╌>

What speech is going to justify expulsion next?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  71 comments

What speech is going to justify expulsion next?

Oklahoma University President David Boren has expelled two students for leading a racist chant. These students speech was indeed quite repugnant, but for reasons I discuss here , its protected by the First Amendment.

And heres one reason why. Consider the presidents statement to the students : You will be expelled because of your leadership role in leading a racist and exclusionary chant which has created a hostile educational environment for others. Similar things could be said about a vast range of other speech.

Students talking to each other about a student group event about how Hamas has it right? (The Charter of Hamas, recall, expressly says, The Prophet, Allah bless him and grant him salvation, has said: The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, (evidently a certain kind of tree) would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews. (related by al-Bukhari and Moslem).) Why, that could be labeled leading an anti-Semitic and exclusionary discussion that, once its publicized on campus, creates a hostile educational environment for Jews.

Black students talking to each other about how all whites are racist, and white cops and maybe other whites should get shot? Again, that could be labeled racist and exclusionary speech that, when publicized, can create a hostile educational environment for whites.

Students talking about what a horrible, oppressive religion Islam is, or Scientology is, or Catholicism is, or conservative Christianity is, and how no-one should associate with people who have such evil religious views? Could be called religiously bigoted and exclusionary discussion that, when publicized, can create a hostile educational environment for members of that group. To be sure, this hypothetical doesnt include discussion of violence but president Boren seems to think that even this isnt required for expulsion, so long as the speech is bigoted and exclusionary. And the rhetoric of hostile educational environment, when it has been used to try to restrict speech on campuses, has never been limited to speech that mentions violence.

Likewise, students talking about homosexuality is evil, and homosexuals shouldnt get equal treatment? Could be called bigotry based on sexual orientation and exclusionary statements that, when publicized, can create a hostile educational environment for gays. Students talking about how women are inferior to men, or men are inferior to women same thing.

And I take it that open membership in groups including off-campus groups that espouse actually or allegedly racist, religiously bigoted, antigay, sexist, etc. views would be covered as well. Surely a students membership in the KKK, if other students learn about it, will lead them to infer that the student is racist just as much (if not more than) the singing of a racist song would. Likewise, a students membership in a group that endorses the Hamas Charter, a religious organization that harshly criticizes homosexuality, an organization that believes whites are inferior or morally corrupt, and so on.

There is, as Ive mentioned before, no First Amendment exception for supposed hate speech. But if there is such an exception, there certainly is no First Amendment foundation for distinguishing speech that is actually or supposedly anti-black from speech that is anti-white, anti-Semitic, anti-Muslim, anti-Catholic, anti-women, or anti-men. If the Oklahoma University presidents position is accepted as legally sound, then thered be no legal basis for protecting the other kinds of speech while expelling students for this sort of speech.

And what I call censorship envy will make it all the more likely that there will indeed be calls for expelling students who express those other views. Right now, for instance, Jewish students who have deal with their classmates holding anti-Semitic views, and expressing them to each other, may rightly assume that such speech is protected by the First Amendment and the university cant expel the anti-Semites. But if it becomes accepted that a university can expel people who express racist views about blacks, why wouldnt many Jewish students call for expulsion of students who express (even just to each other) anti-Semitic views? Indeed, many students might think that they would be chumps for failing to demand such expulsion, after theyve been taught that such speech victimizes them by creating a hostile educational environment that can be remedied by expelling bigoted students. And thats just one example.

Moreover, this surely wouldnt be limited just to people who use epithets president Borens statement speaks generally of the viewpoint of the speech (racist and exclusionary) and not just the particular words that were used. Nor would it be limited to things that really are contemptible; as weve all seen in past years, hate speech and hostile educational environment is a label that is cheerfully thrown around, to refer to criticisms of illegal immigration, to people deliberately trampling the Hamas flag, and much more. To quote Justice Jackson in West Va. Bd. of Education v. Barnette (1943), First Amendment law is designed to avoid these ends by avoiding these beginnings.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/03/10/what-speech-is-going-to-justify-expulsion-next/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I know it asks a lot for you to actually think through your knee jerk hostility to the First Amendment. Probably too much. I guess exposing you to the thoughts of one of the preeminent First Amendment Scholars in the country got you all riled up.

