Op-Ed: What the West Must Do In Order to Survive
Op-Ed: What the West Must Do In Order to Survive
Americans must demand that their government defend their country and their way of life.
By Professor Phyllis Chesler, Arutz Sheva 7, Tuesday, January 13, 2015
If Europe does not do the following immediately, the birthplace of the Western enterprise will soon be conquered by barbarism.
First, the European Union must dissolve itself. Borders and passports must return. No one should be allowed to travel unhindered from European country to European country.
Second, each European country must pass legislation to deport all those who are on no fly lists; all radical imams at radical mosques, together with their radicalized followers in mosques and in prisons; and all those who have traveled to Iraq, Syria, and Yemen for jihadi training.
Third, legislation must empower police and military forces to physically abolish theno-go zonesthe hostile, separatist Muslim-only neighborhoods in which the European rule of law does not exist and which areruled, instead, by vigilantism, terrorism, and a superstitious version of Sharia law.
Fourth, the most vigorous requirements must be put in place for new immigrants and for the families of existing immigrants.
I truly wonder whether France will both pass and enforce such legislation.
As for America, the country that chose to send no important leader to rally against terrorism and in support of free speech in Paris:
We must immediately close our southern border. Here, I am not talking about Hispanic children or Hispanic would-be domestic workers. I am talking about the thousands of illegal immigrants who are coming into America via this route carrying Korans.
We must use language accurately. Jihad is not workplace violence or the acts of mentally ill and lone individuals. When a Muslim murders and massacres others, as the Ft Hood shooter did, yelling Alahu Akbar (Our God, Allah, is the greatest God)this is an act of radical political Islam. The word Islamic (or Islamist) must sanely be joined to the word terrorism in the lexicon of the FBI, CIA, and Office of Homeland Security.
For the civil libertarians and multi-cultural relativists among us: The West does not believe in collective punishment or in judging an individual based on collective stereotypes about that individuals race, religion, or culture. And, not all Muslims are terrorists. But 95% of terrorism today is committed by Muslims who believe they are carrying out Koranic commandments. Until this changes, we must be on a war footing.
For those who forget: The first World Trade Center Bombers were Muslims; The U.S.S. Cole Bombers were Muslims; The 9/11 World Trade Center Attackers were Muslims; The Shoe Bomber was a Muslim; the Beltway Snipers were Muslims; the Ft. Hood Shooter was a Muslim; The Underwear Bomber was a Muslim; The Madrid Train Bombers were Muslims; The Bombay/Mumbai, India Attackers were Muslims; The Bali Nightclub Bombers were Muslims; The London Subway Bombers were Muslims; The Moscow Theater and Beslan School Attackers were Muslims; The Boston Marathon Bombers were Muslims; the Sydney, Australia Lindt Caf Hostage Taker was a Muslim; The Charlie Hebdo and Kosher Supermarket Killers in Paris were Muslims, etc.
This list is very short and does not include all the Jihadi attacks against Jews and against Israelis for the last one hundred yearsnor the Jihadi attacks against all infidels (Christians, Hindus, Bahai, Zoroastrian, etc.), as well as against the wrong kind of Muslim since the 7thcentury AD.
Americans must understand that war has been declared against the infidel West by radical political Islamists and that the time to fight back is long overdue. Americans must demand that their governmentdefend their country and their way of life.
We must defeat President Obamas plans, which are underway, to welcome thousands of Muslim immigrants who have not been vetted in terms of radical anti-American, radical anti-Jewish, and radical anti-Western prejudices.
Our lives depend upon doing so.
Prof. Phyllis Chesler
The writer, a Shillman-Ginsburg Fellow at the Middle East Forum and recipient of the 2013 National Jewish Book Award, is the author of fifteen books, including Women and Madness, Woman's Inhumanity to Woman, and The New Anti-Semitism. She has published three studies about honor killing and is at work on a fourth. Her latest book is An American Bride in Kabul, (Palgrave Macmillan)

Please note: This is not a criticism of Islam. It is not a criticism of the vast majority of peaceful Muslims. I do not hate Muslims and I would appreciate your not accusing me of that. This is a warning against the actions of the Islamic fundamentalist terrorists and those who aid and abet them.
"Islamic" terrorists are NOT MUSLIMS. They are criminals using Islam as a pretext to "justify" their criminality.
Until slovenly-"thinking" governments, individuals and the media stop pigeon-holing and begin dealing with realities, much time, energy and resources will be wasted.
This is from The Onion , right?
They profess to be Muslims, shout "Alahu Akbar" when they slaughter others, twist the Quran to their own purposes, are cheered by many Muslims - don't you think it's time to call a spade a spade or are you being sarcastic?
