The Kentucky county clerk facing potentially stiff penalties for refusing to issue same-sex marriage licenses has been married four times, raising questions of hypocrisy and selective application of the Bible to her life.
The divorces, documented in court records obtained by U.S. News, show that Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis divorced three times, first in 1994, then 2006 and again in 2008.
She gave birth to twins five months after divorcing her first husband. They were fathered by her third husband but adopted by her second. Davisworked at the clerk's office at the time of each divorce and has since remarried.
Davis has described her desire to strictly adhere to the Bible in stark terms and thus far has shown no sign of bending to court orders on same-sex marriage. She said Tuesday she fears going to hell for violating "a central teaching" of the Bible if she complies with the orders.
Davis' struggle to exempt herself from the Supreme Court's June decision legalizing same-sex marriage has excited some Christian conservatives but legally has proven futile: The Supreme Court refused her request Monday that the justices intervene, and a federal judge will decide Thursday whether to hold her in contempt.
Davis divorce records, in the meantime, are a popular file at the local courthouse, a woman who answered the phone tells U.S. News, as bloggers and social media users titter with accusations of hypocrisy.
The matter first attracted public attention in July, when WKYT-TV reporter Victor Puente made a passing on-air reference to the fact that Davis latest marriage certificate shows she was married four times. Davis office stores that document.
Davis did not respond to an emailed request for comment, and her offices phone line was busy throughout the day Tuesday.
The leader of the organization providing her legal representation, Mat Staver of Liberty Counsel, says hes not sure precisely how many husbands Davis has had, but that it's not relevant.
I know she was married more than once Ive heard three [times], he says. Its a matter of fact that shes been married multiple times.
Staver says its not really relevant, its something that happened in her past and that her conversion to Christianity about four years ago wiped her slate clean. Its something thats not relevant to the issue at hand, he says. She was 180 degrees changed.
In a Tuesday statement released by Liberty Counsel, Davis admitted she had lived an imperfect life, but insisted her current beliefs are sincere.
It is not a light issue for me, she said. It is a heaven or hell decision.
Three other Kentucky county clerks have expressed opposition to facilitating same-sex marriages, and one of them says Davis divorces in no way diminish her credibility.
Casey County Clerk Casey Davis, who is not related to Kim Davis, tells U.S. News he believes theres a difference between getting a divorce and then repenting and living in a same-sex relationship.
I dont have any problem with that whatever, how she was before. If the lord can forgive her, surely I can, he says. Thats something thats forgivable just like any other sin, but if you continue in it and live in it, theres a grave danger in that.
Casey Davis says he wasnt personally aware Kim Davishad been divorced and thathe has no desire to speak with her about that. You know this, people will say everything and all this stuff, they want to bring the worst out in the best of people. Obviously its human nature. I dont like it and no one should, he says.
The Casey County clerk currently is riding a bicycle across Kentucky to raise attention to the issue and wants DemocraticGov. Steve Beshear to call a special session of the state legislature to pass a law allowing local clerks to play no role officiating marriages and make their role mere recordkeeping.
Staver says other possible avenues include the state centralizing marriage issuance or allowing marriages to be performed without attaching the names of county clerks.
But theres no sign that will happen, and Staver acknowledges it's impossible for clerks to hold out indefinitely against ruinous fines given for contempt.
The American Civil Liberties Union, which is advocating on behalf of a male same-sex couple repeatedly denied a marriage license by KimDavis' office, is asking for fines significant enough to compel compliance.
Staver says supportive donors likely can extend Davis' resistance for at least some amount of time if fines are ordered Thursday.
Jail is also a possible tool to compel either her compliance or resignation.
#ccc;margin-bottom:2px;">
We are not asking that she go to jail, and nobody wants her to go to jail. We simply want her to do her job and follow the rule of law,"says Heather Weaver, an ACLU attorney working on the case.
Weaver says she knows nothing about Davis' personal life.
