Executive Action – Where Do We Go From Here? By Robert in Ohio
The President addressed the nation last evening and outlined his executive action providing legal status, rather than full and immediate amnesty as many on the far right have been wailing about, to millions of illegal immigrants in the U.S.. You will note that I termed these individuals as illegal immigrants, rather than illegal aliens, as the problem with undocumented visitors from other planets is a subject for another article. The majority of the illegal immigrants who will be affected by this executive action are Hispanic with origins in Mexico, Central America and South America and while the border states are home to large numbers of the illegal immigrants, they are located around the country in large cities of nearly every state.
There are a number of points that are arguable concerning the presidents executive action, i.e. his approach to the immigration issues facing the nation, the political motivation and the timing of the action but most reasonable citizens will agree that something needs to be done to fix a broken immigration and border security process in the U.S. In response to those questions and criticisms, the President challenged the Congress to pass a bill to replace the executive action he has announced, and it is very likely that early in 2015 a number of immigration bills (border security, expansion of visas for skilled workers, a path to legal status, etc) different in approach and scope to the executive action will be passed by the Congress and presented to the president. It is just as likely that the President will veto those bills he receives and that funding for the various processes of the executive action will be curtailed or eliminated as part of the budget process, putting the prospect of shutting down the government on the presidents desk if he decides to veto those budget bills.
Many on the right and even some on the left have problems with the how rather than the what as far as the executive action on immigration policy is concerned.
Interpretations of what is going to happen vary greatly based on a speakers location on the political and ideological continuum - it is too much, not enough or just right. Cries of amnesty are heard loudly from opponents of the executive action, with echoes of political base building, shredding the constitution and the end of separation of powers thrown in the mix. Supporters are equally vocal and hyperbolic in support of the action, asserting that all presidents have done similar things, that the action is not permanent even those changes such as these tend to have the inertia effect and last forever and that there will be no cost but rather significant contributions to the economy by these actions.
Will there be a positive or negative effect on unemployment, wage levels, social safety net costs and services? Will there be scope creep as the executive action processes take hold that will encompass many more millions of illegal immigrants than the President and his adherents have spoken about in promoting the executive action?
The presidents executive action allows illegal immigrants, who are the parents of citizens, to obtain a three deferment of deportation provided they pass a background check; expands the DACA directive; makes changes to immigrant labor policies; and, provides for citizenship education for legal residents and makes changes to the process of paying fees for the citizenship process. It does not expand the scope of the visa programs for skilled foreign workers, desired by many industries in the U.S. Is there room among these items for a compromise between the two sides? Perhaps!!
There are some concerns in the private sector about the effect of the orders on labor and wages both on the part of employers and employees. Illegal immigrants coming out of the shadows will be able to take positions in fields heretofore unavailable to them and that could affect the employment of some citizens. The work permit status of so many illegal immigrants at the same time could push wages up in some entry level positions and may or may not adversely affect the number of citizens hired into those positions.
There are more unknowns than knowns about what will happen but there is a lot of room for discussion and dare I say compromise.

President Obama's executive action plan for immigration is nether the answer to the immigration challenge nor the pathway to chaos.
It could be a starting point
It might be a starting point
It needs to be a starting point
Excellent Mike.
The only difference this will make for many illegals is now they don't have to worry about producing the (forged) papers to prove they are allowed to be here. The earned income tax credit will wipe out any tax gains for the country. They will only rush to file back taxes if they are going to get a refund, not if they owe. And if there are conditions they must meet to stay, it should follow that if those conditions are not met, they will be immediately deported, right?
Wow
A lot of negativity so far
I hold on to the idea that we might see a bill or series of bills come out of the Congress that will provide mat least the majority of what is in the executive action, along with expanded visa program for skilled foreign tech and engineering workers desired by the private sector and significant border security process improvements.
I also think that President Obama will be open to such a meeting in the middle rather than a fight bill after bill in the appropriation and budget process with provisions to reduce funding foroffices and programs that support the provisions of the executive actions he has put in place.
Of course, when I look the glass is half full
You may be correct, but if you are that means that there is no room for any compromise from President Obama and when one side of the process is unwilling to give anything (witness this issue for the past few yeas) nothing gets done.
But as I said you may beright, in which case the insanity continues and President Obama spends the next two years vetoing bills one another which may end up being good politics in the long run but would seem to be very bad for the country in the near term.
flameaway
You mightbe right, but I hope you are wrong and some how a compromise comes out of this
Thanks for the feedback
Mike
I disagree, to a degree
This could be a pivot point to compromise, if the Republicans pass real immigration reform an the president is open to giving a little to get a lot
John
But if they do not follow the steps and process the president laid out then they will be deported at least that is what the order says
I agree.
If they pass some type reform it will be as big of a disaster as healthcare reform. Most of these people are low income and will pay little income taxes. They will then be eligible for all kinds of government benefits and entitlements like Obamacare subsidies, medicaid and disability that will drive us farther into the ground. It is the goal of the democrats to get as many people hooked on government benefits as possible and that is why democrats are pushing for so called reform.
Dean
Now that perspective is truly of a half empty glass
Thanks for sharing
Mike
He could do it 60 days from now or he could have done it 60 days go or two years ago or two years from now
All of that is moot, it is done and now we have to deal with it
Thanks for the feedback
hold on to the idea that we might see a bill or series of bills come out of the Congress that will provide mat least the majority of what is in the executive action,
Why in God's name would republicans want to do that? With deportation off the table, there's no pressure on Congress to anything on these issues right now. Congress will pass some border control issues that are widely popular in among bothrepublicansand the public in general while the amnesty remains in place. If Obama wants to veto legislation that secures the border, we will have that fight.
Obama'spoisonedthe well. There is zero chance of acomprehensivesolution taking place now. Maybe if an adult is elected in 2016 you'll some movement towards it. But there's zero chance theRepublicans willwork with Obama now on this and there's certainly nopoliticalpressure onthem to do so. As a matter of fact, Republicans can reward Obama'sconstitutionalterrorism if they want to have any support in 2016.
You took the words right out of my mouth, how about the health care sector, the number of professional health care workers been trained in the USA, having to return to their country of origin, also, entrepreneurs, starting businesses and hiring Americans, even if they hire people from their own country, they have to pay taxes...
Why wouldn't they do that in order to get an expanded work visa programs for skilled tech and engineering workers to work in the U.S. which they will not get past President Obama's veto unless they give in on something he wants.
Enough with the clichd metaphors "poisoned the well", "burnt playing with fire", "constitutional terrorism", etc etc
If they do not do something with immigration, with jobs, with infrastructure and other issues facing the nation their support in 2016 will be eroded even further and there will not even be the small chance there is no of winning the white house.
CM
Thanks for the feedback
It remains to be seen if either the Congress or the President is really willing to give a little to get a little, but I remain optimistic.
There were zero chances when Mitch McConnell said "His Mission", was to make President Obama a one term President, and he and Boehner sat on their Azzes and did nothing, it was always ZERO CHANCES GOP would work with Obama...
I believe this is a good move by The President, but, Boehner and McConnell will remain adamant and not do anything but more lawsuits...But, its good to be optimistic, Obama will just do his thing and to hell with them, as long as he remains within the laws...
y do that in order to get an expanded work visa programs for skilled tech and engineering workers to work in the U.S
We don't need any more. There are plenty of skilled tech and engineering workers in the USA right now.
"A Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) report released on Tuesday ahead of a panel on the subject at the National Press Club found that from 2007-2012,STEM employment averaged "averaged only 105,000 jobs annually" while the U.S. admitted about 129,000 immigrants with STEM degrees. That means "the number of new immigrants with STEM degrees admitted each year is by itself higher than the total growth in STEM employment." During that time period, thenumber of U.S.-born STEM graduates grew by an average of 115,00 a year.
Authors Steven Camarota, CIS's director of research, and Karen Ziegler, a CIS demographer, wrote that these numbers are "truly extraordinary" and "it should not be surprising that most STEM graduates (immigrant or native) do not have STEM jobs."