I believe it was first published in the Israel National News , then picked up by Arutz Sheva 7 (or the other way around). Nothing whatsoever to do with The Onion. The author is not a fly-by night but is fairly established.
If they are not Muslims, why was the Ft. Hood shooter's trial delayed so long over the asinine issue of his freaking beard? Why wasn't he just held down and shaved, or put to sleep and shaved so he would be presented in court according to military protocol?
If he is not a Muslim why have we danced around every damned demand he has made that concerns his religion which should not have had any bearing on his court martial... seeing as how it was all called "workplace violence" at the time and he was a member of the "workplace" when he committed it and he is not a Muslim?
Sorry, Mac. You can say they are not Islamic because they are subverting the religion, but you cannot say they are not Muslim, because that is the culture of which they were born and raised. It would be like saying I am not Southern because I am Indian.
If a self-ascribed Christian or a group of them, or say Nazis or Klansmen, or White Supremacists, if any of these commit violent acts against groups that they specifically target and declare that it's exactly what they're doing -- are they Christians who actually practice their Christianity, or, are they using their religion as a pretext?
Robert G, instead of your usual personal non-rebuttal-rebuttal, answer the question. It's fundamental is there such a phenomenon as deciding that, in the name of god, to avenge or do god's bidding, it's mandated by the word of that god to kill those who don't worship that god?
FYI: I was quoting as ollows
Mocking precedes learning the hard way. Toba Beta ,
No one is born with a brand on his/her ass as to what religion he happens to be; religious beliefs are taught/learned assimilated or rejected over ones lifetime; religion is a state-of-mind, a belief in a set of tenets. There are good _____________ s (fill in the blank), bad __________________, hypocritical ___________________ and criminals, some of whom either by way of delusion or, pretext of convenience, hide behind religion.
Disagree. Your race is biological/genetically determine but the cultural elements you were taught and assimilated are your ethnicity a matter of choice if you wish it to be. Genetically, biologically, you are what you are, but ideologically/religiously and culturally, you have a choice to be a strict adherent, a casual one, one who rejects altogether or one who uses parts of the cultural elements as "justification" to commit acts that are unethical, immoral and/or illegal based on convenient (mis)interpretation/application.
oh, yeah...
The "interpretations" can be counter to the tenets.
If I said I was an orthodox Jew but "interpreted" parts of Jewish tenets if I were a bigamist, if I ate pork products, if I violated the Commandments and still called myself a Jew would I be a Jew, or, would I be a Jew in name only? And would you judge all who identified themselves as Jews to be frauds and hypocrites because I and some others were?
Answer that specifically, please.
Does that mean I can LEGITIMATELY identify myself in any way I choose whether or not I ACTUALLY LIVE AND BEHAVE IN CONCERT WITH THE THINGS I SAY I BELIEVE -- THAT IS, WITH THE THINGS THAT THOSE WHO ACTUALLY BELIEVE THEM, AND, WHO LIVE THEIR LIVES ACCORDINGLY?
You ducked the question; lip service as opposed to being truthful, and worse, giving lip service to "justify" mayhem.
According to Jewish law a sinning Jew is still a Jew.
To quote the New Testament:
The result of islamic activism in Paris, celebrating new years.
Robert G wrote,
My response:
Don't summarily dismiss my thoughts by taking them out of their context.
And since that's what you have done, for starters, let's backtrack to my feelings regarding Eric Cantor and his Judaism.
Representative Cantor's voting record and political ideology is largely contrary to the tenets of Judaism which is humanistic in terms of charity and the performance of good deeds for the sake of humanity. FromtheTalmud The end result of wisdom is ...good deeds.
Voting to deny children and their families health care and trying to make it more difficult for parents to feed their children, voting to deny workers a living wage, voting against legislation to protect women from violence ... these are not the values of Judaism.
But beyond that, the context of my remarks about Cantor were with regard to the fact that, for whatever the reasons, Republicans don't seem to elect Jews to Congress. Mr. Cantor, while a member of Congress, was for most of that time, the only Jewish Republican member.
"You shall be known by your deeds."
I do quote biblical passages where there is great wisdom to be found and applied to day-to-day situations. Unfortunately, that wisdom is often ignored by frauds of all stripes who hypocritically use their religion like a tattoo, like a bogus membership card to a club that implies a status which they flaunt, as an I.D. the exploit in order to pander and bullshit, while actually using it like a mask in a holdup!
Rather than pull stuff out of my butt like some do, if I can quote the wisdom of a respected source to make a point, I do. That you see that as something to be mocked is more about yourself than about me.
