Democrats Lost the South through Culture War and Elitism
Fritz Hollings, John Edwards, Zell Miller, Blanche Lincoln, John Breaux, Kay Hagan, Mark Pryor and Mary Landrieu. These eight Democrats have been senators from the South in the past decade.If not for Southern Democrats, Republicans would have nearly had a filibuster-proof Senate supermajority after the 2002 elections, giving George W. Bush some real clout. Without Southern senators, Democrats wouldnt have taken over the Senate with Jim Jeffords party switch in 2001. If not for Southern Democrats, Obamacare wouldnt have become law.For the foreseeable future, though, Democrats will have make do without Southern senators.With Mary Landrieus gigantic loss on Saturday, following Hagans surprise loss and Pryors thumping, the Southern Democratic senator is officially extinct. In the House, there are no White Democrats from the South.Why did it happen?In short: Democrats waged a culture war against the South, trying to force Southerners to stop clinging to their guns and to God. When you try to make it illegal for people to conduct their own affairs according to their conscience, you tend to lose their votes.The self-soothing story the Left tells itself is that its all racism, that Democrats have lost the Southern vote because theyre not as willing to be racist as the Republicans are. Liberal columnist Michael Tomasky cheered the Democrats' loss of the South, which he lovingly called one big nuclear waste site of choleric, and extremely racialized, resentment.Any full accounting of Southern politics has to involve race and racism, but it isnt a top reason for the realignment.Tomasky and other liberals may not have heard of Sen. Tim Scott, the first black Southerner elected to the U.S. Senate since reconstruction. South Carolina not only elected Scott to the Senate in a special election this fall, it gave him 757,000 votes 85,000 more votes than his South Carolina colleague Lindsey Graham received the same day.South Carolinas voters re-elected their Republican Governor, Nikki Haley, nee Nimrata Nikki Randhawa. The state that defeated Mary Landrieu has had an Indian-American governor since the 2007 elections.White racism cant explain the GOP takeover of the South.The best explanation comes from the mouth of President Obama himself. Speaking to San Francisco donors in 2008 about white voters in the Midwest, Obama lucidly expressed his low opinion of all non-rich voters in flyover country: they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion.Naturally, Democrats and the Left have tried to pry Southerners away from their guns and religion. Gun control has largely been a culture war effort for Democrats. Some of the southern areas have cultures that we have to overcome, was Congressman Charles Rangels explanation for why gun control was both needed and difficult.The Washington Posts Gene Weingarten cursed the Second Amendment as "the refuge of bumpkins and yeehaws who like to think they are protecting their homes against imagined swarthy marauders desperate to steal their flea-bitten sofas from their rotting front porches."Obama and his party waged this culture-war crusade with glee and failed, but not before making it clear that they disapproved of the way Southerners live.And the Democrats have made it clear that they are willing to use government to impose their morality on others. Through the courts, the Left has banned prayers at high school football games and forced states to remove the Ten Commandments from public grounds.The Obama administration, through its birth-control mandate that includes abortifacient drugs, has told Christian employers that they cant run their businesses as Christians.Theres no mystery here, and no need to assign widespread racism to why Southerners have rejected Democrats. Its simple: Democrats and the Left have tried to outlaw Southerners way of life.Heres a related factor in the realignment: Democrats have given up on being the populist party, and as they have increasingly won over the wealthy suburbs and the college-educated have embraced their status as the party of the economic elite.As crony capitalism and corporate welfare have grown, and as the Washington region has sucked in more and more of the nations wealth, Republicans have started to take up the populist mantle.Alabamas Jeff Sessions, whose populism flares up in many ways, joined Louisianas David Vitter in co-sponsoring a bill to break up the big banks. Sens. Landrieu, Hagan and Pryor all campaigned unsuccessfully on their support for the Export-Import Bank (a federal agency that subsidizes U.S. manufacturers and the banks that finance them).Democrats have become the party of Hyde Park and Chevy Chase elitist on culture and economics. Its no wonder they cant also be the party of Charleston and Shreveport.Timothy P. Carney, The Washington Examiner's senior political columnist, can be contacted at tcarney@washingtonexaminer.com. His column appears Sunday and Wednesday on washingtonexaminer.com. http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/democrats-lost-the-south-through-culture-war-and-elitism/article/2557157

I would add mocking and bigotry, the dominate attitudes of the democratic elite towards southerners, exacerbated their problems in winning votes.
That, right there, is exactly what this article refers to. An elitists, condescending and judgmental attitude as there ever was, and prime example of what hascaused the exodus from the Democratic party. Do you actually promote yourselves as theparty of "I am smarter than you, I am better than you" or is it that you just can't help but come across that way? I know lottsa Democrats, yet not all seem to be of the same smarmy ilk.
