Should The West Do Anything About The Middle East?
The current festering wounds across the Middle East are suddenly making America popular with a variety of folks who were flag-burners only a short while ago. Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iraq, Iran--- seems like everybody wants our help (or at least our money and weapons). So many Muslim politicians and religious leaders are declaiming Obama as soft on terrorism that youd swear the Middle East was turning Republican
As predicted, without Yankee dogs and American imperialists to focus their hatred on, the multiple sectarian factions in the ME are turning on one another, as theyve been doing pretty much ever since Mohammad shuffled off to Paradise with his 72 virgins. Amidst the shifting alliances and overlapping splinter groups at this point, its damn near impossible to keep track of the players even WITH a scorecard--- the only thing thats readily apparent is that all these jokers now hate each other even more than they hate us.
Belatedly recognizing that maybe shit-canning Saddam Hussein wasnt the brightest move (you remember, the former despot whos now referred to as the watchdog), the US is now suffering from what could be labeled imperialist guilt. Ah shit, we fucked up, destabilized Iraq and squandered billions on that stupid nation-building fiasco and did the same damn thing in Afghanistan, surely we have to do something to try and fix this Things are so screwed-up now that America is on the verge of becoming buddies with Iran (bet you havent heard shit about their nuclear weapons program for a while, huh?). We have the NSA and CIA sifting through the assorted combatants looking for some moderates we can trust enough to fund and arm--- somewhat like deciding to accept a pack of feral dogs as housepets, cause at least they arent rabid.
I think theres a message to be gleaned from the resounding silence out of Britain, France & Germany (well, the whole EU really): Leave these assholes alone If the Middle East is (even more) destabilized, WTF?? The worst-case scenario I can see (for the immediate future) is that the price of gasoline goes up-- and that has almost nothing to do with jihadist nut-jobs, they arent dealing in oil futures. (If we really want the most bang for the buck on stabilizing oil prices, we probably ought to consider drone-strikes on international oil speculators.)
If the US (and the rest of the West) doesnt do jack-shit, Middle Eastern fanatics will keep on slaughtering one another for next couple years, giving us plenty of time to sort out who the most dangerous whack-jobs are. By the time ISIS (or ISIL, or some other Muslim acronym) manages to carve out a piece of territory to squat on, the key players will all be identified from their Youtube videos and well have targets on their backs and satellite images of exactly where to pinpoint the air-strikes
NONE of these MFers are our friendstheyre all just varying degrees of enemy. So why should we do a damn thing to help anybody in this fight? If the situation in the Middle East was a turf war amongst rival gangs in NY, Detroit or Chicago, would the cops waste two minutes trying to figure out whom to back?
Tags
Who is online
65 visitors

Muslim psychos fighting Muslim fanatics fighting Muslim knotheads--- and the downside is?
Morning MiG, tnx for checking in. The only thing thats ever distracted the various sects/tribes/cliques from cutting one anothers throats is some foreign devils to fight with. If the US was really smart, wed pull out of Afghanistan tomorrow and let that added crop of lunatics start fighting with all the others...
Im afraid that morality doesnt have much traction in international politics, BF. Moral quandaries aside, Id agree that supplying arms to anybody in that quagmire would be a colossal error in judgment. Whatever faction you look at, its choosing among people who hate our guts, people who cant be trusted, or people who are incompetent to maintain what weve already given them. It would be cheaper (and safer in the long run) to take the money and munitions and just drop them into an active volcano
Suck the oil out of the place, then let them have at it with each other. Sooner or later they might get the message that no one needs them or cares much about their backwards progression towards civilization.
Short answer, Nope.
I'd advocate for drone-strikes on the wells--- see if 'the caliph' has the cojones to put 'em out.
Nuff said, Miss... tnx for checking in.
The Arabs have a saying:
First the Jews...then the Christians. And from time to time there are foreigners to toward their wrath toward. But when there are no minorities in the area left to persecute, and foreigners are scarce-- they turn to torturing and killing other Muslims. (Or Kurds-- but the Kurds don't put up with their sh*t).
For some strange reason the US State Dept just doesn't get it. Kerry had been making all those trips trying to get the "Palestinians" to make peace with Israel. His latest folly is trying to keep "Iraq" together-- what a maroon!
And our administration is now sending in ore American kids to die.
I totally agree about sending arms to any Arab faction, be they Sunni or Shia, or pro-Assad or anti-Assad.
However, there is one exception: the Kurds. (They are not Arabs, but rather a distinct ethnic group). They have been unjustly denied their own ancient homeland by the colonial powers unfair division of the region. Like the Jews, because they've been so persecuted by various powers over so many years, they've become fierce fighters (their "Peshmerga" forces). And currently, they are the main (or perhaps the only?) obstacle to ISIS/ISIL expansion in northern Iraq.
No Americans need be sent to defend them. (Although it would be nice if Kerry would stop trying to thwart their drive for independence)
Might sound good in theory. But one of the factors determining the price of oil is supply and demand. Any decrease in world oil supply causes the price to rise. This hurts the world economy, and would also halt (or slow down) the economic recovery underway in the U.S.
