Is the President Incompetent or Lawless?
It has been well established under the Constitution and throughout our history that the president's job as the chief federal law enforcement officer permits him to put his ideological stamp on the nature of the work done by the executive branch. The courts have characterized this stamp as "discretion."
Thus when exercising their discretion, some presidents veer toward authority, others toward freedom. John Adams prosecuted a congressman whose criticism brought him into disrepute, an act protected by the First Amendment yet punishable under the Alien and Sedition Acts, and Thomas Jefferson declined to enforce the Acts because they punished speech, and pardoned all those convicted. Jimmy Carter asserted vast federal regulatory authority over the trucking and airline industries, and Ronald Reagan undid nearly all of it.
The president has discretion to adapt law enforcement to the needs of the times and to his reading of the wishes of the American people. Yet that discretion has a serious and mandatory guiding lightnamely, that the president will do so faithfully.
The word "faithfully" appears in the oath of office that is administered to every president. The reason for its use is to assure Americans that their wishes for government behavior, as manifested in written law, would be carried out even if the president personally disagrees with the laws he swore to enforce.
This has not always worked as planned. President George W. Bush once famously signed into law a statute prohibiting federal agents without a search warrant from reading mail sent to persons other than themselvesand as he was literally holding his pen, he stated he had no intention of enforcing it. That was a rejection of his presidential duties and a violation of his oath.
But today, President Obama has taken the concept of discretion and so distorted it, and has taken the obligation of faithful enforcement and so rejected it, that his job as chief law enforcer has become one of incompetent madness or chief lawbreaker. Time after time, in areas as disparate as civil liberties, immigration, foreign affairs and health care, the president has demonstrated a propensity for rejecting his oath and doing damage to our fabric of liberty that cannot easily be undone by a successor.
Item: He has permitted unconstitutional and unbridled spying on all Americans all the time, and he has dispatched his agents to lie and mislead the American people and their elected representatives in Congress about it. This has resulted in a federal culture in which the supposed servants of the people have become our permanent and intimate monitors and squealers on what they observe.
Item : He has permitted illegal immigrants to remain here and continue to break the law, and he has instructed them on how to get away with it. His encouragement has resulted in the flood of tens of thousands of foreign unaccompanied children being pushed across our borders. This has resulted in culture shock to children now used as political pawns, the impairment of their lives and the imposition of grievous financial burdens upon local and state governments.
Item: His agents fomented a revolution in Libya that resulted in the murder of that country's leader, the killing of the U.S. ambassador and the evacuation of the U.S. embassy. His agents fomented a revolution in Ukraine that resulted in a Russian invasion, an active insurgency, sham elections and the killing of hundreds of innocent passengers flying on a commercial airliner.
Item : He has dispatched CIA agents to fight undeclared and secret wars in Yemen and in Pakistan, and he has dispatched unmanned drones to kill innocents there. He has boasted that some secret reading of public positive law permits him to kill whomever he wishes, even Americans and their children.
Item : His State Department has treated Hamasa gang of ruthless murderers whose stated purpose is the destruction of Israelas if it were a legitimate state deserving of diplomatic niceties, and this has encouraged Hamas to persist in attacking our only serious ally in the Middle East.
Item: His Department of Veterans Affairs has so neglected patients in government hospitals that many of them died, and it even destroyed records to hide its misdeeds. His Internal Revenue Service has enforced the law more heavily against his political opponents than against his friends, and it has destroyed government computer records in order to hide its misdeeds.
Item : He has relieved his friends of the burdens of timely compliance with Obamacare, and he has burdened his enemies with tortured interpretations of that laweven interpretations that were rejected by the very Congress that enacted the law and interpretations that were invalidated by the Supreme Court.
He has done all these things with a cool indifference, and he has threatened to continue to do so until the pressure builds on his political opponents to see things his way.
The Framers could not have intended a president so devoid of fidelity to the rule of law that it is nearly impossible to distinguish between incompetence and lawlessnessand I am not sure which is worse. Archbishop Fulton Sheen often said he'd prefer to deal with a smart devil than a stupid one.
But the Framers did give us a remedy, and the remedy is not a frivolous lawsuit that the federal courts will no doubt reject as a political stunt. The remedy is removal from office. This is not to be undertaken lightly, as was the case when this remedy was last used. But it is the remaining constitutional means to save the freedoms the Constitution was intended to guarantee.
