Je Suis Pamela Geller?
Since Pamela Geller likes to fashion herself a heroine of the Jewish people, let me use a Yiddish word to describe her: shanda .
Shanda means shame, and its usually used to describe a person or behavior that shames or embarrasses the Jewish community. It is hard to think of an American Jewish public figure of more ill repute than Geller, the self-styled anti-jihadist web warrior who hosted the Draw Muhammad event that came under attack Sunday in Garland, Texas.
From her luxury apartment in Manhattan, Geller has been single-handedly waging a crusade against global Islamic fundamentalism, which, in her considered view, is Islam itself. Like extremists of all stripesincluding Sundays featured speaker, populist Dutch politician Geert Wilders, who has advocated banning the QuranGeller lacks nuance, seeing the world in black and white. The only moderate Muslim is a secular Muslim, this reputed scholar of religion told The New York Times in 2009 after coming to prominence as a leader in the anti-Ground Zero mosque movement. When Muslims pray five times a daytheyre cursing Christians and Jews five times a day, she asserted.
If Geller embraced an element of camp, like that other right-wing female firebrand, Ann Coulter, she might be mildly amusing. Early in Gellers Internet career, she produced an amateurish music video called My Shariah, with original lyrics refashioned to the tune of The Knacks My Sharona. Now sadly erased from the web, it hinted at someone who at least had a sense of humor.
But Geller isnt performance art. Shes deadly serious. The problem is that, contrary to her self-imaginings and those of her deluded followers, she isnt a latter-day Golda Meir. Shes what you would get if Fran Drescher and the late ultranationalist anti-Arab rabbi-turned-political leader Meir Kahane reproduced.
For those of us who genuinely want to combat extremism and promote liberalism in the Muslim world, Geller is a uniquely toxic presence in the public discourse. She makes it easy for Islamist apologists to avoid debate, as they can always point to Geller and her outrageous behavior for ready examples of how pervasive Islamophobia has become in American society.
Yet Gellers being an obnoxious blowhard cannot lessen her claim to the same free speech rights that more salubrious individuals enjoy.
Yet Gellers being an obnoxious blowhard cannot lessen her claim to the same free speech rights that more salubrious individuals enjoy. Indeed, it is vital that free speech supporters unequivocally condemn Sundays attack precisely because Geller is an obnoxious blowhard. To understand why, it helps to remember one of Americas most important First Amendment legal cases.
The archetypical test of ones commitment to free speech is his or her position on National Socialist Party of America v. Skokie . The 1977 case concerned a planned demonstration by neo-Nazis in the heavily Jewish Chicago suburb, where one of every six residents was a Holocaust survivor. After the neo-Nazi group announced its plans to march in the community, local authorities did everything they could to stop it, using bureaucratic tools like demanding the NSPA post $350,000 worth of liability insurance in advance of its demonstration.
The case eventually made its way to the Supreme Court, which overruled an injunction against the march issued by lower courts. Ultimately, the march, as such, never took place. Instead, some 20 neo-Nazis milled around for 10 minutes, drowned out by thousands of counter-protesters. The very freedom that the bigots used to express their bigotry became the tool for decent people to demonstrate their much larger numbers.
As is the case today with manifestations of Muhammed, critics argued that permitting neo-Nazis to march anywhere, never mind a community home to so many Jews, was provocative and hateful. Yet what Ill take the liberty of calling the Skokie test has endured as a barometer of devotion to free speech because its the most extreme example one could possibly devise: the most despised, loathsome individuals (neo-Nazis) expressing their views unhindered to those people most likely to be offended by them (Holocaust survivors).
The Skokie case was taken up by the American Civil Liberties Union, and liberals love to cite it as proof of their free speech bona fides. Today, however, many liberals only begrudgingly endorse the free speech rights of those with whom they disagree. Its useful to be reminded of the Skokie test today, when so many members of our literary, cultural, and journalistic elite have revealed themselves to be such fair-weather friends of free speech. As of this writing, more than 200 writers (some of themFrancine Prose, Teju Colequite well known, most of them non-entities) have signed an open letter protesting the decision of the PEN American Center to bestow an award on the remaining staff of Charlie Hebdo, the satirical French newspaper that has continued to publish on a regular basis despite the massacre of a dozen of its staff by Muslim terrorists in January. Garry Trudeau, in an April speech spitting on the graves of his murdered fellow cartoonists, deemed Charlie Hebdo to be hate speech and unworthy of our regard.
