╌>

Nebraska Judge Halts TransCanada's Eminent Domain Grab for Keystone XL

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  kavika  •  11 years ago  •  116 comments

Nebraska Judge Halts TransCanada's Eminent Domain Grab for Keystone XL
Sue Ogrocki/AP
Keystone pipeline piled up in Cushing, Oklahoma.

Nebraska Judge Halts TransCanada's Eminent Domain Grab for Keystone XL

2/16/15

TransCanada has for now lost its bid to seize Nebraskans land via eminent domain for its Keystone XL pipeline project, thanks to a February 12 temporary injunction.

The company, which wants to run part of its 1,700-mile-long, 800,000-barrels-per-day crude oil pipeline through Nebraska en route between the oil sands of Alberta to the Gulf Coast of Texas, had taken legal steps in January to begin forcing landowners to sell their rights of way. Several of those landowners filed suit to challenge the measure by taking issue with a state law that had given the governor the authority to approve the route.

A Holt County, Nebraska District Court judge halted the proceedings.

TransCanada has suspended its eminent domain activity even among those who did not file suit, Huffington Post reported.

We are committed to working respectfully with all landowners as shown by todays decision to stay eminent domain actions until there is a final resolution of the plaintiffs claims," said TransCanada spokesman Mark Cooper to Huffington Post .

Bold Nebraska director Jane Kleeb called it a major win for landowners in a statement from the group that has been front and center in opposition to the pipeline.

The pipeline has been contested since it was first proposed more than six years ago.

Read more at http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2015/02/16/nebraska-judge-halts-transcanadas-eminent-domain-grab-keystone-xl-159233

Read more at http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2015/02/16/nebraska-judge-halts-transcanadas-eminent-domain-grab-keystone-xl-159233

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

Excellent.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

''What a crock of shit. This company just tried to essentially steal land through the court so that they can make money off land that they have absolutely no right to. This is hardly respectful... greedy as hell... But not respectful.''

My thought as well flame.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
I agree in 99% of cases. It was supposed to be used sparingly, for vital community interests. Not to benefit private companies.
 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    11 years ago

This is just the beginning of the court battles that will follow. This isn't the end, by any means. This is a good start, though. Keystone's lawyers will make a fortune off of the litigation that is sure to follow. Hopefully, those lawyers will have enough sense to drag this court case on for as long as is lawyer-ly possible so they can line their pockets with gold.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Excellent point Cerenkov.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

They would still have to ship it, which is what they don't want to do. Guess why? The dangers of shipping it over land.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

You hit the nail on the head Cerenkov.

I remember a case that Eminent Domain was used to uproot a middle class neighborhood to make way for shopping and condo's. This is total abuse of Eminent Domain. If I remember correctly the reasoning for it, was that it would improve the area and bring in revenue to the city.

In the end, they succeeded but the project to build the shopping and condos, was still not started 3 years later.

Sorry I don't remember where this took place.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

Yes, they could have 2blue. To get it to the W/C of Canada they would have to go through the provience of British Columbia which is dead set against it.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

I'm sure that it is just the beginning Grump. I, like you, would like to see it stuck in the courts for decades.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

This is good news. Eminent domain is what the Sioux were threatened with they refused to sell the company the right of way. They told the company they would meet them at the boundary if they tried to come onto Sioux land, regardless of a court ruling.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Eminent Domain should not exist.

Especially for a Canadian company!

I did some work in the BP refinery in Hammond, Indiana years ago. They were just getting the refinery modified to handle the stuff from Canada. It is nothing short of nasty given the amount of sulfur and other crap in it.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

That raises a very interesting question Mimi. Since rez land is tribal and part of a sovereign nation, Eminent Domain would not apply here, IMO.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

flame, the First Nations of Canada and the Tribes in the US have been at the forefront of this fight for years.

Now, many others have joined in. There is the ''Cowboy and Indian'' alliance that is made of ranchers, farmers, cowboys and Indians.

There is no benefit to the US in this, only danger.

