'Camouflaged' Aliens Inhabit the Earth
We've all been guilty of Agenda based seeding-- some more than others. All of us have beliefs that others don't agree with, messages we want to get out, or points of view that we wish to express.
At times, the agenda based seeding can alter the entire ethos of a web site. When all of us, who are fairly sensible people, are subjected to a constant "barrage of half-truths, twists of reality", and, quite plainly, seeds designed to elicit anger and disbelief-- tempers flare, and all of us feel, well, uncomfortable .
We find ourselves saying things we wouldn't normally say, defensive, frustrated, and angry. What's the point of coming here, if we don't enjoy it?
This is an example of Agenda Based Seeding:
University of California Scientists -- 'Camouflaged' Aliens Live Among Us
Scientists of the University of California came up with an unusual hypothesis suggesting that space aliens have long settled on Earth and lived among us as observers.
Of course, there is no evidence of this, but according to ancient sources, including the Bible, our planet has been visited by representatives of extraterrestrial civilizations since its inception.
In 2000 scientists of the University of California, led by Professor Jonathan Malkisom, held a press conference, during which the sensational news that representatives of extraterrestrial civilizations have long been among humans was reported. They adopted human appearance and closely monitor our every move.
Link: http://humansarefree.com/2014/07/university-of-california-scientists.html
Very likely, few of us truly believe that camouflaged aliens live among us, spy on us, or make plans to conquer the earth so they can eat us. While a great premise for a Sci/Fi movie, in real life most of us realize, nah, not so much a REAL problem. But there are those who would see this nonsense and behave as if they believe it. There are those of us who would expound upon this, and use it to rile up others. There are those of us who feel that if they constantly harangue others with their viewpoint, they will actually convert of few of the non-believers into believers...
Tongue in cheek-- 'Scientists' have named this an an internet personality disorder . It is called, "Internet Asperger's Syndrome", and is characterized by the utter loss of awareness of social rules and empathy that seems to happen to some people who communicate solely via the keyboard and their computer.
In real life, it is called "Asperger's Syndrome". While rarely diagnosed, it is a real problem for some-- a very real disorder on the autism spectrum. However, there are many that show this "personality disorder" that are basically just a$$hats. Trolls, if you will. Provide a troll with an audience and they have reached their objective. Since they lose the understanding of social mores and empathy, they ARE the 'camouflaged aliens'.
There are those who will do anything, as long as there isn't a rule against it. To stop this behavior, it requires the writing of rules that keep a web site functional-- simply because one or two people continually violate the social mores of a web site, all because there isn't a RULE, per se, that prohibits their behavior. The trouble is that a moderator can't ban them from a site, because they haven't violated a rule-- although their behavior helps to make the site an unpleasant place to be.
While most of us don't need "rules" to behave properly, and relish civil discussion and debate-- there are the 'camouflaged aliens', aka "Trolls", to deal with. To stop this behavior, the only answer, without writing specific rules designed to stifle free speech, etc., is to ignore them.
Do Not Feed The 'Camouflaged Alien'.
Take away their audience, and they will disappear. They will make ever more ridiculous and outrageous claims-- but if no one responds, they will go away of their own free will.
The best sure-fire way to destroy a viable website is to make an ever increasing burden of rules, that are applied broadly-- when all the site wants is peace to grow, a place where everyone has an opinion and is allowed to express it respectfully, a place to get informed and discuss the issues of today. We lose site of our NORMAL, REALISTIC goal-- to discuss and express-- if one or two of us dominate the front page with nonsense.
I invite you to join me-- in not feeding the 'Camouflaged Aliens', who only want attention, and will use any outrageous means at their disposal to get it-- all because there isn't a rule against it. I know it will be very difficult for many of us-- we see something so outrageous and we feel that we MUST correct the record. However, the only way to stop this behavior is to ignore it-- completely, and totally.
This is just my opinion, as a member of the site. I want NT to grow and continue to be a healthy, viable site, where all of us participate and none of us feel uncomfortable about participating.
Thank you for coming by!
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen:
We have discussed this to death, and I think we've all gotten an idea of what we need to do-- either way. I am, therefore, closing this article to further comment. If you wish to contact me via email, please feel free to do so!
Thank you, for your participation!
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

Good article.
I wish you (and Perrie) good luck. But I am skeptical. There are more members interested in carpet-bombing the Front Page than are interested in serious conversation.
A microcosm of America.
Bob,
Let's try to be more positive. And while I agree that there are few who are interested in serious conversation... I take BF at his word.
When I observe the Front page, I am tempted to seed five articles every day, from AlterNet, as a response to C4P's crap. But the problem is that I actually like NT. Carpet-bombing like C4P would be harmful.
It's a quandary. The vandals are more interested in doing their thing than in preserving NT. Must those of us who despise the vandals "destroy NT in order to save it"?
When an individual gives his word on-the-record so-to-speak I believe that individual should be taken at his word until and unless at some future time, that word is violated.
"To err is human, to forgive , etc. ."
((((((Dower))))
Outstanding article as usual. Your thoughts and the written skills to convey them are excellent.
Can everyone just get along? The answer is NO. One person's vision of peace on Earth is another's vision of Hell on Earth. The best that we can possibly achieve is balance and a respect for reasonable boundaries.
I have recently left my comfort zone of listening to country music and made myself listen to what is popular with today's youth -- Taylor Swift, Ariana Grande, Pharrell Williams, etc. I am enjoying their music and vitality, but I have major doubts that we could have conversations that would be meaningful to either of us.
