The moment America finally made its peace with Iran and rewrote the rules of its political relationship with Israel came suddenly, even to those who have been urging both upheavals for the longest.
Inside the Washington headquarters of J-Street a liberal Jewish American lobby group that has countered Israeli government critics by campaigning vociferously for the Iranian nuclear deal news that enough US senators now supported it too flashed across an almost empty office.
Though the walls of the headquarters are lined with painstaking whip counts of where members of Congress stand on issues related to Israel, voting on the controversial deal to contain Irans nuclear programme was not due to begin until Congress returns after Labor Day, and, like much of Washington, several of J-Streets top officials were still away travelling when an announcement from Maryland Democrat Barbara Mikulski dramatically ensured there were enough votes for the White House to withstand any motion of disapproval and allow the international deal to proceed.
Whether there is also enough Democratic support to prevent Republicans passing even a symbolic vote against the deal remains to be seen in the coming days, but White House loyalists believe the one third of US senators now committed to helping Barack Obama veto this threat already represents a huge victory over those who sought to split his party over Iran .
Mikulskis support for the agreement means that Obama now has enough votes in the Senate to uphold his veto if Congress rejects the deal . If the administration continues to amass votes, and obtains 41, it could even stop congressional Republicans rejecting it in the first place.
There was a substantial effort from the moment this deal was announced to kill it in Congress, says J-Street political director Dylan Williams. Tens of millions of dollars some people have estimated upwards of a hundred million dollars were used to fund ads and lobbying.
At the heart of this unprecedented effort against the deal is J-Streets rival Washington lobby group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac), which promised to oppose the deal with the entirety of [its] institutional resources and has hitherto counted on strong support from both Democrats and Republicans.
Both lobby groups describe themselves equally as pro-Israel, but the flurry of previously hawkish Democratic senators who switched sides away from Aipac in recent days has led to growing speculation that the days of reliable bipartisan support for the Israeli government - as distinct from Israel as a whole - on Capitol Hill may be over.
Constantly throughout these battles, Democrats in Congress were being asked to put aside their realist, pro-diplomacy worldview to back increasingly rightwing Israeli policy, argues J-Streets Williams. The numbers on the Iran fight show the extent to which Democrats understand that Aipac and other right-leaning groups are not speaking for the majority of their Jewish constituents who support the administrations worldview. Not only has this fight resulted in a series of losses for Aipac, this fight has revealed the Aipac tiger to be a paper one.
Not surprisingly, Aipacs supporters strongly reject the argument that its influence has now peaked in Washington, at least among Democrats.
Importantly, they point out that simply achieving enough votes to sustain a veto over Congress is far from a ringing endorsement of Obamas policy and point to opinion polls suggesting significant suspicion of the deal among the wider US electorate.
This is hardly the first battle that Aipac has lost, but remember the definition of losing here is [having] a majority of both houses of Congress, a majority of the American people and members of both parties [against the deal], which is a strange definition of losing: mathematically, this was a crush on the side of the sceptics, says Omri Ceren, managing director for press and strategy at the Israel Project .
Aipac, which focuses on lobbying politicians rather than the media, declined a request for comment on what this might mean for the broader US-Israel relationship but directed enquires at Ceren, whose group describes itself as a non-partisan American educational organization dedicated to informing the media and public conversation about Israel and the Middle East.
The public debate has been so one-sided that even the president is talking about squeaking through Congress, he said. Now, that is not a mandate to reshape American foreign policy. You dont squeak through Congress on a deal that will remake American foreign policy; this is not a highway bill.
Other critics of the deal also urge caution in reading too much into Obamas reaching the 34 senators necessary for the president to withstand a veto override arguing that it will be more important whether his opponents can assemble the 60 votes necessary to force him to use his veto in the first place.
Its definitely an important moment but I dont think anyone who followed this carefully ever believed there would be the 67 votes against the deal needed to override a veto, says Noah Pollak, executive director of the Emergency Committee for Israel .
The real issue has always been, and remains, getting to 60. There will be huge symbolic significance if the president actually has to veto the bill and it will show how unpopular the deal really is.
On Capitol Hill, the verdict is also mixed. Some bristle at the suggestion they are beholden to lobby groups at all, despite the huge sums of campaign finance raised by pro-Israel groups on both sides of the Iranian question.
