Senate Democrats Clear Way for Iran Nuclear Deal
Senate Democrats delivered a major victory to President Obama on Thursday when they blocked a Republican resolution to reject a six-nation nuclear accord with Iran , ensuring that the landmark deal will take effect without a veto showdown between Congress and the White House.
By JENNIFER STEINHAUER SEPT. 10, 2015
A procedural vote fell short of the number needed to break a Democratic filibuster . It culminated hours of debate on the Senate floor and capped months of discord since the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Russia and China announced the agreement with Iran in July.
President Obama at a meeting to discuss the Iran nuclear accord at the White House on Thursday. [ Credit:Alex Wong/Getty Images]
Debate over the accord divided Democrats between their loyalties to the president and their constituents, especially Jewish ones, animated the antiwar movement on the left and exposed the waning power of the Israeli lobbying force that spent millions to prevent the accord.
Regardless of how one feels about the agreement, said Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, one of four Democrats to vote against the president, fair-minded Americans should acknowledge the presidents strong achievements in combating and containing Iran.
Acknowledging the tortured decision he and other skeptical Democrats traveled, Mr. Schumer said, I also have a great deal of respect for the careful thought and deliberation my colleagues went through, adding, I recognize for them, that this is a vote of conscience just as it is for me.
Yet President Obamas triumph in securing the international agreement without the support of a single member of the party now in control of Congress is refashioning the definition of victory for a waning presidency in an era of divided government.
While bipartisan victories tend to be those most celebrated outside Washington, in the current political climate, success by the president is now often measured more by the scope of the policy achieved than by any claim of sweeping consensus. And losing has its own evolving meaning. Republicans will use Mr. Obamas triumphs as they did with the health care law as a means to attack Democrats in anticipation of next years election.
Mr. Obama may go down in history as a president whose single biggest foreign policy and domestic achievements were won with no Republican votes, a stark departure from his 2008 campaign that was fueled by the promise of uniting. As with the Iran accord, the health care law passed exclusively with Democratic votes was a policy achievement that has come to define his presidency, in part through the vehemence of its opponents in Congress.
President Obama can claim that he found a way to move an extremely important, yet controversial, diplomatic agreement through the political process, said Julian E. Zelizer, a history professor at Princeton University. For conservatives the deal fulfills every negative view that they have about how President Obama and the way Democrats handle foreign threats, he added. The narrative is built for the campaign trail a Democratic president agrees to drop sanctions on a horrible regime that even most Democrats agree shows little signs of reform.
With an ample majority of Republicans running the House but a narrow one in the Senate, Mr. Obama has learned to measure when and how he can hold congressional Democrats together when he needs them as is the case with the use of the filibuster for the Iran disapproval measure but also when he needs to turn to Republicans to help flatten his own party, as was the case with a major trade package over the summer.
But the sheer partisan nature of the Iran matter does not bode well for impending fights on Capitol Hill, including one over whether to raise the debt ceiling and how to deal with spending.
[ LINK ]
Tags
Who is online
75 visitors

Congratulations, Mr President!
The Iran Deal Explained
The fact that this monstrosity had to be filibustered to pass tells you all you need to know about how terrible it is and how much the American public despises it.
What a legacy.
Sean, you should be ashamed that your party is SO partisan that it opposed this negotiation 300-0 in Congress. This despicable fact negates any and all of your complaints about the process.
Congratulations, Mr President!
Exactly. Not congratulations America. You say congratulations Mr. President, because you realize this is a political win for the President, rather than a victory for our country.
Party before country as always with Obama lovers.
"Party before country as always with Obama lovers."
That is laughable coming in support of a group that intended to vote in 300-0 lockstep. You might want to think about rephrasing some of your comments.
A filibuster to keep Congress from voting on a foreign policy agreement.
How low can the President sink?
is laughable coming in support of a group that intended to vote in 300-0 lockstep
Key words, right there. Once upon a time, Congress actually voted on foreign policy agreements. No more.