I have also heard the argument many times, that this will free us from foreign oil. As far as I know, Canada is not part of the US, and will do what is in their best interest.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

It's very nasty stuff FLY, and something that we don't need.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Eminent domain is a scam. one that HAS been abused in the last few decades by government to pay off the investors in their political shenanigans.

It should be abolished.

As far as XL goes?

We are an oil producing nation, Bush opening up drilling rights and expanding drilling leaseholds has, a decade later made this nation a net exporter of oil. (one of the few good things he did) We have the ability to transport our oil cause we have to, the risks we take doing it are risks we have to take.

I say let Canada take the risks for the oil they produce. No pipeline.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Kavika, I recall several stories like that. The only beneficiary was a private property developer.
 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

Yes, Cerenkov that is true. If I remember correctly the developer in this case couldn't get financing for the project. So the land sits empty. Brilliant decision by the city/state in this case.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    11 years ago

How can Trans Canada a foreign Company declare and get the use of eminent Domain in the United States in the first place. We have more oil than ever and often seem unable to process the oil we have. Companies are wanting to ship crude overseas that is routed through our nations farmland to the gulf. Guess The Supreme Court will allow the Koch brothers who I understand own majority stock in the tar sand venture. Canada has an east and west coast they can use it instead of our land. At 800,000 barrels a day would 12 hour of leaking Destroy huge amounts of cropland drinking water and wildlife. Just who thinks this is a good idea. 1 barrel = 42 Gallons 800,000 barrels times 42 gallons = 33 million 600 thousand gallons a day 8 hour leak = 11,200,000. gallons.

After all a high pressure line like that could make quite a mess for only adding 35 permanent Frown.gif jobs.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

TheRosebud Sioux Tribe (Sicangu Lakota Oyate) said it recognized the passage of the bill through Congress as an Act of War, and other South Dakota Tribes have joined with them. They said they absolutely would not allow the pipeline to cross Sioux land, that it was a death sentence not only for Mother Earth but for their children and grandchildren and this time they would die fighting.

The tribe has done its part to remain peaceful in its dealing with the United States in this matter, in spite of the fact that the Rosebud Sioux Tribe has yet to be properly consulted on the project, which would cross through tribal land, and the concerns brought to the Department of Interior and to the Department of State have yet to be addressed.

The House has now signed our death warrants and the death warrants of our children and grandchildren. The Rosebud Sioux Tribe will not allow this pipeline through our lands, said President Scott of the Rosebud Sioux Tribe. We are outraged at the lack of intergovernmental cooperation. We are a sovereign nation and we are not being treated as such. We will close our reservation borders to Keystone XL. Authorizing Keystone XL is an act of war against our people.

In February of this year, the Rosebud Sioux Tribe and other members of the Great Sioux Nation adopted tribal resolutions opposing the Keystone XL project.

The Lakota people have always been stewards of this land, added President Scott. We feel it is imperative that we provide safe and responsible alternative energy resources not only to tribal members but to non-tribal members as well. We need to stop focusing and investing in risky fossil fuel projects like TransCanadas Keystone XL pipeline. We need to start remembering that the earth is our mother and stop polluting her and start taking steps to preserve the land, water, and our grandchildrens future.

The Rosebud Sioux Tribe, along with several other South Dakota Tribes, stand together in opposition to risky and dangerous fossil fuel projects like TransCanadas Keystone XL. The proposed route of TransCanadas Keystone XL pipeline crosses directly through Great Sioux Nation (Oceti Sakowin) Treaty lands as defined by both the 1851 and 1868 Fort Laramie Treaties and within the current exterior boundaries of the Rosebud Sioux Reservation and Cheyenne River Sioux Reservation

I've been trying to find the article I read where they were told if they didn't sell the land rights it would be taken from them by imminent domain, and that's when the Chief said they would meet them at the boundary.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

How can Trans Canada a foreign Company declare and get the use of eminent Domain in the United States in the first place.

Easy, they have a US subsidiary, own property in the US, and are general partners in a conglomerate that does business in the US.

From TransCanada's website....