Outside of the internet, we have people that we enjoy interacting with and people that we avoid as much as possible and even some that we openly snub. How can we do otherwise on the internet?
Even like-minded people will find areas where they disagree. It is how people settle their disagreements that is the most important concern. Recognize your own and your opponent's objective and decide if you are going to honor your own objective or your opponent's objective. That will be a major factor on what the outcome will be.
Hope all is well with you and yours, my dearest Dowser. I have cabin fever and am looking forward to tackling the necessary landscaping, gardening, painting and building projects that did not get accomplished last year.
Perrie,
I took bf at his word. I am quite ready to believe he cares about NT. And that caring brings worry.
I doubt, though, that all members care. Some are here to "spread the word". Paid or not.
Yes.
A Mac has so much to teach all of us... All of us could learn so much of value from him-- I do, every day.
I think that what A. Mac is saying, is more that the lack of responses, lets the good articles fall off the board, while the more strident articles thrive... Perhaps.
I don't want to put words in anyone's mouth!
Thanks! I'm glad you understand that it is sometimes difficult to read these articles that make me physically sick to my stomach...
It has been quieter around here lately, except for one outlandish explosion, and it has been an enjoyable experience overall.
Not so much from conscience but from a meta article which expressed overall the dissatisfaction of much more than half the members to such behaviors and the arrival of a bigger stick which accentuates the members desires for more civil interactions.
And Numerous efforts of members to bring content that adds to the site and expands it's reach over the medium rather than that which "pidgeon" holes it. (intentional misspelling)
Kudos to everyone.
But especially to you dear Dowser, for I have never heard it expressed in such clarity, the way it SHOULD be, the way we strive for it to be.
thank you.
Do unto others, the way you wish them to do you.
Yes, it is. We have lost a few of our members lately, that our site needs! Looking through my friends list-- so many just aren't around anymore...
We can fix this!
Very likely! But, could you try it for a week? Or even a few days?
I know how hard it will be for you!
We don't name names, because it is a violation of the CoC... This article was not aimed at you, I assure you!
Me, too! Let's all behave and make her job a little less difficult!
I know... I can't come up with 5 articles a day that are worth reading. Unless it would be in geology, and no one cares about that!
But it sure is a quandary, as you say...
Yes. I take bf at his word, too!
He is a very intelligent fish, you know!
LMAO! I think one very good example of the trolls she speaks of would be someone who seeds 15 or so ridiculous OPINION articles on Libertarians for the sole purpose of trying to get under peoples skin.
((((((((((mocowgirl))))))))))))
I love you, very much!
I don't think that anyone wants NT to be an echo chamber, and we all certainly want to be free to express ourselves. I hope that we can discontinue to "carpet bombing", as Bob so aptly described it...
I love you-- my hands have been swollen for a few months, and I can't get my rings off! Other than that, I'm suffering from cabin fever, too! Let's go to the Bahamas for a few days... Can't we?
Much love, dear friend--
Golly! Thanks!
You know that I'm just a old geologist, achy of bone and the viewpoint of weird... I don't want to lose more members-- people I love and enjoy interacting with.
I know you left for a while, and have returned, I'm glad to say! Please, don't leave again.
I have found the majority heated fights to be nothing more than echo chambers.
I will try to give an example that many here can relate to.
The old Newsvine format is a great example of echo chambers. An author wrote/seeded biased material. People chose up sides and throw the same stones back and forth until someone with supreme authority wades in and declares the winner and loser. Then more fights ensure about the supreme authority. Then rinse and repeat endlessly.
There are a few Viners left hanging around griping about not being paid to be on the Vine. Of course, as with most people who start wars for their own monetary gain, the premise is that the Vine is an echo chamber with unfair moderation. This amuses and disheartens me that anyone would buy what they are selling.
I am not enough of a masochist to ever put up with that kind of utter worthless crap in my life again regardless of where I find it.
I really wish you all well with stemming the division on News Talkers before the malcontents make your site as unenjoyable to visit like a handful of mercenary members are attempting to do on Newsvine.
I pretty much can't go anywhere I can't drive because I have a fear of heights.
Mike, I think of you as a really sensible sort of person. We don't always agree- but I have never seen you post anything I would think of as "crazy". But we're not really talking about that-- we're talking about Carpet Bombing, flooding the site with articles that present only one point of view.
I could post all kinds of crazy stuff... We all can-- the point is, we don't. I guess, what I'm trying to say is that while all of us don't agree with one another-- we can just ignore those articles that are designed to stir up problems. Let's put it this way-- if we don't voluntarily agree to tone it down, the majority of the membership may just vote to tone it down via rules at the next CoC discussion. And no one wants a lot of rules... Least of all, the mods!
You and I probably have about 10 things in common-- and yet, I love you and treasure you as my friend. I respect your opinion, and know that, for the good of the site, you don't post "crazy". Your voice is needed, wanted, and respected. For the good of the site, as a whole, you wouldn't do your best to destroy it. That's just not you!
So, what do we do about those that don't give a hoot about the site, and only wish to destroy? The only thing I can think of is to ignore them... Their articles will fall off the board, and we can all go back to our normal nastiness, not our supercharged nastiness...
Thanks for your perspective!
I believe that RW says the same thing, because it keeps happening-- not because she is a broken record. Again, you can always choose to not engage her.
