8 Myths and Atrocities About Christopher Columbus and Columbus Day
1. On the WayColumbus Stole a Sailors Reward
2. Columbus Never Landed on American SoilNot in 1492, Not Ever 3. Columbus Painted a Horrible Picture of Peaceful Natives 4. Columbus Men Were Rapists and Murderers 5. Columbus Enslaved the Native People for Gold 6. Columbus Provided Native Sex Slaves to His Men 7. Columbus Men Used Native People as Dog Food 8. Columbus Returned to Spain in ShacklesBut Was Pardoned Now, the rest of the story -On the second Monday of October each year, Native Americans cringe at the thought of honoring a man who committed atrocities against Indigenous Peoples.
Columbus Day was conceived by the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic Fraternal organization, in the 1930s because they wanted a Catholic hero. After President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the day into law as a federal holiday in 1937, the rest has been history.
In an attempt to further thwart the celebration of this holiday, we at ICTMN have outlined eight misnomers and bloody, greedy, sexually perverse and horrendous atrocities committed by Columbus and his men.
On the WayColumbus Stole a Sailors Reward
After obtaining funding for his explorations to reach Asia from the seizure and sale of properties from Spanish Jews and Muslims by order of King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella, Columbus headed out to explore a new world with money and ships.
Brimming with the excitement of discovering new land, Columbus offered a reward of 10,000 maravedis or about $540 (a sailors yearly salary) for the first person to discover such land. Though another sailor saw the land in October 1492, Columbus retracted the reward he had previously offered because he claimed he had seen a dim light in the west.
Columbus Never Landed on American SoilNot in 1492, Not Ever
Were not talking about the Leif Ericson Viking explorer story. We mean Columbus didnt land on the higher 48ever. Columbus quite literally landed in what is now known as the Bahamas and later Hispaniola, present-day Haiti and the Dominican Republic.
Upon arrival, Columbus and his expedition of weapon laden Spaniards met the Arawaks, Tainos and Lucayansall friendly, according to Columbus writings. Soon after arriving, Columbus wrecked the Santa Maria and the Arawaks worked for hours to save the crew and cargo.
Impressed with the friendliness of the native people, Columbus seized control of the land in the name of Spain. He also helped himself to some locals. In his journal he wrote:
As soon as I arrived in the Indies, on the first Island which I found, I took some of the natives by force in order that they might learn and might give me information of whatever there is in these parts.
RELATED: American History Myths Debunked: Columbus Discovered America
Columbus Painted a Horrible Picture of Peaceful Natives
When Columbus first saw the Native Arawaks that came to greet him and his crew he spoke with a peaceful and admiring tone.
They ... brought us parrots and balls of cotton and spears and many other things... They willingly traded everything they owned... They were well-built, with good bodies and handsome features.... They do not bear arms, and do not know them, for I showed them a sword, they took it by the edge and cut themselves out of ignorance. They have no iron. Their spears are made of cane... . They would make fine servants.... With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want.
After several months in the Caribbean, on January 13, 1493 two Natives were murdered during trading. Columbus, who had otherwise described the Natives as gentle people wrote (they are) evil and I believe they are from the island of Caribe, and that they eat men. He also described them as savage cannibals, with dog-like noses that drink the blood of their victims.
The cannibal story is taught as fact in some of todays schools.
Columbus Men Were Rapists and Murderers
On Columbuss first trip to the Caribbean, he later returned to Spain and left behind 39 men who went ahead and helped themselves to Native women. Upon his return the men were all dead.
With 1,200 more soldiers at his disposal, rape and pillaging became rampant as well as tolerated by Columbus.
This is supported by a reported close friend of Columbus, Michele deCuneo who wrote the first disturbing account of a relation between himself and a Native female gift given to him by Columbus.
While I was in the boat I captured a very beautiful Carib woman, whom the said Lord Admiral gave to me, and with whom, having taken her into my cabin, she being naked according to their custom, I conceived desire to take pleasure. I wanted to put my desire into execution but she did not want it and treated me with her finger nails in such a manner that I wished I had never begun. But seeing that (to tell you the end of it all), I took a rope and thrashed her well, for which she raised such unheard of screams that you would not have believed your ears. Finally we came to an agreement in such manner that I can tell you that she seemed to have been brought up in a school of harlots.
Several accounts of cruelty and murder include Spaniards testing the sharpness of blades on Native people by cutting them in half, beheading them in contests and throwing Natives into vats of boiling soap. There are also accounts of suckling infants being lifted from their mothers breasts by Spaniards, only to be dashed headfirst into large rocks.
Bartolome De Las Casas, a former slave owner who became Bishop of Chiapas, described these exploits. Such inhumanities and barbarisms were committed in my sight as no age can parallel, he wrote. My eyes have seen these acts so foreign to human nature that now I tremble as I write.
Columbus Enslaved the Native People for Gold
Because Columbus reported a plethora of Natives for slaves, rivers of gold and fertile pastures to Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand, Columbus was given 17 ships and more than 1,200 men on his next expedition. However, Columbus had to deliver. In the next few years, Columbus was desperate to fulfill those promiseshundreds of Native slaves died on their way back to Spain and gold was not as bountiful as expected.