The Pipelines business is principally comprised of TransCanadas natural gas pipelines in Canada, the United States and Mexico. We are also the general partner of TC PipeLines, LP, a limited partnership that owns interests in U.S. pipelines.

This is always how it is done. International corporations recognize no national boundaries.

Besides they are majority owned by Americans.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The don't recognize boundaries comment was directed not at ACTUAL recognition of differing political entities (nations and laws) but was referenced in that national boundaries are no impedance to doing business. they can make their business practice conform to what ever laws or national policies are in effect.

Doesn't stop them at all.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

That is the one S....and SCOTUS did rule that it was constitutional...How very sad.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

There is a demand in China. Building the refinery in B.C. would seem to be the answer.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Randy, that is what the Sioux promised. Armed resistance.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

most sensitive parts of the aquifer

It has no business going over ANY part of that aquifer. And it certainly has not business going over any part of Sioux land.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

We don't need Keystone and we don't need eminent domain. Together they are a horrible, no good, nasty, very bad thing.

We've already destroyed enough Mother Earth. We have millions of miles of oil and gas pipelines that aren't taken care of as it is. Keystone will not help "the people", it will help a few people, but not "the people.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

LNG, is highly volatile and is shipped via ocean carrier. Refined oil (gas) is also shipped via ocean.

China surpassed the US in 2010 for total energy consumption. Of course this would include coal. I don't have the latest figures for anything past 2010.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

S, it really isn't about where the company is headquartered, what per cent is owned by American corporations or what LLC they are operating under.

It's the fact that many in the US DO NOT want the pipeline running across our country. That's a fact.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

To sell that oil to the US? Really?

The oil won't be sold to the U.S. -- not directly; it will be sold on the global market and the U.S., like other countries, will buy it based on the manipulated prices.

This crude is not meant to supply the U.S. market. We have a glut of oil and gas in the U.S. because of largely unregulated fracking going on in 31 states. Between our growing natural gas supply and OPEC's effort to quash the U.S. energy boom, gas prices are so low that American producers may slow their drilling. The Keystone pipeline will not reduce the cost of gasoline or home heating oil for American consumers.

...

So why is the plan to run the pipeline through the U.S.?

Because it's a more direct route to the Gulf AND U.S. Legislator whore/pimps have been paid off by the pipeline folks.

Money Pipeline Flowing Between U.S. Congress and Big Oil

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

S, actually the Canadians per capita are larger consumers of energy than the U.S. is.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

I read the article where they said they would take it via E.D.

It should be more than interesting if they try to cross Sioux land.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

Many people are surprised when they find out, that only 35 permanent jobs will be the end result retired military.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

I think that many of us are aware of where and how much of the tar sands oil is being used in the US. That is part of the problem, adding XL pipeland just aggravates the problem.

To me, water is a much more valuable commodity than is tar sands oil.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Seriously folks, fight the fight, BUT FIGHT THE RIGHT FIGHT. THis is nothing but politics and you are ALL being played for a political bullshit game.

That is the way politicians and big business like it.

Money takes all the time it needs.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

If I recall things properly there were two additional pre-processing steps that were being installed (expanded really) there in Hammond to handle the heavy crude feedstock. They were hydrodesulfurization to remove the SO2, and hydrodenitrogenation to reduce the nitrogen content of the feedstock to reduce the rate of them poisoning the catalysis in the cat-crackers where the different distillates are separated. Both processes can be found in refining of lighter Midwestern/Texas crude, but not to the same magnitude. Don't quote me, but I think the sulfur content of the oil sands was six to seven times that of Midwestern crude, and nitrogen at least three times that of the lighter oil. I may have them reversed too. I think metal removal to processing was a concern as well.

The Canadian oil sands also render a much higher level of bitumen (asphalt) that cannot be upgraded into fuels. In short, you have to put more energy into the Canadian oil sands for less converted energy out. The oil companies can make a profit at it. I think they are getting 5-6 times the amount of energy out for energy in. Midwest crude was up at around nine to one as a comparison.

