What is the definition of "Palestinian"? ... ... by Bob Nelson
I have Al Jazeera among my RSS feeds.It has more Middle East coverage than most, often concerning aspects that are not very well covered by my Occidental news sources -- the overall Shi'ia / Sunni struggle and way various countries engaged in it, for instance.
Still... Al Jazeera is like most American news sources: it has an agenda. It is firmly "pro-Palestine". A reader must constantly adjust the site's articles for that bias.
Recently, I have noticed something I had not previously. Al Jazeera is using terms like " Palestinian citizens of Israel" to describe Muslim citizens of Israel.
I don't understand...
These people -- and their parents, and perhaps grandparents -- have been Israeli citizens since 1947. Since long before there was a "Palestinian movement".
If they are now to be termed "Palestinian"... then I do not understand the meaning of the word. If it simply means any Muslim born within the post-WWI "Palestinian Mandate", then it now covers people of two different "nationalities", Jordanian and Israeli, and a considerable diaspora all across the Middle East. This usage, it seems to me, changes the meaning of "Palestinian" fundamentally , from a "nationality" to an "ethnicity".
When we speak of the "Chinese" of Malaysia, we are not speaking of displaced Chinese nationals. We are speaking of ethnic Chinese who are Malaysian citizens, most of them since long before the country became independent in 1957. Indeed, there are "Chinese" in many countries, all around the world.
Importantly, this usage recognizes implicitly that the majority of the population of Jordan is "Palestinian". The "two state solution" has quite another meaning when Jordan is included in the conversation...
So I don't understand why Al Jazeera is now using this term...
Any ideas?

This is obviously an attempt to manipulate the conversation by controlling the vocabulary. But I do not understand the purpose. It seems to me that it waters down the term "Palestinian", and that it very obviously puts Jordan into the conversation at the same level as Israel: a nation with a lot of "Palestinians".
What is the objective?
It is a propaganda ploy. They are trying to ferment discontent and an allegiance with the Israeli Arab population with those who live in Gaza and the West Bank.
Yes...
I cannot see, though, how this shift in vocabulary is helpful to them. Muslim Israelis already sympathize massively with the Palestinian cause... while recognizing that they would not want to live elsewhere! (Emotions and intellect are so often at odds, in this mess...)
It actually isn't helpful to the Israeli Arabs. But this is about agendas, and not what is best for anyone.
I agree.
But it doesn't appear helpful to the "Palestinians" either, to be considered an ethnical group rather than a nation.
... unless the Arab states are looking for a way to cut them loose...
When I think about this, I get a headache.
This may be a bit off topic, but: al-Jazeera has another, related bais as well. In addition to being "pro-Palestinian"-- they are also extremely anti-Israel!
Palestine has never been an independent country, so its definitely not a a nationality. In fact, before modern Israel was created in 1948, Jews living in the areas sometimes referred to themselves as "Palestinian Jews" (as opposed to, for example, "South American Jews" or "European Jews".
Yes.House of Cardsis simple...
That's what I first wrote... but I shifted to "pro-Palestinian" because I don't remember many critical articles, outside the Palestinian question. Reporting on the election has been pretty straightforward.
And its definitely not a distinct ethnicity-- those living in Gaza are no different ethnically than "non-Palestinians" living just over the border in Egypt (who are called "Egyptians").
In fact, before the Israeli occupation of Gaza (more or less 1967-2005) Gaza was occupied by Egypt. At various timrs since then the Gaza-Egypt border as been open-- or not. As a result, many Gaza "Palestinians" are of mixed Egyptian-Palestinian ancestry.
In the so-called "West Bank", the Arabs are no different than various Syrian Arab groups. (Like other former colonies in the area, new countries were created by colonial rulers-- borders that do not conform to any ethnic group.
If "Palestine" means any inhabitant of" The British Mandate of Palestine", then most Jordanians are "Palestinians". In fact, I suppose you could make a good case that a Palestinian state already exists-- its called "Jordan". (Although its not ruled by the "Palestinian" majority, but rather the minority Hashemites).
Heck-- two Arab states with "Palestinian" majorities now have self rule-- Jordan and The Republic of Hamastan (more commonly referred to as "The Gaza Strip").
I agree entirely. But until now, the pro-Palestinian camp has done everything in its power to pretend that "Palestine" is / was / should be a nation. I posted a "Shrinking Palestine" map the other day that very definitely tried to make readers imagine that there is a "History of Palestine" somewhere.