The report, titled, Is There a STEM Worker Shortage?A look at employment and wages in science, technology, engineering, and math , isconsistent with research fromGeorgetown University, the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), the Rand Corporation, the Urban Institute, and the National Research Council that have alsofound no evidence that America has a shortage of high-tech workers. And its findings concluded that America "has more than twice as many workers with STEM degrees as there are STEM jobs." When combined with slight wage growth in the STEM fields for more than a decade, the authors concluded that "both employment and wage data indicate there is no shortage of STEM workers in the United States."
...
"enough with the clichd metaphors "poisoned the well", "burnt playing with fire" , "constitutional terrorism",
No. Accuracy compels them.
o n their support in 2016 will be eroded even further and there will not even be the small chance there is no of winning the white house
Like failure to pass immigration reformed doomed them in 2014? They have about a 50% chance of winning the white house in 2016 and it will come down to which candidate people "like" better, not actual issues.
here were zero chances when Mitch McConnell said "His Mission"
That's obviously false. Obama's amnesty passed McConnell's Senate. When McConnell said that, the Republicans were powerless to stop Speaker Pelosi and Leader Reid from passing amnesty. Why did they sit on their azzes?
There's been 3 national elections since then and Republican representation in Congress is now at its highest levels since the 1920s after being at about its lowest point in 2009. Americans obviously like having Republicans block Obama.
No. Accuracy compels them.
Cliches are never needed much less compelled, they are filler when content is missing from and argument
Like failure to pass immigration reformed doomed them in 2014?
The white house is what I mentioned and their chances are slim and falling at this point for 2016
His legacy is important to him and should be but a long term solution to the immigration issue and long term changes needed in other areas are more important than his legacy and the republican egos.
and their chances are slim and falling at this point for 2016
That's insane and completely unsupportable unless you are some sort of witch who can see into the future. But please quantify exactly how far the republicans chances have fallen since the amnesty? 2.4% or is it 2.5%?
No one even knows who the candidates are and what the big issues are going to be at this point. In 2006, no one knew that the 2008 election would be dominated by a financial meltdown.
Speculation at this point about which party (since we don't even know the candidates) will win the election and what issues will dominate is pure silliness.
At this point, odds are that should she run Hillary will be elected in 2016 regardless of who runs against her, with J Bush being likely to give her the best run for her money.
The republicans chances for the presidency have been falling since they put up such crap candidates in the past two elections and did everything but govern with the power that they had in Washington.
Christie, Bush, Paul, Perry, Rubio, Romney (again) - which of those do you really think has a chance to win in 2016?
If the Republicans prove that they are in Congress to actually govern rather than simply the on Obama for the next two years and then somehow find a viable candidate they might really have a chance in 2016. If they continue to simply fight against rather than work with the executive branch then they will lose the white house in 2016.
What the private sector didn't get in the executive action --
My opinion.
The Republicans have been painted into a corner. Any legislation they are likely to pass will either take away something that millions currently have, like and/or hope to have and like, i.e. ACA, or the current Immigration action and
If Republicans want the White House in 2016, they will most likely have to consider GIVING things most Americans want, but which will piss off its base i.e. an increase in the minimum wage.
People will by 2016 wish they were corporations my friend
Careful what you wish for
A Mac
Thanks for the perspective
I said pretty he same thing earlier in the thread - the Republicans will send a bill to Obama with pretty much everything in the executive action along with a couple of things they way, e.g. expanded H1B visa program and ?? and he ends up signing it
Of course that is just my opinion.
Thanks again
Here's more, RIO,
A bi-partisan Senate Immigration Reform Bill has been in the House for a year and a half; Boehner won't call it for a vote because he knows it will win! HE LIKELY LOSES HIS SPEAKERSHIP BY PUTTING UP A BILL THAT WILL WIN!
He's been painted into a corner by the radical-right Tea Party House Members who pander to the xenophobes and haters in the Republican base.
And a recent poll (I'll find the link) shows that 74% of Americans don't want another government shutdown -- this one predicated on Obama's immigration order. McConnell and some other Republicans have stated they don't want a shutdown and a budget default -- but Cruz, Bachmann and other Tea Party types are pushing a shutdown.
Republicans did well in the 2014 elections because dumbass, lazy Democrats sat home -- the lowest midterm turnout in 42 years. SHAME ON DEMOCRATS!
But in a Presidential election year, in 2016, even lazy Democrats will turn out big time, along with a tidal wave of Hispanics, minorities and other traditional Democrat voters. Boobus americana often gets what it deserves -- but sometimes, it gets the last word.
Again, this is my opinion and only time will tell.
A Mac
Just as everyone needs to accept the president's executive action, everyone also needs to accept that the bill passed by the Senate that died in the House will not be the bill sent to the president.
I stand by my prediction that a bill is sent to the president that contains most all of what is in the executive order and a couple of things that the Republicans want and that the president signs it and the executive order is replaced and forgotten.
Appreciate the feedback
Laws not broken - They are not enforced.
Immigration and Nationality Act - H.R. 5678, June 27, 1952, Public Law 414-June 27, 1952
Immigration Naturalization Act of 1940 as Amended -
Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigration Responsibility Act of 1996 - ...
Bills passed by the House that Harry Reid is sitting on (206 for the 113th Congress) -
1. H.R.15 : Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act
2. H.R.72 : Border Security, Cooperation, and Act Now Drug War Prevention Act of 2013
3. H.R.140 : Birthright Citizenship Act of 2013
7. H.R.406 : To provide discretionary authority to an immigration judge to determine that an alien parent of a United States citizen child should not be ordered removed, deported, or excluded from the United States.
8. H.R.425 : To prohibit the use of funds for the rule entitled "Provisional Unlawful Presence Waivers of Inadmissibility for Certain Immediate Relatives" published by the Department of Homeland Security on January 3, 2013 (78 Fed. Reg. 535).
9. H.R.457 : Criminal Alien Accountability Act
12. H.R.463 : To amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to reform the provisions relating to status under section 101(a)(15)(U) of that Act
14. H.R.478 : E-Verify Modernization Act of 2013
15. H.R.490 : Visa Waiver Program Enhanced Security and Reform Act
16. H.R.502 : Electronic Employment Eligibility Verification and Illegal Immigration Control Act
17. H.R.519 : Uniting American Families Act of 2013
18. H.R.547 : Border Security and Responsibility Act of 2013
20. H.R.633 : Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act of 2013
21. H.R.639 : Immigration Oversight and Fairness Act
22. H.R.640 : Student Visa Security Improvement Act
25. H.R.707 : Short Term Retention for Agricultural Workers Act of 2013
26. H.R.717 : Reuniting Families Act
27. H.R.830 : SAVE Act of 2013
35. H.R.1354 : Jobs Originated through Launching Travel Act of 2013
36. H.R.1365 : Refugee Protection Act of 2013
37. H.R.1417 : Border Security Results Act of 2013
38. H.R.1444 : H-2A Improvement Act
39. H.R.1525 : Save America Comprehensive Immigration Act of 2013
43. H.R.1680 : Tohono O'odham Citizenship Act of 2013
44. H.R.1760 : Immigration and Naturalization Investment Ventures for Engineering, Science, and Technology in America Act of 2013
45. H.R.1772 : Legal Workforce Act
48. H.R.1784 : Domestic Refugee Resettlement Reform and Modernization Act of 2013
50. H.R.1886 : Promoting Border Commerce and Travel Act
51. H.R.1901 : Keep Our Communities Safe Act of 2013
52. H.R.1923 : To amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to provide for the eligibility of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region for designation for participation in the visa waiver program for certain visitors to the United States
55. H.R.2124 : Keeping the Promise of IRCA Act
56. H.R.2131 : SKILLS Visa Act
57. H.R.2264 : CLEAR Act of 2013
58. H.R.2278 : SAFE Act
59. H.R.2377 : Encourage New Legalized Immigrants to Start Training Act
62. H.R.2624 : Child Trafficking Victims Protection Act
63. H.R.2630 : 1986 Amnesty Transparency Act
64. H.R.2631 : Visa Overstay Enforcement Act of 2013
66. H.R.2936 : Protecting Immigrants From Legal Exploitation Act of 2013
67. H.R.3000 : REVIVE Act of 2013
68. H.R.3130 : Protect Family Values at the Border Act
69. H.R.3163 : CIR ASAP Act of 2013
72. H.R.3431 : American Families United Act
75. H.R.3611 : DHS Immigration Accountability and Transparency Act of 2013
76. H.R.3732 : Immigration Compliance Enforcement (ICE) Act
78. H.R.3921 : IN STATE Act of 2014
81. H.R.4238 : To amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to provide for requirements for employers of H-2B nonimmigrants, and for other purposes.
