╌>

A War of Words (Some More Accurate Than Others) at Brandeis

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  screminmimi  •  12 years ago  •  14 comments

A War of Words (Some More Accurate Than Others) at Brandeis

By: Lori Lowenthal Marcus

Brandeis University junior Khadijah Lynch who tweeted she has "no sympathy" for slain NYPD officers, shown here on "Wake Up With Tayla Andre, "Dec. 24, 2014.

Brandeis University junior Khadijah Lynch who tweeted she has "no sympathy" for slain NYPD officers, shown here on "Wake Up With Tayla Andre, "Dec. 24, 2014.

Theres an ugly tempest brewing at Brandeis University and its based, at least in part, on free speech, tolerance and student safety. The stormgrew out of a more generalized anger with the state of public discourse and of the safety of individuals in our society at large.

But at this point, one black self-described revolutionary and one Jewish conservative journalist, both Brandeis students, are the figureheads in a battle for the soul of an institution.

That institution, Brandeis University, was founded so thatJews, barred from most colleges by anti-Semitism, could find an open door to attain the education they desired. The school was named after theSupreme Court justice Louis D. Brandeis, whose distillation of the essence offreedom of speech has stood for decades as the lynchpin for America, and, in turn, much of the western world.

It was also Louis Brandeis, in an earlier incarnation as a lawyer, who brought humanity into the justice system.His famous Brandeis Brief for the first time opened the way for courts to consider human facts, not just legal doctrine, when making decisions about the lives of those people.

The deaths of black unarmed men at the hands of police officers, Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri and Eric Garner in New York City this summer led to days of protests which increased in fury and exploded in violence after grand juries in both cases declined to indict the police officers involved.

Those deaths were followed by the execution-style murder of two random New York City police officers by a man pledging vengeance for the murders ofBrown and Garner.

In response to the death of the two officers, Rafael Ramos and Wenjian Liuon Dec. 20, a Brandeis junior, Khadijah Lynch, tweeted the following: i have no sympathy for the police officers who were murdered today. She followed that bleet with another, the next day: lmao, all[,] i just really dont have sympathy for the cops who were shot. i hate this racist f[expletive deleted]ing country.

Justice Brandeis might have been first in line to offer to defend Lynch if she were threatened with expulsion for expressing her views publicly. But no one made any such threats. Instead, another Brandeis student took what Lynch placed in the public arena, and wrote and published an article about it for his site that same day. Daniel Mael, a Brandies senior and journalist for the site TruthRevolt.com, merely sent out further whatLynch hadalready launched.

What Mael wrote was little more than a description of Lynch and what she tweeted. All facts. All taken from public information. All fair game. And then some commenters to Maels article posted some seriously ugly talkbacks. Also free speech. Also fairly common in the world of Internet websites with any political orientation.

It was at this point that certain members of the Brandeis community decided to rally round Lynch, raising the issue of community and safety. But it was too late for such hamishe invocations. Once Lynch chose to make her views public by using social media (one that could have been set on private, but was not), she leftthe cocoon of the university; her righteous defenders were unlanced. But that did not stop them.

No Brandeis Lynch defenders publicly praised herlack of sympathy for the murdered police officers, but one student, Michael Piccione, sent an email on Dec. 22 to more than 200 members of the Brandeis community. Picciones statementcondemned Mael for compromising Lynchssecurity and for continuing to endanger her. WhatPiccione demanded, in his own and in the name of others, was that action [be] taken to hold this student accountable for his actions.

Another email was sent out later that eveningto the Brandeis community by the leaders of the Brandeis University Undergraduate Student Union. This group issued a full-throated defense of Lynch and condemnation of her attackers, while distancing itself very gingerly from the substance of her tweets. But not one word about Mael and his free speech rights.

When asked, Mael told The Jewish Press : It is sad that the Brandeis Student Union failed to condemn Ms. Lynchs vicious rhetoric. I believe that the leaders of the campus community should have the moral courage to takea stand in favor of humanity and against her utter lack of empathy for the murder of American police officers.

Neither the student government leadership nor, not surprisingly, Michael Piccione mentioned Daniel Maels right of free speech and opinion. This disappointed Mael as well. He commentedto The Jewish Press:

It is unfortunate that not a single member of the faculty or student administration has condemned the derogatory and abusive language used online that was often libelous. The campaign of grotesque language has created an atmosphere is incitement and intimidation. The silence of campus leaders in this situation is deeply saddening and worrisome.

Attempts by The Jewish Press to obtain a comment from Brandeis University went unanswered.

An email petition campaign , however, was started by an external Coalition for A Safe Brandeis asking for signatures calling on Brandeis University to secure Maels safety and free speech rights. Many alumni have signed the petition, expressing disgust overthe contretemps and dismay thatthe administration has beenabsent without leave.

Most of what Lynchs defenders excoriate Mael over is making public what Lynch and they claim were her private views. That claim, of course, fails utterly because Lynch chose to publicly share her lack of sympathy for the cold-blooded murder of two completely random police officers.

Not one Mael critic has come up with any errors or inaccuracies in his articles. Some parroted a groundless claim of Lynchs that Mael slandered her, but that was made in writing and easily dismissible as an improper invocation of the term. Lynch wrote in an email to Mael, who wrote her before publishing his article:

I do not want my personal opinion publicized and if you do not abide by my wishes I constitute [sic] your disregard as slander.

But this privacy claim is even more ridiculous given Lynchs subsequent appearance on a public radio station to discussher views about the tweets and the response to them. Lynch said she wanted to put her tweets in context, and her appearance on the Wake Up with Tayla Andre show allowed her to do just that.

