America's high-wage earners give generously
The first option was: Poor people have hard lives because government benefits dont go far enough to help them live decently.
The second option was: Poor people today have it easy because they can get government benefits without doing anything in return.
The study shows that respondents who have higher levels of financial security tend to agree more with the latter option. However, agreeing with the latter option simply does not translate to the conclusion that financially secure people believe poor people have it easy. If anything, the study shows that high-wage earners disagree with the notion that we need to spend even more coerced tax-payer dollars on government programs.
Second, the assumption that a lack of support for increased government programs shows a lack of compassion is not only an illogical leap, but it is also devoid of the basic understanding of the workings of government, as well as the true meaning of charity and compassion.
Government is not a charity, nor does it display compassion. Everything it gives to others it must first take from someone else. It would be an error to call someone uncompassionate because he or she does not believe in increasing the amount that government takes from others. Real compassion is giving from the heart and from one's own things and it is an admirable undertaking, nearly the opposite of coerced taking of property by the government.
Furthermore, to think that there are those who have no choice but to seek help from the government is patronizing and belittling to individuals abilities to make something of themselves without government handouts. Such ideology shows a lack of faith in mankind.
Third, the statement that the richest Americans ergo conservatives according to the article are the least compassionate group is factually wrong.
The average conservative-headed household donates 30 percent more to charity than the average liberal-headed household. Conservatives also donate more time to charity and give more blood
Tags
A. Macarthur
11 years agoThe average conservative-headed household donates 30 percent more to charity than the average liberal-headed household. Conservatives also donate more time to charity and give more blood
To primarily religion-based charities.
And FYI
Study: Conservatives and liberals are equally charitable, but they give to different charities
And
What the MIT researchers did find, however, was that conservatives give more to religious organizations, such as their own churches, and liberals more to secular recipients. Conservatives may give more overall, MIT says, but that's because they tend to be richer, so they have more money to give and get a larger tax benefit from giving it. (One of the things that makes social scientists skeptical of the benchmark survey Brooks used, in fact, is that it somehow concluded that liberals are richer than conservatives.)
The degree of religious contribution is important, because a 2007 study by Indiana University found that only 10% to 25% of church donations end up being spent on social welfare purposes, of which assistance to the poor is only a subset. In other words, if you think of "giving" as "giving to the poor," a lot of the money donated by conservatives may be missing the target.
An extreme case may have been that of Mitt Romney, whose tax disclosures during his 2012 presidential campaign indicated that he gave a higher percentage of his income away than his Democratic opponent, President Obama, 29.4% to 21.8%. Of course he was richer, so he gave away a lot more dollars. But fully 80% of Romney's donations went to the Mormon church; and a large further chunk went to a family foundation that also funneled much of it to the church.
The Obamas' contribution mostly went to humanitarian organizations like the Red Cross and the United Negro College Fund. In 2011 there weren't any general church donations, though $5,000 was listed to the Sidwell Friends School, which educates the Obama daughters.
The bottom line, according to the MIT study, was that "liberals are no more or less generous than conservatives once we adjust for differences in church attendance and income."
A. Macarthur
11 years agoConservatives also understand that the best way for able-bodied individuals to succeed is through their own hard work and perseverance, not reliance on government programs
Did you know companies like Wal-Mart that pay poverty wages consequently making many of its WORKING POOR employees eligible for food stamps; that means Wal-Mart in essence is subsidized BY TAX PAYER MONEY!
Walmart benefits from billions in government subsidies: Study
04/14/14 06:01 PM UPDATED 04/15/14 08:12 AM
Walmart is the beneficiary of billions of dollars per year in federal subsidies, according to a new report [PDF] from the non-partisan, progressive group Americans for Tax Fairness.
The report estimates that Walmart and the Walton familywhich co-founded the company and still owns a majority sharecollectively profit from nearly $7.8 billion per year in federal subsidies and tax breaks.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoof course the rich give more, they have more to give.
They also pay taxes at a lower rate than the middle class if they pay taxes at all.
The lower ones income, the higher ones overall effective state and local tax rate.
Combining all stateand local income, property, sales and excise taxes that Americans pay, the nationwide average effectivestate and local tax rates by income group are 10.9 percent for the poorest 20 percent of individuals andfamilies, 9.4 percent for the middle 20 percent and 5.4 percent for the top 1 percent.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoAmerica's high-wage earners give generously
Yeah; and Al Capone opened soup kitchens during the Depression.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoat some point, both sides will eventually have to come up with some new ideas, because the old rants that have been going on for how many years now, are just so fucking tired.
Completely agree; but until Boobus americana stops voting its race (all), religion (all), gender (both) and special interests, we will continue to piss into the wind.
The first know reference to the "dumbing of America" came from Ralph Waldo Emerson
"The mind of this country, taught to aim at low objects, eats upon itself."
Ralph Waldo Emerson offered that observation in 1837, but his words echo with painful prescience in today's very different United States. Americans are in serious intellectual trouble -- in danger of losing our hard-won cultural capital to a virulent mixture of anti-intellectualism, anti-rationalism and low expectations.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoOdd that you post a quote showing low expectations, because alas, the one that the left did vote for, pretty much has shown that even the lowest of expectations aren't going to be met.
Really?
Where were you during the "W" era?
1. "Our enemies are innovative and resourceful, and so are we. They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we."Washington, D.C., Aug. 5, 2004
2. "I know how hard it is for you to put food on your family."Greater Nashua, N.H., Chamber of Commerce, Jan. 27, 2000
3. "Rarely is the question asked: Is our children learning?"Florence, S.C., Jan. 11, 2000
4. "Too many good docs are getting out of the business. Too many OB/GYNs aren't able to practice their love with women all across the country."Poplar Bluff, Mo., Sept. 6, 2004
5. "Neither in French nor in English nor in Mexican."declining to answer reporters' questions at the Summit of the Americas, Quebec City, Canada, April 21, 2001
6. "You teach a child to read, and he or her will be able to pass a literacy test.''Townsend, Tenn., Feb. 21, 2001
7. "I'm the decider, and I decide what is best. And what's best is for Don Rumsfeld to remain as the secretary of defense."Washington, D.C., April 18, 2006
8. "See, in my line of work you got to keep repeating things over and over and over again for the truth to sink in, to kind of catapult the propaganda."Greece, N.Y., May 24, 2005
9. "I've heard he's been called Bush's poodle. He's bigger than that."discussing former British Prime Minister Tony Blair, as quoted by theSunnewspaper, June 27, 2007
10. "And so, General, I want to thank you for your service. And I appreciate the fact that you really snatched defeat out of the jaws of those who are trying to defeat us in Iraq."meeting with Army Gen. Ray Odierno, Washington, D.C., March 3, 2008
11. "We ought to make the pie higher."South Carolina Republican debate, Feb. 15, 2000
12. "There's an old saying in TennesseeI know it's in Texas, probably in Tennesseethat says, fool me once, shame onshame on you. Fool meyou can't get fooled again."Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002
13. "And there is distrust in Washington. I am surprised, frankly, at the amount of distrust that exists in this town. And I'm sorry it's the case, and I'll work hard to try to elevate it."speaking on National Public Radio, Jan. 29, 2007
14. "We'll let our friends be the peacekeepers and the great country called America will be the pacemakers."Houston, Sept. 6, 2000
15. "It's important for us to explain to our nation that life is important. It's not only life of babies, but it's life of children living in, you know, the dark dungeons of the Internet."Arlington Heights, Ill., Oct. 24, 2000
16. "One of the great things about books is sometimes there are some fantastic pictures."U.S. News & World Report, Jan. 3, 2000
17. "People say, 'How can I help on this war against terror? How can I fight evil?' You can do so by mentoring a child; by going into a shut-in's house and say I love you."Washington, D.C., Sept. 19, 2002
18. "Well, I think if you say you're going to do something and don't do it, that's trustworthiness."CNN online chat, Aug. 30, 2000
19. "I'm looking forward to a good night's sleep on the soil of a friend."on the prospect of visiting Denmark, Washington, D.C., June 29, 2005
20. "I think it's really important for this great state of baseball to reach out to people of all walks of life to make sure that the sport is inclusive. The best way to do it is to convince little kids how tothe beauty of playing baseball."Washington, D.C., Feb. 13, 2006
21. "Families is where our nation finds hope, where wings take dream."LaCrosse, Wis., Oct. 18, 2000
22. "You know, when I campaigned here in 2000, I said, I want to be a war president. No president wants to be a war president, but I am one."Des Moines, Iowa, Oct. 26, 2006
23. "There's a huge trust. I see it all the time when people come up to me and say, 'I don't want you to let me down again.' "Boston, Oct. 3, 2000
24. "They misunderestimated me."Bentonville, Ark., Nov. 6, 2000
25. "I'll be long gone before some smart person ever figures out what happened inside this Oval Office."Washington, D.C., May 12, 2008
We were having a good discussion until you went with the right-wing, Obama-hater pronouncement; AND AS USUAL, NOTHING SPECIFIC TO BACK IT UP.