The choice is between two more years of government by decree or two years of prosecution. It is a choice the president has imposed upon us all.

Simple answer to both - yes. Explanation provided by his actions.
"He's Back"
Indeed he is!
Back with a vengeance it seems.
Beat me to it.
As always.What -six threads already on the front?? Doesn't waste any time, does he?
Which incompetent IDIOT wrote this story??? OH, I see, it is Andrew Napolitano, I suppose the only ones he could get to listen to the "LIES" are the uninformed in his party:
A Brief History of the US Government Spying on Its Citizens
By Ray Downs Jun 14 2013
Nothing is ever new. The NSAs monitoring of the internet and the phone records of millions of Americans surprised some people, and made the public as a whole fairly pissed off , but its not the first time US government has taken an Big Brotherly interest in its citizens. The feds have been tapping into the private lives of Americans without warrants and with the help of communication companies for nearly a century. Here are some of the more significant spying programs:
Black Chamber
Herbert O. Yardley, the head of Black Chamber, who later revealed its secrets.
What many consider a predecessor of the NSA began in the 1920s, when a group of Army codebreakers working under the friendly-sounding moniker Black Chamber began a project to spy on other nations communications. Black Chambers chief was Herbert O. Yardley, considered to be one of the greatest cryptologists of all time. The idea was to monitor international telegraphs as the were sent to and from the US in search of anything that could affect national securitybut first they had to get those telegraphs, so they asked the presidents of the major telegraph companies if they could see them.
Turns out, companies like Western Union were happy to comply.According to journalist James Bamford, who has reported widely on the NSA, Yardley later wrote : After the men had put all our cards on the table, President Carlton [of Western Union] seemed anxious to do everything he could for us.
The Black Chamber program set the template for a now-familiar story: a group is put in charge of monitoring communications in the name of national security and gains access to those communications through the cooperation of the private companies that own the communication infrastructure. It was Western Union telegrams back then; its Facebook messages now.
Funding for this program ended in 1929, and Yardley would go on to write a book titled The American Black Chamber that exposed the groups activities. Quite possibly the first whistleblower in the American intelligence community, he is now disparaged on the NSA website and official histories , where he'sdescribed as a disgruntled employee who wrote the book because he was unemployed and accustomed to luxury. The NSA calls the book itself a monumental indiscretion that put America in danger. But this exposure didnt stop future spying programs.
Illegal Immigration Solutions
ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION SOLUTIONS PROS AND CONS:
I am quite sure the readers and the writer of this article are descendants of Illegal Immigrants, the only people with the right to not call themselves an immigrant are the Native American Indians:
1607 - Beginning of Colonial Immigration; English Settlers Arrive in America
Depiction of settlers landing in America, 1584.
Source: Virgina Historical Society, www.vahistorical.org (accessed July 20, 2009)
"...[T]he settlement on the James River in 1607 marked the beginning of a nation--a nation that was certainly English in its foundation, whatever may be said of the superstructure. Virginia, New England, Maryland, the Carolinas, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Georgia were begun by Englishmen; and New England, Virginia, and Maryland remained almost entirely English throughout the seventeenth century and well into the eighteenth. 'Foreigners' began early to straggle into the colonies. But not until the eighteenth century was well under way did they come in appreciable numbers, and even then the great bulk of these non-English newcomers were from the British Isles, of Welsh, Scotch, Irish, and Scotch-Irish extraction."
1619 - Importation of African Slaves Begins
Loading plan of a slave ship hold.
Source: New Georgia Encyclopedia, www.georgiaencyclopedia.org (accessed July 15, 2009)
"The continuous presence of persons of African descent on soil that became the United States begins in 1619 with the arrival of twenty Africans at Jamestown, Virginia, aboard a Dutch warship from the West Indies. Their arrival was a part of the trans-Atlantic slave trade; lasting almost four centuries (1501-1873). Although the twenty Africans... arrived by virtue of the slave trade, they actually became indentured servants, Thus, they eventually gained their freedom, and some later actually owned slaves themselves... By the end of the colonial period, blacks numbered about five hundred thousand and constituted their largest proportion of the total American population ever, nearly 20 percent."