Go back to reading "Lawyers, Dogs and Haircuts" or whatever cut rate blog it is that informs your legal "views." Its nice and safe and its "analysis" consisting of "progressive policy=constitutional, everything progressives don't like=unconstitutional," is nice and easy.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Interesting article. Just a quickcomment, if he believes that free speech is being revoked on some, it would be a great idea to prove it. He, or anyone could walk up to a black and call him nigger. If you feel thatevery utterance is governed by free speech, than you should actually test the subject.

I would certainly like to know the results of the encounter.

Next, we could work on, wetback, wop, donkey, redskin, gook, chink, hunky, kike,or any number ofvulgar words regarding a persons race.

Anyone willing to give it a try?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Free speech can result in getting punched in the face by a citizen, which is fine.

When the government punishes you for speech, it is not.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

John,

When you started calling blacks Uncle Toms, you lost all right to even suggest other people are racist. Please deal with your own serious issues on the subject first.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Sean, are you willing to try out your 1st amendment rights with any person I listed above?

The government did not punish the students, the University did. But, that is beside the point really. Ignorant, racist comments have a select place of their own.

One can hide behind the free speech mantra, when they know damn well it's a bullshit defense when insulting another person due to their race. Or they can live free speech, and go about making their feeling well known to the person listed above.

It's their choice, and most choose to be silent and not get their ass kicked.

Using my free speech rights, I would call them cowards and liars.

What the government is doing, is saving the idiots from themselves.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

willing to try out your 1st amendment rights with any person I listed above?

What person did you list and why would I want to?

The government did not punish the students, the University did.

The State University is the very embodiment of the State. It is a governmental institution and citizens are protected from its actions by the First Amendment.

The first amendment doesn't protect you from a punch in the face, it protects you from the government punishing you from speech. No one hides behind the First Amendment to save themselves an ass-kicking. Paper doesn't stop punches very well.

Using my free speech rights, I would call them cowards and liars.


And you should have that right. But according to the University of Oklahoma, you could be kicked out of school for doing that..Calling someone a coward creates a hostile learning environment for cowards.

What the government is doing, is saving the idiots from themselves.

What the government is doing is punishing someone for the content of their speech. Its the idiots who are "threatening" to others, remember.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Even public universities have a code of ethics that their students must adhere to and that chant was questionable by any standard. When you suggest that a group of people are better hanging from a tree you have just gone into hate speech.

In my article I covered two different kinds of discrimination, this one being one of them. But the biggest lesson from this is that we should all be held responsible for what comes out of our mouths.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

from this is that we should all be held responsible for what comes out of our mouths.

As long as you get to decide what hate speech is, I'm sure you are fine with it. Most people are perfectly comfortable telling others what is permissible speech and what isn't. The whole point of the FirstAmendmentis to protect unpopular speech.

ave a code of ethics that their students must adhere to


I'm also pretty sure public universities can't require you to waive your constitutional rights as a condition of admission.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Free speech, as long as it doesn't infringe on the rights of others, seems to ring a bell.

I doubt if I would get kicked out of school for calling someone/group cowards Sean. I'm sure that you know that as well as I do.

You also know that I wasn't referring to actually hiding behind a piece of paper, but the amendments wording.

Sean, are you saying that the students should not have been banned/punished, because of their hatefulspeech?

Not only did they use the word nigger, but suggested that they were better ''hanging from a tree''...Sounds like hate speech. Suggesting that someone be hanging from a tree (with the images KKK and their reign of terror) is beyond the pale.

BTW, these are the folks I was referring to. I'm sure you knew that as well. ''Next, we could work on, wetback, wop, donkey, redskin, gook, chink, hunky, kike,or any number ofvulgar words regarding a persons race.''

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Was the speech they used disgusting, degrading and reprehensible? Yes.

Did it violate any laws? Not that I am aware of.

Did it violate any university rules? I am unsure if university rules were broken or not, but it does seem a bit of a stretch to call the activities on a bus, where presumably the only participants were members of the fraternity, ascreating 'a "hostile environment" for students and the university community.' If, however, it is shown that theracismand bigotry shown in the video is pervasive across other activities and is endemic culturally to the frat, then I believe that the university president is well within his authority given in the school and fraternity charters to discipline the fraternity. That standard has not, to my knowledge, yet been shown to be true. One could hope that it is not endemic to the fraternity, but given the attitudes of the participants, I think that hope is slim.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

l ong as it doesn't infringe on the rights of others, seems to ring a bell.

What actual right of others is being infringed on? Hate speech is not an exception to the first amendment. There is no right to not be offended.

