Federal judge overturns Wisconsin's gay marriage ban
Madison A federal judge in Madison on Friday overturned Wisconsin's gay marriage ban, striking down an amendment to the state constitution approved overwhelmingly by voters in 2006 and prompting an emergency action by the state to halt the scores of weddings that began in the state's two largest cities.
In the 88-page decision, U.S. District Judge Barbara Crabb ruled that the prohibition on same-sex vows in the state violated the rights of gay and lesbian couples to equal protection under the federal constitution and fair treatment under the law.
She did not stay her ruling but also did not immediately issue an order blocking the enforcement of the ban, sparking a heated and hasty debate on whether the ruling meant that couples could immediately marry in the courthouses of Wisconsin.
Instead, Crabb asked the gay couples who had sued over the ban to say by June 16 exactly what they wanted done to enforce her ruling, with a further wait of one to two weeks for both sides in the lawsuit to file responses. Crabb, who was appointed by President Jimmy Carter, said she would then address whether to stay her decision while the matter is on appeal . - Source
***************************************
Time for celebration here in WI. Another state bites the dust.
Tags
Who is online
120 visitors

Congrats to the gay community! Nice to see you Aeon!
Hey, neither do I.
Actually no - it is a state's right's issue, not a fed. Her ruling is unconstitutional - "Full Faith and Credit shall be given in each State to the public Acts, Records, and judicial Proceedings of every other State. And the Congress may by general Laws prescribe the Manner in which such Acts, Records and Proceedings shall be proved, and the Effect thereof." - and, as of yet, there is no Federal law FOR gay marriages, so it is still a state prerogative for enforcement within the state's boundaries.
An excellent point, BF.
And while our Declaration of Independence was to spell out to the English what we were going to be, fundamental to that document is the "Pursuit of Happiness". It seems that some people think it only applies to certain people and not all.
The "Pursuit of Happiness" is not all its cracked up to be ...
But, the Constitution is what we operate under, not the Declaration of Independence.
It is what is what we as American's founded our Constitution on and made us different than being English. If it means nothing, we should just tear it up.
Pursuit of Happiness is everything... anything else is superficial.
The pursuit of Herpes should be added to the Declaration of Independence to update it ...
The Declaration was a convenient fantasy written to appeal to the common man . What made the US constitution different than being British was the enumerated and codified rights .
The Declaration was not written to appeal to the common man, since they didn't know it was being written. It also guaranteed that everyone's name on it would be hung, had we lost the war.
But it's true significance was as a legal document.
Here do some reading up.
The difference between the declaration and the constitution is the difference between theory and practice .
Likewise , if badfish masturbates while imagining such events who are we to interfere with such pursuits , no matter how frivolous they are ? Although if he stated those events as facts the govt would look into that as slander ...
Why should anyone care what others do of their own free will....These fricking politicians should take on problems this country faces everyday. Instead, they try to write our moral code for us.
Politicians and morals is an oxymoron.
That is irrelevant. It is grounds under which we not onlydeclaredourindependence from England, but also thecornerstone on which the Constitutionwas built upon. It was our only national document for 11 years of our nationunder whichWashington guidedthis nation and made promises to it's citizens and toforeignnations. So the preamble counts.
Now be careful there BF - I'm a helluva lot pickier than that.
Guys.
I could give a crap.... pardon the pun as to who marries who. I think marriage should be taken on as a personal thing with no ties to the government at all. And no obligation for those who are against it to be coerced to abide by it in any way.
But when did judges start writing the law? I thought their job was to interpret the law. When did the people's wishes become insignificant?
Do the people's votes not count anymore? Like I said, I could give a shit, pardon the pun who marries who, but it's not a judges right to change a law, only to interpret it.
If a law is against the states constitution, it can be struck down. It is up to our lawmakers to write laws that don't conflict with the each states constitution.
No. And even though I am for gay marriage, it is besides the point.
Oh poop! Some people just don't like to have things crammed down their throats. Then some people do.
If you read the decision, you'll find that;
a) Wisconsin argued that their marriage ban on same sex marriage was immune to constitutional review (page 6) - Judge Crabb shot that down.
b) Like in all the other states that have had similar laws overturned, she ruled that the ban on same sex marriage violated the due process clause and the equal protection clause of The US constitution.
There have been at least a dozen different Federal judges who have used that same jurisprudence in overturning as many state laws around the country.
Note Well;
That was an excellent Ben Franklin quote . Thanks A Pax .
Well said Aeon.
Mike,
You tripped backwards in your time machine...
Bears repeating:
If only more people thought like that....
Applause!!!
He's from an alternate reality....