House Votes to Sue Obama for Overstepping Powers
WASHINGTON The House of Representatives voted on Wednesday to sue President Obama for overstepping the powers of the presidency a move that has angered conservatives who call it insufficient, emboldened Democrats who say Republicans are being vengeful, and further eroded much of what is left of bipartisanship on Capitol Hill.
In a 225-to-201 party-line vote, Republicans authorized the House to move forward with a lawsuit against Mr. Obama for his application of the Affordable Care Act, which they argue has been selective and intended to delay the laws most undesirable aspects.
During a pointed, impassioned hourlong debate, Republicans accused the president of flouting the law and breaking a solemn constitutional oath. They summoned lessons from the American Revolution and the Bible.
Speaker John A. Boehner all but accused Mr. Obama of leaving the Constitution in tatters. No member of this body needs to be reminded about what the Constitution states about the presidents obligation to faithfully execute the laws of our nation, Mr. Boehner said from the House floor. Are you willing to let any president choose what laws to execute and what laws to change? Are you willing to let anyone tear apart what our founders have built?
Democrats pointed to a litany of bills that Mr. Boehner had kept from reaching the floor for a vote this year legislation to raise the minimum wage, extend unemployment insurance and overhaul the immigration system and accused Republicans of wasting time and money.
A sorry spectacle of legislative malpractice, said Representative Louise M. Slaughter, Democrat of New York. The majority of the American people recognize this for what it is: political theater.
The lawsuit was Mr. Boehners version of what might be termed impeachment-light a way to send a signal that Republicans would fight the presidents efforts to revise laws Congress had passed while not going as far as many on the right would like.
But, as the speaker has found with other efforts to appease the right wing of his party, he was not well received. Sarah Palin responded by calling for Mr. Obamas impeachment, stirring up the kind of intraparty fight that Mr. Boehner had hoped to avoid. (Five Republicans voted no on Wednesday: Paul Broun of Georgia; Scott Garrett of New Jersey; Walter B. Jones of North Carolina; Thomas Massie of Kentucky; and Steve Stockman of Texas.)
Other prominent conservatives ridiculed the lawsuit. Erick Erickson, the blogger and pundit, also called it political theater that wasted taxpayer dollars. Mark Levin, the popular radio host and former Reagan administration official, called it a foolish move that made him cringe.
On this point, Democrats agree.
In a speech in Kansas City on Wednesday, Mr. Obamas mere mention of the lawsuit drew boos from the crowd. Everybody recognizes this is a political stunt, he said. But its worse than that, because every vote theyre taking like that means a vote theyre not taking to actually help you.
Democrats have turned the lawsuit and rumblings of impeachment into a financial boon. The party claimed to have raised $1 million on Monday alone. Dont let this stand, read one fund-raising email sent this week by the Democratic National Committee. Chip in $10 or more before Thursdays deadline to fight back.
Representative Steve Israel of New York, chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, said, When they decide to obsess on suing the president, they shouldnt be surprised that our base is as energized as theyve become.
Recent polling shows that Republicans overwhelmingly favor impeaching the president. A Fox News poll released last week found that 56 percent of Republicans believe that Mr. Obama should be impeached. That compares with just 36 percent of all registered voters. CNN found nearly identical numbers in a poll of its own last week.
Since the president threatened in his State of the Union address this year to use his executive powers to change policy when Congress would not act, Republicans have been increasingly vocal in criticizing the president as imperial, particularly with regard to his signing of executive orders to implement new regulations on politically divisive issues like gun control and pollution.
This was a dominant theme in Republican speeches before the vote on Wednesday.
Representative Tom Rice of South Carolina drew comparisons to the tyranny of King George III (Mr. Obama) and the revolt by the American colonies (House Republicans). At the end of the bloody revolution, the last thing that they wanted was another king; they wanted freedom, he said, dismissing concerns about the lawsuits costs as a small price to pay for a worthy cause.
He added, We cannot stand by and watch the president shred our Constitution.