That's what confuses me. This "Palestinians of Israel" vocabulary from Al Jazeera seems to me to be a radical change of orientation.
Well here is a game changer....
Netanyahu just said that there will NOT be a two state solution.
Read more about it here:
Opinions?
... problem with the link...
I'd be kinda skeptical of everything Bibi says these days. He's flailing, because of unfavorable pre-election polls.
A Palestinian is a non-Jew living in the occupied territories who wants a two state solution to the problem of violence between themselves and Israel. IMHO a two state solution is the ONLY one that will work.
That means that their identity is determined by a political agenda? Really?
Hamas does not want a two-state solution. Hamas wants the destruction of Israel. Is Hamas therefore NOT a Palestinian organization?
No, they are a terrorist organization first in the same manner that Al Qaeda is a terrorist organization first and does not represent Muslims.
The vast majority of Palestinians would accept a two state solution. As long as there is not a two state solution, as long as there is not a nation of Palestine, there will be war, so let's look at alternatives. Or perhaps the Israelis should just round up all Palestinians into concentration camps?
Is it not possible for an organization to be both "terrorist" and "Palestinian" at the same time?
There is a difference between "being" and "representing".
I don't see how they want a solution to the problem of violence when violence is the staple they live on. Like the cartels of Mexico, they would not know what to do with themselves tomorrow if everything they asked for were handed to them today.
i believe his previous position was that he supported a two-state solution-- or at least that's what he said. So why the change?
IDK for sure, but I do think he running scared-- he's afraid of losing some support from the far right.
You are presenting this as if there are only two possible future outcomes: either there will be a two state solution and peace--or the Israelis will put all the Palestinians in concentration camps.
But you are ignoring a third possibility-- one that lies between those two extremes. What's that? Simply that things will remain the same as they have been..for decades.
IMO, at least in the near future, that's the most likely scenario.
I think that's true of the majority of people in Gaza. In the West bank theyk are robably divided.
But at least for Hamas- their priority is not a Palestinian state. Rather, it is to destroy Israel and exterminate the Jews. (Peace and a two state solution flies in the face of what Hamas wants).
And whether we like it or not, the fact is that Hamas rules one of the two major areas that would become a Palestinian state. They are committed to never making peace.
I don't see how they want a solution to the problem of violence when violence is the staple they live on.
No. It is not.
And whether we like it or not, the fact is that Hamas rules one of the two major areas that would become a Palestinian state. They are committed to never making peace.
And if a true Palestine was established, Hamas would wither and die.
What's that? Simply that things will remain the same as they have been..for decades.
Slaughtering each other in war and terrorism. That's one hell of a solution to peace you have there.
And that extreme bias is what helped Al-Jazeera get itself banned in Canada.
Is it not possible for an organization to be both "terrorist" and "Palestinian" at the same time?
Is it not possible to be Christian and terrorist at the same time. Of course it is (just ask the Irish), but that doesn't mean the terrorists represent Christianity any more then then Al Qaeda represents the Muslim world. I would also argue that both types of terrorists have given up their right to claim their religion.
He didn't say it was a solution, Randy, he said it was a possibility. It isn't necessary to always talk in extremes the way you do, so don't expect that everyone else does.
It's not a road to PEACE though, which should be the goal, except for those who profit from war, financially, politically or just to play victim and martyr forever more on both sides!
If it's not a road to peace then it is nothing.
Randy, you have SUCH a sense of humour.
If not violence, then anti-normalization, and if not that, support for terrorism like naming squares, parks and streets after terrorists and praising them. But a very small percentage might actually want to live peacefully with Jews.
We've been down this road before and it ends up with hating each other. You are convinced you are right and I am wrong and I am convinced it's the other way around. I will say I never laughed at you. Goodbye old friend. You are nobody to me now.
This was a meta comment . Did you address the points he brought up ? No . Facts & argument are of no interest to you ...
YOU never were anything to me...
Boo hoo ...
Sorry,
Here is the link:
IDK for sure, but I do think he running scared-- he's afraid of losing some support from the far right.
Bingo!!!
I agree. The last thing that Hamas wants is peace. They would be irrelevant, instantly.
Not quite. He knowshe's going to lose centrists, so he is trying to be absolutely sure of the right wing.
