╌>

A Forgivable Genocide: Part 1

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  12 years ago  •  52 comments

A Forgivable Genocide: Part 1

By Bob Nelson

Part 1 - Historical background

Article Photo

To the victors go the spoils

Defeat in the Great War brought down the house of cards that was the Ottoman Empire. The victors, Great Britain and France, scrambled to gather up as much influence, oil, land and population as possible. At the time, European countries still held their world-wide empires, so they naturally considered their action in the Middle East to be a just another form of empire-building.

The Ottomans' administrative units (known as "sanjak" and named for the administrative seat) were ignored when the Allies drew their lines on their maps, just as ethnic groups and relief features had been ignored in Africa.

The land east of the Jordan River, Sanjak Kerak, had been ruled from Damascus under the Ottomans. Damascus was in the French sphere, so the British, who intended to control the region through the local sheiks with whom they had allied themselves against the Turks, needed a means of carving it loose.

Article Photo

They found a means in the "Palestine Mandate". The "mandates" were agreements among the Allies, confirmed by the League of Nations, for the administration of former Ottoman territories. The British "traded" the Golan Heights, which the French wanted as part of their "Syrian Mandate", for the land east of the Jordan River... or perhaps east of the Hejaz Railway, the limits being very unclear!

During the Great War, the British were most magnanimous! They were quick to distribute land to people they wanted as friends... land that they did not in fact control... land that was still part of the Ottoman Empire. Sometimes they were so magnanimous that they gave the same land to two different people! Or at least they were not very careful about the boundaries of their "gifts", leaving a bit of overlap here and there between them.

Article Photo

In 1915, they promised land (McMahon-Hussein correspondence) to the Arabs... without actually defining its limits. The British specified areas that were not included... but did not specify what land was included! In any case, this land was "somewhere" east of the Jordan.

Also during the war, the British promised a homeland to the Jews -- the famous Balfour Declaration of 1917... which did not specify any boundaries, either! Balfour himself considered that the new country should "extend east of the Jordan but not include the Hejaz Railway".

These two British promises are each so vague that they may... or may not... overlap geographically. They also may or may not overlap politically.

The Balfour Declaration included the phrase, "it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine"... without defining its meaning. At the time, displacing a few hundred thousand people would not have been considered unacceptable, if it was done humanely, and if living conditions on arrival were as good as those left behind. The same sort of massive displacement was done all over Europe, to collect all of an ethnic group within its national boundaries. Quotes from Balfour seem to indicate that this was his presumption for Jews and Muslims in Palestine, but nothing was explicit, and certainly nothing was official.

The victors of WWI (Great Britain, France, Italy and Japan) met at San Remo, Italy, to finalize the dissection of the Ottoman Empire. The San Remo Resolution (25 April 1920) reconfirmed the objective "of the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country."

Already, in 1920, the British were afraid that their Arab allies from the Great War would attack the French in Damascus. The British felt they needed to find political solutions that would "calm" the Arabs. The Cairo Conference of March 1921 decided (among others) to give the land east of the Jordan to Abdullah ibn Hussein, while excluding that land from any eventual Jewish homeland... but not excluding it from the Muslim portion of the Balfour Declaration...

Thus was created the Emirate of Transjordan.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Please take note of a common misconception.The Balfour Declaration and the state of Israel had nothing to do with WWII but WWI.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

You found it! (I thought he had posted it on at least 2 sites I know of, but later deleted both...?)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

BF,

I have to say that after reading this article on NV years ago, I checked out the info and it's amazing how little people know about the history of WWI and the 20th century history of the ME yet talk about it with great authority. There are two other parts to come but I figured I would post it the way it was posted on NV.

Thanks to Bob Nelson for his permission to repost it here.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Perrie

Very interesting and informative article

Thanks for sharing

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

Interesting stuff. Thanks.

When I get in conversations with people about the middle east it often seems they know little about the people themselves. I highly recommend T. E. Lawrence's book The Seven Pillars of Wisdom. It gives a good understanding of the shaping of the area and the raging power struggles. Plus, it's just a good read.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

You are missing a very important point. After WWI this went on not only in the ME but also all over Europe. This is what happens after war. Furthermore, this is no different than what the Ottoman Empire did. Finally, the Jews that were living in the area, were always in that area.