When a member of any entity, religion, ideology, etc. commits murder and mayhem to allegedly defend one if those entities, unless he is defending the very physical existence of the entity, he is likely murdering on behalf of its ideology ... murdering human beings for thinking or believing differently from himself. Horrifically, throughout history, ideologues murder and use ideology, actually the bastardization of that ideology, as a pretext and a "justification." They claim to murder for God at which point, while they may talk-the-talk, by virtue if their actions, they walk their own, insidious, self-serving, perverted, criminal walk.
See if you can hold that thought and in the future, quote it in and others in full and in context when mocking me.
I know the quote, Len. Not sure why you reference the New Testament as the way to determine who is a Jew.
But you are correct in the literal sense of what you say
But in a pragmatic sense, in the real world, would you want the world to identify Judaism with the Meyer Lanskys, with Murder Inc.? Jewish by definition is not necessarily going to determine how the world regards certain Jews. And that applies across the board.
While all terrorists seem to call themselves "Muslims," to think that all Muslims are terrorists is inane.
That is about Islam and contradicts your defense of the religion. You evidently are not aware of the myriad Qur'anic justifications, and indeed advocacy, of the terror we see almost daily around the world.
This is about dedication of the Tent of Meeting but close enough.
That is part of our burden. But you needed to go back 70 years for that, not one week -- every week.
>>While all terrorists seem to call themselves "Muslims," to think that all Muslims are terrorists is inane.
It isIslam's job to clean up their act. Too many imams advocate terrorism and jihad of which there have been almost 25000 individual acts since 9/11 in 4700 days -- over five per day.
How many is "too many"? One is too many but that's not my point, Len.
MY POINT IS THAT IT IS SPECIOUS TO ARGUE THAT TERRORISTS WHO MURDER IN THE NAME OF ISLAM ARE LEGITIMATE "SPOKESPERSONS" FOR ALL OF ISLAM. Instead, they use Islam as a pretext -- being outside-of-the-mainstream-of-Isalm-fanatics, delusional or just plain haters who express their hatred by murdering their targets.
A hypothetical Jew who would kill his Christian neighbor because that neighbor called him a "kike," or, a Catholic who killed a Protestant because the Protestant said that "Catholicism is not the only true religion," or any zealot who kills because of ideology, regardless of what he may identify with religion-wise when he kills, he kills by virtue of his own interpretation and not because the legitimate doctrine of his religion handed him a weapon and a directive.
Actually Amac the Koran is VERY CLEAR in that if there are contradicting passages in the Koran that the latest passage replaces the first. This is call abrogation. If you keep this in mind you find there is nothing positive in the Quran for non-Muslims. Period. Every single one of the verses in the Quran with a positive message for non-Muslims is abrogated, leaving nothing positive for non-Muslims. Not one verse.
How many verses in the Quran are positive for non-Muslims? The answer is 245 . That's pretty good. That adds up to 4,018 words in the Quran, and comprises 2.6 percent of the total Quranic text. Unfortunately in every case of a peaceful verse, the verse is followed by another verse that contradicts the 'good' verses." Furthermore, except for seven verses, every "good verse" is abrogated later i n the same chapter (known as a "sura"). Those seven exceptions are abrogated in later chapters.
As I said before, the Quran is very specific about which verse should be followed.
And there are 527 verses in the Quran that are intolerant to non-Muslims, 109 verses calling on Muslims to make war on non-Muslims.
Here is Mohammad's last words (last revelation) about non-muslims
9:5 Slay the idolaters wherever you find them.
9:6 Those who submit and convert to Islam will be treated well. (Those who don't submit will be killed. See previous verse.)
9:7-9 Don't make treaties with non-Muslims. They are all evildoers and should not be trusted.
9:11 Treat converts to Islam well, but kill those who refuse to convert (see 9:5).
9:12-14 Fight the disbelievers! Allah is on your side; he will give you victory.
9:23 Don't make friends with your disbelieving family members. Those who do so are wrong-doers.
9:29 Fight against Christians and Jews "until they pay the tribute readily, being brought low."
9:33 The "Religion of Truth" (Islam) must prevail, by force if necessary, over all other religions.
9:41 Fight for Allah with your wealth and whatever weapons are available to you.
9:42 Those who refuse to fight for Allah (claiming they are unable) are liars who have destroyed their souls.
9:73 Fight the disbelievers and hypocrites. Be harsh with them. They are all going to hell anyway.
9:81-83 Those who refuse to give their wealth and lives to Allah will face the fire of hell.
9:85 Those who refuse to fight for Allah will be treated (along with their children) as unbelievers.
9:111 Believers must fight for Allah. They must kill and be killed. Allah will reward them for it.
9:123 Fight disbelievers who are near you, and let them see the harshness in you.
