Who Represents German Muslims
Who Represents German Muslims
By Veli Sirin, The Gatestone Institute, December 21, 2014
The most serious and crushing harm to those Muslims who respect their non-Muslim neighbors and detest the extremists is that many Western commentators appear utterly uninformed about the representatives of the moderate, non-extremist Muslims.
How long will it take before responsible Westerners perceive the struggle among Muslims between extremists and non-extremists, between the radicals and anti-radicals?
Who represents Muslims in Germany? An integrated German-Turkish woman such as Tue Albayrak, who defends other women (left), or the small group of supporters of the "Islamic State?"
A Sunni Muslim funeral for the slain student Tue Albayrak , a German-born 22-year old woman of Turkish descent, was attended on December 3 by 1,500 mourners in Wchtersbach, a town in the western German state of Hesse. Prayers for Albayrak began in the local mosque, which is controlled by the Turkish-Islamic Union for Religious Affairs [DTB], an official arm of the Turkish government that administers Sunni religious affairs in Germany. She was then buried in her hometown, Bad Soden-Salmnster, not far away.
Tue Albayrak was an aspiring high school teacher, hoping to complete university courses in German language and in ethics. She was knocked to the pavement of a parking lot on the night of November 15, at a McDonald's restaurant in the city of Offenbach, also in Hesse. With a severe head injury and in a coma, she was kept alive for two weeks, but on November 28, her 23 rd birthday, her parents asked that life-support technology for her be switched off, and she died.
Whether the death of Tue Albayrak was caused by a blow to the head or by her impact on the pavement has yet to be made clear by investigators. But Tue perished, according to witnesses , after trying to protect two German girls, 13 and 16, whom she allegedly heard complaining of harassment in the restaurant's toilets. The girls did not come forward immediately; following German law, their identities and statements remain confidential.
Germans as a whole non-Muslims no less than Muslims have been moved by the case. Tue Albayrak has been treated as a civic hero. Calls for stricter measures against juvenile crime are accompanying appeals for improved schooling and more programs to prevent violence.
What immediate measures can prevent such incidents in the future? Perhaps teachers should be more aware; perhaps parents can choose better educational alternatives. Young women could be educated to defend themselves better physically. Training might be offered within the sports curriculum. Another possibility is to teach boys exercise self-control and avoid violence.
Click this link to read the whole article:
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/4959/german-muslim-leaders
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

This article is posted with the intention of it being commented upon by the NT members who posted the following comments about The Gatestone Institute, and about my posts. I need not identify them they know who they are. They are just blind to their own bias.
Referring to an article published by The Gatestone Institute
Who Represents German Muslims
Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan would like to think he does. With a Turkish Muslim immigrant population of over 3 million, they represent the largest Muslim minority in Germany. He has warned the Turkish immigrants against assimilation into German culture,""Assimilation? No. I have said this before and I'm saying it again - we don't compromise our language, religion and culture."
He has also stated his opposition to the term "moderate Muslim". In 2007 he said, "These descriptions are very ugly, it is offensive and an insult to our religion. There is no moderate or immoderate Islam. Islam is Islam and thats it.
This is, IMHO, a pretty good article. That's high praise, since I began reading it with a large dose of skepticism. The author is the head of a militant rights group, and the publisher is run by John Bolton. Considering the complexity of ethnic politics in Europe in general, and in Germany in particular... I wasn't expecting much.
Surprise! The author lays out the situation quite well, without too much bias. The quandary of "third-generation Turks" -- whose parents were born in Germany, but who are still held at arms-length by Germany's "blood inheritance only" citizenship laws -- is despicable. These are, in American vocabulary, "third-generation Dreamers"!
These people want to be German... but are above all being required to condemn activities in a corner of the world of which they know no more than you or I!
Erdogan had a choice, several years ago: install solid human-rights processes and institutions (and be eligible for the EU) or go the "Islamist democracy" route: "one man, one vote, one time".
He chose to keep power. Too bad for Turkey....
Germany does not grant citizenship by place of birth, only by parentage. A child born to Turkish parents, in Germany, is Turkish. That child grows up to marry another Turk-born-in-Germany... and their children are Turkish, too.
There are "Turks" in Germany whose parents never knew how to speak Turkish.
Yes. So since 2000, new cases are not being created. But the "Turks" born before 2000 are still screwed.
I was unaware of the change concerning dual citizenship. It's an improvement, but as your linked article says, the change is needed because the parents are "Turks".
Good comment, Randy.
Very interesting post, Robert.
I think that's a very American idea. Most European countries are homogenous. Swedes are Swedish. Czechs are Czech. Germans are German... today -- Germany is a historically recent construction. France is a bit different. It is the oldest nation state, and nationality / ethnicity are coherent for most of the country. But over the millenium+ that France has existed, it has collected other ethnicities at its periphery: Corsicans, Bretons, Basques, Alsatians, ... In each of these regions, there are militant defenders of the local language. Only Corsica (which was conquered by France just a few years before the birth of a fellow named Buonaparte) has a significant militant independentist fringe.
So the rule in Europe is conguity between ethnicity and citizenship... or rather... it was...
During the Glorious Thirty (the thirty years, 1945-1975, of strong, continuous economic growth) Europe didn't have enough workers to fill its factories. France brought in North Africans. Germany brought in Turks.
These gstarbeiter -- "guest workers" got lousy pay and housing... but far better than in their home countries. Two generations later...
I dont pretend to intimate knowledge of Germany. I know France pretty well, after forty years... The "Muslim integration" problem is vastly complex. Most "real French" want Maghrebins (North African Muslims) to be integrated... in someone else's neighborhood. (Sound familiar?) In response, young Maghrebins, who have never set foot in Africa, are ambiguous. They were born French. They want to BE French. And Muslim. Uh-oh!
And politics adds to the problem, rather than resolving it, with some parties playing the ethnic equivalent of the race card.
Integration progresses. Slowly...
Did you mean congruity ?
Yes. congruity