Fifty killed in a knife attack at a Chinese colliery - take away their guns???????
Nine suspects are being pursued after they launched a coordinated knife attack and killed 50 workers at a northwestern Chinese coal mine, reports Radio Free Asia .
The incident occurred on September 18 in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. The attackers are alleged to be Uyghur separatists.
After overtaking security guards, the attackers killed the workers while they were asleep in bunkhouses at the Sogan colliery in Aksu. Another 50 workers were injured. The suspects are believed to be hiding in a nearby mountain ravine where a manhunt operation is underway.
Most of the victims were Han Chinese.
The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region suffers from discord due to ethnic fault lines. Uyghurs identify more closely with Central Asian nations. The area was independent up to 1949 when it became part of China. China has been asserting is control over the area with more westward migration and a heavier military presence.
Information about the attack is being guarded by officials:
The damage of the attack was very severethat is why we are controlling [the flow of] information about the incident so strictly, lest we frighten Han migrants in Aksu, said the cadre, speaking on condition of anonymity.
Nine suspects are being pursued after they launched a coordinated knife attack and killed 50 workers at a northwestern Chinese coal mine, reports Radio Free Asia .
The incident occurred on September 18 in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. The attackers are alleged to be Uyghur separatists.
After overtaking security guards, the attackers killed the workers while they were asleep in bunkhouses at the Sogan colliery in Aksu. Another 50 workers were injured. The suspects are believed to be hiding in a nearby mountain ravine where a manhunt operation is underway.
Most of the victims were Han Chinese.
The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region suffers from discord due to ethnic fault lines. Uyghurs identify more closely with Central Asian nations. The area was independent up to 1949 when it became part of China. China has been asserting is control over the area with more westward migration and a heavier military presence.
Information about the attack is being guarded by officials:
The damage of the attack was very severethat is why we are controlling [the flow of] information about the incident so strictly, lest we frighten Han migrants in Aksu, said the cadre, speaking on condition of anonymity.
Nine suspects are being pursued after they launched a coordinated knife attack and killed 50 workers at a northwestern Chinese coal mine, reports Radio Free Asia. The incident occurred on September 18 in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region.
The attackers are alleged to be Uyghur separatists. After overtaking security guards, the attackers killed the workers while they were asleep in bunkhouses at the Sogan colliery in Aksu. Another 50 workers were injured. The suspects are believed to be hiding in a nearby mountain ravine where a manhunt operation is underway. Most of the victims were Han Chinese. The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region suffers from discord due to ethnic fault lines. Uyghurs identify more closely with Central Asian nations.
The area was independent up to 1949 when it became part of China. China has been asserting is control over the area with more westward migration and a heavier military presence. Information about the attack is being guarded by officials: The damage of the attack was very severethat is why we are controlling [the flow of] information about the incident so strictly, lest we frighten Han migrants in Aksu, said the cadre, speaking on condition of anonymity.

Muslims seem to use terror tactics often in many locations .
The Uyghurs / w i r / ( Uyghur : , ULY : Uyghur ; [10] [j] ; Old Turkic:
; [11] Chinese : ; pinyin : Wiwr z ) are a Turkic ethnic group living in Eastern and Central Asia . Today, Uyghurs live primarily in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region in China , where they are one of 55 officially recognized ethnic minorities .
An estimated 80% of Xinjiang's Uyghurs live in the southwestern portion of the region, the Tarim Basin . [12] Outside Xinjiang, the largest community of Uyghurs in China is in Taoyuan County , in south-central Hunan . [13] Outside of China, significant diasporic communities of Uyghurs exist in the Central Asian countries of Kazakhstan , Kyrgyzstan , and Uzbekistan , and in Turkey . [14] Smaller communities are found in Afghanistan , Pakistan , Germany , Belgium , the Netherlands , Norway , Sweden , Russia , Saudi Arabia , Canada , and the United States .
They practice Islam and are a physically diverse ethnic group ranging from Western Eurasian ( Europeans , Middle Eastern ) to a more mixed race and East Asian appearance.
It has less to do with religion, than ethnic differencesand invasion by China...Tibet anyone.