What someone told me was that in the midwest, we were shipping the excess condensate to Canada where it is blended with the extracted oil for pipeline transport to US refineries. The condensate (drip as I remember it called) is stripped off, and sent back to Canada.

The real nastiness are the tailing ponds that have come about in areas where the oil extraction takes place. The extraction process takes large quantities of water which are really contaminated with all matter of things once they have come in contact with the oil. This is the big headache in this type of production. My neighbor a few years ago wrote a paper where the tailing ponds can be compacted by running power lines through them. The electrical field generated compacts the solids by 90% or better. They were looking into building a large scale installation for testing. I don't know where that went.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

China is going to get their oil from Russia by the looks of things.....

And from the East and South China seas if they have their way.....

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

You talk as though Americans are uneducated idiots. We are not. We know where beef, chicken meat and pork chops come from. We even know how sausage and bologna are made, and that rice contains arsenic.

We also know that as long as we continue to allow oil and gas companies to do anything and everything they want to the environment in order to extract fossil fuels that alternative sources will never be invented or found. The executives of these companies know their bones will be dust before the planet is depleted of the fossil sources, and they have the money and resources to move and live away from the areas they contaminate.

The one thing that outsourcing and offshore manufacturing has taught the people of America in the face of lack of employment and money is, there are other ways to get along and live. Didn't like it at first, but a sort of reset button has been set, and more attention paid to natural resources.

Native Americans and the First People of Canada have drawn a line in the sand; there is no where else to go. I have seen the results of a leak and seepage of tar sands on Canadian lands, and I can't understand anyone wanting it to cross US lands. It is a disgusting mess worthy of a Sci-Fy movie. Wherever it touches, the water and land are toxic unto eternity. IT. CANNOT. BE. CLEANED. UP.

For the sake of safety of the environment at large, it needs to be refined at the closest place of extraction. It certainly does not need to be transported over fertile land and aquifers.

Seriously folks, fight the fight, BUT FIGHT THE RIGHT FIGHT. THis is nothing but politics and you are ALL being played for a political bullshit game.

This is the right fight. Take a good, long look at the people here on NT who are saying, "No pipeline." Some of us can't agree that the sky is blue on a sunny day... but we are agreeing on this. Don't treat us as though we are ignorant children you are required to educate on the ways of the world. Some of us have worked in "politics" and some still do. Some of us have more experience in the game than you will ever know.

Want to know about Washington "politics?" Ask an Indian.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Much of the issue comes down to refining. There are but a handful of refineries that can handle these newer sources of oil. Three of which are in the Gulf states, and the fourth in Hammond, Indiana. They each process between 400k to 600k barrels per day.

The US uses close to 19 million barrels of oil per day. Building a refinery and getting it on line is very expensive. With Midwest/Texas crude supplies dwindling the gulf coast refineries have excess capacity. So..... we demand that refineries be built up north in the Dakotas closer to the source of crude production. There is no free lunch here any way you look at it. We either find a way to use less oil, or we find a way to produce it and refine it that impacts our way of life and environment the least.

I'm not in favor of the XL, but I'm realistic to know that to feed our need for oil, something has to give. The time to react was thirty years ago in fact.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

FLY, you are correct, and 30 years ago was the time to do something about it.

But, ''better late than never'' can apply here as well. To allow the oil companies to just do as they please is not in our best interests. There can be alternatives to a pipeline across the US. I'm not an expert in his, but I find it hard to believe that we, the U.S. cannot find alternatives to the pipeline. If the problem is refineries than, why doesn't Canada build one. Because it to expensive, seem to be the answer from them. Who is going to profit from it, of course Canada and the oil companies, so if they want the profit, take the risk and build one. Taking a risk and investing capital is done every day by business. I don't see this as anything different. The only difference is that they want the U.S. to take the risk with our environment and they get the profit.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

'' Want to know about Washington "politics?" Ask an Indian. ''

We do have a bit of experience when it comes to DC bullshit.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

S, it would be better to discuss the problem, ratherthan slinging shit about the U.S.