"What I would say is she's entitled to her personal religious beliefs, but she cannot impose them on others through her job as a public official," she says."Those other clerks that are refusing to issue marriage licenses should re-evaluate their strategy. They may find themselves embroiled in a lawsuit and facing contempt charges."
Her colleague Casey Davis says he wont comply or resign, perhaps making himself the next local official to be sued. But it hasnt come to that in Casey County. His higher-profile colleague is from a larger county. There are more people there that practice that lifestyle, he says.
Steven Nelson is a reporter at U.S. News & World Report. You can follow him on Twitter or reach him at snelson@usnews.com.
Source link
She's been married four times and gave birth out of wedlock, yet she says she won't issue gay marriage licenses because of her deeply held religious views on marriage? What a fucking hypocrite!!! Fine her $1000 a day and send her to jail until she complies. At least!
NOW they are going to judge her by her religious beliefs.
Typical liberal media.
Talk about hypocritical self righteousness!
And it isn't about religious beliefs...
Tell that lie to someone else.
Well, she's been washed in the blood of the Lamb, so she's clean now.
While they're at it, they ought to remove any other issues characteristic of demographics that you staunchly oppose.
Yes, they shouldabsolutely extend it to any group who: 1) is identified by a perverse oraberrantsexualbehavior; 2) demands that the state accept the behavior as normal for the purpose of marriage; and 3) has a Supreme Court decision that recognizes that a marriage is anything other than a unionbetween one man and one woman. Congress has the power to nullify a Supreme Court decision and conservatives should press it to do so rather than ask civil servants to stand up individually and risk their jobs in a fruitless act of religious defiance.
Green beans are just as good as black or red beans, but when a green bean jump up and says "Hey Baby!" you're gonna haveta .. well you know, caint have no green and red beans mixed and nobody aughta grease a wild pig and send their moonlit half-sisters after it beyond moonlight and daydreaming. Knowhatimean?
Rowan County is known to be cantankerous and "backwards"... Home of Morehead State University. My son once talked of going there to school and I suggested he look at other schools in the state, too! Thankfully, the other universities stack up much better.
If she is unable to perform her duties, she should resign. If it takes a fine or jail time for her to resign, then do it.
Jim Bunning is the federal judge in the case. He ran for the senate once, and that's the only time I voted for Mitch McConnell.
Six beans high and all jawly apple, knowwhatimean?
That would definitely include the heterosexual community. How many wives out there are taking in the can from their husbands, or orally helping them to spill their seed?
They do not identify themselves based on this behavior plus there are two other conditions. I joined them with "and" notthedisjunctive"or".
NOW they are going to judge her by her religious beliefs.
Just like she judges gays, by her religious beliefs. Make it $1500 a day until she agrees to do what she gets paid to do or resigns.
It would be better for conservatives to press congress to use its existing constitutional authority to remove the gay marriage issue from the jurisdiction of the federal court.
Which won't happen any more then Walker will build a wall between the US and Canada. LOL!
1) is identified by a perverse oraberrantsexualbehavior;
Except being gay is not. Read the DSM four and five.
This is simply a matter of pointing out that "people in glass houses shouldn't throw stones". There's no "self righteousness" in making this observation. Your indignation is misdirected.
Shoot! Listen here Chicken Little! Your horse is smaller than my cow and Mexcan jumping beans and this and that and yadda yadda so lets pretend we're communicating. Knowwhaddimean? I'll put in here some off topic fart jokes and yo'll go "wow!" and this and that and so on and so forth and this is all just a typing exercise, right?
Then somebody says "hey! That's "off topic" and calls the cops ... and the cops come and erase sombody's post and still the fart and dick jokes by the twelve year olds run the joint.
Shwee! Ders dah whoboy yadda if yo knonwwaddimean!
Now you see, I told you you need to up your game.
Otherwise you wind up with fried brains.
No excuses now, you a good ol' boy at heart?
I assume you're trying to say that, except for the deviant behavior, all people are normal. That truism would apply to all sexual perversions and establishes nothing. When a pedophile is not with a child, he is going to the movies, cooking dinner, going to ball games etc. Same for every other deviant behavior.