Representative Jeff Duncan of South Carolina summoned the story of Adam and Eve in explaining how men, because of their inherent fallibility, could not be trusted with too much power, something he said the Founding Fathers understood. As Christian men of the day, they understood that since the Garden of Eden, man has fallen, he said, urging Mr. Obama, a former constitutional lawyer, to read up on the federal governments founding document. Our Constitution does not say the president gets to write his own laws, Mr. Duncan said.
Statistics show that as of last week, the Obama White House had issued a total of 183 executive orders, the vast majority in his first term. George W. Bush, by comparison, issued 291 in his eight years in office. Bill Clinton issued 364; Ronald Reagan 381. Executive orders do, however, vary in scope and significance.
House Republicans, in fact, are not the only ones in Congress who have sued the Obama administration this year. Senator Ron Johnson, Republican of Wisconsin, filed suit challenging the governments ability to provide money so members of Congress and their staff could buy health care through the exchanges established by the Affordable Care Act. A federal judge tossed out that suit this month.
Senator Rand Paul, Republican of Kentucky, has sued Mr. Obama and the leaders of several intelligence agencies to challenge the National Security Agencys bulk collection of Americans phone data.
Legal scholars have questioned whether any member of Congress can prove injury by the president and therefore prevail in court. (This was the reason Mr. Johnsons suit was dismissed.)
Perhaps the most impassioned speech of the day came from Representative John Lewis, Democrat of Georgia, who called the Republicans resolution a shame and a disgrace.
It has no place on this floor, he said.
Tags
seeder
Miss_Construed
12 years ago
A sorry spectacle of legislative malpractice, said Representative Louise M. Slaughter, Democrat of New York. The majority of the American people recognize this for what it is: political theater.
Other prominent conservatives ridiculed the lawsuit. Erick Erickson, the blogger and pundit, also called it political theater that wasted taxpayer dollars. Mark Levin, the popular radio host and former Reagan administration official, called it a foolish move that made him cringe.
I wanted to retitle this as "another giant waste of tax payer money", but the article title stands as published.
Heaven knows they just got done working the last four weeks straight...
1stwarrior
12 years agoAnd this, sadly, shows the divisiveness of our Congressional members. We need a clean house with thoughts and desires of working for the people of this country - not the businesses, not the special interest groups - the people.
A. Macarthur
12 years agoWe need a clean house with thoughts and desires of working for the people of this country - not the businesses, not the special interest groups - the people.
We totally agree!
For the record, one cannot sue unless one has "standing," and in order to have "standing," the plaintiff must be able to show "personal injury."
Sean Treacy
12 years agoOf course this is political theater. It's a desperate wake up call to the President and the nation at large about the perilous path the President has started us down with failure to faithfully execute the laws of the country. It's purpose is not to win a court case, but to alert everyone as to what is at stake by the President's refusal to uphold the Constitution. When laws become meaningless, when the President claims the right to pick and choose to enforce only those laws he personally agrees with, the republic cannot endure for long.
As anyone who has studied any history can tell you, republics are fragile things. Authoritarian governments are the natural state for mankind to live under. Republics and democracies are historical anomalies that can flourish for hundreds of years, before inevitably falling back into authoritarianism. The founders understood this. Their obsession with avoiding faction (parties) and respecting and venerating the rule of law permeates the Federalist papers.
Once respect for the rule of law is gone, so is the legitimacy of the government. Anyone whose studied Rome from the Gracchi to Ceaser is familiar with how this plays out. Laws were passed and then ignored with impunity by the leaders of the late Republic as it suited their own ambitions. Once the Romans saw the precedent set that laws can be discarded at the whims of a strong man, the late Republic became consumed by leaders struggling to amass enough power so they too could do whatever they wanted. Laws served as mere ornament to their despotship. Once power, rather than the law, becomes the arbiter of whether a President can do something we have gone a long way towards that place where laws are mere decorations for an authoritarian to follow or discard as it suits his needs.
That's why the Constitution and any functioning Republic depends on its chief magistrate FAITHFULLY executing the laws. The President's job is not to do what he thinks is best for the people. The Constitution requires him to faithfully execute those laws that are passed, and Obama clearly has abandoned living up to that most fundamental and important of his job descriptions. A President who puts party over country was the worst nightmare for our founders, because they understood what the inevitable result would be. Dissolution.