Pamela Geller is no hero, and, unlike the staff of Charlie whose irreverent work has artistic meritshe doesnt deserve any sort of prize. What she does deserve, and nothing more, is the protection of her right to say what she wants, especially by those of us who detest what she has to say.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/05/04/je-suis-pamela-geller.html

Kindly read the article before commenting.
Pamela Geller is an extremist. Her actions do not promote a solution to our huge global problem. There are always grains of truth in what she says, but they are completely smothered by hatred. She is a hater, and I don't support haters.
But what of free speech?
What of freedom of expression?
What of double standards?
Why is what this one says "free speech", but what that one says "hate speech"?
What to do?
I fully understand that, John.
Now, the question:
Is she entitled to air her views in America, as an American?
I think that the basis of your opinion is the very reason why she's a good example.
When we're formulating laws and societal guidelines, we have to find the extreme example, in order to establish boundaries. This allows us to view these types of things more objectively.
From the article:
The archetypical test of ones commitment to free speech is his or her position on National Socialist Party of America v. Skokie. The 1977 case concerned a planned demonstration by neo-Nazis in the heavily Jewish Chicago suburb, where one of every six residents was a Holocaust survivor. After the neo-Nazi group announced its plans to march in the community, local authorities did everything they could to stop it, using bureaucratic tools like demanding the NSPA post $350,000 worth of liability insurance in advance of its demonstration.
The case eventually made its way to the Supreme Court, which overruled an injunction against the march issued by lower courts. Ultimately, the march, as such, never took place. Instead, some 20 neo-Nazis milled around for 10 minutes, drowned out by thousands of counter-protesters. The very freedom that the bigots used to express their bigotry became the tool for decent people to demonstrate their much larger numbers.
As is the case today with manifestations of Muhammed, critics argued that permitting neo-Nazis to march anywhere, never mind a community home to so many Jews, was provocative and hateful. Yet what Ill take the liberty of calling the Skokie test has endured as a barometer of devotion to free speech because its the most extreme example one could possibly devise: the most despised, loathsome individuals (neo-Nazis) expressing their views unhindered to those people most likely to be offended by them (Holocaust survivors).
She's a hater, Rob. We can't dance around that.
There's a way to express what she's thinking without being a hater. Wilders is not a hater. Condell is not a hater. Geller is a hater, and a good example for the purpose of determining the limits of free speech, which, IMHO, she is entitled to, even with that content.
I agree that she hates radical Islam and those who practise it. She publishes daily reports on Islamic radicalism, but if anything she publishes is untrue then that would be an exception to free speech and she could be found guilty of libel or at least sued successfully. Has she ever been sued successfully for libel? As well, America has laws against hate speech, so I ask the same question. Has she ever been found guilty of the crime of disseminating hate speech?
Because if she has not libelled, or been guilty of hate speech, then perhaps she is the canary in the mine.
Geller knew that there was a high likelihood that her "contest" would.
Really? You think she was anticipating rioting, of which there was none? Was she anticipating picketing? Perhaps. Armed men ready to use automatic weapons?
Really?
This is America, not France.
We are told that ISIS is not a threat to us here.
I guess that would be an incorrect assessment.
It's a good thing we have the right to bear arms here.
Jonathan...
Spot on with your stance. She is a disgusting human being, but she does have the right to her free speech.
We can add her among the other nuts like the Westboro Baptist Church.
Well thank you for the instructions, j.
I thought I was rather clear, but I suppose you have a problem reading between the lines.
No, she should not have anticipated armed assailants converging on the event. Maybe some rowdy protesters, but not people with murderous intent.
And please try to maintain a little decorum on the seed. Everyone is playing nice. You can get your message across without taunting people.
Thank you.