Here is the link:
Excellent article! Bibi is desperate and it shows. It also shows he always intended to annex the occupied territories as a permanent part of Israel. It's a land grab and that's all it's ever been for him.
Who says it will? With a two states the support for Hamas would pretty much disappear. The average Palestinian wants peace just as much as the average Israeli does.
Yes. If, as seems to be the case, the Arab states are losing interest in favor of the Shi'ia / Sunni fight, just kicking the can down the road may be the best solution right now. There's no way to achieve stable peace right now, but maybe in fifteen years...
So we quit trying? Peace can be had between the Israelis and the Palestinians. It doesn't have to be the status quo.
Buzz, MM, Petey...
Please play nice.
Always.
However, given a choice between a state, a country, of their own, the support for Hamas would fade rapidly and the PA would take care of the rest. Peace is right there in front of both sides. All they have to do is to reach out and take it or want it. Bibi doesn't want it any more then Hamas does.
I might try to run a ten-second hundred meter dash... again and again and again... but since success is impossible, I will never succeed.
Peace between Hamas and Israel is at least as impossible...
We don't "quit". We put the mess on hold.
Yeah - - He's flailing...
Which is the same thing as telling Israel that they can continue to build more settlements in the occupied territories until they annex them. Peace between Israel and Hamas IS impossible, but if a state of Palestine is established and the people see a real chance for their own country and peace, then support for Hamas will disappear and so will they.
There is no possible way to put it "on hold".
The Green Line is a nonsensical border, a purely incidental cease-fire line from a haphazard war seventy years ago.
When peace comes, in five or twenty-five years, the border will be "cleaned up". The settlements will be abandoned or compensated. It's futile, today, to do more than keep track of them.
Peace is there right now. Within months. Not 25 years of slaughter from now. To wait is to guarantee there will not be a two state solution or is that your goal too? I am beginning to think that's what you want. One large Israel. And no homeland for the Palestinians. Just Israel. There will NEVER be peace without two states. Never!
The only people stopping it is Likud and Hamas. Two sides of the same coin. Everyone else wants peace except for them.
I did. Mr. "overreaction" didn't.
Just what the world needs, another mind-reader.
I never said it was a solution!
I was mentioning it as a third possible outcome. Personally, i would like to see peace. But of the two possibilities you mentioned-- I saw that as an additionalpossibiity. And IMO I believe that the current situation will continue for some time. I don't know how long it will take, but I think eventually there is a good chance of peace...maybe in 20 years?
Nope. It is something-- it is the situation that now exists-- in reality!. It is real (unfortunately). And, BTW, none of the two things you mentioned are real-- there is currently no 2 state solution and neither are Israelis are not rounding up the Palestinians & putting them in concentration camps!
Actually, it does-- at least for now.
This isn't the first time I've had this discussion . The last time I said peace is impossible-- at least for now, someone replied:
It has been my experience, more often than not in Internet discussions when someone throws out a nice sounding cliche, it because they don't have enough factual evidence to support their position. And it that discussion,it worked to some degree-- my comments were getting mostly 2 votes, the cliche-user was getting 7 or 8! (Which IMNSHO is a good indication of the usual superficiality that permeates most online discussions...)
Of course you don't have to use a cliche. You can just say we must keep trying. But the fact is, we don't have to, and probably shouldn't. (Remember Kerry's numerous shuttling back and forth to attempt to make the two parties make peace?)
Heck-- I just thought of a cliche to respond to you assertion that we keep trying:
I was mentioning it as a third possible outcome.
However your solution is no solution at all. All it is is more war and terrorism when neither has to happen. We need to pursue peace now and it IS possible in the very, very near future, not 25 years down the road. Doing nothing is exactly that, nothing. The only reason for maintaining the status quo is to make sure Israel has time to build more and more settlements and then absorbs the territory as their own because so many Israelis live there. This has happened in the middle of the last century and it didn't turn out well for anyone involved. YOU do not want a 2 state solution and it's right there in front of them NOW. You and Likud WANT war as much as Hamas does. Likud is the same as Hamas.
There's no way to achieve stable peace right now, but maybe in fifteen years...
I disagree. Peace is right in front of Israel and Palestine and it can happen now! The only reason for it not to happen now is that some people don't want it to happen. You are a defeatist. Why kick the can of peace down the road when it's right in front of us NOW!!
