Germanwings Crash: Is Depression Really to Blame?
Did Germanwings co-pilot Andreas Lubitz commit a deliberate act to cause the crash of a plane in the French Alps, killing all 150 people on board?
By Matt Sloane
WebMD Health News
Authorities are still attempting to determine a motive for Lubitzs alleged actions in last weeks crash, and many questions remain unanswered. Reports have surfaced that Lubitz was treated for suicidal tendencies prior to getting his pilots license, and that he had visited a neuropsychologist and an eye doctor recently and been deemed unfit to work. Both of those doctors concluded that he had psychological issues, according to media reports . Antidepressants were reportedly found in his apartment, leading to speculation he may also have been battling depression.
But depression alone likely was not the cause of the actions Lubitz is thought to have committed, says Charles Raison, MD, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Arizona who was not involved in Lubitzs case. Raison provides insight into what may have occurred.
Debris of the Germanwings Airbus A320 are seen at the site of the crash, near Seyne-les-Alpes, French Alps March 29, 2015. REUTERS/Gonzalo Fuentes
Q:Reports have suggested that theco-pilot was suffering from depression, and that he had been prescribed antidepressant medication. Does that make somebody ineligible to fly?
A: Just because somebodys depressed is not a reason for somebody not to fly. Somebody who is acting suicidal, that may be a different issue, but I dont think it was depression that was the problem here, although I cant say for sure.
If you think about what this entails, heres a guy who plans this out, the door gets closed, then he hears people screaming, the other pilot is banging on the door, theyre cascading down from 30,000feet. Hes calm as can be thats not usually depression.
Im pretty sure that eventually itll come out that he had some kind of psychotic break. If youre depressed and you want to die, you dont want to do this to other people thats just not part of the gig. If youre psychotic, you hear things, and you begin to develop these odd ideas where you actually think youre doing the right thing.
We used to say in medical school: common things happen commonly. And when somebody does something this bizarre, the common explanation is that theyve developed a psychotic condition.
Seven-month-old Julian Pracz-Bandres and his mother Marina Bandres, were killed when the Germanwings Airbus A320 crashed in the Alps. Diario Del Alto Aragon
Q: Millions of people have depression, and dont carry out acts such as this. Knowing as little as we do about Lubitzsfull history, do you believe something else had to have been going on with this mans mental state?
A: He may have been depressed and psychotic, but Id be willing to bet that he had a break with reality. That is unusual in depression. It occurs in people who have manic depression, or bipolar disorder. In fact, if you get depressed and psychotic as a young person, its almost always bipolar disorder.
Psychosis is more common in mania than it is in depressions, so I dont think it was just a simple case of depression.
At the end of the day, theres really only a couple possibilities. If he was, on average, just depressed he wasnt hearing voices or anything, he was just depressed and had not lost touch with reality, to do something so horrible to so many people, to have people screaming and other guys banging on the door, its going to come out that he had a chronic history of being horribly narcissistic or unbelievably sadistic.
As far as I can tell, this guy did not have a history of violence. He had a history of mental illness, but he didnt have a history of violence, or at least we havent heard that yet.
This is a very violent act. This is a slow, long, horrible violent act.
Germanwings pilot Andreas Lubitz is believed to have sought treatment for eye problems
Q: We do know that he had been treated for suicidal tendencies in the past. What does that tell you about this mans mental state?
A: It tells me that this guy was sick. At lot of people with depression have suicidal tendencies, and some people with depression kill themselves. With really serious depression, somewhere between 8 and 15% of people commit suicide eventually.
Of those people, veryfew take anybody with them. When they do, theres usually a personality problem too.
We do know that the worse depression you have and the younger you are, the more likely you are to have bipolar disorder. Young men dont tend to get depressed the rates for depression are less than half of what they are in women.
When you see young men with catastrophic depression, they have a very high rate of converting to bipolar disorder.
urbed.
Q: Are there methods in pla Ive heard that he also received an official diagnosis of generalized anxiety disorder. Anxiety, chronic anxiety [is also more associated with] bipolarity, compared to [just] depression.
Im fairly certain that this guy had a really nasty bipolar disorder, and my guess would be that in the last few weeks, he developed this crazy delusional system which caused him to do this very horrible thing.