I don't blame you!
Well, this is likely dust in the wind, but all I can do is try... Don't worry!
Oops, that does mean we'll have to fly. And I don't do that anymore, either. How about driving down to Corpus Christi and enjoying a little Americana?
No apology necessary, RW. A sincere impassioned plea is sometimes the most effective way of making a point (shoulda' seen me when I was defending workers or attacking management in arbitration hearings).
And when I was a newspaper editor, I wrote the editorials.
Anyway, I'm about to put up a second article since Dowser posted hers one in the Photography tab, and, the other momentarily in the Creative Arts Group.
How about driving down to Corpus Christi and enjoying a little Americana?
That would be fun except I am saving my pennies to have extensive dental work done this spring. I would joyfully put this off, but it is because I have neglected having basic work done that I am having to pay for extensive work. Yuck and double yuck.
I fear dentists less than heights and red wasps, but I still have to convince myself that it is necessary torture.
I've been tempted at times to send my dear husband off too...
Oh no!
It is all I can do these days to make myself go get a hair cut. Much less dental work! You will be in my prayers that all goes well!
Mine is into the statistics of ammo. Trajectory, drop rate, and on and on and on... But that's ok, I guess. I probably drive him nuts about rocks.
We must all work together, to keep the site viable!
My policy has always been to ignore trolls. I've learned how to spot a genuine discussion vs. a trolling for a knock-down-drag-out battle, and I ignore the latter. Some people seem to think that whoever gets the last word is the winner. I have news for them: all too often, the last word is the one that blows the speaker out of the picture altogether. The last word often reveals - unmasks - the troll and exposes it for all to see, and to avoid. As soon as I realize I'm being baited, I shut down and that will be the last you will see of me on that article. The troll may think he's won, by having "the last word," but actually he's the biggest loser on the forum, because now he has nowhere to hide. He's center-stage, and naked as a jaybird. And the audience is laughing their asses off!
The internet is a huge place. Why should someone stick around Trollville when there are countless other sites where an honest discussion is taking place? There is plenty to read, plenty to learn, and plenty of it from decent, balanced writers who are sharing something, not pounding bile into the mindless heads of fellow trolls. Time is a precious commodity. I choose to spend it on quality. There are groups on NT that are extremely friendly, where trolls are not allowed, and where honest discussions take place. I rarely have as much time to spend there as I would like, but when I have the time, that is where I will spend it. I don't care if it is Front Page material or not. I do care about the people I spend my time with, and what page they are on is irrelevant. The important thing is that they are on the site.
Thanks for an enlightened article, Dowsey. However, I daresay that non-troll Aliens might appreciate an apology...
{{{{{Dowsey}}}}}
Dear Non-troll Aliens of Another Planet: My sincere apologies for not believing in your existence, but then, again, that is your purpose, isn't it? The very best of luck to you in the future! May you long be hidden!
sincerely,
Dowser
Note to bitey-- I don't blame you!
It might work but some people seem to thrive on conflict whether it is actively causing it and/ or engaging in it or just passively viewing it. And when the focus is on "me, me, me" instead of something that might be important or enjoyable to others, all of the people who thrive on drama are happy. This is one of the reasons that meta articles are the most popular and do the most damage.
If COH violations were addressed as they occur and then forgotten, it would probably be a real good thing.
However, even the most civil debate/discussion in the world is unlikely to sway a person from believing in whatever it is that they believe in if that belief makes them feel good about themselves. See a theme here? Many, even most, people feel that they are the be all / end all of human existence. This is probably because we are innately programmed to survive and even thrive.
I believe that the majority of humans are basically good people. That does not mean that my belief is correct. It is a belief that makes my life better because it allows me to do mundane things like leave my home and buy groceries without feeling I need an armed escort.
Try challenging your own belief systems in every way possible and see if it takes you out of your comfort level. If it does, then you have some idea of how the other person feels when you don't agree with him/her.
I challenge my own beliefs frequently and even sometimes change them over time. This is why I am comfortable with other people challenging them also.
I highly recommend watching "The Lottery of Birth". It is on Amazon Prime or Netflix or possibly both. Maybe on youtube (I haven't checked).
I'll look for it, mocowgirl! It sounds interesting!
Dowser,
My husband even enjoyed watching "The Lottery of Birth" or at least pretended to.
Thank you for a fabulous post!
I will confess the main reason I've never seeded an article is purely selfish on my part, not wanting to deal with ugly, dissenting view(s). Not thin skinned, but seeing the amount of commentary that is void of interest andcomments postedto inflame I question why would I subject myself to that behavior? I'm looking to learn why people support a particular issue. If one feels compelled to put up a thread, they should be able to articulate their own views and stop dropping hand grenades to see how the masses respond.
The wealth of knowledge is vast and varied on NT, I'm all for utilizing it to learn from each other. For me learning is not consensus but the ability to "hear" and determine if my personal view or opinion can or should be expanded.
Nope, dearest Mickey Mouse, I couldn't ignore you. I'm addicted to cute!
I'm sure the non-Troll Aliens, wherever they are, appreciate your apology. They exist, alright, but can you blame them for wanting to remain hidden? Heck, I'd hide if I could!
Sigh... I need to get some sleep. I get kinda looney when I get tired...
{{{{{Dowsey}}}}}
I am. However, that does not mean that I should be subjected to nasty comments by people who cannot or will not have a civil discussion on or off of the internet.