I don't think that the democrats really understand the southern mentality of today all that well. It was one thing when you had Governor Wallace protesting the integration of Alabama's schools, but Times Have Changed. I think most southerners have accepted that protest is futile, and I HOPE they have. It is better, these days, for blacks, but still not great.
Kentucky, which is the northern-most southen state, and the southern-most northern state, is it's own little political world, so I can't really judge what is going on in the states to the south of me... I haven't been there any length of time for quite a while. But, just as some observations: there is more to the south than sweet tea:
It may be lingering racism, and it may also be economic disadvantages. Or both. Every night, on the news, they announce Louisville's Most Wanted. They are all black. I haven't seen a white guy on there in years. Is it because only the black people commit the worst crimes? OR is it that they commit crimes because they are educationally and economically disadvantaged? OR is it the racism of the TV stations? I don't know.
As far as God goes, well, that's not going to change any time soon. Southerners are staunch believers. Even though I believe in God, I get tired of all the social Hoo-Haa that goes on with church, especially in the small towns. If one doesn't believe as they do, one is a social pariah. Period.
I surely did! Pfffthpt! What an idiot!
Thanks for providing the perfect example of the author's point. What's your slur of choice when describing chicago voters who continue to vote the policies that ran that city into the ground?
I think it is so people can identify them, sort of like John Walsh's show, America's Most Wanted. They always say that the police are asking for help in finding them...
But, yeah, makes you wonder...
Dowser,
That's a great post... truthful and to the point. You don't mess with a Southerner's guns or God, or, as you pointed out with your comment about the support the South gives the military, with his country. We produced the likes of Jim Bowie, Robert E. Lee, Davy Crockett, Sgt. York, Audie Murphy, ..... and just for good measure, we produced the most famous outlaw of all time, Jesse James.
Gunmen all, who stood their ground in the face of incalculable odds against them ever coming out of their conflicts alive... and some of them didn't.
These are the breed of people against whose descendants the Democrats set their anti-gun and anti-God campaigns, without understanding what it would cost them in the form of elections.
These are the breed of people against whose descendants the Democrats set their anti-gun and anti-God campaigns, without understanding what it would cost them in the form of electio
Their anger that southerners don'timmediatelyditch their culture and beliefs and immediately bow down and blindly accept what northern liberals tell them to do always baffles me. It's like Democrats really don't want to win in the south ever again.
I think the democrats do want to win in the south, but are going about it the wrong way. You can't take God out of the equation, because then, you've got all the preachers screaming hell fire and brimstone at you on Sunday.
These preachers have people believing that democrats are the anti-christ, and what-not. The most vocal are the Southern Baptist preachers, it seems, although all of them do it. My husband works with several people who are not only convinced that the earth is 6,000 years old, but that Obama is the anti-christ. Whoever got the preachers on board was one smart cookie.
All this hellfire and brimstone always amazes me, because the Southern Baptists have their convention here in town. I used to work in an office catycornered across from a titty bar, and during the convention, I could barely find a place to park and GET to work as they elbowed their way past me to be the first inside the titty bar when the show began. Out on the street they were very huffy to me, a conservatively dressed professional with a briefcase, computer, and purse. Obviously, I worked at some 'den of inequity' as opposed to an engineering office, and was obviously a woman of ill-gotten gains, since I walked on the same street as the titty bar. They all looked like well-dressed poliwogs, as they purposefully strode to the titty bar, raking me with a glance of condemnation.
It's just one of the strange contradictions that seem to exist in the south, that are accepted without question. Until the democrats can get God on their side and in their corner, they don't have a chance in the south.
But that is just my opinion...
You don't like peanut butter?
Thanks, mimi! I appreciate your kind comment.
I was telling the truth as I know it. That doesn't mean it's right.
I understand. I enjoy traveling in the south, because everyone talks to you and it's nice. I mean, you can talk to the little old ladies about produce and they don't behave as if you're going to rob them. They smile back.
I like southern food, with all it's grease, butter, and lard. My heart may not, but the rest of me does. I love sweet tea, even though tonight at dinner, we had some that tasted as if it had been brewed with the wash water from dirty sweat socks. Grandma would call it a bad batch.
We're not really southern, here in Louisville. My family has been in KY for over 200 years now, and I can't imagine living any where else. Yet, I get annoyed at our backwardsness.