Y ou also know that I wasn't referring to actually hiding behind a piece of paper, but the amendments wording.


No one hides behind the First Amendment as protection fromphysicalretribution. I guess don't know what you mean.

S ean, are you saying that the students should not have been banned/punished, because of their hatefulspeech?


They certainly shouldn't be expelled. It's illegal and the government should not actillegally. That's one of beliefs.

Or do you think its okay for thegovernmenttoactillegallyin favor of thingsyousupport?

To quote Professor Volokh:

1. First, racist speech is constitutionally protected, just as is expression of other contemptible ideas; and universities may not discipline students based on their speech. That has been the unanimous view of courts that have considered campus speech codes and other campus speech restrictions see here for some citations. The same, of course, is true for fraternity speech, racist or otherwise; see Iota Xi Chapter of Sigma Chi Fraternity v. George Mason University (4th Cir. 1993) .

Likewise, speech doesnt lose its constitutional protection just because it refers to violence You can hang him from a tree, the capitalists will be the first ones up against the wall when the revolution comes, by any means necessary with pictures of guns, apostates from Islam should be killed.

.Sounds like hate speech

Hate speech is not illegal.

' TW, these are the folks I was referring to. I'm sure you knew that as well. ''Next, we could work on, wetback, wop, donkey, redskin, gook, chink, hunky, kike,or any number ofvulgar words regarding a persons race.'' ''

.Do you believe someethnicitiescan automatically beat up others orsomething. I don't get your point.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
The national fraternity already justifiably closed the local chapter, so the president can't do anything to it at this point.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
And you ignore the Constitution.Naturally.
 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

As a fraternity, maybe not, but the individuals on the bus were or are members of the student body, and as such, the university still has jurisdiction over the fraternity members. Further, the university has jurisdiction over the fraternity because the fraternity exists by charter with the school. If they were hoping to avoid litigation by closing down the local chapter, they are foolish. Closing the barn door after your sooners have gotten out still does not put the sooners back in the barn.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

When you join any organization, you agree to abide by the rules and covenants of that organization, and grant the organization certain authorities over you, in effect ceding some of your rights to the organization.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

ut the individuals on the bus were or are members of the student body


The University can investigate the students and discipline any of them who engaged in actual acts of discrimination, such as members of a membership committee who denied membership to someone because of their race. But they may or may not be the same people who were pictured in the video.

If they were hoping to avoid litigation by closing down the local chapter, they are foolish


I doubt the national fraternity faces any liability. They areseparatelegalentitiesand covertheirasses to protectthemselvesfrom thestupidityof local chapters. Plus, I'm not sure what legalliabilityexists from the singing an offensive song. I can't think of anyone who would have a valid cause of action.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

You can't cede your First Amendment rights to a University. Its called the Unconstitutional Conditions doctrine.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

I didn't say hate speech was illegal. I said it sounds like hate speech.

Actually what I believe is that the group that sang the racists song should be put in a room with a group of blacks, and than sing it.

For every action there is re-action Sean.

If you believe that I'm endorsing violence, that is your choice. I'm only stating what would probably happen if they chose to sing the song, while with a group of blacks.

I understand the 1st amendment fine Sean. If you choose to use the most vulgar terms to describe a person or group, you are within your legal rights. To expect them to standby and listen to the racist crap is a whole other scenario.

I believe that it's called ''fighting words''...Which is in the 1st amendment.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

I thought the point of the first amendment was to protect the citizens who air their grievances toward the government from said government reacting in a punitive manner.

I'm sure what the University president did was legal, he likely checked with the school's legal counsel before taking that action.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

As much as Sean and I disagree, there is a possible First Amendment issue here. But it must be understood that the First Amendment does not protect ALL speech.

Which types of speech are not protected by the First Amendment?

Although different scholars view unprotected speech in different ways, there are basically nine categories:

  • Obscenity
  • Fighting words
  • Defamation (includes libel, slander)
  • Child pornography
  • Perjury
  • Blackmail
  • Incitement to imminent lawless action
  • True threats
  • Solicitations to commit crimes

Some experts also would add treason, if committed verbally, to that list. Plagiarism of copyrighted material is also not protected.

And there is no law against being an ASSHOLE.

Good thing too; despite the anatomical ratio of 2:1, buttocks over anuses, it is nevertheless abundantly clear that he world has way more assholes than buttocks.