1637 - Massachusetts Requires Permission to Host Aliens
In May of 1637, the General Court of Massachusetts ordered that no town or person in the colony should receive or host any alien without permission from the authorities. John Winthrop, Governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, defended the 1637 court order as follows:
"...If we heere be a corporation established by free consent, if the place of our cohabitation be our owne, then no man hath a right to come into us without our consent... If we are bound to keep off whatsoever appears to tend to our ruine or damage, then may we lawfully refuse to receive such whose dispositions suite not with ours and whose society (we know) will be hurtful to us."
1656 - Anti-Quaker Immigration Popular but Quakers still Immigrate
Woman being escorted to her execution for being Quaker, 1660
Source: www.worldspirituality.org (accessed July 20, 2009)
"Although most of the settlements were made by Englishmen, they nevertheless differed fundamentally in character and purpose, and pursued, in some instances, widely varying policies in the admission of new settlers... For a period of several years, beginning with 1656, the records of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and indeed of all of the New England Colonies, except Rhode Island, are filled with legislation designed to prevent the coming of the Quakers and the spread of their 'accursed tenets.' Whippings, imprisonment, banishment, and in a few instances capital punishment, were the order of the day.' To what extent these various laws restricted the immigration of this sect, it is, of course, impossible to ascertain. That they were not prohibitive, and consequently did not meet the expectations of the authorities, is painfully evident; for, in spite of the severe penalties, members
1670 - 10,000 Indentured Servants Kidnapped from England and Sent to the Colonies
"[Most] indentured servants or redemptioners... were brought under compulsion; the others came voluntarily. The former consisted of convicted criminals and kidnaped persons... Boys and girls of the poorer classes were hustled on board ships and virtually sold into slavery for a term of years. Kidnaping or 'spiriting' became a fine art under Charles II. Slums and alleys were raked for material to stock the plantations... About 1670 no fewer than ten thousand persons were 'spirited' away from England in one year. One kidnaper testified in 1671 that he had sent five hundred persons a year to the colonies for twelve years and another testified that he had sent 840 in one year. The government was slow to strike at this infamous traffic... Ship masters made an enormous profit from this traffic..."
1700 - 222,500 White and 27,500 Black Inhabitants Live in the Colonies
"In 1700, nearly a century after Jamestown, only about 250,000 white and black inhabitants populated the colonies... The vast majority of the white inhabitants were either born in England or descended from English immigrants. Only about 11 percent [27,500] of the non-Native American population were black."
1717-1769 - 36,000 British Convicts Transported to America after Passage of Transportation Act of 1717
Biographical account of a British felon transported to the colonies
Source: Documenting the American South, www.docsouth.unc.edu (accessed July 20, 2009)
"The late 17th and 18th centuries saw a decline in the 'older' punishments in favour of fines, prison and, a new solution to the problem: transportation. From the Transportation Act of 1717 up to 1769, 36,000 convicts were sent to British colonies in America. 70% of offenders at the Old Bailey in London in this period were transported... Under the 'Bloody Code,' courts were looking for a punishment which was not as extreme as hanging, but tougher than a fine. In the absence of proper prisons, transportation seemed the answer and was used for over a hundred years. In the 18th century convicts were transported to America. After US independence in 1776, however, this option was closed and the British government looked for another destination... Australia."
LIES ITEM # 3
His agents fomented a revolution in Libya that resulted in the murder of that country's leader, the killing of the U.S. ambassador and the evacuation of the U.S. embassy. His agents fomented a revolution in Ukraine that resulted in a Russian invasion, an active insurgency, sham elections and the killing of hundreds of innocent passengers flying on a commercial airliner.
Right Wingers are totally sickening, blaming Obama for a civil war and a commercial jetliner that was shot down by the Russians in Ukrraine, you can't get any lower...
Lies # 4
The only thing I can call y'all are Al-Quaida sympathizers and Osama Bin Laden Lovers:
BS, is my response:
The Veterans Affairs Scandal Was Decades in the Making Yes, you should be angry. But at whom?
ts been more than six months since CNN and then the Arizona Republic began reporting about veterans dying while they were waiting for medical services in some cases, on secret lists that clinics were maintaining to hide the long delays from authorities in the Department of Veterans Affairs. Its not clear how many of these people died because they were waiting for care. An initial examination of 17 deaths, in Phoenix, suggested that none were the product of delays. Then again, it's not clear how much such nuance should matter. People who really need medical care shouldnt have to wait for it, especially when those people have served their country. Everybody in Washington seems angry. For a change, they should be.