I know there are a lot of people that dislike the south to the point where they say nothing good ever came out of it. Well, MY comment is this: There are a lot of nice people down south. Some of them are redneck nutjobs, but most of them are just nice folks that happen to live down south. There are a lot of nice people that live up north, too. Some of them are rude yankees, but most people are just nice folks that happen to live up north.
Maybe it is all in how we look at things through our own eyes, and not necessarily the way things really are. I'm sure one can go into any city in the US and find contradictions and things you don't like. I'm sure one can go into any city, too, and find things you do.
Eh, it's true. The south was living on grass and acorns when it quit. However much we all hate the facts of the reasons for that war, we all have to stop and pay attention to one small fact: The south did not quit, did not falter, and was willing to give EVERYTHING for what they believed in. Our enemies should take note. They should also realize that a lot of southern boys serve in our military. They won't quit, today, either. There is nothing wrong with anyone admitting that.
There is a really good book that I can't read any more because it gives me nightmares-- Last Full Measure by one of the Shaaren's. The son, I believe. It isn't a one-sided story, by any means.
Also, and I just remembered this, but our police chief is black and he is the one that decides who gets their picture on the news.
Again, go figure.
I don't think they want to go, except for Mississippi that votes for seccession every year. They also vote against women having the vote, every year.
No need to remind me why I don't want to live in Mississippi.
I know, I know...
However, the political climate in the south is decided mainly by what the preacher says. I don't agree with it, I think it's pretty dumb, etc. But that is the reality of the situation.
The republicans have certainly cornered the market on the God issue. I agree with your assessment, but I'm just telling what I think is the truth.
Ahhhhh. Thanks!
Yeah, and I'm a lone voice in the wilderness, too. I know there are other democrats out there, but I sure wish I could find 'em.
The Democrats lost the south because they have become enslaved by the religious right, aka; Evangelicals, Baptists and Fundamentalists.
Chicago is the most segregated city in the country according to the Manahtten Institute. The "huge amount of diversity" you cite is only in the aggregate. On a day to day level, the people of Chicago segregate themselves at least as much as the people of Green Bough.
Moreover, the south is in the midst of reversing "great migration" of the fist half of the last century, as blacks are leaving the urban horrors of places like Chicago to return to the South.
"But today, generations later, amid higher costs of living, concerns over crime and what many perceive as too few job opportunities in those same cities, African Americans are returning to the South in the largest numbers since the first Great Migration, according to sociologists and those who have studied the new migration. During the 1940s, roughly 1.5 million blacks migrated to the North. Between 2000 and 2010, an estimated 1,336,097 blacks moved to seven major southern cities alone, according to the Brookings Institute, which compiled the most recent data from the U.S. Census. Former magnets for black migrants, including Illinois, Michigan, New York and California (blue states all, notes S.T.) all have had black population declines "
...
John,
Melodrama or not, Johnny, it's true.
Better ask some of the guys who are actively in combat zones about that. Many have said there is no one they would rather have at their six than a redneck from the South, because they don't give up and they don't run, and they are crack shots, and their belief in "G_d and country" means they can be counted on to stand their ground.
The irony is that Southerners take a sort of pride in their ability to be poor and get by. Ever heard of "A country boy can survive?"
Southerners consider themselves "rich" as long as they have family and friends and something on the table at dinner time. As long as they can fish and hunt, play music and dance, worship on Sunday, drink on Saturday night, salute the flag any damn time it's on a flag pole, they really don't care who gets "theirs" and they generally don't worry about politics until you try to take their guns and their G_d.
And they flat out don't believe you when you try to tell them this is not a Christian nation because every president before Obama played into the notion that we ARE a Christian nation.
Their favorite holidays are Fourth of July and Memorial Day, Christmas is right there at the top.
The idiot politicians who don't understand this, who haven't realized that Country Music and Western Music is tops in the South for a frickin' good reason deserve to die on the political vine.
Before you start caterwaulin' about "let 'em go" you should probably take a good look at what you will be paying in tariff for goods that will have to cross the "border" into the Union states from the South should that unlikely event ever happen.
People who think they are "rich" if they have G_d and family are hard to convince that they are "poor." And they are not going to vote for a party that they think are trying to strip them of either one, and they see guns as necessary in being able to take care of family and putting food on the table.
You are welcome, Dowser, and no, it doesn't mean it is right.
I am not a Christian, but most of my family are. The Southern mind set is just foreign to most people who do not live here.
I laughed at your tale of going to work during the Baptist convention. There are so many stories and jokes about the pious Baptist and their Sunday sermons after six days of good livin'. One of the best is how most of the other Christian religions have folks who will sit on the porch on Saturday evenings and drink their beer feeling sorry for the Baptists who have to hide under the bed to drink so they can walk into church on Sunday with heads held high... lol.