I noticed that NT has groups that allow people to have complete control of whom is allowed into that group. The site where I am most active is Newsvine and we have the exact same thing. There are many people having fits about it. They want the ability to troll everyone on Newsvine like they were allowed to do in the past. I am pleased to see that NT developed a better system in that regard from the start.
The key thing is to find groups with people who share your passions in life (whatever they may be). I used to be a member of a gardening group on the web, but I don't really want to spend much time discussing gardening. I want to know how to do certain things and leave. A simple Google search answers most of my questions so I rarely visit gardening forums these days. Therefore, I was just not a "good" member for a gardening group.
Hang in there. There are still a lot of good people here that I knew years ago. It is difficult to believe that over 2 years has passed since I saw many of them.
Lynne: you said it much better than I did! Excellent comment!
{{{{{Raven Wing}}}}}
Call it elevated self-esteem, but my punching bag days are long over! At 58 I don't put up with much crap be it from family, friends, or internet buds...life is too short to be an angry shrill. I'm impassioned, yet willing to listen and on occasion reconsider my point of view
Really? When it is "acceptable" to post five trolling articles every day? Serious articles are swamped.
Newcomers see only the Front Page.
To me the bottom line as to why people are nastier than ever before.
Because they can sit in front of a computer screen, say anything they want with no repercussions.
They would never say the things to a persons face. Cowards all.
As far as articles go, the ones that are political get all the comments.
Those that are not political get few. If you really want more articles that are other than political or posted to start a fight, then you have to comment on those that are other than the usual BS ones.
I have two that are pretty interesting, one on the largest desalination plant in the western hemisphere, San Diego and another on a mind boggling discovery in Hondoures about a culture/people that we didn't know existed.
They received 7 or 8 comments, half of them mine. Don't complain do something about it.
End of my rant.
RW, I added more to my comment after you read it. Check it out.
No, not ignoring the point of view. Ignoring the troll, who presents the point of view solely to garner replies...
For example, your point of view may be very opposite of mine, yet you post respectful, well-thought out articles that aren't flames... There IS a difference.
Do you see what I mean?
True, but there's another, less obvious, aspect: I think there is a conscious effort to "crowd out" all conversation other than their own.
Any article aimed at getting under someone's skin is to me, trolling...
Are you laughing at me? I'm trying hard to be good!
I have said very little until this point. As we speak I am working on our new home. I am only in the beginning stages, but it is my understanding that we can break the forums down. So here is an idea. Let's say that we have a politics broken down into these topic Conservative/liberal/ Open Discussion? This way, if you just can't stand looking at a specific POV you can avoid it.... but if you really want to have a discussion you can pick Open Discussion.
Just spit balling here.
That's correct Bob, they want an echo chamber.
I love you, bitey!
I'm tired, too!
What a lovely articulate comment! Thank you!!!
I think the only place I have seen the type of behavior that Raven is talking about is on the political threads. I have never seen trolling on a photo article or one on the life of bees. So, clearly, that is where the issue lies.
BTW, as lead mod, everyone thinks the guys from the opposite team are the trolls when it comes to politics. It seems to be part of the problem.
ambi, I love this! Thanks for posting it!
Yes, that is what I think, too...
I am sure that there are members who don't care and use it to their purposes. Those who do it for free, I have nothing I can do about it, other than disciplinary. Those who are paid and there is proof, will be gone, as it would violate our CoC. But I have no definitive information about any member of that nature.
As I said earlier, there will be a change in the formating of the front page. Hopefully, we can all work together to make the site function better, and a bit differently.
Perhaps if we all made a concerted effort to occasionally post something that is non-political, and all of us that feel this way go to support that article, it would help.
For sure Raven. I am spread so thin right now.
Sounds interesting. Does this mean that, for example, seeds from American Thinker would necessarily be in "conservatives" and seeds from AlterNet in "liberals"? That would be good. It would leave the "Open" page for neutral topics.
Bob,
That rule was to provide guidance as to stop spamming. No rule is written in stone. But it was a rarity that it would happen in the past.
Ditto Lynne!
Quite true, as is your meme.
I understand. But we now have a pro...
Kavika,
I had the same thing happen with my seed about where do insects go in the winter. I thought it was really interesting. Heck we all encounter them all the time. They are a part of our lives. Yet, not much in the way of comments.
I am not sure if it is so much a dis to us, other than how many times can someone go... wow interesting. Looking at the pageviews gives you a better idea.
I don't take it as a dis Perrie. What it points out to me is that the majority of people would rather fight about politics than anything else. It's really that simple.
If we help each other, we also help Perrie!
Maybe it will help her!
Raven,
No one could argue with anything you have said there. Well done!
Ummm... I was thinking that Open was for those of either side who wanted a civil but invigorating discussion.
I am not sure what a neural topic is.
There would be topics like we have here, science, the arts, etc.
Some of it is perception brother, how a comment is read is just as important and asking an adroit question at an opportune time can defuse a lot of the back and forth...
BF, you have hit the nail on the head-- we must ALL support the articles that are not flaming... I hope I came to your article-- if I didn't, I will try to do better in the future!
No, we can't, you're right. But we can all make the effort, as you are going to do. I, too, will make the effort!
I agree... kinda... but...
A BIG part of the problem is the way the Front Page works. A "low volume" article quickly slides off the FP, chased by a flood of trollish seeds. A small number of participants, playing ping-pong, can (and IMHO do) control the FP.