Columbus forced the Natives to work in gold mines until exhaustion. Those who opposed were beheaded or had their ears cut off.
In the provinces of Cicao all persons over 14 had to supply at least a thimble of gold dust every three months and were given copper necklaces as proof of their compliance. Those who did not fulfill their obligation had their hands cut off, which were tied around their necks while they bled to deathsome 10,000 died handless.
In two years time, approximately 250,000 Indians on Haiti were dead. Many deaths included mass suicides or intentional poisonings or mothers killing their babies to avoid persecution.
According to Columbus, in a few years before his death, Gold is the most precious of all commodities; gold constitutes treasure, and he who possesses it has all he needs in the world, as also the means of rescuing souls from purgatory, and restoring them to the enjoyment of paradise.
Columbus Provided Native Sex Slaves to His Men
In addition to putting the Natives to work as slaves in his gold mines, Columbus also sold sex slaves to his mensome as young as 9. Columbus and his men also raided villages for sex and sport.
In the year 1500, Columbus wrote: A hundred castellanoes are as easily obtained for a woman as for a farm, and it is very general and there are plenty of dealers who go about looking for girls; those from nine to ten are now in demand.
Columbus Men Used Native People as Dog Food
In the early years of Columbus conquests there were butcher shops throughout the Caribbean where Indian bodies were sold as dog food. There was also a practice known as the montera infernal , the infernal chase, or manhunt, in which Indians were hunted by war-dogs.
These dogswho also wore armor and had been fed human flesh, were a fierce match for the Indians. Live babies were also fed to these war dogs as sport, sometimes in front of horrified parents.
Columbus Returned to Spain in ShacklesBut Was Pardoned
After a multitude of complaints against Columbus about his mismanagement of the island of Hispaniola, a royal commissioner arrested Columbus in 1500 and brought him back to Spain in chains.
Though he was stripped of his governor title, he was pardoned by King Ferdinand, who then subsidized a fourth voyage.
Read more at http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2013/10/14/8-myths-and-atrocities-about-christopher-columbus-and-columbus-day-151653

Bet this ain't the way you learned it in school, is it?
And the pilgrims begat many white-faced young'ns.
Now - back to the thread.
Rape in the context of that era was no big deal . Judging the past by today's standards is misleading at best .
But - cutting off hands, bashing kids against rocks, cutting off heads for disagreement - and much, much more.
Apples and oranges.
It was a very brutal era . And Spain was one of the most brutal countries of Europe . Their lust for gold knew no bounds .
If Columbus didn't "discover" America, from the European point of view, then who did ?
What's with Squanto - 200 years later - different subject.
And the peoples of Santo Domingo have done their damnedest to cleanse their island ever since.
The Viking were here in appx 1100 AD....Research the stones of MN and the White Indians....Myth or truth?
I would say Columbus discovered "America" from a European viewpoint because his exploration /conquest led to fairly immediate "permanent" settlements.
The first English settlement in North America was more than a hundred years after John Cabot.
Link?
So his atrocities are acceptable?
I am not going to dignify such a foolish question.
But John - 180 million people already had lived in the Western hemisphere for over 30,000 years BEFORE Columbus got lost. Wouldn't 30,000 years be considered "permanent"????
Shit happens.
Only in Europe, right?
The Europeans in 1492, and after, didn't have the same viewpoint the people who had lived there for thousands of years did.
That is the whole problem with saying Columbus did or did not "discover" something. It depends on what viewpoint you are using. In terms of European exploration and colonialism and commercialism, he did.
In terms of European's, they did everything before anyone else.
Columbus Men Were Rapists and Murderers
So were the native men , as raiding and stealing women was a popular cause of war.
The cannibal story is taught as fact in some of todays schools
It should be. The Caribs were cannibals. That's well documented from sources other than Columbus or other Spaniards.
Kinda like for you to give me some links to that - not well documented at all.
Sure raiding and stealing was a popular cause of war in Europe. In the Western hemisphere, for the most part, it was done to replenish the population of the tribe/nation as the population had dropped due to disease, warring with other tribes/nations to protect their boundaries, or just protecting their homeland from invaders.
Native American tribes/nations were not the "warring" nations that the Euro's were/are - that statement can be supported with tons and tons and tons of links. Ever heard of the Crusades? How 'bout the 100 years war? How 'bout the War of the Roses? Control - that's all it is with the Euro's - control and domination.
There are worse things than control and domination . For example the 100 years war was due to a lack of domination .
Personally, I don't believe that we should be celebrating Columbus Day at all.
No, we never learned about this in school. But, I'm glad I know now.
How 'bout an example Petey because under control and domination, the other horrible acts follow.
The Caribs were real peaches:
"the first detailed description of the treatment of captured itotos was made by Antoine Biet (1664), under the chapter heading : " How they conduct warfare against their enemies and the cruel death which those who are taken prisoner suffer ". Biet relates that any captured women or children, if not integrated into Carib society as poitos or " slaves ", would be tied to a tree, shot full of arrows and their corpses burnt. Men, who were not to be taken back to the village alive :
... had the principal parts of their bodies cut off, taken away and attached to the pirogues... (1664 : 382 ; see also Gumilla : quoted p. 7)
Women and children were treated well on their arrival at the victorious village but men, after being washed, dressed and well fed, were taken to the village long-house. Here they were tied up and, after the women of the village had performed a dance, were tortured to death by the application of an inflammable resin to their bodies. Certain parts of the body were then removed, Biet mentions the ears, nose and penis, cooked and eaten, though some of the carcass was kept so that it could be shared with allied villages (1664 : 383-4)."
