╌>

I've Always Loved Israel but this Brutality Breaks my Heart

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  rescue  •  12 years ago  •  45 comments

I've Always Loved Israel but this Brutality Breaks my Heart

Some of the dead are Hamas fighters. But many others are women, children, the helpless old. Israel is exacting vengeance at its usual tariff for Hamas rocketing, and the murder of three Israeli students by terrorists. For each Israeli killed, the lives of many times that number of Palestinians are forfeit.

Israel says: they started it; we have a right to retribution. But much of the world says: the Jewish people have been historic standard-bearers for civilisation. Does Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahus campaign in Gaza represent that or instead barbarism?

A historian friend, himself a Jew and an uncommonly astute observer of the world, said to me a while back: Consciously or unconsciously, Israel has decided that it prefers a state of permanent war to making the concessions to the Palestinians that would be indispensable to any chance of peace.

Israel has become more inward-looking, less receptive to foreign opinion, than at any time in its history. Its economy is booming. Tel Aviv boasts a thrillingly buzzy caf culture. Barack Obama, the only recent U.S. president to try to persuade Jerusalem to moderate its policies, has been thwarted by Netanyahu and his friends in the U.S. Congress.

Few Israelis seem to show much concern for world discomfort about the bombardment of Gaza, and indeed about their policies towards the Palestinians.

Yet even so, many other Jews are deeply dismayed. Three years ago, a team of Israeli documentary-makers produced a brilliant film about the occupation of Gaza and the West Bank entitled The Gatekeepers. For this, they persuaded five former heads of the Shin Bet, the nations security service, to be interviewed on camera.

The outcome was fascinating, and devastating. Each chief in turn described the ruthless policies he had enforced to sustain Israeli dominance. Most agreed that repression had been counter-productive.

The security forces have simply been left to impose varying degrees of repression, while Jewish settlers grab ever-larger areas of the West Bank and Jerusalem. I n a remarkable moment of frankness, one former Shin Bet chief said: Occupation has made us a cruel people.

Uglinesses have mounted steadily since the early Seventies, when the Israeli Army merely demolished Palestinian orange groves to improve its fields of fire. Three Palestinians have been killed in reprisals for every Israeli killed by terrorism.

A few years ago, I revisited the West Bank and Gaza, and like most visitors recoiled from their squalor, the prevailing culture of rage and despair. It is true that the Palestinians, led by men skilled in guerrilla war but little else, speak a language of emotion and unreason.

But I have also watched the soldiers of the Israeli Army that I once loved disport themselves among the Palestinians like other arrogant occupiers through the ages, displaying at best casual rudeness, at worst murderous brutality.



http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-2703531/MAX-HASTINGS-Ive-loved-Israel-brutality-breaks-heart.html#ixzz38Pi4xjqJ


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Israel is exacting vengeance at its usual tariff for Hamas rocketing, and the murder of three Israeli students by terrorists.

This statement is one man's perception of events , nothing more . Israel is also paying a price in the lives of her soldiers :


They have a job to do which is clearing out tunnels between Gaza and Israel . When they finish that job they will withdraw but not until then .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

the destruction of those tunnels is not going to stop an increased occupation of Gaza

I think you're wrong . It is too expensive in lives of Israeli soldiers captured or killed .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Why should I respond to your obviously biased comment ? You have accused me multiple times of lying and worse . This is not a dialogue . It is your diatribe . There is nothing in it for me .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

That being said, I am disgusted by what I see as Israel's failure to be much more surgical in their air attacks. They have much more capability to do so than what we are seeing.

As surgical as we are in our battles? ISIS? Are you aware that there were Palestinian families that left that area so that their families were safe and not in a war zone? Are you aware of this:

Israel has publicly accepted Egypt's call for a cease-fire and condemned Hamas for not doing so. Hamas political leadership lives in Qatar, another country involved in efforts to achieve a cease-fire.

How interesting. Hamas leadership isn't even in the war zone, but safe in Qatar. This is a war of public opinion, waged by Hamas. It is a lose/ lose for Israel. How can one make peace with a terrorist organization?

