╌>

Surfers Beat Billionaire in landmark California Beach Case

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  kavika  •  12 years ago  •  22 comments

Surfers Beat Billionaire in landmark California Beach Case

Surfers Beat Billionaire in Landmark California Beach Case

Surfer Joao Demacedo walks past a San Mateo County Sheriff's deputy along a private road to Martin's Beach, a popular surfing and fishing spot, in Half Moon Bay, Calif.
Time 18 hr ago By Katy Steinmetz of Time

The latest ruling in the ongoing battle over a northern California surf spot is a blow to venture capitalist Vinod Khosla.

A California court issued a milestone ruling Sept. 24 that may restore public access to a beach that requires traveling across privately owned land, the latest turn in a multi-year legal frenzy that has pitted the surfers who cross the property against the billionaire who owns it.

Judge Barbara Mallach of San Mateo Superior Court ruled against venture capitalist Vinod Khosla, a co-founder of Sun Microsystems, who was sued by the nonprofit Surfrider Foundation after his property manager blocked the public from accessing a beloved seaside spot known as Martins Beach.

At the center of the controversy is a low-slung metal gate that sits at the top of Martins Beach Road , an offshoot of the Pacific Coast Highway that is the only way to access Martins Beach from dry land. The road snakes across 53 acres that Khosla bought for $32.5 million in 2008. For two years, his property manager allowed the public to occasionally visit a stretch of sand where locals have gone smelt-fishing and surfing and picnicking for decades. But Khosla allowed the gate to be closed permanently in 2010 after his property manager received a letter from the county demanding that it stay open every day.

The conflict comes at a time when an influx of tech wealth has sharpened class tension in northern California . [Kholsa] believes that he can find a way to use his wealth and power to strong-arm the situation, says Chad Nelsen, environmental director of the Surfrider Foundation.

Khosla doesnt own a home on the land and says he has no plans to build one. The decision to shut off access to the road was a way to take a stand about what he felt were his basic rights. This is a case about private property, Khosla told TIME in an email. We need to assert our rights and get the courts to clarify them.

Khoslas lawyers say they are considering appealing the verdict. We will continue to seek protection of the constitutional rights of private property owners that are guaranteed by the U.S. and California Constitutions and that have long been upheld by the United States and California Supreme Courts, his attorneys said in a statement.

Surfriders argument rested on a seemingly bureaucratic detail. The organization claimed that under the 1976 Coastal Act, which gave a statewide Coastal Commission jurisdiction over beachfront land, Khosla needed to apply for a development permit in order to close the gate. The commission will often only grant development permits, typically to build a home or another structure, if the public gets an established right of way in return.

Because theyre in charge of beach development, theyre allowed to do this quid pro quo, says Arthur McEvoy, a professor at Southwestern Law School in Los Angeles. They can ask you in trade to dedicate a little easement, if the development threatens to impede public access.

The tricky matter is that while beaches are widely considered public, people dont necessarily have a right to cross private property to get there. Cases such as this one set precedents that resonate up and down Californias 840 miles of coastline.

Its easy to see why Martins Beach is beloved. Its sands wrap around a cove with cliffs jutting out on either end, creating a rare surfing spot protected from the wind and also preventing people from walking to the beach from the north or south. Secluded and full of wildlife, its dramatic rock formations are often blanketed by birds. Seals pop their heads up between surfers and the beach.

For decades, cars that wound their way down the road from Highway 1 paid a small fee to the landowners for parking and frequented a snack shop that has fallen into disrepair. A now-defunct sign advertising $15 parking, the amount Khoslas employees charged when visitors were allowed, still lays on the ground.

Steve Baugher, Khoslas property manager, testified at the trial that it was his decision to close the gate. He also testified that he hired security guards to deter trespassers; their presence prompted five surfers to defiantly march past them last October to proclaim their right to be on the beach. Known as the Martins 5 the surfers were arrested by the county sheriff but the District Attorney declined to prosecuteinspiring more surfers to take advantage of this legal limbo and hop the fence with abandon.

In California, public access to the beach is protected by the public trust doctrine, a common law that can be traced back to the English crown proclaiming rights to all submerged lands, in order to let the public use the water above them for fishing and navigation.

Our culture abhors private beaches, and generally speaking our law abhors private beaches as well, McEvoy said. And any landowner is going to want to keep people away from their beach.

In an earlier case that went Khoslas way, a group called the Friends of Martins Beach used a different angle to sue, testing a clause in the state constitution that declares that no entity shall exclude the right of way to such water whenever it is required for any public purpose. In a 2013 ruling, another San Mateo Superior Court judge said that because Martins Beach had been part of a land grant that settled the Mexican-American war in 1848, a year before the constitution was adopted, the intentions of that document were immaterial.

Beyond the ongoing court cases, two other avenues may force the drama to a close. One is a bill sponsored by State Senator Jerry Hill, a San Mateo Democrat, that would require the State Lands Commission to consider purchasing the road if negotiations with Khosla for public access fail. Meanwhile, the Coastal Commission, which has been fielding the publics complaints about the closure of Martins Beach, is asking people to write in about how theyve used the area in the past. That testimony may prove theres a historic right of access that Attorney General Kamala Harris can sue to restore on the Commissions behalf. The Commission is trying very hard to bring it to a close, says Nancy Cave, a commission manager who was part of negotiations with Khoslas team that went nowhere. We are frustrated, too.