This is Allah's "last word" on tolerance and peace toward non-Muslims. If nothing else up to this point had abrogated the tolerant verses, the above verses completely wipe out every last positive verse in the Quran for non-Muslims.
Evidently Political correctness prohibits this.
Adviser to Egypt's Mufti Ibrahim Negm asserted on Thursday that Islam totally rejects killing innocents under any pretext, condemning the terrorist attack on the Paris office of French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo.
In a statement issued by Egypt's top religious institution Darul Ifta, Negm said terrorism has no religion and its impact is not limited to specific communities.
He added that the perpetrators of this terror attack should be punished as being outlaws.
"We all have common responsibility for confronting extremism and terrorism," Negm stressed.
Further
And
Pope Francis Lectures Terrorists on Proper Islam Condemns Deviant Forms of Religion for Paris Attacks
Dang, I could have used one of those cars. I'm looking for something with a little better gas mileage that will handle ethanol better.
Political correctness is not to be confused with common courtesy or common sense.
IMO, political correctness undermines what might otherwise be practiced as "The Golden Rule." Attempts to mandate or institutionalize "common courtesy," "common sense" and respect only jeopardizes the inherent value of those expressions when extended sincerely.
Almost anything that includes the word "political" is suspect on its face.
This is coming from a so-called "liberal."
There are limits to my liberalism.
What these "officials" are saying is contrary to what the Quran teaches.
It is important to remember that it is OK for Muslims to lie if it benefits Islam.
according to the quran the term they call it is "taqiyya"
you must lie for the sake of their allah.
Qur'an (3:54) - "And they (the disbelievers) schemed, and Allah schemed (against them): and Allah is the best of schemers." The Arabic word used here for scheme (or plot) is makara, which literally means deceit. If Allah is deceitful toward unbelievers, then there is little basis for denying that Muslims are allowed to do the same. (See also 8:30 and 10:21)
Sahih Bukhari 3:49:857
He who makes peace between the people by inventing good information or saying good things, is not a liar.
-
Source:
-
...
I am not really interested in getting into a discussion of what Imam's and Muslims SAY about these things as much as what their holy book TEACHES about these things. Show me any video where a follower of Islam is reading from the Quran to promote it as a religion of peace and I can show you a violent verse that abrogates it. The people quoting these verses know this and are purposely trying to deceive nonbelievers into thinking Islam is not a threat in order to advance Islam. This is completely acceptable to them.
SO....If you educate yourself in the religion and are still willing to take what these folks say at face value. Do it at your own risk and peril my friend.
Huh?
Murder in the name of anything is still murder. And those who use a name, a deity, an ideology or a dogma as a pretext to kill are KILLERS.
Don't play word games with me; I express myself clearly. Feel free to disagree but don't give me the rhetorical one-liners that purport to ask a question but which actually beg the question or statement they can't viably rebut.
If you're going to educate yourself, you need to look at the sources you are using to advance your education.
ali sina is a malcontent, possibly with some justification but hardly objective.
If you don't have time to educate yourself on the religion (It took me over a year) then at least educate yourself on Sharia law and ask yourself why all these Islamist countries still practice it.
Here is only a partial list of the more chilling aspects of Sharia Law:
According to the Sharia law:
Theft is punishable by amputation of the right hand.
Criticizing or denying any part of the Quran is punishable by death.
Criticizing or denying Muhammad is a prophet is punishable by death.
Criticizing or denying Allah, the moon god of Islam is punishable by death.
A Muslim who becomes a non-Muslim is punishable by death.
A non-Muslim who leads a Muslim away from Islam is punishable by death.
A non-Muslim man who marries a Muslim woman is punishable by death.
A man can marry an infant girl and consummate the marriage when she is 9 years old .
Girls' clitoris should be cut (per Muhammad 's words in Book 41, Kitab Al-Adab, Hadith 5251).
A woman can have 1 husband, but a man can have up to 4 wives; Muhammad can have more.
A man can unilaterally divorce his wife but a woman needs her husband's consent to divorce.
A man can beat his wife for insubordination.
Testimonies of four male witnesses are required to prove rape against a woman.
A woman who has been raped cannot testify in court against her rapist(s).
A woman's testimony in court, allowed only in property cases, carries half the weight of a man's.
A female heir inherits half of what a male heir inherits.
A woman cannot drive a car, as it leads to fitnah (upheaval).
A woman cannot speak alone to a man who is not her husband or relative.
Meat to be eaten must come from animals that have been sacrificed to Allah - i.e., be Halal .
Muslims should engage in Taqiyya and lie to non-Muslims to advance Islam.
Looking on the bright side, Muslim car burning in France was down 12% this past New Year's Eve. They only torched 940 cars this year.