I happy that you think your above it all, and not an idiot. Sadly you are exactly what you think other people are.

If you chose to name call, and hold yourself as the supreme authority on all things, it would be best if you found another article to express your superior attitude.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

This stuff isn't your usual crude. I have been reading about it, and it is the most toxic to the environment. If there is a leak (never mind purposeful terrorism) on this pipeline, we could be killing people without them even knowing it, until it's too late. This actually happened in Russia,where entire villages were dying from toxic leakage.

What most people don't realize is that we have pipelines running throughout Canada and the US. That is bad enough. But they are carrying finished product.. not this sludge. Let the Canadians refine it and then move that pipeline away from our water supply. Mimi is right that after oil, water will become the thing we need the most.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago
  1. In the United States,stand-your-ground lawstates that an individual has no duty to retreat from any place he/she have a lawful right to be and may use any level of force, including lethal, if he/she reasonably believe he/she face an imminent and immediate threat of serious bodily harm or death.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I was thinking I know the politician pimp/whores take money from the pipeline profiteers to allow eminent domain but wouldn't it be interesting if land owners filed suit and/or stopped construction using the following

castle doctrine(also known as acastle lawor a defense of habitationlaw) is a legaldoctrinethat designates a person's abode (or, in some states, any legally occupied place [e.g., a vehicle or workplace]) as a place in which that person has certain protections and immunitiies

Or, to stretch it a bit in states where it's law (although I ordinarily think it should be repealed) how 'bout

stand-your-ground lawstates that an individual has no duty to retreat from any place he/she have a lawful right to be and may use any level of force, including lethal, if he/she reasonably believe he/she face an imminent and immediate threat of serious bodily harm or death.

I contend that a major pipeline breach could easily constitute "an imminent and immediate threat of serious bodily harm or death".

The defense rests.

Pro bono publico on this one.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

Good one Mac, I think that is what the Sioux in South Dakota plan on doing.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The only problem with this Brother is the word "Imminent".

You and I both know what that meaning is under the law.

And a pipeline does not qualify, especially one that hasn't been built yet.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

If it creates an "imminent" threat by its very presence, then the laws apply.

If I cited for the record, all of the documented pipeline breaches and called witnesses who were victimized, and, whose lives were changed in perpetuity (re: property, health issues and loss of life) as a direct consequence of pipeline breaches, I could make the case or "imminent."

Worth a try.

If I were to call as a witness, a "signed-on-to-the-pipeline-legislation" politician, and ask him, while he's under oath, if he would sign the affidavit (I was holding) stipulating that, "in the event of a pipeline breach, I accept, along with pipeline executives, culpability/liability for any/all resultant damages, etc. " even when the objection to my question is sustained the point will have been made.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

No one wants to hear the obvious way to reduce consumption... or at least one of them.

We can stop trying to feed the whole damn world. Let every country take care of its own and every population live or die by its own management of resources. Over population is the cancer that is demanding more and more of every resource from every productive nation, and every time a successful country allows hundreds of thousands of refugees in to take care of them, it only leaves a vacuum behind to be filled with more uneducated, unproductive people who will flee their circumstance when they are old enough to run.

Earth is only as big as it is right now... it's not going to grow and provide more space and more natural resources. Natural resources are finite. Natural resources are finite. There is an inability of even the most educated mind to understand that, or if they understand, they don't care.

Technology cannot keep expanding by drawing on natural resources. It is insane to think it can. At some point, the taking of natural resources has to stop, or mankind will stop. This pipe dream of flying off into the galaxy to some as yet undiscovered planet that we can consume and pollute the way we have Earth fuels the idea that it's okay to be parasites instead of stewards of our planet.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Hot damn, flame! We agree on something today!!

That makes you, Randy and myself agreeing on something... that alone should be an indicator of how evil this pipeline is. Only something with the potential to be so catastrophic could possibly bring the three of us together in agreement.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I'm sure it would be, and I would agree with it.

but we both know that it would be objected to and why.