And in the next parts you will see that the other Arab nations also chased the arabs that lived in their countries out, yet people only focus on Israel. Why is it that?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Grump,

Thanks for the recommendation. I agree that most people don't know the history of the region, or become hyper focused on one nation or another. They were all chasing people out of one country or another. Most people don't know that during the Iranian Revolution that up to 60,000 Iranians were killed during the revolution and an unknown number fled, yet that seems to be forgotten.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I find this even more surprising-- most westerners don't know that Iran& Iraq fought a long and bitter war. Maybe 800,000 casuaties! Saddam totally at fault-- he started it. He also used poison gas on iranian civilians. (And Kurds).

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

It seems that the argument you are making is that the Palestinians should "get over it", and in fact that argument makes sense. But not to the Palestinians and other aggrieved Arabs, evidently.

To a degree. These people were given a land of their own. That was the plan. Furthermore, there was no real "homeland" that they had. In many ways they are/ were like the Kurds, yet no one is outraged that Iran, Turkey, Iraq and Syria control their land. In fact, no one even thinks about the Kurds at all. It seems that there is no outrage when it is Muslim on Muslim injustice.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Of course we know that to the victors go the spoils is a time tested way of acquiring land. What is different in this case is that the 'conquered' or 'aggrieved' people have kept up an active resistance basically since the day the action (of "giving" the land to Israel ) was taken.

The state of Israel was re-established in 1948. (And there were no settlements 'till after 1967! ). But Arabs living in the area (there was no such thing as a "Palestinian" state or ethnicity until '67) were having violent Pogroms and killing Jews in the area many, many years before 1948.Frown.gif

And "resistance"? It seems the only thing they were resisting was getting along with their non-Muslim (be they jews, Chritins, or Druze) neighbours..Frown.gif Frown.gif

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Great point Perrie. Everyone focuses on the founding of Israel like it is unique in modern history. After WWI, central and eastern Europe were entirely reconstructed. Completely new nations were formed as Poland, Austria, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia, and others. Millions of people within the various ethnic groups voluntarily moved or were forcibly displaced to other countries or areas. After WWII, upwards of 12 million ethnic Germans were brutally uprooted from homes which had been lived in for generations with the barest of possessions and forced back into the much smaller new states of West and East Germany. Did they cry about it for 60+ years? Have we heard about terrorist Germans murdering thousands of people in retaliation in the following years? No, they sucked it up, rebuilt their lives, and moved on.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Of course we know that to the victors go the spoils is a time tested way of acquiring land. What is different in this case is that the 'conquered' or 'aggrieved' people have kept up an active resistance basically since the day the action (of "giving" the land to Israel ) was taken.

Wrong again! Of the "British Mandate of Palestine", the vast majority of land (over 60%) was given to the Arabs-- not the jews! (This Arab ruled Palestinian majority state is now called "Jordan").

A second 100% Palestinian-ruled state now exits in Gaza.

"to the victors go the spoils" ( six day war)'

Well-- sort of. They actually returned the vast majority of land:

The Jews conquered the entire huge Sinai Pensinsula in '67. Yup-- along with the oil patches that were discovered there. They returned it to Egypt in exchange for peace (both sides got what they wanted :-)

Gaza had been occupied (by Egypt-- it was never any "Palestine")). Control passed to "the victors" (Israel) in '67. They built settlements there. But-- in 2005 they left-- turning control over to the Arabs. There's no longer a "victor" (Jew) in the entire place. palestinians now have 100% self-tule in Gazar

And those settlements-- that were supposedly a "permanent obstacle to peace"? They are no longer...

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Also, tens of thousands of child soldiers were pitilessly sacrificed by the Ayatollah Khomeini in that war. With little more than a symbolic key to Paradise around their necks, they sent waves of children to clear minefields with their bodies.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

John,

Most of Israel is secular. I am aware of religious zealots, and like most, they not only tend to get the most attention, but also tend to stir the pot. It isn't what I believe. I do believe in the original idea of a two state solution.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Exactly Mike. And we are not talking about land masses as tiny as a country the that is less than the size of NJ. The fixation on this tiny spot is ridiculous.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Excellent article Perrie. A good history lesson for many.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Great stuff Perrie...I believe there are more installments as well. Did you get this off Bob's blog, or did you save it, or somewhere else...?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

the region had been inhabited by Arabs for hundreds of years.

True-- but the area has been inhabited continuously by Jews for thousands of years..

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

And before the Jews it was inhabited by other people.

Well, it is inhabited by the Jews now and no matter how much you, a billion Muslims, and who knows how many anti-Semites wish otherwise, they aren't going anywhere. Since the birth of the State of Israel in 1948, they have proven to have both the brains and the balls to keep their land.