I've read the DSM and I know it was changed because of homosexual political pressure not some psychological breakthrough. All documented by Dr. Charles Socarides.
Not that long ago, same-sex marriage was unthinkable and yet it happened.
Do you really think that Walker will build a wall between the US and Canada? There is still as much of a chance as it happening.
We were talking about Congress restricting federal court jurisdiction, not a wall . . . and, even if we were talking about a wall, where there's a will, there's a way.
''And it isn't about religious beliefs...''
She, the clerk made it about religion.
And I compared it's likelihood and to (A) Walker being elected and (B) to him building a wall between Canada and the US. It's a valid comparison of possibilities. Neither are going to happen.
Regardless of her personal actions being hypocritical in conjunction with the issue-at-hand, the religionist ideologues constantly "justify" their anti-gay-marriage, anti-abortion, etc. positions with the words "religious-freedom-separation-of-church-and-state."
Although the words"religious-freedom-separation-of-church-and-state." do not appear anywhere in the Constitution, we get the idea.
SO, HOW IS IT THAT KIM DAVIS HAS FAILED TO SEPARATE HER RELIGION FROM A MATTER OF STATE AND IN CONTEMPT OF A SUPREME COURT RULING?
And, since Kim Davis "works for God"
John 13:34
Conservative hypocrisy feeds on a steady diet of hatred and discrimination and blames it on God!
Can you be less specific?
SO, HOW IS IT THAT KIM DAVIS HAS FAILED TO SEPARATE HER RELIGION FROM A MATTER OF STATE AND IN CONTEMPT OF A SUPREME COURT RULING?
Because she's a fucking hypocrite.
It was changed because the Psychiatric community couldn't find a valid reason for it to be in there in the first place, so they removed it. It is not a definable mental illness and never was. It was in there in the first place due to political pressure to include it.
It was in there for clinical reasons and removed for political ones because homosexuals were turning up to protest at every event the psychiatric association held. But it really doesn't matter to me what they think since psychiatry is based on opinion rather than science (and more like social science than medicine).
No, I just say what I think is right even if I'm the only one saying it. Running with the herd is for cattle and sheep.
You don't speak for "everyone". You're free to walk in circles with the others bleating how right you all are just as I am free to stand apart.
Yep.
Dowser - she isn't "unable" to perform her duties - she "refuses" to perform marriage to same sex couples because of her religious beliefs.
Randy - her religious beliefs have nothing to do with how many times she was/is married - unless she's Catholic - which she ain't.
Randy - her religious beliefs have nothing to do with how many times she was/is married - unless she's Catholic - which she ain't.
Of course they do because she is using them as a reason NOT to do her job! SHE brought her religious beliefs into this dispute and no one else. Her religious beliefs are central to her reasoning not to issue marrlage licenses to gay couples. Her previous history shows her to be a hypocrite of the very lowest kind! She said that she was a sinner and was forgiven. She considers gay marriage to be a sin. So she is saying that her religious beliefs require that gay couples follow her religious teachings! Which is illegal according to the fact that the SCOTUS refused to over-turn the lower court's ruling. I know there is little chance she'll go to jail, but I am hoping for at least a $1000 a day fine until she complies and then jail after a set time if she still refuses. What she is doing is a criminal act. That's a sin too. To say her religious beliefs have nothing to do with this is absurd! You con NOT put your version of the magic sky fairy above the law!!
I know, dear 1st. She sees it that she is "unable", but the truth is, she won't . She is being hard-headed.
Much love to you!
SCOTUS has stated that you can't force a person/corporation to do anything contrary to your religious beliefs - Hobby Lobby.
Try again.
Foolish and arrogant schmuckery at its finest. You have the Blue Ribbon! Congratulations. You're a winner!
Now I shall return to ignoring you.
" It was in there in the first place due to political pressure to include it."
Precisely correct.
