╌>

image of Mohammed on U.S. Supreme Court-- should Muslims be offended?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  12 years ago  •  60 comments

image of Mohammed on U.S. Supreme Court-- should Muslims be offended?

qjnx3d6

What is this?

The answer may surprise you:

The North Frieze on the Supreme Court building in Washington, DC features a bas-relief sculpture of Mohammed, among several other historical law-givers. He is in the center of this image holding a curved scimitar; on the left is Charlemagne, and on the right is Byzantine Emperor Justinian. You can download a detailed pdf of the Supreme Court friezes here .

The urban legend site (Snopes.com) has info about the frieze in this entry . A slightly less clear photo of Mohammed in the frieze can be found here , as part of this article which gives some background on the sculpture.

Is it offensive to Muslims? Should it be removed?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Why? Is it your intent to be offensive?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Is it your intent to be offensive?

Yes-- occasionally. I do it to stimulate discussion.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"It's my intent question litmus testing group membership in order to avoid dissent in a country which prides itself on free speech and public discourse."

I recently wrote an article about my opinion that there are too many unused and abandoned groups on NT, being a reason that they are not being used but rather people like to post on the front page. I thought the list should be pruned. How would you like to serve on a committee to go through groups that have been dormant for 6 or 12 months, have administrators who have left NT so they are rudderless, etc.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Does that mean it's to discuss the benefits/detriments/limitations of free speech, or is more like the Heated Discussions group which allows virtually any kind of shit to be flung around, including personal attacks and insults?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Dissent is okay, but surely there are SOME limitations to free speech. Your SCOTUS has determined this. In Canada the offence of hate speech in the Human Rights legislation was overturned because it was a limitation on freedom of expression. However, it still exists in the Canadian Criminal Code, and led to a Nazi anti-Semite (Ernst Zundel) to be deported from Canada to his native Germany where he was promptly put in jail. There is also a more recent example of it. I doubt that absolute free speech exists anywhere, including the USA, but this is probably a topic for your new group.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Then what is the solution to the 'no consequences' problem or should there be one? It is rare indeed that whoever is in control of a web site like Facebook, Twitter, etc will remove a posting or cancel a membership. Sites like Newsvine and NT have a lot more control, but isn't it free speech to provide instructions to build a home-made bomb (thinking of the Boston Marathon bombs)? Again, sorry, maybe all of these things would be better discussed on your new group where more people could be involved in the discussion.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I don't know how Muslims feel about depictions of Mohammed. I was thinking the title meant Mohammed Ali... We have a nice statue of him in our court park/square.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Permalink Reply by flameaway 11 hours ago

It's on the building where the Supreme court meets and who cares whether it's offensive to Muslims -- unless they are US citizens? In which case, I'd imagine they support the idea vigorously.

Well-- your "imagination" has once again mislead you-- perhaps you'd be better off posting actual facts in your comments-- rather than trying to pass off some of the bizarre phantasies in your depraved imagination as facts?

Re: your bizarre comment that they "support the idea vigourously-- here's the truth:

Muslim Groups Object To Frieze That Shows Muhammad's Face

Offended by a depiction of the Prophet Muhammad etched in marble inside the U.S. Supreme Court chamber, a coalition of Muslim organizations is quietly pushing to have the artwork sandblasted into propriety

A petition signed by 16 groups across the country has asked that the larger-than-life frieze of great lawgivers be altered "in the spirit of religious tolerance and pluralism," because Islamic tradition discourages artistic renderings of people, and showing the face of Muhammad is considered particularly offensive.

At present, the Supreme Court sculpture is the coalition's only target. According to Ibrahim Hooper of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, one of the petition signatories, the coalition is unaware of any other public representations of the prophet in such a prominent location.

The coalition also has said that the curved sword in the prophet's right hand "reflects long-held stereotypes of Muslims as intolerant conquerors. "If maybe they can sandblast out the face," said Awad, "we suggested they could replace it with a piece of marble with maybe a verse from the Koran or a saying of the prophet pertaining to justice and law.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Is it offensive to Muslims? Should it be removed?