They have my respect for their achievements and my full support for their future.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

The fixation on this tiny spot is ridiculous.

Not if you have a fixation about jews.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Fascinating article, and well worth the read! Thanks for posting it!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Who is Goldberg mentioned in this article?

I don't have the time right now, but there are many inaccuracies in this article like this one:

The economist published an odd assertion that the Negev Desert was empty and should not have been shown in the first map. But it wasnt and isnt empty; Palestinian Bedouin live there, and they and the desert were recognized by the League of Nations as belonging to the Mandate of Palestine, a state-in-training.

First, the Bedouin are not Palestinian. Second, they still live in the Negev and thrive there. No one else lives in the Negev but the Bedouin, and they have a large tourist business there.

I'll get to the rest later.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

John - that's really interesting. I went to the link and could find no reference to "reference" materials (other than the links listed in the article). Thanks.

I wonder - is there really a viable source with more information, that a layman could understand, available?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Thanks. I printed it out so I could take it home and read to have time to question and digest the enormous history.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Until Jews began to return to the region in large numbers, after World War I, the region had been inhabited by Arabs for hundreds of years. In 1915 there were something like 10 times as many Arabs as Jews in Palestine, and even when the state of Israel was created in the late 40's there were still more Arabs than Jews in Palestine.

Actually Jews resided in Palestine continually since thebiblical era though their percentage rose and fell. European Jews began returning in great numbers in 1871, during Ottoman rule,not 1915. But contrary to your false impression they did not "steal" the land of others.

In 1948 Israel 9 % of the land was Jewish owned, 20 % was Arab owned including the land abandoned by the Arabs who fled, and 71 % wasex-British domain .

Zionists did start showing up in droves in 1871. However, they moved into land purchased for ten times the price of black American farmland. No reputable person even accuses Jews of stealing land before the refugees fled after the UN partition.

The population went up and down over the centuries. There were seven million Jews in the Roman Empire in 70 CE when Jewish independence ended, according to Josephus, and there were 3 million 60 years later when large numbers were either killed, fled, or were deported after a revolt. While there were about 200,000 people in Palestine (including what is now Jordan ) in 1785, by the mid 1800s this had been reduced to 50-100,000 as a result of drought and Bedouin raids.

In the mid 1700s British archaeologist Thomas Shaw wrote that the land in Palestine was "lacking in people to till its fertile soil." Also in the Eighteenth century, French author and historian, Count Volney, wrote of Palestine as the "ruined" and "desolate" land. "Many parts --- lost almost all their peasantry. In others --- the recession was great but not so total. --- upwards of 3200 villages were reckoned; but at present, the collector can scarcely find 400. --- Our merchants have themselves seen the greater part of the environs become depopulated. The traveler meets with nothing but houses in ruins, cisterns rendered useless, and fields abandoned. Those who cultivated them have fled."

In 1817-18 travelers reported that there was not "a single boat of any description on the lake [Tiberias.] in am 1827 German encyclopedia Palestine was depicted as "desolate and roamed through by Arab bands of robbers." In 1840 a traveler wrote that the once populated area between Hebron and Bethlehem was now "abandoned and desolate" with dilapidated towns. The "masses" of Jerusalem were estimated at less than 15,000, of whom more than half were Jews.

In 1843, A. Kieth wrote in "The Land of Israel," that, in Volney's day, "The land had not fully reached its last prophetic degree of desolution and depopulation."

The British Counsel reported in 1857 that "The country is in a considerable degree empty of inhabitants and therefore ITS GREATEST NEED IS THAT OF A BODY OF POPULATION."

In the 1860s it was reported that "depopulation is even now advancing." At the same time H. B. Tristram noted in his journal that: "The north and south of the [ Sharon plain] land is going out of cultivation and whole villages are rapidly disappearing from the face of the earth. Since 1838 no less than 20 villages have been erased from the map [by marauding Bedouin] and the stationary population extirpated."

When Mark Twain toured Palestine in 1867 he wrote the following:

"Stirring scenes --- occur in the valley [Jezreel] no more. There is not a solitary village throughout its whole extent -- not for 30 miles in either direction. There are two or three small clusters of Bedouin tents, but not a single permanent habitation. One may ride ten miles hereabouts and not see ten humans.---- We reached Tabor safely--- we never saw a human being on the whole route. Nazarath is forlorn. --- Jericho the accursed lies a moldering ruin today... 'Peace on earth, good will towards men' is untenanted by any living creature.--- Bethsaida and Chorzin have vanished from the earth, and the 'desert places' around them, where thousands once listened to the Savior's voice --- sleep in the hush of a solitude that is inhabited only by birds of prey and skulking foxes."

