╌>

U.S. general says cannot rule out larger ground role in Iraq

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  12 years ago  •  23 comments

U.S. general says cannot rule out larger ground role in Iraq

s2_reutersmedia_net.jpg (Reuters) - The most senior U.S. military officer raised the possibility on Tuesday that U.S. troops might need to take on a larger ground role as they fend off Islamic State militants in Iraq, but the White House stressed there would be no combat mission for U.S. ground forces.

General Martin Dempsey, chairman of the U.S. military's Joint Chiefs of Staff, said there was no intention of placing American military advisers on the ground for direct combat. The U.S. plan relies on other contributions, including air strikes.

Still, he told a Senate hearing: "I've mentioned, though, that if I found that circumstance evolving, that I would, of course, change my recommendation." - Source

*******************************

Mark my words; this will be an all-out effort by the Obama cartel for eventual troops on the ground. Backed by the corporate controlled media, the banks, the military industrial complex and oil interests, Obama will set the stage for perpetual war against an enemy that poses no threat to the US and benefits only the 1%.

tCljPtG.jpg


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

You have a good point, but let me ask you a sincere question Aeon. 1) Is the U.S,and 2) the West, under a generation long threat from radical Islam, 3) which wants to perpetrate large scale terrorist attacks against us in a "war of civilizations", or not?

4) If we are, to whatever extent you may perceive, 5) what should be done about it? 6) Do we withdraw all our attention and apprehension about radical, violent, jihad to within our own shores?

1) The US is not under any immediate or long term threat from the ISIS. They are only a threat to US corporate interests in that region. I for one am against spending anymore American blood to maintain corporate profitability.

2) It is a threat to Europe and the Middle East, not so much militarily but as a destabilizer.

3) Fear mongering.

4) From hindsight, we never should have invaded Iraq, which ended up facilitating this kind of violent, militaristic behavior.

5) What we should do is stop being mercenaries for Europe, Saudi Arabia/Gulf states and Israel and let them sacrifice their own children and spend their own money to stop them. We should try any and all avenues to achieve a peaceful solutionwhich the US has refused to do.

6) As they are not likely to be landing on the shores of the US nor gathering the resources to start a Fifth Column within the US, such talk is again, fear mongering.

Additional reading;

China Should Send Troops to Fight ISIS

China Unlikely to Join Obama's Anti-ISIS Coalition: Report

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

I did not say the US "do nothing." What I am saying is that if we do something, it should not involve American ground troops in actual combat.

The US invaded Afghanistan, haphazardly I might add. Did that stop the Taliban? No. It only further infuriated the Muslim convictions that the US and the West are their enemy.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Our return to Iraq will draw tens of thousands of insurgents to the region.

I have said it many times in the past, we are using out military as "bait". Best to draw out and kill the insurgents on their soil than to have to hunt them on ours.

As to why our military is there in the first place..... again, follow the money.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

In a very sickening way, yes they helped preserve American freedoms and liberties. I don't like it any more than you do.

Bottom line of this is that you have two choices, to fight them over here, or fight them over there. Choosing not to fight them is not realistic at all given the profit that will be made by those that decide to send our kids off to war, and the companies that they hold stock in.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The leader of Iraq seems to feel he doesn't want foreign troops (Americans) on the ground in Iraq. Rather, he wants them next door fighting the current Islamic radicals in Syria before they get to his country.

It's the old "of-course-we-need-a-landfill-project-but-not-in-OUR-backyard" syndrome.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Iraq would not be unstable if we had not toppled Saddam. In toppling Saddam, we ignored the advice of every country in the region (except Israel) who warned that it could lead to regional instability. We also supported a rebel attempt to topple Assad in Syria but we didn't adequately arm the rebels (not that I support toppling Assad). Others in the region warned that, if the Syrian war dragged on, it could become a regional sectarian fight between Sunni and Shia. It has. Now we're stupidly on both sides of a regional sectarian war: supporting the Sunni in Syria and the Shia government in Iraq. We have the gall to do as we see fit in creating a mess and then wonder why those who cautioned against our actions are slow to put their lives on the line to fix it.

ISIL has usurped the Sunni revolt in both Syria and Iraq. It is gathering enormous wealth from captured oil facilities and looting. It threatens the stability of countries from Egypt to Turkey with teh prospect of turning the entire area into a terrorist training camp. We are eventual targets of an organization far more powerful than al-Qaeda. Obviously, the ISIL army poses no military threat to us but it will have the resources to project terrorism beyond anything al-Qaeda could ever dream of doing. Whether we want a fight or not, the fight will come to us. FlyNavy is right. Fight them over there before they get over here.

This fight cannot be won by air power alone. The Kurds are simply not strong enough to take the place of an Iraqi military and the Syrian rebels cannot fight a two front war by fighting Assad/Iran/Hezbollah while simultaneously fighting ISIL. The Syrian rebels are probably not stupid enough to get themselves killed in a crossfire so they may ultimately reconcile with ISIL in order to fight Assad. The Saudis look like their commitment extends only to training the Syrian rebels which makes sense since their goal all along has been to topple Assad (ISIL suits them just fine as long as they purify Islam by eliminating the Shia).