I think it is a big problem that this question keeps being asked. Why is it we never hear "will it offend Jews" Or "will it offend Christians"? Or will it offend ANY other religion for that matter.

BTW, If everything that is offensive to Muslims was removed there would be nothing left but Sharia law, stones, and AK47's.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Interesting piece at the Snopes link .

Seems that this symbolism on the SCOTUS physical structure, is a display of the ideals our judicial system strives for. If someone misses the point of that, and is offended by that, then screw 'em.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Well if you look at history I am not so sure about that. They have been killing each other for centuries.....I suppose one would be left.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Interesting Awad - since no one has ever seen a picture of Mohammed, and no one has the foggiest idea what he looked like - other than ME'rn, who the hell can complain when they have no comparison??

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Just some things that don't offend Muslims:

Forced marriages

Honor killings

Female Genital Mutilation

Beheadings

Stoning of adulterers

Executing gays and apostates

Women covered from head to toe

Barbaric halal slaugthter of livestock

etc., etc., etc.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

I stand corrected.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Although I believe that Halal and Kosher slaughter of livestock properly carried out is as humane as any other slaughter of livestock, I would add to your list the destruction of world heritage works of cultural and historic importance such as the 1000 year old Buddhas by the Taliban.

Now it's the frieze in the SCOTUS building. They were successful in silencing Hirsi at Brandeis University so now they flex their muscles and make further demands, what's going to be next? The Statue of Liberty? DaVinci's Last Supper? The ceiling of the Sistine Chapel? Mount Rushmore? (although I can think of a lot of people who would agree with that last suggestion, considering the faces that REALLY belong there):

Although I know that Flame will say that their demands are a valid exercise of free speech, acquiescence to their demands, such as their success at Brandeis University, but it is the crack in the dyke - How soon we forget the legend of the Little Dutch Boy who inserted his finger to stop the leak. Had he not done so...

"The physical lesson is also taught: a small trickle of water soon becomes a stream and the stream a torrent and the torrent a flood sweeping all before it..."

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I think the problem here, Flame, is that you speak American, but I speak English:

"British Dictionary definitions for dyke
dyke
/dak/
noun
1.
an embankment constructed to prevent flooding, keep out the sea, etc
2.
a ditch or watercourse
3.
a bank made of earth excavated for and placed alongside a ditch"

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Don't put your hand in the box.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

Hey, let's just change the sculpture... wouldn't want to offend anyone:

3406_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I believe we have a freedom to assemble, as well. Thus the private groups
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Yes, they shouldn't be offended. It's not a religious depiction in this context. It's a series of historical figures reputed to have been lawgivers. These fringe groups do not have the right or the wisdom to dictate propriety to the majority. I suggest they avert their eyes when they visit.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Note the depiction was not religious art. It was historical. M was a poltical leader (and conquerer) as well, and it is that context which is depicted.
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

That's a good point, Cerenkov.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"What you do with your freedom matters more than the fact that you have it in the first place."

I'm not so sure about that. Freedom is an absolute that's basic and IMO a necessity. As for what you do with it is a matter of individual choice within the ambit of it.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

But he is not being depicted in a negative way, but honoured by the company he is in and the location where he is - is this not an example of the tail wagging the dog? I think the separation of church and state are necessary (although they don't) but surely only when it interferes with freedom. This is America, not The Islamic State. It is harmless, a mere matter of context. just as I thought having a depiction of the ten commandments in front of a court house was harmless - it too was an original example of what was considered basic law. I do not feel I have the right to complain when a Christmas tree is erected in the White House.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

It was their suggestion to obliterate the face, but is that the Koran he is holding? If so, is that on a par with the ten commandments?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
It's not "their" history; it's "ours." And my history includes this conqueror. I'm pretty sure Christians didn't like government funding of "piss Christ," but it was not destroyed. Angry Muslems need to grow up.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I concur. Perpetual outrage is tedious.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I say replace it with one of the Danish cartoons. ..
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

How a Mohammad Statue Ended up at the Supreme Court

Miscellaneous Mohammed Images

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Good thing we now have copies of those images, before they get obliterated by the fanatical fundamentalists, or their lackey PC-devotees, or pandering governments.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Now that I look at that obliterated image a little more closely, I noticed the little slit at the top. It makes the head look like the head of a penis. I wonder if that were intentional.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

It's been said that 'the Devil is in the details'...