82. H.R.4279 : United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement Authorization Act
84. H.R.4303 : Border Enforcement Accountability, Oversight, and Community Engagement Act of 2014
87. H.R.4460 : To amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to repeal the sunset of the special immigrant nonminister religious worker program.
88. H.R.4467 : Best Return on America's Investment Now Act
92. H.R.4620 : Accountability in Immigration Detention Act of 2014
95. H.R.4936 : Vulnerable Immigrant Voice Act
99. H.R.4962 : National Border and Homeland Security Act
100. H.R.5053 : Expedited Family Reunification Act of 2014
So folks - how 'bout somebody explaining to me and the rest of NT that, if the House has passed 206 bills regarding immigration during the 113th Congress, and Harry Reid refuses to bring them up for discussion or vote - how, then, are the House members being called lazy - obstructionists - not performing and Obama decides, well, since Harry won't let anyone talk about them, they must be bad so I'm gonna do it myself????
Please - legitimate conversations - intelligent conversations - conversations on topic.
Can ya do that?
And you don't know crap about the process. I knew you couldn't/wouldn't be able to discuss this - so don't try.
1st,
How many of these House Resolutions were addressed/incorporated in the bipartisan Senate Bill that Boehner won't call to a vote? It's not as if nothing came of the House Resolutions.
Please - legitimate conversations - intelligent conversations - conversations on topic......
....and accurate. You flooded your post with a list of bills with links that do not work. That happens so I looked up one bill and picked HR 4620 . Here are some facts about it;
1) It never passed the house (as you claimed)
2) On 7/21/2014, it was passed to the Subcommittee on Immigration and Border Security headed by Republican Bob Goodlatte where it's been sitting since.
What the hell does Reid have to do with this?
What does this bill have to do with Obama's Executive Order?
Great information A. Mac - my point is - the House has tried, much to many people on this board's consternation.
The House is TRYING - kinda shoots down the ol' "they ain't nuthin but lazy azzez" that so many on this board are trying to convince you/us of.
Regardless of whether it passed the Subcommittee - or any committee for that matter - the House was TRYING.
Well, 1st, that's where we disagree; all the House had to do was to vote on the Bill; the votes were there, but, for reasons I cited before, Boehner would not call it for a vote.
None of them.
The republican leadership has already told us it's plans regarding the future, they are the same as the past six years: No, No, No, No....
Those cliches you mentionedearlierare right on target and telegraph their intentions quite clearly- Speaker Boehner:poisoned the well. If that does not tell you that everything they may accomplish in the next two years will be purely political at the expense of (any) leadership, then I don't know how better to convey that message.
President Obama, for better or worse, has used theauthority of his office. Those claiming he has overstepped areignoringhistory and playing with words. It is time for the republican leadership to step up to the plate and start doing something.
How about H.R. 140 Birthright Citizenship Act..Wacko Steve King (R) why would Harry Reid bring that up for a vote????
Have you read the bill A. Mac???
Your Links do not work 1stwarrior...
H.R.3810 - Immigration Control and Legalization Amendments Act of 1986 99th Congress (1985-1986)
Bill
Tracker:
This bill has the status Passed House
Here are the steps for Status of Legislation:
Get more information
See Coverage Dates for Legislative Information and learn about other sources.
Subject Policy Area:
Summary (3)
Text
Actions (79)
Titles (4)
Amendments (12)
Cosponsors (1)
Committees (7)
Related Bills (5)
Summary: H.R.3810 99th Congress (1985-1986) All Bill Information (Except Text)
Shown Here:
(Measure passed House, amended, roll call #457 (230-166))Passed House amended (10/09/1986)
Immigration Control and Legalization Amendments Act of 1986 - Title I: Control of Illegal Immigration - Part A: Employment - Amends the Immigration and Nationality Act to make it unlawful for a person or other entity to: (1) hire (including through subcontractors), recruit, or refer for a fee for U.S. employment any alien knowing that such person is unauthorized to work, or any person without verifying his or her work status; or (2) continue to employ an alien knowing of such person's unauthorized work status.
Makes verification compliance an affirmative defense to any violation in the hiring or referral of an alien.
Establishes an employment verification system. Requires: (1) the employer to attest, on a form developed by the Attorney General, that the employee's work status has been verified by examination of a passport, birth certificate, social security card, alien documentation papers, or other proof; (2) the worker to similarly attest that he or she is a U.S. citizen or national, or authorized alien; and (3) the employer to keep such records for the period required by regulation.
States that nothing in this Act shall be construed to authorize a national identity card or system.
Sets forth employer sanction provisions. Provides for a six-month period of public education during which no employment violation penalties shall be imposed.
Provides for a subsequent 12-month period during which violators shall be issued warning citations.
Provides, at the end of such citation period, for graduated first and subsequent-offense civil penalties, injunctive remedies, or criminal penalties (for pattern or practice violations). Subjects violators to graduated civil penalties for related paperwork violations.
Directs the Attorney General to provide notice and, upon request, an administrative hearing in the case of a disputed penalty. States that: (1) judicial review of a final administrative penalty shall be in the U.S. court of appeals; and (2) suits to collect unpaid penalties shall be filed in U.S. district courts.
Makes it unlawful for an employer to require an employee to provide any type of financial guarantee or indemnity against any potential employment liability. Subjects violators, after notice and hearing opportunity, to a civil penalty for each violation and the return of any such amounts received.
States that such employer sanction provisions preempt State and local laws.
Makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice for an employer of four or more persons to discriminate against any individual (other than an unauthorized alien) with respect to hiring, recruitment or referral for fee, because of such individual's origin or citizenship (or intended citizenship) status.
Requires that complaints of violations of an immigration-related employment practice be filed with the Special Counsel for Immigration-Related Unfair Employment Practices (established by this Act) within the Department of Justice. Prohibits the overlap of immigration-related discrimination complaints and discrimination complaints filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
Authorizes the Special Counsel to: (1) investigate complaints and determine (within 120 days) whether to bring such complaints before a specially trained administrative law judge; and (2) initiate investigations and complaints. Permits private actions if the Special Counsel does not file a complaint within such 120-day period. Sets forth related administrative provisions.
Amends the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act to subject farm labor contractors to the requirements of this Act, beginning seven months after enactment and ending six years later.
Makes it illegal to fraudulently misuse or manufacture entry or work documents (up to a $5,000 fine or two years' imprisonment or both).
Provides for a study on the use of a telephone verification system for determining alien employment eligibility. Requires a report to the Congress.
States that it is not an unfair immigration related employment practice to hire a U.S. citizen or national over an equally qualified alien.
Part B: Improvement of Enforcement and Services - States that essential elements of the immigration control and reform program established by this Act are increased enforcement and administrative activities of the Border Patrol, the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS), and other appropriate Federal agencies.
Authorizes increased FY 1986 and 1987 appropriations for: (1) INS; and (2) the Executive Office of Immigration Review. Directs the Attorney General, from funds appropriated to the Department of Justice for INS, to provide for improved immigration and naturalization services and for enhanced community outreach and in-service personnel training.
Directs the Attorney General to report to the appropriate congressional committees within six months regarding the INS's data processing requirements.
Increases FY 1987 through 1989 authorizations of appropriations for additional border patrol personnel. Sets forth related equipment acquisition requirements. Prohibits any such acquisitions without the approval of the Administrator of General Services.
Revises the criminal penalties for the unlawful transportation of unauthorized aliens into the United States.
Directs the Attorney General to develop a contingency plan to provide for the allocation and management of personnel and resources in the event of an immigration emergency. Establishes an immigration emergency fund to be used in accordance with such plan. Authorizes appropriations. Prohibits the use of such funding unless the President has certified to the appropriate congressional committees that an emergency exists.