The only military reliable enough to take care of this situation quickly is our own. We let the genie out of the bottle. We should be the ones to stuff him back in as best we can. Do it now before this mess gets worse.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

We let the genie out of the bottle. We should be the ones to stuff him back in as best we can. Do it now before this mess gets worse.

Not with our blood we don't.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"Not with our blood we don't."Everybody can say that and ISIL will grow. But I guess it would be easier to wait until they are an army of 300,000 and after they have trained operatives to blow up our trains, bridges, subways, malls etc. We must seem odd to others. We destroy Iraq when it posed no threat to us and do next to nothing against those who swear to kill us in any way they can.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

I am not at all concerned what "everybody" thinks. I am not a weak willed creature that like a lamprey, attaches itself to the fickle fate of popular opinions.

These special trained operatives you speak up sound like agents straight out of a James Bond movie. Besides that, you seem to have little faith in homeland security and the NSA; two rat holes we've poured literally hundreds of billions of dollars down....not to mention the FBI, CIA, Coast Guard and Customs; all which are supposed to protect us.

When the ISIS has a fleet of ships poised to invade the US...maybe then I'll worry but most likely will end up waking from an alcohol induced nightmare.

The ISIS does not present a "clear and present danger" to this country, only to corporate assets and profits in that region, that being Oil.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Please point out where I am wrong. I stated; the ISIS does not present a "clear and present danger" to this country...

I have no idea where you are coming from with this "clash of civilizations". That sounds ambiguously archaic.

We can avoid it by staying out of it.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

No we are not going to be able to avoid it...

We have too many high visibility people like Lindsey Graham screaming their livers out for action. We have too many pseudo-Christian leaders calling for the eradication of Islam. And lastly, we have too many people not looking at the facts of the matter, and willing to go along with what the talking heads are selling.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago
  • I am not a defeatist.
  • I am not prone to throw my hands up in the air and say whats the use?
  • I do not lack the guts to stand up against imposing opposition.
  • Nor am I cowered by the rich and powerful.

An avalanche starts with one rolling pebble and many wars are won by unseen feints and piercing thrusts. The immoral/ inhuman use of sons and daughters to fight wars we have no business in, wars that protect corporate assets and insure our bought and paid for politicians cushy six figure jobs when they leave, that battle starts now.

I am realist and am grimly aware of who the enemy is and it's not the ISIS.

You are either part of the problem or part of the solution. Giving up is not an option, at least for me.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

AP

There are simply not enough voices, nor enough time to convert enough voices that are going to be heard. The real battle is with our elected officials. A conversion there is going to take at least another generation if it is going to happen at all.

This military action in the ME is all but done. That is being realistic. I'm not saying to stop trying, but jeopardizing your sanity trying to hold back a river is a waste considering the number of battles you and your voice can make a real difference in.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"I am not at all concerned what "everybody" thinks. I am not a weak willed creature that like a lamprey, attaches itself to the fickle fate of popular opinions . . .""Everybody" was a reference to other countries not what other people think. In any event, Al-Qaeda has already proven that we can be attacked without a fleet of ships and despite all the alphabets we employ to protect us. Corporate interests are irrelevant to ISIL and they will come after us whether we go after them or not. And unlike al-Qaeda, ISIL will have tremendous oil resources to fund its plans. The threat is obvious. Bush wanted to fight (in Iraq) without good reason and Obama has good reason but will not fight (to win). The problem is not fighting but knowing when and where to do it.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"And that's why we went into Iraq the first place and it's still the same reason we're going back. International corporations with no loyalty to the United States, (same with the bulk of the GOP leadership)want us to"Saddam did not threaten oil markets or international corporate interests. He threatened Israel by paying the families of suicide bombers. Bush was stupid enough to be stampeded into war based on manipulated intelligence of a nuclear threat and a false connection to al-Qaeda. We were stupid to go into Iraq when it posed no threat to us and we're being stupid not to go back when the threat to us is clear.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

FLYNAVY,

I disagree. Realism is a perspective. To quote the Spanish philosopher Ramn de Campoamor;

  • En este mundo cruel nada es verdad ni es mentira, todo es segun del color del cristal con que se mira" - in this cruel world nothing is truth or lie, everything depends of what colour is the glass you're looking through.

You as a military man should know the dangers of a defeatist mentality amongst the troops and especially with its commanders. Would Corregidor have ended any differently had Patton been in charge instead of Wainwright?

What of the cost of surrender? A slow painful death as prisoners or to make the ultimate sacrifice for something you believe in?

When it comes to reality of a political system ripe with criminality, does one see the situation as hopeless or a situation whereby the odds are against you?

Reality of history tells me nothing is hopeless which is why we need a leader but perhaps more of a hero, to lift the shroud dullard complacency and ignorance from the American people.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

The United States could not physically reinforce or resupply Corregidor.