True. Also, we are not online 24/7. So we need some means of keeping "marginal" articles alive, so that even less assiduous members have the opportunity to see them, and to join them.
Yep. Once someone learns how to play the system, then it is easy to control... THAT's a big problem.
I notice that the usual dissenters have not shown up here... But are active elsewhere. Especially where they can be insulting to someone else. I guess boys will be boys!
Dowser - wonderful and very accurate thread/article.
I notice a "few" folks who haven't commented, but may have read the thread and realize they are the ones being discussed - the aliens in disguise.
Thank you Dowser - thank you.
Good night, everybody! I'm going to bed and will return tomorrow, after my doctor's appt. That is, IF I can get out of the driveway to go!
Take care, and sleep well-- all of you!
Thank you. So does all of the members who care about making NT their home. This is how it should be and I wish the best for everyone.
I have checked in from time to time here just to make sure that my friends from the other site were doing well.
I am not on the internet as much since life off of the web has been trying and busy. When I am on the internet, I am looking to be amused, entertained and informed. If I want to fight, I don't have to look far. I am a liberal atheist living in a GOP stronghold in the Bible Belt. Because I really hate wasting my life fighting with anyone, I spend a lot of time with my dogs. They love me and I spoil them as much as I possibly can.
Hold you head high Girl, your in good company!
Yeah the board is like a mosh pit, a violent place, you don't like it stay away.
Hows that for judging?
Much like the back alley reference you used a while back.
Maybe you might consider that most do not like a violent confrontational place, and reject those trying to create one.
Sound familiar?
From what I see and read, you are the only one that likes a violent place.
Maybe we should take the political articles off the front page, what do you think about that? How long do you think you will stay without an audience around your ring.
Very nice piece Dowser.... very timely too. Kudos
No. Wrong. Totally wrong.
The word "terrorist" has a definition: a person who uses violence against civilians to advance a political agenda. Like any word, "terrorist" may be misused -- applied to persons who do not in fact fit the definition -- but that does not change the definition.
Likewise, "troll" has a precise definition: "one who posts a deliberately provocative message to a newsgroup or message board with the intention of causing maximum disruption and argument".
Abuse of definitions is a technique used to prevent rational debate by muddying the waters to the point where it is impossible to see...
So... "In other words calling trolls and cowards is cowardly trolling" is false, too. This sentence uses false definitions to disqualify anyone who disagrees with you. It is intellectual dishonesty, whether intentional or just sloppy.
Then you try to impose a very peculiar partition on NT membership: normal folks (i.e. those who like to debate politics) and marginal folks (who like dog pictures). There is no third possibility.
This is another form of intellectual dishonesty: trying to frame a conversation in such a way that one's own position seems to be the only reasonable one.
Here are the same two portions, with different descriptors: wackos who like to swarm the Front Page with rabid rehashes of the same-old same-old, and normal folks who like to calmly discuss a wide variety of topics.
Then, having "marginalized" normal people, you exclude them:
Anyone who does not fit your definition of "normal" must leave!
Next you try a bit of sleight-of-hand:
Are you hoping that no one will notice that you have assimilated the Front Page to a mosh pit? In the midst of a discussion of what the Front Page is and/or should be, you brazenly decree what it is, as though the subject was already decided.
And -- cherry on the sundae -- finally you become holier-than-thou, declaring that those who disagree with you are the problem: "The self righteous displays and condemnation as a group we see occurring throughout this seed is part of the problem, not part of the cure."
All told, your post is a remarkable display of histrionic and intellectual deceit. If anyone wants to see the kind of post that disgusts others into abandoning "debate", this is it!
Violence?
You characterized it as violence.
Now, in your response to me you declare that I brought up violence in this context, when I pointed out that violence is what you SEEK. You are always twisting things into other responsibility. Thank you for the clear example.
You spammed the front page cause you posted five articles the day before that resulted in five echo-chambers where C4P's posts five articles that all received commentary and vigorous debate on some of them. And you got jealous.
Your spamming was a direct attack on C4P, Conservatives in general and the board. to engender the most violent and angry responses you could solely for the purpose of disruption.
Yeah I got pissed, yeah I exposed it, yeah your playing the hurt little puppy now, yeah you wish I would leave, yeah you have tried to drag others into backing up your BS play and failed, Yeah your weak excuses now have you looking the fool.
You would like me to leave, I'm hanging around to see the final act, with a box of popcorn.
Watching you wiggle and squiggle trying to recover from your asinine antics, and fail.
Expected, but then again you have always been about everyone else haven't you.
It's got to be a real sad existence for you that the only way you can survive is on the good graces of everyone else.
After the last Meta discussion you left, once the board decided they didn't want what you like here.
Why did you come back?
Very well said Bob
Dowser....
I agree with you 100%. Itry never to feed the troll(s). In fact I rarely comment on the FP. I actually prefer discussion and interaction within the group level. Thank you. Now I have to read 150 comments here, before me.
As we all do.
Nobody is perfect.
Hey Dowser!!! I care about Geology, post away!
Yes. We all come here to "play", so to speak, but most of us don't use the site as our own personal soapbox-- most of us are concerned for the site, and its overall health.
Thank you, dear 1st. I think you may be right.
One thing that to me, is very noticeable-- many of our better writers/commenters have come here, and agree with this premise. These are the people that have something to say-- their point of view may be entirely different from mine, but they are here because they care about the site!