If we fail to achieve peace between Israel and Palestine it is OUR failure too, because it is right there for both sides to take. All they have to do is to reach out and do it like when Israel signed a peace treaty with Egypt that "everyone" said could not happen. However there are forces on both sides that don't want it and that is the ONLY reason for it not to happen now.
I wonder if you are aware of all the efforts that have been made over time?
Many Americans (& others in the west don't really understand the situation).
Anyone remember Yaakov? Anyway he seeded an excellent article about why many Americans don't understand te situation. Its well worth reading (unfortunately two sites seem to have links to the last part that might not work). But it says a lot, and some of the comments are really good:
--> LINK
If a state is established for the Palestinians then they will desert Hamas in droves and it won't mean a damn thing if Hamas will never recognize Israel as the PA will not recognize Hamas any longer, will take Gaza back away from them and they will disappear. There will be peace in Gaza. We just have to want it and it will happen because everything is in place for t to happen except for Likud and Hamas and they can both be marginalized.
That's an assumption on your part. And, incidentally, it happens to be totally false.
At this point, after a totally silly and highly uninformed statement like that, tradition dictates that we get into a angry yelling match, and leave the topic and instead engage in personal attacks. But I've been there, done that-- and now find it boring. So instead I'll be civil, and ask a key question: on what are you basing that assumption (the assumption that peace is possible now?).
I am never going to change your mind and you're never going to change mine.
Impasse.
Wrong again!
In order to have peace, both sides have to agree to it-- and both sides have to make some compromises (give up on some of their demands). At this point no side is willing to do that).
Israel didn't start building settlements until 1967. They built them in Gaza, occupied Egyptian Sinai, the West Bank, and the Golan.
Although they are often mentioned as a "permanent obstaclse to peace", Israel's occupation of Gaza ended in 2005-- and these so-called obstacles to peace no longer exist. Israeli settlements in Egypt no longer exist.
In the west Bank, even though they've been building them since 1967, they still only occupy something like 2% of the land!
However, even if they keep building them, that doesn't stop a peace process from being stopped by them-- look what happened in Gaza and Egypt.
(The Golan had never been claimed by "Palestinians"-- it was formerly part of Syria.)
It doesn't have to be "put" on hold. It already is on hold-- and has been since '48.
I called an Impasse, which means the subject is closed concerning any of my or your posts on this subject. So I'll thank you to stop violating the CoC by commenting on my posts.
Impasse.
LOL!
Yes, the "only" people stopping it are:
A: The people currently governing Israel.
B. The people currently governing one of two parts of Palestine... (and I'm not entirely sure about Abbas).
A rather far out assumption-- what makes you say that?
Obviously you are not aware of how Hamas came to power-- they were elected. (And BTW it was a fair election-- the place was swarming with International Observers). The "Palestinians" freely voted-- and Hamas come out #!!
I called an Impasse, which means the subject is closed concerning any of my or your posts on this subject. So I'll thank you to stop violating the CoC by commenting on my posts.
Impasse.
Are you aware of the fact that that by typing that last sentence, you just contradicted what you've been saying all along? (That peace is possible...now..)
Oh-- this is soooo sad!
Two very dear old friends feeling the need to part ways-- it brings tears to my eyes!
And hopefully failing...
FWIW, I am really enjoying this-- its better than those soap operas they used to run on daytime TV. Remember General Hospital-- now there was a show! (They don't make 'em like they used to!). And whatever happened to "Jersey Shore"-- did they take that off the air-- a pity!
Now all we've got on TV are show like "The Real Housewives of _________".
Sometimes I think we should change the name of this site to (tada!):
I don't give a flying fuck how it makes you feel. Your opinion is meaningless.
Woe is me, such a loss. I don't know how I'll survive.
MM,
I see no evidence to support this affirmation. Hamas was democratically elected... and then never again held any elections. (Arab democracy: "One man, one vote... one time!) Hamas now holds Gaza under police-state conditions.
MM,
How? Hamas clearly does not want peace... and I'm not sure that Bibi wouldn't scuttle it too, to maintain power in Israel.
How can we get peace if one side -- perhaps both -- doesn't want it?
How? Hamas clearly does not want peace... and I'm not sure that Bibi wouldn't scuttle it too, to maintain power in Israel.
How can we get peace if one side -- perhaps both -- doesn't want it? Because if we give the Palestinians a chance at a real country of their own, their support for Hamas will fade away and so will Hamas.