Its truly amazing to me that Obama intends to provoke a Constitutional crises in peacetime. Worse, he even wants to be impeached because he thinks its his best way to raise money and further polarize the country. Its tremendously sad and would probably be impossible for the founders to believe that a Presidnet would intentionally act lawlessly in order to court impeachment becuase he thinks his party will be strenghtened by his lawlesseness and he knows that his fellow party members in the Senate will block his removal no matter how brazenly he brreachs the Constituion.
This lawsuit is a simply a forlorn, desperate plea for the rule of law to be asserted over a reckless, partisan President. It will fail and its failure presages the failure of our country. Because once the precedent is set that Presidents can arbitrarily decide which laws will be enforced, we are no longer a Republic. Because I guarantee you that future Republican Presidents will follow the President Obama's lead. Get ready for tax cuts by Presidential decree!
A. Macarthur
12 years agoThis lawsuit is a simply a forlorn, desperate plea for the rule of law to be asserted over a reckless, partisan President.
Total crap. Executive actions and delays in implementations of laws have always been available to the POTUS; in this case the Republican-hypocrite-panderers-to-a-hater-loony base, are suing the President for not expediting a part of a law THEY HAVE TRIED TO REPEAL MORE THAN 50 TIMES!
1stwarrior
12 years agoI know you hate the Republicans with a passion A. Mac - it is, oh, so very obvious in your responses. But - Obama's "I've got a pen and phone" has applied to many more laws than the ACA. True, as you know, you can't flood the court with a missive 1,000 pages thick outlining each law not enforced and it's resultant impacts. However, you have to make your pleading to the court in your initial opening and Obama's failure to execute many of the ACA requirements and his very open exemptions that are contrary to ACA are a huge violation of the "faithfully . . . protect and defend the Constitution of the United States" portion of his swearing in.
What part of "defend" is he not doing? Congress, per the Constitution, drafts and submits for signature, laws for the Nation. Once signed and approved by the Pres, only Congress can make changes to the laws passed - not the Pres.
seeder
Miss_Construed
12 years agoIf Bohener were a little more black... and Obama a little more orange... they could admire each other through a window frame and swear they lost 5 lbs this month.
In fact, they might try to take selfies
A. Macarthur
12 years agoI know you hate the Republicans with a passion A. Mac
Nah! I hate selective indignation hypocrisy.
It would be nice to see a couple of enlightened liberals express an understanding of that. Just so we know there are a couple.
Wish granted.
Dems: Bush delayed healthcare laws too
By Jonathan Easley - 03/26/14 12:02 PM EDT
Democrats are pushing back at Republican outrage over the Obama administrations latest unilateral change to ObamaCare, pointing to instances when President George W. Bush enacted similar extensions to the Medicare prescription drug benefit program.
And
Enough Already on HealthCare.gov. Dont You Remember Medicare Part D?
Republicans certainly deserved a few weeks of toldja so! about the sites awful rollout. But why cant they start helping their constituents figure it out now, as Democrats did with Bushs Medicare Part D?
OK. Ive officially had enough of this Republican gloating about HealthCare.gov . Yes, it was a major and inexcusable fiasco, as I wrote last week . So they were entitled to a week of we told ya so. Or even two. But really, its practically a month now. Enough already. I know that we expect no decency from these people, so this will sound nave, but truly, what they should be doing now is helping their constituents figure it all out. Thats what the Democrats did in a similar situation.
I refer, of course, to the Medicare Part D implementation in late 2005 and early 2006. That was the big prescription drug bill passed in 2003. You rememberits the one where the Republicans didnt have the votes in the House, even though they controlled the House, and Speaker Tom DeLay held the floor open for 15 minutes after the bell rang as his lieutenants went around and badgered and threatened some GOP members until they changed their vote from nay to aye. My, how at home DeLay would have been with the Tea Partiers.