There have been a number of mass killing/attacks in China by knife since 2010.
Chinese citizens are not allowed to own guns, with exceptions for hunters.
Gun restriction laws too tough - can't have one, can't spell one, can't see one, can't shoot one, can't be allowed in the country.
Not much.
We can't trust those commies to release accurate records. We may never know how many are being slaughtered by chopstick violence.
Dean, he's Japanese....
But, the military/industrial complex is supplying China with ''made in America'' deadly chopsticks.
...
Sorrry 1st, couldn't resist.
Ya know, he looks like Bugger from the Nerds.
My bad.
If you had a knowledge of chopsticks you would know that Japanese chopsticks come to a point like those in the photo. Chinese chopsticks do not, so are much less deadly in the hands of "fressers".
The Muslims in China are extremely peaceful, friendly and live side-by-side with all other Chinese without incident. I often eat in Muslim restaurants and feel very comfortable there. However, the Uyghurs are violent and China has its hands full dealing with them. A few years ago there was a similar incident in a railway station in south-western China. These terrorists, if caught, will be treated by the Chinese government no different than terrorists world wide should be treated - a bullet in the back of the head within one month of trial.
I think you have a much better chance of survival against a person using a knife than one using a gun.
Appropriate way to deal with them - BUTT - in the luv-fest of the U. S., killing anyone for committing a crime of murder is just down right cruel. People who commit crimes are "mis-understood" by society.
Would that be a month before or a month after the trial?
In China that depends on when a recipient is ready for your organs.
What does nine assailants killing a bunch of people while they were sleeping have to do with gun control?
They couldn't defend themselves with guns. Do you think they slept through the whole thing? They don't even have pointy chopsticks to protect themselves with.
the dead, yes.
why didnt they defend themselves with knives by the way, if they were all awake? there seems to have been far more of the workers than the attackers.
Well John, some people (here and elsewhere) have said that banning guns will stop mass murders because people can't use knives to kill as effectively. Looks like this shows that they were full of crap.
Yeah, when the victims are sleeping.
I assume you said that to incite hatred, but I see nothing wrong with harvesting healthy organs for transplant from a convicted and executed murderer. Americans have no right to criticize a country that employs capital punishment. You're pretty good at it.
I'm sure that if the assailants were using guns there would have been a lot more dead.
China also lied about the killing prisoners for their organs for several years.
Please provide a link from a reputable medium.
The "logical" choice would be before it occurred.
And 50 additional were wounded while fighting off the "killers".
It's not that simple . If those who were attacked also had guns there might not have been so many of them killed .
On which side?
The assailed ...
But, the attackee's fought back and 50 additional were wounded.
Had guns been used it would have been more likely that more victims would be killed. Please don't think people are so naive to think that it's not easier to fight off and survive a knife attack than one using guns, that can also be used from a distance.
They lie just like I said - from your article.
Though Chinese officials had also said in 2007 that they would stop using organs from prisoners , China Daily reported in 2009 that 65 percent of the country's organ donations still came from convicts.
But that would imply that the user knew how to use their "gun". 'Course, with a .45, two feet can be quite a distance but it has one helluva impact.
Perhaps convicts who had been sentenced to death - with organs removed upon their death. Although China has recently reduced the number of crimes earning the death penalty, I'm sure they're probably more than any other country in the world. Lots of organs available from cadavers.
I don't think people here go to sleep armed with knives. Do you?
You are missing an important point . These people were attacked in their sleep . That is easy to do with knives . But with a single gunshot fired they would wake up and return fire .
Thanks for explaining what a colliery is, too!
The important point Petey is that the use of knives can also be the cause of mass murders - but, where is the outcry?
So can rolling pins, hammers, nail guns the point is that while NINE MEN WITH KNIVES killed 50 people, IT ONLY TAKES ONE MAN WITH AN ASSAULT RIFLE to do the same and that man can do it from a distance without making physical contact with his victims.
The relative danger of a firearm is exponentially more devastating because it can kill at significant distances, thus, the relative importance of background checks is correspondingly and exponentially greater.