Yes, I am deeply disturbed by the death of Gazans in this conflict. The pictures are horrifying but that is exactly what the leadership of Hamas wants, while they are watch the death toll rise in Qatar and smile at the outrage from the rest of the world.

jwc, I personally feel that your reaction is normal. You are a kind person and no one wants to see those images on the TV and that reaction is exactly what Hamas wants.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Israel CANNOT maintain a blockade , land sea and air , on Gaza and also claim Gaza is an independent entity that Israel left to it's own devices seven years ago. It is ABSURD.

It's give and take, John. How about this. When Hamas accepts the existence of Israel and remove from it's charter that it wants to drive Israel and Jews out of the region, then there would be grounds for removing the blockade.

You seem to think that this happened in a vacuum. It happened because there were open borders and non stop suicide bombing in Israel. Where was the world's outrage over that? Hundreds of dead civilians and tourists that never made the nightly news. Why is that not part of the narrative here?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

First let's get something straight. I personally don't wish for this fight to go on forever. And in fact, the majority of Israelis don't either. But they also want security in their homeland.

Again, what you have seem to have missed is that there have been several attempts at peace talks. Israel try to make good by removing forcefully Israeli settlers out of Hebron as an act of goodwill? Did you ever see video of that?

Yes, I agree that it would be lovely if they could all sit down and discuss this, but it's not like it hasn't been tried before. Every time Israel tried to make peace, new demands were made. And while I agree that there should be an independent Gaza and West Bank, realistically Israel will never give up Jerusalem, which is something that has been demanded of them. If peace came with every Jew out of those areas... that should be good enough.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

The majority of the bombing has been done in Gaza City, so logic would dictate that leaving that area would be the wise thing to do. Many families did leave when they were notified.

Now answer me this Rescue? Why has Hamas never taken any of their international aid and spent it on bomb shelters? Because dead kids make for better press and that is what they are hoping for and why the bombs keep coming over to Israel. This is the way that people in Ashkelon and Sderot live. There is no iron dome there. Do you know the rate of PTSD the children there have? Do you even care?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Almost half of Sderot's preteens suffer from signs of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) according to a study that was published this November in the Journal of Adolescent Health . Based on a questionnaire answered by 154 seventh and eighth grade students, it was found that 43.5 percent of the children demonstrated clinical signs of PTSD.

The survey, which was conducted in 2007-2008 during a time period when thousands of rockets had been fired towards Sderot, was directed by a team led by Dr. Rony Berger, a clinical psychologist at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev. Dr. Berger is also the community services director of NATAL, the Israel Trauma Center for Victims of Terror and War, which released a report in 2011 that 70 percent of all Sderot children suffer from at least one symptom of post-traumatic stress, and that 50 percent continue to relive rocket trauma.

...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Given the fact that (ALL OF) the conquered people will never be given full citizenship in Israel , there is only one other solution available. The conquered land , West Bank and Gaza must be given back. There is no other way out. The conquered people must be given self-determination, they cannot be kept indefinitely in second class citizenship or as refugees.

I agree. Now let's see if Hamas is willing to recognize Israel and stop bombing it. Then you would have a case. But you see, their leadership is safe in Qatar, so why would they? It doesn't fit their agenda of destroying Israel.

Do you realize what you are asking from Israel is more than any other nation would do. When the WTC was hit, we traveled thousands of miles to make sure they hurt as much as we did. When other nations had terrorist attacks, they joined us. How does one deal with terrorist?

But I will say this. If Abbas was smart, this would be an excellent time to make peace with Israel and cut ties with Hamas. At least there would be peace for Palestinians for those who want it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Here is a map of the current hits by both sides:

There is a large swath of land in the middle of Gaza that is pretty much free from strikes. I would think that would be pretty safe.

The article that this came from is pretty interesting and I would say fair.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Wonder if any children in Gaza suffer from PTSD?

Of course they do. The difference is that I recognize that both sides children are hurting, but that Hamas has made the pain for their people far worse. And when you recognize that they are a terrorist organization, then we can have a real discussion on this subject.