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Thanks, Flameaway. I try...
 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Who really cares? As long as the Muslim pedophile isn't a member of OUR SCOTUS, and as long as Sharia law is not the law of this land, who cares if Muslims are offended? At best, they should be honored that some jackass thought enough of that bastard to put him in the frieze to begin with.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Maybe you should put an "s/" after some things that you say.3.gif

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I agree with the first part of your reply; I don't care who is offended. I am often offended by stupid crap but somehow manage ro get over it.You should expect the government to protect your rights. You should not expect them to shield you from bad thoughts...
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

If that is so, then why does the government document describing the frieze indicate that it is Muhammad?

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

If that is so, then why does the government document describing the frieze indicate that it is Muhammad?

Could it be simply more pandering by this Administration to the sensitivities of the Muslim world. Four years ago the head of NASA said the following:

"When I became the NASA administrator , (President Obama) charged me with three things," Bolden said in the interview which aired last week. "One, he wanted me to help re-inspire children to want to get into science and math; he wanted me to expand our international relationships; and third, and perhaps foremost, he wanted me to find a way to reach out to the Muslim world and engage much more with dominantly Muslim nations to help them feel good about their historic contribution to science, math and engineering."

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

If those symbols are on our government building they should be preserved as a message concerning how easy it is for church and state to become intermingled.

A good way to look at it.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"...their historic contribution to science, math and engineering."

Seriously?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

If that is so, then why does the government document describing the frieze indicate that it is Muhammad?

Because it is a depiction of Mohammed.

And I believe images of mohammed may be on other court buildings in the U.S. as well.

Why?

Because courthouses sometimes have images of famous "lawgivers" throughout history.

This one is indeed Mohammed-- in fact the Council on American-Islamic relations (a Muslim group) wanted to have the image removed by sand-blasting for that reason.

The Supreme Court refused:

In 1997, the Council on American-Islamic Relations demanded that part of a 1930s frieze in the main chamber of the U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. be sandblasted into oblivion, on the grounds that Islam prohibits representations of its prophet. The seven-foot high marble relief by Adolph Weinman depicts Muhammad as one of 18 historic lawgivers.

Official court information points out that "The figure above is a well-intentioned attempt by the sculptor, Adolph Weinman, to honor Muhammad and it bears no resemblance to Muhammad. Muslims generally have a strong aversion to sculptured or pictured representations of their Prophet."

Chief Justice William Rehnquist, however, rejected CAIR's pressure, finding that the depiction "was intended only to recognize [Muhammad] as an important figure in the history of law; it is not intended as a form of idol worship." Rehnquist only conceded that court literature should mention that the representation offends Muslim sensibilities. His decision met with riots and injuries in India.

LINK

________________________________

And, BTW, as usual, CAIR attempts to perpetrate yet another falsehood:

on the grounds that Islam prohibits representations of its prophet.

Some extremist sects believe that but Islam does not prohibit images of Mohammed-- but that is not part of the islamic religion.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Incidentally, islam does not say that women should wear some of those "potato sacks" or other bizarre coverings-- that's also an interpretation by extremists crazies-- & their propaganda is perpetrated by politically correct "Useful Idiots" in the western media;).

H%C3%B6fu%C3%B0b%C3%BAna%C3%B0ur-b%C3%BArkur-niqab.jpg?width=400

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

3407_discussions.jpg

Which one is your wife, Mohammed?

Why they all are, of course.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Al-Jebr is quite important in the field of mathematics... (algebra). Not to mention the foundation to calculus.