Imminent means in a court of law, a clear, present and immediate danger to life & limb (and property in those states that allow such)

Immediate meaning right now. The objection would be sustained on the basis of "Out of scope"

I don't know if a jury would understand. With that argument on the record with a verdict in your favor would result in decades of appeals. While the issue destroys many others.

You would get quicker results with a gun standing the county line. and if enough of your neighbors were there with you, well, they very well can't have a massacre on their hands now could they? this is not the 1890's anymore.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

In a jury trial, a closing argument would be

"Members of the jury, I ask you to consider how you would answer the following: 'Would you want the Keystone XL or any other such pipeline to be constructed and active in proximity to your property or residence knowing that any resultant damage(s) would very likely require a protracted litigation, health-related issues and no guarantee of 'winning' or outlasting the deep-pockets, and behemoth legal-representation of a corporate giant?"

Later getting back to work but I'll be checking in and out.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

and in a jury trial, that closing argument would be disqualified, because it has NOTHING to do with the law.

Like I said, "OUT OF SCOPE"

It's psuedo jury nullification, which is inapplicable in a civil trial, if the judge allowed the question after the opposition objects, the trial gets thrown out on appeal. Guaranteed. Very high probability it gets overturned even if the judge does disallow the question.

Like I said, your client would be better off with guns at the border.

You would stand a better chance of winning.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

I disagree S.

Closing Argument: Only after the jury has seen and heard the factual evidence of the case are the parties allowed to try to persuade them about its overall significance. Closing arguments are the opportunity for each party to remind jurors about key evidence presented and to persuade them to adopt an interpretation favorable to their position. At this point, parties are free to use hypothetical analogies to make their points; to comment on the credibility of the witnesses, to discuss how they believe the various pieces of the puzzle fit into a compelling whole, and to advocate why jurors should decide the case in their favor.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Disagree.

The jurors would not be asked to disregard evidence, in this case, the inherent (imminent) danger of the pipeline. While the closing argument asks the jury to consider empathetically, it has nothing to do with their consciences they would not be asked to put the law on trial, rather, the potential consequences of imposing that law under a given set of conditions, that based on verified catastrophes when such a law was imposed.

But yeah, the gun thing

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Precisely why I stated it as a "closing argument."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

closing arguments must have relevance to the law, if the eminent domain is fundamentally legal, and if the process that was used to seek that eminent domain was correctly applied as per the law, then it is not a matter that is subject to civil action.

Driving a motor vehicle when properly licensed is fundamentally legal driving it on the sidewalk or into a crowd of pedestrians is not.

The law is not on trial here; the possible adverse situations because of the imposition of that law is the issue.

But just saying, "I don't want a pipeline in my backyard" is the legal equivalent of "I don't want my neighbour to get a brand spanking new Bently convertable because I don't like the obvious display of wealth".

Not quite I don't want my neighbor to put a gasoline tank and pump that he'll use to fill his Bently anywhere near my residence. It is inherently vulnerable to leakage, combustion, explosion, ground contamination.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The jury in any trial is not supposed to think empathically, which is I believe the point you are missing. This is a court of law, not an episode of the view.

Do you actually believe that jurors do not think and deliberate with empathy? Do you think a prosecuting attorney ever selects jurors based on how he/she thinks those jurors might identify/empathize with the victim(s) of a crime?

Stop watching The View sit in on a jury selection instead.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Closing arguments

Among other elements

Make the jury understand the total dimensions of the injuries, both now and over time. Underscore the dynamic nature of the injuries.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Public law litigation will often, at least as a practical matter, affect the interests of many people. Much significant public law litigation is therefore carried out through the class action mechanism a reason that will likely evoke juror empathy jurors are human beings no way around that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Ordinarily, a government can exercise eminent domain only if its taking will be for a "public use" - which may be expansively defined along the lines of public "safety, health, interest, or convenience". Perhaps the most common example of a "public use" is the taking of land to build or expand a public road or highway. Public use could also include the taking of land to build a school or municipal building, for a public park, or to redevelop a "blighted" property or neighborhood.

