Hillary Clinton speaks out on Israel/Gaza; media coverage
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 12 years ago • 115 commentsLove her or hate her, IMO its important to listen to what she says as she may well be elected our next President:
I asked her about the intense international focus on Gaza, she was quick to identify anti-Semitism as an important motivating factor in criticism of Israel.
It is striking that you have more than 170,000 people dead in Syria.
You have Russia massing battalionsRussia, that actually annexed and is occupying part of a UN member-stateand I fear that it will do even more to prevent the incremental success of the Ukrainian government to take back its own territory, other than Crimea. More than 1,000 people have been killed in Ukraine on both sides, not counting the [Malaysia Airlines] plane, and yet we do see this enormous international reaction against Israel, and Israels right to defend itself, and the way Israel has to defend itself. This reaction is uncalled for and unfair.
She went on, You cant ever discount anti-Semitism, especially with whats going on in Europe today. There are more demonstrations against Israel by an exponential amount than there are against Russia seizing part of Ukraine and shooting down a civilian airliner.
So theres something else at work here than what you see on TV.
Clinton also blamed Hamas for stage-managing the conflict. What you see is largely what Hamas invites and permits Western journalists to report on from Gaza.
( READ IT ALL )

A clear condemnation and separation of herself from the current administration foreign policy approach
I think I will actually.
I was in her corner in 2008 as the McCain/Palin ticket had no appeal and I really thought she could bridge the ideological divide into a modicum of progress by working with the opposition and encouraging the same of democrats and republicans alike in the Congress.
And the First Gentleman of course would be readily available for consultation and project work as needed.
John
No shit?
Are you sure?
McCain and anyone was not very appealing to me, I was still pro-Hillary even after she lost the Democratic bid for the reasons stated above - thinking she had a better chance to bring the country (the government) together and move it forward.
Maybe not as easy now, but still think she has a better chance than President Obama and anyone from the Republicans that has surfaced so far
flameaway
I gotta agree that the Clinton years were the best we have seen in recent decades when one looks at the good and the bad that occurred
Never as confused as you
Lets see if Hillary becomes Mrs. President then that makes Bill the first lady? Just what America needs is the Clintons is the White House.
She's an incredibly smart woman. I disagree with many of her stands on issues as she leans too far left, but given that, she's still one smart cookie and a very good political operator. I thought (and still do) feel she has far more credentials for the job than the current occupant.
John-great contribution to the discussion. One the smartestand most insightful comments you've posted in a week or two.
End the occupation!
The onus is on the Palestinian people to end their current predicament. They elected a terrorist organization to rule them. They must undo that. They are an armed territory. They must undo that. They want to foster economic growth, but have pledged to hate the one country that is in the best position to help them. They haven't paid their electric bill in over a year, but Israel is supposed to leave the lights on for people that have pledged to commit genocide against them.
End terrorist rule!
There is no way to respond to this post, other than to let you know that when you make those comparisons, you are placing yourself in a position that people will at best take you less than seriously, and at worst question your motive for supporting the Palestinians.
In your opinion, it is.
It was in response to a one sided description.
Anything to contribute, or just being an assboil?
flameaway-- have you ever wondered-- maybe Hillary might actually be a Jew herself...???
The media spokesman for Netanyahu tried to slip that one in yesterday too
This was a stipulation dating to the first round of negotiations, which Israel had discussed in the public forum prior to that first round.
1)Were you aware of the first round?
2)Were you aware of the stipulation at that time?
3)Do you understand why you suffer from a credibility deficit on this topic of discussion?
End israeli rule! End Zionism!
The comparison stands and people can make of it what they will.
Israel is a fascist colonial enterprise
Not according to the UN. According to the UN, they are a recognized member-nation of the world.
Again, you have invoked a comparison between Israel and South Africa. By making this comparison, you will at best be taken less than seriously, and at worst, have your motive in this debate questioned.
BTW, would you mind defining "fascist" for me?
Being a fascist colonial enterprise and a recognized state within the UN are not mutually exclusive.
Then I suggest you expend your energy picking on the other ones, because THEY are the ones that will affect your world in a far more adverse way.
I know you disagree, but Israel holds the moral high ground on many of these issues. Russia, Syria, Iraq, ISIS?
Not so much...
If this weren't so sad I'd be laughing.
"No one forced Israel to use military hardware".
Wow, flame. Just wow.
I don't recall anyone forcing Hamas to lob thousands of rockets at Israel.
And what about the unmitigated gall to proclaim that they'll continue to lob rockets if their concessions aren't met?
Are you fucking kidding me?
Yes-- she wants to clearly separate herself from the "stupid stuff" of the Obama Administration's foreign policy:
Who died in greater numbers during WWII-- German Civilians killed by Americans-- or American civilians killed by Germans?