To sum up...
".As far as the issue as to what exactly was involved in Carib cannibalism is concerned, one may note that the sources are remarkably consistent in defining it as a limited, ritual act only associated with victory in battle and also as an act that was to be clearly differentiated from the kind of funerary customs, of which Columbus made so much, and which can still be observed today. Undoubtedly, funerary practices which involved the preservation of bones and the consumption of human remains were a fertile source of misinterpretation, as Las Casas quickly observed, and even such sympathetic observers cannot be relied upon to have always fully distinguished these practices 12, despite claiming to be eyewitnesses to the relevant events.
In sum, a close reading of the sources strongly indicates the existence of cannibalistic practices among the Caribs, as well as other Amerindians, though it would seem that it was the European pre-occupation with this subject, still evident today, rather than its overall sociological significance for Carib peoples that necessitates such a detailed treatment of the topic."
Carrib CannibalismJournal de la Socit des Amricanistes
Native American tribes/nations were not the "warring" nations that the Euro's were/are
That's an unsupported statement. You should read "War Before Civilization"
From the New York Times Book Review:
"Offering abundant supporting evidence, he concludes that the idea of the Noble Savage is essentially nonsense, that in fact primitive warfare was more brutal and intense and probably less ritualized than its civilized counterpart.
Mobilization was more complete in primitive warfare, Mr. Keeley contends. Battles went on more often. More people were killed and fewer prisoners were taken. Weapons were designed to inflict greater damage: the author cites arrowheads and spear points designed to break off in the wounds they caused, and the use of septic poisons intended to cause death long after contact.
Territory was gained and held. Massacres occurred. And evidence of all this often predates contact with Western culture. "For example," Mr. Keeley writes, "at Crow Creek in South Dakota, archeologists found a mass grave containing the remains of more than 500 men, women and children who had been slaughtered, scalped and mutilated during an attack on their village a century and a half before Columbus's arrival (circa A.D. 1325)."
Moreover, he argues, primitive cultures were rarely contaminated by contact with more civilized cultures. If anything, the influence occurred in reverse, as in the case described by a New Englander in 1677: "In our first war with the Indians, God pleased to show us the vanity of our military skill, in managing our arms, after the European mode. Now we are glad to learn the skulking way of war."
Sean - after my move back to Las Cruces and after I retrieve my over 200 reference books, I'll be glad to "refute" your inserts above.
Suffice it to say - yes, there were cannibals in Africa, Asia, Australia, Europe, South America and Central America - even in the islands of the Polynesians. In the Caribbean, there were the Caribes (from South America), Cibonia, Arawak, Bogota , B oruca , B ribri , Bu glere , C abecar, Caquetio, Changuena, Corobici, Cueva, Cuna, Dorasque, Garifuna, Guajiro, Guaymi, Huetar, Inyeri, Island Carib, Maleku, Miskito, Paraujano, Pech, Rama, Shebayo, Taino, Teribe (my wife's Tribe ), and Voto Tribes . Your reference regarding one tribe?
So, "selecting" the Caribs as the models for the remaining tribes is ineffectual in your discussion.
Yes, tribes in the Americas conducted warfare - but I really don't think that a "mass grave of 500" individuals equates to over 70 million peoples being killed as a result of the Euro's methods of "friendship" - ya think?
I've stood beside Columbus's casket in the Catedral de Sevilla. I was happy be there in the presence of such prestigious remains.
I have stood exactly where Columbus stood in the throne room at the Palace in Segovia where Columbus proposed the voyage around the world to Ferdinand and Isabella.
The church as another hero. How many other church members do you see receiving this type of adulation?
Jamestown 1607 - John Cabot - 1497 - didn't establish anything other than stopping to obtain water - Cabot is reported to have landed only once during the expedition and did not advance "beyond the shooting distance of a crossbow". Pasqualigo and Day both state that the expedition made no contact with any native people; crew found the remains of a fire, a human trail, nets and a wooden tool. The crew appeared to have remained on land just long enough to take on fresh water; they also raised the Venetian and Papal banners, claiming the land for the King of England and recognising the religious authority of the Roman Catholic Church. After this landing, Cabot spent some weeks "discovering the coast," with most "discovered after turning back."
And Cabot wasn't English - he was Italian navigatorin the employ of the English.
Columbus was a sociopath. Columbus was everything in the article and worse.
But the one thing that is always left out of these topics is who funded the Columbus voyages and enabled him to end up in the Caribbean Islands? It's the same people who have funded both sides of wars between countries, the money changers. During the time of Columbus the thing that turned them on was GOLD!!!!
Just when you think that it can't get dumber on Newstalkers...
It is practically by definition . If there was a single dominant force the 100 year war would have ended a lot quicker . Don't make it harder than it has to be .