Does the source really matter when it is merely quoting the Quran? You can very easily find out if it is accurate by reading the passages yourself can't you? I used the source because it has both original and abrogated in one spot and refers only to actual verses in the Quran. Don't take the sources work for it. Look it up it the Quran yourself.
Reading the above list, it is striking how many offenses merit the death penalty. Oddly, in Islamic law a parent or grandparent can murder their child/grandchild without incurring the penalty of death. Thousands of Muslim girls are "honor killed" each year by their families. The perpetrators often get off, when they are even charged, with imprisonment of only months or a couple years.
I am not justifying the tenets of Sharia Law, 96; I am stating that the Muslim population of the world is overwhelmingly not using the tenets of Islam to commit acts of ideologically-motivated mayhem and murder.
Can we agree on that?
Two hundred years ago, people were hanged for theft in the US.
The death penalty exists for most states, and the Federal government.
The US executes more people than any other nation, except China.
Hello "pot"?? Meet "kettle"...
The source matters WHEN IT FAILS TO MENTION THAT AMONG THE BILLION-PLUS MUSLIMS OF THE WORLD, THE OVERWHELMING MAJORITY DO NOT COMMIT ACTS OF IDEOLOGICAL MURDER AND MAYHEM.
I'm not debating the obviously alarming tenets you (and your sources) cite. I am noting that as a whole, only the extremists perpetrate those tenets WHICH RAISES THE QUESTION
Are the extremists representative of Islam AS IT IS PRACTICE BY A BILLION OR MORE MUSLIMS WHO ARE NOT EXTREMISTS?
It is not a complicated question.
don't give me the rhetorical one-liners that purport to ask a question but which actually beg the question or statement they can't viably rebut.
What else can one do in the face of white american liberals with the arrogance todeclarethemselves arbitersof who is and who isn't anauthenticMuslim? I find the hubris truly stunning.
Not content with commandeering the power to declare who is and who isn't a "true"Muslim, you bastardize the beliefs of Muslims so badlythatMohammedhimself doesn'tqualifyas a trueMuslimunder your definition, which is the height ofabsurdity. It's likedeclaring anyone thatbelievesJesus Christ sacrificedhimself upon the cross to redeem mankind isn't a real christian.
Mohammed killed people in the name ofregion. That's as factiest a fact as you'll find in a long's day march. He was a killer who killed expressly in the name of hisregion. Ignoring that to construct someliberallysanctioned,politicallycorrect, imaginary version of history and the Muslim religion is simply absurd and insulting.
But you can as a white-American conservative of course. Check the history books on that one.
I'm sorry you can't comprehend a distinction made based on the actions of individuals as opposed to your ascription of how they manifest what you believe they believe.
This is an intentional misrepresentation of what I've contended, namely, that to broad-brush-repudiate every Muslim in the world as being both capable of ideological mayhem and murder, and de facto guilty by association of same is a sloppy demagogue-like way to by-pass the process of thinking.
It's too damned easy to label and walk away from the facts because then you need to be analytical
The world is never just black or white, Sean. We are judged by our deeds.
Global Islamic terrorism has nothing to do with Islam?
Muslim population of the world is overwhelmingly not using the tenets of Islam to commit acts of ideologically-motivated mayhem and murder.
Can we agree on that?
I suppose that would depend on if you define the death penalty for Sharia laws murder or not.
Did you look at the list of countries that enforce Sharia law?
Here's where you and I and others part ways.
I make a distinction between what an individual calls/labels himself and how his ACTIONS CORRESPOND TO WHAT HE CALLS/LABELS HIMSELF.
To further explain my view, A TERRORIST PERPETRATING MURDER AND MAYHEM IN THE NAME OF "ISLAM," IS NOT THE SAME AS A MUSLIM WHO FINDS SUCH ACTIONS REPREHENSIBLE AND WHO CONDEMNS THEM.
Screw the labeling consider the deeds.
And just answer the question is every Muslim by virtue of his identification with Islam, by virtue of that alone on the same level as ISIS, al Qaeda or any terrorist organization/individual?
Of course i do not think all Muslims are on the same level as ISIS in that they do not go to other countries and try to convert or kill.
However, I think it is also very foolish to ignore what people who call themselves Muslims and DO practice the faith as commanded in the Quran find acceptable in their own country including:
Criticizing or denying any part of the Quran is punishable by death.
Criticizing or denying Muhammad is a prophet is punishable by death.
Criticizing or denying Allah, the moon god of Islam is punishable by death.
A Muslim who becomes a non-Muslim is punishable by death.
A non-Muslim who leads a Muslim away from Islam is punishable by death.
