Rise of the “Crazy Buts”
By Ron Fournier
I spent most of the summer with Crazy Buts.
From Detroit, where my family lives, to northern Michigan, where my family vacations, I heard Republicans, independents, and even Democrats begin sentences this way: Donald Trump is crazy, but
Crazy, but hes a winner, and Im tired of America losing.
Crazy, but he cant be worse than what we got.
Crazy, but hes punishing the establishment.
Crazy, but hes driving the media nuts.
Crazy, but he says what I cant say.
Most dont mean crazy in a clinical sense. Crazy as in crass, a landscaper from rural Michigan told me in mid-July. Im not sure he has the temperament to be president, but I like how hes messing with your minds in Washington. Crazy like a crash-test dummy.
Crazy successful. Trump defied political conventions and conventional wisdom all summer, seizing support of one-third of registered Republicans and GOP-leaning independents in todays Washington Post/ ABC News poll. Combined with retired neurosurgeon Ben Carsons 20 percent, two political outsiders are favored by a majority of GOP voters.
Thats astonishingto anybody who hasnt been paying attention.
For more than a generation, the publics trust in social institutions has steadily declined, as virtually every foundation of American lifechurches, charities, schools, police, courts, small businesses, big businesses, the medial system, and the mediafailed to adapt to immense economic and technological change, a phenomena I wrote about in a 2012 essay called In Nothing We Trust . The trend is most pronounced in politics and government: Lessthan a quarter of Americans trust government in Washington always or most of the time; the Democratic and Republican parties approval ratings are less than 40 percent; and only 14 percent of Americans think well of Congress . Those are all-time lows.
And now this from The Washington Post/ ABC News poll:
Overall, the survey underscored the degree of dissatisfaction toward government and politics that is shaping the campaign. More than 7 in 10 Americans say people in politics cannot be trusted. More than 6 in 10 say the political system is dysfunctional. Sizable majorities of Democrats, Republicans and independents agree with those assessments.
Think about that. When professional partisans measure the health of their business strictly by campaign victories, they ignore a deadly cancer: Most Americans dont participate in politics or government, and most of those who do hate the system. Even people who regularly vote for candidates of a particular stripe are inspired by their loathing of the other party rather than respect for their own.
Populist restlessness has a foot in the Democratic campaign, too. Socialist Bernie Sanders has closed the gap on establishment favorite Hillary Rodham Clinton. Interestingly, Clinton runs about even with Trump on the critical issue of trust: Almost 6 in 10 Americans says Trump is not trustworthy, while 56 percent say that about the former secretary of State.
In June, I wrote that Trump should be taken seriously because he is a combed-over reflection of angry America. That has proven to be true.
But I also wrote, He wont win the nomination. That was a silly thing for me to say.
In an era of radical connectivity, instant celebrity, and social unrest and mistrust, almost nothing can be ruled out certainly not the electoral success of somebody who promises mass disruption. Barack Obama was such a person in 2008, though his pledge of positive change was frittered away. Who am I to predict 2016 wont be the year of negative disruption?
Even I misjudged how angry we are. Perhaps after years of disgust, disconnection, and disillusionment, we have moved beyond shrugging our shoulders at Washington. Maybe were shaking our fists.
That would be a good outcome, if our anger gets channeled into new political institutions and better leaders. But what if anger blinds our collective judgement?
Maybe a guy like Trump becomes president. Sounds crazy, but
Tags
Who is online
83 visitors

Crazy, but...
Uh hu. No matter how crazy it sounds, to the average Joe and Jane, it sounds crazy to listen to politician politic when allJoe and Janeare trying to do is pay bills and put food on the table. It's hard to take politicians seriously when they don't get anything done, day in and day, out except campaign and court power; all the while, regular folks are having an increasingly difficult time just getting the basics.
DC has brought this on themselves.
Every single one of them should be kicked to the curb, from the top all the way to the bottom.
Well let's see, 8 years of Clinton, 8 years of GW, and 6.5 years of Obama. (finishing out at 8 years)
That is 24 years of voting for the lesser of two evils only to find out we got the opposite.
The last popular candidate was shafted in a corrupt political scheme to keep the voices of America down. (Remember? John Boehner: "No more Ronald Reagan's" ie. no more popular candidates after blatantly shafting Ron Paul at the last republican convention?)