From what I've been hearing, it sounds like the Kurds are holding their own and de facto have become 'independent' of Iraq.
There was a recent NPR piece about how Iraq was 'created' when the Brits & the French (w/ the tacit agreement of the US) divvied up the ME at the end of WWI-- just a little geographical manipulation on behalf of propping up decaying empires, regardless of how the 'fuzzy-wuzzies' felt about it. So it's taken just about a hundred years for those chickens to come home to roost...
Might still be worth it to knock out a major chunk of income for the caliph-crazies. Without the oil, nobody on the planet would give a rat's ass about that piece-of-shit desert or what the whack-jobs do with it.
True-- most of the modern "countries" in the area are artificial creations. Before the colonial powers divided areas up, there were "tribes" or "nations" (somewhat similar to American Indian tribes). Iraq was an artificial creation-- it consists mainly of three groups-- Sunni Arabs, Shia Arabs, and Kurds (Kurds are not Arabs. Most are Muslims, but they are not into radical islamic jihad like so many Arabs are. They just want to have their own country to rule as they wish, and to live in peace).
Further south, the area was split into a French area of influence ("Greater Syria") and "The British Mandate of Palestine". (Palestine was never a country, tribe , or ethnicity-- rather, "Palestine" referred to a vague defined area-- akin to the U.S. "Southwest"-- or "Scandinavia").
Now, hopefully, the Kurds will get their long denied independence (although Kerry is acting like a total asshole, as usual-- he wants to keep Iraq from "splitting up" so that the inhabitants can rule their own areas).
Worried about ISIS? Its basically a Sunni vs Shia religious war. The Iranians have sent in troops to Iraq to aid the Shia fight vs ISIS, the Iraqis have just obtained Russian jet planes, and Assad is bombing ISIS positions on his border....
Obama has sent in troops (But they must keep their boots off the ground
IMO we should get all Americans out fast. Give military aid (but no troops) to the Kurds, as they are fierce fighters and a barrier to ISIS expansion in the north. Promote an independent Kurdistan diplomatically.
Forget about Syria. Those three teenagers have been found murdered, who were kidnapped in Israel. One of them was an American teen, although you'd never know it given the lack of interest of the American media and the president.
The Israelis will not even pretend to listen to Kerry now.
As things stand currently [as far as I can tell ] ISIS has captured only one refinery in Iraq :
But that is a refinery , not oil wells . The wells are still under the control of the Iraq govt . I don't know how they expect to get petroleum to supply the refinery with ...
It's never been about helping them; we're helping ourselves and turmoil on top of the world's largest oil reserves is not in our interest. I didn't support the second Iraq war because I wasn't convinced that Saddam had non-degraded WMDs or that he was involved with al Qaeda. What followed shouldn't have taken anybody by surprise because theSaudispredicted it (and, in part, helped cause it by funding a Sunni revolt).
Anyway, Bush's mistake was compounded by Obama deciding to toppleQaddafiin Libya. Following the fall of Qaddafi, Libyan arms and Sunni fighters made their way to Syria to try and topple Assad (probably with our help). Libya is now a failed state (with large oil reserves) that could be haven for terrorists. Assad is Shia. Iran, also Shia, came to Assad's defense. Iran brought in Hezbollah and clearly hopes to create a Shia dominated crescent from Iran to Syria. The fight has now become a regional sectarian war. The same fighters we fund to topple Assad have crossed the border into Iraq to topple Malilki. They have found many disaffected Sunnis who hate Maliki's "you non-Shia can kiss my ass" method ofgoverning and have joined the fight.
So now, thanks to our mindless meddling, we are on both sides of one sectarian fight (aiding the Sunnis in Syria and the Shia in Iraq). Although often forgotten, removing the dictators was exactly what Osama bin Laden wanted in order to create anenvironment where al Qaeda canthrive. ISIS is using the Sunni revolt to gain control of at least part of Iraq and Syria. This is not something we can ignore because they will, in time, seek us out and attack us whether we go home or not. There is no reason to let them grow strong enough to choose the time and terms for an attack. They should be destroyed while they are weak . . . before they can use oil revenues to fund widespread terrorism and play havoc with world economies through market manipulation.
This is a mess with no easy solution. Right now, I suggest backing off of Assad. He will likely crush ISIS in Syria (and kill thousands of others in the process). Send in military forces (assuming Maliki agrees) to basically draw a line between Shia and Sunni so that the Sunni cannot overrun Iraq. If we have to work with Iran, then so be it. ISIS will be caught between Syria, Iran and (Shia) Iraqi forces. Meanwhile, get Maliki tostepdown and help the Iraqis devise an inclusive government. Peel off Sunni groups by offering them something (even if it's money) and unravel the Sunnicoalition. The Sunnis, themselves, may turn on ISIS if they're offered a better alternative.
Yeah they would if one gang's next order of business was to kill the cops and then kill everybody else.
So, after spending three paragraphs to demonstrate that playing policeman to the world and propping up puppet factions with massive bribes hasn't worked (and I agree wholeheartedly), your suggestion is that we return to playing policeman to the world and bribing puppet factions all over again.
