The talking heads on the tube of life have taught us well how to break every one of those commandments. They lead by example. Journalism at it's finest. Oh crap. Now I'm sounding like Rush Limpbaugh, but it's true. And, as you say, ridiculous.
Some excellent rules to follow ... the only one that may be a problem that I can detect is #8 . When someone makes a broad statement claiming it is true , the burden of proof is on them ...
My Blue Moon Agave Nectar wheat is telling me that "shalt" works quite well ifyou happen to be speaking portuguese. Otherwise "whateva" works well too!:~)
Great post, ambi! They are all good points of reference. #s 7 & 8: A claim is a claim - it's an interpretation, opinion, a premise or an idea; it's true in the mind of the beholder. I have to be open on 8 - I do that. Because the claim that often can't be proven is attacked, I resent having to defend an assertion which is one's own reasoning/experience.
This isn't something I would say, but is an example: A person claiming a higher entity can't prove that an experience happened, but it is something they experienced, and while it doesn't mean they understand it, it alters their conclusions. To me, the person arguing the reality has the burden of proof that the other person's experience is negligible. Just my opinion.
ambivalent
A great guide
Would that it were true. A worthy goal, even when I break these Commandments. Thanks, Ambi.
The talking heads on the tube of life have taught us well how to break every one of those commandments. They lead by example. Journalism at it's finest. Oh crap. Now I'm sounding like Rush Limpbaugh, but it's true. And, as you say, ridiculous.
I can tell ya right now that this article is BS. I mean just look at the person who posted it!
As if this one NT'er has ALL the wisdom in the world and knows ALL the rules to a proper debate.
Not too many people are even aware that such rules for debate exist, and most wouldn't follow them anyways.
Besides, no one wants to debate fairly or reach sound conclusions, so why have all these rules?
The only reason that this article was posted in the first place was to avoid debating the topic (of debating).
Either people get on a blog site to debate or just to spout.
One other thing, I've never heard of any of these supposed debate tactics before, I'm positive they are all lies!
I don't believe this at all, I'd like more proof please that this is even real.
The more I think about it, the more sure I am that this was posted in order to give the poster a "pass" for debating subjects with me.
Nearly everyone hates this article as much as I do, so I'm sure that it's not even valid.
:~)
Some excellent rules to follow ... the only one that may be a problem that I can detect is #8 . When someone makes a broad statement claiming it is true , the burden of proof is on them ...
Actually, this is a very good reminder and thanks Ambivalent.
Ideally , that would be the best approach ... but it is not always possible .
Would consistency not be a rule? If you're going to use biblical language like "thou" and "thy", then "shall" should be "shalt".
Agreed.
My Blue Moon Agave Nectar wheat is telling me that "shalt" works quite well ifyou happen to be speaking portuguese. Otherwise "whateva" works well too!:~)
Ambi,
I love this! Especially #8. I want them all tattooed onto every members forehead.
But if you do that it would have to be a mirror image so they could read it every time they look in a mirror. How about on their arm instead?
These are the same rules I always follow.
Great post, ambi! They are all good points of reference. #s 7 & 8: A claim is a claim - it's an interpretation, opinion, a premise or an idea; it's true in the mind of the beholder. I have to be open on 8 - I do that. Because the claim that often can't be proven is attacked, I resent having to defend an assertion which is one's own reasoning/experience.
This isn't something I would say, but is an example: A person claiming a higher entity can't prove that an experience happened, but it is something they experienced, and while it doesn't mean they understand it, it alters their conclusions. To me, the person arguing the reality has the burden of proof that the other person's experience is negligible. Just my opinion.