It is not just conservatives who recoil at these choices, but Americans of all political stripes. Of course, politicians pushing a single-payer system will promise a utopia, but after the “if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor” con, no one is likely to believe the duplicity. But with the Republicans’ failure to repeal and replace Obamacare, the high taxes and rationing of socialized medicine may seem a veritable paradise compared to the shambles that will remain of our health care system once the death spiral concludes its destructive path.
Socializing Medicine Through Single-Payer Will Lead To Rationing And Bankruptcy
With the Senate’s failure to pass legislation to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act, the future of Obamacare and, more broadly, the crumbling American health care system remain uncertain. While the president has threatened to end cost-sharing payments to insurance companies to force Congress to act, even though the law requires him to do so regardless, moderates of both parties are instead floating measures to bail out insurance markets.
Also gaining voice are proposals from the Left for a single-payer system, or an entirely government-controlled health-care system. Claims that a single-payer system presented a better option emerged even before Republican efforts to repeal and replace proved futile. At the time, The Daily Wire highlighted five Democrats who admited they want a single-payer system. And in the closing hours of debate, the Senate rejected a single-payer amendment to the now-obsolete Republican plan, but only four Democrats (and one Independent) crossed the aisle to record their opposition to the proposal. Sen. Bernie Sanders and 42 democrats instead voted “present,” with Sanders later encouraging Republicans to work toward entirely socialized medicine in America.
This development comes as no surprise to those on the Right who, in opposing the Affordable Care Act, warned that Obamacare merely represented another lurch towards the Left’s ultimate goal of government-run health care. But what is shocking to see are claims that socialized health-care is conservative. Yet that’s just what Chase Madar proclaimed in “ The Conservative Case for Universal Healthcare ” in The American Conservative, writing: “Socializing healthcare is the only demonstrably effective way to control costs and cover everyone. It results in a healthier country and it saves a ton of money.”
There Is Nothing Conservative About Socialism
However, contrary to Madar’s claim, there is nothing conservative about socialism. Like the fictional utopia his compatriots on the Left concoct, such as Sanders’ Medicare for All , low-cost universal care exists nowhere in reality, and never will. It’s economically impossible.
Instead, what does exist proves that government-run health care is not the promised panacea. Consider, for instances, the disaster of the Veterans Administration, which is a socialized system: Veterans dying because of chronic delays in the diagnosis and treatment of diseases. Medicaid, another socialized system, likewise lays bare the truth: Government price controls—capping reimbursement rates to physicians at about 52 cents on the dollar of the insurance rate, which is the only way to make this program even pretend to be financially sustainable—leave Americans without access to doctors and with health outcomes no better than those who are uninsured.
Yet as is often the case, when socialism fails, proponent of government-controlled economies proclaim that we just need more socialism. If only the United States adopted a single-payer system. Get rid of the private insurers who “suck up a lot of money without adding any value,” and add to that the saving wrought from the federal government flexing its monopolistic bargaining power, and voila—huge cost savings sufficient to fund universal care. And look not to Medicaid—Medicare is how you do it. Medicare for all.
But, as Ezra Klein would say , this is “a puppies-and-rainbows approach to single-payer”—a promise of universal care based on fanciful promises of cost savings and soaking the rich. Nor could a Medicare-for-all approach work, as Susann Moy expertly explained in Newsweek, quoting none other than socialized medicine proponent Paul Krugman: “It’s not something most Americans want to hear about; foreign single-payer systems are actually more like Medicaid than they are like Medicare.”
As Moy detailed, the only reason Medicare works—and that is debatable given the fast-approaching fiscal cliff and the increasing number of doctors refusing to accept Medicare patients—is: “Medicare simply doesn’t pay the bills of hospitals and doctors. Medicare exists at its current high level of care because a significant part of the care is cost shifted from the 170 million Americans who have employer based health insurance.”
Get rid of private insurers, and gone too is the level of care older Americans enjoy through the Medicare system. Instead, we will all experience a much different reality—that socialized medicine controls costs by rationing care: some directly, such as seen with states severally rationing hepatitis C treatment. Louisiana only treated 324 of the nearly 35,000 infected with this deadly disease and only then once liver damage had occurred.
Other rationing occurs more subtly, as Moy explained: In the United States you’ll see the rapid construction of new medical facilities and comparatively rapid adoption of the latest high-tech equipment. But “the UK and Canada slow things down with budget creep. They can’t commit political suicide with huge tax increases that would hurt their economies so they incrementally pass increases. It’s a form of government rationing because budget restrictions create a shortage for everyone in the system, resulting in waiting lists that some patients never get off.”
This gives us more patients like Richard Bonehill, an actor in two Star Wars films who died of an enlarged heart while awaiting surgery in the United Kingdom after two earlier operations were canceled because the hospital “was put on black alert—the highest level which means it can no longer cope with demand.” Bonehill’s death is but one example of the failures of the UK’s system of socialized health care. Avik Roy’s article in Forbes on Friday provides a more complete compendium on the extent of the problem.