A non-Muslim man who marries a Muslim woman is punishable by death.
Here is a very good and eye awakening question for you. If you add the populations of all countries that enforce Sharia law and compare that to the entire Muslim population, What percentage of the Muslim population live by and enforce these laws?
Just to be clear. Do you consider people who enforce and live by the laws listed here "extremists"? Or are they just good practicing Muslims? Or something in between?
Incorrect . Executions carried out in 2013 (per Amnesty International)
Mac, you have completely hijacked this thread from discussion what the West Must Do In Order To Survive and turned it into a discussion about what constitutes a true Muslim.
Gee... We've made progress!!
Now we're behind Iran, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia, as well as China. We can be PROUD!
Of course... we still kill more people than such advanced nations as Somalia, Sudan, Yemen, ... any African state... any South American state...
USA! USA! USA!
Those who enforce and live by extreme laws are of course, EXTREMISTS. And those who do not, are not.
So again, I ask if there is a distinction to be made between those Muslims who in fact live by the letter-of-Sharia law, and those who identify themselves as Muslims but who do not.
I don't care what those who literally label individuals or entities think, I as an individual consider the ACTIONS of individuals and regard them accordingly.
Ironic that extremists target their enemies based on their LABELING of those targets, while those who correctly condemn them for doing so, are content to label ALL MUSLIMS (AND OTHER ETHNICITIES AND RACES, AND DEMOGRAPHICS) IN THE SAME MANNER.
Are we take on some of the characteristics of the evil-doers we despise?
In order to survive, we need to know who is the enemy and who is not LEST WE DO WHAT WE DID IN IRAQ AND, TO A LESSER BUT STILL SERIOUS DEGREE, WHAT WE DID WHEN WE INCARCERATED JAPANESE-AMERICANS AFTER PEARL HARBOR.
As a Native American, surely you can see how whites who convinced other whites that all Indians were savages, were in the wrong (to say the least) and all the innocent lives that were taken and ruined as a result shall we take every Muslim we can get a hold of and set him out on a trail of tears, or, go after the actual perpetrators who threaten our survival?
IT'S CRITICAL, IN ORDER TO AVOID THE UNNECESSARY LOSS OF LIVES AND RESOURCES, TO NOT EXACERBATE A PROBLEM BY SCATTER-SHOOTING AT IT, THAT WE CAREFULLY DISCERN THE ACTUAL CAUSES AND SOURCES OF THE SITUATIONS WE WISH TO SURVIVE AND PROCEED ACCORDINGLY.
And what shall I do regarding my neighbors several doors down they are Muslims who, as far as I know, haven't perpetuated any ideological (or other) mayhem, haven't tried to convert me and who, based on conversations I've had with them, feel ashamed and embarrassed by the acts of extremists? Are they part of the problem requiring a solution?
Apparently you missed my article regarding Yemen and my articles entitled "The Grid."
You're a good example of those who shoot from the hip and nail their foot.
I'm the only one I know of on this site who has offered actual plans of action that might be taken against ideological extremists in the Middle East.
You and others like you stir the (justifiable) rage towards the enemy BUT OFFER NOTHING IN THE WAY OF A SOLUTION AND MOCK THOSE WHO CLARIFY THE REALITIES AND DIFFICULTIES CREATED BY THOSE REALITIES WHICH IS CRUCIAL TO DEVELOPING VIABLE SOLUTIONS.
Ummmm..............
How to share the world with true believers behind global terror
My oversight, Bob. My apology.
Not just your oversight, Mac. It's a brilliant article... that got zero reactions.
Not enough red meat, I guess...
...and again I answer Of course not.
I agree with this and simply wanted to point out to you how much of the Muslim population YOU YOURSELF consider to be extremists.
Note that to be fair I have ONLY included countries in which Sharia applies in full , covering personal status issues as well as criminal proceedings . and have NOT included the countries in which Sharia only applies to PERSONAL issues .
The countries in which SHARIA APPLIES IN FULL and their populations rounded to the nearest half million
Mauritania population 3.5 million
Sudan 37.5 million
Afghanistan 32 million
Brunei .5 million
Iran 77.5 million
Iraq 36 million
Maldives .5 million
Pakistan 197 million
Qatar 2.5 million
Saudi 31 million
Aceh Indonesia .5 million
Yemen 24 million
So if you add it all up and take another good look at your statement
Then a total of 442.5 MILLION Muslims are extremists out of an estimated 1.8 billion worldwide.
That is almost 25% of the Muslim population and I have only included countries that enforce FULL Sharia.
Were you even aware that YOU believe 25% of Muslims are Extremists?