Anyhow. Most Democrats voted against the bill. In the House just 16 of 203 Democratic members voted yes. In the Senate, however, 11 of 48 Democrats voted for the new Bush entitlement. First, lets just stop right there. Could you imagine 16 and 11 Republicans ever voting for an Obama legislative priority, something that was clearly Obamas baby in the same way that the Part D bill was Bushs? Thered be no end to the slobbering over Republicans for being so reasonable. As I recall, the Democrats were attacked at the time for not supporting the bill enough.
And
Bush delays HIPAA legislation
And
July 11, 2003
Press contact: Nancy Stoner, (202) 289-2394, or Daniel Rosenberg, (202) 289-2389
If you are not a member of the press, please write to us at nrdcinfo@nrdc.org or see our contact page .Bush Administration Plans to Limit Scope of Clean Water Act
Early this year the Bush administration initiated a process to rewrite Clean Water Act rules to narrow the scope of the law. If the administration gets its way, thousands of streams, wetlands and other waters would no longer be protected by the law, allowing industry to dredge, fill or dump waste into them without a permit and without notifying the public. That would undermine efforts to control pollution and floods, and seriously threaten wildlife habitat and public drinking water supplies.
Shall I go on?
Perrie Halpern R.A.
12 years agoI'm freakin sick of our do nothing, petty congress.
Here let me do the accounting for you folks.
$174,000 (plus full benefits)/ annually
X 435 Members of congress
$75,690,000 annual cost of the congress
$174,000 annual salary
/126 working days
$1,381 a day
What a joke on us.
1stwarrior
12 years ago 535 x 174,000.00 = $93,090,000.00 = 0% ROI
100 Senate, 435 House - you forgot to add themost worthless of thegroup.
Perrie Halpern R.A.
12 years agoYou asked for it.. You got it!
The current salary (2013) for rank-and-file members of the House and Senate is $174,000 per year.
Special Incomes:
Majority Party Leader - $193,400
Minority Party Leader - $193,400
Speaker of the House - $223,500
Majority Leader - $193,400
Minority Leader - $193,400
Effective January 1, 2001, the annual salary of the President of the United States was increased to $400,000 per year, including a $50,000 expense allowance.
seeder
Miss_Construed
12 years agoforgot old uncle joe...
$230,700
And these nine dunderheads
The chief justice is being paid$255,500, up from$223,500, according to court documents and data compiled by Bloomberg. Associate Supreme Court justices now have a$244,400salary, up from$213,900.
What does each member's support staff run us I wonder? Cabinet members?
Dear FSM this list is long...
1stwarrior
12 years agoBoehner said - This situation shows the intense concern within our conference and among the American people about the need to ensure the security of our borders and the presidents refusal to faithfully execute our laws. There are numerous steps the president can and should be taking right now, without the need for congressional action, to secure our borders and ensure these children are returned swiftly and safely to their countries. For the past month, the House has been engaged in intensive efforts to pass legislation that would compel the president to do his job and ensure it can be done as quickly and compassionately as possible. Through an inclusive process, a border bill was built by listening to members and the American people that has the support not just of a majority of the majority in the House, but most of the House Republican Conference. We will continue to work on solutions to the border crisis and other challenges facing our country.
Highlighted areas are based on existing law that the President can/should enforce.
Nice try Randy.
1stwarrior
12 years agoThe TEXAS republicans - Texas Republicans are pressing President Obama to take the southern border crisis into his own hands
That is NOT Congress nor is it Boehner.
1stwarrior
12 years agoBack atcha - Bonner is "saying" the Obama has the Immigration Naturalization Act of 1940 as Amended, the Illegal Immigration Restoration and Immigration Reform Act of 1996 and the "Send the kids home free" Act of 2008 to use his authorities on - but refuses to do so.
A. Macarthur
12 years agoThe came here illegally and entered this country illegally. as far as I know NO ONE has given them refugee status. Thus they are illegal aliens.
Children escaping forced entry into drug gangs under the threat of death, or death to family members, and/or girls escaping rape, sex slavery and other human atrocities are REFUGEES and NOT ECONOMIC-ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS.
WTF is wrong with you f'n people?
THEY'RE CHILDREN!
It is much wiser to sue than to impeach, when you do not have a majority in congress.
