Science Increasingly Makes the Case for God-- The odds of life existing on another planet grow ever longer. Intelligent design, anyone? -- WSJ, By Eric Metaxas, 12/25/2014
In 1966 Time magazine ran a cover story asking: Is God Dead? Many have accepted the cultural narrative that hes obsoletethat as science progresses, there is less need for a God to explain the universe. Yet it turns out that the rumors of Gods death were premature. More amazing is that the relatively recent case for his existence comes from a surprising placescience itself.
Heres the story: The same year Time featured the now-famous headline, the astronomer Carl Sagan announced that there were two important criteria for a planet to support life: The right kind of star, and a planet the right distance from that star. Given the roughly octillion1 followed by 24 zerosplanets in the universe, there should have been about septillion1 followed by 21 zerosplanets capable of supporting life.
With such spectacular odds, the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, a large, expensive collection of private and publicly funded projects launched in the 1960s, was sure to turn up something soon. Scientists listened with a vast radio telescopic network for signals that resembled coded intelligence and were not merely random. But as years passed, the silence from the rest of the universe was deafening. Congress defunded SETI in 1993, but the search continues with private funds. As of 2014, researches have discovered precisely bubkis0 followed by nothing.
What happened? As our knowledge of the universe increased, it became clear that there were far more factors necessary for life than Sagan supposed. His two parameters grew to 10 and then 20 and then 50, and so the number of potentially life-supporting planets decreased accordingly. The number dropped to a few thousand planets and kept on plummeting.
Even SETI proponents acknowledged the problem. Peter Schenkel wrote in a 2006 piece for Skeptical Inquirer magazine: In light of new findings and insights, it seems appropriate to put excessive euphoria to rest . . . . We should quietly admit that the early estimates . . . may no longer be tenable.
As factors continued to be discovered, the number of possible planets hit zero, and kept going. In other words, the odds turned against any planet in the universe supporting life, including this one. Probability said that even we shouldnt be here.
Today there are more than 200 known parameters necessary for a planet to support lifeevery single one of which must be perfectly met, or the whole thing falls apart. Without a massive planet like Jupiter nearby, whose gravity will draw away asteroids, a thousand times as many would hit Earths surface. The odds against life in the universe are simply astonishing.
Yet here we are, not only existing, but talking about existing. What can account for it? Can every one of those many parameters have been perfect by accident? At what point is it fair to admit that science suggests that we cannot be the result of random forces? Doesnt assuming that an intelligence created these perfect conditions require far less faith than believing that a life-sustaining Earth just happened to beat the inconceivable odds to come into being?
Theres more. The fine-tuning necessary for life to exist on a planet is nothing compared with the fine-tuning required for the universe to exist at all. For example, astrophysicists now know that the values of the four fundamental forcesgravity, the electromagnetic force, and the strong and weak nuclear forceswere determined less than one millionth of a second after the big bang. Alter any one value and the universe could not exist. For instance, if the ratio between the nuclear strong force and the electromagnetic force had been off by the tiniest fraction of the tiniest fractionby even one part in 100,000,000,000,000,000then no stars could have ever formed at all. Feel free to gulp.
Multiply that single parameter by all the other necessary conditions, and the odds against the universe existing are so heart-stoppingly astronomical that the notion that it all just happened defies common sense. It would be like tossing a coin and having it come up heads 10 quintillion times in a row. Really?
Fred Hoyle, the astronomer who coined the term big bang, said that his atheism was greatly shaken at these developments. He later wrote that a common-sense interpretation of the facts suggests that a super-intellect has monkeyed with the physics, as well as with chemistry and biology . . . . The numbers one calculates from the facts seem to me so overwhelming as to put this conclusion almost beyond question.
Theoretical physicist Paul Davies has said that the appearance of design is overwhelming and Oxford professor Dr. John Lennox has said the more we get to know about our universe, the more the hypothesis that there is a Creator . . . gains in credibility as the best explanation of why we are here.
The greatest miracle of all time, without any close seconds, is the universe. It is the miracle of all miracles, one that ineluctably points with the combined brightness of every star to somethingor Someonebeyond itself.