Thank you for coming!!!
BF, I REALLY wasn't talking about you!
All of us have been guilty of some careless habits-- but the people here care about the site and each other. Everyone loves you, BF. We sometimes get irritated by your shenanigans, but we still love you! And many of us enjoy the shenanigans. I enjoy your satire, and enjoy talking with you!
UGH, what a night! My husband went to bed last night at 8 pm, VERY unusual for him-- then he couldn't sleep and got up at 4. All the lights and noise got me up. He was in and out trying to dig out enough to go to work, which he did, but I was up until he left. I had a doctor's appt, but he told me not to try to get out, as the snow had covered up the tail pipe, and unless I could get Matthew to shovel the entire driveway, to not try it. Then, the rigamarole of trying to cancel the appt, and reschedule! ARGHH! I now have 2 doctor's appts!
Dowser,
My post was in response to JR who asked RW to name names, and is someone who actually DID post about 15 or so inflammatory opinion articles about Libertarians solely in the effort to get under peoples skin....BTW... I know you don't play those games.
Whoa guys-- this isn't personal!
A discussion is what we're after. I don't want to take politics off the front page, but I do want to take the snarky, mean articles off the front page. And i do want to take all the spamming articles and perhaps put them somewhere. Never mind where...
I enjoy discussion about the topical events, but I'm truly tired of every article about politics just being snarky. Yes, it is a point of view that should be represented-- but does it have to be represented such a mean way?
Let me ask this-- is it possible to present a point of view on the issues, without being snarky? I mean, I guess, is can one discuss Michelle Bachman and leave out the wild-eyed crazy woman part? Can one discuss Obama rationally-- most of the criticism aimed at political entities seems to be belittling-- from all sides. The titles are encouraging heated debate that should be found in the heated debate section-- not on the front page.
I know there are people who hate the other side politically-- I would like to know why! and No One will answer that question without denigrating the person who asks...
I think putting someone on ignore, and ignoring those articles that are just trolling, are two different things.
I don't have anyone here on ignore. But I had 1 or 2 that I ignored on NV.
Yes, I agree, Bob.
I can see why flame called them the same, or made the comparison, but there really isn't a good comparison. I don't know of another comparison that accurately describes what I mean-- So far, the best I've seen is Internet Asperger's Syndrome...
thank you, dear friend!
Bless your heart! It takes awhile!
ambi, we all do...
To err is human, to forgive is divine...
Dowser, just a suggestion, maybe the difference between "discussion, argument, and fighting" should be explained. Reading the comments it is clear some do NOT know the difference......
Now my dear friend, we've been friends for almost five years now so when I say this next comment to you I want you to know I mean no disrespect,.....
Listen here freaky lady, if you don't believe in aliens then don't come crying to me when they get here and suck your brains out,......
Love the cat picture, and so true!!
Bob gave a pretty good explanation of trolling:
That is a good definition, to me... Do you have a good one, too? I would love more input on this...
No actual answers, hmm, flame?
When logic doesn't apply, just go for an ad hominum...
You really are a piece.
Duck and dodge...
Link?
WTF??
You posted . I answered. You persisted . I persisted.
Now you say this isn't the right place?? How does that work? You can post whatever you like, but if someone's answers get beyond you, then you simply announce "DO OVER!!"??
Yep... you really are a piece...
I'm afraid that I feel that I have had my mean-spirited moments, too! We all make mistakes, and I've certainly made my share!
BF, I truly tried to point that out above-- Asperger's is a very real condition in real life. I know several people with it, and have dealt with them, very closely. In no way, do I wish to denigrate their condition, or to harm them.
However, the 4 that I know that have been diagnosed with Asperger's, have no wish to socialize and much prefer to just be left alone-- at all times. They seem to suffer only from the consequences of their desire to be left strictly alone-- and don't understand that the desire to be left strictly alone is what makes them suffer.
I have also dealt closely with several children diagnosed with autism-- they want to socialize, but can't. Maybe it's a different diagnosis, based on what part of the country you're from. That's just been my experience. One of these children is my niece-- so I have seen her a lot, and been with her a lot, and tried to be good and loving to her-- a lot!
This was in an article I read, and as I said above, the name was "tongue-in-cheek"-- the link is supplied in the body of the article. It seems to be a fitting name, as we don't know enough about people, but they seem to have trouble fitting into a congenial group, or communicating with others, and resort to "trolling".
As flame and few others have pointed out, "trolling" means different things to different people. It's a lot like porn-- I have trouble defining it, but know it when I see it.
No one is trying to 'get rid of' anyone here. I am hoping that by working together, by not responding to trollish articles, we can modify their behavior so that the site is more comfortable for everyone. That is not trying to 'get rid of', that is trying to teach them how to behave in a community environment.
And I can say that "green" has no precise definition, too! Denialism has now reached the English language....
Just as denialists refuse any facts that do not fit their preconceptions, now we have people who redefine words at their whim, to make them better fit their arguments.
Dictionaries exist for a reason! To consign the meaning of words, to make it easy to know what a word's meaning is. So let's stop accepting that flame (or anyone else) simply decree what words mean.
The definition I gave for "troll" was not my definition. It comes from Urban Dictionary : " One who posts a deliberately provocative message to a newsgroup or message board with the intention of causing maximum disruption and argument"
Merriam-Webster on "terrorism": "the use of violent acts to frighten the people in an area as a way of trying to achieve a political goal".
