Federal Court Rules Citizens Have No Right to Film Politicians & Police in Public
Contradicting the rulings of six others federal courts, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals annihilated free speech rights in upholding a district court decision stating citizens do not have the right to film public officials — politicians, police, and others — in public.
By: Claire Bernish
This article first appeared at FreeThoughtProject
In affirming the decision of the lower court to dismiss, the Eighth Circuit effectively ended free speech activist Matthew Akins’ challenge to the Columbia, Missouri, Police Department, which he accuses of unlawfully stopping and arresting him on multiple occasions — though nearly all charges were later dropped — as he filmed their encounters with the public, in public.
Akins says the spate of arrests and harassment from law enforcement is brazen retaliation for the nature of his activist work — filming officers on the job.
As a journalist and founder of Citizens for Justice in 2011, a group committed to monitoring police for accountability purposes, Akins frequently stopped to record officers’ interactions with the general public — a tactic employed by a plethora of civilian impartial observation groups to stem an epidemic of police violence and veritable impunity in courts, so common to law enforcement officers who misbehave.
Judge Nanette Laughrey penned in the stunning decision Columbia Police officers indeed had probable cause to arrest Akins each time, and — again, contrary to previous rulings from six circuit courts —that “he has no constitutional right to videotape any public proceeding he wishes to.”
Attorney Stephen Wyse already filed an appeal on Wednesday for the court to rehear the case — originally filed against Boone County Prosecutor Dan Knight, two former Boone County assistant prosecuting attorneys, and several members of the Columbia Police Department — as he contended unequivocally, prior,
“You can’t target journalists because you don’t like their reporting.”
ABC affiliate KMIZ reports ,
“Wyse took issue with Laughrey’s decision to stay on the case, despite his request she recuse herself. Laughrey’s husband, Chris Kelly, was the head of a city task force on infrastructure, which could have skewed her decisions in a case against the city, Wyse claimed. While federal law does call for a judge’s recusal, the appeals court said nothing in Akins’ case rose to the level of bias or prejudice against his case.”
While the topic of filming the police — of particular interest to law enforcement accountability activists, First Amendment advocates, and others concerned for decaying free speech rights — appeared in federal court before, Laughrey’s ruling goes against precedence established by the First, Third, Fifth, Seventh, Ninth, and Eleventh Circuits, which decided the Constitution guarantees the right to film public officials in public settings, as long as recording does not interfere.
In fact, Judge Thomas Ambro wrote the decision for the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in a similar case comprised of separate instances in which Philadelphia law enforcement actively thwarted the efforts of two citizens, Amanda Geraci and Richard Fields, to film arrests. Both sued for violations of their civil rights, and — like many other litigants — won.
“The First Amendment protects the public’s right of access to information about their officials’ public activities,” Ambro clarified, adding that access “is particularly important because it leads to citizen discourse” on public and private issues — an exalted exercise of that preeminent protection. The government, ruled the judge, is prohibited constitutionally from “limiting the stock of information from which members of the public may draw.”
American law enforcement, on the whole, has not responded hat graciously to civilians whipping out cell phones and video cameras to record encounters in public — though filming police can indeed provide additional pictorial and audio evidence in the event of contention or disputation.
“Bystander videos provide different perspectives than police and dashboard cameras, portraying circumstances and surroundings that police videos often do not capture,” Ambro continued . “Civilian video also fills the gaps created when police choose not to record video or withhold their footage from the public.”
Laughrey, however, broke ranks in a manner which could portend a precarious existence of certain First Amendment rights — rights which had previously been assumed by the public and averred in peer courts.
“The First Amendment is a core American value,” Wyse asserted in a press statement following the decision’s astonishing departure from precedent. “The right to free speech and a free press are central to our liberty and our ability to hold our government accountable. This holding of the 8th Circuit undermines the basic rights of Missourians and the citizens of the six other 8th Circuit states and undermines the First Amendment rights for all Americans.”
Reports indicate Akins — barring an unlikely rehearing in the Eighth Circuit Court — may indeed appeal his case to the Supreme Court. Because multiple federal judges have upheld the right to film police and public officials as a constitutionally-protected activity on multiple occasions, the ramifications of Laughrey’s ruling may not be as far-reaching and detrimental as appears now — but the ultimate litmus test seems inevitably poised for SCOTUS.
In the meantime, irascible law enforcement officers keen to prevent civilians from filming their activities would do well to remember two crucial points: recording public officials keeps them responsible and accountable for their actions — but can also protect them in situations of disputing claims. After all, raw video recordings — not police, officials, or citizens — have no need of mendacity and duplicity.