Q: There are also reports that he may have had vision problems, and there is some suggestion that those could have beenpsychosomatic. What does that mean exactly, and does that give us any clues?
A: Psychosomatic symptoms are associated with mental disorders; there is no doubt about that. There are very powerful associations with many disorders depression, anxiety. We actually have what are called somatoform disorders in psychiatry, where the primary problem is that peoples lives are destroyed by physical symptoms that no doctor can find an explanation for.
But it doesnt provide you any specific guidance. Its another piece of evidence that this guy was psychiatrically dist be violent. The vast majority of people with very serious mental illnesses where they lose touch with reality are not violent. The main reason to have that awareness is because we know that these disorders are catastrophic, and the sooner theyre treated, the more likely a person is to have a good outcome.
But also, every once in a while, ce, or should there be methods in place to help catch things like this before they happen? Is that even possible?
A: This is a complex issue, and its a tragic thing that Ive now been asked this question about eight times in the last five years. There has been a string of stuff like this Newtown (Connecticut), Jared Loughner (2011 shootings in Tucson, Arizona) and this is always the question.
In my thinking, the answer is its a balance between personal privacy and personal freedom, and public safety. Where you draw that line is not so easy. Something like this happens, and everybody says OK, we need to do this, this and this. But then you start putting all of those restrictions on people, and it starts to look like a police state.
So what I have said consistently is that people need to be on the lookout for friends and loved ones who begin to act strangely at any age, but especially over the age of 18. If somebody you know well begins to change strikingly in their behavior, in their hygiene, in the way they speak if they begin to talk about strange ideas that dont make sense, every bell should go off in your head .
Not because theyre likely to these disorders are associated with violence, and weve seen that repeatedly. So thats what we need to be looking for.
What Id love to know is, did this guy show evidence that he was losing touch with reality in the weeks or months before this happened? Did his sleep change, did he start acting oddly, and to the degree that he did, its more and more certain that something like this could happen.
Tags
seeder
Jerry Verlinger
11 years agoApparently the protocol is for European pilots to ground themselves when they are deemed unfit to fly. "This don't understand", to quote an old boss of mine,
Why in the hell airlines are not required to monitor the physical and mental of it's pilots is beyond me.
This should cost Lufthansa a ton of money, but I heard there is some kind of victims compensation settlement in Europe that pays the families a max of $100 k for the loss of life due to a downed plane.
I'm going to have to look it up.
Buzz of the Orient
11 years agoIn Germany there are very strict laws about doctor-patient confidentiality with serious consequences if breached. In this case his doctors were aware that he was a risk to fly, but would not disclose this fact. IMO airlines should require pilots to execute a release of that confidentiality and the airlines should require frequent examinations with doctors appointed by the airlines so that the pilots' condition will become known to the airlines. It seems to me that the balance of saving the lives of hundreds of innocent persons outweighs the confidentiality rule.
Randy
11 years agoSo the doctor believe he may have been bi-polar, which would account for the violent and homicidal behavior. My second wife was Bi-polar and I actually called the Sheriff's Department after she had been up for days and suggested a family murder-suicide for the two of us and our two young sons. She was put on a 72 hour hold and that was extended to send her to the State Mental Hospital in Kalamazoo (it's n longer there).
Her mother said I made it up to get rid of my wife, when I was simply to afraid to go to work and leave her alone with them. It was during that same episode I had to talk her out of killing herself by walking out into the snow at night naked until she died. I felt guilty about feeling it at the time, but I was so relieved that she was in the hospital and I didn't have to to care of her for awhile. It was an exhausting thing to have to do. Bi-poplars un-medicated, are very, very difficult to handle.
The Doctor's diagnoses of Bi-polar makes perfect sense. This is something that an un-medicated Bi-polar is capable of, IMHO.
Randy
11 years agoI can see that. He was extremely disappointed that he was not going to be able to fly much longer, so he killed himself, while also taking out his anger on the other people on board the plane and the company.
Perrie Halpern R.A.
11 years agoSounds about right to me. Also a bipolar off their meds, runs on their impulse emotions without any consideration to those around them.
Who is online
154 visitors