Robert if you knew the true history of Columbus I think you would agree. Just be thankful there is a difference in dumb and ignorant. Your ignorance in this case will possibly save you from any accusation of being dumb.
If I knew...
I am amazed at how stupid people are.
Not true - everybody kept on changing sides which is why the war lasted 100 years.
Reflections?
Everybody kept changing sides because there was no one dominant power ...
''Just when you think that it can't get dumber on Newstalkers...''
You show up RG...Perfect timing..
Are you RG's waterboy Thug puppet?
I thought that the G stood for Gagwaaisagendaagozi
Let's not go there folks.
Your right 1st, no use wasting time with faux comedians and malcontents.
The Caribes were also in the Antilles, where Columbus landed. Accordingly, his reports of cannibals were accurate, not lies.
t I really don't think that a "mass grave of 500" individuals
One, theSpaniards or Westerners did not kill 70 million natives. That's likeclaimingtheChinesekilled 100 million Europeans in the 14th century.
Two, if we are talking about the brutalityof their respective civilizations, denizens of pre-contact Mexico, for instance, had a significantlyhigher chance of dying violently than their counterparts in Europe. In fact, all of the studies of pre contact Indian burial grounds that I'm aware of showincrediblyhigh rates of violent death. If you have objective evidence of the pacific nature of life in the pre contact Americas, I'd beinterestedin seeing it.
No one likes to be lied to or taught distorted history, which unfortunately is very difficult to dismiss when the truth hits you smack dab in the face, but Columbus was not the person, nor were the sailors on his numerous voyages that we have been led to believe. During that time GOLD and other RICHES were the most important things to Columbus, his sailors and those who funded his voyages.
Here's something to read if you have the time and eyes for it. Understand this is just one more version of the life of Columbus and none of us truly know every detail and can only gain a general understanding, but there are certainties that can not be ignored.
Believe me, there are other versions which are far worst than this. If the true history hadn't been manipulated about Columbus and many other actual facts in this world's history, it may not be so upside down today as it is. I believe you can never go wrong if you are open to the truth in any matter once you accept it.
Christopher Columbus
People on NT are too stupid to be embarrassed by their ignorance.
Your poor schooling is not my problem.
Sure Jethro, we know you had great reasons to kidnap and murder.
(Look Pa, I got me a womans. Now what do are do?)
Well, they had to make sure that it rained, so it is understandable that they would sacrifice some children.
RG is suffering from delusions of grandeur, a common occurrence among the malcontent.
You're heading into the personal attack arena RG - need to rethink how you posit things.
"The strongest measures were necessary to undo this mischief, and, backed by his brother Bartholomew, Columbus proceeded to reduce the natives under Spanish sway."
Same message, eh?
Uncomfortable truth: Columbus was a mass killer and father of the slave trade
Christopher Columbus is a polarizing historical figure whose life has been defined, by many, for his astonishing level of courage and intestinal fortitude; nevertheless, such impressive traits should never blur the fact that he oversaw a murderous quest for material riches that resulted in the utter demise of a people. Each year, as October 12 comes and goes, a question is raised what are we celebrating about his life?
Christopher Columbus was an immensely talented mariner who navigated the Santa Maria and two other smaller ships across the Atlantic Ocean in search of Asia. However, he and his crew inadvertently arrived in the New World on October 12, 1492. Their long and arduous journey was driven by one clear objective to find and establish a long-term source of wealth, preferably gold, for the King and Queen of Spain.
In return, Columbus would be allotted 10 percent of the profits, governorship over new-found land, and awarded the prestigious title of Admiral of the Ocean Sea. Upon arriving in the islands, which we now refer to as the Bahamas, Columbus and his crew first encountered the Arawaks. It was at that fateful juncture in human history that he made two keen observations regarding these indigenous people. Firstly, they were docile and trusting in nature; and, secondly, they wore gold jewelry. Columbuss own words from his personal journal capture the ominous fate that awaited the Arawaks:
"They do not bear arms, and do not know them, for I showed them a sword, they took it by the edge and cut themselves out of ignorance. They have no iron. Their spears are made of cane. They would make fine servants. With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want."
The concept of private property and the pursuit of material riches had reached a frenzied pitch within 15th century Europe. As an independent contractor, Christopher Columbus recognized the seemingly limitless economic potential of the land he had discovered.
It was at this point in time that his bravery had begun to shift to sheer brutality. This transition within his personality was encapsulated in many of the notes that he had sent to the King and Queen of Spain to bolster expectations. In one particular note he promised as much gold as they need and as many slaves as they ask.
Soon thereafter, he and his men kidnapped a number of the Arawaks and forced them to identify other sources of gold throughout the region.
With an extensive arsenal of advanced weaponry/horses, Columbus and his men, arrived on the islands that were later named Cuba and Hispaniola (present day Dominican Republic / Haiti). Upon arrival, the sheer magnitude of gold, which was readily available, set into motion a relentless wave of murder, rape, pillaging, and slavery that would forever alter the course of human history.
A young, Catholic priest named Bartolom de las Casas transcribed Columbuss journals and later wrote about the violence he had witnessed. The fact that such crimes could potentially go unnoticed by future generations was deeply troubling to him. He expanded upon the extent of Columbuss reign of terror within his multivolume book entitled the "History of the Indies":
"There were 60,000 people living on this island, including the Indians; so that from 1494 to 1508, over 3,000,000 people had perished from war, slavery, and the mines. Who in future generations will believe this? I myself writing it as a knowledgeable eyewitness can hardly believe it."