Amends the Immigration and Nationality Act to permit the owner or operator of a railroad line, international bridge, or toll road to request the Attorney General to inspect and approve measures taken to prevent aliens from illegally crossing into the United States. States that such approved measures shall be prima facie evidence of compliance with obligations under such Act to prevent illegal entries.
Expresses the sense of the Congress that the immigration laws of the United States should be vigorously enforced, while taking care to protect the rights and safety of U.S. citizens and aliens.
Requires INS to have an owner's consent or a warrant before entering a farm or outdoor operations to interrogate persons to determine if undocumented aliens are present.
Part C: Verification of Status Under Certain Programs - Requires States to verify the immigration status of aliens applying for the following benefits: (1) aid to families with dependent children, medicaid, unemployment compensation, food stamps, and supplemental security income under the Social Security Act; (2) specified housing assistance under the Housing and Community Development Act of 1980; and (3) title IV educational assistance under the Higher Education Act of 1965.
Provides an opportunity for the alien applicant to submit status evidence without denial or termination of benefits until such evidence has been verified.
Provides States with full reimbursement for implementing and operating such verification programs.
Requires: (1) INS program implementation by October 1, 1987; and (2) State implementation by October 1, 1988.
Authorizes appropriations.
Requires the Comptroller General to report to the Congress regarding the current verification pilot projects and the implementation of the verification system under this Part.
Title II: Legalization - Directs the Attorney General to adjust to temporary resident status those aliens who: (1) apply within 18 months; (2) establish that they entered the United States before January 1, 1982, and have resided here continuously in an unlawful status (including Cuban/Haitian entrants) since such date; and (3) are otherwise admissible.
Authorizes similar status adjustment for specified aliens who entered legally as nonimmigrants but whose period of authorized stay ended before January 1, 1982. (States that in the case of exchange visitors the two-year foreign residence requirement must have been met or waived.)
Prohibits the legalization of persons: (1) convicted of a felony or three or more misdemeanors in the United States; or (2) who have taken part in political, religious, or racial persecution. Requires an alien applying for temporary resident status to register under the Military Selective Service Act, if such Act so requires.
Directs the Attorney General to adjust the status of temporary resident aliens to permanent resident if the alien: (1) applies during the one-year period beginning with the 13th month following the grant of temporary resident status; (2) has established continuous residence in the United States since the grant of temporary resident status; (3) is otherwise admissible and has not been convicted of a felony or three or more misdemeanors committed in the United States; and (4) either meets the minimum requirements for an understanding of English and a knowledge of American history and government, or demonstrates the satisfactory pursuit of a course of study in these subjects. (Authorizes an exemption from such language and history requirement for individuals 65 years of age or older.)
Specifies circumstances in which the Attorney General may terminate an alien's temporary resident status. Permits travel abroad and employment during such period.
Authorizes the filing of status adjustment applications with the Attorney General or designated voluntary or governmental agencies. Directs the Attorney General to work with such agencies to: (1) disseminate program information; and (2) process aliens. Provides for the confidential treatment of application records. Establishes criminal penalties (fines, imprisonment, or both) for: (1) violations of such confidentiality; and (2) false application statements. Provides for application fees.
Waives numerical limitations, labor certification, and other specified entry violations for such plans. Permits the Attorney General to waive other grounds for exclusion (except criminal, most drug-related, and security grounds) to assure family unity or when otherwise in the national interest.
Requires the Attorney General to provide an alien, otherwise eligible but unregistered who is apprehended before the end of the application period, an opportunity to apply for the legalization program before deportation or exclusion proceedings are begun. States that such alien shall be authorized to work in the United States pending disposition of the case.
Provides for administrative and judicial review of a determination respecting an application for adjustment of status under this Act.
Makes legalized aliens (other than Cuban/Haitian entrants) ineligible for Federal financial assistance, Medicaid (with certain exceptions), or food stamps for five years following a grant of temporary resident status and for five years following a grant of permanent resident status (permits aid to the aged, blind, or disabled). States that programs authorized under the National School Lunch Act, the Child Nutrition Act of 1966, the Vocational Education Act of 1963, chapter 1 of the Education Consolidation and Improvement Act of 1981, the Headstart-Follow Through Act, the Job Training Partnership Act, title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965, the Public Health Service Act, and titles V, XVI, and XX of the Social Security Act shall not be construed as prohibited assistance. Continues assistance to aliens under the Refugee Education Assistance Act of 1980 without regard to adjustment of status.
Requires the Attorney General to disseminate in English and other appropriate languages information regarding the legalization program.
Establishes procedures for the status adjustment to permanent resident of certain Cuban and Haitian entrants who arrived in the United States before January 1, 1982.
Updates from June 30, 1948, to January 1, 1976, the registry date for permanent entry admissions records.
Authorizes FY 1987 through 1991 appropriations for State legalization impact assistance grants. Directs the Secretary, subject to appropriated funds, to provide States with: (1) full reimbursement for public assistance provided to eligible legalized aliens; and (2) payments for educational services to such aliens.
Title III: Reform of Legal Immigration - Part A: Temporary Agricultural Workers - Separates temporary agricultural labor from other temporary labor for purposes of nonimmigrant (H-2A visa) worker provisions.
Requires an employer H-2A visa petition to certify that: (1) there are not enough local U.S. workers for the job; and (2) similarly employed U.S. workers' wages and working conditions will not be adversely affected. Authorizes the Secretary of Labor to charge application fees.
Prohibits the Secretary from approving such petition if: (1) the job is open because of a strike or lock-out; (2) the employer violated temporary worker admissions terms; (3) in a case where such workers are not covered by State workers' compensation laws, the employer has not provided equivalent protection at no cost to such workers; or (4) the employer has not made regional recruitment efforts in the traditional or expected labor supply.
Provides with regard to agricultural worker applications that: (1) the Secretary may not require such an application to be filed more than 60 days before needed; (2) the employer shall be notified in writing within seven days if the application requires perfecting; (3) the Secretary shall approve an acceptable application not later than 20 days before needed; and (4) the employer shall provide or secure housing meeting appropriate Federal, State, or local standards, including making provision for family housing for employees principally engaged in the range production of livestock.
Provides that for three years, labor certifications for specified employers shall require such an employer to hire qualified U.S. workers who apply until the end of 50 percent of the H-2A workers' contract work period. Requires the Secretary, six months before the end of such period, to consider the advisability of continuing such requirement and to issue regulations (in the absence of enacting legislation) three months before the end of such period.
States that employers shall not be liable for specified employment penalties if H-2A workers are dismissed in order to meet such 50 percent requirement.
Permits agricultural producer associations to file H-2A petitions.
Provides for expedited administrative appeals of denied certifications.
Prohibits the entry of an alien as an H-2A worker if he or she has violated a term of admission within the previous five years.
Authorizes permanent appropriations beginning with FY 1987 for the purposes of: (1) recruiting domestic workers for temporary labor and services which might otherwise be performed by nonimmigrants and agricultural transition workers; and (2) monitoring terms and conditions under which such individuals are employed.
Authorizes permanent appropriations beginning in FY 1987 to enable the Secretary to make determinations and certifications.
Expresses the sense of the Congress that the President should establish an advisory commission to consult with Mexico and other appropriate countries and advise the Attorney General regarding the temporary worker program.
Establishes a special agricultural worker adjustment program. Provides for permanent resident adjustment for aliens who: (1) apply during a specified 18-month period; (2) have performed at least 90 man-days of seasonal agricultural work during the 12-month period ending May 1, 1986; and (3) are admissible as immigrants. Sets forth adjustment dates based upon periods of work performed in the United States. Authorizes travel and employment during such temporary residence period.
Authorizes applications to be made inside the United States with the Attorney General or designated entities and outside the United States through consular offices. Provides for confidentiality and limited access to such information. Establishes criminal penalties for false application information, and makes an alien so convicted inadmissible for U.S. entry.
Exempts such admissions from numerical entry limitations.
Permits waiver of exclusion (except for specified criminal, drug offense, public charge, Nazi persecution, and national security grounds) for humanitarian or family purposes, or when in the national interest.