BTW are you fine with political opposition to Hamas being dragged to death on the back of a car? Is it OK when it's Palestinian brutally killing Palestinian?

It was a sight that shocked the world the corpse of Ribhi Badawi being dragged through the streets of Gaza City Tuesday by a motorcycle as Hamas gunmen fired into the air.

NEW YORK DAILY NEWS
Monday, November 26, 2012, 2:17 AM
Palestinian gunmen ride a motorcycle as they drag the body of a man, who was suspected of working for Israel, in Gaza City November 20, 2012. Palestinian gunmen shot dead six alleged collaborators in the Gaza Strip who "were caught red-handed", according to a security source quoted by the Hamas Aqsa radio on Tuesday. REUTERS Palestinian gunmen ride a motorcycle as they drag the body of a man, who was suspected of working for Israel, in Gaza City.



Read more: ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Wonder if any children in Gaza suffer from PTSD?

They are raised to welcome death ... so probably not so much PTSD .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Hamas could be ostracized if the Palestinian people were presented a better option.

I believe that there are Palestinians who would get rid of Hamas, but they can't because they are killed by Hamas. I realize that this isn't what they thought they were voting in, but you can't vote them out either.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Declaring repeatedly that something is bullshit does not make it so . But repeating the same meaningless claim over & over reduces its power to persuade . Come up with a real argument instead of an epithet or lose your audience ...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Randy which part is bullshit?

The fact that despite hundreds of millions of dollars given to Gaza for aid, that there are no bomb shelters?

The fact that Hams leadership is in Qatar safe, while their people suffer?

The fact the the UN found missiles in one of their schools?

If Hamas cared about their people don't you think they would provide bomb shelters in Gaza city, if they are going to bomb Israel every day, in the inevitable event that there would be retaliation?

Is Hamas not a terrorist organization?

Please tell me what is the BS?

And while you are answering those questions, please also tell me why I am not saying the same thing about Abbas and the PA, nor do they act like Hamas?

Yes I would like a two state solution. I see that possibility with Abbas. He seems like a reasonable man and I hope it come to pass, but as long as Hamas is in control of of Gaza, there will be no peace because they don't want it.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Now answer me this Rescue? Why has Hamas never taken any of their international aid and spent it on bomb shelters?

Here, Perrie, is one reason why they never build bomb shelters.

Gaza's Next Disaster: No Cement for Rebuilding

To rebuild after its war with Israel, Gaza is going to need tons of cement. But Hamas has a history of using cement for military rather than civilian purposes, and importation of the vital building material is likely to be even more tightly controlled once hostilities end than it has been in the past. So big swaths of Gaza that have been devastated by Israeli bombardment will likely not be rebuilt for many years to come.

The bottom line: Visible scars from this war will last a long time.

Troops of the Israel Defense Forces have been surprised by the number and sophistication of tunnels discovered during their ground incursion, considering that Israel and (sometimes) Egypt have gone to great lengths to prevent Hamas engineers from getting their hands on material for building tunnels.Whats clear now is that those efforts to keep cement strictly for civilian purposes failed miserably. As of July 21, the IDF had found 23 tunnels under the Gaza-Israel border with 66 access points. The soil in the area is soft, which means tunnels are easy to dig but frequently require concrete for reinforcement. The Israeli military estimates that 600,000 tons of concretemade by mixing cement with sand, gravel, and watermay have gone into the tunnels.

The tunnels can be surprisingly sophisticated. Last October, for instance, Israel discovered an attack tunnel under the border that was 1.6 miles long and 66 feet below ground, equipped with electricity, a communications network, and stockpiles of cookies, yoghurt and other foods to allow for stays of several months, the website Al-Monitor reported.

The construction of attack tunnels and underground lairs came at a time when Gaza was appealing to the world to be relieved of limitations on the importation of cement on humanitarian grounds. The Israeli human rights organization BTselem reported last year that contractors and construction laborers in the Gaza Strip depicted a harsh reality in which projects are put on hold due to lack of materials. They related that contractors were forced to dismiss employees, so that thousands of people, most of whom support large families, lost their livelihood.