A. Macarthur
11 years agooh wow, so now criticizing the sitting president is now a right wing pronouncement.
It is typically when a summary dismissal/pronouncement with no specifics is spewed!
I criticize BOTH sides, for pretty much the same thing, they both are depressing caricatures of leadership.
On which we agree. But when I castigate individual politicians, it is typically with specifics as to my reasons for doing so
So yeah, if you think that the Obama administration's success at furthering the US's economic decline,
Check the Wall Street numbers since Bush's tanked the economy and the numbers since. The Republicans have killed jobs bills and tried to undermine the recovery AND THE OBAMA ECONOMY HAS STILL CREATED JOBS FOR A RECORD NUMBER OF MONTHS, CORPORATE PROFITS ARE AT RECORD HIGHS your " SIMPLY DOING NOTHING" pronouncement is exactly what I'm talking about!
Deal with specifics not declarations that are false.
Meanwhile, back in America we havent had an official, declared policy of fiscal austerity b ut weve nonetheless had plenty of austerity in practice, thanks to the federal sequester and sharp cuts by state and local governments.
The good news is that we, too, seem to have stopped tightening the screws : Public spending isnt surging, but at least it has stopped falling. And the economy is doing much better as a result. We are finally starting to see the kind of growth, in employment and G.D.P., that we should have been seeing all along and the publics mood is rapidly improving.
Whats the important lesson from this late Obama bounce? Mainly, Id suggest, that everything youve heard about President Obamas economic policies is wrong.
You know the spiel: that the U.S. economy is ailing because Obamacare is a job-killer and the president is a redistributionist, that Mr. Obamas anti-business speeches (he hasnt actually made any, but never mind) have hurt entrepreneurs feelings, inducing them to take their marbles and go home.
You know the spiel: that the U.S. economy is ailing because Obamacare is a job-killer and the president is a redistributionist, that Mr. Obamas anti-business speeches (he hasnt actually made any, but never mind) have hurt entrepreneurs feelings, inducing them to take their marbles and go home.
And what this bounce tells you is that the alleged faults of Obamanomics had nothing to do with the pain we were feeling. We werent hurting because we were sick; we were hurting because we kept hitting ourselves with that baseball bat, and were feeling a lot better now that weve stopped.
Will this improvement in our condition continue? Britains government has declared its intention to pick up the baseball bat again to engage in further austerity, which does not bode well. But here the picture looks brighter. Households are in much better financial shape than they were a few years ago; theres probably still a lot of pent-up demand, especially for housing. And falling oil prices will be good for most of the country, although some regions especially Texas may take a hit.
So Im fairly optimistic about 2015, and probably beyond, as long as we avoid any more self-inflicted damage. Lets just leave that baseball bat lying on the ground, O.K.?
I'm happy to debate with those who disagree with me; but I don't allow platitudes, pronouncements and one-liners with no specifics to go unchallenged.
Make your case then give your declaration; otherwise, expect a rebuttal with the insistence that, going forward, if you're not addressing my points with counter-points, it's because you can't.
Peace.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoThere is no logical adjustment for religious donations. Religious organizations provide for much of the charity work that is done in this country.
Churches run tax exempt; religious schools in many cities get reduced utility rates.
What really angers the left about rich people giving to charity is that those dollars are taken from the control of big brother nanny state government and allocated as the private individual wishes instead. I too would give away a little more of my money if it meant that I could control who it went to and that big government then couldn't get as much of it.
Tell it to the Corporations, many of which NOT ONLY PAY NO FEDERAL INCOME TAX, BUT GET SUBSIDIES AS WELL! There's your MAJOR CHARITY CASES.
The working poor WORKING POOR like their children to eat.
Organized Wealth and its bought politicians have convinced a swath of the zeal-without-knowledge folk that the problem is the victim.
While poverty is often associated with joblessness, a significant proportion of the poor are actually employed. [1] [2] Largely because they are earning such low wages, the working poor face numerous obstacles that make it difficult for many of them to find and keep a job, save up money, and maintain a sense of self-worth. [3]
The stupidity of those who fail to understand the dynamics of the working poor and the economy is infuriating. If these workers were paid a living wage, they would not require food stamps, they'd have more to spend thus enhancing CONSUMERISM -- 70% OF THE U.S. ECONOMY -- which would further reduce the number of welfare recipients by creating more jobs, more profits, thus more tax revenue.
WAKE TF UP! These simplistic untruths appeal to non-thinkers who see everything as black and white.
Please, no bullshit response rebut what I explained with specifics or back off.
A. Macarthur
11 years ago Charities don't have buildings comparable to charities, nor schools, nor do they collect tithes, nor are they exclusionary in the way religions are;
Opponents argue that giving churches special tax exemptions violates the separation of church and state, and that tax exemptions are a privilege, not a constitutional right. They say that in tough economic times the government cannot afford what amounts to a subsidy worth billions of dollars every year. Read more.
Charities that run independently of sectarian activities are not thus subsidized for religious activities.
And the IRS rarely investigates churches for violating the political campaign ban. Nor do charities that have employees impose their religious beliefs a la Hobby Lobby, et al.
The Secular Coalition for America wants the Internal Revenue Service to revoke the tax-exempt status of religious organizations that violate 501(c)(3) rules by, for example, promoting political candidates or not using their funds for charitable purposes.
The coalition estimates that stringent enforcement of 501(c)(3) could generate up to $16.75 billion in additional annual revenue - almost enough to fund NASA for a year. Less conservative estimates, including an academic paper that pondered the fiscal implications of taxing all churches like for-profit corporations, put that number at $71 billion - enough to send a Mars Rover into space almost every two weeks.
Political candidates don't pander to charities BUT PANDER LIKE HELL TO RELIGIONS!
And then there's the parsonage exemption which allows clergy members to deduct their homes' upkeep, furnishings, and utilities, in addition to rent, mortgage payments or even the cable bill.
"One calculation of the resources expended by 271 U.S. congregations found that, on average, 'operating expenses' totaled 71 percent of all the expenditures of religions, much of that going to pay ministers' salaries,"
the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints only gave .7 percent of its annual income to charity between 1985 and 2008.
Shall I go on.
Big difference between a church and a charity.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoRonald Reagan was a real and great American President.
Shill much? Buy the myth much?