For the record, I disagree with the expulsion of the students in question; an institution of higher education might better use this event to educate rather than merely castigate and repudiate. Community service, the compulsory attendance at a series of historical lessons on the perpetration and effects of racism, ethnocentrism, genocide, sexism, etc., etc. -- this with a final exam on the series content plus community service make more sense to me.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Sean,

The University can investigate the students and discipline any of them who engaged in actual acts of discrimination, such as members of a membership committee who denied membership to someone because of their race.

Unless in the rules and charters of the school there exists a prohibition on offensive and threatening speech. As students, they are responsible to abide by these rules and can expect to be disciplined forbreachesof the same. Is this constitutional? That is up to the courts to decide, but in this particular instance, I would say that the students in question failed to uphold the university's standards and deserve to be expelled.

I doubt the national fraternity faces any liability.

Nor do I.

Most schools have a written standard of behavior for just such instances as this.

I went to the schools website and found this, Student Rights and Responsibilities Code . Contained within said document is this paragraph:

Direct Administrative Action In collaboration with the appropriate University official, the UVPSA or other appropriate administrative official vested with such authority, may immediately take Direct Administrative Action, which he/she deems necessary for the welfare or safety of the University Community; to maintain order on the campus and preserve the orderly functioning of the University; to stop or prevent interference in any manner with the public or private rights of others on University premises; to stop or prevent actions that threaten the health or safety of any person; or stop or prevent actions that destroy or damage property of the University, its students, faculty, staff, or guests.

Any student so affected may be entitled to a hearing as outlined in the Procedures, attached as Appendix A and available at:

Seems a pretty wide door to go through as far as disciplinary actions go.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

You can't cede your First Amendment rights to a University. Its called the Unconstitutional Conditions doctrine.

Did I say you could?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Sean,

Hate speech is defined by the FBI as incitement. They could have been disgusting and call blacks the N word, but they can't say that talking about hanging blacks.

I'm also pretty sure public universities can't require you to waive your constitutional rights as a condition of admission.

Not only can they, they do. Have twins in college and you have no idea how many kids were booted from school just for breaking the law. And in this I find irony. When we had the discussion about business who would not serve gays the conservative consensus was that it was a private company and so they were not bound to. Well that is the thing about institutions...they sometimes make you wave your constitutional rights to go there, and since it is your choice to do so then you can't complain when you get the boot.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

The national fraternity already justifiably closed the local chapter, so the president can't do anything to it at this point.

I just checked at my kid's school and they were also closed down there until spring 2016. There must be something fundamentally wrong with this Frat.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

I prefer racists actually expose themselves. It's the behind the scenes racism that bothers me. There will always be racists. Forcing them to hide their opinions is a mistake. Let them come out of the closet so you know who they are.

That's you. To some of the other students this might have been a very uncomfortable position to be in. There is a reason that someone posted this on Youtube, and I don't think it was just because they were stupid.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

Well that is the thing about institutions...they sometimes make you wave your constitutional rights to go there, and since it is your choice to do so then you can't complain when you get the boot.

Same thing with the military, people who sign up give up lots of constitutional rights. If new recruits were caught singing this song they'd have been booted immediately if not worse.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Yes. We are discussing the First Amendment and you said"in effect ceding some of your rights to the organization. " What other "rights" are you referencing.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Same thing with the military, people who sign up give up lots of constitutional rights.

Good point, Pat.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

All this hand wringing.

Ummmm.. John... the purpose of a discussion is to discuss. You don't want to, that's fine. But let the rest of us talk.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

ate speech is defined by the FBI as incitement.


Incitement and hate speech are two different things. Hate speech can be incitement, but not necessarily. The links above make that distinction pretty clear.

. Have twins in college and you have no idea how many kids were booted from school just for breaking the law.


Breaking the law is not protected by the First Amendment. Racist speech is protected by the First Amendment.

business who would not serve gays the conservative consensus was that it was a private company and so they were not bound to.


Businesses are not thegovernment and thus not subject to the First Amendment. I don't what point you are trying to make but that distinction is as old as the country.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

a me thing with the military, people who sign up give up lots of constitutional rights.

Themilitaryis the treateddifferentlythanpublicschools for obvious reasons:

While the members of the military are not excluded from the protection granted by the First Amendment, the different character of the military community and of the military mission requires a different application of those protections. The fundamental necessity for obedience, and the consequent necessity for imposition of discipline, may render permissible within the military that which would be constitutionally impermissible outside it Parker v. Levy, 417 U.S. 733, 758 (1974). This quote from the Court sums up what is known as the Doctrine of Military Necessity or the military-deference doctrine.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Unless in the rules and charters of the school there exists a prohibition on offensive and threatening speech.