It was in there for clinical reasons and removed for political ones
Not according to every Psychiatrist I know. And I don't just mean the ones I have seen as a patient. Being married to a Psychiatric RN for 20 years means most of your friends are Psychiatrists, Psychologists, Psychiatric RN's, Therapists of various kinds, etc. and you all hang out together (there is nothing funner or funnier then a bunch of drunk mental health professionals
). They all say it should have never been in there in the first place as it never was a definable mental illness and putting it in there was done because of pressure from moralists. It was taken back out because, as they say, it's never been a definable mental illness so it never belonged there in the first place. Sure there were some protesters saying it shouldn't be there, but the bulk of the Psychiatric community already agreed with the protesters anyway, so it would have been removed even if no one had made a peep about trying to get it removed.
Lucky bastard...
Homosexuality and pedophilia both concern an adult human desiringsomething abnormal.Both were considered diseaseswarranting treatment. One no long is, but not because of any science I have seen.
Yes. Orange.
Her views evolved after she was "born again." Obama's positions evolved also, although he was already technically Christian.
Because she is the opposite: true to her beliefs.
I wouldn't support either of them. However, she has the right to make her stand. She will likely lose in court.
That Quaker pacifism quote totally nailed it, AMAC! LOL
Randy: "They all say it should have never been in there in the first place as it never was a definable mental illness and putting it in there was done because of pressure from moralists."
BINGO!
One no long is, but not because of any science I have seen.
That's because there was never any science put out to rationalize it being in there in the first place. Since there was no science or reason to put it in there in the first place (beyond the insistence of the stiff neck religionistas) there was no scientific reason not to remove it. It simply did not belong there.
Being gay is not pedophilia (give that lie and association a rest. It's a sign of raw ignorance. Try to be better then that shit, OK? It's a worn out pile of shit.) and it's not a definable mental illness. It simply is not and never was.
It was put in there due to pressure from religious moralists, not because it was or is a mental illness. Psychiatrists realized this and remove it from the DSM IV. Again, it had nothing to do with any protests and it would have been removed anyway. The Psychiatric community agreed that those who didn't think it belonged there were right.
It was not removed because of political pressure. It was in there in the first place because of political (religious) pressure. The DSM IV is a professional correction concerning homosexuality, not a political caving in.
Oh and BTW, being gay is not an abnormal craving. It is simply a different normal one. And yes, that is different then being a pedophile, which is an abnormal craving since it involves helpless children. Pedophilia is about power, not sex or love. You can believe different if you choose, but you'll still be wrong if you do.
That may be what your friends tell you but Dr. Charles Socarides was there when it was removed from the DSM and he tells adifferentstory as do others who were there. BTW, I talked to Socarides personally years ago and what's represented in this article is what he told me.
http://traditionalvalues.org/content/article/30884/Exposed:%20The%2...
By thatreasoning, nothing should be considered abnormal.
Although everyhomosexualis not a pedophile, every male pedophile who has sex with boys is a homosexual. But back tohomosexuality, the act requires sex in a manner for which the body was obviously not designed and is a misuse of a procreative function. Whether dubbed unnatural or out of balance (a yin/yang approach), it is simply abnormal. It should never be acceptedas normaland never presented to children as a viable alternative to healthy heterosexual sex.
So she can play the "born again" card ? What if everybody could do that ? For whatever random reason they say they can't perform their jobs because of their beliefs ? You have to be kidding, the result would be mayhem !
Because she is the opposite: true to her beliefs.
Wrong. Fucking hypocrite is the correct answer. Thanks for playing though. Don't forget to pick up your home game version of the show on your way out.
And rightfully so. We are not a Christian nation. Or any religion of a nation as a matter of fact. Compared to the law her religion means exactly dick.
In Japan there are times of year when they worship the penis . Would that make a good addition to US beliefs ?
Hobby Lobby - how's that for dick?
Breaking News
Kim Davis was led out of court in handcuffs, in the custody of federal marshals, after being declared in contempt of court.