1. Reagan was a serial tax raiser. As governor of California, Reagan signed into law the largest tax increase in the history of any state up till then. Meanwhile, state spending nearly doubled . As president, Reagan raised taxes in seven of his eight years in office , including four times in just two years. As former GOP Senator Alan Simpson, who called Reagan a dear friend, told NPR, Ronald Reagan raised taxes 11 times in his administration I was there. Reagan was never afraid to raise taxes , said historian Douglas Brinkley, who edited Reagans memoir. Reagan the anti-tax zealot is false mythology, Brinkley said.
2. Reagan nearly tripled the federal budget deficit. During the Reagan years, the debt increased to nearly $3 trillion, roughly three times as much as the first 80 years of the century had done altogether. Reagan enacted a major tax cut his first year in office and government revenue dropped off precipitously. Despite the conservative myth that tax cuts somehow increase revenue, the government went deeper into debt and Reagan had to raise taxes just a year after he enacted his tax cut. Despite ten more tax hikes on everything from gasoline to corporate income, Reagan was never able to get the deficit under control.
3. Unemployment soared after Reagans 1981 tax cuts. Unemployment jumped to 10.8 percent after Reagan enacted his much-touted tax cut, and it took years for the rate to get back down to its previous level. Meanwhile, income inequality exploded . Despite the myth that Reagan presided over an era of unmatched economic boom for all Americans, Reagan disproportionately taxed the poor and middle class, but the economic growth of the 1980s did little help them. Since 1980, median household income has risen only 30 percent, adjusted for inflation, while average incomes at the top have tripled or quadrupled, the New York Times David Leonhardt noted .
4. Reagan grew the size of the federal government tremendously. Reagan promised to move boldly, decisively, and quickly to control the runaway growth of federal spending , but federal spending ballooned under Reagan. He bailed out Social Security in 1983 after attempting to privatize it, and set up a progressive taxation system to keep it funded into the future. He promised to cut government agencies like the Department of Energy and Education but ended up adding one of the largest the Department of Veterans Affairs , which today has a budget of nearly $90 billion and close to 300,000 employees . He also hiked defense spending by over $100 billion a year to a level not seen since the height of the Vietnam war.
5. Reagan did little to fight a womans right to choose. As governor of California in 1967, Reagan signed a bill to liberalize the states abortion laws that resulted in more than a million abortions . When Reagan ran for president, he advocated a constitutional amendment that would have prohibited all abortions except when necessary to save the life of the mother, but once in office, he never seriously pursued curbing choice.
6. Reagan was a bellicose peacenik. He wrote in his memoirs that [m]y dreambecame a world free of nuclear weapons. This vision stemmed from the presidents belief that the biblical account of Armageddon prophesied nuclear war and that apocalypse could be averted if everyone, especially the Soviets, eliminated nuclear weapons, the Washington Monthly noted . And Reagans military buildup was meant to crush the Soviet Union, but also to put the United States in a stronger position from which to establish effective arms control for the the entire world a vision acted out by Regeans vice president, George H.W. Bush, when he became president.
7. Reagan gave amnesty to 3 million undocumented immigrants. Reagan signed into law a bill that made any immigrant who had entered the country before 1982 eligible for amnesty. The bill was sold as a crackdown, but its tough sanctions on employers who hired undocumented immigrants were removed before final passage. The bill helped 3 million people and millions more family members gain American residency. It has since become a source of major embarrassment for conservatives.
8. Reagan illegally funneled weapons to Iran. Reagan and other senior U.S. officials secretly sold arms to officials in Iran , which was subject to a an arms embargo at the time, in exchange for American hostages. Some funds from the illegal arms sales also went to fund anti-Communist rebels in Nicaragua something Congress had already prohibited the administration from doing. When the deals went public, the Iran-Contra Affair, as it came to be know, was an enormous political scandal that forced several senior administration officials to resign.
9. Reagan vetoed a comprehensive anti-Apartheid act. which placed sanctions on South Africa and cut off all American trade with the country. Reagans veto was overridden by the Republican-controlled Senate. Reagan responded by saying I deeply regret that Congress has seen fit to override my veto, saying that the law will not solve the serious problems that plague that country.
10. Reagan helped create the Taliban and Osama Bin Laden. Reagan fought a proxy war with the Soviet Union by training, arming, equipping, and funding Islamist mujahidin fighters in Afghanistan. Reagan funneled billions of dollars, along with top-secret intelligence and sophisticated weaponry to these fighters through the Pakistani intelligence service. The Talbian and Osama Bin Laden a prominent mujahidin commander emerged from these mujahidin groups Reagan helped create, and U.S. policy towards Pakistan remains strained because of the intelligence services close relations to these fighters. In fact, Reagans decision to continue the proxy war after the Soviets were willing to retreat played a direct role in Bin Ladens ascendancy.
Keep 'em coming. I'm busy for the next few hours but I'll be back to challenge what needs to be challenged.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoRampant consumerism is really the core of our economic problems,
Until another economic model is established, what else fuels a healthy GNP?
I'll listen if you have ideas.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoIf the consumerism was balanced, it wouldn't be an issue, but the consumerism in the west isn't balanced. It has two spending zones (western europe, north america) and one creation zone (for the most part, China).
I agree; but short of a tariff on Chinese imports, what can we do other than to incentivize manufacturing in the U.S. . There was a repatriation bill from Democrats about a year or so ago to reward American businesses to mitigate outsourcing. The Republicans wouldn't allow it.
Cerenkov
11 years ago
A. Macarthur
11 years agoAre you suggesting high wage earners are criminal?
Did you notice how the Wall Street Banksters almost crashed the world economy, then, after they gambled with depositors money and lost, you and I bailed them out after which they gave themselves bonuses then made record profits and now their pimps control Congress and they're trying to end the regulations that would prevent a repeat of the near meltdown they caused.
"Envy" my ass. You just can't do a credible job of connecting the dots because of your myopic fixation on trying to discredit everything Obama. Do you think that isn't obvious?
Does the irony elude you?
The self-serving do the CYA thing, giving with one hand while taking more with the other.
And the middle class gets crumbs from the table.
Let 'em eat crumbs!
LynneA
11 years agoBrian,
Isn't this Op-ed from 2006? Instead of comparing "conservative-headed" and "liberal-headed" maybe we should just look at who's giving and who's not as a percentage of income to charity.
pat wilson
11 years agothe more religious and more conservative one is the more of their income, time, possessions, blood, etc. they give
Good, that will help offset the lost revenues from religious institutions due to their tax-exempt status.
Len
11 years agoThat mess was largely caused by Democratic Congress' generosity to unqualified home buyers via Fannie and Freddie. Your "banksters" just made the best of it.
Back when the housing mania was taking off, Massachusetts Congressman Barney Frank famously said he wanted Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to "roll the dice" in the name of affordable housing. He created laws that lowered lending standards, forced banks to lend with small or no down payments and, with ACORN's help, put pressure on them to do so. That directly caused the housing bubble, failed banking system and economic mess.
Theexecs of Fannie/Freddie were Democrat politicians who had exorbitant salaries. One was Barney Frank's "partner." Democrat congresspersons received the lion's share of Fannie and Freddie campaign contributions in return.
Obama was near the top of the list -- in fact second next to Chris Dodd:
A. Macarthur
11 years agoWith a little help from the people that got mortgages but couldn't afford them.
If you research it a bit, you'll find that the Banksters were responsible for that; instead of denying those individuals, the banks knowingly gambled, broke the mortgages into pieces called derivatives, sold them all over the place and lost the bet. And they were playing with depositors' money
And you and I bailed their criminal asses out and hardly anyone went to jail.
Stop making excuses for organized wealth.