Since the pipeline product will not be of "direct (public) use" to U.S. consumers, rather, sold on the global market, and, is verifiably a potential threat to "safety, health, interest, or convenience" how does it comply with the standards?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I believe the New London case had to do with repurposing regarding commercial property but I will review it; thanks for the heads up.

The city was not taking the land simply to benefit a certain group of private individuals, but was following an economic development plan.

The Keystone Pipeline, IMO, does not constitute an "economic development program" for residents whose land would be crossed by the pipeline, rather, it's an economically expeditious plan for a private entity.

My opinion.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

It doesn't matter that the particular case was for a commercial endeavour, but only that it was essentially for the benefit of a private party.

Disagree; the point being that eminent domain for PRIVATE ECONOMIC vs. PUBLIC ECONOMIC development is not within its scope.

because the purpose of it is to ship crude to a refinery that would otherwise be shut down, causing the loss of several hundred jobs (this is specifically the Port Arthur refinery).

If saving jobs in private industry was the issue, what a can-o'-worms that would be. How many homes, farms, natural resources, churches, etc. could the government take under eminent domain to save the CEO and Executives (and workin' stiffs) at the Tasty Cake Factory.

Still disagree but it's a good discussion.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

The Lakota have said they will stand their ground. If Wakan Tonka allows my health to remain robust enough for the drive, I will stand with them. Enough is enough.

When my country's government told me in 1067 that over population was the number one crisis facing the planet and that responsible intelligent people should limit households to no more than two point five children in order to conserve resources for coming generations, most of my generation did the math, considered the consequences of large families such as our parents and grandparents had, and decided it was best to heed the caution.

In the meantime, millions of illegal aliens were swarming the back door while millions of legal immigrants and refugees were knocking down the front one, every one of a cultural and religious leaning that said, "Go forth and multiply." In addition, the government's social policies of paying unwed girls to have as many babies as possible with as many men as possible, relieving either mother or father of the responsibility of providing for them, increased the population on a massive scale and shows no sign of slowing down.

With the "Go Green" concept, there are many of us who have honestly cut back on energy consumption and found ways to reduce material needs. Yet there has been no honest search for alternative energy sources and never will be. It goes on and on until there are only a few humans left standing on each continent after the others have been killed off, and those who are left have to revert back to smoke signals for communication and walking for transportation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago
The SCOTUS decision was predicated on eminent domain being imposed for the purpose of public economic development. "Public" is the key word. That's not my opinion, it's the opinion of the Court.

Keystone XL is not a public entity. We still disagree and until the appeal process is exhausted, we won't know whose right here.

Further, the economic development took place where eminent domain was imposed; not so in Nebraska, etc. .We are at an impasse.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

This is the problem....

"Members of the jury, I ask you to consider how you would answer the following: 'Would you want the Keystone XL or any other such pipeline to be constructed and active in proximity to your property or residence...

He's asking for an opinion NOT based upon evidence or the law, he IS asking what they would want themselves.

Essentially he threw the case, law and evidence right out the window and wants a decision based upon how they personally feel.

Even Mac knows that you do not do that in closing arguments. this is why he originally said that it would be objected to and decided against. But his point was that it was out there for the jury to consider even though the judge is forced to tell the jury they cannot consider it. (pattern jury instructions)

Any judge I know, or worth his salt, would call a mistrial right then and there. And MAC KNOWS IT. If the judge let it go to judgment, it never makes it past appeal.

I can agree with his position completely, but the law is the law. All he has to do to get around this is add a couple of words....

"Members of the jury, I ask you to consider how you would answer the following: 'Given the evidence presented here today, would you want the Keystone XL or any other such pipeline to be constructed and active in proximity to your property or residence...

You see the difference? the same question is asked, but the juror is forced to consider his feelings against the actual evidence given the law as explained by the court. No Mistrial, No Appeal.

I've actually seen this happen in court, it is no joke and is very real. just those few little words changes the whole thing, and a good lawyer knows this.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

"Members of the jury, I ask you to consider how you would answer the following: 'Given the evidence presented here today,would you want the Keystone XL or any other such pipeline to be constructed and active in proximity to your property or residence...