I am merely trying to point out the facts here A Mac. One of those facts are that 25% is NOT a "small portion" at least it isn't IMO. So think hard about that next time someone tells you "Extremists are only a very small percentage of Muslims" I don't know about you but when I think for "a very small percentage" I usually think less than 2%. BTW even if it was only 2% of 1.8 billion, that is still 36 MILLION!!!!!!
Lemme see... according to the list of countries that execute people... we are killing lots more people than many of these "Sharia" countries.
How does that work?
You don't know shit actually; that's not an objective rebuttal of his article, it's the usual summary, off-handed right-wing style dismissal of anything not within its truncated, demagoguery-"justified" reach.
Do you count among that population, those who cannot openly resist the tenets they find loathsome for fear of being punished by those who enforce them?
What slave can openly let his master know he's opposed to slavery and hate's him for being his master without consequence?
Of course.
Did you ever hope for anything better?
I certainly don't but that statement is profoundly different than:
Isn't it? I am simply trying to illustrate that the Muslim world is a lot more extreme than most think in this country, and that OUR media coverage is EXACTLY why it is more extreme than most think.
Let's visit this statement again
Now let me ask, how do we tell the extremists from the rest when the rest are afraid to speak out? I would also ask, once over half find it loathsome would you not expect to start to see resistance? Would you not expect to hear voices of the contempt?
Who'd a thunk it?
Fanatical, ideologue oppressive dictatorial tyrants not denouncing themselves!
Learn somethin' new every day.
And many do not BTW, how "many" is "many." Nebulous much?
I'm going to go out on a limb here and guess that almost all those who lived under Sharia law, as they approached death while being buried up to their necks and stoned for violating one or more of its tenets, on their way out, had an even deeper understanding as to why they and others like them were afraid to say, "fuck this barbaric law that I always regarded thus."
Who of sound mind can't fathom that oppressed human beings who, by virtue of that oppression, SECRETLY DON'T LIKE BEING OPPRESSED BUT CAN'T SAY SO?
NEVERTHELESS, THESE ARE COUNTED AS "BELIEVERS" BY THOSE WHO NEED TO AVOID COMPLICATED IDEAS LIKE -- "REALITY ISN'T SIMPLY BLACK OR WHITE"?
The Master of Rebuttal smacks again.
And misses, only to be the smack he is consistently.
Really, Robert G, strong rebuttal with endless specific counter points
in complete absence.
You think the countries that are murdering people in the name of Sharia are going to be honest with the rest of the world about the numbers of murders they carry out?!?!
LMFAO!!!
You have got to be kidding me. Remember in Sudan what happened when word got out they were going to execute a pregnant woman under Sharia law? Do you really believe she was the first pregnant woman to be sentenced to death under Sharia law? Can you tell me how many Hitler admitted to murdering? How about Stalin?
Just so you know Bob, countries that break international laws usually stay quiet about it. I know, it is probably hard for you to believe, but it's true.
This is true Amac. Islam ENSLAVES people, and the penalty for leaving it or even trying to is death. Even to speak out against it is death. Yes it is not cut and dry. It is not fair to assume the whole population that lives under FULL Sharia are OK with it. It is also not fair to say that there aren't many Muslims in countries where Sharia is not followed fully that would like to see it be implemented fully. Plenty of Imams have shown this to be true. This why I chose to include only the populations of full Sharia, I thought it to be a little more accurate. The fact is that neither you or I can say how many are radical. We can only say how many live by the laws of the most radical, and how many live by the laws that are somewhat radical (those that only impose Sharia on personal issues) and try to get a bit of a picture.
If you would like to believe only a very small portion of those who live under the "extremist" version of Islam are NOT AGAINST it. That is up to you. I would like to point out what cowards they must be if this is the truth.
Not if you understand that I meant
"Those who enforce and live VOLUNTARILY by extreme laws are of course, EXTREMISTS."
I should have written it that way rather than have assumed my intent was understood. Now i have made it clear.
Let's visit this statement again
My "Grid" and "Yemenade" articles address that very question; I stated clearly that those living oppressed will not, if at all, out the terrorists living among them UNLESS FACED WITH AN IMPOSED DILEMMA THAT DILEMMA HAVING BEEN BASED ON THE ROE IMPLEMENTED BY THE TERRORISTS.
Please read my articles and see.
Their cowardice can be understood which is why my DILEMMA tactic. Given a pair of less than ideal choices, hopefully they would make the one that MIGHT lead to their (relative or de facto) un-oppressed futures.
Revolutions occur when an oppressed demographic perceives it has nothing left to lose, or, has to make a choice that could be the lesser of two evils.
______________________________________________
NOTE: We disagree but do so respectfully and with regard to a sticky subject; as it should be.
Peace my friend.