“We ask much of our police,” Ambro wrote in the July decision. “They can be our shelter from the storm. Yet officers are public officials carrying out public functions, and the First Amendment requires them to bear bystanders recording their actions. This is vital to promote the access that fosters free discussion of governmental actions, especially when that discussion benefits not only citizens but the officers themselves.”
Laughrey, unfortunately, did not agree — and now the public has yet another constitutionally-protected right left dangling by a fraying thread.
http://www.thedailyliberator.com/federal-court-rules-citizens-no-right-film-politicians-police-public/
Tags
Who is online
88 visitors

WTF!?!?
You know what they say about those who have nothing to hide...
And yeah, what is that? To hell with the first?
LOL I think it has more to do with security, then privacy
the courts have previously ruled that if you are in public you have no reasonable right to privacy....guess that only means us "little people"...they have camera's on every street corner to watch us...
There you go. I have a big problem with Big Brother.
I am going to speculate that there's more to this story … will do some checking.
A wise way to go, think about assassination, assassination attempts, Citizen life Broadcasting, and security
Think about this …
A news media photographer such as a newspaper, TV, journalist, etc. … A CITIZEN … under this ruling cannot photograph/record any political news conference, nor any event where police or public officials are present.
I will content that, a politician or police officer, by definition, are, in-and-of-themselves, ALWAYS IN PUBLIC BY VIRTUE OF THE FACT THAT THEY ARE, IN THEIR OFFICIAL CAPACITIES, PART OF THE PUBLIC SPACE.
This smells of Donald Trump or his operatives.
Reiterating … I have to think there's more to this story (future appeals notwithstanding).
If you find more please let me know.
Not the first time this court has gone in this direction …
Eighth Circuit Decision Opens Door for Violations of Students’ Speech Rights
By Zach Greenberg November 1, 2016
Check the bios of the judges and by whom they were appointed.
yah yah we get it only the ninth district court or one out of hawaii has any credibility../s
yah yah we get it only the ninth district court or one out of hawaii has any credibility../s
I don't care for people putting words in my mouth; I gave another example of this court handing down a similar ruling.
If you can specifically refute, with counter-information, anything I post, we can have a debate … but please don't talk down to me or mock, pr mischaracterize what I post.
Note the /S at the end!
Note the /S at the end!
I did notice it … it was simultaneously putting words in my mouth and mocking me for saying what I did not say.
No step back, relax, and allow others to have an opinion!
A MAC was the one that stated this smells of donald trump or his operatives...
inferring that it is only trump that tries to infringe on free speech ....
you were also trying to infer about who appointed those judges of the eight district court as being republican--
i am against this ruling if it is true, -- people have the right to film and record cops even tho it may be annoying to them
but the hypocrisy from the liberals on this issue is very thick and that is what i pointed out...the liberals only are in favor of the first amendment when it represses the "other guy" and we have many examples of that..
Any law, that prohibits " Free speech " is indeed against ALL " Humans Rights " But we need to understand that ALL laws have limits, and above I posted an example when a Prohibition can be warranted for the safety of " Free Speech " and those representatives of the said!
I understand your positions regarding limits to laws, however …
PRIOR RESTRAINT is what you are advocating
Prior restraint (also referred to as prior censorship or pre-publication censorship) is censorship imposed, usually by a government, on expression that prohibits particular instances of expression.
No again You are taking what I said out of Context, relax
A MAC was the one that stated this smells of donald trump or his operatives...
inferring that it is only trump that tries to infringe on free speech ....
Implying actually that such a decision is wholly and ominously consistent with Trump's calling the Press, "THE ENEMY," his recent advocacy of police brutality which was subsequently repudiated by police organization, his comparing America's security agencies to Nazi Germany …
you were also trying to infer about who appointed those judges of the eight district court as being republican--
I did not infer nor imply anything other than to suggest that members in the tread see who the judges are, read their bios; I WILL ADD, SUSPICIOUS INDIVIDUAL THAT I AM, THAT THERE WILL LIKE BE SCOTUS VACANCIES TO BE FILLED IN THE NOT-TO-DISTANT-FUTURE -- a reality.
i am against this ruling if it is true, that people have the right to film and record cops even tho it may be annoying to them
And we agree.
but the hypocrisy from the liberals on this issue is very thick and that is what i pointed out...the liberals only are in favor of the first amendment when it represses the "other guy" and we have many examples of that..
Is that ALL LIBERALS or just radical individuals who you want to label as "liberals"? I'm a liberal for the most part … I don't agree with preventing a speaker from expressing a view with which I disagree.