Len
11 years ago100% wrong as I showed.
The "banksters" got the crumbs with the lion's share to the homeflippers and speculators whose profits were enabled by Democrat legislation. Fannie, Freddie, their execs and Dem politicians also benefited.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoSorry, Len. It was George W. Bush who named "THE OWNERSHIP SOCIETY" AND HIS REGULATORS WHO LOOKED THE OTHER WAY.
I'll nail down the deal for you tomorrow -- good night for now.
sixpick
11 years agoReagan raised taxes in seven of his eight years in office,
Now this is referring to when he was governor in California. As it turns out the Democrats held the state legislature for 7 of those 8 years, so I guess that is why he didn't have a perfect score.
When Reagan was president the House was controlled by the Democrats who are suppose to control the purse the entire time he was in office. It's true the Republicans held the Senate for 6 of the 8 years, but wonder if the situation he inherited and Volcker made some good decisions evidently to turn things around.
And another thing, why do the Democrats think Clinton's years were so great when the Republicans held the Senate and House for 6 out of his 8 his years in office?
I could go on, but why do it?
When in fact this article has gotten way off topic and I'm just a guilty as the next person.
Len
11 years agoYou are so out of touch and zealous that you are not worth responding to. Your motto is: "My mind is made up. Don 't bother me with facts."
If you took the trouble you could easily verify what I wrote in the message just below. I provided a link to the Fannie/Freddie campaign contributions. They were obtained by The Center for Responsive Politics, the nation's premier research group tracking money in U.S. politics and its effect on elections and public policy. Nonpartisan, independent and nonprofit, the organization aims to create a more educated voter, an involved citizenry and a more transparent and responsive government.
Here is the list spelled out: (Totals from Pacs and individuals, which show even more bribery, are off the page. Then can be seen from the link:
All Recipients of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Campaign Contributions, 1989-2008
| Name | Office | State | Party | Grand Total | Total from PACs | Total from Individuals |
| Dodd, Christopher J | S | CT | D | $165,400 | $48,500 | $116,900 |
| Obama, Barack | S | IL | D | $126,349 | $6,000 | $120,349 |
| Kerry, John | S | MA | D | $111,000 | $2,000 | $109,000 |
| Bennett, Robert F | S | UT | R | $107,999 | $71,499 | $36,500 |
| Bachus, Spencer | H | AL | R | $103,300 | $70,500 | $32,800 |
| Blunt, Roy | H | MO | R | $96,950 | $78,500 | $18,450 |
| Kanjorski, Paul E | H | PA | D | $96,000 | $57,500 | $38,500 |
| Bond, Christopher S Kit | S | MO | R | $95,400 | $64,000 | $31,400 |
| Shelby, Richard C | S | AL | R | $80,000 | $23,000 | $57,000 |
| Reed, Jack | S | RI | D | $78,250 | $43,500 | $34,750 |
| Reid, Harry | S | NV | D | $77,000 | $60,500 | $16,500 |
| Clinton, Hillary | S | NY | D | $76,050 | $8,000 | $68,050 |
| Davis, Tom | H | VA | R | $75,499 | $13,999 | $61,500 |
| Boehner, John | H | OH | R | $67,750 | $60,500 | $7,250 |
| Conrad, Kent | S | ND | D | $64,491 | $22,000 | $42,491 |
| Reynolds, Tom | H | NY | R | $62,200 | $53,000 | $9,200 |
| Johnson, Tim | S | SD | D | $61,000 | $20,000 | $41,000 |
| Pelosi, Nancy | H | CA | D | $56,250 | $47,000 | $9,250 |
| Carper, Tom | S | DE | D | $55,889 | $31,350 | $24,539 |
| Hoyer, Steny H | H | MD | D | $55,500 | $51,500 | $4,000 |
| Pryce, Deborah | H | OH | R | $55,500 | $45,000 | $10,500 |
| Emanuel, Rahm | H | IL | D | $51,750 | $16,000 | $35,750
|
Len
11 years agoBill Clinton Helped Cause The Housing Crisis.
September 27, 2008 05:21 PM EDT
The Community Reinvestment Act (or CRA, Pub.L. 95-128, title VIII, 91 Stat. 1147, 12 U.S.C. 2901 et seq.) is a United States federal law that requires banks and savings and loan associations to offer credit throughout their entire market area and prohibits them from targeting only wealthier neighborhoods with their services, a practice known as "redlining." The purpose of the CRA is to provide credit, including home ownership opportunities to underserved populations and commercial loans to small businesses. It has been subjected to important regulatory revisions.
The CRA was passed into law by the 95th United States Congress in 1977 as a result of national grassroots pressure for affordable housing, and despite considerable opposition from the mainstream banking community. The CRA mandates that each banking institution be evaluated to determine if it has met the credit needs of its entire community. That record is taken into account when the federal government considers an institution's application for deposit facilities, including mergers and acquisitions.
The bill encouraged the Federal National Mortgage Association, commonly known as Fannie Mae, to enable mortgage companies, savings and loans, commercial banks, credit unions, and state and local housing finance agencies to lend to home buyers. It also encouraged the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation, commonly known as Freddie Mac, to buy mortgages on the secondary market and sell them as mortgage-backed securities on the open market.
Enter Bill Clinton
In 1995, as a result of interest from President Bill Clinton's administration, the implementing regulations for the CRA were strengthened by focusing the financial regulators' attention on institutions' performance in helping to meet community credit needs.
These revisions with an effective starting date of January 31, 1995 were credited with substantially increasing the number and aggregate amount of loans to small businesses and to low- and moderate-income borrowers for home loans. These changes were very controversial and as a result, the regulators agreed to revisit the rule after it had been fully implemented for seven years. Thus in 2002, the regulators opened up the regulation for review and potential revision.
Part of the increase in home loans was due to increased efficiency and the genesis of lenders, like Countrywide, that do not mitigate loan risk with savings deposits as do traditional banks using the new subprime authorization. This is known as the secondary market for mortgage loans. The revisions allowed the securitization of CRA loans containing subprime mortgages. The first public securitization of CRA loans started in 1997 by Bear Stearns. The number of CRA mortgage loans increased by 39 percent between 1993 and 1998, while other loans increased by only 17 percent.
Other rule changes gave Fannie and Freddie extraordinary leverage, allowing them to hold just 2.5% of capital to back their investments, vs. 10% for banks. By 2007, Fannie and Freddie owned or guaranteed nearly half of the $12 trillion U.S. mortgage market. Thus leading us to the problems of today.
Just like all other administrations, the effect of a presidency often isn't felt until after he leaves office. Clinton reaped the benefits of the Reagan/Bush era, and George W. Bush, and Barack Obama had to deal with the problems created by their predecessor.
Len
11 years agoBarney Frank: Yes, I Once Helped My Domestic Partner Find Work At Fannie Mae
May 26, 2011, 4:57 PM 4353
Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA) confirmed on Thursday that he helped his former domestic partner secure a job at Fannie Mae, an institution that Frank was entrusted with overseeing as a member of the House Financial Services Committee.
The story was first reported in a new book on the 2008 financial crisis by reporter Gretchen Morgensen, Reckless Endangerment. According to Morgensen, Frank talked up then-partner Herb Moses qualifications to Fannie Mae executives in 1991 to help him score a job with the mortgage giant. Frank later took Fannie Maes side against claims it had grown dangerously large repeatedly during his time on the committee, which he eventually took over as chairman in 2007.
In an interview with the Boston Herald, Frank confirmed the account, saying he was approached by Fannie Mae first about Moses and that he vouched for his qualifications. However, he denied there was anything improper about the exchange.