Shame on the President and shame on Harry Reid.
300-0 Sean, that cannot even be explained in any rational way. Obviously no one in the GOP thinks for themselves.
The Iran Deal Explained
Very interesting reading. Thanks for posting it.
Under the agreement, it will be virtually impossible for Iran to cover up nuclear activity, Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz says.
We are better off forever in terms of Iranian nuclear activity under this agreement than we would be without it, Moniz told "Fox News Sunday.
Read more
Another interesting read and I do agree with the Secretary.
If this such a good deal, you'd think the Democrats would welcome the opportunity to debate and showcase its supposed merits to the American people who overwhelmingly hate it. Instead they took the cowards way out and resorted to a filibuster.
"The Senate has spoken, and has spoken with a clear voice," said America's dirtbag, Harry Reid said. It sure did, Harry,It sure did. Good luck explaining your desperate filibuster.
Whatever Dean.
Read the report and if it's not over your head as it appears to be, you can give us your opinion minus the photo-shopped bullshit.
Your welcome Randy.
Too bad some other people around here are unwilling or unable to read and digest that report, but the commentscomingin here from the Right areconsistentwith their normalbehaviorofcriticizinginformation they haven't even read.
That fact that you would post an asinine comment like that tells us all we need to know about how terribly uninformed you are, because you have obviously not read the report and have no basis to claim the American public 'despises' it.
What a [comment not posted because of CoC]
The filibuster was necessarybecauseyou extreme Right Wingers actually think yourepresentthe majority of theAmerican public, and were possibly going to block the deal in spite of how bad it would make the United States look to our allies.
The truth is there are very few people outside your closed minded sphere of influence that are against the deal.
Wake the fuck up Sean, read the report, join the informed majority and stop marching lockstep with the anti-Obama neocons.
Correct.Once upon a time, Congress actually voted.
It's called politics. The only reason the Right Wingnuts want to defeat this agreement, is to make Obama look bad, andthey'rewilling to do that even though they actually are making the entirecountry look bad. But they don't care about that, they only care about 'getting' Obama.
Well, I've read the articles, those you post, those Randy posts, those John posts, and a lot more. Personally, what I can't understand is that if they are so spot on, why is it that a majority of Americans and a majority of lawmakers representing them are overruled? Is that what American democracy is all about? Is it because the majority of Americans are STUPID and their representatives are IDIOTS? So much for American democracy. Wallow in it.
Well Buzz, while the past isn't always prologue, sometimes it works out OK when a leader leads.
The deal the P-5 plus 1 struck with Iran could very well end badly and we may have to go all " Dick Cheney " on them but the Constitution gives the Pres. the authority to negotiate foreign policy and, since this was an International deal and not a treaty, voting on it is simply political theater.
Just saying, I bet you're pretty happy that Nixon took the chance he did, despite the popular sentiment of his day, huh Buzz.
Oh, I've been meaning to ask you, why is this all Obama's bad? Isn't China one of the deal makers in this whole thing? What is your local news saying about the deal?
I've got a question . With all the petroleum that is available at low prices why does Iran need a nuclear reactor ? They could get all there energy needs met with their own domestic oil . If the US agreed to refine it for them it would be even a simpler path to pursue .
I rarely watch the local news here, because it's so whitewashed it isn't worth it. I get my news from the internet. Anyway, why would China care one way or another? It has interests in Iran and none if ITS allies have been kicked in the face by this deal.
Nixon's meeting with Mao was to open trade relations with China, a billion new customers for American products, which made Nixon a shoe-in for re-election. There was no just delaying possible armageddon or nuclear holocaust down the road while guaranteeing that an ally was being kicked in the teeth. If people were unhappy back then it was because of making friends with a Communist country, and if you recall, Communism was not exactly loved in those days and from some postings I've seen on NT it isn't any different now.
Who is "overruled"? The only people saying the "majority of Americans" are against the Iran deal are the politically motivated Right Wingers, Obama haters, and the Republican leadership.