Provides for a temporary stay of exclusion or deportation (and authority to work) for apprehended aliens who are able to establish a nonfrivolous claim for status adjustment.
Provides for a single level of administrative appellate review of such status adjustment applications. Limits such review to the order of exclusion or deportation.
Defines "seasonal agricultural services" as the performance of field work related to growing fruits and vegetables of every kind and other perishable commodities as defined in regulations by the Secretary of Agriculture.
Directs the Secretaries of Agriculture and of Labor, jointly before each fiscal year (beginning in FY 1990 and ending in FY 1993) to determine whether additional special agricultural workers should be admitted because of a shortage of such workers in the United States. Sets forth factors to be considered in making such determinations.
Authorizes associations and groups of employers to request additional admissions due to emergency or unforeseen circumstances. Authorizes groups of special agricultural workers to request decreased admissions due to worker oversupply. Requires the Secretaries to make request determinations within 21 days.
Sets forth numerical limitations for such admissions beginning with FY 1990.
Provides for the deportation of newly admitted special agricultural workers who do not perform 60 man-days of seasonal agricultural work in each of the first two years after entry. Prohibits naturalization of such workers unless they have performed 60 man-days of such work in each of five fiscal years.
Treats temporary agricultural workers and special agricultural workers as "eligible legalized aliens" for purposes of Federal assistance to State and local entities for specified costs associated with such workers during their first five years in the United States.
Establishes a 12-member Commission on Agricultural Workers to review the special agricultural worker provisions, the impact of the legalization and employer sanctions on agricultural labor, and other aspects of agricultural labor. Requires a report to the Congress within five years. Authorizes appropriations. Terminates the Commission at the end of the 63-month period beginning with the month after the month of enactment of this Act.
States that specified agricultural workers shall be eligible for legal assistance under the Legal Service Corporation Act.
Part B: Other Changes in the Immigration Law - Increases the annual colonial quota from 600 visas to 5,000 visas.
Requires foreign students to return to the country of their nationality for at least two years after completing their studies before petitioning to return to the United States. Sets forth conditions for the waiver of such requirement.
Declares aliens who have obtained certain advanced degrees, or are training for such degrees, eligible for educational visitor status.
Prohibits non-waiver students from adjusting to permanent resident status.
States that time spent in student or trainee status shall not count for purposes of eligibility for suspension of deportation.
Includes within the definition of "special immigrant": (1) unmarried sons and daughters and surviving spouses of employees of certain international organizations; and (2) specified retirees of such organizations ("I" status) and their spouses.
Grants nonimmigrant status to: (1) parents of children receiving "I" status while they are minors; and (2) other children of such parents or a surviving "I" status spouse.
Authorizes the three-year pilot visa waiver program for up to eight countries providing similar benefits to U.S. visitors. Requires such visitors to the United States to: (1) have a nonrefundable roundtrip ticket; and (2) stay in the United States for not more than 90 days.
Includes the relationship between an illegitimate child and its natural father within the definition of "child" for purposes of status, benefits, or privilege under such Act.
States that for suspension of deportation purposes, an alien shall not be considered to have failed to maintain continuous physical presence in the United States if the absence did not meaningfully interrupt the continuous physical presence.
Authorizes additional immigrant visas for natives of certain countries based on immigration from such countries during the ten-fiscal year period beginning July 1, 1955.
Title IV: Reports to Congress - Directs the President to report to the appropriate congressional committees on: (1) general legal admissions under the Immigration and Nationality Act; (2) unlawful employment of aliens; and (3) the temporary agricultural worker (H-2A) program.
Directs the Civil Rights Commission to monitor and report to such committees on the implementation and enforcement of provisions of this Act that result in unlawful discrimination.
Directs the President to make two reports to the Congress on the legalization program established by this Act.
Directs the Attorney General and the Secretary of State to jointly monitor the visa waiver program established by this Act, and report to the Congress within two years.
Directs the Attorney General to report to the Congress within 90 days regarding INS resources.
Provides for a feasibility study of a social security number validation system.
Authorizes the President to negotiate with the Government of Mexico for the establishment of a free-trade and co-production border zone as a first step to achieving a U.S.-Mexico free-trade area. Requires a report to the Congress.
Title V: State and Local Assistance for Incarceration Costs of Illegal Aliens and Certain Cuban Nationals - Directs the Attorney General to reimburse States and local jurisdictions for the costs incurred in incarcerating illegal aliens and Cuban nationals. Authorizes appropriations.
Title VI: Commission on International Migration and Development - Establishes a National Commission on International Migration and Development to conduct studies and report to the Congress regarding: (1) conditions in sending countries; and (2) trade and investment programs to alleviate such conditions. Requires annual reports to the Congress. Authorizes appropriations. Terminates such Commission 30 days after the end of the three year period beginning on the date the majority of the Commission members are appointed.
Title VII: National Commission on Immigration - Establishes a National Commission on Immigration to conduct studies and report to the Congress regarding: (1) factors influencing illegal immigration and reciprocal trade and economic programs with Latin America; (2) employment of unauthorized aliens; (3) agricultural reliance on unauthorized workers; and (4) immigrant visa backlogs. Requires a report to the Congress within three years. Terminates such Commission 30 days after submission of such report. Authorizes appropriations.
Title VIII: Investigation, Review, and Temporary Limitation on Deportation of Displaced Salvadorans and Nicaraguans - Part A: GAO Investigation and Report - Requires the Comptroller General to begin an investigation within 60 days concerning displaced nationals of El Salvador and Nicaragua. Requires a report to the Congress within one year.
Part B: Congressional Review - Provides for the referral of such report to the appropriate congressional committees for committee hearings and committee reports.
Part C: Temporary Stay of Deportation - Provides for a temporary stay of detention and deportation for certain nationals of El Salvador or Nicaragua.
Title IX: Federal Responsibility for Deportable and Excludable Aliens Convicted of Crimes - Provides for expeditious deportation of aliens convicted of crimes and for the transfer of aliens convicted of certain drug crimes from State and local prisons to Federal prisons.
Provides for the identification of Department of Defense facilities that could be made available to incarcerate deportable or excludable aliens.
Congress.gov
Does any of this look familiar to you? Well, the fact is immigration isn't broken, it is and has not been enforced. A law is no more effective than the enforcement of that law which Obama is very familiar with since he picks and chooses which laws he wants to enforce.
Yes you are right Flame.... Reagan used his executive order after the bill was passed to defer deportations.
No Flame, I'm not missing the point. You did. I'm not in favor of sending these people back to their countries. I'm in favor of enforcing the border laws and putting into the new law guidelines to discourage illegal immigration, which are already there, but have not been enforced. You see Reagan, a great president, did this from his heart and not for political reasons. The passed bill at that time wasn't sufficient and he made it so. Obama is writing law, which isn't his authority to do so. Do you think Obama is doing this for his compassion for the illegal immigrants?
Reagan lost the house the last two years he was in office and the Democrats didn't follow through with the enforcement in the law, so the law wasn't broken by the dude who pushed it through Congress as you say and neither have any administrations or Congress since then really enforced it.
I ask you again, do you think Obama is doing this because of his compassion for the illegal immigrants at all cost?
compassion
Now there's a word not included in the Republican/conservative lexicon.
Flame, you obviously didn't read my comment. I guess you were too interested in trying to point out what I said without even reading it. Except one difference in Reagan's executive order. He took a law that was passed and saw the flaws in it and corrected it. You'll notice it really stressed the reason for the law was to keep families together, but also to stop illegal immigration which as we can see hasn't been very effective.
To say there are 12 million or whatever in this country is ridiculous. It has been the same number for 14 years unless I'm just imagining I'm living in Mexico. I have nothing against Mexicans, in fact I don't think I've met a one that I didn't like. Of course all the Mexicans I've met have been family units, not the rapist, murderers and others Obama released into our society last year from prison.
So tell me, do you think Obama is doing this because of his tremendous compassion for the illegals at all cost?
Well if the Democrats have so much compassion, then I guess they wouldn't mind showing it by allowing these people to stay become legal and not be able to vote for the next 20 years if that is the Democrat motivation, compassion, that is.