If it is [a conflict of interest], then much of Washington is involved [in conflicts], Frank said. It is a common thing in Washington for members of Congress to have spouses work for the federal government. There is no rule against it at all.
Len
11 years agoLawmaker Accused of Fannie Mae Conflict of Interest
Written By Bill Sammon
Published October 03, 2008
FoxNews.com
Unqualified home buyers were not the only ones who benefitted from Massachusetts Rep. Barney Franks efforts to deregulate Fannie Mae throughout the 1990s.
So did Franks partner, a Fannie Mae executive at the forefront of the agencys push to relax lending restrictions.
Now that Fannie Mae is at the epicenter of a financial meltdown that threatens the U.S. economy, some are raising new questions about Frank's relationship with Herb Moses, who was Fannies assistant director for product initiatives. Moses worked at the government-sponsored enterprise from 1991 to 1998, while Frank was on the House Banking Committee, which had jurisdiction over Fannie.
Both Frank and Moses assured the Wall Street Journal in 1992 that they took pains to avoid any conflicts of interest. Critics, however, remain skeptical.
"Its absolutely a conflict," said Dan Gainor, vice president of the Business & Media Institute. "He was voting on Fannie Mae at a time when he was involved with a Fannie Mae executive. How is that not germane?
"If this had been his ex-wife and he was Republican, I would bet every penny I have - or at least whats not in the stock market - that this would be considered germane," added Gainor, a T. Boone Pickens Fellow. "But everybody wants to avoid it because hes gay. Its the quintessential double standard."
A top GOP House aide agreed.
"Cmon, he writes housing and banking laws and his boyfriend is a top exec at a firm that stands to gain from those laws?" the aide told FOX News. "No media ever takes note? Imagine what would happen if Franks political affiliation was R instead of D? Imagine what the media would say if [GOP former] Chairman [Mike] Oxleys wife or [GOP presidential nominee John] McCains wife was a top exec at Fannie for a decade while they wrote the nations housing and banking laws."
Franks office did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Frank met Moses in 1987, the same year he became the first openly gay member of Congress.
"I am the only member of the congressional gay spouse caucus," Moses wrote in the Washington Post in 1991. "On Capitol Hill, Barney always introduces me as his lover."
The two lived together in a Washington home until they broke up in 1998, a few months after Moses ended his seven-year tenure at Fannie Mae, where he was the assistant director of product initiatives. According to National Mortgage News, Moses "helped develop many of Fannie Maes affordable housing and home improvement lending programs."
Critics say such programs led to the mortgage meltdown that prompted last months government takeover of Fannie Mae and its financial cousin, Freddie Mac. The giant firms are blamed for spreading bad mortgages throughout the private financial sector.
Although Frank now blames Republicans for the failure of Fannie and Freddie, he spent years blocking GOP lawmakers from imposing tougher regulations on the mortgage giants. In 1991, the year Moses was hired by Fannie, the Boston Globe reported that Frank pushed the agency to loosen regulations on mortgages for two- and three-family homes, even though they were defaulting at twice and five times the rate of single homes, respectively.
Three years later, President Clintons Department of Housing and Urban Development tried to impose a new regulation on Fannie, but was thwarted by Frank. Clinton now blames such Democrats for planting the seeds of todays economic crisis.
"I think the responsibility that the Democrats have may rest more in resisting any efforts by Republicans in the Congress or by me when I was president, to put some standards and tighten up a little on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac," Clinton said recently.
Bill Sammon is FOX News' Washington Deputy Managing Editor.
Len
11 years agoBush, McCain Tried To Reform Freddie Mac
First, from a disapproving New York Times :
New Agency Proposed to Oversee Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae
By STEPHEN LABATON
September 11, 2003
The Bush administration today recommended the most significant regulatory overhaul in the housing finance industry since the savings and loan crisis a decade ago.
Under the plan, disclosed at a Congressional hearing today, a new agency would be created within the Treasury Department to assume supervision of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored companies that are the two largest players in the mortgage lending industry .
The new agency would have the authority, which now rests with Congress, to set one of the two capital-reserve requirements for the companies. It would exercise authority over any new lines of business. And it would determine whether the two are adequately managing the risks of their ballooning portfolios.
The plan is an acknowledgment by the administration that oversight of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac which together have issued more than $1.5 trillion in outstanding debt is broken. A report by outside investigators in July concluded that Freddie Mac manipulated its accounting to mislead investors, and critics have said Fannie Mae does not adequately hedge against rising interest rates .
There is a general recognition that the supervisory system for housing-related government-sponsored enterprises neither has the tools, nor the stature, to deal effectively with the current size, complexity and importance of these enterprises, Treasury Secretary John W. Snow told the House Financial Services Committee in an appearance with Housing Secretary Mel Martinez, who also backed the plan.
Mr. Snow said that Congress should eliminate the power of the president to appoint directors to the companies, a sign that the administration is less concerned about the perks of patronage than it is about the potential political problems associated with any new difficulties arising at the companies.
The administrations proposal, which was endorsed in large part today by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, would not repeal the significant government subsidies granted to the two companies. And it does not alter the implicit guarantee that Washington will bail the companies out if they run into financial difficulty; that perception enables them to issue debt at significantly lower rates than their competitors. Nor would it remove the companies exemptions from taxes and antifraud provisions of federal securities laws .
The proposal is the opening act in one of the biggest and most significant lobbying battles of the Congressional session.
After the hearing, Representative Michael G. Oxley, chairman of the Financial Services Committee, and Senator Richard Shelby, chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, announced their intention to draft legislation based on the administrations proposal. Industry executives said Congress could complete action on legislation before leaving for recess in the fall.
The current regulator does not have the tools, or the mandate, to adequately regulate these enterprises, Mr. Oxley said at the hearing. We have seen in recent months that mismanagement and questionable accounting practices went largely unnoticed by the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight, the independent agency that now regulates the companies.
These irregularities, which have been going on for several years, should have been detected earlier by the regulator, he added.
The Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight, which is part of the Department of Housing and Urban Development, was created by Congress in 1992 after the bailout of the savings and loan industry and concerns about regulation of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which buy mortgages from lenders and repackage them as securities or hold them in their own portfolios.
At the time, the companies and their allies beat back efforts for tougher oversight by the Treasury Department, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation or the Federal Reserve. Supporters of the companies said efforts to regulate the lenders tightly under those agencies might diminish their ability to finance loans for lower-income families . This year, however, the chances of passing legislation to tighten the oversight are better than in the past.
Reflecting the changing political climate, both Fannie Mae and its leading rivals applauded the administrations package. The support from Fannie Mae came after a round of discussions between it and the administration and assurances from the Treasury that it would not seek to change the companys mission.
After those assurances, Franklin D. Raines, Fannie Maes chief executive, endorsed the shift of regulatory oversight to the Treasury Department, as well as other elements of the plan.
We welcome the administrations approach outlined today, Mr. Raines said. The company opposes some smaller elements of the package, like one that eliminates the authority of the president to appoint 5 of the companys 18 board members.
Company executives said that the company preferred having the president select some directors. The company is also likely to lobby against the efforts that give regulators too much authority to approve its products .
Freddie Mac, whose accounting is under investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission and a United States attorney in Virginia, issued a statement calling the administration plan a responsible proposal.
The stocks of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae fell while the prices of their bonds generally rose. Shares of Freddie Mac fell $2.04, or 3.7 percent, to $53.40, while Fannie Mae was down $1.62, or 2.4 percent, to $66.74. The price of a Fannie Mae bond due in March 2013 rose to 97.337 from 96.525.Its yield fell to 4.726 percent from 4.835 percent on Tuesday.