Also a lot of the building blocks for geometry of spheres and trigonometry as a branch of mathematics is from the Persians.

One source

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Who really cares? As long as the Muslim pedophile isn't a member of OUR SCOTUS, and as long as Sharia law is not the law of this land, who cares if Muslims are offended?

Some lawmakers in New York cared:

Perhaps the longest-running if least noticed depiction of Muhammad in New York City was an 8-foot-tall statue on the roof of the State Appellate Division courthouse on Madison Square. The building was erected at the turn of the 20th century, back in the days when graft got you some architecture.

Muhammad was one of 10 lawgivers among them Moses, Confucius, Justinian and Alfred the Great along with other allegorical figures like Peace, Wisdom, Justice and the four seasons, for a total of 21 statues adorning the building.

His identity came to public light after more than 50 uneventful years when the Department of Public Works announced a $1.2 million project to repair the statues, clean the building and put up a five-story addition.

Ambassadors from Indonesia, Pakistan and Egypt went to the State Department to ask that the statue be destroyed rather then renovated. The justices in the court agreed.

So in 1955, Muhammad, who had a turban, a book, a scimitar and rather Old Testament-looking beard, lost his prominent place atop the courthouse's southwest corner. Everybody else was moved one spot to the left, leaving empty the pedestal that once held Justinian. Muhammad was lowered by block and tackle, wrapped in excelsior and trucked off to a stone company in Newark.

LINK

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I always got a big laugh out of that photo.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Why do you think we have so many prisons full so constantly. Because the government is weeding out the rebellious blood; teaching compliance.

Nope. Its because of private prisons-- a huge industry. And a powerful lobbying group (Read more ).

REPORT: Banking on Bondage: Private Prisons and Mass Incarceration
(2011 Report): The imprisonment of human beings at record levels is both a moral failure and an economic oneespecially at a time when more and more Americans are struggling to make ends meet and when state governments confront enormous fiscal crises. This report finds, however, that mass incarceration provides a gigantic windfall for one special interest groupthe private prison industryeven as current incarceration levels harm the country as a whole. Read the Report

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Permalink Reply by flameaway on Saturday

I'm sure that matters to you; but if there is an Islamic proscription against displaying images of their prophet then the matter does become religious in nature.

Nope. Wrong yet again!

There is no Islamic proscription against portraying Mohammed. Rather, i ts a belief amongst some extremist sects.

But why are so eager about dancing to the tune if the extremists? Hmmmm...

-- but why cater to extremists?)

The fact is, that prohibition is not mentioned in the Koran . Not even once.

Oh-- and BTW-- just like most other religions, Muslims have been making pictures of people they revere for centuries:

siyer-i-nebi-beheading.jpg This is a miniature from Siyer-i Nebi , a Turkish religious biography of Mohammed completed in 1388 and later lavishly illustrated with 814 miniatures under the reign of Ottoman ruler Murad III, being completed in 1595. Many of the miniatures depict Mohammed, and this particular one shows Ali bin Abu Taleb beheading Nasr bin al-Hareth in the presence of Mohammed and his companions.

0_01.jpg

Illustration showing Mohammed (on the right) preaching his final sermon to his earliest converts, on Mount Ararat near Mecca; taken from a medieval-era manuscript of the astronomical treatise The Remaining Signs of Past Centuries by the Persian scholar al-Biruni ; currently housed in the collection of the Bibliotheque Nationale, Paris ( Manuscrits Arabe 1489 fol. 5v ). This scene was popular among medieval Islamic artists, and several nearly identical versions of this drawing (such as this one [shown in detail below] and this one ) were made in the Middle Ages.

Algerian_postcard.jpg Mohammed's Flight from Mecca in 622 AD; Algerian color postcard from the 1920s or '30s. Mohammed is the figure entering the cave. The original postcard is in a private collection.