Codes of conduct don't trump the First Amendment. I've pointed that doctrine out to you already. Any written standard of behavior that conflicts with the First Amendment is null and void. If you can find an actual authority that states otherwise I'd be very interested to see it.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

wants to preemptively discourage a lingering media circus. Get rid of the bad apples right off the bat and show everyone the situation is under control.


Iactuallyagree with this. This was a political decision rather than a legal one. The President had to dosomethingimmediately, and the risks of legal liability arecomparativelytiny and remote.

The reality is that it's unlikely that either student will dedicate the time andresources necessaryto win acourt case and reinstatement. It will take years to win with appeals and its just easier to go to a different school.

The likely result is that the students will threaten a lawsuit and theuniversitywill agree toreclassifytheirexpulsionas awithdrawalto allow the students totransferwithout theblemishofanexpulsionon their records.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Isn't learning how to handle an uncomfortable situation part of growing up? Colleges shouldn't be about protecting adults from uncomfortable situations.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Sean,

Legal facts speak for themselves:

4. Does the First Amendment apply to private companies and organizations?
No. The First Amendment applies to the government to protect individuals from government censorship. While the text of the First Amendment says Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, it means that no federal, state or local government official can infringe on your free-speech rights. A private company is not a government or state and therefore generally is not subject to the requirements of the First Amendment.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

College is suppose to provide a safe place to get an education. And while we can't protect out kids from everything (not should we), they should be able to go to school that would not sanction that kind of behavior. As I said earlier, this isn't about them using the N word, but about talking about hanging blacks, and that takes it to a whole new level.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

This isn't political. No public figure has spoken out about either this case or the one at UCLA. And making guesses at how it will go legally in the future for the student and the expulsions isn't the point.

But I am sure you realize that.

BTW schools expel kids all the time for breaking rules, like drinking on campus, or hazing, cheating. They will not be the first to have this done to them. And with a public case like this, these kids will probably have a very hard time finding a school who will accept them.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Exactly and a State University is a governmental body and therefore cannot infringe upon your First Amendment rights.

Expelling a student for speech is a clear violation the First Amendment.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Of course the expulsions were political or call it public relations whatever you are more comfortable with. It's a national story that reflects poorly on the University. The expulsions were done so rapidly to save face for the university. It's risk management for the university's reputation and the benefits to expelling the students immediately is worth some possible litigation costs down the road.

TW schools expel kids all the time for breaking rules, like drinking on campus, or hazing, cheating.

As well they might. None of those actions are protected by the first amendment. Speech is.

e kids will probably have a very hard time finding a school who will accept them.

That's why theyprobablywon't beofficiallyexpelled once the issue dies down. Since the explusion is legally indefensible, some sort of arrangement will be made that keeps them out of the school but doesn't list them as expelled.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Except there was hate speech.

Hate speech is, outside the law, speech that attacks a person or group on the basis of attributes such as gender, ethnic origin, religion, race, disability, or sexual orientation. [1] [2]

In law, hate speech is any speech, gesture or conduct, writing, or display which is forbidden because it may incite violence or prejudicial action against or by a protected individual or group, or because it disparages or intimidates a protected individual or group.

The moment they chanted about hanging blacks they crossed the line.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

It's not politically until it is and unless you can show me someone in politics who came out and said something, then it's a bad college event no different than a bad hazing.

And you talk about the 1st as if it has no limitations. It does, most often expressed as your rights end when they step on my toes, or screaming fire in a movie theater.

I think these boys just got a lesson they will never forget. I hope the same thing happens at UCLA, too.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

And you ignore the Constitution.

Would that be the constitution that the founders set up for the white ruling class?

Or the one where all men are created equal, and women, not so much?

Or some other interpretation that serves a racist or bigoted agenda?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
I'm not arguing that the first amendment has no limitations. A college can restrict you from holding a rally on the quad at 2:00 in the morning or walking into classrooms and screaming your political messages. Time and place restrictions are typically fine, content based restrictions are not.Banning speech because it's offensive is abhorrent to a free society. If only popular speech is permitted, free speech doesn't exist. The potential for abuse is too large.
 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Perrie, So they can chant about hanging you unless you are a protected individual or group? ... that doesn't sound right....