Such words offer the reader a firsthand account of the state-sponsored genocide that the Spanish Empire had financed through Columbus. Clearly, the intent of the Spanish Empire was to eradicate the islands of indigenous people through slavery and violence. In doing so they had further established their already dominant political / economic standing within Europe. In a matter of years, Columbus and his men decimated the indigenous people of the Caribbean islands.
The fact that Columbus Day is celebrated each October is a testament to the intellectual dishonesty that has stemmed from the likes of academics, teachers, and politicians. It has become an annual ritual to sanitize history and present half-truths as absolutes. In 1937, Columbus Day was officially established as a federal holiday in the United States; however, to this day it is not observed in Hawaii, Nevada, Oregon and South Dakota.
The other 46 states that observe the holiday acknowledge Christopher Columbus as a superior mariner that had unknowingly found himself in the Caribbean Sea after departing from Europe. Incidentally, in conjunction with those facts, it would also be quite fair to label Columbus as one of the founding fathers of the trans-Atlantic slave trade. Unfortunately such an unpleasant truth has been relegated to the background of history.
For decades now we have been hearing self proclaimed experts espouse Columbuss many accomplishments particularly his discovery of the New World, yet, in doing so they have opted to minimize the extent of his violence or have utterly disregarded it.
The shame in all of this is that people living in countries throughout the Western Hemisphere, including the United States, have been indoctrinated into believing such fallacies and have been intentionally miseducated.
In sum, history cannot be rewritten. However with information now at our fingertips we can no longer fault our teachers, politicians, etc. for being left in the dark regarding our collective histories. Thoroughly researched academic materials are readily available for those who seek the truth.
In fact, it is fair to assume that as people gain a better understanding of Columbus they will begin to support other efforts to acknowledge this particular point in time.
Such forthright thinking is certainly evident within the cities of Denver and Minneapolis which have both taken the lead in distancing themselves from Columbuss crimes and have acknowledging his victims with an Indigenous Peoples Day on October 12. Or, perhaps, we should consider an Italian Heritage Day?
One could certainly make a valid argument for the recognition of Galileo Galilei, Saint Francis of Assisi, Dante Alighieri, or Leonardo Da Vincis accomplishments. Be that as it may, most Americans take pride in our collective history and it is incumbent upon us to rectify past errors through education and enlighten our young people to the rich, yet, nuanced nature of American history. Taking a moment to reflect upon the man Columbus truly was is the first step to gaining a better understanding of how far we have come as a model nation.
Owen McCormack is a teacher within the New York City Department of Education. He holds a Master of Arts degree in History from the City College of New York and a Master of Science degree in Special Education from the College of Staten Island. He enjoys analyzing the complexities of todays social and political issues through a religious / historical prism. His writing has been featured in TRUTH-OUT.org.
Given the historical context of when Columbus did his mariner thing means that a lot of these accusations were not a big deal back then . Rape and slave trading were pretty much SOP back in those days .
Well, Robert, please educate us. Get us all set straight on these issues. You seem to have a greater understanding and knowledge than everyone here.
Grenade comments don't educate. Tell us what you know so we may consider your point of view. I'll listen.
seen on twitter
columbus might not have been cool but at least I get a day off of school
6 minutes ago
I have learned that it is not worth the effort with 90 percent of NT members, and especially not worth any effort with the NA bigots and racists.
Stay stupid, my friend.
RG, If I wanted to kill myself I would climb up you ego and jump down to your IQ level.
The thing that I have to wonder about Columbus Day is this - how many societies and cultures around the world have celebrated someone who was brutal, murderous and greedy from their group. I'm thinking a lot.
"Celebrations" like Columbus Day are always about more than the individual, I have a feeling that very few Americans alive today really give a rat's ass about Christopher Columbus, even among those who support the holiday.
Like it or not, the explorations of Columbus led directly to the European expansion into the "New World". Many people think that represents the advent of the modern world.
Then there are the Italian-Americans who see it as their ethnic heritage to support Columbus Day.
It's not really as simple as just saying Columbus was a bad guy.
LMAO!!!! I like that Kavika..
All that you have written may be so, but, the truth must be revealed, then people can make you their own minds about this guy...
Hint....
Study Darwin to figure out what happened to Indians.
RG, if ignorance every goes up to $5 a barrel, I want drilling rights to your head.
Darwin himself had many concerns about his own theory. Today many scientistsview the survival of the species as a partial explanation, with may holes and unconvincing arguments. Therearestudies emerging explaining much of the holes left in Darwin's theories. We are starting to see a pattern that tells a story of chemical and bacterial symbiosis driving evolution, as strongly or even stronger, thancompetition. makes sense if ya think about it.
Good point . Jared Diamond went into that concept somewhat in "Guns Germs and Steel" .
That's not really conflicting. It just acknowledges a greater complexity. And add... viral. Since those are what killed most Indians.
In spite of the apparent dominance of idiots, and the desire to find and generate the most hate, there was no all encompassing plan that covers five hundred years.