While there was always a Jewish presence in the cities, European Jews began coming in a small but steady stream in the 1870s-80s. This is called the First Aliyah. They settled largely in Western Palestine, along the Mediterranean coast north of Jerusalem roughly between Jaffa and Haifa , and along the West bank of the Jordan north of what is now called the West Bank territory. This aliyah was followed by several others; the Second Aliyah from 1907 to 1917, the Third after the war, and the Fourth following 1924-5 which followed the closing of America to Eastern European Jews.

Just as now, where neighboring Arabs are largely dependent for work on Israeli employers, so was the situation always.

Who has heard of Jews seeking employment in Ramallah, Nablus or Bethlehem ? As Jews cleared swamps and reclaimed land, and later as they built industry, Neighboring impoverished Arabs came to work from both within Palestine and from neighboring countries; Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, etc. When they had work at all in their place of origin, they were felahin, tenant farmers that worked for effindis, large landowners.

There were not enough workers for the labor-intensive tasks among the Jews. Under the British mandate, however, only Jewish immigrants were kept careful track of by the Ottoman Empire .

The significant point about the new gentile arrivals is that they were headed to the same place as the Jewish immigrants -- to seek work. Quoting Dr. John Voss, Chairman of the American Christian Palestine committee in 1953:

"The Arab population of Palestine was small and limited until Jewish resettlement restored the barren lands and drew to it Arabs from neighboring countries."

There is more of the same in later years. There was large-scale immigration of both Jews and Arabs. Winston Churchill said in 1939, "So far from being persecuted, the Arabs have crowded into the country and multiplied till their population has increased more than even all world Jewry could lift up the Jewish population." [Martin Gilbert, Churchill, vol. 5, p. 1072.]

And Franklin D. Roosevelt said: Arab immigration into Palestine since 1921 has vastly exceeded the total Jewish immigration during this whole period.

The following is taken from the peace-oriented, largely objective MidEastWeb.

"Under the British Mandate which began after WWI, Jewish population increased due to immigration, especially in the 1930s. Arab population also increased at an exceptional rate, so that according to birthrate figures, Palestinian Arabs had the highest birthrate figures of any Arab country. Joan Peters, in her book "From Time Immemorial," argues that most of this increase was in fact due to illegal Arab immigration. Norman Finkelstein and others have criticized her thesis and shown evidence of poor scholarship.

"Finkelstein's analysis also shows that the largest increases of Palestinian Arab population occurred close to Jewish population centers in Palestine , which would argue against the Palestinian contention that the Zionists were dispossessing Arabs.

"We do not know if this increase was due to population shifts in Palestine or immigration from outside Palestine . It is certain that there was at least some illegal Palestinian-Arab immigration, as noted in British mandatory reports. Immigration from Transjordan was not illegal, and was not recorded as immigration at all until 1938. During World War II, the British recruited Arab workers from the Houran in Syria and elsewhere. Arabs also came to Palestine before the war, attracted by higher wages. However, since much of the depletion of Palestinian population that had occurred in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries was due to migration to neighboring countries, many of these returning Arabs may have been families returning to Palestine ."

T he point is that, while in some areas population was predominantly Arab, in other areas Jewish population was considerable. This was considered in forming the borders when the UN recommended partition in 1947.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Population exchanges are not that unusual, dwarfing what we are talking about here. In 1913 Turkey and Bulgaria had an equal population exchange and in 1923 Turkey and Greece exchanged over a million Greeks and about 350,000 Turks. From 1933 to 1945 over 79 MILLION people were displaced; since WW 2 an additional 100 MILLION people have become refugees. In the 50s there was an exchange between India and Pakistan where over eight million Sikhs and Hindus from Pakistan fled to India and over six million Muslims moved from India to Pakistan.

Most of these people are no longer refugees because resettlement and integration has been considered to be the normal and humanitarian course. Throughout history, people who felt unsafe or uncomfortable migrated to places where they felt safer. There is an international legal precedent for granting refugees the privilege of living in dignity as citizens in their new countries. Consider all the Muslims who have moved to Europe and even the USA. Why is it so far fetched to have Palestinian Arabs move to neighboring Arab nations?