Personally, I have to take your opinion on this issue, Buzz, with a grain of salt because I strongly suspect your opinion is influenced by stance of your fear-mongering, war-hawk buddy, Bebe Netanyahu.
Bebe is taking his usual "Israel will be annihilated if you do not continue to keep me in office so I can protect you" rhetoric, and you're as guilty for falling for his bullshit as the rest of the Israeli people.
You read the report, please show us exactly how and why the deal is so bad. All I've seen is, 'the deal is NG, John Kerry, Barack Obama, the UK, France, Germany and the European Union are all fucked upand don't know what they're doing because they agreed to a deal that will allow Iran to build a bomb within a year'. Which BTW, is a totally false claim. Actually, without the agreement they can build a bomb sooner than that.
Let's see some specifics on why this deal is so bad, so we can have an intelligent discussion.
We don't know if that's actually true. The can sell their oil and make a profit, so the real question is, if they have the cheaper nuke energy we would have to know if the net savings of nuke energy exceeds the net profits from the oil sales. Also, nuke energy is cleaner.
We have restrictions on exporting oil, it would likelyrequirelegislation toaccommodatesuch anarrangement, and our congress does not seem to be amenable tolegislation.
I missed this one before, yeah it's laughable, it's fucking hysterical! The GOP is ALL about Party, they're like the fuckinig gestapho when it come to Party, that's why I quit the GOP. If you don't adhere to the party line you become an outcast, and not to be trusted.
No, Jerry, I won't swallow your bait. Perhaps you are unaware of the fact that I have posted over the past year at least 20 articles about why I have the attitude I have so I don't intend to spend the time to seek them out for the sake of an armchair critic who has never been to Israel as compared to myself who has had to hide in a bomb shelter in northern Israel, personally witnessed a bus bombing and whose daughter only through the grace of God was not standing closer to her murdered classmate on a Tel Aviv beach when she stepped on a buried bus bomb, or my son who was knocked out of bed when he slept in one day instead of having coffee as usual at a street cafe in front of his building in Jerusalem when a bomb went off slaughtering the people in the cafe. No, Jerry, I'm not going to repeat for you the reasons I know why the Israeli people elect a strong PM who will not capitulate to the terrorists surrounding his nation who openly swear to destroy Israel and annihilate its citizens. If you can't understand that, you never will. You haven't lived the experience of having to withstand anti-Semitism, the "no Jews allowed" and the "some of my best friends are Jews" bullshit. You couldn't possibly comprehend the need for the survival of the one country in the world where the word "Jew" is not used as a pejorative, the one country in the world where it can be a refuge from the increasing world-wide anti-Semitism - example: the exodus of the Jews of France to where they will be safe.
As for the "deal" that wonderful deal that does not stop but simply delays the inevitable, as I have said, I have posted enough articles on why a better deal was needed, or an increase in sanctions were needed, but I never said a war was needed, yet I keep being accused of that. Just as Bibi is accused of being a bloodthirsty (ah, the stereotypical children's blooddrinking Jew) warmonger. Please list for me the wars HE started, but leave out the defensive ones that were retalitory or preventative.
Here are a few articles for your reading pleasure while you sit back and criticize me from your comfortable safe armchair. After all, Did ISIS take over Canada? Did "Death to America" Iran conquer Mexico? Did Putin put nuclear ballistic missiles in Cuba? Relax, YOU have nothing to be concerned about.
The choices are no deal and they have a bomb within a year. Or we stop them from getting said bomb by a land invasion and conquest of Iran costing ten's of thousands of troop's lives, many of them ours, because air strikes would be a joke to try to stop them and they'll build a bomb within a year anyway. Or we do the deal and MAYBE they might make a bomb 15 to 25 years from now. MAYBE! Without the deal they'll have the bomb soon anyway. With the deal they may never have one.
And no, they do not get inspect their own facilities or are able to hide nuclear activity within 24 days. Both of those are lies made up out of whole cloth from the right wing with basis in reality whatsoever.