Acomplexity that goes beyond my imperfect understanding, I guess. Yet, if we seriously look at that, might we not find that one of the reasons why humans are failing to thrive (at least in the last 150 years or so) is because we have failed togrow into that knowledge, with all it's complexity.
How much differently would we view ourselves and each other (that includes all living creatures) if we realized that our growth depends more on helping each other, rather than competing against each other.
In regards to this conversation, even if one was a Darwin purist, they would be hard pressed to say that the Europeans who have been grafted into North America are surviving any better than their indigenous counterparts. Makes me wonder how much better we would/could be doing if we modeled our behavior and attitudes after the examples given in Nature.
Nature is merciless.
And Larry, this is ALL about people who are upset about ancient shit, and want everyone to join in the wallow, NOT about joining together to solve problems.
It is certainly NOT about knowledge. It IS about ignorance and about furthering the influence of ignorance.
Columbus Day and , I guess Thanksgiving to a little lesser extent, are the only two calendar days of the year when the indigenous of North America can have their voices heard with the appropriate level of attention. Even though I think the crusade against Columbus Day will continue to be fruitless on a national basis, anti-Columbus voices have a very legitimate point of view to express and they should continue to do so.
For our lifetimes, this day will likely continue to be controversial, without much anyone can really do about it.
People who say that are usually too confused to know a truth when they see one .
Fascinating that the use of certain keywords substitutes an emoticon without being prompted to do so . Confused is a word that means something . I wonder if capitalizing it will preserve it . If not there is always quotes : "confused" .
I know, crazy right?!
Robert,
I could just as easily say that Nature is merciful too.
:~)
I would love to get into a thing about where modern science is taking our understanding about evolution and symbiosis; but, besides being too much for right here and now (I am poorly prepared) it would stray too far from the topic as well.
So how about just straight to it then?
Perhaps you are right, and others are wrong, perhaps not. Yet, without conclusive information from both sides, howare we to glean any wisdom? If all I see is one side, I will never come to any sorta balanced judgment. That seems to be what this article tries to expose, is a one-sided account of a rather important aspect of American history. If there is more than one, or two, or three...viewpoints, isn't it important to hash through all of them?
My concern is that unless all sides attempt to fully engage with solid arguments and proofs, then the entire exercise is futile as nobody will learn anything. You state that there is actually an attempt for ignorance to be propagated rather than knowledge. If that is true, then I would say it is incumbent on you to present your argument, your knowledge, your wisdom, for the betterment of us all.
See? Competition as well as cooperation could benefit the entire organism called the NewsTalkers; and, we could learn and grow and be better.
:~)
Sure. We can do that for all races, ethnicities, and religions. Equal time. That would mean a few hundred articles where the Poles, the Pakistanis, the Chinese.... and a hundred other extra special groups, made their cases as to how one or another group screwed them over some time during the last 10,000 years.
We could all sympathize, and agree to piss on graves.
Point... I don't need or care about "solid proof" provided by alternate bigots. Most of what is provided here as news and revelations is embarrassingly simple, obvious, and well known. Much if it is bullshit. YOU make the mistake of assuming that I want to avoid the discussion, when the issue is about how people want to assail a man, a race... Euros and Spaniards, whites, Catholics, Not to mention Italians who claim Columbus as theirs, and they have ZERO interest in what you claimed to be important... a gaining of understanding.
In fact, it is laughable that you miss that, or laughable that you claim to miss that.
And, when 1st makes the farcical claim that Columbus was responsible for the death of 70 million people, that is an obvious attempt, and need, to blame ONE person for what was, in fact, very much associated with and linked to Darwin's theories, AND to your point about bio and viral linkages, and thinking about it, almost funny how science and anthropology have ignored that for so long.
My main point, always, is that these whiner/bigots bore the crap out of me, and out of anyone with a functioning brain, and that is why NT has so few intelligent people still participating.
Good luck.
Don't forget the "Knights of Columbus" who fought for this holiday.
"when 1st makes the farcical claim that Columbus was responsible for the death of 70 million people"
Robert - I have NEVER made that claim. You wish to attempt to castigate me? Let's do it through the mail - or I'll give you my phone number. But, to attempt to publicly castigate me is beyond, even you.
How is that ?
Says 70 million, but doesn't say Columbus did 70 million.
I think I am young enough to accept the truth and still bounce back, others, maybe not so..
That says a lot about the deficiencies in our school system!
Here's what I remember-- I think this is mainly factual:
Columbus was Italian. His voyages were sponsored by Spanish Royalty. I believe he never set foot on the North American continent at all, so of course never meet Squanto or any other Indians in the area now known as new England. If the stories of the "first Thanksgiving" have any truth to the, the Europeans involved were not Columbus or his men.
However there were Europeans who landed on the North American continent, specifically "new England". They were the Pilgrims. (I believe the Puritans also landed in that area). The Pilgrims were English, and they were not sent to explore. Rather they wanted to find religious freedom they didn't have in England. They landed at Plimoth Rock in MA., meet Indians & if the story is true they meet Squanto.
But its not surprising, because so much of the history taught in American schools has very little correlation with what actually happened!!!
There's apparently disagreement, but I believe the current view is that it was him.