Does anyone expect any different?
One has to go to extremes to break through. That is the real message of T Rump, the Don Corleone of extreme.
Who is at fault?
WE are of course.
Ron Fournier is an ultimate beltway hack political analyst. If you don't want to believe me look him up on google or bing.
Fournier is one of the kings of the "both sides do it" school of political analysis
Not someone I would put up as the man to dissect the present political scene unless you want a "both sides do it" conclusion
Can't help but agree!
''That would be a good outcome, if our anger gets channeled into new political institutions and better leaders. But what if anger blinds our collective judgement?''
Bingo, there you are.
Perhaps.
Perhaps it isn't just one side or the other. Perhaps it isn't just both sides.
Perhaps, just perhaps, it's a systemic failure that neither side is helping to find solutions for; but, is feeding off of instead.
"Yes. Liberals bear equal responsibility for a xenophobic whackjob making a mockery of the already mock-worthy electoral process because liberals somehow abandoned hope for change while ushering in universal health coverage, marriage equality, two more women on the Supreme Court and the end of two damn wars, while conservatives were busy debating just how many blood draws it would take to get $200 a month in food stamps for your hungry children.
I can see the equivalence there, cant you?
This Trump thing has really brought out the desperation in the old guard of the Beltway press corps. As long as they could treatpolitics as a tennis match between two equally matched and equally worthy opponents, in which the only doubt about the outcome is whose name gets engraved on the trophy, they were free to not pay attention very much. Go to all the parties, stay at the ones with the hottest women and the best food. Watch the tussles happening on the House floor with detached amusement; its not like any of this MATTERS, right?
Theyve spent their whole lives like this, following these rules that they created and pretended were ironclad: Both sides deserve mention, both sides are equally good or bad, both sides are equally to blame for any failing. This allowed pundits like Fournier to bounce back and forth between Democratic and Republican camps being, if not everybodys friend, at least nobodys enemy. He followed the rules and therefore was virtuous."
"Trumps candidacy would, if they had the self-awareness God gave a carrot, force people like Fournier to confront the polite fictions that keep everything running smoothly, question the bullshit he feeds himself and his readers, and begin to consider that perhaps there is a difference between a president who tried to close Gitmo (even if he failed) and one who wants to put all of Mexico in there.
If he did start to question that, though, the fucking earth might cave in underneath him, so Fournier twists himself into knots trying to make Donald Trump the fault of liberals AS WELL AS conservatives, because that way Fournier can go about his business and nothing has to change."
"ushering in universal health coverage"
Author doesn't even appear to know what universal coverage is. What a joke.
marriage equality
Who cares if you had to make a mockery of the Constituion to do it?
two more women on the Supreme Court
Doesn't matter if they are worthy justices. Only that they are women. Perfect example of the identity politics Americans hate.
and the end of two damn wars,
Obama lost two wars (saying he ended then is weak), turned Libya into a terrorist playground, first ignored ISIS and then corrupted intelligence reports to fit his narrative that ISIS was being defeated. I could spend an hour on his manifest foreign policy failures (red line, russian reset, Jihadist stimulus agreement with Iran etc etc).
I can see the equivalence there, cant you?
It's funny how the Democrats have to pretend the Republicans have been running things for the last six and a half years. They've run the country into the ground and are now surprised Americans are mad.
I, and many others believe it is much, much deeper than that John. Deeper than Fournier, deeper than Rump, deeper than the last few election cycles.
It is a systemic failure. Both sides have been piranhas in a feeding frenzy, while the middle class starves more everyday, and the poor simply die off.
So while I hear what you are saying about the present political demise in the person of Rump, it is actually the product of a system wide, persistent and unavoidable failure. The same catastrophic consequences that give us a huckster like Clinton give us a huckster like Trump. Nether give a flyin' fig about the American people, about our kids, about our jobs, or our future. They eat us up like bubblegum and spit us out the same. It is so obvious that wide swaths of the political landscapehave lost ALL FAITH in the process. I give the entire thing maybe, maybe, another cycle or two, before there is revolution in the streets. There is only so much folks can take before they have had enough, and they are damn well nearly there. The only ones that don't recognize it at this point are partisan dreamers.
He didn't end two wars.
The first one was ended on terms that GW agreed to, I remember that Obama even wanted to alter those terms to make the first last even longer.