A journalist for Al-Monitor, Rasha Abou Jalal, told the poignant story of a 22-year-old man who needed bags of cement last year to complete the construction of his marital home. The man had to buy them in secret, meeting his connection precisely at 10:30 p.m. at an arranged location. The article attributed the need for secrecy to the Hamas governments going after merchants monopolizing the cement market. What seems clear now, however, is that the governments real concern wasnt fighting monopolistic merchants but keeping the cement for itself.

This history will further immiserate Gaza in coming years. International organizations willing to give Hamas the benefit of the doubt before are less likely to do so now. Hamas militants have demonstrated that when they get their hands on cement, they use it for attack tunnels. The victims, of course, will be the ordinary residents of Gaza who are caught in the middle.

Perhaps at some point the people of Gaza will get a chance to look about and ask Hamas and Abbas why there were no safe houses or bomb shelters for them to go to. And if they are too frightened of Hamas to ask, and too frightened of Hamas to act in their own best interest, there is absolutely nothing anyone else can do for them.

And the US and other countries need to stop funding terrorists who kill their own people.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Because dead kids make for better press and that is what they are hoping for and why the bombs keep coming over to Israel.

That's a total load of crap. To say they are hoping for dead children because it makes for better pressis pure propaganda garbage!

Randy, the parents and families of these children don't want them dead. But go read the Hamas Charter. They don't mind this kind of collateral damage, since they believe in a radical form of Islam, which means not only do they feel that these people are being myrtered, but that it's OK to do so to get the results they want. That is why Hamas is a terrorist organization. They are sick radicals. They are not the PA. When that is recognize, maybe the world can come to the aid of the people in Gaza and get Hamas out.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

He won't read the charter . His wife won't let him ...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Randy,

I am not going to get into this with you. You are a kind man and maybe too kind... if there can be such a thing.

Impasse.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

If Hamas didn't want dead babies they would build bomb shelters instead of confiscating all the concrete and building sophisticated tunnels with it, stocking them with food and other amenities, and preparing to stay down there while the civilians remain on top of the ground as fodder for rocket fire.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Rescue,

I understand that what Christians believe is probably unimportant to you, but that's where Jesus taught in the temple when He was 12 and amazed the elders. The temple where He drove the money changers out.

Now that is down right cheek. You don't know me. You don't know anything about my background, so how dare you insult me. I am more than well aware of what Jerusalem means to Christians. In fact, Christians are among some of Israel's biggest supporters.

And for the record, I went to a Church of England school, so I damn well know my bible lessons, both Testaments.

And as long as there is an Israel, all who want to go and worship can, including at theAl-Aqsa Mosque.

You go and explain to theBaha'iwhy they had to leave Iran, who BTW havetheir temple in Israel, too.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

exactly where was the safety zone?

In the hundreds of tunnels deep under Gaza.

(But of course Hamas never let ordinary people use them for shelter-- it would have interfered with their plan to produce more dead ids for good propaganda photo ops.Frown.gif )

I understand that what Christians believe is probably unimportant to you,

More covert hostility.

Golly gee rescue-- for someone who claims to be a Christian, you sure do have a lot of hate in your heart.

Jus' sayin'

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Hell, they wouldn't even need bomb shelters if Hamas would quit firing rockets and building infiltration tunnels in their sick attempts at killing Israeli civilians. If they weren't smuggling arms and rockets into Gaza, Israel would ease and eventually remove the blockade. The bottom line is that as long as the genocidal terrorists of Hamas are in control (with the support of most Gazans), all Gazans innocent or not will continue to suffer these retaliatory strikes as well they should.

When will they learn?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

as long as Israel withdraws the blockade. They won't because they like being in total control of Gaza.

Are you aware of the fact that Egypt is also blockading Gaza?

And for the same reason-- both countries know that the lovers of dead (& mutilated!) babies-- Hamas-- are violent religious fanatics similar to ISIS-- terrorists who pose a real danger.

 
 

Who is online


devangelical


68 visitors