Butangry at whom? It's hard to be sure right now. Conservativessay this story is proof that big government bureaucracies are prone to failure and that Obama has failed to create the "21st Century V.A." he promised as a candidate. Both claims seem credible but, even together, they also seem incomplete.The process for getting veterans into the government's health system and then getting them seen by VA medical professionals has a long history of problems, dating back decades. And while the Obama Administration obviously hasn't solved them, it's presided over significant improvements in these and other areas of veterans s ervices at a time when the need for care from wounded veterans is growing.
the struggle to make sure veterans get the assistance and care they need dates at least as far back as the presidency of John F. Kennedy. There have been ups and downs, frequently set off by surges in demand. In the 1990s, for example, federal lawmakers changed eligibility guidelines, so that all veterans not just those with service-related disabilities or low incomes were eligible to get medical services at government-run veterans clinics. That flooded the system and caused delays.
Yet there is a Judge Andrew Napolitano laying blame at the feet of Obama, what a friggin FOOL!!!
Business asked for a delay, so did the DO NOTHING GOP CONGRESS, THE PRESIDENT COMPLIED AND NOW THEY HAVE A LAWSUIT, A BUNCH OF NO GOODERS!!!!!!
Blame Obama for everything that goes wrong in the world is the strategy of the GOP, where are the "FRIGGIN JOBS BOEHNER"????????
Sitting on Harry Reid's floor, along with 212 other bills the House has tried to get passed under this Congress.
If the" DO NOTHING GOP HOUSE" had sent Quality bills they would have been debated in the Senate, instead of 50 repeals to Obamacare and everything they can think of to cut off assistance to American people...
Need to get your facts straight if you plan on continuing to SHOUT about the issue.
The House presented 61 bills/resolutions to the Senate for discussion/passage - three of those bills/resolutions were brought up for discussion, two were tabled and one was passed - the Agriculture Act of 2014 - yesterday (Thomas Library of Congress has a tremendously great store of information - if you care to look). So Reid and his children threw 59 out of 61 (96.7%)jobs bills on the floor - who's still at fault????
So the house passed three (3) bills on 7/31/2014 one was Suing Obama and the other on Veterans health Care as well as the Highway Bill..Whoopie!!! 50 repeals to Obamacare and other cuts to programs that Americans need, they should be thrown in the toilet...
C'mon CM - you can do better than that. For Bills to be passed, they have to be passed by the Senate, not the House.
If you don't like the Republicans - do a thread to that topic. This thread deals with Obama's incompetence or lawlessness. Has nothing to do with the House nor the Senate.
As usual - what does your comment have to do with the topic??? NOTHING.
Please discuss the topic.
I don't dislike Republicans, just the ones that does nothing and gets a paycheck, free health care, and several vacations, yet, complain EVERYDAY, about what Obama is not doing, when they have not done any quality work that benefits AMERICANS...
I expect a COC on this, but, you're an idiot!!!!
HuH?????? Who??
Not you 1st, Robert G.
The bat posting below wants to be recognized, I don't respond to creepy crawly bugs...
I thought it was coc Robert G. I guess because it was personal...anyway, I have changed my mind...you were expressing your views....
Creepy , Crawly, Bug!!!!!
That one might have been an example ofincompetent madness. It should be impeachable.
I think I've been here before...
???
Is the President Incompetent or Lawless?
no
Yeah ... Who cares about that silly "balance of powers" thing they mention in the constitution . That is just a suggestion anyway . Each pres should be valued for his self esteem . The congress is unimportant ...
And the coward removed his post...
The congress is important, the GOP with Boehner as speaker has abandoned their duties...
Robert G: You seem to have the language down perfect, that tells me you are leading the pack...
Get your facts right about executive orders:
Administration of George W. Bush (2001-2009)
GWB: 291 Total Executive orders Issued
Administration of Barack Obama (2009-Present)
184 Total Executive orders Issued
Aren't Right Wingers ashamed of the LIES they repeat constantly?????