I've always thought it strange that we say some Europeans or other "discovered" America. Indians had been living here a long time, so if anyone "discovered America"-- it was some Indian tribe!
I agree with one of your previous comments John. The fact is it would be hard to find anyone from any of those European countries including the Muslim countries and Russia who were any better than Columbus. We do know the Muslims were really big on slave trade and they all wanted GOLD, RICHES and to conquer more land, islands and if possible continents for their countries during that time in history.
As far as the number of Indians who died, I believe most of them died from diseases brought to them by these people, not saying these people didn't promote their deaths intentionally by giving them infected blankets that killed almost everyone in the tribe.
Staying on topic, Columbus was not the fellow who came to the New World any more than any of the rest of them and smoked the peace pipe with the people he came upon during his voyages.
I don't mind native Americans stating their case in the annals of history on Columbus Day. There is no more appropriate day. By the same token, it is not easy for modern people to think like someone from 500 years ago. What did they believe?
I had thought the Vikings only went to the east coast-- Nova Scotia & Newfoundland?
1st,
Ignore that comment. It just a mean spirited and silly comment and no one will judge you by it.
Actually I think that's why the holiday still exists.
There are some controversial issues with many people who feel passionately about them-- some pro, some con. But sometimes there is an issue that a small group feels strongly about-- and the majority Of Americans don't care about ether way. In those cases often a small group can lobby hard and get something passed. (BTW I also think that's why the NRA is so powerful).
Most people I know don't think much about Columbus Day or have strong feelings about it. (But I imagine some Italian-Americans do).
And think about Washington's Birthday-- or several other holidays. How many people do you know that care about it much (either pro or con)-- for most people its just nice to have another day off from work!
I agree, there are layers upon layers here. There is the brunt of the article, which discusses Columbus. Overtones about Colonialism, attacks on cultural edifices, and genocide provide backdrop. These are all important aspects are they not? I don't believe that you find these too trvial to discuss; rather, you question the veracity of the of the author and/or commenters here, intentions in discussing them. You believe you do not know, intentions or compass. I know you are a smart fella, possibly the best downright actual writer we have here. Let me propose to you though Robert, that you may be wrong sometimes.
How can I make that claim? Because of your doubt that there are people here conversingfor the express purposeof socializing yes, but also learning and attempting to affect understanding between differing opinions.That is a mistake in judgement, an assumption about reality based on what we may actualy know about some, but is still a mere generalization, and isn't true of all.It discount others here who genuinely want to reach some conclusions. Some truths about history, hopefully enabling meaningful conversation, and yes, even reaching understanding. I'm not blind, I know how difficult that is. I also know that it is possible. I know it for a fact in my mind and my gut, because I've experienced it.
I work a shitload of hours, not because I like it, but because I'm trapped just like nearly every other fuckin' slob I know. If I was a rich dude I would travel all over,,,see the world. But I'd start by seeing the USA,,,all the places I've always wanted to visit, all the foods and beers I'd like to try....But I can't because I ain't a rich dude.I got mouths that depend on me to feed them. So instead, I started visiting places on the internet, whenI first got online years ago. I got to see the world through others. It was not my own exactly, it was a shared eperience. That started me thinking. A lot.
I started seeing that I could REALLY learn, I mean about anything! So sweet! Then came the revelation that many, many others were doing the exact same thing I was. That this new venture, was much more compelling, dynamic and important than I first imagined. That this was a shared adventure, and that sealed the deal for me. I came to truly believe that even though it's like kicking against bricks much of the time, there were enough validparticipants, who shared enough mutal desire to make it worth while. Every once in a great while, I would even run into someone who was quite fantastic at delving into intricate thoughts and debates, some broke the mold and stood out above the others.Therewere and are, thosewho's righteousness of cause and reasoning were at times even heroic and inspiring! Seriously.
One of those guys went by the name of Judge, andI miss him.
That guy may have been into it for the entertainment value; but, at least he left us mere mortals with enough gristle to chew on, 'till we figured out how to get to the bone.
Yes'm - I would expect more from Robert.
No sir - Columbus did not do 70 million. Bartolome de las Casas testified that Columbus killed over 3 million in a two year period of time. However, the presence of Columbus in the Western Hemisphere led to the avalanche of thousands and millions of others and through their contact with the native peoples, the 70+ million death toll was attained.
Good response Larry - excellent.
Thank you Larry from the heart.
Hey your wife has been cheating on you!!!!! Well maybe not, but if it were true, you'd like to know, wouldn't you? LOL
Yep!!! Excellent...
I had a friend , someone I grew up and knew as a friend for over 30 years until he died from cancer about 10 years ago. He had an interesting story that he told from time to time about how his grandfather was an original partner and founder of professional football, but never became either rich or famous for it because the bastard George Halas screwed my friend's grandfather out of all his rights associated with the creation and ownership of the league. George Halas got rich and famous and the guy who helped him create pro football got nothing.
I have no idea whether my friend's story is true or not, but in the end it doesn't matter. George Halas won whatever confrontation or argument they may have had.
There are two parts to any historical grievance , the facts , and the long term results of the facts at the time. Some people celebrate "Columbus" because that era heralded the modern world. They rationalize the "progress" was worth it in the end.
