. They will simply sit back and let it collapse. When asked why they didn't replace it with something else, their reply will be, "We tried but the Democrats and RINOs wouldn't let it happen." The RINOs will then be primaried in the next election and will have to go back to chasing ambulances for a living. After the collapse, the foolish idea that there is some sort of right to have other people forced to buy your health care for you will be completely discredited. While you should have the right to have access to health care and health care insurance, you do not have the right to force others to pay for it for you.
In the same vein, while I have the right to buy as many firearms as I want, I do not have the right to have the government pay for them using other people's money. Not being mentioned in the Constitution, health care isn't even in the same league with firearms.
You know I have no problem at all with paying taxes as they re necessary to run a human and humane civilized (read non-Right Wing Republican or Libertarian) society.
Dream world! No human society has ever been run that way, nor will any be until humans evolve into something other than wild animals, which would require major changes in our DNA; changes which would take millions of years and would be counterproductive anyway. Such changes would make it impossible for humans to defend ourselves and would probably cause species extinction. All the Leftists really want is to throw the scoundrels out and replace them with their own scoundrels. The system wouldn't change, just the names of the rulers.
And yes, that's cynical as hell; cynicism with a very good reason, because it's based on the actual facts of humanity's fang and claw existence throughout our, somewhat bloodstained, history. That's the basic problem with Socialism, it assumes that all men are brothers, and they're not.
The Republicans now own all health care. Completely. They have ever since they have tried to repeal and replace it. Even the ACA. They own it too now 100%. If they let it collapse (and only them sabotaging it or neglecting it) millions will lose their health care and they will blame the Party in power. The Party that owns the House, the Senate and the White House. If the ACA is allowed to collapse, the voters will take it out on Republicans, not the Democrats. After all, we are helpless and they control everything, including the ACA.
No human society has ever been run that way, nor will any be until humans evolve into something other than wild animals, which would require major changes in our DNA; changes which would take millions of years and would be counterproductive anyway. Such changes would make it impossible for humans to defend ourselves and would probably cause species extinction. All the Leftists really want is to throw the scoundrels out and replace them with their own scoundrels. The system wouldn't change, just the names of the rulers.
With just a very, very, very few tweaks, we can easily have a human and humane government, It's right there. All we have to do it take it. It really is that simple.
With just a very, very, very few tweaks, we can easily have a human and humane government, It's right there. All we have to do it take it. It really is that simple.
Nope, what would happen is that your own thugs would then take over and run things to suit themselves, regardless of what everyone else in the country wants. There is nothing sacred, or even good or bad, about government. It is simply a machine for applying force. What force is used and for what purpose is at the discretion of the rulers and the rulers on one side are just as corrupt and inept as those on the other. Therefore, government will continue to be corrupt and inept. Even a ruler who starts out as non corrupt, will become so once he/she becomes aware of the personal possibilities for wealth and power. The desire to increase wealth and power as far as circumstances permit cannot be stopped or even modified. It is an outgrowth of the instincts for survival and reproduction (which is, in itself, a form of personal genetic survival beyond death). As such, the aggression and acquisitiveness inherent in the instinct for survival can't be changed without changing the human pattern to eliminate the instinct for survival. Once that is gone, the product will no longer be human, and a society formed of such creatures couldn't survive for long. Humane government is a contradiction in terms since humanity can never be achieved through the use of force. All you can get through the use of force (government) is repression.
Man are you reading waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much into what I am saying about having a more human and humane nation. I am thinking about things like changing our health care to single payer. I am not talking about some sort of Socialist revolution.
Can I have a hit of whatever you're smoking? Please?
TTGA by your view you only want to pick and choose what your taxes pay for.
What about, I don't want to pay for the waste in the DOD. Better yet why should my taxes pay for the care given vets under the VA? How about my taxes paying for the retirement of LEO's...Why should I be paying for them?
Let's just quit paying taxes and let everyone survive on their own.
IMHO with what we spent on the US Gerald Ford we could have helped a lot more Vets then what we'll get in return for the use of the carrier. The old L.A. Veterans hospital is sitting on large piece of land that developers are screaming for the VA to sell so they can build a shopping center and a huge condo development, but a lot of Vets are organizing to try to get the old buildings retro-fitted for earthquakes, brought up to code and used as housing for homeless Vets, plus a center for PTSD Vets. I'd rather see that then another carrier that we don't need. It could house a couple of hundred homeless Vets and still provide services too, plus it's right across the street from the newer VA Hospital.
