Hypothetically speaking, US admiral says ready for nuclear strike on China if Trump ordered one
Hypothetically speaking, US admiral says ready for nuclear strike on China if Trump ordered one
Reuters, July 27 2017
Commander of the US Pacific Fleet Adm. Scott Swift in front of a large poster of an Australian navy ship. Thomson Reuters
MELBOURNE (Reuters) - The U.S. Pacific Fleet commander, addressing a security conference in Australia, said in answer to a question on Thursday that he would be prepared to launch a nuclear strike on China if President Donald Trump so ordered.
The fleet spokesman later said the question was asked as an "outrageous hypothetical."
Admiral Scott Swift was speaking at the Australian National University in Canberra when he was asked whether he would be prepared to launch a nuclear attack on China if ordered to do so by Trump.
"The answer would be yes," he said.
Swift said that all members of the U.S. military had sworn an oath to obey officers and the U.S. president as commander in chief to defend the constitution.
"This is core to the American democracy," he said, in a recording of the event obtained by Reuters.
"Any time you have a military that is moving away from a focus, and an allegiance, to civilian control, then we really have significant problems."
Swift's answer reaffirmed the principle of civilian control over the military and was based on an "outrageous hypothetical" in the question, Pacific Fleet spokesman Captain Charlie Brown told Reuters.
"Frankly, the premise of the question was ridiculous," he said. "It was posed as an outrageous hypothetical, but the admiral simply took it as an opportunity to say the fact is that we have civilian control of the military and we abide by that principle."
The United States and China enjoy a generally friendly relationship, with strong economic ties, albeit with frequent barbs about trade, jobs, currencies, human rights, Tibet, the South China Sea and North Korea.
Trump has held high hopes for greater cooperation from China to exert influence over North Korea, leaning heavily on Chinese President Xi Jinping for his assistance. The two leaders had a high-profile summit in Florida in April and Trump has frequently praised Xi.
(Reporting by Colin Packham in SYDNEY and Melanie Burton in MELBOURNE; editing by Nick Macfie)
Tags
Who is online
88 visitors

If EVER I have seen an example of NEGLIGENT IGNORANCE, this takes the cake. If the "hypothetical" were to have named North Korea, or even Iran, rather than China, it would have been a little more tolerable. If the Admiral would have softened his answer by even first saying that that question is so entirely hypothetical because there is absolutely no intention whatsoever to threaten China, a country with which we have friendly relations, with such a thing..., then PERHAPS the Chinese government might discount it. However, I think that after living in China for 11 years I have a bit of a feeling about how they would interpret such a statement, and they would look at it as a kind of understated threat. I think it was the stupidest question and answer that ANYONE could have asked and answered. I know that the Chinese government will react to it in a manner that will NOT be for the benefit of the USA. In fact it makes me think of a comment that Queen Elizabeth II is known to have greatly understated: "We are not pleased."
Enough people in America, and around the world, are of the opinion that Trump is irrational, inexperienced, even crazy, so why WOULDN'T China be concerned with such a statement?
Buzz,
The way the U.S. Military works is, we obey the orders of those appointed over us. The top of that chain, the Commander in Chief or CINC is the President. And if he says go bomb the Maldives, we go bomb the Maldives. That's how it works. Much as, if ordered by their Premier in China, the Chinese military would bomb who they were told to bomb. Actually, disobeying orders in the Chinese military would probably be treated a bit more severely than in the U.S. especially for officers.
The bottom line? What a stupid question. What professional member of the press decides to ask such a provocative question? Very simply put, this idiot was asking, would you obey the orders given to you? Every member of the military would answer yes to that question or they would be separated/dismissed from their job.
As to China not being 'pleased', I doubt those in charge even care about this as if asked to one of their military leaders a similar scenario, the answer would be yes. They may make a public statement for face value, but it would be nothing more than that.
I think that what you and MANY others are forgetting (or just don't know) is that certain criteria has to be met before the consideration for a nuclear launch. The President cannot just order it out of the blue. This officer's statement that he would launch a nuclear weapon means that the criteria has been met, the decision has been made after a lot of careful strategic and tactical planning and all involved are accepting responsibility.
And I'm pretty sure that IF that decision is met, there will be more than just the US and China involved.
The whole premise of how this was reported is nothing than an attempt to make our military leaders and the President look inept.
"...the decision has been made after a lot of careful strategic and tactical planning and all involved are accepting responsibility."
Thank God for that.
Dear Friend Buzz: Beyond belief!
E.
As to the friendly relations, China has consistently been one of the most active countries in attempting to hack our military systems and other government systems. And that's been going on at least the last decade. How does that sound for friendly?
Every technically advanced country does it, and America was probably first - after all, America has NEVER interfered with another country, right?
Though I have never seen proof of America hacking others, I have seen detailed proof of the Chinese doing it to the United States (It's what I do for a living, so I do see this stuff). They were responsible for the data breach of how many hundred thousand federal employees? And yes, I am one of those, BTW.