FBI Faces $30M Lawsuit Over Fatal Boston Bomber Related Shooting
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) is moving ahead with a plan to sue the Federal Bureau of Investigations over what CAIR says is the wrongful shooting death of Ibragim Todashev, friend of the late alleged Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev, msnbc has exclusively learned.
By Aliyah Frumin 3/2/15
On Monday, the Florida chapter of the nations largestMuslim civil liberties advocacy will send a notice of claim a precursor to a civil lawsuit to the FBI alleging negligence and misconduct in the fatal shooting of the 27-year-old Todashev in his Orlando home in
The actual civil lawsuit, which will seek $30 million in damages for Todashevs family, is expected to be filed this spring, said CAIR Floridas chief executive director Hassan Shibly.
We want to send a strong message to the FBI that they cant engage inpredatory behavior and misconduct We also want a change of policy so this never happens again, said Shibly.
The father of the Florida man, Abdulbaki Todashev, said in a statement through CAIR that his son was killed by the FBI in cold blood and that we mourn his death and have not forgotten our Ibragim for a second. He added, The murder of our son is unjust and is a result of the FBIs abuse of power . We expect that the FBI agents that murdered our son will be held accountable.
Todashev, a Chechen-born mixed martial arts fighter who had trained with Tsarnaev in Boston, was killed by FBI agent Aaron McFarlane after Todashev reportedly became violent after hours of questioning about the Boston attacks and a separate 2011 triple homicide in Waltham, Mass. Investigators said in the report that Todashev had implicated both himself and Tsarnaev who was killed in the days following the Boston Marathon bombings in the Waltham murders, which were unsolved prior to Tsarnaevs death.
In its notice of claim, CAIR asserts that Todashev did not pose a threat of serious bodily harm to McFarlane or any other person and that none of the agents present sought to intervene to prevent the excessive force, though able.
The Florida state attorney and the U.S. Department of Justice both issued separate reports last spring clearing McFarlane of any wrongdoing, ruling he was acting in self-defense when he shot and killed Todashev. The state report details how Todashev, who had been writing a confession, allegedly lunged forward at law enforcement officers with a metal pole after throwing a coffee table top. According to the report, the FBI agent fired three to four shots, but Todashev was still able to advance toward the officer, at which point more shots were fired. An autopsy report showed Todashev was shot seven times, all reportedly by Todashev.
CAIR and other advocacy groups have maintained that the circumstances of Todashevs death remain murky, with law enforcement officials making contradictory statements about whether or not the Florida man was armed when he was killed. They question why he was shot so many times, and point to McFarlanes checkered past. A Boston Globe investigation claimed McFarlane had previously been at the center of two police brutality lawsuits and four Internal Affairs investigations during his time at the Oakland Police Department in California. CAIRs notice of claim asserts that the FBI was negligent in hiring McFarlane.
The FBI did not return requests for comment.
The pending lawsuit comes as several police killings have rocked communities across the country, raising concerns about police practices. That includes last years death of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri and Eric Garner in Staten Island, New York.
Shibly said these deaths, along with Todashevs, reflects the dramatic loss of liberty Americans have been facing in the last decade-and-a-half since 9/11 with a lot more deference to authority at the expense of our liberty, which is what makes America so great to begin with Its clear we cant trust law enforcement to police themselves. He added that if not for the FBI wrongly targeting the Muslim-American community, I dont think he would be dead to begin with.
Separately, the jury selection process in the trial of accused Boston bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the younger brother of Tamerlan Tsarnaev, is ongoing. The siblings are suspected of planting bombs that killed three people and injured 264 near the finish line of the Boston Marathon on April 15, 2013.
Related Stories;
Filmmaker exposes FBI counter-terrorism strategy
FBI obstructs oversight, DOJ Inspector General says
Tags
Who is online
91 visitors

" The state report details how Todashev, who had been writing a confession, allegedly lunged forward at law enforcement officers with a metal pole after throwing a coffee table top. According to the report, the FBI agent fired three to four shots, but Todashev was still able to advance toward the officer, at which point more shots were fired. An autopsy report showed Todashev was shot seven times.... "
" CAIR and other advocacy groups have maintained that the circumstances of Todashevs death remain murky, with law enforcement officials making contradictory statements about whether or not the Florida man was armed when he was killed. They question why he was shot so many times, and point to McFarlanes checkered past. ABoston Globeinvestigation claimed McFarlane had previously been at the center of two police brutality lawsuits and four Internal Affairs investigations during his time at the Oakland Police Department in California. CAIRs notice of claim asserts that the FBI was negligent in hiring McFarlane. "
Which story do you believe?
When I first read about this incident in May of 2013, I didn't give a second thought. But now that I learn of McFarlands' background in the Oakland PD, I have some questions in my mind.
Why was McFarland taking a confession at Todashevs' home? It seems if Todashev confessed, McFarland should have immediately arrested and cuffed Todashev, then taken him to an FBI facility to take the written confession.