Only the Palestinian refugees from 1948 and 1967 are treated as somehow "privileged;" as if they were in an affirmative action program. 900,000 Jewish refugees were absorbed by Israel in the late forties, and many Russian, Ethiopian and other refugees since. But the Palestinian refugees are rejected by other Arabs for political reasons; to hold them as a hammer over Israel. They are ineligible for employment in Syria for instance. The UN Works and Relief Agency (UNWRA), a UN bureaucracy of over 10,000 Palestinian employees and less than 1,000 others and is mostly financed by the USA, has been responsible for the Palestinian refugees since its formation.

Unfortunately the UN goes beyond giving rhetorical support for terrorism. In a variety of ways, its agencies have been complicit in Middle Eastern terror, beginning with the refugee camps.

Unfortunately, none of the above considerations motivate the opponents of Israel's existence. It is clear that the objection is religiously based. ME Muslims cannot stand to have a Dhimmi infidel nation in their midst. That is really the beginning and the end of all the arguments.

The 1948 war, the Jewish argument continues, erupted because the Arabs rejected the UN partition plan. Since many of the Palestinian Arabs were in fact aliens, they quickly left the country to return to their permanent homelands. Only the persistent refusal of the rulers of the Arab countries prevented them from being absorbed there. The Jewish refugees from the Arab countries were, on the other hand, cared for and rehabilitated. The result was an "exchange of populations" which should have been confirmed in a political agreement; only Arab intransigence has kept this from taking place.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Excellent Buzz.

palestinian-loss-of-land-1946-2010

The maps shown above have been widely circulated by the BDS movement, and they are misleading and dishonest. They appear in the Zionism Unsettled study guide. They appear on the websites of the Israel Palestine Mission Network (IPMN) and the Presbyterian Peace Fellowship (PPF). They also appear in the supporting materials for the BDS overtures submitted to the 2014 Presbyterian General Assembly.

The intent of the maps is clear: to falsely demonstrate an ethnic cleansing that did not occur, one perpetrated by the colonizer Jews upon indigenous Arabs (the incendiary words colonizer, indigenous, and ethnic cleansing are used repeatedly in BDS literature).

In 1946 the area labeled Palestine was the British Mandate of Palestine . All who lived there were Palestinians, Arab Palestinians and Jewish Palestinians. In the 1946 map these terms change. The Arab Palestinians are now simply Palestinians. The word Palestinian now means Arab and no longer refers to all of the people who live there, and the Jewish Palestinians are simply Jews. In 1946 Jews paid over 50% of property taxes in Palestine. Almost half of the land was public land, owned by no one and administered by the British. The premise that the land was almost all Arab land is nonsense. It was shared land and belonged to no particular ethnic group.

Now lets consider the 1967 map in terms of ethnic cleansing, keeping in mind that before 1948, both Jews and Arabs lived in all of the areas of the British Mandate of Palestine, including the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem. It is quite common to hear that the entire West Bank is Arab Land and always has been, but numerous Jewish communities existed in what is now the West Bank prior to 1948. These communities were attacked and wiped outby Arab mobs in 1920, 1929 and 1936 and during thewar waged by Arab militias and Arab governments in 1947-48. Here are some facts:

Until it was wiped out by Arab riots in 1929 in what is known as the Hebron Massacre , there was a large Jewish community in the center of Hebron

The Jewish population of Jerusalem (which has had a Jewish majority since at least the second half of the 19 th century) was dispossessed by the Arab riots of 1929 and 1936 (when Jews fled most of what is now called the Muslim Quarter). In 1948, the Jordanian Legion expelled all of the Jews then living in what is now East Jerusalem and destroyed its holy places.

Sizeable tracts of land owned by Jews in the rural West Bank including the Gush Etzion settlements , land between Nablus, Jenin and Tulkarm, and in Bethlehem and Hebron were seized by the Jordanians in 1948.

The Jewish settlements north of Jerusalem, Atarot and Neve Yaakov, were evacuated in 1948, under the declared threat of advancing Arab armies to massacre all the Jews in their path.

Today, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians live on land in and around Jerusalem that is still owned by the Jewish National Fund, including the Kalandia refugee camp and the Deheishe refugee camp south of Bethlehem.

Photo below: Jews being expelled from Old City by Jordanian forces 1948

JordanianforcesexpelJewsfromtheOldCity1948

Here are some 1967 figures:

Arab population of Israel: 390,000

Jewish population of West Bank: none

Jewish population of Gaza Strip:none

Jewish population of East Jerusalem: none

In 1967, the only land in in Israel-Palestine that was ethnically cleansed was the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip. All three areas were 100% ethnically cleansed of Jews after the 1948 war. In addition to the photo above, review these additional 1948 historic photos of Jews expelled from the Old City .