They cannot legally bring suit unless they have "standing," that meaning that the plaintiff must be able to show personal injury.
Heartless, clueless parrots of a bullshit, right-wing well-funded-by-Organized-Wealth disinformation-propaganda campaign.
The hatred of Obama is palpable and the zeal-without-knowledge rhetoric is sickening.
Petey Coober
12 years agoIf they are here strictly to take advantage of Obamacare they are con artists ... or at least motivated by adult con artists .
1stwarrior
12 years ago"Heartless, clueless parrots of a bullshit, left right-wing well-funded-by-Organized-Wealth disinformation-propaganda campaign."
Perfect description of Harry and his children A. Mac - thanks. I'd quit looking, but think you should also add pathetic, whiney, gluttonous, and lawless to the Dem definition.
1stwarrior
12 years agoDon't think that means what you think it means Randy - again.
That law, if you'll read the title, is for ' TRAFFICKED " persons - male, female, young, old - TRAFFICKED . These pathetic little "kids" (as you folks like to call them) - 90% of them are 15 - 20 years of agewere not being TRAFFICKED . They were told that, if you cross the border, Obama will give you freedom.
Only those classified as TRAFFICKED are authorized to have standing in front of an immigration court. Those not TRAFFICKED are to be transported and deported across the border back to their home countries.
Read the law and understand it before you start telling people they're wrong.
A. Macarthur
12 years ago
1stwarrior
12 years agoNow A. Mac - I italicized your wording and placed them in quotation marks, giving you credit for having made the comment with one minor "editorial freedom" change.
Only liked his bike.
Robert in Ohio
12 years agoOne more self inflicted wound by the Republicans in an election year.
A stupid, senseless approach to political differences with the president and his administration.
Anyone who has been on NT for a while, knows that I am no fan of the Obama administration, but stupid is as stupid does (to paraphrase Forest Gump) and this is stupid. There is a constitutional process available to the House of Representatives, if they feel the President is violating his oath of office or misusing his authority and that is Impeachment (which would also be a stupid approach).
Grandstanding for the far right of the party,is in fact all this is and the outcome of such stupidity is that the Republicans are doing everything they can to insure that the Democrats retain control of the Senate when in fact it is the Republican's to lose.
We need to have legislators in the legislature not in court and we need the peoples' money spent on the peoples' needs not on frivolous lawsuits.
1stwarrior
12 years agoRandy - below is the section of the '08 Act that folks get really confused with because they don't read the full section. I have highlighted the pertinent section that discounts your comment.
"Authorizes the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to permit an alien who may be a victim of human trafficking (currently, only if the alien is such a victim) to remain in the United States to facilitate the investigation and prosecution of those responsible for human trafficking. Requires a federal law enforcement official to respond to a request for continued U.S. presence within 15 days, and DHS to approve or deny such request within 1 month."
A. Macarthur
12 years agoRefugee Admissions
Refugee Resettlement in the United States
The United States is proud of its history of welcoming immigrants and refugees. The U.S. refugee resettlement program reflects the United States highest values and aspirations to compassion, generosity and leadership. Since 1975, Americans have welcomed over 3 million refugees from all over the world. Refugees have built new lives, homes and communities in towns and cities in all 50 states.
Resettlement: The Solution for Only a Few
A refugee is someone who has fled from his or her home country and cannot return because he or she has a well-founded fear of persecution based on religion, race, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group. The first step for most refugees is to register with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) in the country to which s/he has fled. UNHCR has the mandate to provide international protection to refugees. UNHCR determines if an individual qualifies as a refugee and, if so, works toward the best possible durable solution for each refugee: safe return to the home country, local integration, or third-country resettlement.
According to UNHCRs latest statistics, there are approximately 15.4 million refugees in the world. The vast majority of these refugees will receive support in the country to which they fled until they can voluntarily and safely return to their home country. A small number of refugees will be allowed to become citizens in the country to which they fled, and an even smaller number primarily those who are at the highest risk will be resettled in a third country. While UNHCR reports that less than 1 percent of all refugees are eventually resettled in third countries, the United States welcomes over half of these refugees, more than all other resettlement countries combined.