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Perrie,

First off, the Wikipedia article you cite is referring to "hate speech" globally, not specific to the US. Some countries have outlawed hate speech, the US is not one of them.To make it as simple as possible, there is no hate speech exception to the First Amendment. It's not a term used in first amendment law. What makes speech possibly unprotected is specific to the circumstances, the court doesn't ban speech on content alone no matter how " hateful"

The Supreme Court can't be any more clear on the subject, racist speech is protected speech, no matter how vile. Even burning an actual cross on a black family's lawn is protected. To lose that protection, there has to be an actual incitement to violence that is real.

If actually burning a cross is not incitement, there's no way a song can be considered incitement.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Brolly,

No they can't because that is considered harassment.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
You want to piss on the first amendment, go ahead. It plays right to type.
 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

This..you and I...is free speech. Hate is not speech by law and law is constitutional.

BTW-I do my pissing in the pissah! Thank you.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Let me be as clear as I possibly can:

The First Amendment protects speech, no matter how offensive, absent actual incitement to imminent violence.

The video makes clear that the song doesn't meet that standard. There was no danger of violence breaking out immediately on that bus from singing that song.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Sean, I've thought very carefully about my answer here, and must go with my first impression. Please bear with me. It may seem to be off topic, but it isn't.

To me, these students were fortunate to have behaved this way in Oklahoma City, rather than in KY. If they were in the same small town where I went to college, Murray State University, they would have been arrested, and faced the "hanging judge" who was once my friend, Bucky, at the Pike Lodge and is still my friend, but a tough judge.

They would have been in jail for awhile, and not only expelled from college, but the college would have likely sued them for a hate crime.

There are less than 0.9% African Americans in Calloway County, and Robert E. Lee still stands on the court square, facing Richmond, with his hand on his heart. When KY didn't secede from the US, this part of the state voted to secede from the state. Yet, even back in the dark ages, the university brooks no prejudicial treatment of minorities. There is such a thing as decorum, and these young men demonstrated none.

The idea that one should be able to say anything without consequences dies a horrible death in the little town of Murray. Had they been local boys, not only would they have been expelled from the university, the whole town would have shunned them. Their only chance to get beyond this would be to leave town.

I once went downtown to Leba and Rudie's for a hamburger without my white gloves, and was nearly kicked out of the sorority. And no, this was not 1950, this was 1974. There are certain bounds of behavior that civilized humans must meet, and the university sees it as their job to make sure all graduates are educated, no only in the arts, sciences, and humanities, but in proper civilized behavior. My school strives to be non-controversial and a place of learning-- it is also listed as the best bargain for the buck in the southeast US.

We had a streaker once, (do you remember streakers?), and, despite the fact that he harmed no one, and hurt no one's feelings, he was arrested for indecent exposure and placed in jail for 30 days. He used the defense of 1st amendment rights, and that didn't fly then, under a different judge, and wouldn't fly now.

So, I have no sympathy for those who were expelled, and only hope that they learned a valuable lesson. They should count themselves fortunate that they didn't face charges for public intoxication, threatening hate crimes, etc.

Behavior like this only blackens the name of a university, and you have to remember that this is in Oklahoma, which is sort of a tight ass state. I feel sure that the University of Oklahoma alums stand behind their president, and are taking down the displays of their diplomas in order to hide their origins until the controversy dies down.

Hope your evening is a good one! By the way, MSU has had only one loss this basketball season, so when they play at the SEC, please root for them! They likely won't make it far, but to get as far as they have come is a miracle! Take care!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

They would have been in jail for awhile


I don't doubt it. But eventually, at some point, those kids may have sought redress at a higher court and likely would have been victorious.

Please understand I'm not defending these kids. I'm sure they are worthy of whatever pejoratives you want to use.But I'm familiar with the Supreme Court interpretations of the First Amendment and that's what I'm trying to convey. The Court takes an extremely hostile view of content based restrictions. As I pointed out, burning an actual cross in a black family's lawn is protected speech. A song pales in comparison to that.