Assad is busy killing off his own citizen rebels and hasn't been able to do jack to stop ISIS. It's unclear what (if anything) Iran is doing (other than trying to draw America back into the conflict), and at this point both Syria and Iraq are failed states... after billions of dollars & US assistance, the Iraqi gov't's best effort is reverting to Shia militia groups to save their ass. Please explain how Syria (assuming it can be 'rescued') or Iraq (assuming it can be 'rescued') or Iran are supposed to become meaningful 'allies' after we bail them out...
When American politicians are bribed, they usually stay bought; that hasn't been the case w/ foreign power-brokers--- they take the money & then renege. If there are uneasy members of the 'Sunni coalition', let 'em stand up & be counted, fuck trying to bribe them into being 'good guys'.
The non-psycho Sunnis need to decide if a promised 'caliphate' is worth the price of total acquiesence to brutal fanatics-- the West doesn't need to offer a 'better alternative' than submission to fundamentalist zealots who kill everyone who disagrees with them. It's way past time that Muslim governments across the ME made a choice about dealing with their own religious schisms. The hell with pulling Saudi Arabia's chesnuts out of the fire...
IMO, the West has nothing to lose by letting this situation cook and allowing the Muslim states pursue their own 'destiny'. IF and AS ISIS or ISIL or whoever-the-fuck they are eventually become a threat to anyone besides their next door neighbors, they'll be bombed back to the stone age in a couple weeks, end of story.
As for world oil supplies, the worst case scenario is that the US speeds up drilling & fracking, the non-fragmented OPEC nations make even more money, and the Russians finally get a bigger market share. Still less costly and more reasonable than getting suckered back into trying to bribe or coerce some kind of 'stability' amongst people who are fundamentally irrational...
Exactly.
Whatever we do would end up costing American lives. And Iraqi lives.And American taxpayer dollars. But-- it wouldn't accomplish anything. Violence against "the other"is an inherent part of Arab culture-- we aren't going to be able to change it overnight.
I don't think Assad is going to get heavily involved inside Iraq, but apparently he's been bombing ISIS strongholds (and supply routes) on the Syrian Iraq border.
Their blitzkrieg has mainly been through Sunni areas. However, there is increasing opposition to ISIS. As they approach Baghdad, they will be coming up against Shia militias. In the north they are facing the Kurds who are strong fighters (I non't think ISIS wants to engage them)..
Russia has apparently been selling jet fighter to Iraq (may take a while to integrate them though). There are Russian advisors in Iraq, advising the gov't forces.
The US has apparenty sent advisors to the Iraqi military-- plus some missiles.
iran also has elite units in Iraq oppoasing ISIS (I don't know if they have fought with them yet).
Finally, while they are also Sunni Muslims Like ISIS, the Saudis are really opposed to ISIS extremism (they are afraid ISIS might turn on them and try to capture shrines in Mecca/Medina). The Sauids will be using their money and other influence behind the scenes.
Like the battles in Syria, this whole scenario may result in the tide turning, back and forth, with onging warfare for some time.
But why should we get our kids killed-- and spend more money there?
We're pretty much on the same page about this, Krish...
It's about time Saudi Arabia (& some others) started doing some of the heavy lifting in this mess. My bet is that the Saudi elite are shitting bricks at this point-- the royal family would be up against the wall about 15 minutes after ISIS gained control in SA.
Won't cause me to lose any sleep...
Krishna said:
"...one of the factors determining the price of oil is supply and demand. Any decrease in world oil supply causes the price to rise."
I would state that differently....
....one of the factors determining the price of oil is the perception of future supply and demand. Anypotentialdecrease in theperceivedworld oil supply causes the price of oil futuresto rise.
That would be a best-case scenario as far as I am concerned. The U.S., Canada, and Europe should encourage their own jihadis over there as cannon fodder. My hope is they kill each other until down to the last man and that lonely fellow blows himself up.
OK, so if you could figure out who the "good guys" are... and we arm them and then they lose, and all that stuff ends up with the "bad guys" then what?
There is no right or wrong here. It is what it is. Yes, we did make the mess in the first place. One could argue that the mess goes back to Reagan, by arming the Mujahideen, which became the Taliban/Al Qaeda, which put us in the region in the first place... but it matters little now. This is a blood feud, and they never have a winner. Tell me, who would you have armed, the Hatfields or the McCoys? And just for history sake... they only signed a peace agreement 10 years ago.
Yet, they still can't make White Lightning together to this day......
Should the Middle East consider doing something about the West?
Just as valid as the question posed?
Since Maliki is almost demanding help from the US [threatening to get military help from other countries if we don't help ] then it is not the same question .
I disagree but as always appreciate your perspective
Disagree with what exactly ? Maliki is , in fact , insisting that the US help him fight an additional war of his own creation :
Iraq is increasingly turning to other governments like Iran, Russia and Syria to help beat back a rampant insurgency because it cannot wait for additional American military aid, Baghdad's top envoy to the U.S. said Tuesday.
Petey
So we now bow to the demands if ineffective leaders of Mid East countries?
I was pleased when we got out of Iraq and am not enamored with the idea of going back in, but alas that ship has sailed.
But I guess since Maliki demanded it that it will all be okay.