The Iraqi's bent him over slapped him on the ass and sent him packing.
It's not just the media that has this ideal of what is mucked up, it's die hard core progressive liberals that have also.
Yeah "UNIVERSAL" health care, oh you mean the universal pay more for less health care. I understand, anything a progressive liberal does requires taking more money from those that have the least to give.
24 years of progressivism, and we have arrived here.
I would say it's way past time for a change.
Here's a Democrat author James Howard Kunstler writing on a similar topic:
Hillarys committee to tackle health care reform came to grief, but the effort at least implied a recognition that medicine was turning into a shameless racket (now fully metastasized). Bill managed to shove through a species of welfare reform remarkable for a Democrat that has since deliquesced back into a swamp of disability fraud. But the Clinton turning point was the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act, which opened the door to an orgy of financial mischief so arrant and awful, and to a plague of corruption so broad and deep, that American life is now pitching into a long emergency.
Add to that now the signal failures of Barack Obama: 1) no prosecution or attempted regulation of widespread financial misdeeds 2) no effort to counter the disastrous Citizens United Supreme Court decision that allows corporations to buy elections; 3) no end to dubious military operations in distant lands, and 4) healthcare reform that only fortified the existing rackets take all that together and you can only recoil from whatever it means to be a Democrat.
And now the return of Hillary, gliding above the election arena like Rodan the Flying Reptile caw! caw! Get me outa here! Its not just her, of course. Its the whole disgusting circus parade of identity politics, and PC witch-hunting, and trans-sex drum-beating, and girl-lugging-a-mattress-around-campus idiocy, and blame-it-all-on-Whitey whinging, and drone-strike-du-jour warfare, and out-of-control NSA surveillance monkey business , plus throw in the outrageous scams of civil forfeiture under a president who was supposedly a professor of constitutional law the list of Democratic-sponsored absurdities and turpitudes gives me the vapors. . .
Lots of reasons for people of all political stripes to be mad.
"We are upset, so we are going to vote for a bigmouth ignoramus." Makes perfect sense to me. s
My guess would be that the people who are the most upset about the political process currently are the people who know the least about the issues.
Otherwise, they could not possibly justify supporting Donald Trump. I can see, to an extent (someone)supporting Rand Paul who is also an "outsider", because at least he understands issues, even if I disagree with his answers, but Trump? There is NO excuse. People like Fournier get paid to give analysis, so that is what he will do, even if it is ludicrous.
Hillary Clinton is a fricking Einstein next to Trump. She is a policy wonk. She could say backwards sentences about the issues that Trump couldn't say forwards. Even people that hate her guts say she knows her shit inside and out.
You may not agree with her at all, which is fine, but she is not comparable to Trump.
The opposite? Really? Somehow you think that Romney/Ryan and McCain/Palin would have been better than Obama/Biden? It's obvious that you hate the POTUS, but you may want to rethink that.
I agree she can run circles around the idiot. However that IS NOT the comparison Iam making. I used the word "huckster" not "ignoramus" for a reason. People are rejecting Hillary not because they don't trust her intellect, they are rejecting her because they don't trust her motivations. She is a liar,just like he is, she has continued to put politics ahead of the American people; people simply don't trust her. That is a fact.
Why is that? Why would folks be so self destructive and ignorant, even against all odds and understanding?
Because the political (and economic) system is broken, brokenbeyond repair. People don't trust the system anymore, they don't trust DC....AT ALL!Even if they don't completely understand why, even if they don't understand the facts. Even if they don't know politics, Even if they are dumber than rocks....That doesn't matter. You argue an excuse. I'm arguing a reason, whether it is good reasoning, or not.
People, regular people, people that don't have the time, education, or maybe even the gumption to involve or educate themselves are still, andcompletely, fed up. When people get desperate, when they are afraid, and lost, they do stupid shit. Even to the point of supporting an egomaniacal moron; because, in their minds, they don't see a difference between him and those they perceive as using and abusing them over, and over, and over, and over...
What makes it so hard for wonks, analysts, insiders, and politicos to understand what the plain 'ol John and Jane American Doe does instinctually? That question, and it's answer, ARE the answer.
Agree 1000%.
He wanted Ron Paul and now he wants Rand Paul. And he will tell us that the majority wants them. And people wonder why there is so much acrimony in discussions about politics.