Knives, rolling pins, hammers, Toyotas, etc. have useful functions in addition to being potentially lethal in the hands of the violent and crazy; guns have basically one function that is to put holes in and/or obliterate things.
Thank you for your scream and for showing that you do not appreciate nor have an appreciation for those folks who live, day to day, off of the food they legally kill with a weapon - be it firearm, knife, rolling pin, Datsun, Buick, crazy glue or whatever.
Each and every one of them, in the hands of the wrong person, can have a devastating effect on other things, including people's lives. That is the point of the thread - work with that - and quit shouting.
No one I know hunts with an assault rifle or a concealed handgun, 1st.
It is illegal in every state as far as I know to hunt and intentionally kill game or farm animals with a "knife, rolling pin, Datsun, Buick, crazy glue or whatever." The same reason there are laws regarding hunters, hunting, licenses and weaponry should apply across the board regarding firearms.
As for the "SCREAM," because some one arbitrarily decided one day that ALL CAPS on the internet equates with screaming and bad manners doesn't make it gospel truth. As a (retired) newspaper editor, I can attest that ALL CAPS,bold face type,italics,underlinedand other font types have been used for emphasis eternally in printed media.
But not each and every one is designed, intended nor sold for the sole purpose of destroying or killing. The point of the thread is to attempt to equate the killing efficacies of various objects including those utilitarian in purpose and to express equal outrage when any one is used to kill.
That's a logical fallacy IMO; guns-being-guns require different levels of regulation because of their range and power.
And why is it when you and I disagree, that style becomes an issue over substance?
I'll be happy to stay off of your articles if you so request; but whether ALL CAPS or all lower case, the content is what's paramount.
The article says the 50 dead people were murdered while they were SLEEPING. That fact is everything in this story.
It's certainly a factor, but it's not "everything in this story". The gun worshippers are using the story for justification - like their example of automobiles killilng people.
Personally, I would rather face an attacker who was armed with a knife, than one with a gun. Wouldn't you?
And neither are firearms. They are not intentionally built/designed for destroying. Protection of one's self and family is not destroying - nor, in the hands of an educated and responsible shooter, is it killing. It is a deterrent - and, if used properly, does the job quite well.
I have two black-powder pistols - a .32 Navy Colt and a .44 Army Colt, my Grand-dad's 1917 .45 Cal Army Colt Revolver, my Dad's 1942 M-1 WWII .30 Cal Carbine and my competition Browning High-power 9mm. Will all but the 1917, which I would never shoot, I can hit the bull's-eye a minimum 9 of 10 shots on paper targets - that's my desire. However, I also know that, if push comes to shove, I can and will defend my family/property if needed.
Destroying??? Paper targets. Killing someone??? - done that in 'Nam - the desire ain't there no more.
Working for the Feds, all caps means screaming, rudeness - regardless of the source/reason.
So is the fact that there are other means of conducting mass killings than with the use of a firearm - which is being missed by some.
Someone who is sleeping isn't facing anybody. That is the point.
But of course the death count will be lower in a knife attack, normally.
There were nine assailants - so comparing this to the usual 'one man with a gun'mass killing is not the same issue. Had there been nine assailants with guns there could have been considerably more victims. (apples-oranges)
Not missed by me I addressed that specifically. No one disputes the reality that there are many different methods and objects used to kill but mass killingsrequire either numerous perpetrators, victim-captivity/restraint or weapons of various levels of mass destruction. This is why explosives, incendiary devices and guns require more restrictive laws in terms of acquisition.
If we're going with the NRA "people kill people" then there must be laws to regulate the behaviors of such people -- that's just plain common sense.
the attackers killed the workers while they were asleep
Why in the world are we even discussing this?
The murdered people could not defend themselves, they were ASLEEP, therefore the "other means of conducting mass killings" is irrelevant here. If you shoot someone who is asleep or you slit the throat of someone who is asleep , they are asleep in both cases and not defending themselves.
How dense are some people ?
Maybe because they're not as noisy as guns the downside is that knives are less likely to kill numerous people in a matter of seconds from distances from which the intended victims are less likely to get themselves out of range.