Most of the illegals will not be making enough money to contribute to the tax base. In fact quite a few will not even take advantage of an immigration bill. Why would they give up their tax free money and benefits for having American babies and have to pay a fine which they won't be able to afford? Along with that most will qualify for "Earned Income Tax Credit" and will receive all their paid taxes back plus a little bonus check if they do sign up. Another advantage is they will either go on Medicaid or pay the very minimum for their health coverage. The water in the top of the bathtub doesn't go down the drain first. But all the water eventually goes down the drain. While the elite sit on the side of the tub and watch. This probably doesn't make much sense to some of you, but I can understand why.
Your opinion. Nonetheless, saying you are a Republican/conservative and compassionate in the same sentence is an oxymoron.
Six:
While you are concerned about apple pickers and the such, my concern is in the health care sector, we need qualified immigrants since Americans are not been educated to take those positions, what's the problem with the US education system??? rather than focus on Obama they should be concerned about the next generation..
How Immigrant Doctors Became America's Next Generation of Nurses
A Florida university that helps physicians credentialed in their homelands train as nurses is adding much-needed diversity to the health care workforceand caring for minority patients.
February 20, 2014 MIAMIIsabel Barradas, 48, has been a doctor for 25 years. In her native Venezuela, she was an orthopedic surgeon and head of a hospital department, with expertise in physical rehabilitation. She speaks three languages andsince marrying an American and moving to South Florida more than a decade agois a U.S. citizen.
Barradas passed her U.S. medical licensing exams with flying colors. But she didn't get a residency position in the specialty she loves. "Orthopedic surgery? Forget it. In this country, that is so elite," Barradas says. Competition for the training positions required for medical licensure is fierce, and most go to seniors at U.S. medical schools. Barradas decided that the position she did getinternal medicine in Buffalo, N.Y.wasn't worth leaving her family in Miami for.
Thousands of foreign-educated doctors living in the U.S. would like to practice medicine here but don't have the time, money or language skills to compete for and complete a residency. Miami's Florida International University offers other options: accelerated programs leading to a bachelor's and master's of science in nursing which train foreign-educated doctors to be nurse practitioners. FIU's programs both give internationally educated professionals an outlet for their skills and helps add much-needed diversity to the health care workforce.
The U.S. faces a dearth of 20,400 primary care physicians by 2025, according to federal statistics. The Association of American Medical Colleges projects a shortage of thousands of surgeons and other specialists too. While an aging population and health insurance expansion increase demand for health care services, medical schools and residency programs aren't producing enough doctors to meet demand.
There are thousands of foreign-educated doctors living in the U.S. who have the expertise needed to address some of this growing need. Every year for the past decade, between 5,000 and 12,000 foreign-educated physicians who have passed their licensing exams apply for a residency position. Typically, about half get one, compared with more than 90 percent of U.S. medical school seniors who apply, according to data from the National Resident Matching Program.
International medical school graduates, like minority doctors, often go on to serve medically underserved populations. Graduates of international medical schools make up a quarter of U.S. office-based physicians, and are more likely than their U.S.-educated peers to treat minority patients, foreign-born patients, patients who speak little English and patients who qualify for Medicaid, according to a 2009 study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Demand for highly trained nurses is also growing, particularly for nurses who speak more than one language and reflect the growing diversity of the U.S. population. If highly trained professionals like nurse practitioners and physician assistants were to take on more primary care responsibilities, the shortage of primary care doctors could be cut by more than two-thirds, according to the Health Resources and Services administration.
FIU introduced its accelerated nursing degree program in 2000, in response to pressure from underemployed Cuban doctors living in the area. The FEP-BSN/MSN program began as a bachelor's degree program that prepared students to become registered nurses. In 2010, FIU added a master's degree, and graduates of the full program can now find work as nurse practitionersan advanced role that can include prescribing medicine and diagnosing patients. In Florida, nurse practitioners earn about $86,800 per year. Barradas hopes to find work with an orthopedic surgeon.
Unlike the GOP which has no vision, Obama and his administration knew that there would be a need for health care workers once the ACA was passed, therefore, with this immigration executive order, that will be partly taken care of...McConnell and Boehner, has to know what is in the Law and with wanting Obamacare to fail, "REFUSED" to act on immigration with the intentions of derailing the Law:
Read the Law
The Affordable Care Act was passed by Congress and then signed into law by the President on March 23, 2010.
On June 28, 2012 the Supreme Court rendered a final decision to uphold the health care law.
The Affordable Care Act, Section by Section
Below you will find all 10 Titles of the Affordable Care Act, with amendments to the law called for by the reconciliation process. Click on each Title to see a brief outline and then read the law section by section .
Title V. Health Care Workforce
The Act funds scholarships and loan repayment programs to increase the number of primary care physicians, nurses, physician assistants, mental health providers, and dentists in the areas of the country that need them most. With a comprehensive approach focusing on retention and enhanced educational opportunities, the Act combats the critical nursing shortage. And through new incentives and recruitment, the Act increases the supply of public health professionals so that the United States is prepared for health emergencies.
The Act provides state and local governments flexibility and resources to develop health workforce recruitment strategies. And it helps to expand critical and timely access to care by funding the expansion, construction, and operation of community health centers throughout the United States.
The Secretary has the authority to take action to strengthen many existing programs that help support the primary care workforce.
TITLE V--HEALTH CARE WORKFORCE
Subtitle A--Purpose and Definitions
Sec. 5001. Purpose.
Sec. 5002. Definitions.
Subtitle B--Innovations in the Health Care Workforce
Sec. 5101. National health care workforce commission.
Sec. 5102. State health care workforce development grants.
Sec. 5103. Health care workforce assessment.
Subtitle C--Increasing the Supply of the Health Care Workforce
Sec. 5201. Federally supported student loan funds.
Sec. 5202. Nursing student loan program.
Sec. 5203. Health care workforce loan repayment programs.
Sec. 5204. Public health workforce recruitment and retention programs.
Sec. 5205. Allied health workforce recruitment and retention programs.
Sec. 5206. Grants for State and local programs.
Sec. 5207. Funding for National Health Service Corps.
Sec. 5208. Nurse-managed health clinics.
Sec. 5209. Elimination of cap on commissioned corps.
Sec. 5210. Establishing a Ready Reserve Corps.
Subtitle D--Enhancing Health Care Workforce Education and Training
Sec. 5301. Training in family medicine, general internal medicine, general pediatrics, and physician assistantship.
Sec. 5302. Training opportunities for direct care workers.
Sec. 5303. Training in general, pediatric, and public health dentistry.
Sec. 5304. Alternative dental health care providers demonstration project.
Sec. 5305. Geriatric education and training; career awards; comprehensive geriatric education.
Sec. 5306. Mental and behavioral health education and training grants.
Sec. 5307. Cultural competency, prevention, and public health and individuals with disabilities training.
Sec. 5308. Advanced nursing education grants.
Sec. 5309. Nurse education, practice, and retention grants.
Sec. 5310. Loan repayment and scholarship program.
Sec. 5311. Nurse faculty loan program.
Sec. 5312. Authorization of appropriations for parts B through D of title VIII.
Sec. 5313. Grants to promote the community health workforce.
Sec. 5314. Fellowship training in public health.
Sec. 5315. United States Public Health Sciences Track.
Subtitle E--Supporting the Existing Health Care Workforce
Sec. 5401. Centers of excellence.
Sec. 5402. Health care professionals training for diversity.
Sec. 5403. Interdisciplinary, community-based linkages.
Sec. 5404. Workforce diversity grants.
Sec. 5405. Primary care extension program.
Subtitle F--Strengthening Primary Care and Other Workforce Improvements
Sec. 5501. Expanding access to primary care services and general surgery services.
Sec. 5502. Medicare Federally qualified health center improvements.
Sec. 5503. Distribution of additional residency positions.
Sec. 5504. Counting resident time in nonprovider settings.
Sec. 5505. Rules for counting resident time for didactic and scholarly activities and other activities.
Sec. 5506. Preservation of resident cap positions from closed hospitals.