LOL, I read that story Hal. Amazing isn't it?
"The FBIs record is faultless, according to the FBI. The New York Times highlighted Wednesday [6/19/13] that according to internal investigations carried out by the agency on 150 shootings of the last two decades, not one has been deemed improper."
Goes to show we really need to have an externalinvestigationevery time an American citizen is killed by a LEO. And I don't 'external' as in District Attorneys Office.
Todashev's family will lose the lawsuit, and will cost CAIR a pretty penny.
You won't give a damn until your wife gets pulled over for speeding, and gets raped by the officer. She is guilty after all, if she would just learn to drive the speed limit she wouldn't have gotten herself into that situation.
Any law enforcement officer in the country, from the FBI to a campus cop, can gun down anyone they please, with total impunity. We have seen a lot of people killed by cops, and every case has been ruled "justified".
Keep moving, people! Nothing to be seen here! Move along!
The latest case (in California somewhere) seems to show that laying on the ground can get you shot, too...
Hands up! Don't shoot!
No, they will settle out of court, the government will pay the family off. These are Muslims.
Are you talking about the homeless guy who grabbed the officer's gun, Bob?
If this is Tamir Rice, in his case, that officer needs to be tried in a court of law for murder, and the police chief in the town where the officer worked previously needs to be tried as an accessory, for giving the officer a good reference.
Oh, yeah!!
There sure are a lot of folks grabbing cops' guns these days...
And we know it's true 'cause there's other cops who witnessed it!
Yup...
No need to be snarky, Bob.
The one I'm talking about had a video posted and there were witnesses there who said the man had grabbed the cop's gun. He was tased twice but the taser did not appear to have any effect on him.
There are always witnesses to clear the cops. Apparently, they never use their weapons unnecessarily. Except when someone is filming...
What are your thoughts regarding the preferred activities of Ibragim Todashev, Mr. Nelson?
I am unaware of his activities. I don't see what difference they would make. Regardless of what he may have done, the FBI is not authorized to make summary executions.
Well... at least they're not going with "He tried to grab the officer's gun". It's good to have a little variety in these tales...
That's just a figment of your fucking imagination!
You have no idea how anyone, liberal or not, cares about victims. Most Left Wingers are, by a mile and a half, more compassionate than any fucking Conservative.Actually thecompassion of liberals is routinely ridiculed by you guys.
But, because the soft hearted Liberal is crying over the plight of the of the victim, it does not mean that Liberal does not also feel the criminal that committed the crime is not entitled to the protection of the Constitution we all live under.
Apparently yourinterpretationof the Constitution does not get pastthe2nd Amendment.
"Authorities said ....". Of course that make it right. The "Authorities" said it, it must be right. But we'll never really know will we Robert.
Whatever happened in that room is going to cost the taxpayers a lot of money, it won't be any 30 million dollars, CIAIR will do battle in the federal courts for a year or two then, when no one is looking, they'll accept the 7 or 8 mill they're offered to go away.
Bingo!
(I could have save a lot of typing had I see your comment before I made the above post.)
Your racist attitude is showing again Robert.
(?!) WTF! where did that come from?!
Find me one credible, comment that holdsTodashev in any kind of esteem, let alone calling him a hero.
As I said above, you have quite the imagination.
That prettymuchsoundslike sweeping our race toward becoming a police state under the rug.
I would be a good thing if it always happened that way, however there are many instances wherepeoplehave been shot dead in spite of their compilingwith the police.
When will you be called to testify?
Theprosecutioncan use a guy with an imagination like yours.
Thank goodness. It'sa reliefto know that there is a plausible explanation for your comments.
"Bingo" all you want, Jerry.
Even though most all states except Texas have opted for life in prison without parole for murderers, prosecutors are talking about the death penalty for the man who shot the three Muslims over an argument about parking space in their apartment complex, and they are considering adding the "hate" crime factor.
This is in spite of the fact that they have found the man's journal in which he has kept detailed records of the parking habits of his neighbors over a period of several months. This includes all of his neighbors, not just the Muslims next door. This is also in spite of statements from his ex-wife and others that he had a "thing" about what he considered violations of the parking allocations at the complex and had complained to the manager about it several times.
So if you kill anyone in the US you get life in prison (except in Texas); if you kill Muslims you get the death penalty.
Don't misunderstand me, Jerry. I think all killers should get the death penalty... impartially.
The city of Cleveland is blaming the child for his own death. It is one of the most disgusting things I have read in the news in a long, long time.
They are trying to deflect from the fact that they hired an emotionally unbalanced individual as a cop and gave him a gun, when there was a paper trail documenting that it was advised that he be fired from his first law enforcement job and that he had no business anywhere around a gun.
Yup. In fact, we're already there: Cops kill with impunity. Prison sentences are determined by race. Mentally disturbed are executed while Golden Boys wreck the economy unpunished...
But the words must not be said...
Yes indeed: "Regardless of what he may have done, the FBI is not authorized to make summary executions."
