╌>

Islamists won’t kill free speech—we will

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  11 years ago  •  21 comments

Islamists won’t kill free speech—we will

In my view there is no media outlet in Canada brave enough to allow a full and proper discussion of Islam

Barbara Amiel

It is difficult not to be intemperate in the face of nine murdered journalists, two murdered policemen and a janitor, lying in pools of blood in Paris, the City of Lights: the cold, calculated killing spree a response to journalism that was displeasing. The magazine Charlie Hebdo was firebombed in 2011. Though it regularly heaved dung across and beyond the political spectrum and satirized many religious figures and religions including the Pope, Jews, Christians et al, it was Charlie s caricatures of Islam that brought on the bombs and murders. Not surprising, in our time when virtually all terrorism of the last few decadeswhether in Russia, China, Germany, the killing fields of Syria and the Middle East, New York or Bostonhas been carried out in the name of Islam.

There is really no point in fatuities about Islam being just as tolerant as all other religions, which was uttered endlessly by commentators covering the Paris horror. The public face of Islam has been hijacked by Islamist fundamentalists with a zero-tolerance policy. Though I really wish we had more than the occasional imam declaring this act to be barbaric, I can understand why Western Muslimsthe majority of whom I expect and hope despise this carnagearent taking to the streets to decry what is being done in the name of their faith. When hundreds of girls are kidnapped, enslaved or murdered in Pakistan or Nigeria for attending school (when even in Canada a Muslim women may run a risk of being killed for not upholding the family honour in a forced marriage), when Canadian-born youths are training as jihadists or fighting in Syria, fear takes over. Why endanger your own family or relatives abroad?

Senseless killings, said NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair in condemning the latest violence. Not senseless at all. Terror works. You can see how Islamic terrorism has gripped a culture when even those who may be mentally ill, possibly like Michael Zehaf-Bibeau, the lone Parliament Hill gunman, seemto carry outtheir deranged acts in the name of Islam. They dont kill in the name of vegetarianism or Napoleon. Their targets arent electricians or acrobats but the people symbolic of Western valuesthose standing guard over its memorials or working in its parliament.

On the CBC some commentators tried out the notion that Canada didnt have the same problem as France because our multiculturalism was so much more successful than (failed) French attempts to assimilate its Muslim immigrants. This showed a rather scanty knowledge of recent history. Algeria was until 1962 a department (province) of France and its residents held French citizenship. After a bloody war for its independence causing about a million casualties (figures are difficult to verify), about 1.8 million Algerians moved into France with some economic help from the French government. About 800,000 were Arabs or nomads and the other million were the pieds-noirs Europeans who had lived in Algeria. If Canada found itself with such high numbers of Muslim immigrantsmany of whom were unskilled, if not illiterateour multicultural approach would probably succumb to ghettoes with better living conditions than those faced by the displaced in France but certainly not without serious problems.

For my money, the reason we dont have a slaughter like the one at Charlie Hebdo is because no such magazine would ever be allowed in Canada. We save our Kalashnikovs for murdering free speech. First we had the human rights commissions who literally jackbooted freedom of expression. The case against Macleans centred largely on an article of Mark Steyns. The Canadian Islamic Congress didnt like his piece on Islam and filed complaints with the federal as well as two provincial human rights commissions. Steyns work was vigorously defended by Macleans and Rogers Communications. Macleans and Steyn won. But the cost was high. I speak from experience. When in 2011 I had the one and only column of my 37 years of writing for Macleans spiked, it was on Dutch anti-Muslim immigration politician Geert Wilders. I thought it was pretty milquetoast writing since I was automatically self-censoring and pulling my punches but I really couldnt blame Macleans . They were suffering from battle fatigue: nothing is more enervating and time-consuming than filling out the endless details and forms that human-rights complaints require. Not to mention the legal fees. Youd win, said one of my editors. We know that. But we just cant go there again. In my view there is no media outlet in Canada brave enough to allow a full and proper discussion of Islam.

After the imbroglio with Steyn, Prime Minister Harper gutted the HRC ability to monitor free speech. The issue went by default to the Supreme Courtan inhospitable terrainfor freedom. The jurists took on a case involving flyers written about a cow almost as sacred as Islam, namely homosexuality. The flyers written by Christian Trust Activist William Whatcott wanted to bring sodomites to Christ for redemption but not into classrooms as teachers on human sexuality. The unanimous judgment of Canadas Supreme Court (overturning the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal that had allowed the flyers) should have been reprinted in its entirety in a Canadian satirical magazine with cartoons of our jurists were such a magazine allowed in Canada, which, according to the Supremes decision, it would not. Yes, we have free speech, said the Supremes citing the Charter of Rights but that doesnt mean we can say anything we like because free speech may be hate speech or at least hateful to some group.But a guarantee of free speech is not divisible. You cant guarantee some free speech any more than you can be a little bit pregnant.

Everyone has their red buttons, said one listener to a Toronto radio show on the Paris murders. CNNs Christiane Amanpourwhile condemning the killings in the strongest termsremarked that Charlie Hebdo did go over the top. More than the God-awful (and I use His name advisedly) Broadway hit production Book of Mormon ? And where are the red buttons among Christians when thousands oftheir fellow worshippers are being slaughtered by Muslims in Africa and the Middle East and tortured by communists in China, North Korea and Cuba?