People are manipulated by the media, and hypnotized by the spectacle. They don't give any thought to what they are doing and saying to the pollsters. What if Trump actually wins? It won't be the end of the world, even though the US would instantly become the laughingstock of the world to a degree we never have been in 239 years, but what would Trump accomplish ? Nothing ! He has no knowledge of government, and half of his plans would be opposed by his own party ! American politics would be a circus even more than it is now.
Then there is the idea that Trump is a populist.
The major issue in the country is that a large percentage of the population does not make enough money at their jobs. People HAVE TO HAVE multiple jobs or have both parents working in order to pay the bills of a family. Trump isn't going to do anything about that. Deporting Mexicans is not going to raise American wages.
People are allowing themselves to look like morons by supporting this man, and don't even realize it.
The media hasn't created the anger, dissolusionment, or dishonesty. That is pure DC. I can also promise you that if Hillary takes that victimization tack, it'll only make her look worse. The political climate isn't due to the media. That is false as well as a cop-out,overused and ridiculousto most Americans.
People are pissed because things are going to hell, and their elected officials are playing them for fools.
DC pros will be finding out very shortly how very quickly and easily they can be toast.
I think the answer to make candidates responsive is to kick them out of office at their 4 year reelection . That should send pols a message to pay attention to real problems .
Voters need to stop thinking rationally and start acting pissy ...
I can and have disagreed with the idea that Congress should make law where they are specifically restrained from making law, in regard to speech.
Even a congressman should be able to get that.
And Bush and Clinton and Christie and Cruz and Everson and Gilmore and Huckabee and Graham and Jindal and Graham and Walker and Biden and . . . . . . . .
Butt, butt, that's all folks.
Daffy Duck for President!
That will solve EVERYTHING!!!!
Wait a minute...... we tried that, three times in a row now,
I know, Everyone, altogether now, M... I... C..., K... E... Y...,
MOUSE!
No matter how bad the Prez, it would take more than 6 years to do what this country has gotten to. I think the 24 year period sounds more spot on.
Progressivism? Come on, you call the Bushes progressives? And what about 24 years of bad international policy. I think that both progressives and conservatives alike bare blame here.
Hence the Donald.
While both liberals and conservatives have been beating each other up black and blue, you seem to have not noticed that your parties have been shrinking and that more people now call themselves independents. Why do you think that is?
Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
It's the extremes that I blame for the Donald. People so desperate for anything but party bickering and blaming that even Trump looks better to them. What a sad commentary about partisanship.
The Donald should be your harbinger of things to come, if Washington doesn't straighten up its act... and the sad thing is, probably it won't. They have all been bought and sold already.
Amen Brother Larry!
That is a scary thought, Feronia, but it also may be true.
Yup.
He's crazy, but...
... there are a lot of crazy voters out there!
If your speaking about GW, compared to Reagan? his father? Eisenhower?
ABSOLUTELY!
Especially in foreign affairs.
Personally, I think the power of the presidency went to his head.
Absolutely SPOT ON! I agree 100%
Yeah and up until just a few weeks ago you were claiming that Hillary was a shoo-in.
Care to revise that now?
T Rump is going to drive all the weak candidates out of the race. Whoever is left, will destroy him when it comes time to talk brass tacks...
Carson is a surprise though. But I think his strong religious aspect, although a personal strength, is going to need watching, if only to see if the religious wackos can influence him.
Bush fading isn't a surprise though, I could see that coming before they even announced.
Your early adamant claims of a Hillary/Bush election are fading into the sunset.
If your speaking about GW, compared to Reagan? his father? Eisenhower?
No offense, but that is ridiculous. The last good GOP President was, ready for this, Nixon. And before that, Eisenhower. Ford (bless his heart) was just filling in. The only good thing Reagan did was to raise taxes when he saw supply side economics was a joke. Besides and I know there are fans of his that will scream otherwise about this, he was already showing signs of dementia by the middle of his second term. He was one of the worst Presidents in modern times, mostly because he was, as a rule, a puppet of his handlers, especially toward the end. HW tried, but Reagan didn't leave him much to work with but exploding deficits and a budget out of control.