It's all academic now anyway. It looks like Bibi is going to maintain enough power to keep up the war he has grown to love so much that one wouldn't wonder if it's become a sexual thrill for him. He has said there will be no Palestine, so there will be more war, with the Palestinians and eventually with the Iranians.
I say let the Israelis fight those wars themselves. If they have elected him again, then they have shown they want blood and death instead of peace, so let them have all of it they want. Just so we stay out of it. Bibi is not an ally of America and as long as he is PM, neither is Israel.
What is the definition of "Palestinian"?
A member of a group of people Bibi will have exterminated...one way or another.
Or try to. Israel is no longer America's ally. They are now a state sponsor of terror against Palestinians. Bibi said no Palestine. That leaves him the only option of killing them all since they will fight for a homeland even harder now that the know they can't get one without a lot of bloodshed, instead of at a negotiation. Bibi's re-election and his vow of no Palestine means a lot more bloodshed in Israel in the form of terrorist attacks...and I can't say I blame them. One man's terrorist, is another man's freedom fighter and fighting against Bibi makes you a freedom fighter in my book. After all, Israel was formed by Israeli terrorists.
You've made it clear with your posts that you are not just anti-Bibi and anti-Likud, but that you are almost violently anti-Israel. So why don't you go there and work with the Palestinians to improve their lot instead of just being an arm-chair critic?
That's a pretty heavy word...
Israel has controlled Judea / Samaria for nearly fifty years. If Israel's intent has been "extermination"... they have been singularly incompetent.
MM... overblown vocabulary can make a person lose touch with reality. I think this is your situation, here. May I suggest that instead of starting with words like "exterminate", you take a step back and examine actual events.
Words like this one simply are not credible, and anyone who uses is is not credible, either. I don't think you want to undermine your own credibility.
Maybe it's because vermin thinks in terms of survival or extermination. It's interesting that those who are pro-Israel have been criticized for being hysterical, whereas you can see here a prime example of hysteria.
Buzz, PLEASE!
Bibi has declared that there will be no Palestine. In doing so he has invited terrorism in waves not seen in generations back to Israel. What do you think he's going to do with the Palestinians when that terrorism comes? He's going to have them killed as "helpers" of terrorism. The terrorism he has returned the area! HIM! BIBI! Every death, every drop of blood split, in Israel from Palestinian terrorists, is now blood on HIS hands, not the Palestinians! HE is the one who called down hell on Israel! The PA was willing to negotiate a two state solution and so was the UN and US, but Bibi has decided he'd rather have more war and terrorism. Well I hope that's exactly what he gets! No Palestine? NO PEACE! And he knows it.
I see no evidence to support this affirmation. Hamas was democratically elected... and then never again held any elections. (Arab democracy: "One man, one vote... one time!) Hamas now holds Gaza under police-state conditions.
The operative word is WAS. Yes, Hamas WAS democratically elected, but have now long since taken over as a terrorist dictatorship. When was the last time you heard of them allowing an election in Gaza? NEVER! Because they have seized power. AND that power can be taken back if there is a Palestine for the people of Gaza to either go to or to have the PA come and help there as there will be no more support for Hamas. Why would the people support them once the goal has been achieved? That would make no sense.
Oh? The destruction of Israel is written into the Hamas Charter. Does that justify Israeli attacks on Gaza?
I have just had my eyes opened by wayfarer and I'll be forever grateful. I have just learned that I don't give a shit about either side, that they're way over on the other side of the world and that I hope the blow each other the fuck up! The world would be a better place with all of 'em gone! Have at it! Go ahead and kill each other and I'll laugh all about it on the news, because it doesn't mean shit to me anymore!
Ever watch the movie "On the Beach". Seems only the Beatles had the answer:
"We all live in a yellow submarine"
Once again you show your lack of knowledge about the area.
In ISrael, (unlike in most of the Arab world) Arabs have the right to vote. Arabs comprise 20% of the Israeli population, but they haven't used that power. Why?
1. Their turnout has been very low.
2. They aren't unified-- they disagree with each other.
Well, in the past election that changed to a large degree-- their was a really big turnut, and they decided to vote for a unified Arab list.
The picture you attempt to paint shows your ignorance. Here's what happened:
LINK
More:
So it doesn't exactly look to me like the Palestinian leadership is inciting the population to commit violent jihad against Israel! (Its seems obvious that they know that the best thing to do to benefit their constituents is to work for change-- from within the system).