Khosla notes that he is not the first owner of the property to limit access, pointing out that previous owners closed the gate during certain hours and seasons and even inconvenient days. In court, property manager Baugher testified that he received a letter from the county demanding that the gates be open year round and parking be charged at the rate of $2, what beachgoers paid in 1973. Khosla has also accused Surfrider and the Coastal Commission of attempting to blackmail and coerce him, charges both deny. Surfrider emphasizes that Khosla has allowed changes that are far from what his predecessors didlike painting over a billboard that used to welcome people to come down from Highway 1 to the beach, turning it into a dark green slab.

Surfrider had hoped that the court would also fine Khosla for failing to apply for a permit but Mallach declined, saying that those who closed the gate had acted in good faith that they had the legal right to do so. Nonetheless, Surfrider championed the decision as a huge victory.

Todays court decision upholding the Coastal Act is an important victory for Martins Beach and ultimately strengthens the publics right to beach access in California, Angela Howe, Surfriders legal director, said in a statement. The Surfrider Foundation remains vigilant to protect beach access rights, not only in this case, but also in other cases where the beach is wrongfully cut off from the public.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

The People1, Money 0.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I remember reading about this and am happy with the way it turned out.Smile.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

The Coastal Zone Management Act requires public access - you'd think SunMicro folks would know that since they have so dammmmm many gvnmt contracts.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

There are a number of streams in the Pocono Mountains that cannot be accessed by the public because parts of the land through which they flow, are privately owned and posted.

The land owners did not create those streams (unlike so-called "man-made lakes/ponds" which require engineering and private funding). Further, in almost every case, at some point(s) along those streams, the Pennsylvania State Boat and Fish Commission stocks them with trout, that effort primarily paid for by those of us who purchase Pennsylvania fishing licenses.

In some cases, these private lands are rented/leased by fishing clubs which charge membership fees and which have exclusive memberships.

Given the morons who litter, poach and generally prove, that despite the anatomical ratios, there are way more assholes than buttocks in the world, I understand wanting to restrict access to natural areas; but, that deprives the law-abiding citizen.

My two cents.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Since there are all kinds of wildlife there, perhaps the billionaire could donate it to the state for a wildlife preserve? (hahahahaha) At any rate, how can someone buy public land, (or public strips of land), and prevent the public from using it? If he wants it to be private, about all he could do is give it to a wildlife trust to manage.

I guess he thought that his hunga gunga attorneys could muscle their way through this. Nope!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

This is round one with this guy. From the article he is going to fight the decision.

Hope that he looses again.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

One of the things that is going to go against him is that he used to allow access from Highway 101 and then, out of the blue, he cut everyone off. The court is going to see that as capricious and aggressive behavior on his part. He's going to lose again. The fact that he has no plans to develop the area - put a home on it - further weakens his argument. He could just as easily have tickled everyone pink by putting in a designated trail.

He should be required to hire his own security firm. Using and expecting the Sheriff's Office to patrol his land is disgraceful and, as flame says, a waste of tax dollars. The S.O. should not be providing private security services to the wealthy. There's something really wrong with that idea. The S.O. should send him the bill, I'm sure he would pay up in a flash.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

What kind of sheriff would send his men for this? Shouldn't they be out catching real criminals or something? I would think the sheriff would be in trouble for this, too...

What a creep!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"Since there are all kinds of wildlife there, perhaps the billionaire could donate it to the state for a wildlife preserve?"

A wildlife preserve? You mean so the government can charge people for coming there and forbid the use of cameras?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I have been following this story and I was rooting for the surfers.

On Long Island all beaches are public and you can't close down access to them. So while you may build a home near the shore line and enjoy the views, you can't prevent others from using that shoreline. And we have about 230 miles of shoreline.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

Vinod Khosla??? Sounds like one of the bounty hunters working for Jabba the Hutt.

"Vinod Khosla, meet Boba Fett..."

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

He's from New Delhi.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

I just noticed something interesting about the photo. That Sheriff's Officer looks like he's saying "Alright, man, you are one cool surfin' dude" rather than "get your ass outta here."

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

hehehehe, da bra be a piker dude.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

LMAO...bounty hunters working for Jabba the Hutt..classic.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

bro ?

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

"Whoa, totally gnarly, dude-- be sure to piss on the gate on your way thru...

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

I no speaka da surfer.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

surfers don't use bro, it's bra Grump...Translation, the guy is a surfer from the Pike area. hehehehe, remember, I was the ''Surfin Indian''..Well known in ''Surf City'', Huntington Beach.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

I'd swear I saw him in the Cantina scene at Mos Eisley spaceport, Grump...

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

California Governor Signs Law to Force Billionaire to Restore Beach Access

California Gov. Jerry Brown has signed legislation to force Silicon Valley billionaire Vinod Khosla to allow public access through his property to a contested beach south of San Francisco. The venture capitalist and green energy investor bought the 53-acre property south of Half Moon Bay in 2008 and erected a gate across the road , preventing beachgoers and surfers from reaching popular Martins Beach. The standoff has become a lightning rod in the battle over beach access, spawning legislation and litigation.

Earlier this year, Brown signed legislation allowing the state Coastal Commission to levy large fines against homeowners who block shore access. Then San Mateo Superior Court Judge Barbara Mallach ruled against Khosla last week in a lawsuit aimed at forcing him to reopen the road, saying he must either allow access or get a state permit to permanently close it. Khosla has not reopened the road. Legislation signed by Brown on Tuesday specifically targets Khosla and requires the state Lands Commission to negotiate with him for a year to try to resolve the issue. If no agreement is reached, the Coastal Commission would acquire all or a part of Khoslas property by eminent domain to ensure access. An attorney for Khosla did not immediately return a call from NBC News seeking comment on the new law or the litigation.

```````````````````````````````````````````````````````

Now it's official. Khosla looses and it's now the law that he allow access. hee hee hee.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

"We" already own it.

 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot
shona1


55 visitors