This obsession with Chicago goes neither un-noticed nor without understanding as to likely motives. You want to reduce the GUN VIOLENCE in Chicago consider doing something about the illegal sources of the GUNS.
Clever idea, huh?
and you're not
And the other 50, who were awake and defended themselves, are considered as?????
If we're going with the NRA "people kill people" then there must be laws to regulate the behaviors of such people -- that's just plain common sense.
Concur.
Objection Counselor let us not get bogged down with reason-based arguments, factual references or common sense. What were you thinking?
Thinking is off the table in many of these similar discussions.
I'm being sarcastic for the record.
Had there been nine assailants with knives attacking fifty wide awake potential victims,might the outcome have been somewhat different unlike one assailant with an assault weapon?(apples-oranges/knives-guns)
Let me assist your understanding
The comment you mock with your straw-man comment included
Where did you read that another 50 were awake? The article indicated that another 50 were injured but who said they were awake? Please don't embellish the story - what are you trying to prove?
Sorry Buzz - using this thing called cause and effect - "After overtaking security guards, the attackers killed the workers while they were asleep in bunkhouses at the Sogan colliery in Aksu. Another 50 workers were injured." The only reason why they were just wounded would be because they defended themselves. The other 50 who died were still asleep, thus surprised and could not fight back.
Oh, come on, 1st. That's quite an assumption, so not the "only" reason. Therefore I disagree, and here is MY assumption, which I think is more logical than yours:
It's quite possible that the assailants did not do sufficient lethal damage to the injured ones to kill them. For the assailants to go through so many victims in a short time they just might not have been sufficiently effective in attacking all of the victims.
Wrong then, wrong now; I took no position via the posted image the image was accompanied by the question as to whether or not it was analogous to NRA rationale. You called "straw man" to duck the question and avoid giving the reason for your answer (which you never gave).
Your comment ascribed a conclusion to an individual who posited no such conclusion then you mocked him for doing so. That's the straw man we're talking about.
When you misrepresent something intentionally, or, for lack of understanding, or, for being unwilling or unable to respond in a viable way, someone needs to call it what it is.
Disagree vehemently with anything that requires disagreement, but don't do so by attacking the messenger.
The article asks a rhetorical question, namely, "why aren't people as outraged about a mass murder committed with knives as they are when a mass murder is committed with a gun?" I have answered that question specifically.
No one has questioned whether or not "murder-is-murder," rather, the question is "why the apparent difference in the degree of outrage?"
The weapon is in fact the matter.
As for "get over it" -- it's synonymous with the following and is usually a response given without considering the gravity of that which it addresses instead of a viable rebuttal we find instead
Excellent idea Mac. Since the weapons have been stolen and are sold by illegal street dealers (analogous to drug pushers), why not keep any of the dealers you catch incarcerated without bail until their life sentence is passed, and then make them serve the entire sentence without parole or good time. Removes the weapons from the street without violating the rights of a single honest person.
The above is a halfway method of solving the problem in a manner that is legal in our society. Some years ago, I heard about another, much more effective, method that was supposedly used against drug pushers in China (maybe Buzz can tell us if it actually happened that way). When a policeman caught a pusher red handed, he took the pusher to the curb, kicked him to his knees and put a bullet into the back of his head. Pretty soon, nobody was willing to take the risk of selling drugs.
Actually very close. The assailants did not attack fifty victims, they attacked one hundred and got a 50% ratio of killed to wounded (actually a better ratio than most soldiers achieve in combat). The sleeping victims would remain asleep only until the first one screamed. After that the assailants were dealing with victims that were awake. They still ended up with a 50% kill ratio. That means that each assailant killed or wounded 11 people, a very high number when it's considered that anything over four is considered a mass killing in this country, and most of the mass killers here haven't gotten that many. Obviously, the reason was because the attackers planned their attack. That's not unusual though, most mass killers (no matter how they are armed) plan their attacks. The plan is always aimed at taking the victims by surprise and using whatever force the attacker has available to the greatest advantage.