As for Dubya, there is only one single thing he did right. Only ONE! He tried to reach out to Hispanics and get the GOP interested in comprehensive immigration control. Other then that he sucked dead baby bears at everything he tried. He was the reverse of King Midas. Everything he touched turned to instant shit.
Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
Perrie. In the end the next President will be someone with prior, elective government service and the more the better. A politician and not an outsider. Americans may say the want an outsider, but in the booth they always vote for experience in government. Trump is still a joke and will never be President. Neither will Carson or Fiorina.
How do you figure ? Over the decades, the GOP has swung back and forth between isolationism and interventionism. Right now, there are McCains and Pauls. Most Tea Partiers are Paulian isolationists.
Personally, I don't think foreign policy fits into the left / right spectrum at all. Most politicians' "foreign policy positions" are driven by domestic politics.
What did he do that was "good" enough to tilt the balance in his favor?
What did he do that was "good" enough to tilt the balance in his favor?
Well, with the glaring exception of not working hard enough to end the war in Vietnam soon enough, he was great at bringing the Soviets to the table for nuclear weapons talks and treaties and he re-opened communist China to the outside world. There is a saying that only Nixon could have gone to China and it's right. Also, he helped establish the EPA and worked at at least starting government intervention in taking control of pollution. Of course he was massively paranoid and a crook, but hey, nobody is perfect.
I think you're onto something . The "spectrum" has always been about strictly economic issues . Maybe some of that is about foreign aid but not usually .
One answer is to go back to well known former presidents . Here is Hillary's "creative" new take on that :
Hillary Clinton says Bill for Veep has 'crossed her mind.' Legal?
There is a case to be made that Bill Clinton under the Constitution is perfectly eligible to be VP.
OK. It's a judgement call, I suppose.
IMHO, "crook" is kinda hard to balance out...
Yes. Of course...
IMHO, America has not had any foreign policy at all, since the successful end to "containment". A national policy must be widely consensual, and persistent across multiple administrations of differing parties. We have domestically driven stop-gaps, zigging and zagging at each new administration.
Foreign aid is about two-tenths of one percentof the Federal budget. If it is important to a person's "foreign policy ideas"... then that person does not know what they are talking about.
Well we all know that I have an unusual take on politics in this country.
One that doesn't fit with "Conventional" or "Establishment" thinking.
Unfortunately for most, I'm right more than half the time.
You can see your conventional/ party bias in the comment above....
Which is as untrue as it is funny. But that is how you have to describe it to justify your disdain for anything conservative/Libertarian.
But trust me Libertarianism will destroy liberal socialism in the long run. People will always choose freedom from ideology over slavery to ideology.
Everytime I take the political ideology test, no matter where or who posts it, it shows me as a slightly liberal Libertarian. And I identify as a conservative.
I'm sure that tells you that I'm a wacko. To me it tells me how far the country has shifted left over the last 24 years.
My political life started out as a door knocker for Kennedy. If Jack was running I would be a staunch supporter even today.
What does that tell ya, I haven't changed, the world around me has, for the worse.
But trust me Libertarianism will destroy liberal socialism in the long run
I'm afraid I'm going to have to disagree with that. I think most Americans will see Libertarian-ism as too close to anarchy and I think they'd be right. Still, it's not going to happen in any of our lifetime's anyway and I don't believe in reincarnation. None of us will ever know.
I think it is (though Bill wants the job back so bad she'd probably better keep looking over her shoulder), but he wouldn't be able to run for re-election. If he COULD have run for President for a 3rd term, I haven't the slightest doubt that he would have won. So would Obama if it weren't for the 22nd Amendment.
That is the issue . But do the voters really want a 3rd term of Bill Clinton ? That is what they will get [in effect] if Hillary proceeds with that plan .
George McGovern
NwM,
Not exactly. Not as I would define "wacko". In my vocabulary, a wacko starts with an unshakeable dogma, and then draws from that dogma all sorts of crazy conclusions. Fundy wackos are the easiest example, but there are lots of others. Voodoo economics wackos. Racist wackos. ...
I don't see you that way. I don't think you have any underlying dogma. ("Libertarianism", IMNAAHO, is an empty buzz-word.)
You have a number of gut-feeling-based principles. (Thats an observation, not a criticism: a good person has good gut feelings!) They may or may not be coherent, precisely because they do not arise from any common foundation.
So... No. I do not consider you a wacko.