Flame ,
comment removed for CoC violation (AM) Petey, that's one of the ugliest comments I've ever seen!
It's gone.
How many children has Hamas killed? How many has israel killed? Israel targets the civilian population with artillery, guided missles, and jets in addition to collectively punishing everyone in Gaza. Hitler did the same. The comparison stands. And no matter who they elected, Israel would still occupy them as evidenced by the continued occupation of the West Bank.
Flame is the king of Moral Relativism.
Look it up!
Obama could not shine Palin's shoes wrt either experience, smarts or competence. You just bought into the msm and snlsmears as they did Obama's work for him.
The Clintons and Obama have one thing in common -- the smoothness at deception -- the skill at shell games and three-card Monte. That is why we get what we deserve -- good politicians who stink up their job.
36 % think Obama is competent and he has validated that degree of confidence.
Hey, I was once a shoeshine boy. An honorable job, it certainlybeats food stamps.
The "cowardly" Hamas live in those neighborhoods and fight where they live because they are under siege. Perhaps the "brave" Israelis would like to better demonstrate their courage without hiding behind tanks, jet aircraft, guided missiles, artillery batteries, iron dome, and a wall. Or they could just end the damn occupation.
Aww, c'mon man.
You don't think we can kill children with a pillow?
Made your day, huh...
Hamas has every right to get their asses kicked by Israel, and they shall.
muslims killed by muslims.
Do you forget that that occupied land is a result of defensive wars, or just choose not to consider that? We should just push back against supposed Zionist colonialism, to reinstate what was lost during two world wars, to Ottoman colonialism, is that it? What a farce. Israeli citizens have more rights that every single other countries citizens in the region, yet they are the fascists, or as you suggest, an apartheid state. Ridiculous BS that most Americans see right through. Support for Israeloriginates from thewill of the American people, not politicians, so it must be that Americans are fools in your book. So be it; knowing the difference between right and wrong does often look foolish to those with an opposing agenda to push. Your's and other'ssupport of hamas doesn't elevate hamas' position in the minds of Americans, it merely makes you a terrorist sympathizer.
Made your day, huh..."
No fair hitting kids under 5 years old.
Yeah your right, hamas has their citizen's children's blood all over them, that comes from using them as shields.
Forget swords, clubs, nerf bats or pillows. How about 12 Israeli fighters vs 12 Hamas fighters meet in no-holds barred old fashioned hand-to-hand combat? The side that loses must give up the disputed lands and their respective populations emigrate at least 500 miles away.
I know who I'd be betting on:
1 of many low-information Arab advocates:
Lie.
It was created by the UN.
What a post!!!
What a cogent collection/presentation of factual data!!
This is a keeper.
The Syrians die in much greater numbers in the Middle East - - by far:
That's at least over 110,000 total fatalities, over 6,500 children alone!!!
Don't believe me? Here's the LINK
End the missiles in Gaza . They are offensive weapons .
Israel is not launching missiles on Gaza ... but the reverse is happening . Apparently your one-sidedness makes you desperate to pin stuff on Israel . As biased as that is , it is even more biased to ignore the violence initiated by Hamas .
I guess that explains why Hamas attacks Egypt at times . But I don't hear you making the same hyperbolic accusations against Egypt . Egyptians don't like being kidnapped for ransome either ...
By that logic then, hamas is using children as human shields, in their resistance. That sounds sooooo much better.
Non-existence is not the same as death ...
AM ,
No one asked for your personal commentary . You are talking as if I threatened a member with death . I didn't . Please remove your play-by-play analysis .
Gazans have not been "driven off their land " . Egypt used to occupy Gaza but then they pawned it off on Israel . On the way out of the conference room they could be heard to mutter "Suckers ."
You're killin' me with your one liners ! You should do the comedy circuit with lines like that ...
Better idea . Give Gaza back to Egypt . Let them suffer with that disaster again . BTW I love the way you dodged my point about your obsessive focus on Israel . Egypt is apparently blameless [in your view ] .
Thank you Mr. Broken Record ...
Related topic :
If you include "death by cop " quite a few .
Perhaps you would be happy to see Israel overrun by Arab armies from neighboring countries . But they would never try such a thing ... right ?
Prologue - I will not be voting for Hillary Clinton as she is as two faced as the rest of the Republicrat party. Nothing she says makes any difference.
1) If I were a nihilist and had no regard for human life, I would nuke the entire middle east as shown below. Problem solved. However, I have have too much respect for human life to do that.
2) The Palestinians have been used as dupes by the rest of the Arab world, especially Saudi Arabia, for the the last 80 years. Despite this, they continue on the same course which has caused them nothing but death,pain and suffering. They could live in peace but have deliberately chosen not to. Because of that, I have no sympathy anymore for their plight.