Sec. 5507. Demonstration projects To address health professions workforce needs; extension of family-to-family health information centers.
Sec. 5508. Increasing teaching capacity.
Sec. 5509. Graduate nurse education demonstration.
Subtitle G--Improving Access to Health Care Services
Sec. 5601. Spending for Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs).
Sec. 5602. Negotiated rulemaking for development of methodology and criteria for designating medically underserved populations and health professions shortage areas.
Sec. 5603. Reauthorization of the Wakefield Emergency Medical Services for Children Program.
Sec. 5604. Co-locating primary and specialty care in community-based mental health settings.
Sec. 5605. Key National indicators.
Subtitle H--General Provisions
Sec. 5701. Reports.
TITLE X--STRENGTHENING QUALITY, AFFORDABLE HEALTH CARE FOR ALL AMERICANS
Subtitle E--Provisions Relating to Title V
Sec. 10501. Amendments to the Public Health Service Act, the Social Security Act, and title V of this Act.
Sec. 10502. Infrastructure to Expand Access to Care.
Sec. 10503. Community Health Centers and the National Health Service Corps Fund.
Sec. 10504. Demonstration project to provide access to affordable care.
H.R. 4872. Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010
Sec. 2303. Community health centers.
To learn more visit:
Reconciliation Act Title Five Contents:
1st
Everyone knows a lot of bills were passed, there was no need to list them all
Bu thanks.
Well as usual, we are now off on tangents
......in a battle of who cutting and pasting the largest amount of data
...talking about everything but the topic
....talking about each other or labeling
....talking about the past.....
The topic in case in anyone is interested is Where Do We Go From Here?
The executive action is a fact, it does not matter what Reagan did, or Bush, Or Eisenhower or Lincoln what matters is where we go from here and what happens as a result of the executive action.
Let's try and keep our eyes on the topic
I think I will suggest to Perrie that the "cut and paste option" be limited to 150 characters or one graphic per comment
1st,
The House Republicans couldn't generate enough votes to call their own bill!
House GOP pulls border bill rather than see it defeated
House Republicans let their own immigration bill fail without a vote
They have screwed themselves by forcing Obama's hand; he called their bluff, they called him names and lost any hope of an Hispanic constituency. And yesterday, they filed a lawsuit against Obama as a bullshit ploy to make it appear that they were taking action! The only problem with that is the suit has NOTHING TO DO WITH IMMIGRATION! It's about Obamacare!
Then they went home for Thanksgiving!
You may recall that after the election results, I wrote in another thread, that Obama should take all sorts of Executive actions and FORCE REPUBLICANS, to, in essence, EITHER SAY "YES" OR "NO," that is, in one way or another, make them show their hand as a way to call them out.
There will be a price to pay for being the "party of NO!"
I disagree; readers have a choice as to how much or how little they care to read.
The significance of which can only be grasped by understanding where we've been.
InThe Tempestby William Shakespeare, Act II, scene i, the character of Antonio utters the phrase whats past is prologue.
In Antonios speech, he was trying to convince the character of Sebastian to murder his sleeping father so that Sebastian could become king. All that had happened up until then their past was merely a prologue to the great things to come if they went through with the deed.
Aprologuewas a preface to a play or novel that set the scene and provided some background information.
My two cents, RIO.
The fact that to pass any resolution in the currently configured Senate requires Republican and or Independent votes makes it "bipartisan." I understand your wanting a "qualitative" assessment of a "quantitative" process, but in reality, it doesn't matter now because Republicans shot themselves in both feet.
The xenophobes and Obama-haters had to be pandered-to; they were, and, as a result, they screwed their party and themselves and their sick agenda may collapse upon itself as Republican "moderates" and Republican "extremists" go at each other.
And how utterly ironic, the "Party of Lincoln," is about bring his words to modern-day life
You may be right on the other hand, when one walks through a library does one think that many of the books ought to have some of their pages torn out to make them more likely to be read?
As I usually (not always) ignore long cut 'n 'pastes (that's why hyperlinks were invented) I would tend to agree with you but certainly more than 150 words.
Mac - pulling one bill of 206 ain't screwing themselves. Hell, everybody makes adjustments.
Gee - just what Nancy said - "We can read it after we pass it."
I'm like a computer science book with a bunch of pages torn out.
Didn't list them all - just the ones dealing with immigration from South of the border. There are numerous bills dealing with Iraqi's, Chinese, Haitians, Africans, Afghanistans, etc..
Or the Dementia party.
You really think we care about that right now CM?
Does the same thing in Hamlet - luv that dude.
And then you have the blatherers who don't know how or when to shut up, - kinda like the Dementia party, eh?
Still in the Netherworld, eh Fish?
That is an insult and you need to apologize for your blatant disrespect that you think is so cute.
flame - don't elevate yourself - nothing from you "hits" me.
Then why do you embarrass them by calling them Mexican?
Learn your history flame - BEFORE it was colonized by the Spanish, it was Apache territory. They have never been nor ever will be Mexican - they are Apache and deserve your respect and honor by not calling them "names".
John
Exactly, that wouldrequire people to use their on words in the discussion of a topic.
A radical approach to discussion
flameaway
See one graphic it works
Keep going, Mike you can further erode any Republican Hispanic votes that may still exist after yesterday, by declaring any "bipartisan" immigration reform that might partially credit Republicans is merely a matter of semantics.
The days of discrediting/sabotaging Obama are over; going forward,every utilitarian initiative taken by Obama/Democrats that is roadblocked by Republicans, will result in their being challenged to put-up-or-shut-up to "pass a bill" -- to "shit or get off the pot." And then they'll have to either give in and piss off their base, or bitch and moan when an executive action shoves something up their collective ass.
The days of Republicans sitting on the sidelines, of blocking everything and anything that might improve lives because doing so would would energize a bigot/xenophobic base that cuts-off-its-nose-to-spite-its-face those days are over.
Republicans that will soon control Congress won't be able to blame anyone but themselves for blocking jobs bills, for trying to abolish any minimum wage requirements whatsoever, for trying to cut social security and medicare benefits, for increasing tax breaks for corporations, for pipeline catastrophes
Enjoy the next two years, because if the middle class becomes the victim of the coming Congress, even the dumb old white people who want to "take back the country (to 1825)," will be both diminished in population and beaten with their own metaphorical stick.
Poetic justice albeit unnecessarily painful in the interim for those of us who knew better.
It's in the bill that Boehner refuses to call for a vote, Mike.
And Republican pandering to the xenophobic, birther, etc. white vote that's somehow altruistic is it?
Further
Jeb Bush says illegal immigration is "net zero"
We seem to have wandered far a afield from discussing if, when and how the branches of the federal government can better work together following the executive action taken by President Obama
I would ask (suggest) that we discuss that topic, but I am sure many will go in the direction that they wish to go in and while I will avoid the dog piles, please feel free to have a good time.
In case anyone (or everyone) has forgotten - if, when and how the Republican Congress and the Democratic president can best work together (try and keep the current reality of politics I mind) is what we started out to discuss.
What realistic compromises can be reached on minimum wage, tax code reform, immigration, trade agreements, etc
Please refrain from expounding on why things cannot be done, what was done in the past and what tools those on the other side of the aisle are
Or not as you wish
Of course, one that John would not be able to adhere too.
Yup - same with Kiowa, Comanche, Pueblos, etc.
Robert, I don't have high hopes they will work together at all. But the perception of at least trying is in the hands of the republicans. If they pass legislation that most Americans find reasonable, they will get credit for it even if Obama pulls out his veto pen and they will be rewarded in 2016. If all they do is whine and cry about Obama while doing nothing of consequence, they will pay a severe price in 2016.
Chucky
I completely agree
They must forget repealing the PACA, investigating and impeaching etc and concentrate on passing purposeful legislation and dealing with it being signed or vetoed
Robert G
It is that type of nonsensical rhetoric that must be avoided if any progress is to be made
Hating on Obama is not productive hereon NTor in Washington
Time to refocus on reality
If you don't see the significance, then you are blind, the executive action on immigration and the health care law is related, when the law was passed, the democratic congress and the President knew their would be a need for health care workers, GOP also knew, but in order to derail the ACA, they would not act on immigration, knowing their was a clause in the law regarding the health care workers and funding for their education...