And that's essentially how I would word it it would be prefaced with a statistical summary of pipeline catastrophes which would have been presented in testimony by an expert witness called by the plaintiffs.

The original version was generic.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

1) The law wasn't followed (whether by statutes or by case law)

The law, if imposed under a particular set of circumstances, based upon verifiable precedent, creates an on-going potential danger.

If that is not the underlying premise of the judge's ruling, how did we get to this point?

A Holt County, Nebraska District Court judge halted the proceedings.

TransCanada has suspended its eminent domain activity even among those who did not file suit, Huffington Post reported.

Further

in a statement from the group that has been front and center in opposition to the pipeline.

The pipeline has been contested since it was first proposed more than six years ago.

And what is the basis of the protest? It's either the law itself, or, thatthe law, if imposed under a particular set of circumstances, based upon verifiable precedent, creates an on-going potential danger.

But I'm open to any other explanations.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I am not an attorney but that's another story; I have represented a great many individuals in adverse actions against them irrelevant to this discussion.

If I have not made the case and that remains to be seen then on what basis did the judge halt the proceedings?

Facts can evoke emotions particularly when jurors can (again), empathize with victims or plaintiff-would-be-victims.

I explained the generic "closing statement," one that would be prefaced with a summary opening -- reviewing the testimony by expert witnesses regarding the history of pipeline breaches and the resultant devastation.

But again, why the ruling of this judge?

And again, can we declare an impasse and let the outcome determine which of us is correct or nearly so?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Do you think it's fair that a person is forced to give up a portion of their land so a foreign or domestic business

A great point; the Connecticut case was decided based on "public economic development," that would be the PUBLIC IN A TOWN IN AMERICA!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

No Max, it's isn't fair.

The SCOTUS decision, IMO stinks. Giving away someones land, against their will for acompany profitflies in the face of fair.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Thepowertotakeprivatepropertyforpublicusebyastate,municipality,orprivatepersonorcorporationauthorizedtoexercisefunctionsofpubliccharacter,followingthepaymentofjustcompensationtotheownerofthatproperty.

But after all of this,the judge made the ruling after landowners filed new lawsuits challenging the states pipeline routing law, which was narrowly upheld by the Nebraska Supreme Court in a decision last month.

But, but

The Obama administration is nearing the end of a process to determine whether Keystone XL is in the "national interest." This process for approving international pipelines has been handled since 1968 by the U.S. State Department and has been a prerogative of the executive branch since Ulysses S. Grant was president.

Since the Nebraska Supreme Court's decision five weeks ago, expectations have been that a presidential decision on the pipeline will be announced soon, possibly later this month, but more likely in early March. The latest ruling in Nebraska could delay that decision just as the original land-owners' lawsuit did.

"IN THE NATIONAL INTEREST" -- sort of akin to the Connecticut decision that hinged upon "public economic development/interests."

And good night for now.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

As seeded of this article, I declare an impasse...

Good points by all. Thank you.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

FOR CLARIFICATION:

We actually got involved in two discussions simultaneously and the line between them became blurred.

One of my early comments in the thread was a HYPOTHETICAL, positing howCASTLE DOCTRINE and STAND YOUR GROUND STATUTESmight be used by Nebraska et al land/homeowners to defend their properties against the XL "confiscation-with-compensation."

Nowhere Manresponded by arguing that in a court of law, the term "imminent" as in "imminent threat/danger" as it applies to those laws, could not be successfully argued and from there, the discussion evolved/devolved into various courtroom scenarios. Slartibartfast and I were actually debating two separate legal issues and he may be correct in some of his assertions. And I may be in some of mine.

Time will tell.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

''Time will tell.'' Yes it will.

The pipeline will have other battles to fight. It is currently scheduled to run though Sioux land in SD. Will E.D. tried tobe used on a Sovereign nation?

The tribes are totally against the pipeline.

 
 

Who is online


67 visitors