Members of Congress make their own decisions or weigh their own decisions very seriously in matters of war and peace like this, says one Senate Democratic aide. I dont think its fair to say that if a member of Congress opposes the deal, that a lobbying group got to him or her and if they support the deal the lobbying group failed to get to him or her. I dont believe thats true.
Nonetheless, there is anger at the extent to which critics of the deal, particularly on the right, have portrayed its supporters as anti-Israel or even in favour of Iranian-sponsored terrorism.
The Democrats who have come out and supported the deal are making a case for it with facts and with science, added the aide. Opponents of the deal use spin and fiery rhetoric that simply isnt supported by the facts. I think thats the most striking difference between the announcements.
Others agree that the ultimate reason the deal will now go through is simply that its negotiators succeeded in making the case that it represents the best practical chance of preventing Iran from developing a nuclear weapon.
The presidents influence was greater [than that of Aipac and the anti-deal forces] and that was through the merit of the arguments that he made substantively, and his political teams effectiveness in making sure that no major political argument against the deal ever really got traction, says another Senate Democratic aide.
It felt like a lot of stuff being thrown at the wall but nothing sticking politically or substantively [for the opponents] and thats due to the fact that the administration did a really effective job at defending this deal and making Democrats feel that this is something they should be proud to support.
Tellingly, this view is echoed by some rightwing critics of the deal too, who complain that for once Aipac was not aggressive enough in countering pressure from the White House.
Nevertheless, support among those Democrats who have swapped sides and come out for the deal in recent days has, at times, appeared lukewarm.
The support is very soft; Democrats are not loud and proud for it, argues Pollak of the Emergency Committee for Israel. The progressive base of the party passionately supports it, but among more mainstream Democrats they are not wild about this.
But if this is true, it perhaps suggests even more strongly that what has changed is that the fear of retribution no longer provides a deterrent for moderate Democrats tempted to resist the influence of Aipac.
Sometimes resistance to the deal went into the realm of express threats of a political nature; fund raisers were cancelled after members of Congress came out in some cases [for the deal], claims J-Streets Williams.
Yet once you take a stand and not only survive to fight another day but do so with even more pro-Israel backing than you started out with, that has the affect of vanquishing this finely-crafted myth that there is a terrible political price to pay by going against Israeli government policy.
All sides agree that it is too early to tell whether this more plural notion of what pro-Israeli politics looks like in Washington will stick, but if it does, one of the biggest unwritten rules of American political life may have just been torn up.

Constantly throughout these battles, Democrats in Congress were being asked to put aside their realist, pro-diplomacy worldview to back increasingly rightwing Israeli policy, argues J-Streets Williams. The numbers on the Iran fight show the extent to which Democrats understand that Aipac and other right-leaning groups are not speaking for the majority of their Jewish constituents who support the administrations worldview. Not only has this fight resulted in a series of losses for Aipac, this fight has revealed the Aipac tiger to be a paper one.
All sides agree that it is too early to tell whether this more plural notion of what pro-Israeli politics looks like in Washington will stick, but if it does, one of the biggest unwritten rules of American political life may have just been torn up.
These two paragraph's on the administration's well thought out plans say it all. Aipac is a paper tiger now and no longer can control how, at least Democrats, vote. The threat of retaliation from them is gone. They are no longer feared by anyone in Washington D.C. They were fighting a losing battle because the administration had the science, facts and figures on their side to effectively counter all arguments, which were much more about emotion and pleading, then providing any real evidence to fight against the plan.
The benefit from this is the quashing of the anti-Semitic complaint that AIPAC and/or Israel control the US government.
Oh if only that were true. That would be a good thing.
Complaining about a lobbying group that just happens to be lobbying for Israeli government is not anti-Semitic in any way, shape or form. It's just complaining about one of the thousand of lobbying groups trying to influence our government's decisions. In this case this lobbing group lost. As Vonnegut said "And so it goes."
If anything I think it says much, much more about the correctness and power of the deal that the 6 nations were able to craft with Iran.
Dear Friend Randy: This is a very complicated matter.
Much more to it than seems on the surface.
It isn't a good deal for Israel, those pro-Israeli, or for stability ion the middle east. When Saudi Arabia and Israel are in lock step opposing it, that is an unusual coalition. But telling.