The 2010 map misses the 1.4 million Arab citizens of Israel, who live and own land throughout Israel, and the thousands of Palestinians who own land and live in areas of the West Bank subject to Israeli security. It also fails to reveal that at the present time, the only ethnically cleansed land in Israel-Palestine is the Gaza Strip, which is ethnically cleansed of Jews. The population of Jews in Gaza is zero. Below is another table of interest, describing the ethnic cleansing of neighboring countries since 1948:

Jewish Population

1948

2005

Algeria

140,000

0

Egypt

75,000

100

Iraq

135,000

60

Lebanon

5,000

50

Libya

38,000

0

Morocco

265,000

3,500

Syria

30,000

100

Tunisia

105,000

1,100

Yemen

55,000

200

TOTAL

848,000

5,110

Arab Population of Israel

300,000

1,400,000

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

A hamas missile landing on your head probably wouldn't convince you John. So no, I'm not surprised about your persuasion.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

If reams of facts cannot persuade John, I wonder if she could persuade him.

3936_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Didn't the Balfour also establish (at least on a map) Kurdistan?

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Another interesting fact. The State of Israel almost came into existence 50 before it actually did and would have been due to the German Kaiser Wilhelm II. The founder of Zionism, Theodore Herzl, wrote "The Jewish State" in 1896 and actually met with the German Kaiser in Constantinople and Jerusalem in 1898 who was receptive to establishing a Jewish state in Palestine as a German protectorate. Ironically, it did not progress further as influential German Jews felt themselves assimilated as Germans and saw no need to move to an inhospitable desert despite the ancient ties to the Jewish homeland.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

All true,,,staggering, but true.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

If Israel "stole" the land from anyone....

1. Before Israel control of the West bank began (1967) it was part of Jordan-- there was no such thing as the mythical state of "Palestine" there. (Or anywhere) So if Israel "stole" the West bank-- they "stole" it from Jordan.

2. Before Israel occupied Gaza, it was illegally occupied by Egypt. So if Israel "stole" Gaza from anyone, it would be Egypt. There was never any such thing as the mythical state of Palestine in Gaza either.

Before that? Well, both were part of the British Mandate.

Before that? Who did Britain "steal" it from? The Ottoman Empire....

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

The information I am seeing is that Arabs greatly outnumbered Jews in the area during all of the time between say the mid 19th century until the establishment of the state of Israel.

I told you that the 1947 UN partition allocated Arabs the areas in which they were the majority.

I also told you, with Churchill's and FDR's quotes for verification, as well as the Mideast Web,that there was more Arab immigration than Jewish since the mid 19th century and that Jews either bought the land they owned or received state land.

So what is your problem?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

First, the Bedouin are not Palestinian. Second, they still live in the Negev and thrive there. No one else lives in the Negev but the Bedouin, and they have a large tourist business there.

And many of them volunteer to enlist in the IDF-- to defend the country that they love (Israel!):

Muslim Arab Bedouins serve as Jewish states gatekeepers

The army jeep rolls to a halt and Lieutenant Colonel Magdi Mazarib hops off the back to take a closer look at the dirt path running along Israels border fence with Lebanon.

He kneels, his sharp eyes scouring an unassuming constellation of pebbles, possible proof of an unwanted entry into Israel, and satisfied with what he sees, he jumps back onto the jeep and trundles away down the track.

Mazarib is a Bedouin, a Muslim Arab who grew up in northern Israel, intimate with its green, hilly landscape from an early age.

He is also the Israeli armys highest-ranking tracker and commands a small unit of Bedouin soldiers who use their field craft skills to serve as the Jewish states gatekeepers.

As part of a minority within the Arab Israeli community, itself a minority among the Jews of Israel, Mazarib is at ease protecting his countrys borders from other Arabs, fellow Muslims.

This is our country, he states simply in perfect Hebrew with a light Arabic accent.

(Cont'd)

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Sweet!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Here are some 1967 figures:

Arab population of Israel: 390,000

Jewish population of West Bank: none

Jewish population of Gaza Strip:none

Jewish population of East Jerusalem: none

In 1967, the only land in in Israel-Palestine that was ethnically cleansed was the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip. All three areas were 100% ethnically cleansed of Jews after the 1948 war. In addition to the photo above, review these additional 1948 historic photos of Jews expelled from the Old City .

True-- when Jordan occupied the West Bank & East Jerusalem, they ethnically cleansed it of Jews, destroyed Jewish Holy sites. It was only after Israel liberated the area that all holy sites wee open-- to all religions!