Oh there is always he 4th option. We release several of our nuclear bombs on them and contaminate nations around the region and the world. Don't like the choices? Tough shit, because that is all we have to pick from. This is not rocket surgery. The choice is obvious.
Those who don't know the dangers find it easy to criticize.
The day after I was old enough to vote I joined the local chapter of the YoungRepublicans. At first I just listened to discussions on the issue so I could find out what was going on and what the GOP was trying to do about it.
After a while I started to speak up and questioned the reasoning regarding certain issues. Well, I quickly learned you do not question the reasoning of the Party leaders, you follow the reasoning, you promote the reasoning and you promote the Party agenda. Questioning the reasoning of the Party leaders is not an option for the rank and file in the Republican Party.
Most Republicans are Christians that from early childhood are taught to believe in God .... on faith, to believe in Jesus .... on faith, to Believe in the Bible .... on faith. So, by the time that child, brought up in a traditional Christian household, is old enough to vote, they have been so conditioned to believing in important issues on faith, they have no problem believing in the GOP ..... on faith.
So, based on my observation regarding the people in the GOP, I would say Johns' observation regarding Republicans not thinking for themselves is 'spot on'.
No threats, they read the deal, analyzed the deal and realized they should support in.
I bet you're wrong.
What will change that maybe into a ' probably no t' is the fact that 15 years from now, the young Iranians of today, who are already showing dissatisfaction with their government leaders, will be in their 30's, early 40's, will likely have pushed the Ayatollahs out of power, will be enjoying a healthy, growing economy, in a peaceful international climate, and will not want to lose all that by attempting to build a nuclear bomb they have no use for.
Those lies have been debunked over and over, but the Republican leaders don't care about that, they just keep repeating the lies over and over. They know the GOP rank and file are conditioned to believe whatever they're told [ see comment ].
you mean you only receive e-mails from one Congressman. Why would Congressmen from other districts send you emails?
Many Congressmen regularly send emails to theirconstituents, it's an easy way for them to keep their name out there so if they're challenged in a primary or when it comes time for the GE, they have a leg up when it comes to name recognition.
Everyone (one word) does NOT know, because 'everyone' does not give a shit. And it's agrossexaggerationto say 99.99 percent of the gov'ment does not listen to the people. Because listening to the people is the only way they can get re-elected.
I've worked for elected officials (a city councilwoman, a city mayor and a state senator), they do listen to the people and they do work hard to try to get the things done that the people want done. But they cannot please everybody, because they have to work on the things that mostof people want done. Because, #1, there is only so much time, and #2, there is only somuchmoney, both of which there is never enough of.
Btw, there is no 'e' in Illinois. I know, it took me while to learn how to spell the name of my state, but then I was only in the 4th grade.
"Threatened" them how? What did he threaten to do, waterboard them? Did he threaten to put them on the Hillary campaign staff? Or maybe he threaten to shoot them. (an option some may have preferred when faced with having to work for Hillary).
It's most likely he sat down with them and showed them the good points and the positive values in the deal, convincing them a yes vote was the right thing to do. That's whatPresidentsare supposed to do, it's called leadership.
You go ahead and stand by that asinine comment, I'm sure it will make people realize just how sharp you are.
Yeah, sure you do. It has nothing to do with you not knowing how to spell the name of the State you live in.
What's that got to do with not knowing how to spell its name? Most of us know how to spell the name of every State in the nation.
What happened, get yourself locked up?
(that one's for, "Sorry it took you so long to learn to spell.")
No response to that Jerry?
Well, my opinion is that your opinion is asinine . Anyway you didn't state it as an opinion, you stated it as a statistic.
I love it when people have a different opinion than me, especially when I can prove them wrong.
No, I don't really care, you just seem like the kind of guy that might have gotten hisself locked up.
Sure you do, just like you know you should have said, "...I choose to spell it different ly ."