3) I have no love for the Jewish state of Israel BUT regardless of the arguments for or against its conception, they exist as a sovereign nation and have every right to defend themselves against aggression. If their enemy chooses to launch its aggression from civilian populated areas with their complicity, Israel has every right to neutralize such attacks by any and all conventional means.
4) Lastly....most important...funding. A war going on this long is making some people very, very wealthy.
A chink in the armor.
Why ya gotta be racist?
I never assumed you to be racist. Especially where the Asian community is concerned.
I was just going for the tickle
AP,
Interesting, well thought out assessment. I would add a little here and there, but then again, it would no longer be yours.
John,
The Palestinians DO have a claim on part of the land. They DO have the right to self determination. They DO NOT have the right to dictate the terms, as they have attempted to do so in the last 13 years. Israel is the established nation. They have the right to get a better deal than the Palestinians. They have the right to deal from their position as the stronger party, but the world has convinced the Palestinians that they are actually dealing from strength. This has morphed into their belief that they have the right to resist this "occupation" with violence.
AP's point #2 drives that home. They started out as a pawn in the Arab game. They have come a long distance, but have allowed extreme elements to continue to advise them on the wisest course.
They need to ACT like a movement that deserves to be a nation. Yes, deserve.
"If the Arabs on the land do what we say for an indeterminate length of time, we will work toward a solution that will make them semi-independent. "
A bit of an exaggeration, John, but the premise is valid.
It is Israel's land to decide the outcome. They are occupying the land. May I also remind you how the land came to be occupied? They became occupied as the result of a DEFENSIVE WAR against their neighbors. The land has to remain occupied until such time as the sovereign state feels it is no longer threatened. And especially after the 2005 evacuation of Gaza, there is absolutely nothing to even give Israel the impression that it would be safe evacuating Judea/Samaria.
Yes, John, it is an indeterminate length of time, COMPLETELY dependent upon the sovereign state's impression that it can do so safely, without threat to it's citizens' safety.
Israel retained all the power of an occupying force by controlling all access to Gaza by land, sea and air
And rightly so. They were still being threatened, despite Israel's attempt to maintain the relationship in its current form, while incentivizing the population to engage in more activities that would make it more suitable for nationhood.
Gaza declined. They destroyed the infrastructure that Israel had left intact for them to use. There was a profitable agricultural exporting business left for them. What did the Gazans do? They fought over it, and destroyed it instead. They burned the golden goose to the ground. They would rather struggle than try to show the world that they could make it. And what do you think Israel would have done if, instead, Gaza worked with that infrastructure, and tried to do agribusiness with Israel and Egypt and any other country? Don't you think it would have made a difference? This business brought more than $10 million in revenue FROM GAZA.
They want freedom of movement for one reason. The wreak havoc on the civilian population of Israel. They have not proven otherwise.
No . It is not equal at all . Clearly that is your consistent reason for everything you say . But it is inaccurate at best and a blatant lie at worst .
I would surely like to see hamas go, and it does look like there may be some progress there; but, I think it is a result of Israeli pressure...
Subtle voices of dissent surface in war-torn Gaza
Jimmy Carter must be senile if he thinks Hamas will relinquish power except through a violent overthrow. It ain't going to happen. Below is an example of those who dissent in Gaza from Hamas' rule. They are accused of collaborating with Israel and are invariably murdered.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel%27s_unilateral_disengagement_...
What I thin would make more sense than your proposal is giving the Palestinians the freedom to which they are entitled. End the occupation. Either let them return or give them a viable Palestinian state. Oh yeah, I can post references to the billions of dollars in damage Israel has done to Gaza's infrastructure if you like.
Of course it's equal. What's good for the goose is good for the gander. And an opinion is not a lie simply because you disagree with it.
I'm saying the commitment by both sides to solve their differences via consistent and indiscriminate warfare, has for me at least, reached a point of cynical ennui where I don't even care anymore. In 70 years of violence nothing has been solved...NOTHING.
Oh please. They're pictures. It doesn't matter who takes the picture since the camera captures what it sees. If you feel more comfortable looking at the same damn thing taken by another camera, then knock yourself out.
Post Offices in Michigan, Massachusetts, and New Jersey have been refusing to accept mail addressed to Israel.
Things are getting out of hand with the anti-Semitism.
Well, yes and no... Postal Service apologizes for Israel mail flap .
We have a correct answer!
Funny how many forget that.
OK , there are a lot of anti-Israel protests . What does that prove ?
So ... you prefer "justice" to life ?
So why don't you move to Gaza and join them in their struggle ? That would be the "moral" thing to do based on your beliefs .
I guess it will just be Martha's Garden and back since so many don't want to ever see here again around the world, except maybe the Muslim Brotherhood.
Unless they enter our country illegally through Mexico ...