Nurse Defies Quarantine
A Maine nurse back from treating Ebola patients in West Africa followed through on her vow to defy the state's "voluntary" quarantine on Thursday, leaving her home for a bike ride.
Kaci Hickox and her boyfriend stepped out of their home Thursday morning and rode away on mountain bikes, followed by state police cruiser.
The end of the 21-day period would be Nov. 10.
Hickox, accompanied by her boyfriend, Ted Wilbur, earlier met with the media late Wednesday in the driveway of her home in Fort Kent, and said she will not observe the quarantine directive. The nurse, who returned from Sierra Leone last week after working with Doctors Without Borders, said that she had made no progress in her attempts to negotiate an end to her quarantine with state officials.
If a judge grants the state request, then Hickox will appeal the decision on constitutional grounds, necessitating a hearing, Hickox attorney Norman Siegel said.
"I'm not willing to stand here and let my civil rights be violated when it's not science-based," Hickox said. She contends there's no need for her to be quarantined because she's showing no symptoms of Ebola.

I understand she is unhappy about this imposed quarantine, but in the interest of the greater good, which health care workers are supposed to be concerned with, one would think that she would hang back and make sure the incubation period was over.
Unless we're going to quarantine EVERY worker who has treated ebola patients here and abroad, I hope she has a nice bike ride.
This woman is not some blathering idiot who doesn't know what protocol should be followed for 21 days. She has been willing to have healthcare workers monitor her temperature as she is certainly monitoring it herself. Does anyone think if she becomes symptomatic she wouldn't seek medical help?
It'll be interesting to see the state/court response and to what degree they're willing to take. If arrested will officers be in hazmat gear? If not, will the officers be quarantined? Where will they take her? Oh the endlessness of questions?????????????????/
Risk is our daily companion, living is dangerous. My argument is quarantine is not only impractical its scientifically not necessary.
Nobel Prize winner: Ebola can be spread by people who show no symptoms
Thursday, October 30, 2014
(NaturalNews) Nearly 15 years ago, European and African scientists knew that the Ebola virus could infect a person without them knowing about it, meaning they can walk around with the virus in their system and never show any symptoms.
In 2000, The New York Times ( archived here ), cited the findings of a study published in a prestigious medical journal, reporting:
The possibility of asymptomatic infection was only suggested in earlier studies, they said in last week's issue of The Lancet, a medical journal published in London. Now they said they had documented such infections for the first time. They found that the Ebola virus could persist in the blood of asymptomatic infected individuals for two weeks after they were first exposed to an infected individual. How much longer the virus can persist is unknown.
The Times went on to report that the virus "usually spreads" from someone who is infected via contamination "in clinics or hospitals," generally through contact with materials contaminated with infected bodily fluids. At that time, however, based on the "new finding" at the time, "some" Ebola "cases may result from healthy carriers," though "[h]ow often is unknown."
The 13 percent
Fast-forward to the present. In the largest study of the current outbreak, scientists have further discovered that more than 1-in-10, 13 percent, of Ebola patients don't exhibit a fever or other symptoms. As reported by the Los Angeles Times :
The study, sponsored by the World Health Organization and published online late last month by the New England Journal of Medicine, analyzed data on 3,343 confirmed and 667 probable cases of Ebola.
The finding that 87.1% of those infected exhibited fever - but 12.9% did not - illustrates the challenges confronting health authorities as they struggle to contain the epidemic.
That finding has been echoed by a Nobel Prize-winning scientist, as he voiced support for New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie's recent (now vacated) order to quarantine anyone returning from West Africa for 21 days. As reported by NJ.com :
Dr. [ Bruce ] Beutler, an American medical doctor and researcher, won the Nobel Prize for Medicine and Physiology in 2011 for his work researching the cellular subsystem of the body's overall immune system - the part of it that defends the body from infection by other organisms, like Ebola.
In voicing support for Christie's quarantine, Dr. Beutler -- current director of the Center for the Genetics of Host Defense at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas -- told the website, "I favor it," adding, "I favor it, because it's not entirely clear that they can't transmit the disease." He was referring to currently asymptomatic healthcare worker Kaci Hickox, a Doctors Without Borders nurse who recently returned to New Jersey after treating patients in Sierra Leone and was quarantined in the state for 65 hours. She was eventually taken to her home state of Maine.
'There's a lot of variation with viruses'
"It may not be absolutely true that those without symptoms can't transmit the disease, because we don't have the numbers to back that up," Dr. Beutler continued in his NJ.com interview. "It could be people develop significant viremia [where viruses enter the bloodstream and gain access to the rest of the body], and become able to transmit the disease before they have a fever, even.