Mr. Metaxas is the author, most recently, of Miracles: What They Are, Why They Happen, and How They Can Change Your Life ( Dutton Adult, 2014).
http://www.wsj.com/articles/eric-metaxas-science-increasingly-makes-the-case-for-god-1419544568

I just knew you would be first with a thoughtless, brainless response.
I will bet your mind went blank after the headline and you understood zilch of the particulars.
This is shown by your failure to make an intelligent criticism.
More than two zeros is beyond your cognitive ability to comprehend.
Speaking of particulars, in your own words, tell me what you know about the "200 known parameters necessary for a planet to support life"?
If there is intelligent life out there, which is almost certain given the volume of potential, it could be unregnizable to us, with communications that we wouldn't begin to understand how to detect. You people that are stuck on the whole God theme will never be able to understand this.
If ET were discovered, your whole worldview would be turned upside down and inside out. After some anguished hand wringing, and extensive circular reasoning, you would find the most abstract way to weave a biblical explanation for their existence and discovery, backing it up with a handful of ridiculously ambiguous scripture quotes - and then you would insult their intelligence by trying to spread the word. Personally, I hope we don't find ET until atheism finally becomes the dominant trend. I would be too embarrassed for humans as they exist today.
Do the math, if you are so smart, then get back to me.
Fine-Tuning For Life On Earth
Evidence for the Fine-Tuning of the Galaxy-Sun-Earth-Moon System for Life Support
The environmental requirements for life to exist depend quite strongly on the life form in question. The conditions for primitive life to exist, for example, are not nearly so demanding as they are for advanced life. Also, it makes a big difference how active the life form is and how long it remains in its environment. On this basis there are six distinct zones or regions in which life can exist. In order of the broadest to the narrowest they are as follows:
1. for unicellular, low metabolism life that persists for only a brief time period 2. for unicellular, low metabolism life that persists for a long time period 3. for unicellular, high metabolism life that persists for a brief time period 4. for unicellular, high metabolism life that persists for a long time period 5. for advanced life that survives for just a brief time period 6. for advanced life that survives for a long time period
Complicating factors, however, are that unicellular, low metabolism life (extremophiles) typically is more easily subject to radiation damage and it has a low molecular repair rate. The origin of life problem is far more difficult for low metabolism life (H. James Cleaves II and John H. Chambers, Extremophiles May Be Irrelevant to the Origin of Life, Astrobiology, 4 (2004), pp. 1-9). The following parameters of a planet, its planetary companions, its moon, its star, and its galaxy must have values falling within narrowly defined ranges for physical life of any kind to exist. References follow the list.
Continued
LMAO -- What part of "in your own words" don't you understand?
I rest my case.
51. oxygen quantity in atmosphere
You recognize with science and the Bible that the universe was created ex nihilo -- from nothing. That is a start worth thinking about.
13.5 billion for the universe and about 4.5 billion or our solar system.
I also assume you believe in evolution. Science and Bibleteach that both the universe and life on earth evolved. Life could not have survived in the high-energy early millennia of the universe. our solar system evolved from a supernova; an exploding star.
You might think we are her just by luck, by random chance. But for us to be here we would not just have had to win one lottery but lotteries week after week, year after year, century after century.
We won with the strength of the electromagnetic force that is just right to cause atoms tojoin into molecules. We won at the strength of the nuclear force that is just right to hold atomic nuclei together. Were it a bit stronger hydrogen would not be the major component of the universe and, consequently, no stars.
Physicists (My son has a PhD) know that, besides the electromagnetic force, the universe contains three others with vastly different properties and strengths; gravitation, the strong force and the weak force. If you tried to bring two electrons together gravity would assist you but the electromagnetic force would fight you. You would have a hard time because the electromagnetic force is a million, billion, billion, billion, billion times as strong. The only reason it is not dominant is because matter mostly has an equal amount of + and - charges.
The strong force is 100 times as strong as the electromagnetic force and 100,000 times as strong as the weak force.
If the properties of these forces were even moderately different the universe would be vastly different and we would not exist.