And, can you envision what would have occurred if the nine assailants had had firearms?? After the first "shot", EVERYONE would've been awake and all hell would've broken loose resulting in - unknown quantities dead (nine at least - 45 possibly (5 kills per assailant) or more plus the loss of how many assailants by armed "sleepers" who had taken the weapons from the assailants.
WOWOW - the potentials are enormous.
The story says the dead victims were sleeping. Throats slit , they may not have been able to scream.
There is a presumption inherent in the original post which is that even though mere knives were used, 50 people were still killed, suggesting that knives are as deadly as guns. The answer to that is YES, as long as the victims are SLEEPING. lol.
The fact that some people on this thread don't understand this is discouraging.
Buzz - I concur with the way TTGA explained in on the preceding page.
This appears to have been a well-coordinated attack and the fact that 50 individuals were killed outright is indicative of the speed and planning used in the attack. Some of the other 50 "may have been" light sleepers and were disturbed by the "unusual" activity. None of us will ever know as we weren't there nor do we have any first hand eye-witness accounts.
Has what to do with the thread Mr. Derailer?
Get back on track John.
Until there is a "perfect" solution -- which there will never be -- every illegally-purchased, unregistered gun taken out-of-circulation, and/or prevented from being circulated in the first place are potential saved lives.
In the same way a physician doesn't stop trying to cure any cancer because all cancers can't be cured whatever can be done to mitigate gun violence in the interim should be done.
Every life saved is a life. Anyone care to take issue with that?
I agree with that Buzz, but my thought is that - "Dead is dead - no matter how".
I just hope it's quick and I don't know it.
None that I know do.
Totally concur - and I like the method TTGA puts forth. That would work in a heart-beat - and, as he says, it's legal.
What's even worse John is that not ALL of the 50 killed were sleeping. The story says 50 were killed - not that they were all asleep.
As that line from the old Irish toast puts it;
1sr, "May you be in heaven half an hour before the devil knows you're dead".
I never heard of such a thing happening - of a police officer taking the law into his own hands and invoking capital punishment. I have seen them force street vendors to move if they were not licensed, but nothing more serious than that.
Aye and Begorra missy - may it be true
Oh, well. No one's mind has changed on the issue. Words words words. You are either for or against and there you will stay. Sorry, nothing new here.
Why don't you address Buzz's comment like I did , 1 W ?
Petey - response to Buzz - "
And, can you envision what would have occurred if the nine assailants had had firearms?? After the first "shot", EVERYONE would've been awake and all hell would've broken loose resulting in - unknown quantities dead (nine at least - 45 possibly (5 kills per assailant) or more plus the loss of how many assailants by armed "sleepers" who had taken the weapons from the assailants.
WOWOW - the potentials are enormous."
See also page 7 - well responded.
You should assume that the victims did not go to bed with guns under their pillows - in which case it would have been like a shooting gallery.
I'm feel quite safe and happy in a country where guns are not permitted except for police officers, army and armoured bank car staff. Actually, I don't even recall seeing a police officer with a gun - there must be special units, like SWAT teams. I note that someone here suggested that hunters are probably permitted to have guns.
If you are assuming guns are part of the picture you need to include them on both sides . In Uighur territory you can be assured everyone would have guns available if they were legal .
I agree with that, Petey, but then they're not legal. If the perps had guns I'm sure they would have used them.
Wuz under the impression that, in that part of the world, almost everyone has/had access to firearms and, of course, knives.
Now that you know that's incorrect, does it change your mind about anything you wrote?
No - people can just as readily get killed in mass quantities with knifes as they can with firearms or bombs. Wanton murder occurs where hate/distrust/fear lives.
1st has dug a hole no one could get out of.
The entire premise to this thread is faulty.
Based on what - your inability to read and comprehend? My "stance" throughout the thread is that there are other means of "mass murder" - but they're not addressed as vocally as GUNS. Interestingly, only the U. S. media produces so much garbage about the GUNS aspect - other countries discuss the mass murder and the why's - not the how's.
Your "stance" on this thread is ridiculous. THE REASON they were able to kill 50 people with knives is because they were sleeping.
This is one of the sillier threads on this forum in a long time.