037ad92b99ea2eaddda48129333655cc.jpg

Mohammed solves a dispute over lifting the black stone into position at the Kaaba. The legends tell how, when Mohammed was still a young man, the Kaaba was being rebuilt and a dispute arose between the various clans in Mecca over who had the right rededicate the black stone. (The Kaaba was at that time still a polytheistic shrine, this being many years before Islam was founded.) Mohammed resolved the argument by placing the stone on a cloth and having members of each clan lift the cloth together, raising the black stone into place cooperatively. Miniature illustration on vellum from the book Jami' al-Tawarikh (literally " Compendium of Chronicles " but often referred to as The Universal History or History of the World ), by Rashid al-Din, published in Tabriz, Persia, 1307 A.D. Now in the collection of the Edinburgh University Library, Scotland.

hb_1974.294.2.jpg The Night Journey of Muhammad on His Steed, Buraq; leaf from a copy of the Bustan of Sacdi , dated 1514. From Bukhara, Uzbekistan. In The Metropolitan Museum of Art .

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"What? Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses? Bah, humbug."

Well, okay, there are lots of them, too many in fact - as Krishna explains.
Flame, your freedom of mind in prison was freedom within limits that were set without your consent. If you are talking about imagination and dreams, well, okay, we all are the same in that no matter where we are although some have more imagination than others. I have not read Weisel's book. I've not had much time to read many books until recently and it's taking me time to catch up.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

What was in biblical times does not happen today or if so it is very rare - only seen among fringe cults as you have pointed out - but forced marriages of Muslim children to adults is not so uncommon today. Have you read the book "I Am Nujood, Age 10 and Divorced"? It is not at all valid to make the comparison you did.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Finally don't the Muslims protesting this have the right to protest it?

Well, they could, and so could the Westboro Baptists likewise have the right to protest what they wish as well, right? Freedom of speech and expression, n'est ce pas?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

The mind is its own place and in itself, can make a Heaven of Hell, a Hell of Heaven.

--John Milton, Paradise Lost

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Then life imitates art as I have pointed out so many times. Think of Brooks (James Whitmore) in the movie The Shawshank Redemption. After most of his life in prison, he couldn't handle real freedom. As "Red" (Morgan Freeman) pointed out - After many years people become institutionalized.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"What a great movie. One of my favourites."

Mine too, I never tire of watching it. Andy (Tim Robbins) was unjustly put there, and he had to survive incarceration and all the negative aspects of it, but he kept trying to assert freedom for himself and others (the beer on the roof, playing the opera throughout the prison, stubbornly developing a library, teaching a kid to get his high school diploma, etc.) but he didn't achieve REAL freedom until he escaped - so well personified by the scene of him in the rain in the river standing with his arms extended. It's hard not to see that his freedom had been curtailed, but he fought to maintain his freedom of mind as best he could throughout adversity.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

After most of his life in prison, he couldn't handle real freedom. As "Red" (Morgan Freeman) pointed out - After many years people become institutionalized.

I think there's something in the human psyche (well, most humans) that fears freedom-- even among people who aren't incarcerated by prison walls.

Among other places, its often seen in very abusive relationships. Snd life under a truly totalitarian gov't also means you have less freedom to makes choices-- which means you don't have to make as many choices. Some people actually prefer living under totalitarianism-- some people could find freedom by leaving an abusive relation but don't.

i think the reason is simply a sort of laziness-- due to a misconception. The reason they fear freedom is it means taking responsibility for one's own life. And that means making choices, and taking care of oneself.

Where there is little or no freedom, in some ways life is very unpleasant. But for some people its better-- you don't have to make choices. The abuser (be it an abusive spouse or the government, etc.) does it for you.

Many people fear freedom-- it terrifies them.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

It's not "their" history; it's "ours." And my history includes this conqueror. I'm pretty sure Christians didn't like government funding of "piss Christ," but it was not destroyed. Angry Muslems need to grow up.

And they weren't violent.

But when the "Mohammed Cartoons" were published, angry Muslims got violent-- resulting in the deaths of over 140 people!

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
And we're using our identical freedoms to tell them to shove off.
 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot
shona1


55 visitors