The government punishing someone for the content of their speech, no matter how offensive, is simply not acceptable to me. As numerous justices have noted over the centuries, once you start down that road you are really going down a slippery slope. Everyone will a different definition of what's offensive. Better a couple clowns get publicly embarrassed and remain in school than start down that road.

he whole town would have shunned them

That would be an appropriate response. People are free to respond to ugly speech as they fit, and shunning is perfectly legitimate. It's just not the role of the government to decide what is acceptable speech.

o when they play at the SEC, please root for them


I pretty much always root against the SEC, so I will be rooting for MSU especially if they end up playing Kentucky somewhere down the road.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

First, what would happen if one of those boys were so inspired to do something violent from that little chant, what and who would the fallout be on?

Second, it has come out that there has only been one black member of that frat, which is against the schools rules.

Third, I get that free speech is only as good as when we are offended, hence why the Westboro Baptist Church is allowed to do what they do. But being that the university has it's own rules, and gets both public and private funding, it does change the paradigm from somewhere between public and private.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Thanks, Dean. If the case went to a federal court, they may go free. All this is speculation, anyway...

Times have surely changed!

They may just play against UK-- Murray only has about 10,000 students, but it is a good school. They just don't have the depth that UK has-- so they would be very likely to lose. But, they are good kids, and I'm proud of their hard work! Thanks, so much!

Everyone always ask me if I'm a UK or UofL fan, and I always say, "I'm a Murray fan!" Keeps me out of a lot of trouble! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

David French explained it prettysuccinctlyin his" Congratulations, University of Oklahoma, In Your Outrage You Just Violated the Law" piece:

"Our public universities are becoming national leaders in trampling the Constitution to legislate their brand of inclusive morality. FIREs Robert Shibleygets the issue exactly right:

Censorship isnt necessary for those who are confident in the truth of their views. Its a signal of insecurity and displays a fear that if an idea is allowed to be expressed, people will find that idea too attractive to resist. Somehow, college administrators are convinced that if they dont officially punish racism, their students will be drawn to it like moths to a flame. But theres simply no reason to expect that. Given the history of campus activism in our nation from the civil rights movement onward, there are myriad reasons to expect the opposite.

Instead of government crackdowns on a viewpoint, it is far better to let the marketplace of ideas determine the social consequences for racist speech. In this instance, the OU members of SAE are not only likely to spend the rest of their college careers as pariahs but to be hounded to the ends of the earth on social media and exposed for posterity on Google."

Read more at: ...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Rugby Boy!!! How cute Barbie.

You do understand that I didn't say that I would hit anyone, but if your confronted with ''fighting words'' it does put a whole different take on it. But you of course, being all knowing, would understand that wouldn't you?

What is being discussed is racist rants, and if one is confronted with it. IMO, that would constitute ''fighting words''.Also being a person that has experienced racists rants and physical attacks, I'll stick with what I know works. You, of course, can stick with theory.

It's that old experience thing, Barbie Doll.

BTW, I play Lacrosse, not Rugby.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

What is being discussed is racist rants, and if one is confronted with it. IMO, that would constitute ''fighting words''

Absolutely and not protected under speech anymore then shouting fire in a crowded theater. Free speech has limits.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Sean, here is another viewpoint.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

irst, what would happen if one of those boys were so inspired to do something violent from that little chant, what and who would the fallout be on?


The inspired boy who did something violent would be liable.

t has come out that there has only been one black member of that frat, which is against the schools rules.


That's a totallydifferentsituation. Now you alleging an actualdiscriminatoryact, not speech, has taken place. As Professor Volokh stated:

"The university might thus be able to discipline students who (a) are involved in a fraternitys admissions decisions, and (b) can be shown to have denied membership to people based on race, or intentionally tried to communicate to potential members that they would deny them membership that way."

It comes down to whether the Frat isconsideredsmall and selectiveenough to be covered by a right to intimate association.

t being that the university has it's own rules, and gets both public and private funding, it does change the paradigm from somewhere between public and private

But it doesn't. It's easily verifiable with Google. A public university is bound by the First Amendment, end of story. There's no gray area on this question under American law. Its 2+2=4 clear.

Whether a university creates its own rules or not is really relevant when the First Amendment comes into play. The First Amendment always trumps a university harassment policy. There's plenty of federal cases making that point. A university simply cannot punish a student for violating a policy if that policy conflicts with the protections offered by the First Amendment.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

And it's not protected when it associated with the school, because it makes the entire university look bad. The school did the right thing and they did it right away. They were on top of the problem faster then I've ever seen a major university. Bravo the the school

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The article quotes three First Amendment experts who agree with me by name and one "anonymous"Oklahomalawyerwhodoesn'tbut can't make a legalargumentas to why. Defense lawyers don't sue the University, so its not surprising he would not want to touch this case. I like my company.