Make your case with specifics Counselor as pronouncements don't cut it in venues that actually matter.
There you go, if you don't understand what is taking place, of course you would believe it was irrelevant, their is a correlation between immigration and ACA...Read the Law to get the full understanding...
There's every need it's called "Burden of Proof" in legal venues and it applies in ETHICAL and CREDIBILITY venues as well.
Cite the alleged violations, the law(s) it/they violate and the legal/historical precedents or lack thereof.
Otherwise you're copping out and counting on a pack of zeal-without-knowledge grandstanders to nod their heads with their glazed-over eyes.
Don't expect others to validate your allegations. Own your statements then validate them with the particulars.
See Robert G..There is a need for one of those long Copy/paste jobs to put those words right back down your throat....
Did SCOTUS Already Greenlight Obama's Executive Action On Immigration?
Can President Barack Obama temporarily legalize 5 million undocumented immigrants by himself?
That question has sparked a heated debate as the White House ponders the legal questions surrounding an unprecedented executive action on immigration that it says it will unveil by the end of this summer. The political implications are explosive as conservative Republicans are already floating impeachment of Obama if he unilaterally
So, how much power does Obama have in this area?
Experts agree that the president has wide discretion to decide which migrants to target for deportation under the law enforcement theory of prosecutorial discretion. There are roughly 11 million immigrants in the U.S. illegally and officials have to prioritize which ones to remove. The Supreme Court reaffirmed that wide latitude in the 2012 ruling Arizona v. US , in which the justices said key provisions of Arizona's strict immigration law ran afoul of federal supremacy in the area.
"Removal is a civil matter, and one of its principal features is the broad discretion exercised by immigration officials, who must decide whether to pursue removal at all," wrote Justice Anthony Kennedy in the majority decision, joined by four other justices.
The Center for American Progress, an influential liberal think tank, argued in a July 2014 brief : "Even in the civil context, the Supreme Court has made clear that 'an agency's decision not to prosecute or enforce, whether through civil or criminal process, is a
repeatedly affirmed the long-standing principle that the executive branch has virtually unfettered discretion in deciding how and whether to enforce the law against individuals."But legal experts don't agree on the extent to which a president can formally grant
as DACA, did that for some 553,000 qualified young people brought to the U.S. illegally. Administration work permits to broad categories of immigrants. His June 2012 "deferred action" program, known tration officials have anonymously leaked that they're considering a similar action for up to 5 million immigrants who are also a low priority for removal (though they publicly insist no decisions have been made yet).
Supporters of expanding deferred action point out that the concept existed before DACA: previous deferred action grants for humanitarian cases permitted recipients to obtain work authorization for the period of the deferral, with the government reserving the right to take away that status at its discretion. Therefore it wouldn't be a brand new category; it'd expand an existing category.
"Longstanding law already allows for individuals who are granted deferred action to gain work authorization," John Sandweg, former acting general counsel at the Department of Homeland Security from 2012 to 2013, told the Washington Post's Greg Sargent. "There was a longstanding, preexisting regulation that governs who gets work authorization; deferred action recipients were included in that regulation a decision that was made long before this administration."
Under this theory, Obama could say it's simply a formalization of decisions made under his power of prosecutorial discretion the government decides not to target certain people and gives them a document saying as much.
"They can't do things like grant permanent legal status because how you get permanent legal status is in statute already," said Bob Sakaniwa, senior associate director at the American Immigration Lawyers Association. "So there are things that are less than
problems emerge when considering the scope of such an action. Experts in this area say there's no black-and-white answer to exactly how many immigrants a president can defer action for before it becomes an abuse of his authority. Conservatives charge that DACA was pushing the boundaries at best, and outright illegal at worst, therefore expanding it would be "presidential caesarism," as New York Times columnist Ross Douthat puts it .
"There's no question that past presidents have enjoyed considerable discretion in the
"There's no question that past presidents have enjoyed considerable discretion in the igration area. However, this president's past actions [i.e. DACA] raise very troubling questions under the separation of powers," said Jonathan Turley, a professor at George Washington University Law School. "The suggestion that the president may alter the status of millions of undocumented individuals would magnify those concerns. ... What President Obama is contemplating is quite different in magnitude from prior actions."
CONTINUE READING::
"They can't do things like grant permanent legal status because how you get permanent legal status is in statute already,"
So there are things that are less than permanent legal status in this area that the president can consider."
That is why the President said" Three years Temporary Status"...
I see the suggestions for topic focus and limited size cut and paste have been ignored
Well have fun folks
I have given you the rudiments, Robert G. .
Whenever possible, counsel should discuss before trial exhibits and objections, and pre-admit exhibits before the jury is selected where there are no objections.
Refrain from doing the "evidence dance;" if there are controversies, it's up to you to dispel them with facts.
You must sellyourself and your case. If you do not understand the case, or cannotexplain it, you cannot sell it.
Pro bono protocol from me to you Robert G. .
Make your case or close the door behind you.
A Mac
Please do not find members in contempt of AMac Court on my thread, if people hang around they might discuss the actual topic by accident
Not been ignored RIO, Robert G. is suggesting The President is breaking laws, I am simply showing that The President has the right to this Executive action and the text regarding such argument...
flame
It certainly generated 12 pages of something
The comments are more amusing than annoying as everything except the topic presented is basically being discussed
I am content to allow you folks to have your dog pile and to occasionally throw in a comment or respond if someone speaks to the topic presented either by mistake or design.
So please enjoy yourself
No and I never said that despite your disingenuousness
I think people should use as many of their own words as they can or want to in order to express themselves on any issue on NT or anywhere else
I suggested a limitation on the volume that could be cut and pasted (other peoples' words and ideas) which is used as a crutch by many folks rather than expressing themselves
It is a simple concept - take your time and think about it and it will become clear to you
CM
You could have explained that in your own words and provided a link to reference material ro support your position
A novel approach I know but it could work
But don't let me interrupt please continue the struggle
My opinion means Nothing, I prefer to present facts and from a reliable source, personally, I do not necessarily accept opinions, present reliable sources and I will better accept...
CM
Your opinion on issues and matters discussed is important to me and I am sure it is to others as well.
We can read the links, but what you think it what we (or at least I) are looking for on a discussion forum
I appreciate the back and forth so keep on posting as you wish on my threads
Talk at you later
Here's where Americans want to go from here MOSTLY NOWHERE THE NEW CONGRESS IS LIKELY TO TAKE THEM.
NBC/WSJ Poll Reveals American's Priorities; Guess How they Match With GOP Lawmakers' Priorities
Ok..RIO, I'll do as you asks next article...I just got tired of comments stating that The President was breaking laws and should be put in jail, that's the Right Wing Hate Radio Talk Hosts suggestions...
CM
And you refuted those statements very clearly with all of the stuff you posted, but I am sayingthat you could make your point with your own words just s effectively and show a link to the proof
You are always welcome on my articles whether you change the way you comment or just keep on keeping on as you have
Take good care
A Mac
And I think deals can be had on all of those issues - maybe not to the degree or the amount that some on the left may want and concessions on things the Republicans want may need to be given in order to make the deals on those issues.
Deal making - that is how legislation on policy agendas usually gets done
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
Robert G
Robert in Ohio said nothing of the sort
I said that rhetoric and vitriol are the communications tools of the without valid points to make or the ability to make those points.
You shout and shout, with little to shout about (Chicken Little comes to mind) and thus when you might have a valid point to make no one is listening
Of course that is just my view of the continual "I hate Obama" ranting that you engage in day in and day out
A Mac
And it was a good "2 cents" so there will be no change forthcoming
I just think that links could be used instead of endless text being pasted and the commenter could provide insight and comment based on the cited text. Of course that takes a little effort.
Agreed; compromise is how civilization survives.
A Mac
And we need a little more of the compromising so that the surviving can get a little easier
Robert G
Keep on ranting, you only know one song a it is getting old
But this is a free play zone, so as he DJ you can continue tospin "Nonsense Unending" for as long asyou like