By the way, and I'll post the video if you'd like, recall when Trump tried to turn crowds t his rally against the press, constraining them in pens while inciting the crowds by making defamatory comments about them … he has incited violence at more than one rally, refuses to repudiate the hate groups that support him …
Say the word and I'll post many specifics as to why this decision is in his wheelhouse.
Your comments were fair and I responded.
This decision will be headed to SCOTUS.
One can only hope!
I'm sorry, but I have to call B.S. on the article.
Not sure how that morphed into the court being the bad guys
All documents
Not sure how that morphed into the court being the bad guys
Consider if the next such ruling abrogates the rights of citizen journalism … makes it illegal for a citizen to send letters to the editor complaining about or questioning police or political activities … magazine, newspaper, internet blogs and forums …
Can you not see the slippery slope such a ruling constitutes?
consider when rioters attempt to keep a political campaigner from speaking at his rally (chicago)
or a speaker at some college they were invited to speak at---
or prevent betsey de vos from entering a public building---
granted these were not court decisions, but why should libs be so upset about a practice they have engaged in for quite some time now.
libs only like the idea of curtailing and limiting free speech if it means only they themselves can be heard and not the "other guys"
that slippery slope may be sliding towards libs now, hey ?
consider when rioters attempt to keep a political campaigner from speaking at his rally (chicago)
or a speaker at some college they were invited to speak at---
or prevent betsey de vos from entering a public building---
granted these were not court decisions, but why should libs be so upset about a practice they have engaged in for quite some time now.
libs only like the idea of curtailing and limiting free speech if it means only they themselves can be heard and not the "other guys"
that slippery slope may be sliding towards libs now, hey ?
In essence, you're saying that two wrongs make a right.
Just to be clear, are you referring to all "libs" … do you speak on behalf of all conservatives? The broad-brush, dismissive argument is for those who can't otherwise make a viable one.
Yes, mam!
Can you not see the slippery slope such a ruling constitutes?
At only one point was he ordered to stop filming anything. The police were well aware that he had a constitutional right to film them in action, although several officers did not like it.
He was once told by a citizen support member he should not film inside police headquarters, but was later informed that he in fact, could.
A public meeting was held with credential media invited and require R.S.V.P. He was not invited and chose to "crash" the event. Hence the admonition “he has no constitutional right to videotape any public proceeding he wishes to.”
Sorry, this is NOT the case that the article pretends it to be. The court documentation makes that quite clear and at no point did the 8th overturn anything from previous court rulings. Nor does this ruling overturn anything done in previous court rulings.
Sorry, this is NOT the case that the article pretends it to be. The court documentation makes that quite clear and at no point did the 8th overturn anything from previous court rulings. Nor does this ruling overturn anything done in previous court rulings.
The ruling abrogates a First Amendment right of citizens under the court's purview.
Regardless of the plaintiff's innocence or guilt in incidents leading to the decision, the First Amendment is the issue.
the First Amendment is the issue.
And his first amendment rights were clearly not violated, with the exception of being told not to film in the police headquarters the one time and later informed he was INDEED allowed to film there.
And his first amendment rights were clearly not violated
The precedent it sets is contrary to the First Amendment and extends to "citizens" in general.
The precedent it sets is contrary to the First Amendment and extends to "citizens" in general.
How so?
“The First Amendment is a core American value,” Wyse asserted in a press statement following the decision’s astonishing departure from precedent. “The right to free speech and a free press are central to our liberty and our ability to hold our government accountable. This holding of the 8th Circuit undermines the basic rights of Missourians and the citizens of the six other 8th Circuit states and undermines the First Amendment rights for all Americans.”
This holding of the 8th Circuit undermines the basic rights of Missourians and the citizens of the six other 8th Circuit states and undermines the First Amendment rights for all Americans.”
Again, how does this ruling undermine my first amendment rights or the first amendment rights of other, given he was given unrestricted access to all public functions, except one he chose to crash uninvited and was turned away?
exactly and thanks for the clarification--it was more a ruling that this guy could not go where he was not invited at a private affair even if public officials were there and it's called trespassing in most areas..
it has nothing to do with the free speech of the public at large or limit their ability to film public functions and officials out in public.
it has nothing to do with the free speech of the public at large or limit their ability to film public functions and officials out in public.
You are looking at it narrowly … the ruling is not about a particular incident … it uses the incident to apply as follows …
" … upholding a district court decision stating citizens do not have the right to film public officials — politicians, police, and others — in public.
That is contrary to the First Amendment
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
" … upholding a district court decision stating citizens do not have the right to film public officials — politicians, police, and others — in public.