Those who willfully embrace or enforce the extremism are not of the same mindset as those who loathe it but fear the consequences of expressing it.
Labeling and grouping those who unwillingly, and, who under duress, appear to "accept" an ideology they disdain, is all too convenient for the broad-brush mentality. Beating or threatening to beat someone into submission doesn't make them "believers," it makes them say what they have to say in order to stop the beating.
Agreed and appreciated.
However, to make my point again, which is that the violence and extent of Islam and it's threats are grossly understated by our media, will you honestly answer this?
Before I showed you the actual numbers of 442.5 MILLION Muslims out of an estimated 1.8 billion worldwide, almost 25% Live by "Extreme laws" or "Full Sharia".
What would your response be if I asked how many and/or what percentage of Muslims live under these "extremist laws"? This is the point I am trying to make. The PC media hides and sometimes even lies about Islam, it is a much worse cancer that we are lead to believe. So how many are "extremist"? I don't know. What I DO know is that it is a hell of a lot more than most think and a hell of a lot more than we are lead to believe.
I will if you will honestly answer this;
If the media cannot be relied upon to provide information, from where are you getting the information with regard to the numbers.
Do they all "live by" or do they "live under" those laws -- laws that preclude them from renouncing them?
Unless a demographic is free to declare its true feelings, the likelihood is, that whoever or whatever forcesthat demographic to APPEAR TO EMBRACE AN IDEOLOGY -- an appearance likely imposed and not embraced -- the "whoever" or "whatever" does whatever it takes to skew the numbers in its favor.
And the not-so-PC-anti-Muslim media take it the other way.
The reality, neither of us know how many believe and how many are afraid to confess that they do not. But I contend, if one assumes, acknowledges or empirically knows that a government is oppressive and extreme, logically, he must assume that the numbers either way -- can't be deemed accurate.
Robert G,
Is it just possible that people "polled" in countries where they can be flogged, killed, tortured, mutilated, stoned to death, etc., for giving the correct response MIGHT COVER THEIR ASSES BY GIVING THE "WRONG" RESPONSE TO AVOID SUCH CONSEQUENCES?
Just wondering.
How many slaves if polled, would openly object to slavery if their masters might be aware of their responses?
That goes along with my opinion as to why the vast majority of "moderate" Muslims are fence-sitters. They are in a win-win situation if they keep their mouths shut. If the creeping caliphate is successful, they will hold themselves out to be devout rather than be considered apostates or critical of Islam, whereas if the creeping caliphate is unsuccessful then they can remain being considered acceptable "moderate" Muslims. Lucky them!!!
You cannot deny that if they speak up they would be treated by the extremists no differently than Salman Rushdie or Ayan Hirsi, or even like French cartoonists.
I did provide on link on which the numbers were derived from and these numbers can easily be found in other places. What I was referring to is the media does not provide numbers on the statistics of killings condoned by Islam. Nor does the media even acknowledge it happens. Nor do the countries that enforce full Sharia. That is why they were not provided.
Please let me rephrase the question. Are you surprised how many live UNDER Full Sharia law?
Agreed. We can only take into consideration what we do know know from history, what numbers we do know, and the actual verses in the Quran.
No! You're saying I'm saying that.
Who conducted the polling and who were the respondents?
You may have a point; every now and then I think you're about to break into viable rebuttal mode.
But we can't rely on information coming from places where an oppressive regime rules by constant threat of barbarian retribution for "crimes" such as speaking truth to and about power.
Assuming the numbers you posted are more-or-less accurate, "surprised" is not the word I'd use. That we live in a world where atrocities are so apparent and, reported with such frequency, "sickened" and "fearful" are more applicable terms.
And does it matter in terms of the quantity living under oppression and tyranny and barbarism as much as the reality that it exists at all?
The actual verses of the Quran do not impose themselves nor does their existence imply that those subjugated by them do so willingly, fearlessly and without a wish to be free.
Another fact-laden, solid rebuttal
But sorry, no FR.
Your occasional expressions of compassion seem to be calculated rather than genuine particularly when one sees your inability to separate the victims of plights who may wish to escape those plights, but, who cannot escape from extremists who bastardize religion to satisfy their lust for power using coercion, fear, torture and murder to do so.
To you, declaring all or most Muslims devotees of Sharia law rather than considering the logical possibility of their being its unwilling "proponents" under penalty of barbaric retribution seems all that you require to make it so.
You don't know what you don't know and seem not to know it with stubborn conviction.
"Official: Islam rejects killing innocents under any pretext"
The problem, A.Mac, is that you and I define "innocents" differently than they do. To them, anyone who doesn't adhere to the tenets of the Quran and Sharia are not innocent.