"People may have said that without symptoms you can't transmit Ebola. I'm not sure about that being 100 percent true. There's a lot of variation with viruses," he added.
Despite the massive WHO study, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention continues to insist that the virus is not communicable in people without symptoms.
"There's some imperative to prevent panic among the public," Dr. Beutler said. "But to be honest, people have not examined that with transmissibility in mind. I don't completely trust people who'd say that as dogma."
Since Ebola came to the U.S., the CDC's chief, Dr. Thomas Frieden, has put out so much conflicting information that any reasonable person would conclude that's all it is: dogma.
Learn all these details and more at the FREE online Pandemic Preparedness course at www.BioDefense.com
Need to read the whole thing Robert and click the links, but other than that I totally agree with what you are saying. Maybe a 3 week vacation to Martha's Vineyard would be a nice alternative.
Do you feel this way in regard tothis particular nurse, oris it a generalization about anyonewho comes into contact withan Ebola patient?
My responses relate specifically to this individual.
I'm not of the opinion all exposures/contacts are equal or should be treated systematically the same. Case in point would be the fiance/girlfriend of Mr. Duncan who not only lived in the same household, reportedly had sexual contact, but did so after his fever was evident. Additionally, the biologics were left in the household for three days and no one in the apartment has any medical training.
What is known, John, is that Ebola is a sneaky little virus that remains in a mutative state. Its only functions areto consumethe hostresources, multiply, and move on to the next host. Like other viruses, if one avenue of advancementis cut off, another will take its place. This ishow and whydeadly viruses become immune to treatment; they find another avenue by which to multiply and move on to it's next host.
Also, if there is noevidence to be had stating that Ebolacan betransmitted by an asymptomatic patient, then the same can be said forevidence statingthat the virus cannot be spread by an asymptomatic patient. If you have that evidence, please link it and let us look at it.
On a related note, did you know Ebola has recently been found in semen samples of men 3 months after having contracted, and recovered from, the virus? It wasn't found in their blood samples, it was found in their semen. Read about it here .Like I said,Ebola isa sneaky little thing.
What bothers me are the vast numbers of healthcare workers who have contracted the virus,and those numbersinclude the nearly 300 who have died...in spite of takingmultiple-layered precautions against contracting the disease. We are talking nurses and doctors...the very people who should have been the most protected, especiallyconsidering the huge numbers of infected patients with whom they came into contact. That tells me that eithera large number of infected healthcare workersfailed in their responsibility to takeproper precautions, or the virusis consistently findinga way around those precautions.
Now,if one combines that knowledge withthat with the known fact that Ebola is in a constant state of mutation, shouldn't the oft-said 'over-abundance of caution' be prudent in every case of a returning health care worker?
Until science can find a way to anticipate a virus mutation, I don't think that three weeks is too much to ask of someone.
Well then stoptalking about it and move on to your nextcause clbre.
Would and have done so, well with AIDs at least.
In the 80's I lost 3 personal, longtime friends to AIDs and 5 close friends from work. I remember Paul Brennen, a popular young man, being back in the office to pick up some paperwork. He'd been out sick for weeks so when I heard he was in the break room I went to say hi. As I walked in it struck me as how odd it was that he seemed to be sitting alone in the center of the room while all his friends were hanging back along the walls. I walked to where Paul was sitting, squeezed his shoulder, told him he looked like shit and how good it was to see him then I impulsively bent and kissed the top of his head.
The others in the room laughed and then started gather around Paul to give him their best, which was nice because he would be gone in less than 3 weeks.
I would act the same today around any non-symptomatic person who I knew had been around Ebola.
The bulk of the medical staff going from America to help fight the Ebola outbreak in West Africa are volunteers. Theyre taken a week or a month away from work to go help, mostly using their personal vacation time.
How many of these volunteers would not be able to go help because they cant afford to take an extra 3 weeks off, especially when that lost time IS NOT medically necessary, is just a placebo for the uninformed and the easily frightened?
I, too,have lost several close friends to HIV/aids, and that includes one of my dearest friends in 1997. We were flight attendants together and shared crash-pads and beds on a regular basis. He had a Dallas layover and was supposed to spend the night at my house the day he died, and I have no doubt he would have slept in my bed (in a girl's slumber-party kind of way). I had no fear whatsoever.