They are neither right or wrong.
1st, that's 4,109 a day. The place must have been like NYC even back then, downtown that is.
That certainly puts Casas' reliability in doubt. Did he base the 2 million on the 1490 federal census?
Anything that then refers to "avalanche," or "results," years, decades, and even centuries (hello NT) later is farcical, and driven by fanatical hatred. Columbus, to the psycho-historians, is responsible for Indians who died of smallpox three hundred years later.
That is the kind of thing that makes intelligent people disappear before they suffer brain damage here.
Long Island's Indian Princess weighs in.
1st, you have assumed AND linked Columbus to the deaths of tens o fMILLIONS of Indians, here, and many times on NT. As have others. And that, along with other "facts" which aren't facts, have gone unchallenged, but for a few of us willing to put up with the taunts of the bigots and idiots here on NT, including those of the princess who runs the place.
Are you asking about evolution? Why do species adapt, change, and survive, while others do not?
Do you think humans are immune from the influences of nature?
That you ask, ya know, is a demonstration of how people believe they are.
If I recall, "Judge" was kicked out of Newsvine. Newsvine felt that it had to protect their members from people like him.
Here, "Judge" has been called a bigot and or racists about ten thousand times. What this place admires and encourages is simple-minded platitudes, and millimeter deep expressions of understanding and love, and rewards that kind of shallow, depthless contribution as the kind of membership it wants and needs. SO it is the same kind of place, protecting and promoting idiocy. And yes, I believe it is contaminated by the same kind of social promotion/networking, where the site management depands on that interaction to drive participation.
It works against facts, and against truth. I am not going further into it because I don't friggen care any more with regard to this site, which is a waste of time and energy. Suffice it to say the parameters/ rules promote the acceptance of group bigotry and group ignorance, and find that oppositional opinions, which also include something called .... knowledge and thought, are troublesome, divisive, and antithetical to .... SOCIAL ORDER.
Hopefully, there are a few people left who are intelligent enough to be deservedly insulted by that, and they leave the mind-corrupting influence of this site too.
Ya leaving?
Two of the more prolific current members of this site are XX Jefferson and Sixpick, individuals who regularly post content that "works against facts, and against truth". I don't recall you ever venting against their deleterious effect on this site.
I am not big on revisionism myself, or fantasy recollections of historical eras, which is why I am anti the support for the confederacy that is prevalent on this site and others at times. Could you agree that if 70 million natives did not die from the European advancement across the Americas, then "state's rights" was not the cause of the Civil War ?
Do you see the problem here Robert ?
Interesting. Do you find your mind being "corrupted" here at times Robert? Have you ever considered that what you call mind-corrupting influencemight actually be your mind or spirit attempting to grow beyond it's own traditional boundaries? That part of your job here as spoiler isn't just who you are, but also what is needed. Hey, if your running low on energy or concern, that I can understand. If on the other hand you just simply find yourself too good to be a part of us, then I'm sorry and offended at the same time. Either way, I do wish you the best in your endeavors, and many blessing to you and yours Robert.
States rights/70 million NAs....
WTF?
I don't know how many died, though that number is one of the estimates. States rights and the Civil War are about as related to those deaths as Columbus is related to anything that happened to Indians in the US over the 500 hundred years following his discoveries.
What I referred to in that "facts/truth" comment was about Larry's comment about the social aspect of this site, and of Newsvine.
THAT dynamic, which happens to be the one that made millions, meant and means that the Friending/ social interaction was/is more important than any discussion and than any topic. And, the laws provide and ensure that the discussion support peace and love, (social interaction and money)where the discussion really doesn't matter, to the sites button pushers.
The management of sites like this demand the peace of agreement. That's not a new concept. That's why "Islam is peace." That's how tribal societies work. That's how dictators work. They are not hassled, and their plans are not upset by those who disagree.
Opinions not supporting the majority view cause conflict.
But the social framework and the social model is not compatible with FREE AND OPEN DISCUSSION.
Never was, and never will be.
I can deal with any crap thrown at me, Larry, including the constant hassle of bigots who want their opinions to go unchallenged. But I can't deal with having my comments and articles deleted by retarded people.
So don't tell a person who has his head cut off to keep his chin up.
Lol. Do you understand who you are replying to ?
There are people who complain about me every day on this site.
The point about states rights and the Civil war is simple. It is a viewpoint of American history, just as is the one that the Europeans killed 70 million natives. People are allowed their viewpoint. "Facts" are used both ways. Eventually a consensus develops.
I don't see anything wrong with discussing the cruelty of Columbus on Columbus Day.
I do think there is perhaps more of a clique centered around "mutually repspecting" everyone's feelings on this site than some others of this type. I don't necessarily always like it, but that is the way it is. Short of transplanting in all new members it will probably remain something like that too.
Newsflash... there is no such thing as an indian princess Robert. I will not get into a useless debate with you, since you know apparently, everything. I just don't know how did god create the universe without your help.
As for me being a bigot, what the heck are you talking about? Who do I hate? I don't even hate you, and goodness knows, you have tried very hard to persuade me to.
Don't be so bitter. It is very unbecoming for someone with your intellect.
Good points John - and well said.