From 1977 to 2003 Illinois had Republican governors. Then you had Blago, who was framed by the Republican Legislature, and succeeded by Quinn.
Now you have Rauner, good luck with him.
Sounds like the same problem the current President of the United States has been having with his Republican controlled House of Reps and now the Senate.
Btw, name calling such as "what an ass", "smartass" and "jackass" are all CoC violations, you might want to be more careful in the future, there are 8 moderators on this site, you never know when one of them might stop by.
Woodie lives in the middle of nowhere in Hickville Il. That is why he hates it. People who live closer to civilization think it is fine. 10 million people live in the greater Chicago area. It is one of the largest metros in the nation.
Without Chicago, Illinois would be Missouri or Iowa. What more need be said ?How original.
Proved you wrong?! You make a claim that 99.99%, which is effectively all of the the government, never listens to any of the people, and you think a stupid comment like that needs to be proved wrong?! You're dumber than I thought. I think I'll just leave it up to the readers to make their own judgement on that one.
I'm not disappointed at all, actually I'm happy you were never locked up. I was just busting your chops about that when you said you were living in Illinois because of "circumstances beyond your control", ie your wife wants it that way. (we know who "wears the pants" in your family)
They are CoC violations, but I didn't report them because I want everyone to see what you said so they can judge for themselves what kind of person you are.
If they come across the comments, or if they are reported, it would not be their prerogative, it would be their responsibility to remove them.
That's your prerogative. (Just what we need, another member that doesn't give a shit.)
I'm glad your nature is there for everyone to see, I hope they don't get deleted.
Do you honestly think I wouldconsiderdeleting and article with this many replies because of a snarky comment from you?! Don't flatter yourself.
Yeah it is, you claim Rauner can't make any progress because his efforts are blocked by an opposition legislature, and the media reports say Obama can't make any progress for the same reason. Actually the GOP leaders openly stated their intent to cause Obamas' failure.
Whatever.
His 'constitutional powers'; allows him to use Executive Orders, and although they are legally binding, EOs do not "enact laws" they simply helpofficers and agencies of the executive branch manage the operations within the federal government itself. Congress has the power to overturn an EO, but tmk, this Congress has never attempted to do so.
My research has found only two caseswhere EOs were overturned by the judiciary branch;
One, which Truman issued in 1952, was meant to prevent strikes during the Korean War by placing all the nation's steel mills under federal law.
The second, from Clinton in 1995, prevented the federal government from entering into contracts with organizations that hire replacements for striking workers.
Both were overturned because they were ruled to be regulatory in nature.
If you can produce any credible evidence that any of Obamas' EOs were overturned I will be obliged to entertain your information.
Now, that comment is sojuvenile I'm not even going to attempt to author a response. So, once again in this discussion, I am gong to deffer judgement on that asinine comment to the other readers on this thread.
So that, inconclusion, tells me and the other readers on this thread that youdon't know what your talking about.
Out of Illinois' last seven governors, four, not nine, have ended up going to prison. They are:
Rod Blagojevich (D) Gov. 2002 - 2009, Convicted of numerous corruption charges.
George Ryan (R) Gov. 1999 - 2003. Convicted of racketeering for actions as governor and secretary of state.
Dan Walker (D) Gov. 1973-1977. Pleaded guilty to bank fraud and other charges in 1987 related to his business activities after leaving office.
Otto Kerner (D) Governor from 1961-1968. Resigned to become judge, then was convicted of bribery related to his tenure as governor.
So there you have it. If you want to continue this silly discussion, I'm game. Meanwhile, have a nice day.
What will change that maybeinto a 'probably not' is the fact that 15 years from now, the young Iranians of today, who are already showing dissatisfaction with their government leaders, will be in their 30's, early 40's, will likely have pushed the Ayatollahs out of power, will be enjoying a healthy, growing economy, in a peaceful international climate, and will not want to lose all that by attempting to build a nuclear bomb they have no use for.
100% spot on!