Ah crap. Another martyred American Christian. (S)
The irony here is she would have probably only been find, (for her blatant contempt of court), if it wasn't for the gofundme gold digging Pizza & bakery owners.
Judge decided that a court fine would just make her rich, not chastise her for breaking the law, so he used the only option left to him.
Oh well, she's earned what she's getting.
One fundamental misunderstanding (delusion) common to many religionists, is that religious beliefs trump laws. Believing in the tenets, dogmas, rituals and practices of one's religion is not license to overrule i.e. The Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.
Regardless of the Hobby Lobby SCOTUS decision, which, IMO is contrary to the 14th Amendment clause, it differs from RFRA, etc. tenets, in that it addressed whether or not a business can be made to pay for a benefit, etc., that is contrary to the religious beliefs of a business owner/employer. That the "benefit" in question re: the Hobby Lobby case, is otherwise accessible, again IMO, gave the SCOTUS the latitude to decide as it did.
The fact that the argument made on behalf of Hobby Lobby was factually incorrect (namely that ACA-plan related contraceptives are "abortifacient" -- WHICH THEY ARE NOT -- was said not to matter by Justice Alito for one. The idea that a "religious belief" (no matter how factually flawed) can trump reality, makes the HL SCOTUS decision FUCKING DANGEROUS.
My two cents.
Davis' being ruled in contempt of a SCOTUS decision, ironically, (AGAIN, IMO), contradicts the Hobby Lobby decisions' (ir)rationality. Either "religious beliefs" trump the law, or they don't.
It can't logically be both at once.
Hole, dick, tongue or fingers, even toes go for it as long as all involved are copacetic. You aren't, so go play with who you like to and leave the ones who play differently than you alone. Go try and impress your morals on a cat.
Conscientious objectors must serve in some capacity other than combat, apply for a discharge or, go to jail (Sgt. Alvin -- York before reconsidering and coming to the understanding that he could serve both God and Country; Muhammed Ali went to prison).
FYI:
Hobby Lobby - how's that for dick?
Not even CLOSE to the same thing. They are a privately held company (at which I'll never shop and still disagree with the SCOTUS on) and she is a sworn public employee. So her religion still means exactly dick.
By thatreasoning, nothing should be considered abnormal.
That comment made no sense in relation to what I said. Did you read what I wrote before you posted? Sure doesn't seem so.
Although everyhomosexualis not a pedophile, every male pedophile who has sex with boys is a homosexual.
Nope. Doesn't matter which gender a pedophile has sex with. Their own or opposite. They're still just a pedophile and not a homosexual. Pedophiles are not about sex, they are about power. Any person who has sex with children is a pedophile and the genders of the adult and the child are meaningless to the definition. They are still just a pedophile.
Homosexuals are about sex and love with adult members of their own gender. Big difference. You really don't know much about psychiatry or psychology or gender orientation, do you? Of course there are many young people who identify themselves as being gay (or transgendered (medical issue) or transexual or bisexual or even straight (who'd have thought about that last one, huh?
), but that has nothing to do with pedophilia.
Whether dubbed unnatural or out of balance (a yin/yang approach), it is simply abnormal. It should never be acceptedas normaland never presented to children as a viable alternative to healthy heterosexual sex.
I disagree. I think that it is both natural (lots of animals have homosexual relations and relationships) and normal and that children should be taught that it is natural and normal also, because it is. Human beings are animals, primates, and like almost every other higher form of animal, we have a rich tradition and history of homosexuality
No offense (sincerely), but people who think like you do are quickly becoming antiquated.
May she sit in jail for a long time. Keep the male guards away from her she has a past affliction to mattress boogie. Married or not.
Yes you can force them, because she is a public servant and therefore a government employee. She does not have the right to disobey the law even if it goes against her religious beliefs. She had the options of issuing the licenses (as the law says she must), resigning or going to jail. She decided that she wanted to go to jail. She and no one else, is responsible for her being in jail. She has no one to blame but herself.