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

True-- when Jordan occupied the West Bank & East Jerusalem, they ethnically cleansed it of Jews, destroyed Jewish Holy sites. It was only after Israel liberated the area that all holy sites wee open-- to all religions!

Crazy isn't it? I remember seeing old pictures online of the area before Israel in "'48; sights were indisarray and unkempt....but now I can't find them...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

So ... your authoritative source is the Old Testament , not historians ? No wonder you're confused .

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Really interesting Krish. It reminds me of a group we have here in the US...The ''Shadow Wolves''. Trackers without peer. Native people that patrol part of the border with Mexico.

The drug cartels have put a $1 million bounty on their heads and also their family's.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

A very intriguing title. Not sure I am so kind as to forgive a genocide by anyone, anywhere.

In some ways, the Ottoman Empire's decline is a clear reminder of what the nationalist mindset can do to a region where a major ethnic group gains power to the exclusion of other groups.

I am sure that this article, and its remaining portions will bring forth the cry of Anti-Semite, not knowing that the semitic peoples includeAkkadians, Phoenicians, Hebrews, and Arabs.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Really interesting Krish. It reminds me of a group we have here in the US...The ''Shadow Wolves''. Trackers without peer. Native people that patrol part of the border with Mexico.

The drug cartels have put a $1 million bounty on their heads and also their family's.

When I first learned about the Bedouin I thought they must be similar in some ways to some American Indian tribes.

Most people in the Middle-East, be they Arab or Jew, live in cities, towns or villages (or kibbutzim-- Israeli collective farms).

But the Bedouin were nomadic. They are organized into tribes. They lived in the desert or the fringes of the desert. As such, they were much "closer to nature" than other peoples in the area. (Some of this is changing, many are now living in cities and towns).

When I was in Beersheva, I went to the weekly Bedouin market at the edge of town. Local Bedouin came into town to sell things-- mainly sheep and goats, as well as some handicrafts. (They also came with Camels). Very interesting-- a throwback to another era.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

That is cool Kavika!

The "Shadow Wolves" is a unit of Native American trackers . The law enforcement unit is part of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The Shadow Wolves's primary task is tracking smugglers through a 76-mile (122 km) stretch of the Tohono O'odham Nation territory that runs along the Mexico United States border in the state of Arizona . [ 1 ]

Budget:

The "Shadow Wolves" is a unit of Native American trackers . The law enforcement unit is part of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The Shadow Wolves's primary task is tracking smugglers through a 76-mile (122 km) stretch of the Tohono O'odham Nation territory that runs along the Mexico United States border in the state of Arizona . [ 1 ]

History [ edit ]

The "Shadow Wolves" law enforcement unit was created in 1972 by an Act of Congress , after the U.S. federal government agreed to the Tohono O'odham Nation 's demand that the officers have at least one fourth Native American ancestry. [ 2 ] The Shadow Wolves became the first federal law enforcement agents allowed to operate on Tohono land. [ 2 ]

The unit is congressionally authorized to have as many as 21 members but, as of March, 2007, it consisted of only 15 members. [ 2 ] Members of the unit come from nine different tribes, including the Tohono O'odham , Navajo , Sioux , Lakota , Blackfeet , Omaha , and Yaqui . [ 2 ] [ 3 ]

In 2003, the Shadow Wolves became part of the Department of Homeland Security when ICE was merged into Homeland Security . ICE officials are also considering creating a sister unit of the Shadow Wolves to patrol the Blackfeet reservation in Montana , on the U.S. border with Canada . [ 2 ]

Overview [ edit ]

The Shadow Wolves comprise an Immigration and Customs Enforcement tactical patrol unit based on the Native American Tohono Oodham Nation in southern Arizona. Shadow Wolf officers are known for their ability to track aliens and drug smugglers as they attempt to smuggle their illegal commodities across the border. The unit boasts an esteemed history of tracking passed down from generation to generation. The name Shadow Wolves refers to the way the unit hunts like a wolf pack. The Shadow Wolves were founded in 1972 as an initiative undertaken by the U.S. Congress to track drug smugglers on Native American lands in the American Southwest. Despite possession of high-tech equipment, the unit relies mainly on traditional methods of tracking, primarily a technique called cutting for sign. Cutting is searching for and analyzing sign, which includes any kind of physical evidence (footprints, tire tracks, thread, clothing, etc.). Officers may spend hours or days tracking in the field following a sign until arrests and seizures are made, or it has been determined that the contraband has been loaded into a vehicle and transported from the area. [ citation needed ]