The joke about the Catholics is that they can do anything they want six days of the week as long as they make it to Confession on Sunday before they die..which is why Catholicism is the religion of choice for politicians and criminals...
They should take a look at the number of US presidents who came from the South. They should look up Audie Murphy and Sgt. York and their unbelievable courage during war time.
The Choctaw were the first Code Talkers, and the Choctaw Nation originated in the South.
Vivien Thomas, a black janitor at Vanderbilt Hospital in Nashville in 1930, along with Alfred Blalock, a white surgeon, pioneered heart surgery. When Dr.Helen Taussig challenged Blalock to come up with something to help "Blue Babies" these two men rose to the challenge even though the laws of the time made it necessary for Thomas to enter the hospital through the back doors of the hospital.
There are many more but you can't educate someone who chooses to remain ignorant.
Randy, come and get your sign.
(Sigh)
Aeon, just when I have hope for you......
You are wrong, flame.
Mimi,
Then those Catholics don't understand their own faith. They can't be relieved of their evil deeds without true contrition. They can go through the motions, but in reality every good Catholic understands that going to church and giving confession means nada if your intent is to go right out the door and redo what you just confessed.
Really.
If Democrats are using Duck Dynasty,in their analysis and staging of southern voting demographics, I'd say that is a largely unrealistic strategy. Instead of trying to divide and conquer voters, politicians would do well to instead identify the core issues that are of concern to average Americans. Those from the southare concerned about thesame things as other Americans; Jobs, bills, debt, physical, financial and educational security for their children...
Yet ridicule and demonization seem to be the rule. The plan seems to be transforming peoples values to match the Party's agenda, rather than the party attempting to clarify their own agenda, to more closely align themselves with voters wishes. That is a recipe for failure.
You are defining diversity strictly by multiple races of people who live in an area while other folks seem to want to think of TRUE diversity as different races living in harmony. At least that's my take on it. Although Chicago may be Diverse as far as races it is also segregated and so is probably the worst example of diversity I can think of, with the possibility of Detroit. Or perhaps a good example of failed diversity? Anyhow, I too agree that my idea of diversity is people living in harmony not a segregated city like Chicago. Isn't segregation in opposition to diversity after all? So who is wrong? It depends on your definition of diversity I suppose.
You just can't help proving the article to be true can you?
Guess the Chicago liberals that keep voting in the same crooks deserve what they got too eh?
This is what happened in Detroit too, in case you didn't know.
That is blatant dissembling. It is however revealing as to why and how politicians have lost their way in understanding and representing their constituency, in affect, contriving the political argument that indeed, it IS a Party's job to change the values of voters. If that is the plan, it's no wonder that so many folks, whether Left or Right, Southern or Northern, coastal or central, city or country are losing faith in politicians and the system. Politicians and their parties have no one to blame but themselves for being viewed as elitists, self centered, and greedy.
As is evidenced in some of the comments to this article...
No thanks, we will just stay in Dixie. You guys up North can keep your hell.
Thanks Max, appreciate that bud.
:~)
Politicians seem to have no respect for the citizens of this great country; and, that is reflected by the most partisan of us. Sad, but true.
You're right.
Sigh.
Watching elitists try to justify their condescension is just plain revolting.
Mimi, that was one of the best comments I've ever read.
I'm not going to debate anyone on it. If they don't understand, then that is their misfortune, not ours.
I think a lot of people really have a misunderstanding of the south here. It's kind of like if the United States is so bad, why do so many risk their lives to come to this country. Do you see many people rushing from the south to the north? I don't think so. Where have all the school shootings been including the one today Friday December 12th 2014? Not in the south and not in conservative environments.
Step on up Randy. You can release that feeling down deep inside you, I'm sure. You'll feel a whole lot better when it's gone.
While I would not really put it as bluntly as you, your reply does sum it up pretty well....for the most part.
The Civil Rights Act was a major turning point for the democrats in the south and since the rise fundamentalist christianity as an immoral political force within the republican ranks, it has all but alienated the democrats there.
I think so, too, Six. It's easy to make fun of something, or dislike something you don't understand.
We have a LOT of people from up north down here, in Louisville. Most of my fellow band parents, if not 'locals', are from Michigan, Indiana, and Ohio. They are also from Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, New York State, and New Jersey. If it's so bad down here, why do people move here and are happy? Most of the people I talk with would not move back for love nor money.
I think a lot of people would be surprised about a lot of things, if they just came down here for a look. At the same time, if this is how they feel, just pass on through KY and keep going. The last thing we need is more condescending, smug, and rude northern creeps.