Fannie Mae, which was previously known as the Federal National Mortgage Association, and Freddie Mac, which was the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation, have been criticized by rivals for exerting too much influence over their regulators.
The regulator has not only been outmanned, it has been outlobbied , said Representative Richard H. Baker, the Louisiana Republican who has proposed legislation similar to the administration proposal and who leads a subcommittee that oversees the companies. Being underfunded does not explain how a glowing report of Freddies operations was released only hours before the managerial upheaval that followed. This is not world-class regulatory work.
Significant details must still be worked out before Congress can approve a bill. Among the groups denouncing the proposal today were the National Association of Home Builders and Congressional Democrats who fear that tighter regulation of the companies could sharply reduce their commitment to financing low-income and affordable housing.
These two entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are not facing any kind of financial crisis, said Representative Barney Frank of Massachusetts, the ranking Democrat on the Financial Services Committee. The more people exaggerate these problems, the more pressure there is on these companies, the less we will see in terms of affordable housing.
Representative Melvin L. Watt, Democrat of North Carolina, agreed.
I dont see much other than a shell game going on here, moving something from one agency to another and in the process weakening the bargaining power of poorer families and their ability to get affordable housing, Mr. Watt said.
And three years later, from the Congressional Record :
FEDERAL HOUSING ENTERPRISE REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2005
The United States Senate
May 25, 2006
Sen. John McCain [R-AZ]: Mr. President, this week Fannie Maes regulator reported that the companys quarterly reports of profit growth over the past few years were illusions deliberately and systematically created by the companys senior management, which resulted in a $10.6 billion accounting scandal.
The Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversights report goes on to say that Fannie Mae employees deliberately and intentionally manipulated financial reports to hit earnings targets in order to trigger bonuses for senior executives. In the case of Franklin Raines, Fannie Maes former chief executive officer, OFHEOs report shows that over half of Mr. Raines compensation for the 6 years through 2003 was directly tied to meeting earnings targets. The report of financial misconduct at Fannie Mae echoes the deeply troubling $5 billion profit restatement at Freddie Mac.
The OFHEO report also states that Fannie Mae used its political power to lobby Congress in an effort to interfere with the regulators examination of the companys accounting problems. This report comes some weeks after Freddie Mac paid a record $3.8 million fine in a settlement with the Federal Election Commission and restated lobbying disclosure reports from 2004 to 2005. These are entities that have demonstrated over and over again that they are deeply in need of reform.
For years I have been concerned about the regulatory structure that governs Fannie Mae and Freddie Macknown as Government-sponsored entities or GSEsand the sheer magnitude of these companies and the role they play in the housing market. OFHEOs report this week does nothing to ease these concerns. In fact, the report does quite the contrary. OFHEOs report solidifies my view that the GSEs need to be reformed without delay .
I join as a cosponsor of the Federal Housing Enterprise Regulatory Reform Act of 2005, S. 190, to underscore my support for quick passage of GSE regulatory reform legislation. If Congress does not act, American taxpayers will continue to be exposed to the enormous risk that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac pose to the housing market, the overall financial system, and the economy as a whole .
I urge my colleagues to support swift action on this GSE reform legislation.
Alas, thanks to the Democrat Party and the special interests of the left, both of these attempts to reform the banking system were still born.
But isnt it funny how our watchdog media have missed these two stories?
Related Articles:
This article was posted by Steve Gilbert on Wednesday, September 17th, 2008
Len
11 years agoWhere are Franklin Raines, Tim Howard and Jim Johnson today?
You know the three who helped bring down Wall Street?
All three former Fannie Mae executives who helped cause trillion dollar bailouts?
Franklin Raines was a Chairman and Chief Executive Officer at Fannie Mae. Raines was forced to retire from his position with Fannie Mae when auditing discovered severe irregularities in Fannie Maes accounting activities. Raines left with a golden parachute valued at $240 Million in benefits. The Government filed suit against Raines when the depth of the accounting scandal became clear.
Tim Howard was the Chief Financial Officer of Fannie Mae. Howard was a strong internal proponent of using accounting strategies that would ensure a stable pattern of earnings at Fannie. Investigations by federal regulators and the companys board of directors since concluded that management did manipulate 1998 earnings to trigger bonuses. Raines and Howard resigned under pressure in late 2004. Howards Golden Parachute was estimated at $20 Million!
Jim Johnson A former executive at Lehman Brothers and who was later forced from his position as Fannie Mae CEO. Investigators found that Fannie Mae had hidden a substantial amount of Johnsons 1998 compensation from the public, reporting that it was between $6 million and $7 million when it fact it was $21 million. Johnson is currently under investigation for taking illegal loans from Countrywide while serving as CEO of Fannie Mae. Johnsons Golden Parachute was estimated at $28 Million.
ARE THEY IN JAIL TODAY?
NOPE!
And they ARE NOT working for Barack Obama today as reported to me yesterday see below.
FRANKLIN RAINES?
Raines works for the Obama Campaign as his Chief Economic Advisor.
TIM HOWARD?
Howard is a Chief Economic Advisor to Obama under Franklin Raines.
JIM JOHNSON?
Johnson was hired as a Senior Obama Finance Advisor and was selected to run Obamas Vice Presidential Search Committee.
Here is the base to that rumor how it started and how it was perpetuated according to Wiki.
On 16 July 2008 The Washington Post reported that Franklin Raines had taken calls from Barack Obamas presidential campaign seeking his advice on mortgage and housing policy matters..[25] Also, in an editorial on August 27, 2008 titled Tough Decision Coming, the Washington Post editorial staff wrote that Two members of Mr. Obamas political circle, James A. Johnson and Franklin D. Raines, are former chief executives of Fannie Mae. On September 18, 2008, John McCains campaign published a campaign ad that quoted the Washington Post reporting regarding Raines and Obama. The ad also notes that Raines made millions and then left Fannie Mae while it was under investigation for accounting irregularities.[26]
Neither Raines nor the Obama campaign had disputed the Posts reporting before the ad. The text in question consisted of one sentence in each article. After McCains ad however, both denied that Raines was or had been a provider of advice to Obama or the Obama campaign.[27][28][29]
Len
11 years agoThose cut and paste articles are EVIDENCE.
By contrast all you contribute are ASSERTIONS WITHOUT ANY PROOF WHATSOEVER.
You don't even make any ATTEMPTS to prove your bull. That is good enough for your sycophants.
Len
11 years agoI wrote you this before and here it is again:
The recession was largely caused by Democratic Congress' generosity to unqualified home buyers via Fannie and Freddie. The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), designed to provide affordable housing through Fannie and Freddie, was originally passed in 1977.
Jimmie Carter was president and Congress was Democratic -- both houses -- not G. W. Bush.
Not satisfied, with the number of beneficiaries, the Clinton Administration "enhanced" it in 1995 to reach more low and moderate-income borrowers. Back when the housing mania was taking off, Massachusetts Congressman Barney Frank famously said he wanted Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to "roll the dice" in the name of affordable housing. He created laws that lowered lending standards, forced banks (and therefore mortgage brokers) to lend with small or no down payments and, with ACORN's help, put pressure on them to do so.
Also before W. Bush!
Aeonpax
11 years agoActually this is an opinion piece taken from the Washington Examiner on January 17, of this year. It was written by a person named Jiesi Zhao, a member of the ultra conservative group, Young America's Foundation .
A. Macarthur
11 years agoThe banks suckered many borrowers into mortgage commitments with the sub-prime rates KNOWING THE MORTGAGEES WOULD LIKELY DEFAULT DOWN THE ROAD.
They then broke the mortgages into pieces called derivatives and sold them with the idea that when the defaults came, the derivative holders would be screwed!