More coincidences:
Goldilocks climatology: Earth is just the right distance from the sun to maintain oceans, as well as to provide a hospitable temperature and atmosphere for the support of human life. Mars is too cold, Venus too hot. A difference of just a few percent in many variables would have ended the possibility of life; possible because of a very delicate balance. If the Earth were a few percent closer to the sun, the water would boil off; a few percent farther away and the atmosphere would not be breathable by humans because of the excessive carbon dioxide. We are far enough from other stars to preclude our being subject to stellar explosions, and the consequent cosmic radiation which would sterilize us at best, and kill us at worst.
The Moon: Frequently neglected, the specific structure and movement of the moon, is a major determinant of the weather, as well as the seasons. Without the moon, we would not have the mild climate that permitted human cultural, intellectual and technological development, notwithstanding the factors above.
Our moon was formed from a planetary collision because the colliding body just happened to have the required mass, just happened to have the required velocity and angle of collision, and just happened to have the required composition for its core and mantle.
Origin of Life: There is no satisfactory explanation for the origin of life from inanimate matter. A chicken/egg situation exists. All living cells require nucleic acid for replication. They also require proteins which can be produced only by nucleic acids. But nucleic acids can be produced only in the presence of proteins. Inanimate matter contains neither proteins or nucleic acids.
Steven Jay Gould, writing in the Oct. 1996 Discover, wrote: "To produce a creature with our structural and neurological complexity evolution must be creative in the vernacular sense of this word -- that is, evolution must be able to develop novel structures with previously unrealized functions. ... Yet if evolution worked simply by fashioning exquisitely adapted creatures in an ascending series, humans could never have originated at all. Precise adaptation, with each part finely honed to perform a definite function in an optimal way, can only lead to blind alleys, dead ends, and extinction. ... The key is flexibility, not admirable precision. Ironically, then, to make us at all, evolution must work by processes contrary to the prejudicial hopes that we invest in Darwin's legacy..."
Gould then goes on to explain his own theory of adaptability rather than specialization and concludes: "We are quirky, if glorious, accidents not to be repeated on this planet
Rabbi Norman Lamm wrotge an essay: "The Religious Implications of Extraterrestrial Life."
Lamm, former president of Yeshiva University, writes, "Already there has been established a new science, 'exobiology,' the study of forms of extraterrestrial life." He also references Walter Sullivan's volume, "We Are Not Alone." (McGraw Hill, 1964). Many experts are of the opinion that man will be found to be relatively inconsequential compared to other forms; a conclusion that Rabbi Lamm challenges in his essay on "extheology," a religious conception of a universe in which man is not the only inhabitant. He also reviews and analyzes the conflicting evidence on the possibility of other inhabitants.
Lamm writes, "Objectivity is obtained in science by recognizing that phenomena are without purpose. Modern thought, from scientism to existentialism, has banished teleology and reduced man to a purposeless and insignificant blob of protoplasm. But whether all that is modern is necessarily true is, of course, an entirely different question. -- More than once in the past have the wisest men of a generation been caught up in ardor and passion for certain ideas which seemed most plausible and which later, upon further reflection and examination, turned out to be follies. In our present situation, similarly, we must beware of over-familiarity with the fantastic and an overzealous stretching of the limits of possibility."
Lamm, along with many scientists, considers the possibilities of (significant) extraterrestrial life remote, and reviews the evidence for his conclusion. Nevertheless, he discusses the religious challenges that would ensue should the speculations prove correct. He discusses the subject from the standpoints of the uniqueness of man, the uniqueness of the Creator, and the relation between God and man. I cannot do the very long essayjustice here.
Hardly something!
Do you know how big (or small) a proton is?
Geek does not say how many billions of times smaller. How about billions of billions of billions?
What is known among mathematicians and scientists as a "singularity" is as unimaginably tiny as infinity is large; virtually nothing.
Both Maimonides and Nachmanides, around the Twelfth Century, wrote that the universe was created ex-nihilo, from nothing. In this they disagreed with Aristotle and Socrates, believers in the Steady State theory, and were way ahead of Kepler, Copernicus, Galileo et al. The Jewish sages got their theory from the Torah, though the Torah is not a scientific text.