Therein lies the choice with government-run health coverage: Huge (and regular) tax increases or rationing. Or both. And once the government assumes this role, every dollar of health spending will be a dollar away from another government-funded program. Louisiana perfectly illustrated this trade-off when it created an interactive budget allocator to show the effects of fully funding treatment (as opposed to rationing care) for hepatitis C.
Tags
Who is online
69 visitors

The private insurance I had would cover my C-pap supplies. Medicare won't. Even after my heart doctor and primary care doctor appealed. Now I try to sterilize as best I can.
Medicare=die soon so the government can save money.
Most cpap supplies are cheaper on the Internet anyway.
But it was covered under my private plan. Medicare rations care. Single payer rations care.
Monopolies do not encourage competitive advancements in productivity or technology. Giving the government a monopoly is always bad news for the consumer.
Unless you're one of the dozens of countries who have nationalized healthcare for their citizens, with far better results and for far less than what we pay for ours.
You mean countries with vastly different cultures and ethnic makeups? We have a huge population of obese non health conscious people.
This article is comprised of meaningless sentences and anecdotes. It is basically a rant from a random person.
The writer appears to have no connection at all to medicine or the health care industry, and it shows in the text.
"This article is comprised of meaningless sentences and anecdotes. It is basically a rant from a random person. "
That reminds me of a comment I just read...
32 trillion in Additional revenue will be needed.
Keep the goverment out of the doctors room.
Doesn't everyone? They are the sweetest casting rods I have ever used. I have two now. A three weight and a six. Have you ever watched the shadowcaster in "A River Runs Through it" He is using Winston rods for that.
Hospitals are already declaring bankruptcy, and the uninsured makeup the rationing.
Although the influx of new members is a benefit, it does lead to the boredom of having to thrash the same issues that were recently fully discussed again.
Let's say you're in your 40s or 50s making about 40K a year or a young man or woman in their 20s or 30s making at or close to minimum wage.
Realistically, at that level you really don't make enough to afford a private plan that covers anything remotely close to what you might need even for high deductible and risk insurance.
So there are some alternatives here. First, we could just let them die if they need emergency treatment and they can't pay. Or we could continue to do what we do now which is we treat them as minimally as we can get away with, but by necessity doctors have to pass those costs along to those who can afford to pay.
Which in a way says that having some sort of subsidized insurance like ACA might not be that bad for someone like me who can afford to pay if it's not too expensive because the hospital is collecting some money from insurance they didn't used to collect, so in theory that should translate to a lower cost of service for those that can pay (and yes there are rainbows and unicorns I get it - but this is the theory).
To me the place to start with this really is to actually treat health care as an insurance proposition. Today whether it's ACA or private insurance, we grossly overinsure for the little things, but underinsure for the big things. And the whole point of insurance is to cover costs of things that you wouldn't be able to afford if God forbid something awful happens. The idea is to pool the risk.
Insurance likes to present you with the idea that you have an 8-10K maximum out of pocket. That's one of the cruelest lies ever. It never works like that. You will quickly encounter treatments you need that insurance won't cover.
Before ACA, I had an insurance policy that was a 5K deductible per incident. Basically that means I pay for everything myself unless it's big. It was reasonable cost because the policy doesn't have to pay for a lot of things. ACA decided I wasn't smart enough to know what's good for me so they make me buy insurance I don't need to cover costs others really should be able to pay themselves.
On the other hand, getting 16 million people insured was a giant plus for ACA. Like I said, that money is now not coming out of me when I pay for service for people that got service that didn't pay. Because so many of those people got insurance and pay now.
And yes yawn gosh there's rationing. But having something is way better than having nothing especially when it's your health on the line.
Excellent post!
There is a plan out there that meets those needs yet still allows choices. The Swiss Universal. The ACA is part Swiss. Now that the RINO reps won't do what they promised and repeal it's time to finish making the ACA all Swiss.
Choices - well in theory ACA has choice but the reality is the acceptable parameters for plans you're allowed to offer are much narrower than they used to be. And whether we go to the European style single payer models or not, someone has to pay for that.
I'd add right here that the usual thing I hear is that all we have to do is raise taxes on the wealthy to pay for it. Even if we do that, it would be nowhere near enough. Anyone who thinks their taxes won't rise if we go to full single payer is totally delusional.
It's a tradeoff people have to think about. I talked to a co-worker who emigrated here from Germany and he says his taxes in total there were about 60%. Here it's probably closer to 45%.
But for that extra 15%, he has a retirement plan, free college, and free universal health care amongst other things.
So it's a tradeoff. Is 15% of your income for life worth it for these things? For many people it will be. For others it is not.
What I try for when I think about things like universal health care is to make sure everyone's covered, but I do believe that people should pay out of pocket for things they can. And have insurance to cover you if something serious happens. I never understood why we went to a model where every health expense has to be covered. To me the goal is no way anyone should ever be refused treatment and you're covered fully if it's major.
Our taxes would still go up to provide insurance for anyone that's at or near the poverty line. But if we have a system where people pay for things they can or like the old days, just go on payments, we can make a fair but workable deal between the middle class that pays taxes and needs their money for their families and the poor that should never be refused care.