THE BANKSTERS BET ON THE DEFAULTS! They and the mortgagees and the derivative-holders ALL LOST -- WHICH IS WHY THE ECONOMY TANKED ACROSS THE GLOBE.
The U.S. subprime mortgage crisis was a nationwide banking emergency that coincided with the U.S. recession of December 2007 June 2009. [1] It was triggered by a large decline in home prices, leading to mortgage delinquencies and foreclosures and the devaluation of housing-related securities. Declines in residential investment preceded the recession and were followed by reductions in household spending and then business investment. Spending reductions were more significant in areas with a combination of high household debt and larger housing price declines. [2]
The expansion of household debt was financed with mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and collateralized debt obligations (CDO), which initially offered attractive rates of return due to the higher interest rates on the mortgages; however, the lower credit quality ultimately caused massive defaults. [3] While elements of the crisis first became more visible during 2007, several major financial institutions collapsed in September 2008, with significant disruption in the flow of credit to businesses and consumers and the onset of a severe global recession. [4]
There were many causes of the crisis, with commentators assigning different levels of blame to financial institutions, regulators, credit agencies, government housing policies, and consumers, among others . [5]
A proximate cause was the rise in subprime lending. The percentage of lower-quality subprime mortgages originated during a given year rose from the historical 8% or lower range to approximately 20% from 2004 to 2006, with much higher ratios in some parts of the U.S. [6] [7] A high percentage of these subprime mortgages, over 90% in 2006 for example, were adjustable-rate mortgages . [4] These two changes were part of a broader trend of lowered lending standards and higher-risk mortgage products. [4] [8] Further, U.S. households had become increasingly indebted, with the ratio of debt to disposable personal income rising from 77% in 1990 to 127% at the end of 2007, much of this increase mortgage-related. [9]
Originating banks allowed borrowers to say or to state or to lie about their income and no proof was required to back up what was said or stated or lied about.
Loan officers were the grand facilitators and front-line perpetrators of this fraud. On a refinance, the loan officer simply looked at a particular borrowers credit report, added up the debt payments on credit cards, car loans, and mortgages, and created an income figure which made the debts affordable including the new mortgage. A purchase worked exactly the same way. The income was a derivative of the amount the borrower wanted to spend to buy their new home. Many borrowers were not innocent, but other borrowers were playing on a field where they had no experience. They could easily be lead to believe in the acceptability of this criminal fraud.
Read more:
Where you and I agree is (I think it was you who wrote), "It takes two to tango." BUT THE BANKS KNEW THEY WERE LOOKING THE OTHER WAY TO SET UP THE SCAM.
And there were whistleblowers who were ignored
Fraud and folly: The untold story of General Electrics subprime debacle
FLYNAVY1
11 years agoThe weakening of regulations outlined in Glass-Steagall from the 1960s on at every turn was instrumental in the 2008-2009 financial crisis. As more and more of the regulations were ammended, or removed all together, it allowed the culture within commercial banks to mirror that of the "High Risk/Reward" speculative betting that took place on Wall Street.
Toss in shoddy mortgage underwriting, shadow banks, banks entering into risks they didn't understand or knew that the taxpayers were on the hook for in any event, along with just plain greed, opened a Pandora's box of trouble that will be with us for a very long time.
Unfortunately....... it will happen again as things stand today.
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoI ran across this break down of giving that shows a fairly clear picture of charitable giving across levels if adjusted gross income -
3. Giving as a percentage of adjusted gross income by income level (from itemizers only)Data from the IRSs 2011 Statistics of Income (SOI) file on individuals who itemize on their tax return shows a U-shaped relationship between total adjusted gross income (AGI) and charitable giving as a percentage of AGI. In other words, those at either the high end or low end of the income distribution tend to give a higher percentage of their income as contributions than those in the middle.
In broad strokes, those with income between $100,000 and $200,000 contribute, on average, 2.6 percent of their income, which is lower compared to those with income either below $100,000 (3.6 percent) or above $200,000 (3.1 percent).[1] The effect is even more severe at the extremes, as seen in the figure below.[2]
A. Macarthur
11 years agoThe derivatives sit on top of the mortgages, the mortgages don't get sliced.
You are correct about the underlying value but the insidious strategy I outlined is nevertheless what occurred; in reality, once the mortgages were sliced into derivatives, technically, the original mortgage holder could not produce the mortgage if asked to do so.
Because financial derivatives are cash flows, once the ARMs went up and the defaults started, it was game-over AND WE BAILED OUT THEIR CRIMINAL ASSES!
LynneA
11 years agoAeon, thanks for the sourcing. The only reference I could find was through the "donates 30 percent more..." highlight and it links to an ABC article dated November 2006 indicating the data would be aired on 20/20.
Brian, you really need to correctly source your information.
LynneA
11 years agoRobert, great posting!
One of the reasons I put up the Huffington Post link is to look at historical data from 2006 thru 2012. With any data, a year is a snapshot in time, not providing enough accurate data to draw a conclusion or formulate an informed opinion.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoIf there were that many suckers, then that pretty much says a LOT about america, and especially the idea that the GOP puts forth about the Nanny state.
When a financial or other institution commits a felony and blames it on the gullibility, or ignorance of the victims, I see a problem there.
GUARANTEEING THAT IT IS GOING TO HAPPEN AGAIN.
As in repealing the safeguards in Dodd-Frank like the Republicans are trying to do?
And Lehman Brothers was among the multiple causes.
The Prime Culprit In 2003 and 2004, with the U.S. housing boom (read, bubble) well under way, Lehman acquired five mortgage lenders, including subprime lender BNC Mortgage and Aurora Loan Services, which specialized in Alt-A loans (made to borrowers without full documentation). Lehman's acquisitions at first seemed prescient; record revenues from Lehman's real estate businesses enabled revenues in the capital markets unit to surge 56% from 2004 to 2006, a faster rate of growth than other businesses in investment banking or asset management. The firm securitized $146 billion of mortgages in 2006, a 10% increase from 2005. Lehman reported record profits every year from 2005 to 2007. In 2007, the firm reported net income of a record $4.2 billion on revenue of $19.3 billion. (Check out the answer to our frequently asked question What is a subprime mortgage? to learn more about these loans.)
Further
An attempt by the CFTC to regulate OTC derivatives in 1998 was rejected by Alan Greenspan, then Chairman of the Federal Reserve, Robert E. Rubin, then Secretary of the Treasury, and Lawrence (Larry) H. Summers, then Assistant Secretary of the Treasury .
At the time, regulation ran counter to the dominant ideology in Washington D.C., which reflected the views and interests of the banking and financial services industry.
We're not going to agree so let's call an IMPASSE.
You can have the last word.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoMortgage fraud is a crime in which the intent is to materially misrepresent or omit information on a mortgage loan application to obtain a loan or to obtain a larger loan than would have been obtained had the lender or borrower known the truth.
So, we're in agreement there. But
Mortgage fraud is not to be confused with predatory mortgage lending , which occurs when a consumer is misled or deceived by agents of the lender. However, predatory lending practices often co-exist with mortgage fraud.
Why Prosecutors Whiffed on Subprime Crime
Economic Threat : As observed last year : The greatest triumph of the banking industry wasnt ATMs or even depositing a check via the camera of your mobile phone. It was convincing Treasury and Justice Department officials that prosecuting bankers for their crimes would destabilize the global economy.
With trillions invested in bailing out the banks, the possibility of undoing that might have scared prosecutors out of their roles of enforcers of law, and into the dubious position of economic forecasters. It was a colossal failure of duty, and just plain dumb.
As before, let's call an impasse; I offered you the last word and you posted a comment to which I needed to respond. Again, the last word is yours -- but don't make it a question or comment about me personally.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoIs that because you aren't interested in the economics, or is it that you are only interested in the political argument (which is the LEAST INTERESTING part).