Hypocrite Boehner Demands Obama Act Alone On Border Crisis While Suing Him For Executive Action
Robert G: You need to know the facts before you write, its embarrassing...
By contrast Obama is soooo manly !
Neither. False dichotomy.
I got this far: Jimmy Carter asserted vast federal regulatory authority over the trucking and airline industries, and Ronald Reagan undid nearly all of it. Utter Bullshit. If Ronald Reagan had undone the authority over the airtransportationindustries, how did he fire all of the air traffic controllers? What about the The FAA and NTSB ? All St. Ronnie of Tampico did is bust the unions and give a shove to the downward wage spiral and washup-trickle down economics.
He has permitted illegal immigrants to remain here and continue to break the law... Again I call BS, the US has deported record amounts of illegal aliens under his tenure.
His agents fomented a revolution in Libya , Again BS. Prove it, prove that US agents (and more specifically that he was somehow the hand behind it) were the cause underlying the Libyan upheaval.
His agents fomented a revolution in Ukraine that resulted in a Russian invasion, an active insurgency, sham elections and the killing of hundreds of innocent passengers flying on a commercial airliner. I am detecting a trend here....
His State Department has treated Hamasa gang of ruthless murderers whose stated purpose is the destruction of Israelas if it were a legitimate state deserving of diplomatic niceties, and this has encouraged Hamas to persist in attacking our only serious ally in the Middle East. In negotiations, it is often wise to deal with facts on the ground rather than facts as you would wish them to be. It wouldn't be productive at all to not do so, unless you are planning on just killing them down to the last man, woman and child. Might does not make right, and conversely, weakness is not always a sign of inferiority. Learn this, this is fucking important to understand.
Item: His Department of Veterans Affairs has so neglected patients in government hospitals that many of them died, and it even destroyed records to hide its misdeeds . The Cabinet member who was in charge had come a great way forward in improving the system since the dismal performance of prior administrations, but of course , the violent clique that this author belongs to needs freshbloodto fill theirstomachs, so they were all over this one.
His Internal Revenue Service has enforced the law more heavily against his political opponents than against his friends, and it has destroyed government computer records in order to hide its misdeeds . Still trying to give this legs? The IRS is charged with making sure that the taxes that are collected are complete. To do this, they need to know certain things about the way that a business is run and if it will be promoting a political agenda. Hence, if you have tea party in your name or associated literature, you will be given closer scrutiny than an organization called save the butterflies with documentation related to such a pursuit.
This whole article is based on a screed by a political hack with false dichotomies set up to make the the President look bad to others who already do not like him. Not a very hard thing to do when one is predisposed to disliking anything that he does, by definition. But if you really look at what the author states, you find it lacking in substance, as are most political articles due to the selective blindness that leaning in a particular political direction, towards this or that party (a false dichotomy of epic proportions), incurs.
Break out of this mold and think for yourself, not as someone else would have you think. If you agree with the article, you are just playing into the power structure that is, to the continuation of a system that has been corrupted by the players to maintain control over the people instead of the people having control over the system by giving the illusion that one party is all good and the other all bad. Neither party is all good and they both need to be done away with.
The easy answer is YES! or maybe the easy answer is really NO!
The more complex answer is that like beauty, incompetence is in the eye of the beholder and lawlessness is a matter of interpretation of the statutes (and if an interpretation that supports a particular position is needed there are always "experts" available to provide it)
In my view, it is more the method and public promotion (for political purposes only) of how actions have been taken that is more offensive to most of the President's opposition, than real deep rooted opposition to most of the changes that have been affected.
Like most previous presidents, the current chief executive has supporters that are behind him 100% whether he is right or wrong and he also has detractors that oppose his every action. This is nothing new, but you would now know that to watch media coverage of support and opposition.
Just a minor point, but isn't the attorney general the chief federal law enforcement officer?
Indeed the AG is the chief law enforcement office of the land and he reports directly to the President, from whence he gets and executes his power and authority
obama
I taught constitutional law for ten years. I take the Constitution very seriously. The biggest problems that were facing right now have to do with George Bush trying to bring more and more power into the executive branch and not go through Congress at all, and thats what I intend to reverse when Im President of the United States of America. from townhall
And there's the old "blame it on Bush" from our leader.
Notice how he has done EXACTLY what he says Bush did??
Must be twins from different mothers.