Neither could the Spartans at Thermopylae but you're completely missing the point here.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Corporate interests are irrelevant to ISIL

The ISIS Monstrosity, What The US Corporate, Military, Industrial, Media Complex Is Not Telling You

Obamas ISIS War: Profit for Military Contractors

Records show how Iraqi extremists withstood U.S. anti-terror efforts

Obama has good reason

Could you enlighten me as to this "good reason?" The only people I see promoting this "good reason" are puppets of the corporate interests, party zealots and their assorted "chickenhawks.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"Could you enlighten me as to this "good reason?" The only people I see promoting this "good reason" are puppets of the corporate interests, party zealots and their assorted "chickenhawks."In my opinion, you're confusing the interests of others with the intersts of ISIL. Obviously, some corporations profit from war and obviously the Gulf states are funding ISIL for their own reasons. ISIL doesn't give a flying f*ck why others give them money or who profits from them because ISIL has its own intersts and it's using others as much as others think they're using them.ISIL is a dangerous group of fanatics that not only want to replace western values with Islamic values, they also want to purify Islam. This is beyond a clash of cultures and they have no reservation about achieving their goals by any means available. They currently endanger the stability of three countries and intend to spread from Egypt to Turkey. In doing so, they are seizing oil facilities and acquiring the financial resources to build a conventional army as well as fund terrorism on a global scale. If al-Qaeda could reach us, then so can ISIL and that remains true despite the FBI, CIA or any other alphabets we use as defense.In this case, the best defense against these sociopaths is a good offense. Just wipe them out. And do it whether or not anybody helps us and regardless of who profits from it. Obama is not waiting on others to deal with Ebola and doesn't care that some company will profit from either making medicine to treat the illness or proving supplies to handle the sick. If left unchecked, Ebola will eventually threaten us so we need to handle it sooner rather than later. Same philosophy applies here.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"But, we are in a clash of civilizations spanning decades. This is one battle in a long war. We should fight this battle, but on our terms. No ground troops."The clash of civilizations is the natural result of globalization. I'm not in a fight against Islam nor am I trying impose western values on them. ISIL, however, is trying to turn back time to a golden age of Islam. They see us as the enemy. They have collected into a conventional army. We cannot eliminate them from the air. The ground troops from others are either unavailable or inadequate. This war is on ISIL's terms, not ours. If we're going to fight, then fight to win.
 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

AP..... Not being defeatist. You have to apply small force tactics.

Politics, battle, same, same. You have to concentrate your forces, and strike effectively first against a superior force. A small force that tries to go toe to toe with a superior force will be destroyed. Pick the time, place and the issue. Call it political gorilla warfare, or death through a thousand cuts. You will get what you are after, but you have to be patient and smarter than your foe. From your discussions on NT, and NV, I know you to be both.

Have a really good Friday too please.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

1) In my opinion, you're confusing the interests of others with the interests of ISIL. 2) Obviously, some corporations profit from war and obviously the Gulf states are funding ISIL for their own reasons. ISIL doesn't give a flying f*ck why others give them money or who profits from them because ISIL has its own intersts and it's using others as much as others think they're using them.

2) ISIL is a dangerous group of fanatics that not only want to replace western values with Islamic values, they also want to purify Islam. 4) This is beyond a clash of cultures and they have no reservation about achieving their goals by any means available. 5) They currently endanger the stability of three countries and intend to spread from Egypt to Turkey. In doing so, they are seizing oil facilities and acquiring the financial resources to build a conventional army as well as fund terrorism on a global scale. 6) If al-Qaeda could reach us, then so can ISIL and that remains true despite the FBI, CIA or any other alphabets we use as defense.

7) In this case, the best defense against these sociopaths is a good offense. Just wipe them out. 8) And do it whether or not anybody helps us and regardless of who profits from it. Obama is not waiting on others to deal with Ebola and doesn't care that some company will profit from either making medicine to treat the illness or proving supplies to handle the sick. If left unchecked, Ebola will eventually threaten us so we need to handle it sooner rather than later. Same philosophy applies here.

*************************

1) I dont think so.

2) I think youre a little confused here. Nowhere have I stated or implied that the US corporate interests and banks are supporting the ISIS, through I would not doubt if they were. The fact that US weapons are falling into their hands is the fault of our stupid government. The corporations are interested in perpetual war which means continual profits

3) There are a lot of dangerous and oppressive groups and governments in the world that represent a far greater threat to US sovereignty.

4) A clash of cultures? Whats that? To me it looks like a clash of extreme religious ideologies against Western corporate interests.

5) So its a regional conflict. Let Europe, Saudi Arabia, the Gulf States and Israel handle it.

6) IF.IF a comet hit the world this would not be a problem. They rest of that sentence is faulty logical conjecture that contains no proof. Other than that, I have yet to see anyone offer one iota of any credible evidence that states the US in any threat of the ISIS.that may change if they hijack a couple of Princess cruse liners to invade the US.

7) Again, a regional concern.

8) The Liberian assignment is a humanitarian effort. Troops are there to protect humans (in this case US medical personnel), not to wage an offensive war.

 
 

Who is online

shona1
JohnRussell


75 visitors