You can read Maimonides' discussion in "The Guide of the Perplexed," Part 2, Ch.13-30, in connection with his proof of the existence of God. Although he thought, mistakenly, that the stars rotated around the earth, Maimonides was prescient in other respects.In Ch. 17, Page 296, he wrote,
In Ch. 30, Page 349, he wrote,
In Chapter 25, Maimonides wrote (Page 329),
Let me quote Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman (Nachmanides, 1195-1270) exactly from the English translation of his commentary on the Torah (Shilo Publishing House, NY 1973). Remember; he lived before Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler or Columbus. In his introduction to Genesis he said:
The January,1994 issue of National Geographic confirms what Nachmanides, the Jewish rabbi and scholar, wrote in the 12th century. (Pg. 12):
Do you see the light:-)
There are many so-called proofs available for God's existence but they all have fallacies. Philosophically speaking, Judaism holds that God stays hidden in order to preserve human free will. If we *knew* that God was watching our every move, we would not deserve any credit for following the Bible.
One important thing to consider is which of the alternatives is the most probable. As Rabbi Benjamin Blech wrote in, "Understanding Judaism," (Jason Aronson, 1991, Page 255):
From Robert Jastrow's book, God and the Astronomers (Jastrow is an agnostic scientist.):
A scientific spaghetti monster!
AMEN
You ask me for 200 known scientific parameters to prove the uniqueness of creation, I provide them, and you are not satisfied.
Would you also like an explanation of Einstein'sSpecial and General Relativity in my own words?
No surprise that you are both ignorant of science and anti-intellectual.
You don'[t know and you don't care.
You too!
Now you are pitching paganist polytheism.
Even a lowly potato, even a virus, demonstrates God. But the more complex, the human, the universe, the more profound the demonstration.
Someone showed an atheist a painting.
"This is beautiful. Who painted it?" he said.
"Did I say someone painted it? One minute the canvas was blank and the next minute the painting simply appeared."
There can be no creation without a creator.
That is OK. I am aggressive too.
And now the moment everyone has been waiting for (stop your eye rolling): CHUCKY'S 2 CENTS!
Let me start out by saying that this is my "belief system". It is not a statement of fact and is subject to change based upon my whims at a moments notice for absolutely no reason whatsoever. I "believe" that a supernatural entity outside our space/time universe (lets call it God just to make things easier) created our universe based upon laws of physics. The only direct action God caused was the singularity, and it just let things happen as they may after that.
If I was God (the God I "believe" in will take no offense to my placing myself in it's shoes for the sake of an interesting mental exercise. Plus it has a helluva sense of humor) I would not simply snap my fingers and have everything come into existence at my will. What fun is that? No, I would create a system of physical laws that guide existence for untold billions of years; afterall, I exist outside of space/time so time means nothing to me. Okay, maybe I would stick my nose in just to make sure Bruce Campbell made the Evil Dead movies, but that's it, honest.
I will not take offense to anyone who's belief system contradicts my own. In fact, I would think you weird if it didn't.
The something that was nothing is God, the only Existence prior to the beginning of space and time.
She created everything from nothing; a singularity.
God created nature itself. God IS supernatural.
Seriously? Funny, you say that I am the one who is endlessly literal. You may as well have said that since nobody was there to hear the bang, then it couldn't have made a sound - so it couldn't have happened.
Face it JR, you are a deist, at best. An agnostic at worst. A Christian though? I think not ... which is fine by me.
Maybe I would intervene as well to make sure flying cars were invented. Back when I was a kid, we were promised flying cars. WHERE THE HELL ARE THE FLYING CARS?
Very close to the Jewish concept of God but no cigar!
God not only created based on the laws of physics. She created physics itself.
Second, we say, in our morning prayers, that His goodness CONTINUALLY renews the work of creation, day after day.
Third, She did not create it like a clockmaker; set it up to run by itself. We believe He knows and cares about everything. Most of all She wants us to treat each other kindly.
Ultimately, I believe in a supreme force or divinity exists,far beyond our comprehension. I don't necessarily agree it's the same one the Abrahamic faiths believe in.