The honest answer is that we just don't and cannot yet know if this will work. It is probably the best deal that could be had.
If it doesn't work out, there may not be much recourse.
All that said, I reluctantly support it.
I am not convincedthis is a death knell for American-Israeli relations.
It is probable that the US will do thing to insure Israel will be able to have the upper hand against Iran is necessary. Such adeterrent will help prevent an area war which could erupt and spill over into other areas of the globe. I do not see such a war forthcoming. All sides know the only way to win a conflict like this is not to engage in it.
It is also, it seems to me premature to start paying condolence calls to AIPAC. One lost battle isn't the same as losing a whole war. As a combat hardened veteran of the U.S. Department of Defense and J,C, Penny President's Day white sales I know form first hand experienceyou don't have win everyskirmish to be around to fight another day.
Wouldn't it be nice to live in a world wherewar wouldn't be necessary? Until that happens, the forces of morality must be stronger than thepurveyors of evil. Dealing from a position of strength prevents more conflict than it engenders. Not always (ISIL), but often enough.
Enoch.
Dear Enoch,
I am not thrilled with the deal either. However I believe any alternative would be much worse.
Your analogy of AIPAC is right on point and well explained. Much better then I did. I certainly don't believe the are dead as an organization in any manner. I do believe that, on this issue, they have been weakened. However that is on this issue only.
What I really resent however, is this nearly constant implication that I get from some people (never from you) that to be against an Israeli government position or to disagree with AIPAC is somehow translated into a person being anti-Semitic, which is simply not true. That being in favor of this agreement passing means the same. Not agreeing with everything Israel does (and I don't) is not being anti-Semitic. It is not agreeing with the government of Israel and it says nothing negative about the Jewish people themselves, in Israel, here in the US or anywhere in the world. It only causes division when people conflate the two and it happens far too often here and in the real world. IMHO.
Thanks for your wise words. You have always been respectful to me and I hope you know I feel the same way towards you.
Randy
Dear Friend Randy: There is no daylight between us on all these matters.
We enjoy a relationship of fellowship, mutual respect warmth and humanity.
In this case, since we cannot know how this will pan out, I see insufficient reason not to try it.
Fareed Zakaria poses the question will Iran act more like China or like North Korea in terms of abiding by a treaty agreement? Its a good question. He is a wise person. Only future events will disclose how this plays out.
Peace, Abundant Blessings and Profound Gratitude for All You Do Here and Elsewhere in Life.
E.
Singling out AIPAC or Israel as being in control of the US Government, such as producing cartoons showing Netanyahu holding the strings of an Obama puppet, which is very different than indicating that a lobby has great influence, is IMO anti-Semitic, just as singling out Israel as being the worst world's human rights abuser or most apartheid state in the world is anti-Semitic. This event has established that those who have singled out Israel and AIPAC as being in control of the US government are wrong, and that is the point I made. Hearing again and again that some of us are overstating that any criticism of Israel is unfair just makes me think about them that: "The lady doth protest too much."
Why am I not surprised that your conversation partner had nothing to add about Fareed Zakaria ?!
Agreed.
But some people are a$$holes (especially it would seem some people active in online discussion forums). You can't change that-- so why let it bother you?
However, while it i s true that not everyone who criticizes Israeli policy is not a bigot-- many are. And many play up the fact that some critics of the deal were Jews-- some even obsess about it.
So much so that even President Obama felt it necessary to comment on this:
However, while it is true that not everyone who criticizes Israeli policy is not a bigot-- many are.
Far too often true. In fact I think it happens often enough to where any criticizer of Israeli politics brings about a near automatic "You hate Jews" knee-jerk reaction. I don't worry about it and write it off as just ignorance and even, in some cases, bigotry also. They seem to confuse a disgust with Bibi (which I feel) with a disgust of all Jewish people and the entire nation of Israel in particular, which is absurd and makes the accusers look small minded.
Fareed Zakaria poses the question will Iran act more like China or like North Korea in terms of abiding by a treaty agreement? Its a good question. He is a wise person. Only future events will disclose how this plays out.
Peace, Abundant Blessings and Profound Gratitude for All You Do Here and Elsewhere in Life.
I agree and the same wishes and blessings to you also.
Randy
Agreed?
But then you equivocate? So be clear or just capitulate to the critics. The capitulation of Americans is no longer a surprise to me.