Better yet why should my taxes pay for the care given vets under the VA? How about my taxes paying for the retirement of LEO's...Why should I be paying for them?
Those people performed a service, sometimes a pretty dangerous service, with benefits specified in their contract. Likewise, those on Medicare paid into the system for contracted services for many years, even though the payment was involuntary. In short, they EARNED it. Some time back a very wise football coach told me, "In this world, you don't get what you deserve, you get what you earn." I can add that sometimes you don't even get that.
What have those adults on Medicaid earned? I have no problem with children being on Medicaid, they are helpless and are not responsible for the failures of their parents.
''with benefits specified in their contract'' why should their contacts be a concern of mine.
What makes you think that the parents of children on medicaid are failures. Because they get help with health insurance? How do you know that these failures aren't working a job or perhaps two jobs. Everyone on medicaid is a failure, do you have proof of that since most stats show that it's the working poor that are on medicaid.
why should their contacts be a concern of mine.
If you don't wish to be concerned with them, don't ask those people to join the military or the police department to protect you. If you want their protection, you pay for that service.
Everyone on medicaid is a failure, do you have proof of that since most stats show that it's the working poor that are on medicaid.
Training for better jobs, to remove a person from the ranks of the working poor, at little or no cost, is available through the Unemployment Insurance Departments in all 50 States. It's not difficult to qualify for it, and the State pays the cost, all you have to do is study for it. If they're not willing to even do that, they're failures. Are they willing but can't get into the programs? I've known many of the people running the program here for a lot of years. They tell me that they have far more unfilled spaces than people willing to fill them. I know those people because they used to send students to my high school completion classes. Out of hundreds of "students", I can remember no more than four who made any effort at all to learn anything. The vast majority were there (when they showed up at all) because if they didn't come, they lost their benefits.
''If you don't wish to be concerned with them, don't ask those people to join the military or the police department to protect you. If you want their protection, you pay for that service.''
I don't ask anyone to join the military nor the police department. That is their choice, not yours nor mine. Further more I think that you missed my point entirely. I wasn't advocating that their health care benefits be taken, what I was pointing out why do some have their health care covered by my taxes when others do not. Is it because of a job or position? To me that simply isn't what America is about.
It's rural America that is going to be hurt under Trumpcare. The same people that voted for Trump are the ones that are going to suffer. They are farmers, ranchers, store clerks, people that work hard and need the coverage that the ACA provides them. There are the special needs people that through no fault of their own cannot survive without it. The hospitals in rural America are going to be devastated by it.
A perfect case study is Kansas with a Tea Party governor that has taken a state that was well off and has driven it into the ground with his policies. The state is now a basket case of financial blunders because he felt the same way you feel. Brownback has had his own party turn against him and they have finally, though cooperation with the democrats changed the tax giveaways that he got signed into law and have overridden his veto's. Brownback is one of the governor's that wouldn't expand medicaid which really added to the woes of the citizens of Kansas.
You'll note that one of the republican senators that voted against the new Senate health care plan was the republican senator from Kansas. You think that he may have seen the damage it could cause.
As far as the rest of your argument about training. I to have first hand experience with it. Both in a urban setting and a rural setting.
I recently had a new roof put on my house in Missouri. I talked to the roofers, all hard working guys that did a great job and finished the roof in 2 1/2 days. Each of them works as an independent contractor for a roofing company. The only reason that they have health coverage is because of ACA. What do you tell these people? When you finish your 10/11 hour day, drive to Springfield (50 miles away) and attend a class to get a better job.
When a country as wealthy as the U.S. is, can't help those that need it, it has become a very sad day in America...
Yet we can piss away billion and billions of dollars in many of the federal agencies (DOD) and keep giving them more tax dollars year after year. Yet we can't help those that need it. To me that is a very fucked up position to take.
No it won't they united to send a repeal to Obama and he vetoed it. That's why many of them won reelection. If they don't repeal we are going to repeal them and replace with stronger tea party candidates next primaries.
If they don't repeal we are going to repeal them and replace with stronger tea party candidates next primaries.
First of all Dean, I thought you were a libertarian and not a tea partier.
Second, why do you think they backed out at the 11th hour? It's because they don't think they will be elected if they repeal.
I am and I'm also right leaning and see many common traits between libertarians like myself and tea party people. They are not done yet some backed out like Rand Paul because it wasn't a full repeal.