Terror can backfire in the sense that some people finally dislike being scared and react by doing whatever terror is discouraging. This is generally a temporary response. As George Jonas pointed out in a 2013 column, human beings find a way of rationalizing their behaviour so that they can claim they are refraining from publishing or saying something not out of fear but because they dont wish to offend. They convert the base notion of being scared into a noble weapon of seeing someone elses point of view. In fact, this is one of the most insidious aspects of terrorism: we wash our brains and convert our fear into understanding. Example: the awful spot CBC put news host Evan Solomon in when reporting the Paris murders. He was given the job of reading CBCs rationalization to explain why, although the motive for the Paris murders were Charlie s cartoons of Muhammad and Islamists, the CBC would not show the cartoons in reporting the story. I didnt tape his explanation, fascinated as I was by its maze of clauses, but the phrase not to offend made a cameo appearance.

The West has been ready to give up on itself for some time now. We have no idea of what we stand for and seem to have no faith other than lip-service in the superiority of our institutions. If 9/11 can somehow be made to feel like partly the fault of America, then change foreign policy or administrations and the problem will go away. If young Islamic terrorists are created by feelings of alienation then the problem will be solved by getting them to like us. Its so comforting. Fundamentalist Islam is on the march and all we can do is worry about giving offence. When the blood of journalists can only be expunged by denying other journalists the right to say or show what they died for, we are hemorrhaging freedom. I have no children but some coming generation will pay the price for their parents cowardice.

~~Link~~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

VIDEO: Canadian Man Sentenced to 18 Months in Jail for Saying I Dont Like Islam

A man in Canada who set out to prove that Canadians dont have free speech proved his point by being sentenced to 18 months in jail for daring to say that Islam is evil on a subway in Toronto.

~~Link and Video~~

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

although the motive for the Paris murders were Charlies cartoons of Muhammad and Islamists, the CBC would not show the cartoons in reporting the story.

And there ya have it . I don't think the US media has either ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Most terrorism, worldwide, is Islamist. That is indisputable fact.

The portion of Muslims actively engaged in terrorism is small. This is also indisputable fact.

Most victims of Islamist terrorism are Muslims. Also indisputable.

In other words, the subject is vastly complex. It cannot be decently described in a three minute cable news segment. And most viewers wouldn't sit still for the several hours that would be needed for a worthwhile report.

Reporting isn't easy, and then some folks will add a layer of censure / self-censure.

I'm glad I don't have to do it.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

ISIL has the right idea . There are too many GD Muslims in the world . Kill as many as you can ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

I have a problem with condemning all Muslims although.... these acts make it hard to not wonder why there isn't outrage from the so-called moderate Muslims.

I'm here in North Carolina, a southern state, white and a man. I really don't think even with all that I'm born a natural racist or a member of the KKK, although I've found there are those who seem to have that opinion. One of the differences is I'm outraged when anyone here or anywhere else commits crimes against others regardless of race, gender, religious or not.

I would venture to say all of us on this site feel the same way as I do.

Are the moderate Muslims afraid to speak up? Have they been the first to be silenced?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Right on, great article.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Just as I was going to post this article my monitor blew - now that I have a new monitor I'm happy to see it was posted. I enjoy Barb Amiel's articles. Her first husband and I played in the same poker group and once when we were playing at his father's home she came in to say hello - a very pretty woman, and very right wing.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

A man in Canada who set out to prove that Canadians dont have free speech proved his point by being sentenced to 18 months in jail for daring to say that Islam is evil on a subway in Toronto.

Pamela Geller better not step into Canada.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Cool story Buzz!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

OMG!!

I must be running a fever... because... I agree with Robert 100%!

OMG... OMG... OMG...

Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Ouf!!!! Thank you so much, Robert! Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif

I can now go back to my more comfortable

WTF, Robert????

Smile.gif Smile.gif

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Are the moderate Muslims afraid to speak up?

Ya think? If you speak out against the radicals you die and if you try to leave Islam you die.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Unfortunate that the entire country will suffer for these actions and policies. It is likely, in time, they will pay dearly for them.

Backwards political correctness strikes again. If these folks are smart they will make damn sure that Judge does not get re-elected.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

106.gif 106.gif 106.gif

 
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

IMO, where Americans have gone too far in championing free speech is when they argue that shouting down a speaker and not allowing him/her to speak, for example at a university, is considered free speech. To me it is censorship.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

shouting down a speaker and not allowing him/her to speak, for example at a university

I agree that it's at the limit, but there's a difference between "preventing speech" and "not supplying a podium".

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    11 years ago

Buzz, that is too much of a blanket statement regarding free speech in America. Several years ago, you probably remember the Irvine 11, the group of university students who led an organized and systematic interruption of Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren's speech at the University of California-Irvine. They were boo'ed by the other members of the audience, led out by campus police, charged and convicted in court of misdemeanors offenses.

I agree with you. There should be no such thing as a Heckler's Veto.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

unfortunately I've read stories that are subsequent to the California-Irvine incident that end up differently.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Pokermike and Buzz,

You're talking about several rather different cases.

Until a speaker arrives, I see nothing wrong with peaceful efforts to get the speaker's invitation withdrawn. Once the speech begins, interrupting it is disturbing the peace -- which some may consider worthwhile civil disobedience.

Neither of those cases is in any way comparable to threatening death as the price of speech.

u're

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot


99 visitors