I cut Len some slack. I give him an A+ for his convictions and a U for his argumentative approach. Strong convictions require passion which is a poor substitute for quid pro quo or logical debate. I don't see hate anywhere near as much as I see blinding passion.
It is also impossible to have the experience of a dark sun. Does that prove anything at all? No. It's just stating the obvious - that certain things do not exist in reality. The opposite of free will in a living organism does not exist, making free will an impossibly weak argument for god(s). We've been through this so many times, it's nauseating.
Len, I believe in God, so please don't think that I'm being hard-headed or contrary-- but why, if scientists are moving closer to discovering a "God particle", would that preclude the thought that no other planet would support life?
Personally, if we are one of many, or absolutely alone in this universe-- either thought is utterly mind-boggling.
There is so much we don't know. Maybe there is a good reason for not knowing it all... As far as we've come, scientifically, there is just so much we don't know, yet. I don't think we, as a species, will ever stop learning... Or at least, I hope we don't.
What is your happy medium?
What do you think "exploded?"
Theword used is one thatconstitutes the essence of the thing, what it really is. Maimonides wrote in "The Guide for the Perplexed:
Before the creation nothing existed but God who is outside time and space.
Can you imagine humanity with no universe; no sun , moon or stars? Who are you to question why God does what He does?
There are several errors in logic here.
First, we exist. Regardless of how many criteria there are. You can sometimes roll six straight "snake eyes"... There's no need to invoke God.
Second, all these criteria are for Earth-like life. Personally, I would expect more exotic forms -- silicon, whatever...
Third, there are lots of plausible reasons for not "hearing" aliens, from quarantine to the "communications technology window".
Fundamentally, this seed starts with a conclusion (God created the universe), and reverse engineers arguments to support it.
A singularity is to a proton what infinity is to a millionexcept in reverse.
What other one do you have in mind and how do you know?
I am attempting to answer scornful ridiculing critiques in themost factual, polite way I can. If all that gets is a U it will have to do till you suggest a better way.
But thank you for the A+ and have a great week.
Where did you see hate, and what about the hate of the critics?
One of the major objections to "God" is that if there is a God then there can be no free will, because God would know the future. God indeed would have to know the future, to be God, but that does not impact free will, as I see it.
The Talmud says: "Everything is foreseen [by God] but there exists free will."
Lutherans believe in predestination but Jews and Catholics do not.
I provided a seed that says another planet that supports live is most unlikely. Scientists have been searching far and wide for over 20 years and found nothing.
Enjoy the mind-boggle.
In theory but it likely has never been done and never will be except with loaded dice. The odds against rolling a 1 for a single die six successive timesare6 to the 6th power or 46656 to 1. Doing it twice the odds are 46656-squared or over 2 billion to 1. Assuming 10 seconds per try it would take 690 years of continuous trying 24/7.
Don't even think of doing it 20 successive times let alone 200.
>>Second, all these criteria are for Earth-like life. Personally, I would expect more exotic forms -- silicon, whatever...
Life universally must be carbon based.
>>Third, there are lots of plausible reasons for not "hearing" aliens, from quarantine to the "communications technology window".
The seed conclusion is based on statistical probabilities. Read more here:
>>Fundamentally, this seed starts with a conclusion (God created the universe), and reverse engineers arguments to support it.
It may seem that way but itshows the virtual impossibility of random chance as the cause(the only other possibility) by working backwards.
What would YOU consider a wise answer?
You can lead a horse to water but cannot make him drink.
The only other explanation is that everything appeared by chance. Proving that is an even greater burden.
Care to convince me? I am all eyes.
The article says the government is giving up and withdrawing funding. Maybe you thought it referred to IRS and Benghazi
The closest spiral galaxy is Andromeda, a galaxy much like our own Milky Way. It is 2.2 million light years away from us. Andromeda is approaching our galaxy at a rate of 670,000 miles per hour. Five billion years from now it will probably collide with our Milky Way galaxy.
Care to take a rocket there to search flying 2.2 million years at the speed of light? You will not grow older doing that. Or wait a few billion years and it will be closer.
Perhaps you want to restrict your search to the Milky Way. That isonly 100,000 light years in diameter and 1,000 light years thick.