Banning the American flag? Why UC Irvine flap might be glimpse of future.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/banning-the-american-flag-why-uc-irvine-flap-might-be-glimpse-of-future/ar-AA9wPL9
The controversial decision by the UC Irvine student body government to ban the American flag as well as all other flags speaks to broader generational shifts in views of patriotism. The decision has since been overturned.
A decision by the student body government of the University of California at Irvine to ban the display of all flags including the United States flag has been vetoed.
According to the Associated Press, the university's executive cabinet has voted to overturn the ban, which prompted outrage nationwide and led one state legislator to consider an amendment to the California constitution to ensure the American flag could be flown on the campuses of state schools.
On one hand, the now-vetoed decision to ban the American flag had the feel of student government run amok, as budding iconoclasts tried to make a statement about the moral complexities they're learning in History 101. Flags are "flown in instances of colonialism and imperialism" and they "serve as symbols of patriotism or weapons for nationalism," the statement explaining the original ban noted.
Yet the move, short-lived though it was, speaks to more than an only-in-California spasm of 20-something intellectual angst. More broadly, it points to a generational shift in the notion of what patriotism is.
Surveys by the Pew research Center suggest that Millennials are more wary than any other American generation of defining themselves by larger institutions. Half are political independents. Nearly 3 in 10 do not associate with any religion. And only 26 percent have married by the age of 32 10 percentage points less than Generation Xers at the same point in their lives and 22 points less than Baby Boomers.
That same trend holds true with Millennials' views of the United States itself.
By a host of indicators, Millennials are less "patriotic" than any other generation of Americans at least by the traditional gauges of patriotism. Various surveys have found that:
Just 32 percent of Millennials say US is "the greatest country in the world," compared with 48 percent of Gen Xers, 50 percent of Baby Boomers, and 64 percent of the Silent Generation, according to Pew. Likewise, Millennials are most likely to say America is not the greatest country in the world. Pew also found that 70 percent of Millennials agree with the statement "I am very patriotic," compared with 86 percent of Gen Xers, 91 percent of Boomers, and 90 percent of Silents. American National Election Study found that 45 percent of Millennials say the American identity is extremely important, compared with 60 percent for Generation Xers, 70 percent for Baby Boomers, and 78 percent for Silents. Only 67 percent of Millennials said flying the US flag made them feel very or extremely good, compared with 94 percent of Silents, according to ANES.
Research suggests that these opinions do not change with age but rather stay generally consistent as generations grow older. In other words, with every passing year, America's definition of what it means to be patriotic will likely evolve.

Has it gotten to the point that the "newbies" are just so into themselves that this is happening?
We gave them all they wanted so we wouldn't repeat the mistakes made in raising us. Why did we feel so obligated to raise worthless kids?
So the student government of UC-Irvine wants to ban the American flag from campus. No surprise there. This is the same place where the Muslim Student Union holds their annual Israel Apartheid Week on campus with pro-Hamas and pro-Hezbollah speakers preaching hate. Also, the same campus where 10 Muslim students were convicted of conspiracy to and disruption of a speech given by Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren in 2010. Here is another of the wonderful events sponsored at UC-Irvine:
Flying the American flag can be such a burden. The Federal government shouldn't burden UC Irvine with all that American money that supports the science, research and educational departments. They should be free and unburdened.
I read about this some where and it said the kids viewed the flag as a symbol of hate. ( not an exact quote) the same kids that accept government money to help with their education. Is this like the preacher who pay a hooker for sex on Saturday night then preaches about the evil of sins of the prostitute on Sunday morning?
Hey... What's wrong with skinny jeans and lack of muscle tone?
What - he didn't talk about the sins of money?
Flag of my country can't be raised on a college campus here? Sick and twisted.
We gave them all they wanted so we wouldn't repeat the mistakes made in raising us.
So did the parents of just about every counter culture Hippie.
Hey... What's wrong with skinny jeans and lack of muscle tone?
Yeah!!!!
It was over-ruled and the flag is there and the students learned a lesson about bucking to state school system. All is good all around.
I ran this by my son, who is 16, and he, too, was horrified. I don't know what his generations is called, (is he a millenial?). Anyway, he thought that it was crazy, too!
We can tiptoe around it but we know where it came from and we know why it was introduced.
There has been, in the last several years, a systematic tearing down of the idea of American patriotism. The very word "patriot" is said with a sneer, as if being one is a damn joke or something to be ashamed of. We have military personnel who go where the president and Congress point them; they fight and die and some come home, and all of them have to face the derision of a large portion of our citizens who tell them they only did it for the private business interests, the corporations, who control our government.
So the idea that our military fights for life, liberty and the pursuit of freedom has died a vicious death. Our flag is the symbol of everything wrong on the planet. Our own government has said we don't have a national language, we don't have a national culture, we don't have a national heritage, we don't have right to our own resources, we don't have a right to our country, we don't have a right to our national pride.
We own nothing, we are nothing, our veterans are discarded and deserve the least we are made to give them, they fought for nothing... everything in America belongs to everyone else. Not to the indigenous American Indians, mind you, but to anyone and everyone around the world.
So the American flag is an embarrassment that must not fly because it offends the Mexicans, the Muslims, the Haitians, the Sikhs, the Romulans, the Klingons and Dr. Who.
mimi - on Drudgereport, there is another article dealing with the illegal aliens being very, very upset that the University overrode the Student Union's decision. The illegal aliens want "THEIR" flag to fly, but not the American.
Ironic as hell. Calif gives then full support, financially, and they want the U. S. flag taken down.
In 2006, students at Montebello (CA) high school raised the Mexican flag above an inverted American flag. There is no law requiring anyone to be "patriotic", but to disrespect the flag of the country you immigrated to is beyond despicable.
To me, what's funny 'bout these illegal alien "children" posting the U. S. flag like that means that they are in distress and they need help.
This is also the school that in '09, the U. S. students wore T-shirts with the American flag on it and the illegal alien kids went on strike 'cause it "offended" them.
Supreme Court ruled that students cannot wear any clothing with American flag or any symbols of American patriotism on Mexican holiday... because it will upset the Mexican school students who may riot and create an atmosphere of danger on the school grounds.
Have you ever heard such bullshit? Can you believe such crap? And some people wonder at the animosity directed toward illegal aliens?
Go ahead an try it, CH4P. You will find that activists, the ACLU, community organizations, the DOJ, CAIR, the NAACP, and probably the current president of the US, will block your efforts.
Show me where I said they were okay, blue.
I don't believe that campaign symbols should be allowed at schools. I do believe that a shirt that says, "Veteran" should be allowed if that is all it says.
Don't put damn words in my mouth.
*Snort! (laugh)
blue - quit trying to antagonize. The topic has to do with students who are offended that the U. S. flag is flown on school grounds.
Apples and oranges.
Sorry if I misunderstood. No harm.
I do realize there are racist organizations that use "patriotism" as a by-word to press their agenda.
Awakening pride in America and in being an American would be a delicate tightrope walk between overt racism and true patriotic love of country and the values of what America stands for.
A large part of the problem is that everyone has their own idea of what patriotism actually is.
"My postwas about the general tone that this article had taken. " which is what I'm trying to "re-direct" back to the original tone.
Need some help, OK?
It would be interesting to see who the student body is comprised of. Exactly who are these people?
Just posted a seed that explains that.
96 - Irvine is a mixture - being just outside of Santa Anna, it houses a large contingency of Latino/a's, a decent percentage of Native Americans, and many high-tech companies.
Banning the American flag? Why UC Irvine flap might be glimpse of future.
Or not.