When you find someone playing fast and loose with words, it is usually to hide the fact that their ideas do not hold up if expressed in commonly accepted vocabulary. Only by abusing language can these people make their ideas seem logical.
"Green" is "the color between blue and yellow in the spectrum".
help me, here, ok? Are you saying that, basically, those that respond in kind to a disruptive and argumentative seed in kind are being trolls?
Good idea-- don't respond to a troll and don't be a troll.
OK, Dean... Now let's look at this.
My question was clearly provocative, in the sense of "challenging". I have challenged libertarians again and again to explain their core reasoning... without success. So certainly "provocative".
But what about "the intention of causing maximum disruption and argument"? Not so much! There was no intent of causing "disruption" at all -- the conversation was about libertarianism, after all. And the "argument" I was calling for was the libertarians' own argument!The antithesis of disruption!
So... not "trolling"...
Ok, now I understand a little better.
I agree with you, and that is what this article is about. If it bothers you, don't respond.
I see why you would see it that way-- and am trying to understand.
Provocative isn't the problem, so much. Nastiness is. Do you see the difference? I am asking everyone to not play into the nastiness.
I can understand why you say that intent can not be determined by anyone else but the seeder. But, I also see where a volume of seeds posted by a particular user can show intent. It can show a personal agenda-- and therefore, it can show an intent.
It's like, by your actions, so shall you know them. People can deny their intent in a disingenuous way, but their actions speak louder than words. You mother can slap you up the side of your head and say, "I didn't mean to hit you." What are you going to believe?
It is NOT my intent to drive anyone off the site. It is my intent to make the site more pleasant for everyone. Perrie made a comment somewhere about having different front pages on the new platform. Perhaps that is an answer. Alternatively, perhaps we could have a group dedicated solely to those articles that set a nastier tone, by their titles, content, whatever-- so the rest of us don't have to look at it.
Mike,
Being "provocative," in-and-of-itself is not the problem; the problem is the posting of a provocative article -- the content of which is anywhere from questionable to outright unsubstantiated, insidious, scandalous and/or demonstrably false a lie
WHICH WHEN DEBUNKED, the author/seeder of the article NOT ONLY FAILS TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE ARTICLE'S LACK OF CREDIBILITY but rather
doubles down on the lie
diverts attention from the original content and/or
insults any/all who attempt in any way to challenge the content
THIS IS THE PROBLEM!
Discussion, debate, disparate opinions, these are the heart and soul of discussion forums; what kills these forums is not legitimate disagreement, what kills these forums is the abuse those must endure who try to engage in legitimate disagreement.
I recently wrote to one such serial abuser "My dream scenario is to debate you in a venue of neutral "third" parties where there are rules, protocols and required decorum."
Just because we're not in such a venue doesn't make it any easier to accept abuse for an opinion. And for many, abuse is a reason to quit a site like NT et al.
I certainly think that those who comment nastily help fuel the fire of nasty. But, you have to admit that some titles of articles are nasty, in and of themselves.
Maybe, all of us could use some lessons in tact. I know I could!
Sources are important, in a discussion forum like those here on NT, sources are the cyber equivalent of "witness credibility" or the lack thereof.
Attempts to ban sources in virtually any venue of a free society (including its cyberspace) is essentially "censorship" which implies and even imposes a totally subjective environment. I have no problem with the use of any source, I HAVE A MAJOR PROBLEM WITH THOSE WHO REFUSE TO ACKNOWLEDGE WHEN A PARTICULAR SOURCE AND ANY PARTICULAR CONTENT IT FOISTS, IS DEBUNKED.
FURTHER, WHEN A DISREPUTABLE SOURCE, OR, ANY SOURCE FOR THAT MATTER, REPORTS BULLSHIT AS FACT, THAT PHENOMENON HAS THE INHERENT EFFECT AND VALUE OF OUTING ITSELF!
I much prefer to be reminded from time-to-time, of who the "wolves" are, rather than to have them slink around in the shadows and bite me in the ass rather than lie to my face. At least when someone or some entity pisses in my face and tells me "it's raining," I can likely count on fair-minded individuals to join me when I call out the pisser!
Exactly, A. Mac.
Excuse me folks, but I've been up since 4:30 am, (having gone to bed at 2 am), and I'm going to take a little nap. I'm so tired, I can hardly see.
I'll be back!
Don't stay away too long. If you don't monitor your article good enough something crazy might happen. (sorry the smart alack in me never let's these things go by)
[perrie leans over and flicks '96 in the forehead]
That's what wize guys get. Now go to the blackboard!
Those that end up with piss on their face time and time again do so because they are looking for it. They call it a golden shower.
That's blaming the victim.
Some believe it's ultimately worth a pissing-on if that's part of what it takes to cut the balls off of a liar.
"Serial pisser" "serial liar" they often appear on the same resume.
And in the end, the piss washes off, while the reputation of the pisser-liar sticks.
A quick review of the front page would make one think that this article and other recent and not so recent metas on similar subjects are not getting the message across, because it is now obvious that
Graphic courtesy of
Dean, may I ask a question?
Why do some of you fight civility, as if it is a death knell to you, personally? It sounds like, or seems like, being civil to others would kill your own spirit? If it is heated debate you want, you already have a group for that called Heated Discussions-- that is what Perrie set that room up for. It has devolved into a name-calling, slug-fest-- but the original intent was to have a place where everyone could go and be as nasty and as mean as they pleased, without moderation. Why don't you use it as it was intended?