Do you really believe that economics and politics are independent of one another -- that corporations writing the language of the very loopholes from which they directly benefit, and, that subsidize the very legislators who might call them out, and, the same corporations who help elect the people who appoint regulators do you believe that they are corporation-neutral?
We don't agree.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoOh and by the way, the reality is that BOTH parties, LEFT AND RIGHT (if left and right even mean anything anymore), have been nothing but hindrances on solving the problems that we face.
At last we agree although the hindrances are not the same.
And seriously, did you even bother to look at this article ...
...... or did you bypass it because it wasn't political enough.
You do like to make it personal.
FROM YOUR ARTICLE YOUR ARTICLE
Additionally, this also does not mean that we get government out of this, because, and this is unfortunate, it needs to be yet again said, it was the private sector that got us into this mess in the first place, though the government DID have a strong helping hand.
So, we agree again somewhat.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoI KNOW you are better than that, that's what is so disappointing.
I certainly don't have your knowledge of economics, but I know politics (I was in it myself back in the '80s and 90's) and I stand by the inseparability of money, monetary policy, corporate/lobby purchasing power (of elected officials) and the symbiotic (mutualism) nature os "the deal".
I agree both sides are culpable but I'm a realist; I'll side with the politicians who want to fuck over Organized Wealth on behalf of the poor and middle class rather than those who want to give more to those who have the most.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoThey only pretend that they are interested in fucking over organized wealth.
Agree again; but the crumbs from their table fall to me. The other guys own the bakery, set the price and eat most of the "cake" -- any crumbs that drop from their table are either by accident, or, bird feed.
The game is rigged against the middle class; we get just enough so as not to take to the streets and as you may have noticed the streets are starting to fill from time-to-time, and, more frequently.
And hey, while you don't think much of my "economics," check my artwork some time.
ArkansasHermit
11 years agoOK , I'll bite . Who or what are they ?
Just google todays breaking news Petey and pick your favorite source in pursuit of your answer.
"80 own more than 50 % of the world's wealth"
Seems the richest 80 people in the world now own half of everything, while the other 7 billion + of us are left to strugglefor the rest, and the problem just continues to increases in favor of the Organized wealthy.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoPetey,
If you're willing to have a discussion on this, I'll respond.
Basically, I refer to what has been called, "The 1%".
An example;
Public attention on right-wing funding in political campaigns has been galvanized by the attack on working people in Wisconsin by an ultraconservative governor out to crush labor unions.
Funders such as the Koch Brothers and right-wing institutions such as the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), have been explored by numerous progressive groups.
There is, however, a much larger elaborate strategic right-wing process at work here. It started with the Powell Memo in 1971 urging corporations and wealthy elites to defend the "Free Market" against "Tax & Spend" liberals, "Big Government" progressives, and "Thugish" union leaders. These slogans are part of a carefully-crafted propaganda campaign by organized wealth.
And this massive campaign by organized wealth is just part of the more than $1 Billion spent by right-wing funders since 1971 to shift wealth upwards, pick our pockets, and stomp on the basic human rights of most of us. Their strategy is simple, and they openly brag about it....
Cut taxes, especially for the wealthy, to "starve" federal, state, and local governments until their ability to serve our needs is wrecked.
I have endless specifics as long as the dialogue doesn't get personal.
Petey Coober
11 years agoA Mac ,
The 1% are NOT a stable group . Nor are the 0.1% . Very few of them remain in that percentile ranking from 1 year to the next . That should tell you that you are mistaken about them being organized ... but you'll probably throw in some leftist propaganda at this point .
A. Macarthur
11 years agoVery few of them remain in that percentile ranking from 1 year to the next . That should tell you that you are mistaken about them being organized ... but you'll probably throw in some leftist propaganda at this point .
The individuals may change in ranking order but like any organization, while the individual membership changes over time, the mission remains.
but you'll probably throw in some leftist propaganda at this point .
And now we are done; you can't deal with actual debate without making it about whomever disagrees with you.
I tried.
Petey Coober
11 years agoThe individuals may change in ranking order
You have failed to comprehend even the simplest statement I made . There is a lot of new blood making up the membership of the 1% every single year , way over half . Got it ?
And now we are done; you can't deal with actual debate without making it about whomever disagrees with you.
You misunderstood what I said . Then you gave up . Does this mean you admit I'm right ?
Petey Coober
11 years agoAnd that means you are a wimp when you want to be , but not when you feel like being an a-hole ...
Petey Coober
11 years agoSince 2008, there hasn't been a lot of new blood in the upper eschelon, the .1%rs
Please supply link evidence ...
Dowser
11 years agoI don't know that this study measures the REAL contribution to actual charities made by everyone, be it democrat or republican.
One thing I don't think they consider is the time given-- that is a real cost, or donation, but doesn't seem to be considered as a dollar amount.
No matter which charity one gives time to-- whether it's singing in the choir at church, or helping to muck out the stalls at the humane society, whatever-- that time has a value. Time may be all that poorer people can give, and yet, they spend time helping others. Is their contribution less valuable, because this particular study doesn't assign a dollar amount to time? To me, it isn't.
A. Macarthur
11 years agoTime may be all that poorer people can give, and yet, they spend time helping others. Is their contribution less valuable, because this particular study doesn't assign a dollar amount to time? To me, it isn't.
Perspective at last!
And the uber-wealthy can afford to give time more so than the working poor or middle class.
Dowser
11 years agoAbsolutely!
But they don't. They give $$, which is good, but we cannot devalue the benefits of the hands on, TIME that other people give.
Petey Coober
11 years agoThanks for the info . But that is about the global economy . This thread is about the US . And in the US there is quite a lot of churn in the constituents of the .1% ...
One more thing : I didn't say that wealth is not unequally distributed , only that those very wealthy are not consistently at the top ...
Petey Coober
11 years agoStill extremely wealthy. In other words, what is your point?
You don't seem to understand the difference between wealth & income . Why is that ?
Petey Coober
11 years agoOf course there are new people entering the 1%, and the .1% every year. So what? If your argument is that this means all is well with the world, which is what I expect is your argument, - whose world Petey ?
Your expectation is not to be depended on ... ever . You are 1 of the most consistently wrong in that regard of anyone I've ever encountered . But you never learn . Why is that ? As far as my "argument" goes , go back to the entry by A Mac on the previous page . If you can't understand the train of thought happening I won't be surprised ...
Petey Coober
11 years agoThe organizing is not for any individuals, it is for a class, and for, well, the .1 percenters. Whoever they are.
You still show no signs of understanding the difference between wealth & income . Until you do the nature of that %tile rating will elude you .
LynneA
11 years ago
applauding your level headed, practicality! The giving of ones time is a precious commodity....benefits the receiver and the giver.
Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom
11 years agoNo matter which charity one gives time to-- whether it's singing in the choir at church, or helping to muck out the stalls at the humane society, whatever-- that time has a value. Time may be all that poorer people can give, and yet, they spend time helping others. Is their contribution less valuable, because this particular study doesn't assign a dollar amount to time? To me, it isn't.
Your common sense and gentle spirit are why you are so beloved everywhere you comment.

This story line never made much sense. The truth is that the private sector has done surprisingly well under Mr. Obama, adding 6.7 million jobs since he took office, compared with just 3.1 million at this point under President George W. Bush. Corporate profits have soared, as have stock prices. What held us back was unprecedented public-sector austerity: At this point in the Bush years, government employment was up by 1.2 million, but under Mr. Obama its down by 600,000. Sure enough, now that this de facto austerity is easing, the economy is perking up.