I know it's hard, but you really must make the effort to read beyond the first sentence...
It's even safer if you do not reveal your full name and hide behind a ridicules avatar.
They must not be said to those that don't want to hear them, those that feel threatened by them. Those are the people that have to wrap themselves in their security blanket so they can feel everything is just fine, that the changes in the police attitude, the changes in the climate, and the changes in civil Rights are not happening.
They don't, but think they are all about what America means.
My "Bingo" means I am inagreementthat they likely will settle out of court.
I understand you feel the FBI is culpable, but I'm not sure everyone that kills someone shouldautomaticallybe put to death, as there are often mitigating circumstances.
CAIR is a group comprised of non-violent Muslims, why do you assume they are a 'terror' group?
The guilt or innocence of Ibragim Todashev was never established, yet you automatically call him a terrorist.
Yeah it's a fucking madhouse ..... the Right Wingers among us honestly believe the Constitution does not apply to Muslims, which would be a violation of the Constitution ..... so yeah, we've all gone mad!
There are at least 4 former CAIR officials serving 10-65 year prison sentences for terrorism-related offenses. There are many more who have been deported or have fled the country.
Much like Sinn Fein is the political arm of the terrorist Irish Republican Army, CAIR is the political arm of the extreme savage Islamists. Both CAIR and ISIS/Al Qaeda seek a world dominated by Islam and Sharia law. Same goal, different tactics.
" I wouldn't want to create the impression that I wouldn't like the government of the US to be Islamic at some time in the future, but I'm not going to do anything violent to promote that. I'm going to use education. "
- Ibrahim Hooper
Spokesperson for the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR)
Fat chance of that ever happening especially considering the US is a secular nation.
I have a feeling the family couldn't find a lawyer to take the case on a pro-bono basis because it will be a very tough case to win. It's also reasonable to assume the only reason CAIR is involved is for the publicity.
(?!) What means?
My guess is the "unindicted" autocorrected to "uninvited" in the post about CAIR...
Since I wasn't at the interview, I certainly don't know what happened. The FBI is saying that the young man became enraged and came over the coffee table after them and they fired in self defense.
Americans are raised under the iron hand of law enforcement; we know that all those who carry badges from local police and sheriff's deputies to FBIand fictional MIB alien hunters... I'm talkin' aliens from off-planet... will trash-talk you, your mother and grandmother, even your kids, to get you riled up and start yelling things they can hold against you. Even illegal Mexicans know you don't attack the police, regardless of which suit he is wearing.
Young Muslim men, I would imagine, are a different kettle of fish, especially when they are innocent of any wrong-doing. After all, America is known the world over as the country where everyone is innocent until proved guilty (we really have to change that slogan to "guilty until proved innocent").
Imagine a young Muslim man, in his own home or the home of a relative, being interviewed by FBI agents about a bombing in one of our greatest cities during a highly popular and heavily attended event where multiple people were seriously wounded, and among the dead is a small child. The agents are grim, angry, pushing relentlessly for answers they already THINK they know, maybe becoming hateful and out of bounds with insults.
A young Muslim male who likely has never been subjected to this type of treatment in his own environment, who may be innocent of any knowledge of his dead friend's subversive terrorist actions, becomes fed up with the insinuations and the very ATTITUDE of the agents and just blows up, has to have an outlet for the anger and flips the table.
Yes, I have made the entire scene up from whole cloth, but I can clearly see my grandsons acting in such a way were they to be accused in similar circumstances.
You're probably right.
I only use my cell phone to make phone calls. I'm still back in the dark ages of using my desktop as a Word Processor.
Never gonna happen.... and he might justbecomeyournext president!
A far better choice than Hillary or whatever backward thinking Conservative the GOP put up.
He din't have to "convert", both his parents were atheist so he was brought up in a non-religious home, although he did go to Catholic school for two years as a kid. He now worshipsat the Evergreen Chapel at Camp David.
In January 2008, Obama told Christianity Today : " I am a Christian, and I am a devout Christian. I believe in the redemptive death and resurrection ofJesus Christ . I believe that faith gives me a path to be cleansed of sin and have eternal life." On September 27, 2010, Obama released a statement commenting on his religious views saying "I'm a Christian by choice. My family didn'tfrankly, they weren't folks who went to church every week. And my mother was one of the most spiritual people I knew, but she didn't raise me in the church. So I came to my Christian faith later in life, and it was because the precepts of Jesus Christ spoke to me in terms of the kind of life that I would want to leadbeing my brothers' and sisters' keeper, treating others as they would treat me.[ Source ]
Cops have to believe their suspect is guilty, otherwise they would have no justification for arresting them. Anyway thecynicism of people in general almost always puts the onus of guilt on the accused as soon as an accusation is made (except in the case of a rape charge).
As far as this guy is concerned, he may well have snapped and started throwing things, but this business of cops drawing their guns and starting to shoot at the first sign of trouble has gotten out of hand. There seems to be no attempt made to subdue a suspect that starts to get physical other than to shoot them dead.