But Ebola and HIV are not the same. Ebola can be absorbed through the skin. HIV/Aids is still transmitted blood to blood, semen to blood (whichcan happen withoral, anal and vaginal sex), needle sticks, etc. You can hug and even kiss an HIV patient all day long without fear of infection. As a matter of fact, HIV patients can have protected sex without too much fear of spreading it to their partner,although they still need to practice due diligence.
But a simple brush-up against any bodily fluid emitted from an Ebola patientis enough to transmit the virus.Vomit splatter, flyingphlegm, and even a small droplet ofperspiration, are all enough toinfect another person.
I, like you, appreciate the fact that so many of those going to West Africa are volunteering their time and effort. But those volunteers are not infallible. In fact, seasoned medical personnel are dying by the hundreds. There is still so much to be learned about this deadly virus and the way it is evolving. If it were me, due diligence and a sincere concern for putting others at ease,would take precedence over a subway ride to the bowling ally, and even a bike ride with a boyfriend.
On a side note, I rememberyou posting anaerialphotograph of your remote cabin home, and I was quite jealous of the serenity youmustenjoy. Considering the remote location, it would seem that you are in a perfect place, should such a pandemic catastrophe, no matter how unlikely,occur.
Thanks Formerstew. Love my place, treasure my isolation.
However before I retreated to my cabin in the woods I spent 50 years mostly in Dallas, was even born in Parkland hospital.
Dallas is a good example of how hard Ebola is to spread in a first world country.
Remember Duncan was seen and then sent back to his family after he was exhibiting systems and yet still no one who came into contact with him socially got infected.
I trotted out my history with AIDs because of my memories of how panicked the response to that infection was back in the 80's. The shunning of the kid with HIV when he tried to go back to school. How his bus met by an angry, frightened mob blocking his way. Think about that New York Times article I linked to earlier, printed in the mid 80's, showing how many people wanted to lock those folks away back then, some even wanting to tattoo AIDs patients for identification purposes similar to the way Lepers were made to ring a bell warning people they were in the area back in the day. We should be a lot further along than that.
Now dont get me wrong Formerstew there are many diseases where a complete quarantine would be the proper response but the medical experts tell us such a step would be counterproductive in the battle against Ebola and, so far, all the physical evidence in Dallas, New York & New Jersey is bearing them out.
Weve seen you can get sick if youre neck deep in the diseases and theres a breakdown in your protective protocols but so far in America no one has become infected by shaking hands, living in the same home or even sleeping with someone who is not showing symptoms much less getting sick by bowling in they same building or walking on the same street. If you're going to take away someones freedom @ least have a good reason to do so. Just saying.
The "Natural News" article is based on another article from the New York Times , published in 2000. Unfortunately the NYT did not cite the report it was referring to, which was from The Lancet, a medical journal published in London. Mind you; the year 2000 and ONE report.
Since the right dredged this up to support their own conspiratorial paranoia, another news source, The Washington Blog, on October 6, 2014, checked into it. This news source cited the actual report given by the "The Lancet" back in 2000 which includes their editorial comments. To wit:
But Western governments and scientists have repeatedly said that Ebola carriers can only infect others if they are showing symptoms. So they need to adjust their strategies to account for potential contagion from people who arent showing any symptoms."
This is called " confirmation bias ."
You be funny AeonPax. You didn't say anything that the article itself didn't say, except the confirmation bias link which tickles my funny bone. Thanks. I still think we should reward them by giving them a 3 week vacation with pay to Martha's Vineyard.
I personally wouldn't have any problem quarantining myself if there was a chance of saving someone else the possibility of contracting the Ebola virus I had been subjected to in Africa. I guess to each his own.
I certainly understand at present it appears Ebola isn't like the flu, but with each person or obstacle the virus encounters it mutates. Think of it like a new detour around that obstacle.
And the real culprits of Ebola are not people who are or may be infected, but the carriers of the virus who are unaffected such as the fruit bat. We sure wouldn't want to spread the virus to one of them, would we, since we really can't say with complete confidence we know who all unaffected carriers may be, nor can we expect to eliminate those carriers or we could have eradicated it like Smallpox. We can only hope to develop a vaccine which will be basically like the flu virus vaccine, dealing with a mutating virus with each outbreak. At least the vaccine will, hopefully reduce the severity of Ebola, which has a 25% to 90% mortality rate.
I understand there are many other disease much worse and much more contagious than Ebola which kill many more people than Ebola has or appears it will in the future.
I lean toward caution, not ostracism.
Well Robert, we're dealing with "Political Science" here, not "Hard Science".