Where in all the briefs, is that statement made? "0" none nada zilch.
Contradicting the rulings of six others federal courts, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals annihilated free speech rights in upholding a district court decision stating citizens do not have the right to film public officials — politicians, police, and others — in public.
Contradicting the rulings of six others federal courts
Who says they contradict those other court rulings? Someone with an agenda. I posted the case above, so I invite you to read pages 32~35. You will note that case law is denoted when applicable and the reasoning behind rejecting each of the four 1st amendment complaints by the plaintiff. Note which ones were against someone not mentioned in the lawsuit and thereby overturned. Not the failure of the plaintiff to present necessary evidence as required by existing laws and rulings. There is nothing new in this ruling and no contradictions.
You have a lawyer that presented a poor case, got buttwhipped over and over and is now complaining about the horror of it all. Typical misdirection and it is B.S. pure and simple.
Again, how does this ruling undermine my first amendment rights or the first amendment rights of other, given he was given unrestricted access to all public functions, except one he chose to crash uninvited and was turned away?
Rulings that arise in conjunction with the assertions of a plaintiff apply not only to the plaintiff, they apply as all case law applies. What is denied or permitted UNDER THE LAW TO A CLAIMANT, applies to all.
What is denied or permitted UNDER THE LAW TO A CLAIMANT, applies to all.
Great! This means I cannot charge into/crash events that require an invitation. It's about time! /s
Great! This means I cannot charge into/crash events that require an invitation. It's about time! /s
If it means you're trespassing … you can't.
Sometime you might want to have a serious dialogue …
Sometime you might want to have a serious dialogue …
I know where NOT to look.
Eighth Circuit: Citizens do not have a right to film public officials in public
JEFFERSON CITY — In a free speech ruling that contradicts six other federal circuit courts, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a district court ruling that says Americans do not have a first amendment right to videotape the police, or any public official, in public.
Judge Nanette Laughrey ruled that Akins, and by extension, any citizen or the press, has no right to record the activities of public officials on public property. The Eighth Circuit affirmed this ruling.
AND BY EXTENSION …
Your obstinance and sarcasm define you.
__________________________________________________________
Sometime you might want to have a serious dialogue …
I know where NOT to look.
Apparently you need some direction.
Judge Nanette Laughrey ruled that Akins, and by extension, any citizen or the press, has no right to record the activities of public officials on public property. The Eighth Circuit affirmed this ruling.
Again, nowhere in the ruling is that stated. What was written...
Finally, with respect to the media training event, Akins was not a member of the traditional media, nor does the record show he was an active nontraditional media member at the time. Space limited. These were the content-neutral reasons not to create an exception for Akins to attend the invitation-only event. The media does not enjoy a right of equal access or special First Amendment rights. See Snyder v. Ringgold 133 F.3d 917 (4th Cir. 1998).
The retaliation claim therefore fails.
Notice how case law is cited? Notice how the actual proceedings and your news org. information differ? I invited you to read the actual files, yet you chose not to.
("[N]either the public nor the media has a First Amendment right to videotape, photograph, or make audio recordings of government proceedings that are by law open to the public") and Wis. Interscholastic Ath. Ass'n v. Gannet Co., F.3d 614,627-627 (7th Cir. 2011) (same). His links to the Police Department's Facebook page were treated the same as everyone else's and there is no constitutional right to unlimited posting. See TinleySparks, Inc v. Vill. of Tinley Park, 2015 WL 2265451, *10 (N.D. Ill. May 11, 2015) ("Plaintiffs have not cited any case holding that they have a right to post messages that could be perceived as political in online forums intended to promote small business growth.
Again notice the citations, etc. Enough with the faux outrage.
It need not be so stipulated in a subsequent ruling by virtue of the fact that it does not countermand a previous ruling that stands as case law.
with respect to the media training event, Akins was not a member of the traditional media, nor does the record show he was an active nontraditional media member at the time. Space limited. These were the content-neutral reasons not to create an exception for Akins to attend the invitation-only event.
The appellant was not looking to overturn the previous decision which stipulated that …
… any citizen or the press, has no right to record the activities of public officials on public property.
And The Eighth Circuit affirmed this ruling.
Rather, he was LOOKING TO BE GIVEN AN EXCEPTION … a one-time exclusion from an existing ruling.
That is why, by EXTENSION, the existing ruling, which precludes the right to record the activities of public officials on public property … is not challenged by the appeal … and stands.
"Can you not see the slippery slope such a ruling constitutes?"
INDEED!!!!
Gee... erosion of rights!
Amazing!