I think libertarians are as varied as independents are. So what are you really libertarian about?
For me personally this sums up my beliefs. I'm lucky to have a party that represents my views.
Dean,
All that says is that people are free to chose, which I could have told you is what a libertarian is. But it doesn't say what your beliefs are. How are you on the issues?
I thought it does a good job of describing where I stand on the issues. It covers abortion, taxes, defense, healthcare, subsidies, self defense, and the death penalty.
I didn't mirror my beliefs based on their platform. I just got lucky that their platform jives with my personal beliefs.
Dean,
I don't think you get what I am asking you.
So I am picking one.
Recognizing that abortion is a sensitive issue and that people can hold good-faith views on all sides, we believe that government should be kept out of the matter, leaving the question to each person for their conscientious consideration.
What are your personal belief on abortion beyond the fact that government shouldn't be involved?
I would not consider it for myself for a healthy fetus. In the case you described the other day regarding a family member that regrets saving a severely handicapped child with no quality of life and suffers in pain. I agree abortion would have been the better choice.
Thank you for your candor, Dean and well thought out answer. I am very touched you remembered that anecdote.
There goes McCain.....the flood has started...
McConnell just said the Senate will instead repeal the ACA by trying to pass the House Bill, with a 2 year delay, to give them a chance to come up with a replacement. I doubt it'll stand a just in hell of passing. It is not going to happen.
McConnell knows they all got elected by promising to repeal. They are not trying to win the leftists votes. Just as House majority leader Eric Cantor got the boot by tea party man Dave Brat in 2014 they will face the same it they do not repeal. The heat is on and they are starting to sweat.
However McConnell and yourself, will have to face the truth that the vast majority of those who chanted "Repeal and Replace" have changed their mind, which is why the idea has about a 12% approval rating. So they have to make a choice, "Repeal and Replace" with a horrible, inhuman, godawful bill that will get them voted office if they do. Or accept the truth that the very people who were screaming that at all of the rallies are fickle and do not want that any longer. Only a very, very slim number on the far right still want it to happen and they are not even close to big enough numbers to save the job or any Congress member or Senator in anything close to a purple District or State. If the GOP does "Repeal and Replace" they will hand the House to the Democrats with no problem at all in 2018 and likely continue to lose seats in the Senate.
Oh and being Primaried from the right is the last they should worry about because even if they are, the right winger will lose to the Democrat who wants comprehensive health care reform. Not Repeal and Replace any longer. The American people don't want it any longer. It is an idea that is dead. Repeal and Replace is a dead horse now, no matter how hard you beat it.
Obamacare only has a 46.8 approval rating and has been trending downward lately. I hope the trend continues.
The replacement has 12% approval and gets worse every time they try to take more people's Medicaid and health insurance away. There is an old political maxim that says that once you start a government program you can shoot it, stab it with a knife and beat it with a stick, but you can never, ever kill it. People will not give up Obamacare because the ones that have it want to keep it and instead of "Repeal and Replace" they will threaten their Representatives and Senators to fix it, not get rid of it.
It has become clear over time that health insurance and health care will have to be addressed through bipartisan agreement. Otherwise it will simply be a political football every two years when the House and a third of the Senate is up for election and sometimes the president. Whatever is decided on a partisan basis could be overturned in the next election.
Because they were not in power to change anything and they knew it. Now they have the House, the Senate and the White House and have decided to tackle healthcare. Whatever comes out of it if it is unpopular they will pay for it at the poll in 2018. Once they decided o take on Health Care, they bought it completely, unless they decide to work with the Democrats to fix the ACA.If they don't and the ACA fail, they will not blame the people who started it, they will blame the people who took their healthcare away. The Republicans. Voters always blame the Party that has complete control when they do not make them happy. They can't blame the Democrats, because we do not have the power to save their healthcare, while the GOP has the power to take it away.
It's pretty much impossible to repeal government hand outs. It's a lesson as old as Rome and was pointed out by many commentators when Obamacare was passed. It's too easy to scare people and no one wants to start paying for things they can get others to pay for.
Actually Sean so called give a ways can and have been taken back.
Look at Kansas and the Tea Party governor Brownback. His give a way on taxes turned the state into a financial disaster. Finally his own party joined forces with the democrats to stop the madness. They even went so far as to gather a coalition to override Brownbacks veto.
See it can be done, although I doubt that the working poor/seniors/rural citizens and hospitals would consider it to be free, more of a case of survival.