This is just a thought- Why not take those articles to the Heated Discussions group, that is un-moderated?
Oh, and thanks, I had a nice nap!
Yes, they have. And, as usual, defending their rights to do so.
Dowser your always good.
Thanks, 96. I'm not good at playing games like that.
I love you, too, dear friend!
Thanks, dd!
The truth is that even I find it boring-- at times!
I applaud and support the effort you have made, are making and will continue to make trying to make NT a better place for all of us to enjoy.
thanks, very much!
We are losing too many good people in membership... That worries me!
Lynne your a young yet knowledgeable member. Dowser has been one of my favorites. Thank you Dowser. Perrie Have known of you and respected you for many a moon.
Perrie I read the article on insects and loved it.
Retired Military ex Republican, I love your moniker! More importantly, thank you for your service. Although I do like the ex Republican part as well
.
Thanks for the shout out.
100% agreement regarding Dowser, "met"her years ago on NV!Shecontinues to remaina kind, considerate and peace loving individual - like the Mama always trying to keep everyone in line, not for a personal agenda, but for the sake of humanity. How could anyone not love this beautiful soul?
Perrie is steering the Titanic with a job that is above and beyond. Her tolerance is most commendable!
Perrie - I needed additional protein, so I ate the insects and luv'd'm.
Me, too! I believe there are! It will be a battle, but I believe that the general membership is made of decent people!
Yes... That's my point. They may be members, but they don't come here!
And we have many that have just left. Always a blow!
Oh no! Not the blackboard again! I feel like Bart Simpson! lol
I know how you feel...
Sounds like you're proposing to create a bunch of mini "Echo Chambers". If someone "can't stand" to look at anothers' POV, they have issues.
I've read three pages of discussion on this subject and doubt that reading the following 16 pages will offer much, if anything, toward resolving the differences here.
In the first place, I'm not sure what is meant by "agenda based articles". IMO, articles about, police brutality, gun control, child abuse, climate change, violence against women, politics, foreign policy etc, are all "agenda based".
When I post an article about child abuse it's because I have an agenda regarding the abuse of children.
As far as Marshas' example is concerned, IMO, articles like that are pure nonsense, but someone did publish it somewhere, so to someone it has a value. I know I wouldn't involve myself is a discussion regarding something like that, but I don't feel it's right to say the article shouldn't be seeded (the word 'censor' comes to mind).
I also know there are some rules aboutdeliberatelyposting comments to bring an articleback to the top, so if someone is doing that on an article that has not generated any discussion, the article should be taken down.
Mike, this is the second time you've made that point. Perhaps RW speaks as she does because she does not see the problem changing. I don't know, but that would be my guess.
Please, both of you, stop annoying each other. We have a common goal here-- betterment of the site. How can we accomplish that goal?
Please see my post above-- Please?
I mean no disrespect to either one of you!
I don't think that we're trying to do without controversy, antagonist, or protagonist-- just nasty trolling of the front page. There IS a difference.
Nor do I think that people can always avoid rubber-necking. But rubber-necking doesn't mean that all the people drive by get out of their cars and talk with the EMS... right?
I agree that conflict fuels discussion-- but the tone of the discussion doesn't have to be inflammatory. It would mean that those same people get out of their car and take a sledge hammer to the EMS vehicle. NOT a good idea!
I love ya Raven, but.... In your comment you used the word "attack" or "attacked" four different times. And whenever you comment on this subject you alway use the words "attack" or "attacked".
Frankly I don't understand what you mean when you say someone "attacked" you. On this forum, if someone levels a personal attack against you, their comment is removed, and If they do it often enough they will be suspended.
However if someone simply strongly disagrees with you or your opinion, that is not an attack, it is an opportunity for you to justify your position. It's called a debate, or perhaps an argument, or sometimes rises to the level of what we politely refer to as a "heated discussion". But disagreements are not 'attacks'. Now, if you don't care to engage in any debates, arguments or heated discussions..... don't. But that is no reason to avoid the front page.
As I told you and Mac in a different discussion on the issue of not posting on the front page. If everyone that does not want to engage in differences of opinion abandons the FP, the FP will become owned and controlled by the wise guys and NT will become an endangered species.
I understand...
Just don't stop with the ones that many find to be funny like Obamas gay lover.
NewsTalker #1,
If you are who I hope you are, good to see you, and if you are not, it's still good to see you.
While I agree
I disagree that
Rather, it is the disparate content that inspires or fuels discussion and, it is the antagonist who kills discussion by failing to accede to the truth when it is shown to him, and, instead, devolving the dialogue to a pissing contest.
And then there are those who are conspicuous BY THEIR ABSENCE FROM THIS DISCUSSION.
I try to write articles that I find stimulating to my mind, my point of view. The problem is, I am so strange that no one really thinks the articles are any fun. Shrugs.
I know. Did it add to the discussion? Did it solve a problem?
I am not being critical, or not trying to be. Just trying to keep the discussion on track.
Exactly...
I find your articles interesting, and visit each one, even if I can't think of anything intelligent to say... Please keep them coming!
NO!!! I'm just trying to keep peace, RW!
Blame me, too, Mickey, for inviting RW to speak her mind and not defending her to the death.
It's also my fault for writing the article to begin with...
NO it's the other way around they are trying to tell you what you can and can't post.