Key Facts [ edit ]

  • The Shadow Wolves methodical approach has enabled them to track and apprehend smugglers in parts of the Southwestern U.S. across arduous desert terrain and rugged mountainous areas where tracks left by smugglers may be no more than an overturned pebble or an almost indistinguishable impression in the sand. [ 4 ]
  • An experienced Shadow Wolf can spot small items snagged on branches, twigs bent or broken, or even a single fiber of cloth or burlap from a sack or bag that could be filled with drugs. They can read faint footprints in the dust and determine when they were made, where they came from and whether or not traffickers are carrying additional weight such as backpacks filled with drugs. [ 4 ]
  • The Shadow Wolves are the Department of Homeland Securitys only Native American tracking unit. [ 4 ]
  • The Tohono Oodham Nation, patrolled by the Shadow Wolves, covers 2,800,000 acres (11,000 km 2 ) and is mainly made up of small, scattered villages. [ 4 ]
  • The current unit consists of 15 Native American Patrol Officers representing 9 Native American tribes, (Tohono Oodham, Navajo, Kiowa, Sioux, Blackfeet, Yurok, Omaha, Yaqui and Pima) who employ traditional tracking skills combined with modern law enforcement technology to enforce immigration and customs laws on the 76-mile (122 km) stretch of land the Tohono Oodham Nation shares with Mexico. [ 4 ]
  • The unit was transferred back to ICE from CBPs Border Patrol in October 2006 and is being utilized to enhance ICE investigations and operations on the Tohono Oodham Nation. [ 4 ]
  • Since transferring back to ICE in October 2006, the fifteen-member unit is responsible for the seizure of over 31,000 pounds of marijuana, over forty-three criminal arrests of smugglers and the seizure of 16 vehicles. [ 4 ]
  • Officers estimate in recent years they have seized an average of 60,000 pounds of illegal drugs a year. [ 4 ]

Global training missions [ edit ]

In addition to tracking smugglers on the U.S. border, the Shadow Wolves have also been asked to train border guards and customs agents around the world tracking smugglers, in nations including Latvia , Lithuania , Moldova , Estonia , Kazakstan , and Uzbekistan . [ 1 ] [ 1 ] [ 3 ] [ 5 ] The unit is also being used in the effort to hunt terrorists along the border of Afghanistan and Pakistan by training regional border guards in Native American ancestral sign-reading methods. [ 3 ] [ 6 ]

~WIKI~

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Yes, but then the Bedouin are not taught to hate Jews from birth as other Palestinians are.

P.S: Just a minor point--The Bedouin are not Palestinians.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I don't know if it is considered to favor one side or the other.

Sheesh-- either you're lying through your teeth--or you are extremely gullible! (My guess is its the latter):

HRW Hires Researcher from "Electronic Intifada"

Ken Roth and Human Rights Watch have employed Lucy Mair as a researcher in Israel/Occupied Territories. Ms. Mair's qualifications include writing for the "Electronic Intifada" and work with Grassroots International , a radical pro-Palestinian political organization. ( Since HRW's employment process is secret, and not subject to independent review, we are unable to compare her credentials and expertise on universal human rights issues with the other candidates.) Her descriptions of Life in Palestine , and articles for "Palestine Now" etc., focus exclusively on Palestinian "fear and the loss and the humiliation and the despair", with no mention of terror, suicide bombings, and the human rights of Israelis. References to Israeli soldiers "protected by arrogance and hatred" are hostile stereotypes, and she echoes the false massacre claims in referring to Palestinians "killed in their homes in Jenin when the tanks and the bulldozers ate up their camp" . In this extreme biased approach to Israel that extends far beyond legitimate criticism, she joins the other members of HRW's Middle East team, including Sarah Leah Whitson (from MADRE) and Joe Stork (from MERIP).

LINK

I've heard of Joe Stork-- a really sleazy, lying piece of sh*t! And MERIP-- I can't believe you attempted to con us into thinking they are "an unbiased source"--LOL.

Its one thing to present some sources that are biased toward one side and the other - -if you mention that they are biased. (I often listen to biased source-- tonight for example, I watched news on MSNBC and Fox. Haven't even looked at Fox for several months, I listen to Rachel Maddow daily. But I am aware of their respective biases, so I can filter what they say).

But to try to portray an obviously biased source as unbiased-- did you really think you culd get away with that???

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

If Palestinians loved their own children as much as they hate the Jewish children, things would be different.

 
 

Who is online







66 visitors