The context she demanded people know is what she understands to be the rampant and explicit and very, very visible acts of violence against black and brown bodies that has been happening. She spends more than an hour expressing her fury about the complacency surrounding the deaths of unarmed blacks at the hands of police officers. Never mind that violent protests and riots followed the killings by the police officers. And never mind that there were no riots or any violence following the killings of the police officers.

Lynchstood her ground, refusing to backtrack on what she tweeted. Not even when asked whether she felt any differently, given that the two police officers who were killed were both minorities. Nope. Lynch said that minority members of police departments have an obligation to speak up against their own institutions, and those who are not are just as guilty as the ones who are committing violence against black or brown bodies.

Here are justsome of thestatements Lynch made during the interview :

America is a racist institution which relies and thrives on anti-blackness. Americanlaw enforcement is attacking black people. There are quotas that have to be reached [for arresting black people]. The American Law Enforcementtoday are the descendants of the slave overseers, who have a legacy of protecting capitalism. Youall are killing my people every single day. The police are shooting blacks onsight.

The radio show host congratulates Lynch on her heroic stand:

I am very and thoroughly impressed, Andre said to Lynch. You stand by your words! You didnt say, oh, they were minorities, I take that back, no, I stand by my word, I had no sympathy, as many of ours that have been taken away, I have no sympathy.

To which Lynch replies: I dont.

The interviewer was bothered by one thing, however. She wanted to know why Lynch agreed to step down as a student leader in Brandeiss African and African-American Studies Department. Lynch ended up saying that she had not actually resigned, despite what members of the Brandeis administration said publicly. Lynch said she was told that it might be best if she resigned, but she never officially resigned. Both Lynch and Andre ended up concluding that Lynch still held her position in the AAAS department. That willbe news to the department and the university.

One of the callers to the show warned Lynch that appearing on the show and making the kinds of comments she has made publicly may harm her in terms of future employment or in other ways. He told her that putting it out on social media and in other ways would put it out there for everyone to discuss. Lynch rebuffed the callers concern. She said, Im alive and here for it.

As a young black woman, Lynch clearly sees current events through the prism of her own pain, which is understandable. What is harder to understand is her inability to see that her fury at targeting all black and brown bodies as criminals, as guilty, as bad or as wrong should enable her to see that it is also wrong to target all police officers or all whites or all Jews as rich white rapists, racists, colonialists, Zionists, capitalists, which is exactly what she does, at the end of her radio interview, when she reads aloud a poem she wrote.

Here is a segment of that poem:

I am not as vicious or rapacious as those racists how dare they ask of me to love my enemy, I owe them nothing, not even my cordiality, they have colored my reality with grief and pain drowned me in a peculiar shame.

I laugh at the sick joke because if blessed are the poor then surely the wretched are those rich white rapists, yes, those capitalists, those Zionists, those colonists, the ones we celebrate for their hatred the ones who carved their hugly faces in the sacred mountains of the natives.

Respectability, humility, rigidity, let me be whimsical and carefree All those white males protecting Lynch at Brandeis? She really does not need your help. But Brandeis University may.

Hana Levi Julian contributed to this article.

This article has been correctedto showthe accurate term in Lynchs poem was hugly not ugly. There is a link to the meaning of that word, a term with which this author was not familiar.

http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/a-war-of-words-some-more-accurate-than-others-at-brandeis/2014/12/28/4/

..........................................................................................................

NOTE: I cannot find a definition of "hugly."


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Lynchstood her ground, refusing to backtrack on what she tweeted. Not even when asked whether she felt any differently, given that the two police officers who were killed were both minorities. Nope. Lynch said that minority members of police departments have an obligation to speak up against their own institutions, and those who are not are just as guilty as the ones who are committing violence against black or brown bodies.

It appears that not only white law enforcement officers but black and brown, yellow, and other minorities are being targeted as the problem.

Will we ever see a black LEO shot by a black killer just because he is a cop?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

I can see a Nobel Peace Prize in the works for one young lady...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

As I said when Brandeis administration capitulated to CAIR and cancelled Hirsi's speech, and as I say again now - Louis Brandeis would turn over in his grave if he knew what has happened at the university named after him.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

It appears that the rhetoric has taken a step upwards in the inflaming department. Notwithstanding the fact that murder is a part of life in the minority community, cause they choose it to be.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

What worries me is that, if this young woman is the future of black America, there is little hope of the upcoming generation of blacks working to facilitate the harmony of blacks and whites living together as equals.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Cops in both Los Angeles and Florida were fired upon by wanna-be snipers this week. This type of attitude, especially expressed on a public radio forum, only exacerbates the situation.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

She hates white people, she hates law enforcement, she hates America. What profession does she intend to go into when she graduates that will allow her to avoid contact with all three of them?

I hope she doesn't want to become a teacher.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Brandeis University is certainly getting a lot of press this year, and all of it bad (deservedly so). You are right, Buzz, Justice Brandeis would certainly be outraged.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

I can see her taking over Sharpton's mantle and doing him proud. "Activist" may be one of the few options left for her after that radio interview.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Well, she could always be a community organizer. Riling people up seems to be her forte; she'd be perfect.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Based upon her tweets, Mimi, this woman is more likely to follow in the footsteps of Joanne Chesimard.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Another beer summit anyone?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
That's one wasted college education. It's unlikely she'll ever amount to anything.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

As a young black woman, Lynch clearly sees current events through the prism of her own pain, which is understandable. What is harder to understand is her inability to see that her fury at targeting all black and brown bodies as criminals, as guilty, as bad or as wrong should enable her to see that it is also wrong to target all police officers or all whites or all Jews as rich white rapists, racists, colonialists, Zionists, capitalists, which is exactly what she does

We used to have simple sayings to deal with this kind of situation ; eg: 2 wrongs does not make a right ...

 
 

Who is online



91 visitors