"The attorney said that public opinion in Norman was so overwhelmingly against the fraternity that he didn't think the fraternity students would risk a lawsuit to try to return to campus"

That's not a legal argument, its the exact argument I made that theexpulsionswere a public relations response.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Sean, here is another viewpoint.

Excellent video

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I disagree that OU is breaking the law

Okay, please cite some authority for that proposition. Simply claiming that OU's summary expulsion is legal given the amount of data contained in the links and discussion demonstrating the opposite makes unsupported opinions meaningless.

Students agree to a Code of Conduct upon enrolling at a university, and are given access to their Rights and Responsibilities.

Codes of Conduct don't trump theConstitution. There are plenty of legal cases out there that make thatexact point. In fact, when a college gets sued, itimmediatelyclaims that its Code in noway restricts student's first Amendment Rights. It's a fundamental tenant of American law that you can't give away your First Amendmentrights to the government (outside of joining themilitary).

ur freedom of speech is temporarily curbed on most campuses, for what I believe are obvious reasons.


No, its not. Again, the first thing a College will argue when they are sued is that its code complies with the First Amendment and only restricts speech that is restricted by the FirstAmendment.No college even bothers to try to make the argument that it has the power to limit speech in excess of the First Amendment. If you can point to an actual Courtdecisionstating thatUniversitycan engage in content basedrestrictionsabove and beyond whatothergovernmentagencies can, I'd love to see it.


If you want to believe it should be otherwise, that's fine. But the law is as clear on this as it on anything that the First Amendment applies to publicuniversities.Simply saying it doesn't really is meaningless. You can have your opinions, but the state of the law is the state of the law.

Racists are not a protected clas

No one has said they are. Citizens are a protected class.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

What has been lost is DECENCY. According to Dean Americans can say whatever they wish that is nasty, insulting, provocative, even vicious and they are protected by the First Amendment.

But whatever happened to decency? Whatever happened to polite behaviour? What kind of world would YOU like to live in?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Ooops! Sorry. You're right, I meant Sean.

I know the Constitution protects and defends your rights, but is it really necessary to exercise those rights unreasonably? As I said, what happened to decency?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

ol. Seriously? The authority is common sense,

Now that is LOL worthy, how could any American possibly expect common sense to play a role in our legal system? I can only assume you've been lucky enough to avoid any contact with it.

Work at Target,Go to a bible college

Yes, that's all true but the First Amendment only applies to government actions, not those by employers or private schools.

I'm not making this up. I know this is an appeal to authority, but consider it an appeal to every legal authority. The author of the article is one of the foremost First Amendment scholars in the country and the article is written in Washington Post's law blog, which is probably one of the least partisan news sources out there. This isn't a submission based upon the ramblings of some half assed lawyer with a partisan blog. The linked article contain links to a vast amount of legal support for his position. Kavika's link even cited an additional two nationally recognized experts supporting my position.

At the end of the day, do you think a first amendment expert whose spent his whole career exploring and litigating the First Amendment would not realize the OU had a code of conduct? Every school has a code of conduct its not a surprise or some sort of magic get out of jail card that would confound someone who litigates the First Amendment.

Honestly, I didn't submit a post detailing why OU's actions violate the First Amendment because the answer is so clear cut that I didn't think there would be any discussion pontential. The internally cited links are that clear cut. The implications of what could happen if the expulsions were legal seemed much more interesting and the Professor does a good job laying those out.

IF this were legal, it would appear that a jewish person could have someone expelled for reading the Hamas Charter in public under the same theory. Is that okay to you?

While I believe the court of human opinion will greatly curb their ambitions in the short term, these students would've resigned anyway


That's how these sort of things should be handled. You don't need the government to step in to discredit this type of speech.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
It seems simple to me. A public university cannot require you to forfeit your basic human rights. This way leads to madness.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
When has college supposed to have been a safe place in that context? Never. It is a place where you are supposed to be exposed to new ideas. The next generation will be our weakest yet.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Sean, I forgot to say thank you for your well-reasoned, reasonable response. I hope that you and I can always be "reasonable" together. I know my views may piss you off, but I respect your viewpoint.

Please forgive me that I called you Dean in the above posting. I knew it was you, and just typed the wrong name. It wasn't a case of mistaken identity, it was a case of my brain thinking one thing, and my fingers typing another.

Take care!

 
 

Who is online